pp. 31–338 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Verily I am not ignorant how there fly abroad many Epistles of these holy Roman Bishops & Martyrs which they call decretals. But they overthrow themselves with their own absurdities, and show themselves to be but counterfeits, inasmuch as many things be so light, so trifling, and so utterly unlike that ancient simplicity, pureness, and majesty, that not with out good cause they seem unto godly and learned men, to have ben devised long since by others. Neither do I greatly regard that the same are fathered upon the gathering of Damasus and Isidorus: seeing that there want not some men which put over certain of these kind of things even to the time of Gregory the 7. But howsoever the case stand for the time. I pray yon what can be more fond, then the fathering of these words upon Anacletus? This holy holy and Apostolic Church of Rome obtained the supremacy ⟨image 37⟩and preeminence of power over all Churches, not from the Apostles, but from the very Lord himself our Saviour. And again, There was a difference even between the blessed Apostles: and albeit that all of them were Apostles: yet did the Lord grant and the Apostles determined among them selves, that Peter should have preeminence afore all the rest of the Apostles, and be Cephas, that is to say a head, and hold the sovereignty of Apostleship. Thus saith he. But who knoweth not (though he be but meanly seen in histories,) that after full five hundred years, it was obtained and ordained, not by Christ, or his Apostles but by loitering losels or rather by traitorous persons, that Rome should be called the head of all Churches, that is to wit, that it should obtain supremacy & prerogative of power over all Churches? Or who would believe that Anacletus exercised himself so little in reading of the Gospel, that he knew not how Cephas signifieth, not a head but a stone or a Rock? according as it is interpreted by John the Apostle in the first chapter? And which interpreter should a man rather believe? John the Apostle, or the counterfeit Anaclete? The lewd packing then of the lewd losels is detected both in these and in many other things. The same party maketh very often mention of Archbishops and metropolitans, neither omitteth he primates. But it is most manifest, that those titles were utterly unknown to the primitive Church, and were afterward invented and usurped in times following.
VErely I am not ignorant how there fly abroad many Epistles of these holy Romane Bishops & Martyrs which they call decretals. But they ouerthrow themselues with their owne absurdities, and shew themselues to be but counterfettes, in asmuch as many thinges be so light, so triflyng, and so vtterly vnlike that auncient simplicitie, purenesse, and maiestie, that not with out good cause they séeme vnto godly and learned men, to haue ben deuised long since by others. Neither do I greatly regard that the same are fathered vpon the gatheryng of Damasus and Isidorus: seyng that there want not some men which put ouer certeine of these kynd of thinges euen to the time of Gregorie the 7. But howsoeuer the case stād for the tyme. I pray yon what can be more fond, then the fathering of these wordes vpon Anacletus? This holy holy and Apostolike Church of Rome obteined the supremacie ⟨image 37⟩and preheminence of power ouer all Churches, not frō the Apostles, but from the very Lord himselfe our Sauiour. And again, There was a difference euen betwene the blessed Apostles: and albeit that all of them were Apostles: yet did the Lord graunt and the Apostles determined among them selues, that Peter should haue preheminence afore all the rest of the Apostles, and be Cephas, that is to say a head, and hold the souereintie of Apostleship. Thus sayth he. But who knoweth not (though he be but meanely séene in histories,) that after full fiue hūdred yeares, it was obteined and ordeined, not by Christ, or his Apostles but by loytering lozels or rather by traiterous persōs, that Rome should be called ye head of all Churches, that is to wit, that it should obteine supremacie & prerogatiue of power ouer all Churches? Or who would beleue that Anacletus exercised himselfe so little in readyng of the Gospell, that he knew not how Cephas signifieth, not a head but a stone or a Rocke? according as it is interpreted by Iohn the Apostle in the first chapter? And which interpreter should a man rather beleue? Iohn the Apostle, or the coūterfet Anaclete? The lewd packing then of the lewd lozelles is detected both in these and in many other thinges. The same partie maketh very often mention of Archbyshops and metropolitanes, neither omitteth he primates. But it is most manifest, that those titles were vtterly vnknowen to the primitiue Church, and were afterward inuented and vsurped in times folowyng.
