Fourthly, many Divines, both of ancient and modern Writers, have declared themselves to be of the mind, that the soul comes from the parents by generation,1 per traducem, and that the parents do beget the whole man, which consists of soul as well as body. Now, though it be true, that this opinion hath had, and still hath great patrons, and that it may not be denied, but that it is defended with marvellous great appearance of reason and truth; yet it is rejected, and hath been by the greater part of sound Divines, and by reasons unanswerable: for, if the soul come from the parents, then it must come either from the body of the parents, or from their souls. Now, it is apparent, it cannot come from their bodies,
1. Because a bodily substance cannot beget a spiritual substance, because it cannot derive from it self that which it hath not.
2. Because the soul must consist of the four elements, of which the body is compounded: but, it is apparent, there are no bodily humours in the soul; for, it is not hot, nor cold, nor moist, nor dry.
3. Because nothing that is mortal, can beget a thing that is immortal, such as the soul hath been proved to be.
Fourthly, many Diuines, both of antient and modern Writers, haue declared themselues to be of the minde, that the soule comes from the parents by generation,1 per traducem, and that the parents doo beget the whole man, which consists of soule as well as body. Now, though it bee true, that this opinion hath had, and still hath great patrones, and that it may not be denied, but that it is defended with maruellous great appearance of reason and truth; yet it is reiected, and hath been by the greater part of sound Diuines, and by reasons vnanswerable: for, if the soule come from the parents, then it must come either from the body of the parents, or from their soules. Now, it is apparant, it cannot come from their bodies,
1. Because a bodily substance cannot beget a spirituall substance, because it cannot deriue from it self that which it hath not.
2. Because the soule must consist of the foure elements, of which the body is compounded: but, it is apparant, there are no bodily humours in the soule; for, it is not hot, nor cold, nor moist, nor dry.
3. Because nothing that is mortall, can beget a thing that is immortall, such as the soule hath been proued to be.
- 1Anima non est ex traduce.