Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The consent of Fathers, the second pretended proof for the Papists doctrine in this point, is pretended falsely: and if all be weighted in an even balance, the Fathers check it rather.
The consent of Fathers, the seconde pretended proofe for the Papists doctrine in this point, is pretended falsly: and if all be weighted in an even ballance, the Fathers check it rather.
After the foresaid testimonies of scripture urged by our adversaries in the first place for the commending of their error: Secondly, the same truth (saith the Jesuit) may be proved by tradition. By which his own speech, if we should take advantage of it, he granteth all that I have said against his arguments drawn out of the scripture, and so far forth agreeth with us. For what understandeth, he by the word Tradition? A doctrine not written, asa him-self professeth in his first controversy. Where having noted that all though the word tradition be general & signifieth any doctrine written or unwritten, which one imparteth to another, yet divines, & almost all the ancient fathers, apply it to signify unwritten doctrine only: And soe will we hereafter use this word saith he. If the point in question then may be proved (as Bellarmin affirmeth it may) by tradition: We might conclude it is not written in the scriptures, by his own verdict, and therefore all the scriptures alleged by him for it are alleged falsely. But he seemeth to use the name of tradition in like sort asb Vincentius Lirmensis doth, calling the doctrine delivered by the church the Churches tradition. This to be his meaning I gather by the reason that he addeth saying for there are extant the testimonies of the fathers in all ages for it. The Pamphleteer in other words, but more peremptorily to avouch the proof thereof by the opinion and censure of all ages, affirmeth, he will show that it was never thought lawful since Christ, for Christians divorced for fornication to marry any other while both man and wife lived. That it was never thought lawful since Christ, is a boulder speech them Bellarmin doth use: though to hit the mark as it were with his shaft, he must and doth imply as much in that
⟨p. 45⟩
he saith it may be proved by tradition. For tradition hath not force enough to prove a thing to be true, not in the Papists own judgment, unless it have been always approved & agreed on by the general consent of Fathers, (as we term them) Pastors and Doctors of the Church. Which I affirm not upon the general rule of
Vincentius only so greatly, and so often praised by them as golden: But upon the Canon of the Trent council and pillars of the Popish church subscribing to it.
AFter the foresaid testimonies of scripture vrged by our adversaries in the first place for the commending of their errour: Secondly, the same truth (saith the Iesuit) may be proved by tradition. By which his owne speeche, if we should take advauntage of it, he graunteth all that I have said agaynst his arguments drawen out of the scripture, and so farre forth agreeth with vs. For what vnderstandeth, hee by the word Tradition? A doctrine not written, asa him-self professeth in his first controversie. Where having noted that al though the word tradition be generall & signifieth any doctrine written or vnwritten, which one imparteth to another, yet divines, & almost all the auncient fathers, applie it to signifie vnwritten doctrine onely: And soe will wee hereafter vse this word saith hee. If the point in question thē may be proved (as Bellarmin affirmeth it may) by tradition: We might conclude it is not written in the scriptures, by his owne verdict, and therefore all the scriptures alleaged by him for it are alleaged falsly. But hee seemeth to vse the name of traditiō in like sort asb Vincentius Lirmensis doth, calling the doctrine delivered by the church the Churches tradition. This to be his meaning I gather by the reason that hee addeth saying for there are extant the testimonies of the fathers in all ages for it. The Pāphletter in other words, but more perēptorily to avouch the proofe thereof by the opinion and censure of all ages, affirmeth, he will shewe that it was never thought lawfull since Christ, for Christians divorced for fornication to marry anie other while both man and wife lived. That it was never thought lawfull since Christ, is a boulder speeche them Bellarmin doth vse: though to hitt the marke as it were with his shaft, hee must and doth imply as much in that ⟨p. 45⟩hee saith it may be proved by tradition. For traditiō hath not force enough to prove a thing to be true, not in the Papists owne iudgment, vnles it have bene alwaies approved & agreed on by the generall consent of Fathers, (as we tearme them) Pastors and Doctors of the Church. Which I affirme not vpon the generall rule ofc Vincentius onelie so greatly, and so often praised by them as golden: But vpon the Canon of the Trent councell and pillars of the Popīsh churche subscribing to it.
For thed council of Trent commanding that no man shall expound the scripture against the sense that the Church holdeth or against the Fathers consenting all in one, doth covertly grant, that if the Fathers consent not all in one, their opinion may be false, and consequently, no sure proof of a point in question. eAndradius doth open and avouch the same in his defence of the Council: a work very highly commended byf Oseruis. And gCanus setteth it down for a conclusion, that many of them consenting in one can yield no firm proof, if the rest though fewer in number do dissent. Yeah Bellarmin himself saith that there can no certainty be gathered out of their sayings, when they agree not among themselves. It is a thing granted then by our adversaries that the Fathers have not strength enough to prove ought unless they all consent in one. But the fathers do not all consent in one about the point we treat of, as it shall be showed, Our adversaries therefore must grant that the opinion which they hold in this point, cannot be proved by Fathers. Nay they are in danger of being enforced to grant a farther matter, and more importing them by the consequent hereof. For through a decree ofi Pope Pius the fourth, the professors of all faculties, & all that take degrees in any popish school are bound by solemn oath that they shall never expound and take the scripture1 but according to the Fathers consenting all in one. Wherefore how will Bellarmin, perhaps the Pamphleteer also if he have been amongst them and taken any degree, but what shift will Bellarmin, and his2 puefellowes find to save themselves from perjury, when it shall be showed that many of the Fathers gain say that opinion, which him-self and his expound the scripture for? And what if it appear, that the greater number of Fathers do so? nor the greater only, but the better also, ⟨p. 46⟩and those whose grounds are surer? Then all the probability, which Fathers can yield will turn against the Papists: and that which our adversaries would prove by tradition, and the consent of all ages will rather be disproved thereby. But howsoever men be diversly, persuaded touching the number & quality of Fathers inclining this or that way, by means of sundry circumstances which may breed doubt both particularly, of certain, and of the whole sum in general:
For thed councell of Trent commanding that no man shall expound the scripture against the sense that the Churche holdeth or against the Fathers cōsenting all in one, doth covertly graūt, that if the Fathers consent not all in one, their opinion may be false, and •onsequently, no sure proofe of a point in question. eAndradius doth open and avouche the same in his defense of the Councell: a worke verie highly commēded byf Oseruis. And gCanus setteth it downe for a conclusion, that many of them consenting in one can yeild no firme proofe, if the rest though fewer in number do dissent. Yeah Bellarmin himself saith that there can no certaintie be gathered out of their sayings, when they agree not among themselves. It is a thing graunted thē by our adversaries that the Fathers have not strength enough to prove ought vnlesse they all consent in one. But the fathers do not all consent in one about the point wee treat of, as it shalbe shewed, Our adversaries therefore must graunt that the opiniō which they holde in this point, cannot be proved by Fathers. Nay they are in danger of being enforced to graunt a farther matter, and more importing them by the consequent hereof. For through a decree ofi Pope Pius the fourth, the professors of all faculties, & all that take degrees in any poopish schoole are bound by solemne oth that they shall never expound and take the scripture1 but according to the Fathers cōsēting all in one. Wherefore how will Bellarmin, perhaps the Pamphletter also if he have bene amongst them and taken any degree, but what shift will Bellarmin, and his2 puefellowes finde to save themselves from periurie, when it shal be shewed that many of the Fathers gaine say that opinion, which him-self and his expound the scripture for? And what if it appeare, that the greater number of Fathers doe so? nor the greater onely, but the better also, ⟨p. 46⟩
2As Parsons by name: Epi tom con. part 2. con. 5. quest 4. & canilius catechism. de matrimon. sacram quest. 3▪ & Navarrus in cap divort▪ de peint dist. 1 & their seminarieschollars.
the main and principal point remaining to be showed, namely that the Fathers consent not all in one for the Papists doctrine, is most clear and evident out of all controversy. In so much that many even of them also whom Bellarmin allegeth, and the Pamphleteer after him, as making for it, make in deed against it: and those of the chiefest and foremost ranks specially, in the first, the second, the third, the fourth hundred years after Christ. All the which agree and teach with one consent that the man forsaking his wife for her adultery, is free to marry again: save such of them only, as in this very point of doctrine touching, marriage are tainted with, error by the judgement and censure of Papists themselves. A token of the vanity and folly of our adversaries Bellarmin and the Pamphleteer: who by naming one at least in every age, would needs make a show of having the consent of all ages with them, whereas it will be seen hereby, that in many we have the most and best; and they, either none at all, or none sound. For in the first hundred years after Christ all that Bellarmin saith they have, is the testimony of Clemens in the Canons of the Apostlesk where the man is willed without any exception to be excommunicated, who having put away his wife doth marry another. Now beside that Clemens upon whom Bellarmin fathereth, those canons, is injured therein. As for the later part of theml himself showeth,m his friend for the former, neither are they of Apostolic antiquity and authority notwithstanding their title, asn many Fathers testify, and Papists will acknowledge when they are touched by them:o The author of the Canon had respect therein (by all probability) to the Apostolic doctrine received from Christ, & therefore though he made not an express exception of divorce for whoredom, might as well imply it, as I have declared that some of ⟨p. 47⟩the Evangelists, and S. Paul did. Which the interpreters also of those Canonsp Zonaras and Balsamon, thought to be so likely and more then a conjecture, that they expound it so without any scruple. Balsamon in saying that he who putteth away his wife without cause may not marry another; and Zonaras that he who marrieth a woman put away without cause by her husband doth commit adultery.
the maine and principall point remayning to be shewed, namely that the Fathers consent not all in one for the Papists doctrine, is most cleare and evident out of all controversie. In so much that many even of them also whom Bellarmin alleageth, and the Pamphletter after him, as making for it, make in deed against it: and those of the chiefest and formost rankes spetially, in the first, the second, the third, the fourth hundred yeares after Christ. All the which agree and teach with one consent that the man forsaking his wife for her adulterie, is free to marrie againe: save such of them onely, as in this very point of doctrine touching, marriage are tainted with, error by the iudgement and censure of Papists themselves. A token of the vanetie and folly of our adversaries Bellarmin and the Pamphletter: who by naming one at least in everie age, would needes make a shewe of having the consent of all ages with them, whereas it wilbe seene hereby, that in many we have the most and best; and they, either none at all, or none sound. For in the first hundred yeares after Christ all that Bellarmin sayth they have, is the testimony of Clemens in the Canōs of the Apostlesk where the mā is willed without any exception to be excommunicated, who having put away his wife doth marrie another. Now beside that Clemens vpon whom Bellarmin fathereth, those canons, is iniured therein. As for the later parte of theml himself sheweth,m his friend for the former, neither are they of Apostolique antiquitie and authoritie notwithstanding their title, asn many Fathers testifie, and Papists will acknowledg when they are touched by them:o The author of the Canon had respect therein (by all probabilitie) to the Apostolique doctrine receyved from Christ, & therefore though he made not an expresse exceptiō of divorce for whordom, might as well impply it, as I have declared that some of ⟨p. 47⟩the Euangelists, and S. Paule did. Which the interpreters also of those Canonsp Zonaras and Balsamon, thought to be so likely and more then a coniecture, that they expound it so without any scruple. Balsamon in saying that he who putteth away his wife without cause may not marrie another; and Zonaras that hee who marrieth a woman put away without cause by her husband doth committ adulterie.
kCanon. 48.
lTom, 1. L. conti •. ca. 2•
mFr. Torrensis (otherwise called Turriā) a •esuit lib de 6. 7. et 8. Synod.Fr. Torrensis (otherwise called Turriā) a •esuit lib de 6. 7. et 8. Synod.
nPope Ge•asius the first, with 70. by shops assembled in a coū cell c Scta Romana dist. 3.Pope Ge•asius the first, with 70. by shops assembled in a coū cell c Scta Romana dist. 3.
oG•sar Baronius Annalus Eccle. tom. 1. ad •nnum Christi •8.
Or if these writers mistook the authors meaning, & in his opinion no man, howsoever his wife were put away, without or with cause, might lawfully marry another: th•n take this with all, thatq he skarse allowed any second marriage, but controlled the third as a sign of intemperance, & condemned flatly the fourth as manifest whoredom. Which althoughr a Jesuit go about to cover and salve with gentle glosses likes the false prophets. Who when one had built up a mud wall did parged it with unsavoury plaster: yet sith that counterfeit Clements work did flow out of the fountains of the Grecians, as at great historian of Rome hath truly noted, and among the Grecians many, held that error, as it is likewise showed by av great Sorbonist; the likelihood of the matter, and spring whence it proceedeth agreeing so fitly with the natural and proper signification of the words, will not permit their blackness to take any other hue, nor suffer that profane speech of I know not what Clement, to be cleared from plain contradiction tox the word of God. Wherefore the only witness that Bellarmin produceth out of the first hundred years, doth not help him.y Out of the second hundred he produceth three; Justinus, Athenagoras and Clemens Alexandrinus. The first of whom Justinus praising the compendious briefness of Christs speeches rehearseth this amongst them: Whoso marrieth her that is divorced from her husband, doth commit adultery. Meaning not as Bellarmin, but as Christ did: who excepting whoredom in the zformer branch of that sentence, understood it likewise in this, as I have showed. And how may we know that Justinus meant so? By his own words, in thata he commendeth a godly Christian woman, who gave to her adulterous husband a bill of divorcementb such as did loose that band of matrimony, and saith concerning him that4 he was not her husband afterward. The nextc Athenagoras, affirmeth (I grant) that if ⟨p. 48⟩any man being parted from his former wife do marry another he is an adulterer. But Bellarmin must grant with all that Athenagoras affirmeth it untruly: considering that he speaketh of parting even by death too, as well as by divorcement, & teacheth with thed Montanists that whatsoever second marriage is unlawful.
Or if these writers mistooke the authours meaning, & in his opinion no mā, howsoever his wife were put away, without or with cause, might lawfully marrie another: th•n take this with all, thatq hee skarse allowed any second marriage, but controuled the third as a signe of intemperance, & condemned flatly the fourth as manifest whoredom. Which althoughr a Iesuit goe about to cover and salve with gentle gloses likes the false prophets. Who when one had built up a mudden wall did parged it with vnsavorie plaister: yet sith that counterfait Clements worke did flowe out of the fountaines of the Gretians, as at great historian of Rome hath truelie noted, and amōg the Gretians many, held that errour, as it is likewise shewed by av great Sorbonist; the likelyhood of the matter, and spring whence it proceedeth agreeing so fitly with the naturall and proper signification of the words, will not permitt their blacknes to take any other hewe, nor suffer that profane speech of I know not what Clement, to be cleared from plaine contradiction tox the word of God. Wherefore the onely witnesse that Bellarmin produceth out of the first hundred yeares, doth not helpe him.y Out of the second hundred he produceth three; Iustinus, Athenagoras and Clemens Alexandrinus. The first of whom Iustinus praising the compendious briefnes of Christes speeches rehearseth this amongst them: Whoso marrieth her that is divorced from her husband, doth commit adulterie. Meaning not as Bellarmin, but as Christ did: who excepting whoredome in the zformer braunche of that sentence, vnderstoode it likewise in this, as I have shewed. And how may wee know that Iustinus meant so? By his owne wordes, in thata hee commendeth a godly Christian woman, who gave to her adulterous husband a bill of dirorcementb
qApost const lib. 3 cap, 2
rFt. Turrian, an•ct. in Apoconst ClementFt. Turrian, an•ct. in Apoconst Clemēt
Whereupon a famous Parisian Divinee Claudius Espenseus saith of this same sentence of his which Bellarmin citeth, that it favoureth rather of a Philosopher then a Christian: and may well be thought to have been inserted into his work by Eucratites. A censure, for the ground thereof, very true, that the said opinion is a Philosophical fancy, yea an heresy: Though the words seem rather to be Athenagonas his own, asf sundry fathers speak dangerously, that way, then thrust in by Encratites, gwho generally rejected all marriage, not second marriage only. Athenagoras therefore worketh small credit to the Jesuits cause. As much doth the last of his witnessesh Clemens Alexandrinus. For both in this point about second marriage ihe matcheth Aethenagoras and otherwise his writings are tainted with unsoundness, and stained with spots of error. Which judgment not onlyk Protestants of German have in our remembrance lately, given of him, though al Jesuitical spirit do traduce them insolently, for it: Butm an ancient Pope of Rome with seventy bishops assembled in a Council above a thousand years since, and a Bishop of Spain a man of no small reputation with Papists for skill both in divinity and in the Canon lawn Didacus Covarruvias doth approve the same. Now in the third hundred years (to go forward) Tertullian and Origen are brought forth to aver Bellarmins opinion, of whom one questionless controlleth, perhaps both. Foro Tertullian disputing against the heretic Marcion, who falsely objected that Christ is contrary to Moses, because Moses granted divorcement, Christ forbiddeth it, answereth that Christ saying, whosoever shall put away his wife & marry another, committeth adultery, meaneth 5undoubtedly of putting away for that cause, for which it is not lawful for a man to putt away his wife that he may marry another. And likewise for the wife, that he is an adulterer, who marrieth her being put away, 6if she be put away unlawfully: considering that the marriage, which is not rightly broken off, continueth; and ⟨p. 49⟩while the marriage doth continue, it is adultery to marry.
