To the Reverend Dr. Edward Stillingfleet, Dean of St. Pauls, &c.
pp. 25–100379 passagespart 3 of 10
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§. 26. Serm. p. 18. [Nay, if it be mutual Consent and Agreement which makes a Church, then why may not National Societies agreeing together in the same Faith, and under the same Government and Discipline, be as truly and properly a Church as any particular Congregation?
Ans. 1. Is it only de nomine, or de re that you ask? If de nomine, we grant you, that a Parliament, an Army may be truly called Ecclesia; if de re, we grant you that it is truly a Church of another kind. 2. Mutual Consent makes a Church, but God's Consent or Institution must go first to warrant that Consent, and make it a Church which he will own: Else mutual Consent may make it but Jeroboam's Church, or a false and sinful Policy. Prove if you can, that God hath authorized Men to make as many new Church-Species, Policies or Forms as they please; or any against, or above, or equal to those of his Institution, besides Magistracy.
§. 27. Serm. p. 19. Why many of these Cities, united under one Civil Government, and the same Rules of Religion, should not be called one National Church, I cannot understand: which makes me wonder at those who say they cannot tell what we mean by the Church of England: Sacrileg. Desert. p. 35.
Answ. 1. Admiratio est ignorantis: I am as ignorant of you, as you are of […]; therefore may answer wondering with wondering; 1. That such a Man should not know the reason when I so plainly and distinctly wrote it down, 2. And that while you wonder, you should not vouchsafe to give me the least means of Satisfaction. For I suppose few will think that you do so much as attempt it here. 3. You make it still as if the Controversie were de nomine▪ what it may be called; when I only spake de re, and bid you call it what you will, if you will but tell us your meaning. 4. Yea in my Plea, sect. 4 5. and in the Addition: I fully showed what we grant de re, & de nomine, and what we deny; and what the state of our Controversy is: and do you think to satisfy us, after all this with Wondering that we understand not what you mean?