The fourth Crimination.
pp. 12–147 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 12–147 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
B. These are words of confusion, which, when opened, will appear nothing, and that we are all of a mind. Either you will distinguish Gods Decrees by the Objects, or not. If not, you must not distinguish between Election and Rejection, willing and nilling, loving Peter, and hating Judas, &c. If yea, then you must not take up with the unexplained words, Reprobation and Election. 1. By Reprobation is meant either Gods Will to punish men. 2. Or his Will to give them no special saving Grace. 3. Or his not-willing to give it them. For the first, I told you before that the Object of God• Will to punish men in Hell, is a Sinner fore-seen finally rejecting Mercy. 2. The Object of his Will to punish men with positive temporal punishments, is the Sinner fore-seen in his immediate capacity for them. 3. Whether punishment by not giving that Spirit for Faith, Repentance, and Holiness, be decreed (being nothing but a not-giving) is before discussed. But if it could be proved, yet the Object of Gods denying further 1mercy and help, is evermore one that hath abused former mercy, or refuseth that as offered to him. 4. But Gods non-Volition to give Grace i• no act, and hath no Object. But we judge that all mankind are now from under the mere Covenant of Innocency, and that none perish but for the abuse of mercy, which had a tendency to their recovery (The case of Infants must be spoke to in its place once for all.) But all this belongeth to the Case of Grace and Free-will. *And 2. As for Election, we say that 1. The Object of Gods Will to glorify men, is man sanctifying and persevering in an immediate capacity for Glory in esse cognito. 2. The Object of Gods Will to give the Grace of perseverance, is a fore-seen sanctified person in the next capacity. 3. The Object of Gods Will to justify, sanctify, ⟨p. 13⟩and adopt, is a fore-seen Believer. 4. The Object of Gods Will, to give special Grace, which shall effectually cause men to repent and believe, is ordinarily a fore-seen disposed Sinner prepared by his common Grace; but sometimes an unprepared Sinner, whom, of his free will, he will suddenly convert, as it pleaseth him freely to distribute his benefits (all being unworthy.) 5.
B. These are words of confusion, which, when opened, will appear nothing, and that we are all of a mind. Either you will distinguish Gods Decrees by the Objects, or not. If not, you must not distinguish between Election and Rejection, willing and nilling, loving Peter, and hating Judas, &c. If yea, then you must not take up with the unexplained words, Reprobation and Election. 1. By Reprobation is meant either Gods Will to punish men. 2. Or his Will to give them no special saving Grace. 3. Or his not-willing to give it them. For the first, I told you before that the Object of God• Will to punish men in Hell, is a Sinner fore-seen finally rejecting Mercy. 2. The Object of his Will to punish men with positive temporal punishments, is the Sinner fore-seen in his immediate capacity for them. 3. Whether punishment by not giving that Spirit for Faith, Repentance, and Holiness, be decreed (being nothing but a not-giving) is before discust. But if it could be proved, yet the Object of Gods denying further 1mercy and help, is evermore one that hath abused former mercy, or refuseth that as offered to him. 4. But Gods non-Volition to give Grace i• no act, and hath no Object. But we judge that all mankind are now from under the meer Covenant of Innocency, and that none perish but for the abuse of mercy, which had a tendency to their recovery (The case of Infants must be spoke to in its place once for all.) But all this belongeth to the Case of Grace and Free-will. *And 2. As for Election, we say that 1. The Object of Gods Will to glorifie men, is man sanctifying and persevering in an immediate capacity for Glory in esse cognito. 2. The Object of Gods Will to give the Grace of perseverance, is a fore-seen sanctified person in the next capacity. 3. The Object of Gods Will to justifie, sanctifie, ⟨p. 13⟩and adopt, is a fore-seen Believer. 4. The Object of Gods Will, to give special Grace, which shall effectually cause men to repent and believe, is ordinarily a fore-seen disposed Sinner prepared by his common Grace; but sometimes an unprepared Sinner, whom, of his free will, he will suddenly convert, as it pleaseth him freely to distribute his benefits (all being unworthy.) 5.