Wherevpon a famons Parisian Divinee Claudius Espenseus saith of this same sentence of his which Bellarmin citeth, that it favoureth rather of a Philosopher then a Christian: and may well be thought to have bene inserted into his worke by Eucratites. A censure, for the ground thereof, very true, that the said opinion is a Philosophicall fansie, yea an heresie: Though the wordes seeme rather to be Athenagonas his owne, asf sundrie fathers speake dangerously, that way, then thrust in by Encratites, gwho generally reiected all marriage, not se•ond marriage onelie. Athenagoras therefore worketh small credit to the Iesuits cause. As much doth the last of his witnessesh Clemens Alexandrinus. For both in this point about second marriage ihee matcheth Aethenagoras and otherwise his writings are tainted with vnsoundenes, and stained with spotts of errour. Which iudgmēt not onelyk Protestants of Germaine have in our remembrance lately, geven of him, though al Iesuitical spirit doe traduce thē insolently, for it: Butm an auncient Pope of Rome with seavētie byshops assembled in a Councell above a thowsand yeares since, and a Byshop of Spaine a man of no small reputation with Papists for skill both in divinitie and in the Canon lawn Didacus Covarruvias doth approve the same. Now in the third hundred yeares (to goe forward) Tertullian and Origen are brought forth to averre Bellarmins opinion, of whom one questionlesse controlleth, perhaps both. Foro Tertullian disputing against the heretique Marcion, who falsely obiected that Christ is contrarie to Moses, because Moses graunted divorcemēt, Christ forbiddeth it, answereth that Christ saying, whosoever shall put away his wife & marrie another, committeth adulterie, meaneth
Which words of Tertullian manifestly declaring that a man divorced from his wife lawfully, for the cause excepted by Christ, may marry another, Bellarmin doth very cunningly & finely, cut of with an et caetera, and saith that there he teacheth that Christ did not forbid divorcement, if there be a just cause, but, did forbid to marry again after divorcement. So directly against the most evident light of the words & tenor of the whole discourse: that learned men of his own side, though holding his opinion yet could not for shame but grant that Tertullian maketh against them in it. Forp bishop Covarruvias mentioning the fathers who maintain that men may lawfully marry again after divorcement for adultery, nameth Tertullian (quoting this place) among them. Andq Sixtus Senensis a man not inferior in learning to Bellarmin, in sincere dealing for this point superior, confesseth on the same place, & on those same words (but recited wholly, not clipped with an etcetera) that Tertullian maketh a certain & undoubted assertion thereof.r Pamelius in deed through a desire of propping up his churches doctrine with Tertullians credit, saith that though he seem here to allow divorcement for adultery in such sort, as that the husband may marry another wife: yet he openeth himself, & holdeth it to be unlawful in his book †of single marriage. Wherein he saith some what, but little to his advantage. For Tertullian wrote this book of single marriage swhen he was fallen away from the Catholic faith unto the heresy of Montanus: & so doth hold therein agreeably to that heresy, that is unlawful to marry a second wife howsoever a man be parted from the former by divorcement or by death. But in that thee wrote, while he was a Catholic, against the heretic Marcion, he teacheth contrariwise the same that we do, as Sixtus Senensis and Covarruvias truly grant. Yea Pamelius himself if he look better to his own notes, doth grant as much. Fort he saith that Tertullian useth the word divorcement in his proper signification, for such a divorcement by which one putteth away his wife, & marrieth another. But Tertullian saith7 that Christ doth avouch the righteousness of divorcement. Christ therefore avoucheth that for adultery a man may put away his wife and marry another by Tertullians judgment. Which also may be probably thought concerning Origen:
Which words of Tertullian manyfestly declaring that a man divorced from his wife lawfully, for the cause excepted by Christ, may marrie another, Bellarmin doth very cunningly & finely, cut of with an et caetera, and saith that there he teacheth that Christ did not forbid divorcement, if there be a iust cause, but, did forbid to marrie againe after divorcement. So directly agaisnt the most evidēt light of the wordes & tenour of the whole discourse: that learned men of his owne side, though houlding his opinion yet could not for shame but graunt that Tertullian maketh against them in it. Forp byshop Covarruvias mentioning the fathers who maintaine that men may lawfully marrie againe after divorcemēt for adulterie, nameth Tertullian (quoting this place) amōg them. Andq Sixtus Senensis a man not inferiour in learning to Bellarmin, in sincere dealing for this point superiour, cōfesseth on the same place, & on those same words (but recited wholy, not clipped with an etcetera) that Tertullian maketh a certaine & vndoubted assertion thereof.r Pamelius in deede through a desire of propping vp his churches doctrine with Tertulliās credit, saith that though hee seeme here to allowe divorcement for adulterie in such sort, as that the husbād may marrie another wife: yet hee openeth himself, & holdeth it to be vnlawfull in his booke †of single marriage. Wh•rein he saith some what, but litle to his advauntage. For Tertullian wrote this booke of single marriage swhē hee was fallē away from the Catholique faith vnto the heresie of Montanus: & so doth holde therein agreably to that heresie, that is vnlawfull to marrie a second wife howsoever a man be parted from the former by divorcement or by death. But in that thee wrote, while hee was a Catholique, against the heretique Marcion, hee teacheth cōtrarywise the same that wee doe, as Sixtus Senensis and Covarruvias truely graunt. Yea Pamelius himself if hee looke better to his owne notes, doth graunt as much. Fort he saith that Tertullian vseth the worde divorcement in his proper signification, for such a divorcement by which one putteth away his wife, & marrieth another. But Tertulliā saith7
Although ⟨p. 50⟩it be true vhe saith (as Bellarmin citeth him) that certain bishops did permit a woman to marry while her former husband lived, & addeth, they did it against the scripture. For he seemeth to speak of a woman divorced from her husband, not for adultery, but for some other cause, such as the Jews used to put away their wives for, by giving them a bill of divorcement. The matter that he handleth, and cause that he giveth thereof do lead us to this meaning; Approved by the opinion of certain learned men too. For after he had said (according tox the words of Christ which he expoundeth) that Moses in permitting a bill of divorcement did yield unto the weakness of them to whom the law was given; he saith that, the Christian bishops who permitted a woman to marry while her former husband lived, did it perhaps for such weakness. Wherefore sith in saving that, this which they did, they did perhaps for such weakness, he hath relation unto that of Moses, & Moses (as he addeth) did not grant the bill of divorcement for adultery, for that was punished by death it followeth that the Bishops whom Origen chargeth, with doing against the scripture did permit the woman, to marry upon divorcement for some other cause, not for adultery & so his reproving of them doth not touch us, who grant it for adultery only. Thus dothy Erasmus think that Origen meant: concluding it farther, as clear, by the similitude whichz he had used before of Christ, who put away the Synagogue (his former wife as it were) because of her adultery, & married the church. Yeaa Tapper likewise a great divine of Lovā, & of better credit with Papists than Eros•nus saith that the divorcement permitted by those Bishops, whom Origen controleth was a Jewish divorcement. Wherein though he aimed at another mark, to prove an untruth; yet unawares he hi• a truth more than he thought of, & strengthened that by Origen, which he thought to overthrow. Howbeit if Bellarmin or Bellarmins Interpreter can persuade by other likelihoods out of Origen (as he is somewhat dark, & I know not whether irresolute in the point) that the thing reproved by him in those Bishops was the permitting of one to marry again after divorcement for adultery: our cause shall be more advantaged by those sundry Bishops who approved it, than disadvantaged by one Origen, who reproved them for it.
Although ⟨p. 50⟩it be true vhee saith (as Bellarmin citeth him) that certaeine byshops did permitt a woman to marrie while her former husband lived, & addeth, they did it agaynst the scripture. For he seemeth to speake of a woman divorced from her husband, not for adulterie, but for some other cause, such as the Iewes vsed to put away their wives for, bygiving thē a bill of divorcemēt. The matter that he handleth, and cause that he geveth thereof doe lead vs to this meaning; Approved by the opinion of certaine learned men too. For after he had said (according tox the words of Christ which he expoundeth) that Moses in permitting a bill of divorcemēt did yeeld vnto the weakenes of thē to whom the law was gevē; he saith that, the Christian byshops who permitted a womā to marrie while her former husbād lived, did it perhaps for such weaknes. Wherefore sith in saving that, this which they did, they did perhaps for such weaknes, he hath relatiō vnto that of Moses, & Moses (as he addeth) did not graūt the bill of divorcemēt for adulterie, for that was punished by death it followeth that the Byshops whō Origen chargeth, with doing against the scripture did permitt the womā, to marrie vpon divorcemēt for some other cause, not for adulterie & so his reproving of thē doth not touche vs, who graūt it for adulterie only. Thus dothy Erasmus thinke that Origen meant: concluding it farther, as cleare, by the similitude whichz he had vsed before of Christ, who put away the Synagogue (his former wife as it were) because of her adulterie, & married the churche. Yeaa Tapper likewise a great divine of Lovā, & of better credit with Papists thē Eros•nus saith that the divorcemēt permitted by those Byshops, whō Origen cōtrouleth was a Iewish divorcemēt. Wherein though he aymed at another marke, to prove an vntruth; yet vnwares he hi• a truth more thē hee thought of, & strengthened that by Origen, which he thought to overthrowe. Howbeit if Bellarmin or Bellarmins Interpreter cā persuade by other likelyhoods out of Origen (as he is somewhat darke, & I know not whether irresolute in the point) that the thing reproved by him in those Byshops was the permitting of one to marrie againe after divorcement for adulterie: our cause shalbe more advātaged by those sundrie Byshops who approved it, thē disadvātaged by one Origē, who reproved thē for it.
Chiefly seeing Origen impaired much his credit both by other heresies in diverse points of faith, for whi•h ab general Council withc Bellarmins allowance count […] a damned heretic: ⟨p. 51⟩& in this matter byd excluding all such as are twice married out of the Kingdom of heaven, whiche divines of Paris observe & check him for. Whereas those Bishops of whom he maketh mention, were neither stained otherwise, for ought that may be gathered, nor herein did they more then the right believing & Catholic Church all that time thought lawful to be done, as appeareth by Tertullian & Justine the Martyr. In the which respect fPeter Soto (a friar of great account in the Trent Council) […] said that it is plain by many arguments that the case which we treat of was doubtful in the ancient church allegeth this for proof thereof out of Origen, that many bishops […] married men to marry again after divorcement. This if the two of •thers whom Bellarmin allegeth out of the third hundred years as making for him, do not make against him, which perhaps they do both: yet one of them doth not out of all controversy, & bishops, more in number, in credit greater than the other, agree with him therein. Out of the fourth hundred, the […] which Bellarmin maketh, is a great deal fairer than out of the third: & a number of Fathers, the council of Eliberis S. Am […] S. lerō, a Roman Bishop, & S. Chrysostom are affirmed them •e to join themselves with him. But they are affirmed in the like manner as the former were: skarse on of them avouching the same that he doth, the rest in part seeming to be of other opinion, in part most clearly showing it, & such as show not so much, yet showing their own weakness, & that in this matter their opinion & judgment is of small value. For the foremost of themg the Council of Eliberis, ordained that a woman which forsook her husband because of his adultery & would marry another, should be forbidden to marry, & if she married, she should not receive the communion till he were dead whom she forsook, unless necessity of sickness constrained to give it her. Wherein it is to be noted, first that the Council saith not.8 If any man, so to comprehend & touch generally all both men & women: but they speak peculiarity of the woman alone, & so do not forbid the man to leave his adulterous wife & marry another.
Chiefly seing Origē impaired much his credit both by other heresies in diverse points of faith, for whi•h ab generall Councell withc Bellarmins allowāce count 〈…〉 a damned heretique: ⟨p. 51⟩& in this matter byd excluding all such as are twise married out of the Kingdō of heavē, whiche divines of Paris observe & check him for. Whereas those Byshops of whō he maketh mentiō, were neither stayned otherwise, for ought that may be gathered, nor herein did they more then the right believing & Catholique Churche all that time thought lawfull to be done, as appeareth by Tertulliā & Iustine the Martyr. In the which respect fPeter Soto (a freir of great account in the Trent Councell) 〈…〉 said that it is plaine by many arguments that the case which we treat of was doubtfull in the auncient church al•eageth this for proofe thereof out of Origen, that many byshops 〈…〉 married mē to marrie againe after divorcement. This if the two of •thers whō Bellarmin alleageth out of the third hundred years as making for him, doe not make against him, which perhaps they doe both: yet one of thē doth not out of all controversie, & byshops, more in number, in credit greater thē the other, agree with him therein. Out of the fowrth hundred, the 〈…〉 which Bellarmin maketh, is a great deale fayrer thē out of the third: & a number of Fathers, the councell of Eliberis S. Am 〈…〉 S. lerō, a Romā Byshop, & S. Chrysostome are affirmed thē •e to ioyne themselves with him. But they are affirmed in the like māner as the former were: skarse on of thē avouching the same that he doth, the rest in part seeming to be of other opinion, in part most clearely shewing it, & such as shewe not so much, yet shewing their owne weakenes, & that in this matter their opiniō & iudgmēt is of small value. For the formost of them
bSynod 5 Con stan […] collat 8 cap ••. Nicephor lib. 17 cap •8.Synod 5 Cō stan 〈…〉 collat 8 cap ••. Nicephor lib. 17 cap •8.
cTom. 1 con •. 6 lib. c. cap. 1Tom. 1 cō •. 6 lib. c. cap. 1
dHom▪ 17 in Lucam.
eGenebrad. annot marg▪ in eum locū. Espenceus de continent. lib▪ 3 cap 9.Genebrad. annot marg▪ in eum locū. Espenceus de continent. lib▪ 3 cap 9.
fTractat de in•••cut Sacerd c. de matrimon. lect. ••
gCanon. 9.
8Slquis L. […] D. de ve• ber […].Slquis L. 〈…〉 D. de ve• ber 〈…〉.
Secondly, that the woman is excommunicated, if when she is forbidden by the church to marry, she marry nevertheless, not if before she be forbidden: As it were to punish her disobedience rather then the fact it self. Thirdly, that sh•e is not debarred all her life time from the ⟨p. 52⟩communion, but for a season only, and in time of need, in dangerous sickness doth receive it: yea, even while the party, whom she forsook liveth. Of the which circumstances the first though it might argue the Councells oversight who made the woman's case herein worse then the mans, both being free alike by Gods law: yet for the man it showeth that they allowed him to marry again after divorcement according to the doctrine of Christ which we maintain. The next yieldeth likelihood that the Council did forbid the woman this not for that they thought it unlawful, but unseemly perhaps or unexpedient, ash another Council is read to have forbidden the celebrating & solemnizing of marriages at certain times. But the last putteth the matter out of doubt, that they were persuaded of the woman also marrying in such sort, that her fact was warrantable by the word of God. Forels had they, not judged her marriage with this latter man to be lawful, they must needs have judged her to live with him in perpetual adultery. Which if they had thought, it is most improbable they would have admitted her to the communion in case of dangerous sickness: seeing at the point of deathi they deny it to women so continuing, yeak to men offending less heinously then so. With such extremity of rigour therein thatl Baronius noteth their decrees as savouring of the Novatian heresy: &m Bellarmin layeth it almost as deeply to their charge. So far from all likelihood is it that they would admit her in necessity of sickness to the communion had they been persuaded she lived in adultery still. Therefore it was not without cause that Bellarmin did suppress this circū stance together with the former, in citing the decree of the Elibernie Council: least his false illation, to wit that they accounted such marriage unlawful even for the innocent party, & in the cause of adultery, should be discovered & controlled thereby.
Secondly, that the womā is excommunicated, if when shee is forbidden by the church to marrie, shee marrie neverthelesse, not if before shee be forbidden: As it were to punish her disobedience rather then the fact it self. Thirdlie, that sh•e is not d•barred all her life time from the ⟨p. 52⟩communion, but for a season onely, and in time of neede, in daungerous sicknes doth receive it: yea, even while the partie, whō shee forsooke liveth. Of the which circumstances the first though it might argue the Councells oversight who made the womans case herein worse then the mans, both being free alike by Gods lawe: yet for the mā it sheweth that they allowed him to marrie againe after divorcement according to the doctrine of Christ which wee maintaine. The next yeildeth likeliehood that the Councell did forbid the woman this not for that they thought it vnlawfull, but vnseemelie perhaps or vnexpedient, ash another Councell is read to have forbiddē the celebrating & solemnizing of marriages at certaine times. But the last putteth the matter out of doubt, that they were persuaded of the woman also marrying in such sort, that her fact was warrātable by the word of God. Forels had they, not iudged her marriage with this latter mā to be lawfull, they must needes have iudged her to live with him in perpetuall adulterie. Which if they had thought, it is most improbable they would have admitted her to the communiō in case of daungerous sicknes: seeing at the point of deathi they denie it to womē so continuing, yeak to men offending lesse heynously then so. With such extremitie of rigour therein thatl Baronius noteth their decrees as savouring of the Novatian heresie: &m Bellarmin layeth it almost as deepely to their charge. So farre from all likeliehood is it that they would admitt her in necessitie of sicknes to the communiō had they bene persuaded shee lived in adulterie still. Therefore it was not without cause that Bellarmin did suppresse this circū stance together with the former, in citing the decree of the Elibernie Councell: least his false illatiō, to weete that they accounted such marriage vnlawfull even for the innocent partie, & in the cause of adulterie, should be discovered & controlled thereby.
hConcil. I•e•d. c Non oportet a leptu •gesima. •3 q, 4.
ican. 64.
kCan. 3. 7. 17 18. 47 65 70. 73, & 75.
lAnnal. Eccles •om. 1 ad anū Christ. 57.Annal. Eccles •om. 1 ad anū Christ. 57.
Next is Ambrose brought in, who upon the 16 chapter of Luke, writeth much against them that putting away their wife do marry another, & he calleth that marriage adultery in sundry places: neither doth he ever except the cause of whoredom in that whole discourse as Bellarmin saith. But what if Bellarmin here be like himself too? Certainly S. Ambrose speaketh9 of such wives as lived without crime &1 whom their husbands were (as he addeth) ⟨p. 53⟩forbidden by the law of God to put away. So that he reproving men for marrying others after they had put away their chaste wives, doth evidently show he meant not of marriage after divorcement for whoredom. And if it be sufficient proof that he supposed they, might not marry again after they had put away a whorish wife because he never excepteth whoredom in that whole discourse of marrying again: then by as sufficient a reason he supposed that2 they, might not put away their wives at all, no not for whoredom, because he never excepteth it in that whole discourse of putting away the wife. But tha• Papists will grant that a man may lawfully put away his wife, if she commit whoredom. As Bellarmin then will construe S, Ambrose in this branch, so let him in the former. And if he say, that S. Ambrose thinking upon Luke alone whom he expounded, or trusting his memory forgot the exception added by Christ in Matthew, forn putting away the wife: the same slip of memory might loose the same exception foro marrying another. If he think that Ambrose did not forget himself, but understood the exception in the former point, as thep Apostle did, though neither mention it expressly: what reason why, it might not as well be understood in the later also? As for S. Jerome no marvel if he wrote against second marriage after divorcement for whoredomq who wrote against all second marriages in such sort, thatr Espenceus asketh what could have been said more grievously against them by the impure3 Catharists, then is said by him? Ands Vives pronounceth, that he did not only detest second marriages, but also had small liking of the first, nor did much favour matrimony;
Next is Ambrose brought in, who vpō the 16 chapter of Luke, writeth much against thē that putting away their wife doe marrie another, & he calleth that marriage adulterie in sundrie places: neither doth he ever except the cause of whoredom in that whole discourse as Bellarmin saith. But what if Bellarmin here be like himself too? Certainely S. Ambrose speaketh9 of such wives as lived without crime &1 whom their husbands were (as hee addeth) ⟨p. 53⟩forbidden by the lawe of God to put away. So that hee reproving men for marrying others after they had put away their chaste wives, doth evidently shewe he meant not of marriage after divorcemēt for whordō. And if it be •ufficiēt proofe that hee supposed they, might not marrie againe after they had put away a whorish wife because hee never excepteth whoredō in that whole discourse of marrying againe: then by as sufficiēt a reason hee supposed that2 they, might not put away their wives at all, no not for whordom, because hee never excepteth it in that whole discourse of putting away the wife. But tha• Papists will graunt that a man may lawfully put away his wife, if shee committ whordom. As Bellarmin then will construe S, Ambrose in this braunch, so let him in the former. And if he say, that S. Ambrose thinking vpō Luke alone whō hee expounded, or trusting his memorie forgot the exception added by Christ in Mathew, forn putting away the wife: the same slipp of memorie might loose the same exception foro marrying another. If he thinke that Ambrose did not forget himself, but vnderstoode the exception in the former point, as thep Apostle did, though neither mentiō it expressely: what reason why, it might not as well be vnderstoode in the later also? As for S. Ierom no marveil if hee wrote against second marriage after divorcemēt for whordomq who wrote against all second marriages in such sort, thatr
9Dimletis •uxorem qua•i jura sin• crimine
1Putas id •ibi l•cere quia •ex humana ••on pr•hibet sed divina pro •ib. •. •.
2Noli crgo uxorem dimit tere. Qui dimittit uxorē facit eam m•e cham.Noli crgo vxorem dimit tere. Qui dimittit uxorē facit eam m•e cham.
