1. Thomas Aquinas (in whose time this faction was not in general request,1 much less in the Primitive) in 22. q. 91. a. 2.4. opposeth thus: The Church useth no music for divine praises, lest it should seem to Judaize, and answereth thus: Musical instruments do more stir up the mind to delight, then frame it to a right disposition. In the old Testament there was some need of them, both, &c. and also because they did figure out something. Erasmus, in 1. Cor. 14. saith thus: We have brought a tedious and player-like music into the Church, a tumultuous noise of many voices, such as I think was not heard among the Theatres of Grecians or Romans. For which purpose, whole flocks of boys are maintained at great charges, whose age also is all spent in learning such gibble gabble. At such cost is the Church •or a pestiferous thing, &c.
1. Thomas Aquinas (in whose time this faction was not in generall request,1 much lesse in the Primitive) in 22. q. 91. a. 2.4. opposeth thus: The Church useth no musick for divine praises, lest it should seeme to Indaize, and answereth thus: Musicall instruments doe more stirre up the minde to delight, then frame it to a right disposition. In the old Testament there was some need of them, both, &c. and also because they did figure out something. Erasmus, in 1. Cor. 14. sayth thus: We have brought a tedious and player-like musicke into the Church, a tumultuous noyse of many voyces, such as I thinke was not heard among the Theaters of Grecians or Romans. For which purpose, whole flockes of boyes are maintained at great charges, whose age also is all spent in learning such gibble gabble. At such cost is the Church •or a pestiferous thing, &c.
- 1Instrumenta musica non assumit Ecclesia in divinas lauds, ne videatur Judaizare: Musica instrumenta magis animum movent ad delectationem, quam ut per ea forractur bona dypositio. In et Test. usus erat taiium instrumentorum, tum-tum quia aliquid figurabant Operosam quandam, & theatricam musi•am in sac•as a•es induximus, tumultuosum diversarum vocum garritum, qualem non opinor in Graecorum, out Rom morum theatris unquam auditumsuisse. In hunc usum, magnu sala•ijs aluntur puororum greges, quorum omnis aet as in perdiscendus hujusmodi garnitibus consumitur, tantus sumptibus oneratur Ecclesia, ob rem pestiseram, &c.Instrumenta musica non assumit Ecclesia in divinas laudes, ne videatur Iudaizare: Musica instrumenta magis animum movent ad delectationem, quam ut per ea forractur bona dypositio. In et Test. usus erat taiium instrumentorum, tum-tum quia aliquid figurabant Operosam quandam, & theatricam musi•am in sac•as a•es induximus, tumultuosum diversarum vocum garritum, qualem non opinor in Graecorum, out Rom morum theatris unquam auditumsuisse. In hunc usum, magnu sala•ijs aluntur puororum greges, quorum omnis aet as in perdiscendus hujusmodi garnitibus consumitur, tantus sumptibus oneratur Ecclesia, ob rem pestiseram, &c.