And at their first coming up the manner of using them was after a sort meetly tolerable, till their posterity did afterward use them or rather misuse them more proudly. Besides this, the said counterfeit Anaclete maketh a Bishop greater than an Elder: whereas Jerome himself showeth by Scriptures, that Elders and Bishops are all one, and that in process of time Bishops were preferred before Elders, not by the ordinance of God, but by the ordinance of man. Moreover this Anacletus alloweth the Appeals that are made to the sea of Rome, saying: ⟨p. 32⟩that all questions and matters of weight ought to be referred to the Apostolic sea, for so had the Apostles decreed. But this self same thing is manifestly disallowed by the holy master of Christ Cyprian writing to Cornelius the Pope. Many other things prateth he concerning the privileges and judgements of the Church: which who soever seeth not to disagrees with these first times of the primitive Church, he seeth nothing, but is blinder then a beetle.
And at their first comming vp the maner of vsing them was after a sort méetly tolerable, till their posteritie did afterward vse them or rather misuse them more proudly. Besides this, the sayd counterfet Anaclete maketh a Bishop greater than an Elder: whereas Ierome himselfe sheweth by Scriptures, that Elders and Bishops are all one, and that in processe of time Byshops were preferred before Elders, not by the ordinaunce of God, but by the ordinaunce of man. Moreouer this Anacletus alloweth the Appeales that are made to the sea of Rome, saying: ⟨p. 32⟩that all questions and matters of weight ought to be referred to the Apostolike sea, for so had the Apostles decréed. But this selfe same thing is manifestly disallowed by the holy maister of Christ Cyprian writyng to Cornelius the Pope. Many other thinges prateth he concerning the priuiledges and iudgementes of the Church: which who soeuer séeth not to disagrés with these first tymes of the primitiue Church, he seeth nothyng, but is blynder then a béetle.
Furthermore there is a decree fathered upon Pope Alexander, whereby he commandeth that water should be hallowed with salt, to cleanse the people and to put away the secret slights of the devil. But who is so light headed to believe that so great men in so great light of the Gospel published so filthy decrees concerning such baggagely gewgaws so openly fighting against the Gospel and doctrine of the Apostles? These things savour not that Apostolic and ancient pureness and majesty which entirely attributeth all salvation to the only blood of the son of God and not to water and salt.
Furthermore there is a decrée fathered vpon Pope Alexander, wherby he commaundeth that water should be halowed with salt, to clense the people and to put away the secret slightes of the deuill. But who is so light headed to beleue that so great men in so great light of the Gospell published so filthy decrées concerning such baggagely gewgawes so openly fighting agaynst the Gospell and doctrine of the Apostles? These thinges sauour not that Apostolike and auncient purenesse and maiestie which entierly attributeth all saluation to the onely bloud of the sonne of God and not to water and salt.
Pope Sixtus in the said decretal Epistles commandeth that no man else should touch the holy vessels but he that is hallowed. Ye may perceive that this stuff agreeth trimly with the Apostolical doctrine delivered by Paul in the 2. to the Colossians, and finally with the histories which openly bear record that even the laymen received & handled the bread and cup of the Lord with their [bare] hands, certain hundred years after this Sixtus. Besides this, in the same Epistles, there is open & manifest mention made of Clements journey, which book nevertheless even the very Decrees of Gratian do reject among the authentical writings.
Pope Sixtus in the sayd decretall Epistles commaundeth that no man els should touch the holy vesselles but he that is halowed. Ye may perceiue that this stuffe agréeth trimly with the Apostolicall doctrine deliuered by Paul in the 2. to the Colossians, and finally with the histories which openly beare record that euen the laymen receiued & handled the bread and cup of the Lord with their [bare] handes, certein hundred yeares after this Sixtus. Besides this, in the same Epistles, there is open & manifest mention made of Clementes iourney, which booke neuerthelesse euē the very Decrées of Gratian do reiect among the authenticall writynges.
Yea and Thelesphorus commendeth the seven weeks fast before Easter, forbidding also the eating of flesh. Which thing again how well it agreeth with the doctrine of the Apostles, and with the doings, it is to be known by the things which S. Paul hath written in the 2. chapter to the ⟨image 38⟩Colossians, and in the 4. chapter of the first Epistle to Timothy, and which Socrates hath left written in his Ecclesiastical history in the 5. book and xxii. chap. but most of all which are taken out of Irenaeus by Eusebius in the 5. book and xxvi. chapter of his Ecclesiastical history.
Yea and Thelesphorus commendeth the seuen wéekes fast before Easter, forbidding also the eating of flesh. Which thing againe how well it agréeth with the doctrine of the Apostles, and with the doinges, it is to be knowen by the thinges which S. Paul hath written in the 2. chapter to the ⟨image 38⟩Colossians, and in the 4. chapter of the first Epistle to Timothie, and which Socrates hath left written in his Ecclesiasticall historie in the 5. booke and xxii. chap. but most of all which are taken out of Irenaeus by Eusebius in the 5. booke and xxvi. chapter of his Ecclesiasticall historie.