Beside that himself too, as far as he exceeded the bounds of Godly modesty & truth herein, even by these mens judgments whom Papists do repute learned & Catholic allayeth & correcteth in one of the places, which Bellarmin allegeth, his peremptory censure given in the other. For whereas he saith in his Epistle to Amandus, that the wife who divorced herself from her husband because of his adultery & married another4 was an adulteress for so marrying, and5 her new husband an adulterer: In his epitaph of Fabiola (a noble godly gentlewoman of Rome, who did the like & was penitent for it after her second husbands death) he saith, that she ⟨p. 54⟩lamented & bewailed it so, as if she had committed adultery. By which kind of speech & others suitable to it, as that he te••meth her state after divorcement from her first husband Widowhood; & addeth, that she lost3 the honour of having had but one husband by marrying the second; 4& saith, she thought it better to undergo a certain, shadow of pitiful wedlock,5 then to play the whore, because it is better (saith Paul) to marry then to burn: S. Jeron declareth that although it were a fault in his opinion to do as she did: yet not such a fault, a crime, a public crime, as Bellarmins doctrine maketh it. No more may it be justly thought in the opinion of that Roman Bishop, of whom, because he put Fabiola to public penance after her second husband death, Bellarmin concludeth that it was accounted a public crime in the Catholic Church at that time, if any man whilst his wife yet lived, married another yea, albeit for whoredom. For men at that time were put to some penance in the Catholic Church, for marrying again after their first wives death, as Bellarmin observeth out of the Catholique•Councels: adding therewith all, that although they knew second marriage to be lawful, yet because it is a token of incontinence they chastised it with some penance. Wherefore sith it might easily be that they who laid some penance upon no fault, would lay public penance upon a small fault, specially in women, to whom in such cases they were more severe & rigorous than to men: the penance which the Bishop did put Fabiola to for her second marriage doth not prove sufficiently that it was accounted then a public crime in the Catholic church.
Beside that himself too, as farre as hee exceeded the boundes of Godly modestie & truth herein, even by these mens iudgments whō Papists doe repute learned & Catholique allayeth & corecteth in one of the places, which Bellarmin alleageth, his peremptorie censure gevē in the other. For whereas hee saith in his Epistle to Amandus, that the wife who divorced herself from her husband because of his adulterie & marri•d another4 was an adulteresse for so marrying, and5 her newe husbānd an adulterer: In his epitaph of Fabiola (a noble godly gentlewoman of Rome, who did the like & was poenitent for it after her second husbands death) hee saith, that shee ⟨p. 54⟩lamented & bewayled it so, as if shee had cōmitted adulterie. By which kinde of speech & others sutable to it, as that he te••meth her state after divorcement frō her first husband Widdowhood; & addeth, that shee lost3 the honor of having had but one husbād by marrying the second; 4& saith, shee thought it better to vndergoe a certaine, shadow of pitifull wedlocke,5 then to plaie the whore, because it is better (saith Paul) to marrie then to burne: S. Ieron declareth that although it were a fault in his opinion to doe as shee did: yet not such a fault, a crime, a publique crime, as Bellarmins doctrine maketh it. No more may it be iustly thought in the opiniō of that Romā Byshop, of whō, because he put Fabiola to publique penance after her second husband death, Bellarmin cōcludeth that it was accounted a publique crime in the Catholique Church at that time, if any man whilst his wife yet lived, married another yea, albeit for whordō. For men at that time were put to some penance in the Catholique Church, for marrying againe after their first wives death, as Bellarmin observeth out of the Catholique•Councels: adding therewith al, that although they knewe secōd marriage to be lawfull, yet because it is a token of incontinēcie they chastised it with some penāce. Wherefore sith it might easilie bee that they who laid some penance vpon no fault, would lay publique penance vpō a small fault, spetially in women, to whō in such cases they were more severe & rigorous thē to mē: the penance which the Bishop did put Fabiola to for her secōd marriage doth not prove sufficiētly that it was accounted thē a publique crime in the Catholique church.
4Si non vult adultera reputa•i.
5Non Apellat•r vir sed adulter.
3Vidutiatem […] non poterat.Vidutiatem 〈…〉 non poterat.
4• Sub gloria […]• Sub gloria 〈…〉
5• po• mortē secundi viti • Opera exercised […].• po• mortē secundi viti • Opera exerce•e 〈…〉.
Howbeit if the term of public crime be used in a gentler sense than vcommonly it is, or the Bishop of Rome did never put any but grievous offenders & sinners to public penance: yet perhaps even so too will Bellarmin come short of his conclusion still. For thereby (saith he) we do not understand that • if any man while his wife yet lived, married another, yea albeit for whoredom; it was accounted a public crime in the Catholic church at that time, if any man did it. As who say the Bishop of Rome must needs hold that, if women were not licensed to marry after divorcement for whoredom, men could not be neither. Whereas he might be of the same opinion, that an ancient xCouncil s•emeth (as I showed) to have been before him; and ⟨p. 55⟩an ancienty Father (living & writing asz some think, in Rome about the same time) was; I mean, that this liberty & freedom should be granted to men but not to women. Moreover the delay of Faebiolas penance, in that she was not put thereto until aafter her second husbands death, yieldeth very strong & probable conjecture, that it had not been before them accounted any crime at all in the Catholic church, not for a woman neither to put away her husband because of his adultery, & to marry another. For that which Fabiola did, she did3 openly. Her self was religious, godly, well instructed; & thought it to be lawful. Her husband by all likelihood of like mind & judgment: the church of Rome called not their marriage in to question; The Bishop did not execute any Church censure on them. Nay, sith she was4 very young, when they married, and never heard of any fault therein committed as long as her husband lived: it may be Rome had many Bishops in the mean time, none of whom saw cause why they should blame her for it. The example of Fabiola therefore, & the Roman Bishops dealing in it, maketh more a great deal with us then against us, if it be throughly weighed. Now S. Chrysostom maketh absolutely with us: Howsoever Bellarmin affirmeth that he teacheth the same with S. Jerome yea, withb S. Jerome simply condemning all such marriage. For what doth S. Chrysostom teach in thec sermon that Bellarmin quoteth upon Matthew? Forsooth, that by Moses law it was permitted, that whosoever hated his wife for any cause, might put her away, and marry another in her room:
Howbeit if the tearme of publique crime be vsed in a gētler sense thē vcōmonly it is, or the Byshop of Rome did never put any but grievous offenders & finners to publique penance: yet perhaps even so too will Bellarmin come short of his conclusiō still. For thereby (saith hee) we doe not vnderstād that • if any mā while his wife yet lived, married another, yea albeit for whordo; it was accounted a publique crime in the Catholique church at that time, if any mā did it. As who say the Byshop of Rome must needs hould that, if women were not licensed to marrie after divorcement for whordom, men could not be neither. Whereas he might be of the same opiniō, that an aunciēt xCouncell s•emeth (as I shewed) to have bene before him; and ⟨p. 55⟩an auncienty Father (living & writing asz some thinke, in Rome about the same time) was; I meane, that this libertie & freedom should be graunted to men but not to women. Moreover the delay of Faebiolas penance, in that she was not put thereto vntill aafter her second husbands death, yeildeth very strong & probable coniecture, that it had not bene before thē accoūted any crime at all in the Catholique church, not for a woman neither to put away her husbād because of his adulterie, & to marrie another. For that which Fabiola did, shee did3 openly. Her self was religious, godly, well instructed; & thought it to be lawfull. Her husbād by all likelyhood of like minde & iudgmēt: the church of Rome called not their marriage in to question; The Byshop did not execute any Church censure on them. Nay, sith shee was4 very yong, when they married, and never heard of anie fault therein committed as long as her husband lived: it may be Rome had many Byshops in the meane time, none of whō saw cause why they should blame her for it. The example of Fabiola therefore, & the Roman Byshops dealing in it, maketh more a great deale with vs then against vs, if it be throughly weighed. Now S. Chrysostom maketh absolutely with vs: Howsoever Bellarmin affirmeth that hee teacheth the same with S. Ierom yea, with
v[…]〈…〉
xConcil, […]. 9.Concil, 〈…〉. 9.
yAmbrosia. […] p. 7Ambros•a. 〈…〉 p. 7
zCe••••• Theologorum Lovan in […]. gust lib […] et nor testam To•—Ce••••• Theologorum Lovan in 〈…〉. gust lib 〈…〉 et nor testam To•—
But Christ left the husband one cause alone to put away his wife for namely whoredom. What? and doth it follow hereof that Chrysostom, meant that the husband putting her away for whoredom, might not marry another? Rather the clean contrary: Seeing that he speaketh of such a putting away, as Moses did permit, and maketh this the difference between Christs ordinance, and the law of Moses, that Moses did permit it for any cause, Christ but for one. Which to be his meaning he showeth more plainlyd upon the first to the Corinthians, saying that the marriage is dissolved by whoredom, neither is the husband a husband any longer. For hence it appeareth that he thought the band of marriage to be loosed. when they, ⟨p. 56⟩are severed for whoredom: & therefore consequently the parties free to marry according to thee Apostles rule. Andf other where also, though somewhat more obscurely yet conference with this place will show him to have taught. But what should I stand on farther proof thereof, it being so undoubted, thatg Bishop Covarrisvias an earnest adversary of marriage after divorcement, and bringing all the Fathers that he can against it, confesseth S. Chrysostom to stand on the other side against him for it. And this in four hundred years after Christ, Bellarmin cannot find one of the Fathers, that he may justly say is his: excepting them which make as much for the Encratites, Montanists, and Catharists, as they do for Papists. In the ages following he findeth better store: now one, now moe in each hundred. Yet among them also, look how many he nameth of the Eastern Bishops, whether expressedly, or impliedly: he playeth the Jesuit with him. For the first of them Theophylact he allegeth with the same faith & truth, that he did Chrysostom, whose scholar Theophylact being (afterh Bellarmins own note) did follow his master. And this the two places themselves that Bellarmin quoteth, do insinuate clearly:i the former by opening how Christ permitteth not that putting away which Moses did, without just cause, nor alloweth any cause as just but whoredom kthe later by omitting mention of whoredom, in specifying the causes, for which if a woman depart from her husband she must remain unmarried. Whereto (if Bellarmin need more light to see it by) we may add a third place:
But Christ left the husband one cause alone to put away his wife for namely whoredome. What? and doth it follow hereof that Chrysostom, meant that the husband putting her away for whoredome, might not marrie another? Rather the cleane contrary: Seing that he speaketh of such a putting away, as Moses did permitt, and maketh this the difference betwene Christs ordinance, and the law of Moses, that Moses did permitt it for anie cause, Christ but for one. Which to be his meaning hee sheweth more plainelyd vpon the first to the Corinthians, saying that the marriage is dissolved by whoredom, neither is the husband a husband anie longer. For hence it appeareth that hee thought the bād of marriage to bee loosed. whē they, ⟨p. 56⟩are severed for whoredom: & therefore consequently the parties free to marrie according to thee Apostles rule. Andf other where also, though somewhat more obscurely yet conference with this place will shewe him to have taught. But what should I stand on farther proofe thereof, it being so vndoubted, thatg Byshop Covarrisvias an earnest adversarie of marriage after divorcement, and bringing all the Fathers that hee can against it, confesseth S. Chrysoctom to stand on the other side against him for it. And this in foure hundred yeares after Christ, Bellarmin cannot finde one of the Fathers, that hee may iustly say is his: excepting them which make as much for the Encratites, Montanists, and Catharists, as they doe for Papists. In the ages following hee findeth better store: now one, now moe in eche hundred. Yet among them also, looke how manie hee nameth of the Easterne Byshops, whether expressedly, or implyedly: hee playeth the Iesuit with him. For the first of them Theophylact hee alleageth with the same faith & truth, that he did Chrysostom, whose schollar Theophylact being (afterh Bellarmins owne note) did follow his maister. And this the two places thēselves that Bellarmin quoteth, doe insinuate clearely:i the former by opening how Christ permitteth not that putting away which Moses did, without iust cause, nor alloweth any cause as iust but whordom k
in whichl Theophylact saying that Luke rehearsing Christs words against men putting away their wives & marrying other must be understood with the exception out of Matthew, 3Unless it be for whoredom, doth show how far he differeth herein from Bellarmin, who denieth flatly that Christs words in Luke must be supplied with that exception. The rest of the Eastern Fathers whose testimony is alleged by Bellarmin though their names not mentioned: are such as were assembled in the Council of Florence. For there came thither to confer with the Pope & the western bishops, albeit many of these holding a general Council at Basil the same time, refused to change the place for the Popes pleasure, who sought his own advantage therein, not the Churches, and undermined the actions ⟨p. 57⟩of the Council of Basil mwhich condemned him of heresy, and deposed him; but there came thithern the Patriarchs of Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem, either themselves in person, or by their deputies, with many Metropolitans and Bishops of Greece of Asia, of Iberia, and other countries of the East. Whose credit and consent how untruly Bellarmin pretē death, for the proof of his false assertion, it is plain by that he saith the Council of Florence did decree the same in the instruction of the Armenians. A chapter which is fathered in deed upon the Council by the schismatical Pope Eugenius the fourth, the deviser of it: but fathered unjustly and calumniously as the time argueth, wherein it was begotten. For it is recorded in the same decree, that it was made the6 two and twentieth of November, in the year of Christ a thousand four hundred, thirty & nine. Now the Council ended in July the same year four months before: As botho it self witnesseth, &p Popish stories not•. Wherefore the Council could not be the father of that decree and chapter: no more then a man can be of that child whi•h is borne fourteen months after his death. And the Pope, whose bastard in truth the brat is, by the acknowledgement and record of Papists themselves in theq Tomes of Councils, was so much the more to blame to father it upon the Council of Florence 7the great & general council, and8 date it in a public solemn session thereof; Because neither was it debated in the Council whether marriage after divorcement for adultery were lawful or no;
in whichl Theophylact saying that Luke rehersing Christes words against men putting away their wives & marrying other must be vnderstood with the exception out of Matthew, 3Vnless it be for whoredom, doth shew howfarre he differeth herein from Bellarmin, who denyeth flatly that Christes wordes in Luke must be supplyed with that exception. The rest of the Easterne Fathers whose testimony is alleaged by Bellarmin though their names not mētioned: are such as were assembled in the Councell of Florence. For there came thither to conferre with the Pope & the westerne byshops, albeit many of these houlding a generall Councell at Basil the same time, refused to chaunge the place for the Popes pleasure, who sought his owne advantage therein, not the Churches, and vndermined the actions ⟨p. 57⟩of the Councell of Basil mwhich condemned him of heresie, and deposed him; but there came thithern the Patriarches of Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioche, and Ierusalem, either themselves in person, or by their deputies, with many Metropolitanes and Byshops of Greece of Asia, of Iberia, and other countries of the East. Whose creditt and consent how vntruely Bellarmin pretē deth, for the proofe of his false assertion, it is plaine by that hee saith the Councell of Florēce did decree the same in the instruction of the Armenians. A chapter which is fathered in deed vpō the Councell by the schisimaticall Pope Eugenius the fovorth, the deviser of it: but fathered vniustly and calmuniously as the time argueth, wherein it was begottē. For it is recorded in the same decree, that it was made the6 two and twentieth of November, in the yeare of Christ a thousand foure hundred, thirtie & nine. Now the Councell ended in Iuly the same yeare foure moneths before: As botho it self witnesseth, &p Popish stories not•. Wherefore the Councell could not be the father of that decree and chapter: no more then a man can be of that childe whi•h is borne fouretē moneths after his death. And the Pope, whose bastard in truth the brat is, by the acknowlegment and record of Papists themselves in the
3Parectos logou porneias delade. obscured by the Latin tram slator omitting delade.Parectos logou porneias delade. obscured by the Latin trā slator omitting delade.
and ther Eastern bishops maintained it to be lawful, when the Pope after the end of the Council did reprove them for it: neither is it likely the contrary was decreed by all there present of the west. Chiefly seeing that more than half of them were gone when both parts the East & West, subscribed to the decrees of the Council in the letters of agreement: as appeareth by conferrings their number witht their names & the note thereof. Yea the Council being ended the sixth of Julie, had their subscriptions added unto it the one & twentieth. Then if of seven score or perhaps upward, scarce threescore were remaining at Florence, fourteen days after the Council ended: What may we think there were above four months after? But how many soever were present of the West, as the ⟨p. 58⟩9Pope can quickly muster an hundred Bishops or more, if need be out of Italy alone,1 to carry away things in Council by multitude of voices, such policy hath he used for that; but how many soever Italians he banded to countenance his decree, the Bishops of the East agreed not thereto, neither was it the Councells act. Thus all the Fathers of the Eastern churches, whom Bellarmin allegeth, and may urge with credit their doctrine touching marriage, do not only not say with him, but gainsay him. Wherein their have so many others follow them from age to age till our time, that it is apparent they allow with greater consent a mans marriage after divorcement for adultery then Fathers of the western churches disallow it. Forv Eusebius treating of Justine the Martyr setteth forth with the same praise that he had done, the story of the Christian woman, who divorced her self from her adulterous husband. And S. xBasils canons approved byy general Councils, do not only authorize the man to marry another, whose wife is an adulteress, but also check the custom which yielded not like favour in like case to the woman. Andz Epiphanius saith (his words are read corruptly, but the sense thereof is plain of our side, asa Covarruvias granteth, Epiphanius therefore saith that Separation being made for whoredom, a man may take a second wife, or a woman a second husband. And the same avouchethb Theodoret in effect, affirming that Christ hath set down one cause: whereby the band of Marriage should be dissolved, and wholly rent a sunder, in that he did except whoredom.
and ther Easterne byshops mainteyned it to be lawfull, when the Pope after the end of the Councell did reprove them for it: neither is it likely the contrarie was decreed by all there present of the west. Chiefly seing that more thē half of them were gone when both partes the East & West, subscribed to the decrees of the Councell in the letters of agreement: as appeareth by conferrings their number witht their names & the note thereof. Yea the Councell being ended the sixth of Iulie, had their subscriptions added vnto it the one & twentith. Then if of sevē score or perhaps vpward, scarse threescore were remayning at Florence, foureteene dayes after the Councell ended: What may we thinke there were above foure moneths after? But how many soever were present of the West, as the ⟨p. 58⟩9Pope can quickly muster an hundred Byshops or more, if neede be out of Italie alone,1 to carry away things in Councell by multitude of voices, such pollicie hath he vsed for that; but how many soever Italians he banded to countenance his decree, the Byshops of the East agreed not thereto, neither was it the Councells act. Thus all the Fathers of the Eastern churches, whom Bellarmin alleadgeth, and may vrge with creditt their doctrine touching marriage, doe not onely not say with him, but gainsay him. Wherein their have so many others followe them from age to age till our time, that it is apparant they allowe with greater consent a mās marriage after divorcement for adulterie then Fathers of the western churches disallow it. Forv Eusebius treating of Iustine the Martyr setteth forth with the same praise that hee had done, the storie of the Christian woman, who divorced her self frō her adulterous husband. And S. xBasils canons approved byy generall Councels, doe not onely authorize the mā to marrie another, whose wife is an adulteresse, but also check the custome which yeelded not like favour in like case to the woman. Andz
rSynod Florent sess. ult.
sIn proamio
tSess. ult.
9There are about o• by shops seas in Italy, Leand. Al•ert in descript, Italy.There are about o• by shops seas in Italie, Leand. Al•ert in descript, Italie.