The Object of Gods Will, to give the highest degrees of common Grace, external (in the purest preaching of the Gospel, and other mercies,) and internal (in greater helps of the Spirit) is sometimes a Sinner in esse cognito, who hath not grossly rejected lower helps, and sometimes freely the worser sort of Sinners, who have abused former mercies. 6. The Object of Gods Will, to give the first common mercy which hath a tendency in its use to mens recovery and Salvation, is all mankind fallen in Adam: For all are under the New Covenant of Grace made with Adam, Gen. 3. 15. in some degree, (and with Noah) and all have much mercy tending to Repentance; and none are left as the Devils in despair, without any offered remedy or help. 7. The Object of Gods Will to give man the Covenant of Innocency, was Adam fore-seen as mere man. 8. The Object of Gods Will to create man, was nothing in the sense that we now take an Object in; that is, for the materia circa quam. But if you will call the intended effect the Object, then the Object of Gods Will here (and in the rest) is the thing willed. But if you will needs presume to seek one higher in the Mind of God, *you must say that it was man as conceived fit to be, as well as possible. For we can think no otherwise of the Divine Conceptions and Volitions, but as we are led by the analogy of humane acts. And so we must say, that 1. Gods Power maketh it possible for all things to be. 2. Next God knoweth them possible. 3. He knoweth what is convenient or fit to be made, to his unsearchable ends. 4. He willeth that they shall be, and man among the rest, and so on. If you will needs have the order of Decrees, this is all that we can say of them.
The Object of Gods Will, to give the highest degrees of common Grace, external (in the purest preaching of the Gospel, and other mercies,) and internal (in greater helps of the Spirit) is sometimes a Sinner in esse cognito, who hath not grosly rejected lower helps, and sometimes freely the worser sort of Sinners, who have abused former mercies. 6. The Object of Gods Will, to give the first common mercy which hath a tendency in its use to mens recovery and Salvation, is all mankind fallen in Adam: For all are under the New Covenant of Grace made with Adam, Gen. 3. 15. in some degree, (and with Noah) and all have much mercy tending to Repentance; and none are left as the Devils in dispair, without any offered remedy or help. 7. The Object of Gods Will to give man the Covenant of Innocency, was Adam fore-seen as meer man. 8. The Object of Gods Will to create man, was nothing in the sense that we now take an Object in; that is, for the materia circa quam. But if you will call the intended effect the Object, then the Object of Gods Will here (and in the rest) is the thing willed. But if you will needs presume to seek one higher in the Mind of God, *you must say that it was man as conceived fit to be, as well as possible. For we can think no otherwise of the Divine Conceptions and Volitions, but as we are led by the analogy of humane acts. And so we must say, that 1. Gods Power maketh it possible for all things to be. 2. Next God knoweth them possible. 3. He knoweth what is convenient or fit to be made, to his unsearchable ends. 4. He willeth that they shall be, and man among the rest, and so on. If you will needs have the order of Decrees, this is all that we can say of them.
A. All this pleaseth us well: but it will not please your own Party, or the Calvinists; that you make so many acts of Election, which they tell you is but one entire thing, as mentioned in Scripture: Nor yet that you lay every Decree or Will upon fore-sight.
B. You are mistaken: No moderate considerate man of them will deny any thing that I have said. For 1. As to the Scripture use of the word Election, it is not the mere name that we are now opening, but the matter in question: Nor is it the expounding of particular Texts that I am upon: And if I were, no man will deny but that the word Election is variously used in the Scripture: Sometime for Gods eternal Will to make us Christians of Infidels, and to save us by Christ; and sometime for actual choosing us by converting Grace in time; and sometime for actual choosing men in time by Vocation to some office or special work, &c. 2. And as to the distinguishing of all these Volitions of God, no man will deny the effects to be distinct; undoubtedly these are various effects of God; 1. To make man. 2. To give him the Covenant of Innocency. 3. To give him the Covenant of Grace, with all the common mercies of it. 4. To give some Persons and Nations the Gospel, and other mercies above the greatest part of the World, with answerable helps of the Spirit. 5. To give men special Grace, effectual for Faith and Repentance. 6. To give men Pardon, Adoption, and Sanctification. 7. To give men Perseverance. 8. To give them Glory. And if these are various works, either you will distinguish ⟨p. 14⟩of Gods Will by his various works, or not. *If you do not, our whole Controversy about the Order of the Decrees is quickly at an end (and I am content with the abbreviation): For where there is no Distinction, there is no Order. And when I distinguish them never so much, I say, as well as any, that they are all one in regard of the one Will or Essence of God that willeth them. In God there is no real diversity; but his Will is thus variously denominated extrinsically from its respect to the various objects to which it doth transire, and of the various effects which it produceth. And thus do all men talk of God. Else they could not distinguish his saving Will from his damning Will; nor Election from Rejection, in his Decree. So that no man can tell how to differ here. 3. And as to fore-sight, you as much mistake. For 1. I say not that God fore-seeth any good in any man, but what he giveth him, and willeth to give him; But we speak of the Order of those Volitions, in the way of execution. *2.
