B. Either you mean, that the Object of Gods Decree was but his own permission (as the Arminians use to say) or else, that it was the Sin it self (matter and form) permitted, (not because it is sin or evil, for so man oft willeth it not at least, but) as an occasion of Gods Glory. Arminius his words import the latter: And then you go as high as Dr. Twice or Rutherford. But if you say, that it was but a rash word of Arminius, which you stand not to; to make plain and short work with you, I am so far from being liable to your charge, that I charge you as presumptuous, if not erroneous, in saying, that God decreeth or willeth to permit Sin. And I assert.
1. That God doth not Decree the form of Sin as Sin. 2. Nor yet the event of that form for any good end (For, Ut peccatum eveniat, is but peccatum futurum;) and what is it to decree Sin, but to decree that it shall be? Nor 3. Hath he decreed, that this Act which is the Sin, shall come to pass in its comparative circumstantiated state, from whence it is, that Sin in its form resulteth. And so Augustine's saying so much decantate by Dr. Twice and others, *is not found, that nothing cometh to pass but what God willeth, either effecting it, or permitting it. It cometh to pass without Gods willing it or decreeing it; so that he permitteth it, but decreeth not that it shall come to pass. Not that it is against his contrary absolute Decree; but as Lombard from other places in Austin telleth you plainly, God neither willeth that it shall be, (because it is sin) nor properly and simply willeth that it shall not be, for his Will is not overcome. 4. Yea, he cannot be proved to decree his own permission; Because to permit, is but not to hinder, which is nothing but a negation: And we have no ground to feign, that God hath Volitions or Decrees of nothing, or of negations.
So that I say, that Sin cometh to pass without Gods Decree of the event, or of his permission. (Though not without his Decree of the good which cometh by it; of which more, when I speak to the other extreme.) And of this also more anon.
B. Either you mean, that the Object of Gods Decree was but his own permission (as the Arminians use to say) or else, that it was the Sin it self (matter and form) permitted, (not because it is sin or evil, for so man oft willeth it not at least, but) as an occasion of Gods Glory. Arminius his words import the latter: And then you go as high as Dr. Twisse or Rutherford. But if you say, that it was but a rash word of Arminius, which you stand not to; to make plain and short work with you, I am so far from being liable to your charge, that I charge you as presumptuous, if not erroneous, in saying, that God decreeth or willeth to permit Sin. And I assert.
1. That God doth not Decree the form of Sin as Sin. 2. Nor yet the event of that form for any good end (For, Ut peccatum eveniat, is but peccatum futurum;) and what is it to decree Sin, but to decree that it shall be? Nor 3. Hath he decreed, that this Act which is the Sin, shall come to pass in its comparative circumstantiated state, from whence it is, that Sin in its form resulteth. And so Augustines saying so much decantate by Dr. Twisse and others, *is not found, that nothing cometh to pass but what God willeth, either effecting it, or permitting it. It cometh to pass without Gods willing it or decreeing it; so that he permitteth it, but decreeth not that it shall come to pass. Not that it is against his contrary absolute Decree; but as Lombard from other places in Austin telleth you plainly, God neither willeth that it shall be, (because it is sin) nor properly and simply willeth that it shall not be, for his Will is not overcome. 4. Yea, he cannot be proved to decree his own permission; Because to permit, is but not to hinder, which is nothing but a negation: And we have no ground to feign, that God hath Volitions or Decrees of nothing, or of negations.
So that I say, that Sin cometh to pass without Gods Decree of the event, or of his permission. (Though not without his Decree of the good which cometh by it; of which more, when I speak to the other extream.) And of this also more anon.
- *As Bradwardine who also tells us, That if God damn the Innocent, his Will is the rule of justice and equity: But I think they that so describe his Justice, do rather think that none are damned, than that the Innocent are; or may be, as an act of Justice, whatever a mere Proprietor may do.As Bradwardine who also tells us, That if God damn the Innocent, his Will is the rule of justice and equity: But I think they that so describe his Justice, do rather think that none are damned, than that the Innocent are; or may be, as an act of Justice, whatever a meer Proprietor may do.