1Eneas Sylv• us de ge••s Basiliensis concil. lib. Clā dius Esp•ceus in epist ad Titam cap 1.Eneas Sylv• us de ge••s Basiliensis concil. lib. Clā dius Esp•ceus in epist ad Titam cap 1.
vHist. eccl lib. 4 cap. 17.
xCan 9. et 21.
ySynod sext. in Trull can. 2 c Quoniam […] Synod, sept can. 1.Synod sext. in Trull can. 2 c Quoniam 〈…〉 Synod, sept can. 1.
And ac general Council, wherein there were above two hundred and twenty bishops of the East gathered together, doth imply as much; in saying that He, who his wife 2 having kept the law of wedlock, and being faithful to him, yet forsaketh her and marrieth another is by Christs sentence guilty of adultery. So dothd Oecumenius in applying the precept of abiding unmarried to such as should not have departed, and in abridging Chrysostom's words after his manner, whose scholare Bellarmin therefore termeth him. So dothf Euthymius Chrysostoms scholar too, in charging that man with adultery, who marrieth a woman divorced for any cause but whoredom from her husband. So doth Nicephoras, in copying & commending that out of Eusebius, which he had out of Justin the Martyr. To be short, the Grecians, 3which namg compriseth many nations of the East, all whom theh Florentine Council calleth the Eastern Church do ⟨p. 59⟩put the same doctrine received from their ancestors in practise even at this day, allowing married folk not only, to sperate & divorce themselves in case of adultery but also to marry others, as Bellarmin confesseth. Wherefore his opinion hath not the consent of the Eastern bishops: neither hath had it any age since Christ. Much less can he show the consent of the Southi the Ethiopians, & Abessines, or of thek Muscovites & Ruses in the North: both which as they received their faith from the East, so use they like freedom & liberty for this matter. No, not in the west it self, though he have many thence agreeing with him, yet hath he the general consent of all the Fathers perhaps not of half, if an exact count might be taken of them. For besides Tertullian, the Council of Eliberis and to let pass Ambrose) one Bishop of Rome, or more already showed to have thought that a man being divorced from his wife for her adultery, is free to marry again: there are of the same mindl Lactantius, mChromatius, nHilary, oPollentius, pthe author of the Commentaries in Ambrose his name upon S.
And ac generall Councell, wherein there were above two hundred and twentie byshops of the East gathered together, doth imply as much; in saying that Hee, who his wife 2 having kept the lawe of wedlocke, and being faithfull to him, yet forsaketh her and marrieth another is by Christs sentence guiltie of adulterie. So dothd Oecumenius in applying the precept of abiding vnmarried to such as should not have departed, and in abridging Chrysostōs words after his manner, whose scholare Bellarmin therefore tearmeth him. So dothf Euthymius Chrysostoms schollar too, in •harging that mā with adulterie, who marrieth a woman divorced for any cause but whordō from her husbād. So doth Nicephoras, in copying & cōmending that out of Eusebius, which he had out of Iustin the Martyr. To be short, the Grecians, 3which namg compriseth many nations of the East, all whō theh Florentine Councell calleth the Eastern Church doe ⟨p. 59⟩put the same doctrine receyved from their auncestours in practise even at this day, allowing married folke not onely, to sperate & divorce thēselves in case of adulterie but also to marrie others, as Bellarmin confesseth. Wherefore his opiniō hath not the consent of the Eastern byshops: neither hath had it any age since Christ. Much lesse can he shewe the consent of the Southi the Aethiopians, & Abessines, or of thek Moscovites & Russes in the North: both which as they receyved their faith frō the East, so vse they like freedome & libertie for this matter. No, not in the west it self, though he have many thēce agreeing with him, yet hath hee the generall cōsent of all the Fathers perhaps not of half, if an exact count might be taken of them. For besides Tertullian, the Councell of Eliberis and to let passe Ambrose) one Byshop of Rome, or more alreadie shewed to have thought that a man being divorced from his wife for her adulterie, is free to marrie againe: there are of the same minde
cSext Synod. Constant. no in Trull can. 8• Nomon synap theisan translated otherwise by some but meant thus by the councell as men•oi with the antithelis going before it showeth, & their use o• the word Synap testes Can. 13. d•t. • c Q•o•niamSext Synod. Constant. no in Trull cā. 8• Nomon synap theisan translated otherwise by some but mēt thus by the councell as men•oi with the antithelis going before it sheweth, & their vse o• the word Synap testes Can. 13. d•t. • c Q•o•niam
Pauls epistles,q the first Council of Arles, rthe council of Vans, they who either were at or agreed to thes sixth general council the second time assembledt Pope Gregory the third vPope Zechariah, the council ofx Worms ofy Trybur, ofz Mascon, a council alleged bya Gratian without name, & other learned men alleged likewise byb him,c Pope Alexander the third,d Celestin the 3,e Zechariah andf Paul bishops, the one of Chrysopolis, the other of Burgos, gErasmus, hCardinal Cajetan: iArchbishop Catharinus, kNaclantus bishop of Clugia, finally the teachers of the reformed churches inl England, mScotland, nGermany, oFrance &p other countries, for why should not I name these of our profession & faith among the Fathers as well as Bellarmin nameth the Popish council of Trent on the contrary side? But the Papists (will some man peradventure say, do not grant that all, whom you have rehearsed, were of this opinion. But the Papists (I answer) do grant that sundry of them were? and such as they grant not, the light of truth & reason will either make them grant, or shame them for denying it. As2 Sixtus Senensis, namely doth deny that Hilary and Chromantius allow a man to marry ⟨p. 60⟩another wife after divorcement: or teach that he is loosed from the band of matrimony, while his former wife though an adulteress liveth. Now weigh their own words, & it will appear that Sixtus injurieth them therein. For25 Chromatius saith that they who having putt away their wives4 for any cause save for whoredom, presume to marry others, do against the will of God, and are condemned. Wherein, with what sense could he except whoredom, unless he thought them guiltless, who having put away their wives for it do marry others? Ands Hilary affirming Christ to have prescribed no other cause5 of ceasing from matrimony, but that; she weth that the band of matrimony is loosed thereby in his judgment. Chiefly sith he knew that they might cease from the use thereof, for other causes: & the occasion and tenor of the speech do argue that he meant of such a separation as yieldeth liberty of new marriage. In like sort, or rather more plainly and expressly did Pollentius hold and maintain the same: As Austin (whom in this point he dissented from) doth report and testify.
Pauls epistles,q the first Councell of Arles, rthe coūcell of Vānes, they who either were at or agreed to thes sixth generall coūcell the secōd time assēbledt Pope Gregorie the third vPope Zacharie, the councell ofx Wormes ofy Trybur, ofz Mascon, a councell alleaged bya Gratian without name, & other learned men alleaged likewise byb him,c Pope Alexander the third,d Celestin the 3,e Zacharie andf Paul byshops, the one of Chrysopolis, the other of Burgos, gErasmus, hCardinal Cajetan: iArchbyshop Catharinus, kNaclantus byshop of Clugia, finallie the teachers of the reformed churches inl Englād,
qcan •0.
rcau. •
sCon •antinop in Trullo can. 8•. gr 8• lat.Cō •antinop in Trullo can. 8•. gr 8• lat.
tEpist 4 ad Bo•sacium
v32. q 7 c. con cubuisti.32. q 7 c. cō cubuisti.
xcap. 3. et 10. Bu•chard. decretor l6. c. 4• et l. 17. cap. 17. et 10.
y32. q. 7. c. Si quis cum noverca Burchar. lib. 17. c. 17. et 18.
zca. 5 Burchar lib. 17. c. 15.
a32. • 7. c quae dam
bSed illudead caus et quest.
c• Vemens 1. extt. de eo qui cogu consang uxoris suae.• Vemens 1. extt. de eo qui cogu consang vxoris suae.
d• Quanto. extra. de divo. tljs
ede concord Evang. cap. 100.de cōcord Euang. cap. 100.
Yet Bellarmin (a strange thing in a case so clear, but nothing strange to Jesuits) saith that Pollentius 6did not gainsay Austin, but asked his judgment of the matter: and for proof hereof referreth us to the beginnings of both the books of Austin. Event to those beginnings in which it is declared how Austin having laboured to prove that a woman parted from her husband for his fornication might not marry another, Pollentius wrote unto him7 as it were by way of asking his judgment, and showed he thought the contrary: yet showed it in such sort, that Austin setting down both their opinions, doth specify then as flatly crossing one the other: You are of this mind, I of that: and saith of Pollentius again and again that8 he was of this mind, which Bellarmin denieth he was of. Wherein the Jesuits dealing is more shameful, for that beside the evidence of the thing it self so often repeated in the very same places that he citethv Sixtus Senenses a man as unwilling as Bellarmin to weaken any of their Trent points with granting more then he must needs confesseth that Pollentius thought hereof as we do. Belike because Sixtus Senensis honoureth him with the praise and title of a9 most godly man: Bellarmin thought it better to lie, then ⟨p. 61⟩to grant that they have such an adversary. He would fain avoid too another ancient father bearing the name of Ambrose; &x Ambrose might his name be, though he were not famous Ambrose Bishop of Milan. But whether he were named so, or otherwise (which1 perhaps is truer) unto his testimony pronouncing it lawful by S. Pauls doctrine for a man justly divorced to marry again (though not for a woman, as he, by mistaking S; Paul, through error,x though Bellarmin replieth with a threefold answer. Firsty Gratian (saith he) and Peter zLombard do affirm that those words were thrust into this authors Commentary, by some corrupters of writings. Indeed the one of them affirmeth:2 it is said so; the other,3 it is thought so. But if it be sufficient to affirm barely, without any ground of proof or probability, that it is said or thought so: what error so absurd that may not be defended by perverse wranglers? what cause so unjust, that unrighteous judges may not give sentence with?
Yet Bellarmin (a strange thing in a case so cleare, but nothing strange to Iesuits) saith that Pollentius 6did not gainsaie Austin, but asked his iudgment of the matter: and for proofe hereof referreth vs to the beginnings of both the bookes of Austin. Event to those beginnings in which it is declared how Austin having laboured to prove that a woman parted from her husband for his fornication might not marry another, Pollentius wrote vnto him7 as it were by way of asking his iudgment, and shewed hee thought the contrarie: yet shewed it in such sorte, that Austin setting downe both their opinions, doth specifie then as flatly crossing one the other: You are of this mynde, I of that: and saith of Pollentius againe and againe that8 hee was of this mynde, which Bellarmin denieth hee was of. Wherein the Iesuits dealing is more shamefull, for that beside the evidence of the thing it self so often repeated in the verie same places that hee citethv Sixtus Senenses a man as vnwilling as Bellarmin to weaken anie of their Trent points with graunting more then hee must needes confesseth that Pollentius thought hereof as we doe. Belike because Sixtus Senensis honoreth him with the praise and title of a9 most godlie man: Bellarmin thought it better to lie, then ⟨p. 61⟩to graunt that they have such an adversarie. Hee would faine avoid too another auncient father bearing the name of Ambrose; &x Ambrose might his name be, though hee were not famous Ambrose Byshop of Milan. But whether hee were named so, or otherwise (which1 perhaps is truer) vnto his testimonie pronouncing it lawfull by S. Paules doctrine for a man iustly divorced to marrie againe (though not for a woman, as hee, by missetaking S; Paul, through errour,x though Bellarmin replieth with a threefold answere. First
6Non contra dixit Augustino sed eum consuluit.
tDe adult cō jug ad Pollent. lib 1. cap. •. et lib. 2. cap 2.De adult cō jug ad Pollēt. lib 1. cap. •. et lib. 2. cap 2.
For whatsoever words be enforced against them out of the law of God or man, out of any evidence or record of writers & witnesses worthy credit: they may with Peter Lombard and Gratian reply that the place alleged is said or thought to have been thrust into those monuments by some corrupters of writings. And in replying thus they should speak truly, though it were said or thought by none beside themselves: but how reasonably they should speak therein, let men of sense & reason judge. Surely though Peter Lombard rest upon that answer; for want of a better, yet Gratian (whether fearing the sickly state thereof) doth leave it, & seeketh himself a new patron, saying that Ambrose words are thus meant, that a man may lawfully marry another wife after the death of the adulteress, but not while she liveth, which answer is more absurd then the former. In so much thata Covarruvias speaking of the former only as uncertain, saith that this repugneth manifestly to Ambrose. A very true verdict, as a•ie man not blind may see by Ambrose words: And Bellarmin confesseth the same in effect, by passing it over in silence as ashamed of it. But others (saith he secondly) do answer that this author speaketh of the Civil law, the law of Emperors: To wit, that by the Emperors Laws it is lawful for men, but not for women, ⟨p. 62⟩having put away their mate, to marry another: and that Paul therefore least he should offend the Emperor bwould not say expressly. If a man put away his wife, let him abide so or be reconciled to his wife. Now Gratians second answer was no less worthy to have been mentioned, then this ofc William Lindan, patched up by Bellarmin. For thed civill law pronounceth the band of marriage to be loosed as well by divorcement as by death: and alloweth women to take other husbands, their former being put away, as it alloweth men to take others wives. So that it is a fond and unlearned conceit to imagine that Paul would not say of husbands as he did of wives, least he should offend the Emperor by speaking expressly against that which his law allowed. Fore he did expressly control the Emperors law in saying of the wife. If she depart from her husband, let her remain unmarried, or be reconciled to her husband. And the authors words do show that he meant to speak, not of human laws, but of divine:
For whatsoever wordes be enforced against them out of the law of God or man, out of anie evidēce or record of writers & witnesses worthie credit: they may with Peter Lombard and Gratian replie that the place alleaged is said or thought to have bene thrust into those monumēts by some corrupters of writīgs. And in replying thus they should speake truelie, though it were said or thought by none beside themselves: but how reasonably they should speake therein, let men of sense & reason iudge. Surelie though Peter Lombard rest vpō that aunswer; for want of a better, yet Gratian (whether fearing the sicklie state thereof) doth leave it, & seeketh himself a new patron, saying that Ambrose words are thus meant, that a man may lawfullie marrie another wife after the death of the adulteresse, but not while shee liveth, which aunswer is more absurd then the former. In so much thata Covarruvias speaking of the former onelie as vncertaine, saith that this repugneth manifestlie to Ambrose. A verie true verdict, as a•ie man not blind may see by Ambrose wordes: And Bellarmin confesseth the same in effect, by passing it over insilence as ashamed of it. But others (sayth hee secondlie) doe aunswer that this authour speaketh of the Civil law, the law of Emperours: To weete, that by the Emperours Lawes it is lawfull for men, but not for women, ⟨p. 62⟩having put away their mate, to marrie another: and that Paul therefore least he should offend the Emperour bwould not say expressely. If a man put away his wife, let him abide so or be reconciled to his wife. Now Gratians second aunswer was no lesse worthy to have bene mentioned, then this ofc William Lindan, patched vp by Bellarmin. For thed civill law pronounceth the band of marriage to be loosed as well by divorcement as by death: and alloweth women to take other husbands, their former being put awaie, as it alloweth men to take others wives. So that it is a fond and vnlearned conceit to imagin that Paul would not say of husbands as hee did of wives, least hee should offend the Emperour by speaking expresselie against that which his law allowed. Fore hee did expressely controll the Empero•rs law in saying of the wife. If shee depart from her husband, let her remaine vnmarried, or be reconciled to her husband. And the authours wordes doe shewe that hee meant to speake, not of humaine lawes, but of divine:
ds •. D. de divort et. repud, • si ex lege ad legē sul de adul• l Consensus si constan •e c. de repudijs.s •. D. de divort et. repud, • si ex lege ad legē sul de adul• l Cōsensu• si constan •e c. de repudijs.
of the sacred scripture whereupon he wrote, and what was thereby lawful. Which seemed so evident unto, fPeter Soto, gand Sixtus Senesis, andh the Roman Censors, who oversaw Pope Gregory the thirteenth new edition of the Cannon law, that they confess that Ambrose (meaning this author) doth approve plainly, certainly, undoubtedly, mens liberty of marrying again after divorcement. Bellarmin therefore coming in with his third answer. Yet saith he if these be not so well liked, it may be answered easily: that the author of those Commentaries is not Ambrose, nor any of the renowned Fathers, 4as learned men know. Thus at length this author, if men will not believe that his words are corrupted, or that he spake of the Civill law, shall be granted us with Bellarmins good leave: But then we shall be told that he is not Ambrose, nor any of the renowned Fathers as learned men know. And why could not Bellarmin answer this at first? Why was he so loath to grant that such an author, base, obscure of slender credit, maketh with us? Herein there lieth a mystery. There isi in this authors Commentaries a place, a5 piece of a sentence, which seemeth to speak for the Popes Supremacy: Though perhaps never written by this author, or not with that meaning, as I have showed elsewhere. ⟨p. 63⟩lBellarmin had cited that place for that in6 S. Ambrose his name: andm ma•ie make a feast thereof, as being sure S. Ambroses. Now if he should say, that the author of those Commentaries was neither Ambrose nor Saint: he should gainsay himself. And sith he was learned, when he did cite it so, and therefore knew (by his own words) that it was not Ambrose nor any of the renowned fathers who wrote it: men would see thereby, that he had for the Popes sake against his own knowledge, fathered on S, Ambrose that which is not his. No marvel then if Bellarmin came to this answer as a bear to the stake. At the which though he seem to cast us o•, by saying that the author was no renowned Father, and erred in mistaking S. Paul, as having given more liberty to men then women, whereof in due place afterward: yet in the mean season he is forced to grant that this ancient Father took it to be lawful for men to marry again after divorcement for adultery.
of the sacred scripture wherevpō he wrote, and what was thereby lawfull. Which seemed so evident vnto, fPeter Soto, gand• Sixtus Senesis, andh the Roman Censors, who oversaw Pope Gregorie the thirtenths new edition of the Cannon law, that they confesse that Ambrose (meaning this authour) doth aprove plainely, certainly, vndoubtely, mens liberty of marrying againe after divorcement. Bellarmin therefore comyng in with his third aunswer. Yet saith hee if these be not so well liked, it may be aunswered easilie: that the author of those Commentaries is not Ambrose, nor any of the renowned Fathers, 4as learned men know. Thus at length this authour, if men will not beleeve that his wordes are corrupted, or that hee spake of the Civill law, shall be graunted vs with Bellarmins good leave: But then wee shall be tolde that hee is not Ambrose, nor anie of the renowned Fathers as learned men know. And why could not Bellarmin aunswere this at first? Why was hee so loath to graunt that such an authour, base, obscure of sclender credit, maketh with vs? Herein there lieth a mysterie. There isi in this authours Commentaries a place, a5 peece of a sentence, which seemeth to speake for the Popes Supremacie: Though perhaps never writen by this authour, or not with that meaning, as I have shewed elswhere. ⟨p. 63⟩lBellarmin had cited that place for that in6 S. Ambrose his name: andm ma•ie make a feast thereof, as being sure S. Ambroses. Now if hee should saie, that the authour of those Cō mentaries was neither Ambrose nor Saint: hee should gainsaie himself. And sith hee was learned, when hee did cite it so, and therefore knewe (by his owne words) that it was not Ambrose nor anie of the renowned fathers who writt it: men would see thereby, that hee had for the Popes sake against his owne knowledg, fathered on S, Ambrose that which is not his. No marveil then if Bellarmin came to this aunswere as a beare to the stake. At the which though hee seeme to cast vs o, by saying that the authour was no renowned Father, and erred in mistaking S. Paul, as having geven more libertie to men then womē, wherof in due place afterward: yet in the meane season hee is forced to graunt that this auncient Father tooke it to be lawfull for men to marrie againe after divorcement for adulterie.
fInstit sacerd ca de Matrim Lect. 3.
gBiblioth sare lib. 6. annot 8
hAnnot. in cap. wot. a uro. 32. 97.Annot. in cap. v•ot. a vro. 32. 97.