Moreover in those Epistles Calixtus is reported to have ordained the ember fast at four seasons of the year. Which thing others refer to other authors or founders. And among this stuff this is a thing that can not be read without laughter, that Eusebius the predecessor of Melciades doth with so great stateliness command the feast of the finding of the holy cross to be solemnized the vi. day of May. For some declare that the cross was not yet found at this time, but a xx. years after by Helene the mother of the Emperor Constantine. Again how superstitious, peevish, and fond gear are commanded in the same Epistles, namely that Nuns should not touch the holy vessels. As who should say there had ben any Nuns as yet in those days, the first coming up of whom is referred to far later times. Many other things of this sort do I pass over willingly, least I might make my readers to cast up their stomachs. For in these Epistles there be very many things so foolish, so far against reason, so full of superstition, and so full of ambition: that all men which have eyes may gather thereby that they be counterfeits, and specially forasmuch as there is very seldom or no mention at all made in all the book through out, of uncorrupted faith in Christ, yea or of Christ himself our redeemer, & of the treasures which the father hath given us in him, which things are the natural marks of Apostolical writings. Now although there be many things in them not unprofitable to be read: yet are the same things to be found in other men set forth more purely, and without any parings canker fretted with the filthiness of mans traditions. Furthermore it is very well known that those first most pure times of the Church were not acquainted with so many ⟨p. 33⟩ceremonies, so many decrees, and so many constitutions, as are found urged upon Gods Church in those Epistles. For the holy and devout folk of old time had not yet forgotten the Apostolic Council that was held at Jerusalem, wherein not only Peter plainly would not there should be any yoke laid upon the free necks of the faithful, but also moreover it seemed good to the holy Ghost and to the whole primitive Church of the Apostles, that there should not any burden be laid hereafter upon the faithful. This story is known to be written in the xv. chapter of the Acts of the Apostles.
Moreouer in those Epistles Calixtus is reported to haue ordeined the imber fast at foure seasons of the yeare. Which thing others referre to other authors or founders. And among this stuffe this is a thing that can not be read without laughter, that Eusebius the predecessour of Melciades doth with so great statelinesse commaund the feast of the finding of the holy crosse to be solemnized the vi. day of May. For some declare that the crosse was not yet found at this time, but a xx. yeares after by Helene the mother of the Emperour Constantine. Agayne how superstitious, péeuishe, and fond géere are commaunded in the same Epistles, namely that Nonnes should not touche the holy vessels. As who should say there had ben any Nunnes as yet in those dayes, the first comming vp of whom is referred to farre later times. Many other thinges of this sort do I passe ouer willingly, least I might make my readers to cast vp their stomakes. For in these Epistles there be very many thinges so foolish, so farre agaynst reason, so full of superstition, and so full of ambition: that all men which haue eyes may gather therby that they be counterfettes, and specially for asmuch as there is very seldome or no mention at all made in all the booke through out, of vncorrupted fayth in Christ, yea or of Christ himselfe our redemer, & of the treasures which the father hath giuen vs in him, which thinges are the naturall markes of Apostolicall writinges. Now although there be many thinges in them not vnprofitable to be read: yet are the same thinges to be found in other men set forth more purely, and without any paringes cankerfretted with the filthinesse of mans traditiōs. Furthermore it is very well knowen that those first most pure tymes of the Church were not acquaynted with so many
But if our adversaries will needs proceed to maintain that these are the very Epistles of those men upon whom they be fathered: we have answered a little afore, how they be of no authority against the doctrine of the Gospel and the Apostles, and therefore we admit them not in disputation. Notwithstanding by the way we have better opinion than so, of so great learned men, and of so holy Martyrs of Christ, neither will we in any wise stain and deface their honourable names and blessed memorial with such manner of gewgaws, whereof out of all doubt there never came any in their minds, no not even in their dreams.
But if our aduersaries will nedes procede to mainteine that these are the very Epistles of those men vppon whom they be fathered: we haue aunswered a little afore, how they be of no authoritie against the doctrine of the Gospell and the Apostles, and therfore we admit them not in disputation. Notwithstanding by the way we haue better opinion thā so, of so great learned men, and of so holy Martyrs of Christ, neither will we in any wise stayne and deface their honorable names and blessed memoriall with such maner of gewgawes, wherof out of all doubt there neuer came any in their mindes, no not euen in their dreames.