B. You are mistaken: No moderate considerate man of them will deny any thing that I have said. For 1. As to the Scripture use of the word Election, it is not the meer name that we are now opening, but the matter in question: Nor is it the expounding of particular Texts that I am upon: And if I were, no man will deny but that the word Election is variously used in the Scripture: Sometime for Gods eternal Will to make us Christians of Infidels, and to save us by Christ; and sometime for actual choosing us by converting Grace in time; and sometime for actual choosing men in time by Vocation to some office or special work, &c. 2. And as to the distinguishing of all these Volitions of God, no man will deny the effects to be distinct; undoubtedly these are various effects of God; 1. To make man. 2. To give him the Covenant of Innocency. 3. To give him the Covenant of Grace, with all the common mercies of it. 4. To give some Persons and Nations the Gospel, and other mercies above the greatest part of the World, with answerable helps of the Spirit. 5. To give men special Grace, effectual for Faith and Repentance. 6. To give men Pardon, Adoption, and Sanctification. 7. To give men Perseverance. 8. To give them Glory. And if these are various works, either you will distinguish ⟨p. 14⟩of Gods Will by his various works, or not. *If you do not, our whole Controversie about the Order of the Decrees is quickly at an end (and I am content with the abreviation): For where there is no Distinction, there is no Order. And when I distinguish them never so much, I say, as well as any, that they are all one in regard of the one Will or Essence of God that willeth them. In God there is no real diversity; but his Will is thus variously denominated extrinsecally from its respect to the various objects to which it doth transire, and of the various effects which it produceth. And thus do all men talk of God. Else they could not distinguish his saving Will from his damning Will; nor Election from Rejection, in his Decree. So that no man can tell how to differ here. 3. And as to fore-sight, you as much mistake. For 1. I say not that God fore-seeth any good in any man, but what he giveth him, and willeth to give him; But we speak of the Order of those Volitions, in the way of execution. *2.
And all men that ascribe Intentions, Volitions, or Purposes to God, do and must make the Object of them as such to be Quid cognitum, or something which some call an Idea in the Mind of God; It is not a prius Volitum qua tale that is the Object of a Volition, but bonum intellectum. And therefore nothing but fore-sight or apprehension of the thing, needs to be put in the description of the Object. Nor do I deny, but that we must in our ordinary Discourse speak comprehensively, and denominate Election eminently from the noblest parts: For as our full Salvation includeth all, or almost all, so our Conversion and Glorification presupposeth all that antecedeth. And therefore as we may and must talk of Salvation in general, and not always stand to mention all the parts of it; so must we eminently talk of Election to Salvation, as comprehending the rest, and not always stand to distinguish of the parts. But when you will make a Controversy of the Order and the Object of these acts or parts, we must distinguish.
And all men that ascribe Intentions, Volitions, or Purposes to God, do and must make the Object of them as such to be Quid cognitum, or something which some call an Idea in the Mind of God; It is not a prius Volitum qua tale that is the Object of a Volition, but bonum intellectum. And therefore nothing but fore-sight or apprehension of the thing, needs to be put in the description of the Object. Nor do I deny, but that we must in our ordinary Discourse speak comprehensively, and denominate Election eminently from the noblest parts: For as our full Salvation includeth all, or almost all, so our Conversion and Glorification presupposeth all that antecedeth. And therefore as we may and must talk of Salvation in general, and not always stand to mention all the parts of it; so must we eminently talk of Election to Salvation, as comprehending the rest, and not always stand to distinguish of the parts. But when you will make a Controversie of the Order and the Object of these acts or parts, we must distinguish.