4Quod er•di•i non ignorant.
iIn epist. 1. ad Tim cap. 3.
5Cujushodie •actor est Da••••.
lTo. 2. conte. • lib. 1 cap 6.
6Beatus Ambrosius where by he meaneth famous Ambrose, bishop of M••ā as the quotations following show.Beatus Ambrosius where by he meneth famous Ambrose, byshop of M••ā as the quotatiōs following shew.
mThe English college of Rheimes. Annot. on 1. tim. 3. 15
The sundry evasions and shifts whereby the Papists have laboured to wrest the credit of this one •ather out of our hands, do give me occasion to suspect that they will wrangle much more to withdraw from us the first Council of Arles 7being more ancient in time, in credit greater, and (asn one of themselves doth probably conjecture) confirmed by the Pope also. Hereunto the Councels wishing of certain persons not to marry in the case we treat of might serve them for a colour in as much aso it saith concerning them whose wives are taken in adultery, that if they be young men and forbidden to marry,8 advise should be given them, as much as may be not to take other wives while the former live, though adulteresses. But this giving of advise is in truth an argument that the council judged a man no adulterer, if he took another wife. Else would they have given not advise and counsel, but charge and commandment to refrain from it; and (as it is likely) restrained mens transgression therein with sharp discipline, specially consideringp they punish lesser faults with excommunication. Neither it is nothing that they temper also this counsel and advise to be given such, with9 as much as may be. And a further circumstance yet of more importance, they make not this restraint for all men, but for7 young men: ⟨p. 64⟩nor for all young men, but such as are forbidden to marry: meaning (as it seemeth) those who being under the care of their parents were by them forbidden, & could not honestly disobey. For had not this respect or the like moved the Fathers of the Council, why should they have restrained such young men & not other? Nay, why only young men, not rather men, not aged men, or them also? Sith inq Scripture elder women are chosen to be widows, and younger willed to marry. Our adversaries therefore must yield that the Council of Arles is of our side for the point in question. Whereto they shall have greater reason to induce them, if they note with all that the rCouncil of Vans in the same country,2 the age following made this canon. We appoint and ordain, that they who having l•ft their wives, except for whoredom (as it is said in the Gospel) or upon proof made of adultery, marry others, shall be excommunicated; Least 3sins being suffered by our too much gentleness do provoke other men to looseness of transgressing.
The sundrie evasions and shifts whereby the Papists have laboured to wrest the credit of this one •ather out of our hādes, doe geve mee occasion to suspect that they will wrangle much more to withdraw from vs the first Councell of Arles 7being more auncient in time, in credit greater, and (asn one of themselves doth probably coniecture) confirmed by the Pope also. Herevnto the Councels wishing of certaine persons not to marrie in the case wee treat of might serve them for a colour in as much aso it saith concerning them whose wives are taken in adulterie, that if they be yong men and forbidden to marrie,8 advise should be given them, as much as may be not to take other wives while the former live, though adulteresses. But this giving of advise is in truth an argument that the councell iudged a man no adulterer, if hee tooke another wife. Els would they have given not advise and counsail, but charge and commandement to refraine from it; and (as it is likely) restrained mens transgression therein with sharpe discipline, spetially consideringp they punish lesser faults with excommunication. Neither it is nothing that they temper also this counsail and advise to be geven such, with9 as much as may be. And a farder circumstance yet of more importance, they make not this restraint for all men, but for7 yong men: ⟨p. 64⟩nor for all yong mē, but such as are forbidden to marrie: meaning (as it seemeth) those who being vnder the care of their parents were by them forbidden, & could not honestlie disobey. For had not this respect or the like moved the Fathers of the Councell, why should they have restrained such yong men & not other? Nay, why onelie yong men, not rather men, not aged men, or them also? Sith inq Scripture elder women are chosen to be widowes, and yonger willed to marrie. Our adversaries therefore must yeeld that the Councell of Arles is of our side for the point in question. Whereto they shall have greater reason to induce them, if they note with al that the
7Held in Constantins time about the year• of Christ. 3•0
nBart caran•• in somma con ciliorum.Bart caran•• in somma cō ciliorum.
And this decree I find not any of the Papists that goeth about to shift of▪ Neither can I see how they may possibly: The Council expounding so plainly Christs words of marriage forbidden after divorcement unless it be for whoredom, and accounting marriage after such divorcement not a lesser sin, but no sin at all, as the reason added for strength of their decree showeth, Now for the next, the general Council assembled in the Emperors palace of Constantinople which made the like decree and taught the same doctrine, as I have declared: Bellarmin would persuade us (upon other occasions touching Popery nearer the quick, then this doth) that the western Bishops neither gave countenance thereto with their presence, nor approved the Canons thereof with their consent. To this end he denieth that the said Council was a general Council, & striveth in hiss third controversy to answer some of our reasons which confirm it. But he easeth us of pains to fifth his answers by means that himself in thet fourth controversy, discoursing of general councils purposely, doth reckon it amongst them. For as inv mens laws when they are repugnant one unto another, the later derogateth from the former: so (I trow) when Bellarmin doth contradict himself, his last word must hold. And the more reason it should so in ⟨p. 65⟩this, because bothx Pope Adrian the first of ancient time did call it the sixth Council, declaring thereby he took it to be one of the General Councils whereof he termed it the sixth, and iny the seventh general Council sundry Fathers alleged it by the name of the sixth General, & avouched it to be justly called so. Which sentence of theirs being not controlled by any of that Council, and thez Council it self afterward approving the decrees and Canons of the six general Councils: it is very probable that the western churches yielding their con sent to the seventh Council, and taking it for sound, accounted (asa the Eastern still have done & do) that which they entitled the sixth to be General. Specially seeing that in the West, men of great creditb Ivo andc Gratian andd Pope Innocentius the third and their disciples, the whole school of Canonists have on those authorities of the seventh Council made like reckoning of it.
And this decree I finde not anie of the Papists that goeth about to shift of▪ Neither can I see how they may possiblie: The Councell expounding so plainely Christes wordes of marriage forbidden after divorcement vnlesse it be for whoredome, and accompting marriage after such divorcement not a lesser sinne, but no sinne at all, as the reason added for strength of their decree sheweth, Now for the next, the generall Councell assembled in the Emperours palace of Con••antinople which made the like decree and taught the same doctrine, as I have declared: Bellarmin would persuade vs (vpon other occasions touching Poperie nearer the quick, then this doth) that the western Byshops neither gave countenaun•e thereto with their presence, nor approved the Canons thereof with their consent. To this end hee denieth that the said Councell was a generall Councell, & striveth in hiss third controversie to aunswer some of our reasons which confirme it. But hee easeth vs of paines to fift his aunsweres by meanes that himself in thet fourth cōtroversie, discoursing of generall councels purposelie, doth reckē it amongst thē. For as inv mēs lawes whē they are repugnāt one vnto another, the later derogateth frō the former: so (I trow) when Bellarmin doth contradict himself, his last word must hold. And the more reasō it should so in ⟨p. 65⟩this, because bothx Pope Adrian the first of auncient tyme did call it the sixth Councell, declaring thereby hee tooke it to be one of the Gēeral Coūcels whereof he tearmed it the sixth, and iny the seaventh generall Councell sūdry Fathers alleaged it by the name of the sixth Generall, & avouched it to bee iustly called so. Which sentence of theirs being not controled by any of that Councell, and thez Councell it self afterwarde approving the decrees and Canons of the sixe generall Councels: it is verie probable that the western churches yeelding their cō sent to the seavēth Coūcel, and taking it for sound, accounted (as
sDe Ro. pont, lib. 2. cap. 27
tDe eccles mi lit. lib. 1. cap 7
vl. fin, D. de constitut princip•m.
xlib. 1 d• imaginib. ad Carol Magn c•p. 35 post N••caen synod 2. et ejus synod•act 2.
And although our younger papists for the most part and some of the elder, perceiving what advantage may be taken thence against many grounds of popery, do cross their predecessors herein with4 silly reasons, such as where of the b•st would infer more forcibly that their Council of Trent was no General Council: yet among them also there are who allow the ancient opinion, ase Caranza namely, and Genebrard and Surius, with whose preface tending to the proof thereof it is recommended & published by papists in the two 5 perfitst and last editions of the Councils. Wherefore whether any of the West were present in person, or by deputies,g and subscribed to it which 9 Balsamon andh Nilus, learned Greek Fathers avouch by old records; or whether it were celebrated by Eastern bishops only, as thei second General Council also was in the same City of Constantinople the consent of the west approving it for General averreth my sayings by a cloud of witnesses of the western Churches. Pope Gregory the third followeth, kHe granteth that if a woman by reason of sickness wherewith she were taken could not perform the duty of a wise to her husband, her husband might put her away and marry another. More then by the doctrine of Christ he had learned to grant for any sickness: but so much the likelier that he ⟨p. 66⟩thought it should be granted for whoredom expressly mentioned by Christ. Whereuponl Joverius a Sorbonist in a work approved by Sorbonists, matcheth his Canon with the like of Councils, who gave the Innocent party leave to marry again after divorcement, while the other lived. Neither doth Bellarmin deny the illation, but the proposition, which the point inferred is grounded upon. For the Doctors (saith he mean ing the Canonists) expound the Canon of such sickness as maketh a woman unfit for Marriage: and so is an impediment dissolving matrimony contracted, by showing it was no true matrimony. But the Doctor of Doctorsm Gratian himself understood it otherwise; of sickness befalling to her, who was an able wife. And those his gloss writers use most that exposition which Bellarmin would have us receive for authentic as the fittest salve; yet rest nthey not upon it. Ando Antonius a great Canonist: Archbishop of Florence correcting Gratians slip of memory for the persons, concludeth with him for the matter.
And although our yonger papists for the most parte and some of the elder, perceyving what advantage may be taken thence agaynst many grounds of popery, doe crosse their predecessours herein with4 seely reasons, such as where of the b•st would inferre more forceablie that their Councell of Trent was no Generall Councel: yet amōg thē also there are who allowe the auncient opinyon, ase Caranza namely, andf Genebrard and Surius, with whose preface tēding to the proofe therof it is recommended & published by papists in the two 5 perfitst and last editions of the Councels. Wherefore whether anye of the West were present in person, or by deputyes,g and subscribed to it which 9 Balsamon andh Nilus, learned Greeke Fathers avouch by olde records; or whether it were celebrated by Eastern byshops onely, as thei second Generall Councell also was in the same City of Constantinople the consent of the west approving it for Generall averreth my sayings by a cloude of witnesses of the western Churches. Pope Gregory the third followeth, kHee graunteth that if a woman by reason of sicknesse wherewith shee were taken could not performe the duty of a wise to her husband, her husband might put her away and marrie another. More then by the doctrine of Christ hee had learned to graunt for any sicknes: but so much the likelyer that he ⟨p. 66⟩thought it should bee graunted for whoredom expressely mentioned by Christ. Wherevponl Ioverius a Sorbonist in a worke approved by Sorbonists, matcheth his Canon with the like of Councels, who gave the Innocent partie leave to marrie againe after divorcement, while the other lived. Neither doth Bellarmin denye the illation, but the proposition, which the poynt inferred is grounded vpon. For the Doctors (sayth hee meā ing the Canonists) expound the Canon of such sicknesse as maketh a woman vnfitt for Marriage: and so is an impediment disolving matrymonye contracted, by shewing it was no true matrimonye. But the Doctor of Doctors
4Urged by Bellarmin of Canus etc. lib. 2. de Rom pont cap. •7.Vrged by Bellarmin of Canus etc. lib. 2. de Rom pont cap. •7.
eIn summa conciliorū, chronograph. lib. 3. conciliorū con stantinopolitanum finitur sub Justinian. Rhinotmeto colectis 227, episcopis in eius palatio. The one of coolen in tō • the other at Venice in 5.In sūma cōciliorū, chrōograph. lib. 3. cōciliorū cō stātinopolitanum finitur sub Iustinian. Rhinotmeto colectis 227, episcopis in eius palatio. The one of coolen in tō • the other at Venice in 5.
nvel intellige vel dic. In c quod proposuisti verbo
oHist, part 2, tit. • Ca. 1, quamvis. where he nameth Englshmē in stead of Germans, & Gregory the 1. instead of Gregory the 3 or 2, as Antonins took it.
And the flower of Lovanq Tapper, the Chancellor of their viniversity, approveth this of Antonius. Andr the learned men who were over-seers of the last edition of the Councils do witness by controlling it as a thing which now the Church observeth not'6 that Gregory meant of sickness happening unto lawful wives in their judgement And the Pope himself (ass Bellarmin noteth else where) declareth that he took it to be true matrimony, by saying that the man ought not to bereave the former wife of aid, that is, ought to maintain, & find her as his wife still. Wherefore if no Catholic bishop would imagine that a man may lawfully put away his sick wife, and marry another, unless he thought the same much more to be lawful in an adulterous wife, as we are to presume: then must the Papists by consequent acknowledge that the point in Question is proved and allowed by Gregory the third. A plainer and directer allowance thereof, appeareth in a Canon of his successor t Zechariah, who when a certain man had defiled himself incestuously with his wives sister, granted that his wife should be divorced from him: and (unless she were privy to that wicked act by counselling or procuring it) might marry in the Lord if she could not contain. This so clear a testimony of an7 ancient Pope ⟨p. 67⟩authorizing the divorced woman to marry, Bellarmin would elude, by saying that he meant she might marry another, after the former husbands death. As who say, the Pope enjoining the8 man and the whore for a punishment to stay and abide without hope of marriage, were likely to mean by liberty of marrying granted the guiltless for a benefit, that while the guilty lived, who might overlive her, she should not marry no more then he. Or as though there had been need for the Pope then to grant it with exception,9 If she will not contain Let her marry in the Lord. Whereby it seemeth that he rather wished her to refrain from marriage, if she might be induced thereto, which he had no cause to wish on this occasion after the mans death, she being v then simply free,u and willed to marry xsuch might her age be. But what do I reason out of the circumstances in a thing so certain and clear of it self, that although they great masters whom Bellarmin alleged before & followed here, have assayed to darken the light thereof by this mist:z
And the flower of Lovanq Tapper, the Chauncelour of their viniversity, approveth this of Antonius. Andr the learned men who were over-seers of the last edition of the Councels doe witnesse by cōtrolling it as a thing which now the Church observeth not'6 that Gregory meant of sickenesse happ•ning vnto lawfull wives in their iudgement And the Pope himselfe (ass Bellarmin noteh els where) declareth that hee tooke it to bee true matrymonie, by saying that the man ought not to bereave the former wife of ayde, that is, ought to maynteyne, & finde her as his wife still. Wherfore if no Catholique byshop would imagin that a man may lawfully put away his sick wife, and marrie another, vnlesse hee thought the same much more to bee lawfull in an adulterous wife, as wee are to presume: then must the Papists by consequent acknowledg that the poynt in Question is prooved and allowed by Gregory the third. A playner and directer allowance thereof, appeareth in a Canon of his successor t Zacharie, who whē a certayne man had defiled himself incestiously with his wives sister, graunted that his wife should be divorced from him: and (vnlesse shee were privie to that wicked act by counsayling or procuring it) might marry in the Lord if shee could not conteine. This so cleare a testimony of an7 auncient Pope ⟨p. 67⟩authorizing the divorced woman to marrie, Bellarmin would elude, by saying that hee meant shee might marrie another, after the former husbands death. As who say, the Pope inioyning the8 man and the whore for a punishment to stay and abyde without hope of mariage, were likly to meāe by liberty of marriyng graunted the guyltlesse for a benefite, that while the guilty lived, who might overlive her, shee should not marrye no more then hee. Or as though there had bene neede for the Pope then to graunt it with exception,9 If she will not conteine Let her marrie in the Lord. Whereby it seemeth that hee rather wished her to refrayne from marriage, if shee might be induced thereto, which hee had no cause to wish on this occasion after the mans death, she being v then simply free,
qExplicat articul. Lovan. art. 19.
rConcilior, Tō. 3. annotat mar. ad liunc locum,Cōcilior, Tō. 3. annotat mar. ad liūc locum,
6Istuc he die ecclesiae non servat.
sTom 1 cont 3 lib. 4 Cap 12. 3. q•. c. concubuisti.
7About the year of Christ 740About the yeare of Christ 740
8Sinespe con jugij permane atis.Sinespe cō jugij permane atis.
9Size continere non vult.Si se continere nō vult.
yet Sixtus Senensis confesseth that Pope Zechariah decreed that the women if she would not contain, should marry another husband while the former lived. It is true that Sixtus seeketh to help the matter another way somewhat, by yoking the Pope with provincial Councils: who (he saith) allowed & decreed it, not by a general and perpetual ordinance, but for a time, & to certain nations; & that in such heinous crimes as incest only, But will the Papists stand to this doctrine, that the Popes decrees bind not all nations generally, nor are perpetually to last? Then must they acknowledge (which would touch the Papacy & Popery very nearly) that the Popes supremacy is falsely pretended, he hath his certain limits as Metropolitans have: and some will reason also that the laws of Popes were to last for a time until Luther rose, but for a time only, there date is out now. As for the crime of incest, whereupon the Pope allowed the innocent party to put away her husband and to marry another: that confirmeth rather the point in Question then disproveth it. For he had no warrant to allow this by, but oura Saviours doctrine forbidding such divorcement, except it were for whoredom: so that he might not have granted it for incest, unless he had thought it lawful for adultery; ⟨p. 68⟩bNeither did he consider the crime but as comprised under adultery too: Whereof (in a general sense meant by the 6law) incest is a kind. And therefore in speaking of her with whom the detestable act was committed, he termed her1 the Adulteress not the incestuous person. Thus it is apparent, that in this matter Pope Zechariah was no papist. No more was the Council of c Worms which showed their judgment to the like effect to wit, that a man who could prove his wife to have been of counsel with such as sought his death, might put her away and marry another if he would. Presuming that belike, which they might justly, as2 examples teach us, that she was nought of her body with some of the conspiracy. For else had the Council expressly authorized the same thatd Christ condemn neth, if for any other cause then for adultery they had allowed the man to marry. Thereforee Covaruvias reckoneth3 up this Council among them who held that a man having lawfully put away his wife for her whoredom, might take another while she lived.
yet Sixtus Senensis confesseth that Pope Zachary decreed that the women if shee would not conteine, should marry another husband while the former lived. It is true that Sixtus seeketh to helpe the matter another way somwhat, by yoking the Pope with provinciall Councels: who (hee sayth) allowed & decreed it, not by a generall and perpetuall ordinance, but for a tyme, & to certaine nations; & that in such heynous crymes as incest onely, But will the Papists stand to this doctrine, that the Popes decrees bynde not al nations generally, nor are perpetually to last? Thē must they acknowledg (which would touch the Papacie & Popery verry neerely) that the Popes supremacie is falsly pretended, hee hath his certeyn limits as Metropolitanes have: and some will reason also that the lawes of Popes were to last for a tyme vntil Luther rose, but for a tyme onely, there date is out now. As for the cryme of incest, wherevpon the Pope allowed the innocent partie to put away her husband and to marrie another: that confirmeth rather the poynt in Question then disproveth it. For hee had no warrant to allow this by, but oura Saviours doctrine forbidding such divorcement, except it were for whoredom: so that he might not have graunted it for incest, vnlesse hee had thought it lawfull for adulterie; ⟨p. 68⟩bNeither did hee consider the cryme but as comprised vnder adulterie too: Whereof (in a generall sense meant by the 6law) incest is a kinde. And therefore in speaking of her with whom the detestable act was committed, hee tearmed her1 the Adulteresse not the incestious person. Thus it is apparant, that in this matter Pope Zacharie was no papist. No more was the Councel of c Wormes which shewed their iudgment to the like effect to weet, that a man who could prove his wife to have been of counsail with such as sought his death, might put her away and marry another if hee would. Presuming that belike, which they might iustely, as2 examples teach vs, that shee was nought of her body with some of the conspiracie. For els had the Councell expressely authorized the same thatd Christ condē neth, if for any other cause then for adulterie they had allowed the man to marrie. Thereforee
Yet a certain Spanish Friar named Raymund, one of Pope Gregory the ninths special State-men, the compiler of his Decretals, fwould avoid it also after Gratians manner, by false exposition as if the Council had meant, a man might take another wife after the death of the former. To the more effectual persuading whereof, that questionless they meant so: he useth a special trick of popish cunning. For, making show of registering the Councels own decr•e, in steed of those words4 He may put away his wife and marry another, if he will: the Friar setteth down these5 He may after his wives death marry another, if he will. And whereas the Council had said,6 as we think, which words had been absurdly put in, if they had meant after his wives death he might marry another, a thing agreed on and undoubted: The Friar (as thieves are wont to deface and suppress the marks of things which they have stolen, least they be taken thereby) leaveth that clear out. But by the mouth of two witnessesg Burchardus Bishop of worms, andh Gratian or7 Palea, both elder then the Friar, and from whom of likelihood he received this Canon of the Council of Worms his false and irreligious dealing is bewrayed. Whereto may the confession of the third be added, though in years younger, yet ⟨p. 69⟩greater in credit for things against Papists, himself a popish Doctor and burning light of Paris, i Joverius I mean: who saith of that Council, that it allowed the innocent party to marry again after divorcement, the other being yet alive. And the Council it self maketh further proof that they are not unjustly charged by Joveruis and Covariuvias with this judgement.
Yet a certaine Spanish Frier named Raymund, one of Pope Gregory the nynthes speciall State-men, the compiler of his Decretals, fwould avoyd it also after Gratians manner, by false exposition as if the Councell had meant, a man might take another wife after the death of the former. To the more effectuall perswading whereof, that questionlesse they meant so: hee vseth a speciall trick of popish cunning. For, making shewe of registering the Councels owne decr•e, in steed of those wordes4 Hee may put away his wife and marry another, if he will: the Frier setteth downe these5 Hee may after his wives death marrie annother, if hee will. And whereas the Councell had sayd,6 as we thinke, which wordes had bene absurdely put in, if they hadd meant after his wives death hee might marrie another, a thing agreed on and vndoubted: The Frier (as theeves are wont to deface and suppresse the markes of things which they have stolen, least they be taken thereby) leaveth that cleare out. But by the mouth of two witnessesg Burchardus Byshop of wormes, andh Gratian or7 Palea, both elder then the Frier, and from whom of likelyhod hee receaved this Canon of the Councell of Wormes his false and irreligious dealing is bewrwayed. Whereto may the confession of the third bee added, though in years yonger, yet ⟨p. 69⟩greater in credit for things agaynst Papists, himself a popish Doctor and burning light of Paris, i Ioverius I meane: who sayth of that Councell, that it allowed the innocent partye to marrie agayne after divorcemēt, the other being yet alive. And the Councell it self maketh farder proofe that they are not vniustely charged by Ioveruis and Covariuvias with this iudgemēt.
fcap. Si qua mu. ser extra de divortijs,
4Potest ipsā uxorem digit tere e., si vosuerit al••m ducare•Potest ipsā uxorem di•it tere e., si vosuerit al••m ducare•
5Potest ipse potest axoris li voluer•t alid ducere
6Ut vobis videtur.Vt vobis videtur.
gDere•or. lib 6. cap. 41.
h•i, ua mul•e• 3. q. 1.
7[…] it were a Cardinal or other author soe named: as they who wrote the notes on Gratian of Gregory the 13 edition al•ag out of sundry lawyers that it was praesoliū lect sacer ec•lessiast. class. sect • praemō it. de Can. Conc apud Vermer.〈…〉 it were a Cardinal or other author soe named: as they who wrote the notes on Gratian of Gregorie the 13 editiō al•ag out of sūdry lawiers that it was praesoliū lect sacer ec•lessiast. class. sect • praemō it. de Can. Conc apud Vermer.
For if any man had committed wickedness with his daughter in law, the daughter of his wife by her former husband:k they agreed that he should keep neither of them: but his wife might marry another if she would, if she could not contain and if she had not carnal company with him, after that she knew of his adultery with her daughter. The last clause whereof showeth that they meant of liberty granted her to take another husband while the former lived: sith it cannot be thought with reason, but they judged she might take another the former b•ing d•ad: though she had continued with him as his wife, after she knew of his adultery. Thel Council of Tribur did maintain the same: ordaining that if any committed villainy with his mother in law, her husband may take another wife if he will, if he cannot contain: and the like order is to be observed, if with his daughter in law or his wives sister. Bellarmin like them painter, who being good at portraying of a Cypress tree, when one gave him money to draw and represent a shipwreck in a table asked if he would have a Cypress in, despairing to do ought worth perhaps, unless that helped: saith that all such Canons (all not only this of the Triburian Council) are understood of marriage granted to the innocent party after the death of the former wife or husband. An answer no fitter for this and all such Canons, then a Cypress tree is for a shipwreck, as those of Pope Zechariah & the Council of worms the former whereof he garnisheth also with this Cypress tree, do argue. For the same reasons which proved Zacharies Can on to be meant of the woman's marriage while the man lived, prove the Council of Triburs to be likewise meant of of the mans in the woman's life-time. The punishment inflicted therein 8on the offenders do equally enlarge the benefit to the Innocent. The9 exception added to the enlargement, is stronger: implying they would have him stay unmarried rather, if he can contain. The testimony of n Sixtus is all one for both: neither ⟨p. 70⟩doth the quality of the crime of incest more infringe the argument here then it did there. And this extenuation that the Council being a provincial Council ordained it for men of their own province, and for that time only, increaseth the authority thereof, if the precious be severed from the vile, the truth from the falsehood.
For if any man had committed wickednesse with his daughter in lawe, the daughter of his wife by her former husband:k they agreed that hee should keepe neither of thē: but his wife might marrie another if shee would, if shee could not conteyne and if shee had not carnall company with him, after that she knew of his adulterie with her daughter. The last clause whereof sheweth that they ment of liberty graunted her to take another husband while the former lived: sith it cannot be thought with reason, but they iudged shee might take another the former b•ing d•ad: though shee had continnued with him as his wife, after shee knew of his adulterie. Thel Councell of Tribur did maynteyne the same: ordeyning that if any committed vilany with his mother in law, her husband may take another wife if hee will, if hee cannot conteine: and the like order is to bee observed, if with his daughter in law or his wives sister. Bellarmin like them paynter, who being good at purtraing of a Cypresse tree, when one gave him money to draw and represent a shipwrack in a table asked if hee would have a Cypresse in, dispairing to doe ought worth perhaps, vnlesse that helped: saith that all such Canons (all not onely this of the Triburian Councell) are vnderstood of marriage graunted to the innocent party after the death of the former wife or husband. An answer no fitter for this and all such Canons, then a Cypresse tree is for a shipwrack, as those of Pope Zachary & the Councell of wormes the former whereof hee garnisheth also with this Cypresse tree, doe argue. For the same reasons which proved Zacharies Can on to bee meant of the womans marriage while the man lived, prove the Councel of Triburs to bee likewise meant of of the mans in the womans life-tyme. The punishment inflicted therein 8on the offēders doe equally enlarge the benifit to the Innocent. The9 exception added to the enlargemēt, is stronger: implying they would have him staye vnmarried rather, if he can conteyne. The testimonye of n Sixtus is all one for both: neither ⟨p. 70⟩doth the quallity of the cryme of incest more infringe the argument heere then it did there. And this extenuation that the Councell beeng a provinciall Councell ordeined it for men of their owne province, and for that tyme onely, encreaseth the authority thereof, if the precious bee severed from the vile, the truth from the falshood.
kcap 10. Butchard. lib. 17. cap. 10.
l32. p. 7. c. fi Quis cum No verca.
mHorat de arte Poet.
8Neuter ad conjugiū potest pervenireNeuter ad cōjugiū potest pervenire
9si se continere non potestsi se cōtinere non potest
For why affirmeth he that they did ordain it for that time only? The form of their decree touching 1all generally that should offend so, not some particular person, who presently had; they speaking of the thing as2 lawful in it self, and3 to be observed alike in like cases; their making ofo other Canons to that effect: yeap another Council also peradventure, & no limitation of time in any of them; do persuade the contrary. Now, whereas they ordained it for men of their own province, their modesty was the greater: who did not take upon them as Popes to make laws for men of all nations, but looked as Bishops to their own dioceses. And the greater modesty, the liker toq Christ, and the better to be liked ofr Christians, the more reverence to bes heard with, and their judgment had in greater estimation. Beside that, this self-same decree of theirs was established also byt the Council of Worms.
For why affirmeth hee that they did ordeyn it for that tyme onely? The forme of their decree touching 1all generally that should offend so, not some particular person, who presently had; they speaking of the thinge as2 lawfull in it self, and3 to bee observed alike in like cases; their makinge ofo other Canons to that effect: yeap another Councel also peradventure, & no limitatiō of tyme in any of them; doe persuade the contrarie. Now, whereas they ordeyned it for men of their owne province, their modesty was the greater: who did not take vpon them as Popes to make lawes for men of all nations, but looked as Byshops to their owne diosaes. And the greater modesty, the liker toq Christ, and the better to be liked ofr Christians, the more reverence to bes heard with, and their iudgmēt had in greater estimation. Beside that, this self-same decree of theirs was establyshed also byt the Councell of Wormes.
1Si quis dormie• it
2Potest for id •ossumus qu•d •ureposssu•us
3Sim literob se•andū est.Sim literob se•andū est.
Andu at that time Pipinus (King of France, and of a great part of Germany) was present. Who as he did keep a general assembly of his people4 there: so by all likelihood called Bishops thither out of his whole realm, to make decrees for the whole. A province of such largeness, thatx Councils consisting of Bishops assembled, out of no greater, have been termed General: and worthily (asy Bellarmin confesseth) in comparison of Provincial Councils commonly so called, wherein there were not Bishops of a whole Nation or Realm. Thus Sixtus by striving to lessen & diminish the credit of the canon of the council of Tribur, hath given us occasion to make the more of it: considering on the one side the modesty of the Bishops who were assembled there, and made decrees for their province; on the other the Province which that decree was made for, so large that all the Provinces of Italy cannot match it, though they were linked in one. Had it not been better for him, with out this Rhetoric to say directly and flatly asz Joverius doth, that the Council of Tribur made the like decree to the Council ⟨p. 71⟩of worms, which now the Church (he meaneth the Popish Church) receiveth not? whether any Papist will take exception against the Council of Mascon,a which allowed likewise a certain man, whose wife had been deflowered by his brother before he wedded her to put her away and marry another it may be we shall know hereafter. But unto a Council that made another such decree, asb Gratian showeth alleging it without name, Bellarmin taketh two exceptions: one, that it is lost; the other of the Cypress tree. Touching the former, not as much as the name thereof (saith he) is extant: therefore it might be easily contemned & set at nought. Why? Is it therefore worse then all that have names, because it is nameless? Then havec many Cardinals with other learned reverent men been much to blame, for writing so of Rome as if it had a number of wicked lewd profane in-habitants. For by there report the Romans having every one a name or two, should be worse for the most part, then were the Atlantes, a people of Africa, whomd Diodorus Siculus commendeth very highly for Godliness and Humanity, yet non of them had any name,e Herodotus saith. Or if this be a fable, asf Pliny seemeth rather to think, and well it may be;
Andu at that tyme Pipinus (King of Fraunce, and of a great parte of Germany) was present. Who as hee did keep a generall assembly of his people4 there: so by all likelyhoode called Byshops thither out of his whole realme, to make decrees for the whole. A province of such largenesse, thatx Councells cō sisting of Byshops assembled, out of no greater, have bene tearmed Generall: and woorthely (asy Bellarmin confesseth) in comparison of Provinciall Councells commonly so called, wherin there were not Byshops of a whole Nation or Realme. Thus Sixtus by striving to lessen & diminish the credit of the canō of the coūcel of Tribur, hath givē vs occasiō to make the more of it: cōsidering on the one side the modestie of the Byshops who were assembled there, and made decrees for their province; on the other the Province which that decree was made for, so large that all the Provinces of Italie cannot match it, though they were lincked in one. Had it not bene better for him, with out this Retorique to say directly and flattly asz Ioverius doth, that the Councell of Tribur made the like decre to the Councell ⟨p. 71⟩of wormes, which now the Church (hee meaneth the Popish Church) receyveth not? whether any Papist wil take excptiō agaynst the Councell of Mascon,a which allowed likewise a certain man, whose wife had bene defloured by his brother beefore hee wedded her to put her away and marry another it may bee wee shall know hereafter. But vnto a Councell that made another such decree, asb Gratian sheweth alleaging it without name, Bellarmin taketh two exceptions: one, that it is lost; the other of the Cypresse tree. Touching the former, not as much as the name thereof (sayth hee) is extant: therefore it might be easily contemned & sett at nought. Why? Is it therefore worse then all that have names, because it is namelesse? Then havec manye Cardinals with other learned reverent men bene much to blame, for writing so of Rome as if it had a number of wicked lewd prophane in-habitants. For by there report the Romans having everye one a name or two, should bee worse for the most parte, then were the Atlantes, a people of Africke, whom
u•9. 42. c. Si quis in genuus
4In wormatia civita•e Almein de gestis Francor. lib. 4. cap 66.
xConcil Carthag 4. et Milevet in […] conc. African. Epist. ad Celestin Conc Tolet 3. cap. 18Concil Carthag 4. et Milevet in 〈…〉 conc. African. Epist. ad Celestin Cōc Tolet 3. cap. 18
yet is it most certain that • Plutarch recordeth as grave and wise sayings of Lacedaemonians without names, as of any whose names are known. And Bellarmin (I trust) will grant that in the scriptures there is no less account to be made of the book of Joshua, then of Nehemiah, of Job, than of the Proverbs: though their names who wrote the one be not set down, as theirs who wrote the other. But he will say perhaps that of this Council not only the name is unknown, but also the work it self lost. And what if it be? were noth those of Varro's works, which we have not, as learned as the work5 of Floccus which we have? Of Tully, of Polybius, of Livy, Dio, Tacitus, of infinite writers more, are there not as good books lost, as there are extant.i The same hath fallen out in Ecclesiastical authors specially in Councils: whereof a great many are not to be found: as they who by occasion of Canons cited thence in the Decrees and Decretals, have diligently searched through the chiefest libraries of Europe, do note. And a certain famous and ancient Council of Ments ⟨p. 72⟩being commended and praised above the other, byk Tretenius and Surius, 5who wisheth he might have gotten it to be published, showeth that some extant, are not to be compared with some that are lost, wherefore Bellarmins former exception to the Council that it is not extant, no nor the name of it, was not worth the naming. The latter that the Councels Canon was meant of Marriage after the former wives death: is like to prove as false as the proof thereof is frivolous and fond. For mthese are the words of the Canon: A certain woman lay with her husbands brother: it is decreed the adulterers shall never be Married: but lawful Marriage shall be granted unto him, whose wife the villainy was wrought with. Which words are well expounded (saith Bellarmin) by the Doctors, and their meaning gathered nout of the like Canon following a little after: wherein it is ordained, that When the adulterous wife is deceased, her man may marry whom he will; but her self the adulteress may not marry at all, no not her husband being dead. Gratian in deed, and the Gloss-writers on him (the Doctores meant by Bellarmin) doth them wrong in saying they expound it rightly.
yet is it most certayne that • Plutarch recordeth as grave and wise sayings of Lacedemonyans without names, as of any whose names are known. And Bellarmin (I trust) will graunt that in the scriptures there is no lesse account to be made of the booke of Ioshua, then of Nehemias, of Iob, thē of the Proverbs: though their names who wrote the one bee not sett downe, as theirs who wrote the other. But hee will say perhaps that of this Councell not onely the name is vnknowen, but also the worke it selfe lost. And what if it be? were noth those of Varroes workes, which wee have not, as learned as the worke5 of Floccus which wee have? Of Tullie, of Polybius, of Livie, Dio, Tacitus, of infinite writers more, are there not as good bookes lost, as there are extant.i The same hath fallen out in Eclesiasticall authors specially in Councels: whereof a great many are not to be found: as they who by occasion of Canons cited thence in the Decrees and Decretals, have dilligently searched through the chiefest liberaaies of Europe, doe note. And a certaine famous and aunciēt Councel of Ments ⟨p. 72⟩beeing commended and praised above the other, byk Tretenius and Surius, 5who wisheth hee might have gotten it to be publyshed, sheweth that some extant, are not to bee compared with some that are lost, wherefore Bellarmins former exception to the Councell that it is not extant, no nor the name of it, was not worth the nameing. The latter that the Councels Canon was meant of Marriage after the former wives death: is lyke to prove as false as the profe thereof is frivolous and fond. For mthese are the words of the Canon: A certaine woman laye with her husbands brother: it is decreed the adulterers shall never bee Married: but lawfull Marriage shalbe graunted vnto him, whose wife the vilenie was wrought with. Which words are well expounded (saith Bellarmin) by the Doctors, and their meaning gathered nout of the like Canon following a litle after: wherein it is ordeined, that When the adulterous wife is deceassed, her man may marrie whom hee will; but her selfe the adulteresse may not marrie at all, no not her husband being dead. Gratian in deed, and the Glosse-writers on him (the Doctores meant by Bellarmin) doth them wrong in saying they expound it rightly.
hde civit, Del lib 9, cap 2
5Dominicus Floceus Floren tinus ser forth under the nam of L […] & sacerd tis RomainisDominicus Floceus Floren tinus ser forth vnder the nam of L 〈…〉 & sacerd tis Romainis
iThe writers of the Notes on Gregories ed•tion-xtra de & qui c•gn consangu uxoris suae, •si quis verbo Metiam.
kchro monast. hirsan•g.chro mōast. hirsan•g.
5• concilior. rom 3 post syuod. Mogunt sub Rubano.• cōcilior. rom 3 post syuod. Mogūt sub Rubano.
For this Canon following, out of which they gather that to be the meaning, being a Canon of I know not what Gregory, at least Fathered on him, doth no more prove it theno the above alleged Canon of Gregory the third permitting marriage to the innocent party while the other lived, doth infer the contrary. And the Councells words mentioning expressly the Innocent parties freedom and liberty to marry, which had been superfluous if they meant of marriage after the others death: make it most probable that the Council uttered them with the same meaning, wherewith others uttered the like, as hath been showed. Hereunto the judgement ofp Sixtus Senensis doth add no small weight, sith he albeit striving to weaken the strength and cut the sinews of it, acknowledgeth notwithstanding that it was of one mind with the council of Tribur.3 So was Pope Alexander the third too some time, though Bellarmin allegeq him as of another mind. But let Bellarmin say whether he had two minds and erred in on of them: seeing it is certain he was of this mind once, unless he wrote against his mind. For where as a man that had wedded a wife, did, before he entered the ⟨p. 73⟩marriage-bed with her, enter her mothers bed: Pope Alexander said, that he doing some penance might be dispensed with to marry another wife. Here the Popes favour towards the offender; doth favour of that whichs hath been misliked in Papal dispensations. But he that granted thus much to the incestuous husband, would (I trust) have granted it to the guiltless wife: ast he did also to her that had this injury. The only evasion whereto a Bellarminian might by his Masters example have recourse, is that the Canonists expound the Popes words not of a wife but of a spouse, & her espoused also by words of the time to come, not of the time present.
For this Canō following, out of which they gather that to bee the meaning, being a Canon of I know not what Gregory, at least Fathered on him, doth noe more prove it theno the above alleaged Canon of Gregory the third permitting marriage to the innocent partye while the other lived, doth inferre the cōtrarie. And the Councells words mentioning expressely the Innocēt parties freedom and liberty to marry, which had bene superfluous if they meant of marriage after the others death: make it most probable that the Councell vttered them with the same meaning, wherewith others vttered the like, as hath bene shewed. Herevnto the iudgement ofp Sixtus Senensis doth add no small weight, sith he albeit striving to weaken the strength and cutt the sinewes of it, acknowledgeth notwithstanding that it was of one minde with the councell of Tribur.3 So was Pope Alexander the third too some tyme, though Bellarmin alleageq him as of another mynde. But let Bellarmin say whether hee had two myndes and erred in on of them: seing it is certaine hee was of this minde once, vnlesse hee wrote against his minde. For where as a man that had wedded a wife, did, before hee entred the ⟨p. 73⟩marriage-bed with her, enter her mothers bed: Pope Alexander sayde, that hee doing some pennance might bee dispensed with to marrie another wife. Here the Popes favour towards the offender; doth favour of that whichs hath bene missliked in Papall dispensations. But he that graunted thus much to the incestuous husband, would (I trust) have graunted it to the guiltlesse wife: ast hee did also to her that had this iniurie. The onely evasion whereto a Bellarminian might by his Maisters example have recourse, is that the Canonists expoūd the Popes words not of a wife but of a spouse, & her espoused also by wordes of the tyme to come, not of the tyme present.
oquod prop• suisti, ead. q
pBibl, Sanct lib, • an not•• under the nane of Synodus • libe•ima the author t•es thought of this CanonBibl, Sanct lib, • an not•• vnder the nāe of Synodus • libe•ima the authour t•es thought of this Canon
3• e Veniens. 1. de eo qui cog consang. ••xoris suae• e Veniens. 1. de eo qui cog cōsang. ••xoris suae
qEx parte extra de spons et matrim.Ex parte extra de spōs et matrim.
sFran• Victoria relect 4 omne• qui petunt afferunt dispensations. In petunt Lee compriseth pendunt, City in ver lib. • et. •.Fran• Victoria relect 4 omne• qui petunt afferunt dispēsationes. In petunt Lee cōpriseth pendunt, Cie in ver lib. • et. •.
tEpist Alexand. […]. ad pict. episc Append Conc, Lateran.Epist Alexand. 〈…〉. ad pict. episc Append Conc, Lateran.
Which exposition may seem the more probable, because the Popes words set down in the Decretals give her the name of spouse without signification that the man had wedded her. But hereof Friar Raymund who compiled & clipped the Decretals must bear the blame, asv Antonius Contius a learned Lawyer of their own hath well observed. For the Popes Epistle which is extant whole in thex Tomes of Councils, declareth that the woman was the mans wedded wife, though he did forbear her company a while. No remedy there-fore but it must be granted, that in this matter Pope Alexander the third subscribed to the former Councils. Now by all the rest whom I alleged there is none excepted against by any Papist, for ought that I know, or as I think will be. Fory Lactantius first avoucheth, so the lawfulness of putting away • mans wife for adultery even with intent to marry another that both zCovaruvias anda Dominicus Soto grant him to be clear from it. Nextb touching the authors mentioned by Gratian as holding the same for one kind of adultery: who doubted but there were certain so persuaded, when such an adversary confesseth it. Then for Pope Celestin the third, sithc a Pope saith he thought that a man or wife might lawfully forsake their partners in wedlock for heresy, and marry others: I see not how the Papist may deny he thought it lawful for adultery, more then I showed they might of Gregory the third. And albeitd Zechariah bishop of Chrysopolis, may seem to show rather what other mens opinion was, then what his own, yet it is apparent by his manner of handling that he joined with ⟨p. 74⟩eAmbrose therein, whose words he citeth, and fenceth them against authorities, that might be opposed. As for the Bishop of Burgos, Paul commended highly byf learned men for learning,g he saith that it is manifest by Christs doctrine, that whosoever putteth away his wife for whoredom, commiteth not adultery though he marry another.h Naclantus, who was present at the Council of Trent, a Bishop of principal name and price among them, affirmeth as directly, that a wife being loosed from her husband by death or by divorcement, is not an adulteress if she marry another.
Which exposition may seeme the more probable, because the Popes wordes sett downe in the Decretalls geve her the name of spouse without signification that the man had wedded her. But hereof Frier Raymund who compiled & clipped the Decretalls must beare the blame, asv Antonius Contius a learned Lawier of their owne hath well observed. For the Popes Epistle which is extant whole in thex Tomes of Councels, declareth that the woman was the mans wedded wife, though he did forbeare her companie a while. No remedīe there-fore but it must be graunted, that in this matter Pope Alexander the third subscribed to the former Councels. Now by all the rest whom I aleaged there is none excepted against by anye Papist, for ought that I know, or as I thinke will bee. Fory Lactantius first avoucheth, so the lawfulnes of putting away • mās wife for adulterie even with intent to marry another that both zCovaruvias anda Dominicus Soto graunt him to be cleare from it. Nextb touching the authours mentioned by Gratian as holding the same for one kinde of adulterie: who doubted but there were certaine so persuaded, when such an adversarie confesseth it. Then for Pope Celestin the thirde, sithc a Pope saith hee thought that a man or wife might lawfully forsake their parteners in wedlocke for haerisie, and marry others: I see not how the Papist may denye hee thought it lawful for adulterie, more then I shewed they might of Gregory the third. And albeitd Zacharie byshop of Chrysopolis, may seeme to shew rather what other mens opinion was, then what his owne, yet it is apparant by his manner of handeling that hee ioyned with ⟨p. 74⟩eAmbrose therein, whose words hee citeth, and fenseth them against authorities, that might bee opposed. As for the Byshop of Burgos, Paul commended heighly by
vAnnot•t. de varijs decretal. Epist. compilat e••in praesat Gregorij noni.Annot•t. de varijs decretal. Epist. cōpilat e••in praesat Gregorij noni.
xAppend Conc Later sub Alexand. tert. part 12. cap. 4.Appēd Cōc Later sub Alexand. tert. part 12. cap. 4.
fAust Steuc. recogn vet. Test ad ver Hebr. in Gen 37 Sixth sevens bibl. Sanct. lib. 4.Aust Steuc. recogn vet. Test ad ver Hebr. in Gen 37 Sixt seuēs bibl. Sanct. lib. 4.
To conclude Bellarmin confesseth that Erasmus, Caietan, Catharinus, Luther, Melancton, Bucer Calvin, Brentius, Kemnitius, Peter Martyr, and in a word all Lutherans and Calvinists, (as it pleaseth this Roman Tertullus to name us poori Nazarenes) agree that our Saviour doth allow marriage after divorcement for adultery, Howbeit fearing much what a deadly wound he might give his cause by granting that Erasmus, Caietan, Catharinus three so learned men, and two of them such pillars of the Romish Church a Cardinal & an Arch bishop agree in this point with Lutherans & Calvinists: he addeth that those three differ much from these heretics (meaning By heretics the Nazarenes I spake of,7 whose ring-leader was Paul) in as much as they submit themselves expressly to the churches judgement. And because the church (saith he) hath now opened her mind most evidently, as appeareth by the Council of Trent the 24. session the 7 Canon, where all who think the band of marriage may be loosed for any cause are accursed: therefore it seemeth that those three also, & chiefly the two later, must be thought no otherwise minded in this matter, than 8all the rest of the Catho-Divines are & have been with great agreement & consent. which dispute of Bellar. if it have sufficient ground & strength of reason Erasmus must be counted a catholic in all things For9 in all his writings he submitteth himself to the churches judgement. Then why dothk Bell. call him a demie Christian,l & enrol his name among sectaries & heretics? what are the Fathers of the Council of Trent Demie-christians, sectaries, heretics; thy are (by Bellar. logic) of one mind with Erasmus. Moreover S. Austin the chiefest man of Bellar. side in this question must be counted ours by ⟨p. 75⟩the same logic. Form he taught expressly that himself; yea any bishop even S, Cyprian, yea provincial Counc. too, should yield to the authority of a general Coū. And the 6 general Coū. gram ted liberty of marriage after divorcement, as hath been declared: wherefore if Caietā must be thought no otherwise minded then Papists are, because that church whose judgment he did submit himself to, defined so at Trent2 a good while after his death: S. Austin must be thought no otherwise minded than we are, because our assertion was confirmed likewise by a General Council, whereto he would have yielded.
To conclude Bellarmin confesseth that Erasmus, Caietan, Catharinus, Luther, Melancton, Bucer Calvin, Brentius, Kemnitius, Peter Martyr, and in aworde all Lutherans and Calvinists, (as it pleaseth this Roman Tertullus to name vs poorei Nazarens) agree that our Saviour doth allow marriage after divorcement for adulterie, Howbeit fearing much what a deadly wounde hee might geve his cause by graunting that Erasmus, Caietan, Catharinus three so learned men, and two of thē such pillars of the Romish Church a Cardinall & an Arch byshop agree in this poynt with Lutherans & Caluinicts: he addeth that those three differ much frō these hertiques (meāing By heretiques the Nazarens I spake of,7 whose ring-leader was Paul) in as much as they submitt thēselves expressely to the churches iudgement. And because the church (saith he) hath now opened her minde most evidently, as appeareth by the Coūcel of Trēt the 24. sessiō the 7 Canō, where all who thinke the band of marriage maye be loosed for any cause are acursed: therefore it seemeth that those three also, & chiefly the two later, must be thought no otherwise minded in this matter, thē 8all the rest of the Catho-Divines are & have bene with great agreemēt & cōsent. which dispute of Bellar. if it have sufficiēt groūd & strength of reasō Erasmus must be coūted a catholique in al things For9 in al his writings he submitteth himself to the churches iudgemēt. Thē why dothk Bell. cal him a demie Christiā,l & enrol his nāe amōg sectaries & hertiques? what are the Fathers of the Coūcel of Trēt Demie-christiās, sectaries, heretiques; thy are (by Bellar. logique) of one minde with Erasmus. Moreover S. Austin the ciefeft mā of Bellar. side in this questiō must be coūted ours by ⟨p. 75⟩the same logique. Form he taught expressely that himself; yea any byshop evē S, Cipriā, yea provincial Coūc. too, should yeeld to the authority of a general Coū. And the 6 general Coū. graū ted liberty of mariage after divorcmēt, as hath bene declared: wherfore if Caietā must be thought no otherwise mynded then Papists are, because that church whose iudgmēt he did submitt himself to, defined so at Trēt
iAct• 24. 5.
7Te• ton Nazora•en […] protestatiaTe• ton Nazora•en 〈…〉 protestatia
8reliquorū omiū The o•og or catholicorū communissima sentēreliquorū omiū The o•og or catholicorū cōmunissima sentē
9Ubiqne test atū esse volumus nos nusquam a judicio ecclae catholicae velungué aut digit um latū velle descedere. Quod si quid usquam ejus modideprehendatur id jam nunc pro•ecantat volumus haberi, In capitū Argument, contt. moros•s quosdam et indoctos prefix nov Test. excus con Aunot. edict 4. et 5 Ibidē in 1. cor. 7. ad hunc ipsū locū semper inquit illabefacto. eccl catholicae uidicioVbiqne test atū esse volumus nos nusquam a iudicio ecclae catholicae velungué aut digit um latū velle descedere. Quod si quid usquam ejus modideprehēdatur id jam nūc pro•ecantat volumus haberi, In capitū Arg umēt, cōtt. moros•s quosdam et indoctos prefix nov Test. excus cū Aunot. edict 4. et 5 Ibidē in 1. cor. 7. ad hūc ipsū locū semper inquit illabefacto. eccl catholicae uidicio
kTō, •. cont, •, lib. l. c. •.Tō, •. cōt, •, lib. l. c. •.
Chiefly sith of likelihood he would have more easily yielded thereunto, than Caietan to his churches becausen Caietā showeth he was stiff in holding fast his own opinion,3 when for fear of Church-men he durst not say all that he thought; & in this very point, thougho submitting himself to the See of Rome as well as to the church,p he eludeth decrees ofq popes that make against him,r so resolute he was in it. Sr. Austin contrariwise used very modestly & willingly to retract things that he had written, even when she lighted on ought in an heretic that seemed better & truer, & this point he thoughtt so dark in the Scriptures, & hard to be discerned, that his opinion was not hard to be removed; if he had seen stronger reason brought against it, or greater authority. Now if S. Austin come over to our side by that quirk of Bellar. • a band of Bellar. witnesses is like to come with him: namely the council of Melevis & Afric,u which he was present at, & swayed much with: perhaps Primasius also (x were he Austins scholar) & Bede with a number of Canonists, and schoolmen, who followed most S. Austin. But Bellarmin will never resign all these unto us, to gain the other three from us. For (y as our Be-hive saith) Men live not by losses. He must suffer therefore Erasmus, & Caietan, & Catharinus specially, who (beside thez place that Bellar. hath quoted) doth avouch the matter in a treatise written purposely thereof, more throughly & exactly then Erasmus or Caietan; Bellarmin I say must suffer them to be counted of that mind which they were of, while themselves lived; not cavil as if they were of that which peradventure they would have been4 had they not died before the Council of Trent taught so. Unless he think (which he may by as good reason that whereas they were deceased above x. years ere the C. ⟨p. 76⟩Trent made that new canon, we ought to count them alive all that while, because they did submit them-selves to Physicians and would have lived perhaps till then, had art been able to cure diseases. How much more agreeably to singleness & truth doa Sixtus, bCovarruvias, andc Domenicus Soto acknowledge (the two former touching Catharinus the last for Erasmus, all concerning Caietan) that in this question of marriage again after divorcement for adultery, their doctrine is the same with those ancient Fathers whom our younger teachers of the reformed Churches follow.
Chiefly sith of liklyhood hee would have more easily yeelded therūto, thē Caietan to his churches becausen Caietā sheweth hee was stiffe in holding fast his owne opiniō,3 whē for feare of Church-mē he durst not say all that he thought; & in this very point, thougho submitt̄ig hīself to the See of Rome as wel as to the church,p he eludeth decrees ofq popes that make against him,r so resolute he was in it. Sr. Austin cōtrariwise vsed very modestly & willingly to retract things that he had writtē, evē whē she lighted on ought in an heretike that seemed better & truer, & this point he thoughtt so darke in the Scripturs, & hard to be discerned, that his opiniō was not hard to be removed; if he had seē strōger reason broght against it, or greater authority. Now if S. Anstin come over to our side by that quirck of Bellar. • a band of Bellar. wittnesses is like to come with him: namly the coūcel of Melevis & Affrique,u which he was presēt at, & swaied much with: perhaps Primasius also (x were he Austins scholar) & Bede with a nūber of Canōists, and schoolemē, who folowed most S. Austin. But Bellarmin will never resigne all these vnto vs, to gaine the other three frō vs. For (y as our Bee-hive saith) Men live not by losses. He must suffer therefore Erasmus, & Caietan, & Catharinus specially, who (beside thez place that Bellar. hath quoted) doth avouch the matter in a treatise written purposely thereof, more throughly & exactly then Erasmus or Caietan; Bellarmin I say must suffer them to be counted of that minde which they were of, while thēselves lived; not cavill as if they were of that which peradventure they would have bene
And thus if I should enter into the comparison of Divines on both sides: first, for the number it is more then likely, that we prevail much. For all whom Bellarmim and the Pamphleteer after him do muster out of the west, I mean whom they claim justly, not who either say against them asd Tertullian, or not with them ase Scotus, all therefore whom they muster so out of the West, aref Jerome the Coū cels ofg Milevis andh Africi Innocentius the firstk Austin, lPrimasius, mIsidore, nBede, the Council ofo Friouli andp Nantes,q Anselm, rPope Alexander the thirds Innocentius the third,t Thomas, Bonaventure. Durand; and other School-men,u Pope Eugenius with his Florentines &x the Council of Trent. which thoughy Gratian, Lombard and whomsoever he might bill, were added to them yet ours out of the west alone perhaps would match them. What if the North, the South, whence Bellarmin hath none? what if the East, whence he hath two or three at the most for hundreds of ours be joined thereunto? Then for Qualitya Came the word of God out from you? saith Paul to the Corinthians; or Came it to you only? Meaning that they ought to reverence the judgement of other Christian Churches being more then they were: but of those chiefly and first (as he placeth them) from whom the Gospel came first. Nowb the Gospel came first out of the East: whose con sent we have in a manner generally. and as we have the first in Country, so in time the ancientest & eldest: our two first Councils in5 Spain, and in France elder an hundred years then their two in Afric, our next far elder yet then their next; and so unto the last: yea, for several Fathers, ancient on both sides, there are more with us in the four or five or six for-foremost ⟨p. 77⟩ages then there are with them. Of soundness in doctrine, of learning, of virtue, of constancy, of consent, it is hard to speak by way of comparison whether excelleth other. Saving that forc gentleness and meekness. a special ornament of Bishops, weigh both parts together, and ours surpass our adversaries. Amongst whom the Council of Trent accurseth6 all such as say that that they do err in this point, into which outrage none of ours hath broken against the contrary minded. As for other graces of the holy Ghost, though Bellarmin have noted sundry spots and blemishes whereby some of ours are touched in credit, and their authority is impeached:
And thus if I should ēter into the comparison of Divines on both sides: first, for the number it is more then likely, that wee prevayle much. For all whom Bellarmim and the Pamphletter after him doe muster out of the west, I meane whō they claime iustly, not who either say against them asd Tertullian, or not with them ase Scotus, all therefore whom they muster so out of the West, aref Ierom the Coū cels ofg Milevis andh Afriquei Innocentius the firstk Austin, lPrimasius, mIsiodore, nBede, the Councel ofo Friouli andp Nantes,q Anselme, rPope Alexander the thirds Innocentius the third,t Thomas, Bonaventure. Durand; and other Schole-men,u Pope Eugenius with his Florentines &x the Councel of Trent. which thoughy
let him cast his eyes upon his own witness's without partiality, and he shall find that we have a Rowland for his Oliver. For where he telleth us that Ambrose did err in yielding greater freedom to men then to women; Luther and Bucer in granting second marriage after divorcement for moe causes then whoredom; Poped Gregory the same for sickness:e Cellestin the same for heresy: we tell him again thatf Clemens Alexandrinus• Athenagoras, Origen (if he be out of theirs) Jerome andg Bede, did likewise err in speaking against all second marriages, andh Clemens withi Origen in sundry weighty points of faith. Wherek he telleth us that Lactantius fell into a number of errors, as being more skilful in Tully then in the scriptures, we tell him again that some of the Schoolmen were, though not more skilful in Tully, then in the scriptures, yet as unskilful in the scriptures,l as in Tully; and there grand-masterm the Master of the sentences is charged by themselves with above a score of errors. Where he telleth us that Luther varieth from himself Melancton agreeth not with him, nor Kemnitius with either of them, because Luther allowed divorcement for moe causes afterward then at the first, and Melancton thinketh that both the divorced parties are free to marry, Kennitius that the Innocent only; we tell him again that neither doth Pope Innocentius the third agree with Pope Alexander, nor Alexander with himself nor neither of them with Athenagoras, seeing Athenagoras condemneth second marriage which then Popes allow, though• Alexander punished one who blessed it;o Innocentius checketh a decree of Alexander that deprived the Innocent party of his ⟨p. 78⟩right, because the offender had sinned thus, or thus: & Alexander, whether in this decree I know not (for it is razed out of thep Decretals) but in other extant overthwarteth himself, as his words alleged on both parties, for Bellarmin & for us, do testify. So Bellarmins objections of human infirmities and wants notwithstanding, they which are of our side excel in estimation those which are of his, for diverse circumstances and respects.
let him cast his eies vpon his owne witnesse's without partiallitie, and hee shall finde that wee have a Rowland for his Oliver. For where hee telleth vs that Ambrose did erre in yeelding greater freedō to men then to women; Luther and Bucer in graunting second marriage after divorcement for moe causes then whoredome; Poped Gregory the same for sicknes:e Cellestin the same for heresie: wee tell him againe thatf Clemens Alexandrinus• Athenagoras, Origen (if hee bee out of theirs) Ierom andg Bede, did likewise erre in speaking against all second marriages, andh Clemens withi Origen insundrie weightie poynts of fayth. Wherek hee telleth vs that Lactantius fell into a number of errours, as being more skilfull in Tullie then in the scriptures, wee tell him againe that some of the Scholemen were, though not more skilfull in Tullie, then in the scriptures, yet as vnskilfull in the scriptures,l as in Tullie; and there graund-maisterm the Maister of the sentences is charged by themselves with above a score of errours. Where hee telleth vs that Luther varieth from himselfe Melancton agreeth not with him, nor Kemnitius with either of them, because Luther alowed divorcement for moe causes afterward then at the first, and Melancton thinketh that both the divorced parties are free to marrie, Kēnitius that the Inoc̄et onely; wee tell him againe that neither doth Pope Innocentius the third agree with Pope Alexander, nor Alexander with himself nor neither of them with Athenagoras, seing Athenagoras cō demneth second marriage which then Popes allowe, though• Alexander punished one who blessed it;o Innocentius checketh a decree of Alexander that deprived the Innocent partie of his
dBel. tom. 1. cont. 3. lib. 4 Cap. 12.
eIbid, Ca. 14.
fIn the place above quotedIn the place abo ve quoted
And (the most important respect of all others) the ground whereuponq ours do build their doctrine, is the plain evidence & express testimony of our Saviourr Christ, excepting whoredom namely out of the causes for which he denieth a man may put away his wife & marry another. Contrariwise the ground that our adversaries build on is their own conceit, not able to stand without violent wresting, suppressing, or corrupting of Christs exception the proof whereof is seen in three the most peremptory men for this matter, and best accounted of among them, Innocentius the first, the third, & Thomas of Aquin. sThomas in that he answereth that Christs exception pertaineth to the putting away of the wife, & not to the marring of another, also Innocentius the first, in that he omitteth the exception quite,t & citeth Christs words thus: whoso putteth away his wife for whoredom, & marrieth another doth commit adultery vInnocentius the third, in that he depraveth & altereth the exception, affirming that Christ saith7 whosoever putteth away his wife for whoredom, & marrieth another, doth commit adultery: whosoever puttieth away his wife for whoredom. A notable corruption by scraping out of the sentence8 the exceptive particle having the force of a negative, to change for this point into an affirmative: & so easily to be corrupted by the text of the Scripture it self, that I doubted whether it were not the Printers or bookewriters error, until I perceived that all the printed copies, which I could get the sight of, did agree therein; even the new one too of Gregory the thirteenth conferred with all the written copies in the Popes library, beside many other, & corrected by them. But of such buildings such must be the groundworks, or equal unto such in force; An untruth will never cleave unto the truth by other kind of mortar. in probability therefore it is to be presumed that not only the greater part of the fathers but the better ⟨p. 79⟩also, and they whose grounds are surer do maintain our doctrine. So the weapon which Bellarmin draweth out of their sheath against us, doth bend back and turn the point against himself:
And (the most important respect of all others) the ground wherevponq ours doe buyld their doctrine, is the plaine evidence & expresse testimony of our Saviourr Christ, excepting whoredō namely out of the causes for which he denieth a man may put away his wife & marrie another. Contrariewise the ground that our adversaries buyld on is their owne cōceit, not able to stand without violent wresting, suppressing, or corrupting of Christs exception the proofe whereof is seene in three the most peremtorie men for this matter, and best accounted of among them, Innocentius the first, the third, & Thomas of Aquin. sThomas in that he answereth that Christs exception pertaineth to the putting away of the wife, & not to the marring of another, also Innocentius the first, in that he omitteth the exception quite,t & citeth Christs words thus: whoso putteth away his wife for whoredom, & marrith another doth commit adulterie vInnocentius the third, in that he depraveth & altereth the exception, affirming that Christ saith7 whosoever putteth away his wife for whordom, & marrieth another, doth commit adulterie: whosoever putieth awaye his wife for whoredom. A notable corruption by scraping out of the sentence8 the exceptive particle having the force of a negative, to change for this point into an affirmative: & so easily to be corrupted by the text of the Scripture it self, that I doubted whether it were not the Printers or bookewriters errour, vntyll I perceived that all the printed copies, which I could gett the sight of, did agree therein; even the newe one too of Gregorye the thirtenth conferred with all the written copies in the Popes liberarie, beside many other, & corrected by them. But of such buyldings such must be the groundworkes, or equall vnto such in force; An vntruth will never cleave vnto the truth by other kinde of morter. in probabillity therefore it is to bee presumed that not onely the greater parte of the fathers but the better ⟨p. 79⟩also, and they whose groundes are surer doe maintayne our doctrine. So the weapon which Bellarmin draweth out of their sheath against vs, doth bend backe and turne the poynt against himself:
qTertul chro mat. Hilar. pol lent conc. Ven et. &c.
and the wound it may give, it can not pierce so deep asx that which is sharper then a•y two edged sword, but the wound it may give, it giveth to his own cause, Howbeit if any shall conceive otherwise hereof for the number & quality of the witnesses, as some peradventure will & may by reason of broken conjectures, which the variety of circumstances yeel death, yet no man will (I trust) sure no man of modesty and sense can deny, but the main and principal point I had to show, namely that the Fathers consent not •ll in one for the Papists doctrine, is showed to their shame, whose face & conscience served them to avouch the contrary. Wherefore sith our adversaries do grant that the Fathers have not strength enough to prove a point in question unless they all consent about it: Bellar. with his Pā phletter must consequently grant, that their cursing Trent assertion in this point cannot be proved by Fathers And so the second staff which they have framed themselves to lean upon, is like to that broken staff of reed, 2Egypt, whereupon (saith the scripture) if a man lean, it will go into his hand & pierce it.
and the wound it may geve, it can not pearce so deepe asx that which is sharper then a•y two edged sworde, but the wound it may geve, it geveth to his owne cause, Howbeit if any shall conceive otherwise hereof for the number & quality of the witnesses, as some peradventure will & may by reason of broken coniectures, which the variety of circumstances yeel deth, yet no man will (I trust) sure no man of modestye and sense can denie, but the mayne and principall poynt I hadd to shewe, namely that the Fathers consent not •ll in one for the Papists doctrine, is shewed to their shāe, whose face & cōsciēce served thē to avouch the cōtrary. Wherfore sith our adversaries doe graūt that the Fathers have not strēgth enough to prove a point in questiō vnlesse they all cōsent about it: Bellar. with his Pā phletter must cōsequētly graūt, that their cursing Trēt assertiō in this point cannot be proved by Fathers And so the secōd staffe which they have framed thēselves to leane vpō, is like to that brokē staff of reed, 2Egipt, whervpō (saith the scripture) if a man leane, it wil goe into his hand & pearce it.
and those whose grounds are surer? Then all the probability, which Fathers can yeild will turne against the Papists: and that which our adversaries would prove by tradition, and the consent of all ages will rather be disproved thereby. But howsoever men be diversly, persuaded touching the number & quality of Fathers enclyning this or that way, by meanes of sundrie circumstances which may breed doubt both particularly, of certaine, and of the whole summe in generall:
such as did loose that band of matrimony, and saith concerning him that
any man being parted from his former wife doe marrie another he is an adulterer. But Bellarmin must graunt with all that Athenagoras affirmeth it vntruly: considering that hee speaketh of parting even by death too, as well as by divorcement, & tea•heth with the
vndoubtedly of putting away for that cause, for which it is not lawfull for a man to putt away his wife that hee may marrie another. And likewise for the wife, that he is an adulterer, who marrieth her being put away,
if shee be put away vnlawfully: considering that the marriage, which is not rightly broken off, continueth; and
⟨p. 49⟩
while the marriage doth continue, it is adulterie to marrie.
〈…〉 dimiss•m. Mane•e• mat•imoni quod non 〈…〉 d•ē pt▪ um est.
that Christ doth avouche the righteousnes of divorcement. Christ therefore avoucheth that for adulterie a man may put away his wife and marrie another by Tertullians iudgment. Which also may be probably thought concerning Origen:
the Councel of Eliberis, ordained that a womā which forsooke her husband because of his adulterie & would marrie another, should be forbidden to marrie, & if shee married, shee should not receave the communion till hee were dead whō shee forsooke, vnlesse necessitie of sicknes cōstrayned to geve it her. Wherein it is to be noted, first that the Councell saith not.
If anieman, so to comprehend & touche generallie all both men & women: but they speake peculiaritie of the woman alone, & so doe not forbid the mā to leave his adulterous wife & marrie another.
Espēceus asketh what could have bene said more greivously against them by the impure
Vives pronounceth, that hee did not onely detest second marriages, but also had small liking of the first, nor did much favor matrimonie;
Who cōdemned second marrig•s Epiphan. •aerel. 59 •ugust •e hae resib cap. 38.
sIn August de civit. dei lib. 16. cap 34. The divines of Lovan in in their edition of Austen, printed at Antwerp and Paris have lest this sentence out beyond the prescript of index expurgatorius.In August de civit. dei lib. 16. cap 34. The divines of Lovan in in their ed•tiō of Austen, printed at Antwerp and Paris have lest this sentence out beyond the prescript of index expurgatorius.
sermon that Bellarmin quoteth vpon Mathew? Forsooth, that by Moses lawe it was permitted, that whosoever hated his wife for any cause, might put her away, and marry another in her roome:
the later by omitting mention of whordō, in spesifying the causes, for which if a womā depart frō her husbād shee must remaine vnmarried. Whereto (if Bellarmin neede more light to see it by) we may adde a third place:
date it in a publique solemne session thereof; Because neither was it debated in the Councell whether marriage after divorcement for adulterie were lawfull or no;
Epiphanius saith (his words are read corruptly, but the sense th•reof is plaine of our side, as
Covarruvias graunteth, Epiphanius therefore saith that Seperatiō being made for whoredo, a mā may take a secōd wife, or a woman a second husband. And the same avoucheth
Theodoret in effect, affirming that Christ hath sett downe one cause: whereby the band of Marriage should be dissolved, and wholy rent a sunder, in that hee did except whordom.
other countris, for why should not I name these of our professiō & faith amōg the Fathers as well as Bellarmin nameth the Popish councell of Trēt on the cōtrarie side? But the Papists (will some mā peradventure say, doe not graunt that all, whom you have rehearsed, were of this opiniō. But the Papists (I aunswer) doe graunt that sundrie of them were? and such as they graunt not, the light of truth & reason will either make them graunt, or shame them for denying it. As
Sixtus Senensis, namely doth deny that Hilarie and Chromantius allowe a man to marrie
⟨p. 60⟩
another wife after divorcement: or teach that hee is loosed from the band of matrimonie, while his former wife though an adulteresse liveth. Now weigh their owne wordes, & it will appeare that Sixtus iniurieth them therein. For
for any cause save for whor•dom, presume to marrie others, doe against the will of God, and are condemned. Wherein, with what sense could hee except whoredom, vnlesse he thought them guiltlesse, who having put away their wives for it doe marrie others? And
of ceasing from matrimony, but that; she weth that the band of matrimony is loosed thereby in his iudgmēt. Chiefly sith he knew that they might cease from the vse thereof, for other causes: & the occasion and tenour of the speech doe argue that he meant of such a seperation as yeeldeth libertie of newe marriage. In like sorte, or rather more plainely and expressely did Pollentius holde and maintaine the same: As Austin (whom in this point hee dissented from) doth reporte and testifie.
lTyndale. on mat 5 Bucer. de regno Christ lib 2. ca 43. P Martyr in 1. cor. 7 Bea•on et?Tindal. on mat 5 Bucer. de regno Christ lib 2. ca 43. P Martyr in 1. cor. 7 Bea•on et?
mIn the confession of their faith pref.
nLuther inarrat. in mat. 5 et cor 7 conf Saxon in Harmon conf. sect. 18. art de conj. conf. wirtemb ibid hist. Magdeburg. cent. • li. 1 ca. •, Kennic exam, conc Trident part▪Luther inarrat. in mat. 5 et cor 7 conf Saxon in Harmō conf. sect. 18. art de conj. conf. wirtēb ibid hist. Mag deburg. cent. • li. 1 ca. •, Kēnic exam, conc Trident part▪
ocalvin Instit. Christianli▪ 4, ca. 19, ult. eccl. gall, in Harmou conf.calvin Instit. Christiāli▪ 4, ca. 19, ult. eccl. gall, in Harmou conf.
pEccl. Belg. in Harm. conf. Muscul in mat. 5. Bullin, decad. 2. serm, 10. Saeged in lacorcom de divor […]Eccl. Belg. in Harm. cōf. Muscul in mat. 5. Bullin, decad. 2. serm, 10. Saeged in lacorcom de divor 〈…〉
it is thought so. But if it be sufficient to affirme barely, without anie ground of proofe or probabilitie, that it is said or thought so: what errour so absurd that may not be defended by perverse wranglers? what cause so vniust, that vnrighteous iudges may not geve sentence with?
the age following made this canon. Wee appoint and ordeine, that they who having l•ft their wives, except for whoredom (as it is said in the Gospel) or vpon proofe made of adulterie, marrie others, shalbe excommunicated; Least
Pope Innocentius the third and their disciples, the whole schoole of Cannonists have on those authorityes of the seaventh Councell made like reckoning of it.
Gratian himself vnderstood it otherwise; of sicknsse befalling to her, who was an able wife. And those his glosse writers vse most that exposition which Bellarmin would have vs recieve for authentick as the fittest salve; yet rest
Antonius a great Canonist: Archbyshop of Florēce correctingp Gratians slipp of memorie for the persons, concludeth with him for the matter.
•
Hist, part 2, tit. • Ca•. 1, quamvis. where he nameth Englshmē in sted of Germanes, & Gregorye the 1. insteed of Gregorie the 3 or 2, as Antonins tooke it.
hee sayth that it is manifest by Christs doctrine, that whosoever putteth away his wife for whoredom, commiteth not adulterye though hee marry another.
Naclantus, who was present at the Councel of Trent, a Byshop of principall name and price among them, affirmeth as directly, that a wife being losed from her husband by death or by divorcement, is not an adulteresse if shee marrie another.
a good while after his death: S. Astin must be thought no otherwise minded thē we are, because our assertiō was cōfirmed likewise by a General Coūcell, whereto hee would have yeelded.
ex semichristiā. l. Tō. 2. Jud. sectar. & haeret.ex semichristiā. l. Tō. 2. Iud. sectar. & haeret.
2In the year 1563. caj•tan being dead a 30 years before Sixtus se•enst• bib sact. lib. 4.In the yeare 1563. caj•tan being dead a 30 years before Sixtus se•ēst• bib sact. lib. 4.
had they not died before the Councell of Trēt taught so. Vnlesse he thinke (which he may by as good reasō that whereas they were deceased above x. yeares yer the C.
⟨p. 76⟩
Trent made that new canon, wee ought to count them alive all that while, because they did submitt them-selves to Physitiās and would have lived perhaps till then, had arte bene able to cure disseases. How much more agreablye to singelnes & truth doe
Domenicus Soto acknowledge (the two former touching Catharinus the last for Erasmus, all concerning Caietan) that in this question of marriage agayne after divorcement for adulterie, their doctrine is the same with those auncient Fathers whom our yonger teachers of the reformed Churches follow.
zAnnot in eo meant cajctan. lib. 5.Annot in eo mēt cajctan. lib. 5.
4catharinus, died in the year 552. Sixtus. senens. lib. 4. Erasm. in the year. 1•36, •lend. l. ••.catharinus, died in the yeare 552. Sixtus. senēs. lib. 4. Erasm. in the yeare. 1•36, •lēd. l. ••.
Gratian, Lombard and whomsoever he might bill, were added to them yet ours out of the west alone pehaps would match them. What if the North, the South, whence Bellarmin hath none? what if the East, whence hee hath two or three at the most for hunderds of ours bee ioyned therevnto? Then for Qualitie
Came the worde of God out from you? saith Paule to the Corinthians; or Came it to you onely? Meaning that they ought to reverence the iudgemēt of other Christian Churches being more then they were: but of those chiefly and first (as hee placeth them) from whō the Gospell came first. Now
the Gospell came first out of the East: whose cō sent wee have in a manner generally. and as wee have the first in Countrie, so in tyme the auncientest & eldest: our two firste Councels in
Spayne, and in Fraunce elder an hundred yeares then their two in Africque, our next farre elder yet then their next; and so vnto the last: yea, for several Fathers, aunciēt on both sides, ther are more with vs in the foure or five or sixe for-formost
⟨p. 77⟩
ages then there are with them. Of soundnes in docttrine, of learning, of vertue, of constancie, of consent, it is hard to speake by way of comparison whether excelleth other. Saving that for
gentelnes and meekenes. a speciall ornamēt of Byshops, weigh both partes together, and ours surpasse our adversaries. Amongst whom the Councell of Trent accurseth
all such as say that that they doe erre in this poynt, into which outrage none of ours hath broken against the contrarie minded. As for other graces of the holy Ghost, though Bellarmin have noted sundrie spotts and blemishes wherby some of ours are touched in credit, and their authority is impeached:
Decretals) but in other extant overthwarteth himself, as his words aleaged on both parties, for Bellarmin & for vs, doe testefie. So Bellarmins obiections of humaine infirmities and wants notwithstanding, they which are of our side excel in estimation those which are of his, for diverse circumstaunces and respects.