The ninth Crimination.
pp. 19–204 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 19–204 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
B. You had this Objection about necessity before, and to the answer of it I refer you further, 1. Immutable Election doth set up but a consolatory quietting certainty in the World, without which mans mind must still be in troublesome, unquiet, if not tormenting terrours. Is it a wrong to you, if you can be sure to be saved? Had you rather live and die under these apprehensions, [I know not whether I shall be in Heaven 1or Hell for ever?] If you have not certainty, or a hope that is somewhat near it; I think this conclusion, if you be awake, and in your wits, must needs make your life a constant bondage, and the fear of death your constant misery, and must blast all the pleasures of your fulest Prosperity. Thank God that his Foundation standeth sure, and the Lord knoweth who are his; and see that you keep his mark upon you, professing Christ, and departing from iniquity. And do not cry out as if you were fatally carried to Heaven against your wills. 2. As for the word [Fate] it is ambiguous: Some by fate, mean but the certainty that God's Predictions shall be fulfilled; Quod fatur eveniet. Some mean only the certain connexion of Causes and Effects ⟨p. 20⟩under Gods sapiential Government of the World. (As Campanella maketh Necessity, Fate, and Harmony, to be the result of Power, Wisdom, and Love; but not accurately enough.) And some say, (but how truly I know not) That the Stoicks took Fate for some primary necessitating Cause, which did necessitate all Acts of the Gods and Men. It is a word that we have no need of; they that will play them with it may. 3. But as to Necessity again, I say, 1. Election maketh no mans sin or misery necessary, nor tendeth to it. 2. It maketh no mans Salvation 2necessary against his will in sensu composito. 3. The more it maketh our Salvation necessary, that is, certain and insuperable, the greater is Gods mercy, the greater our happiness, and cause of gratitude and Joy. The Saints in Heaven are not offended at the certainty of their persevering blessedness. If you shall Object, That it necessitateth the perishing of all others, because none can be saved who are not Elect. Remember that this was your third Crimination, and is answered before. I say again, 1. Necessity and Impossibility are either Logical in ordine probandi; or Physical in ordine causandi. The first sort followeth upon your own Doctrine:
He that God fore-knoweth shall sin and perish, it necessarily followeth Necessitate consequentiae; and it is impossible but it should follow, that he will sin and perish, but not by Gods fore-knowledge. Causal necessitating either taketh away the true power of escaping, or depriveth of such power by prevention: But so doth not the Election or Decree of God. 2. Though we hold such absolute Election as hath been opened to you, and that God decreeth to cause men to believe, before he fore-seeth that they will believe, (in order of Nature, according to humane Conception;) yet we hold as you do, that Reprobation doth not so proceed, but that God decreeth men to Hell only on fore-sight of final wickedness, which he never caused or willed. And if in this we agree with you, you must accuse your selves as much as us. 3. God doth both Decree to give, and actually give men power to do more than they do; And his decreeing that another man shall well use that power which he hath, doth sure take away no power from you. 4. Yea, Gods not decreeing to cause you to use your own power well, doth take none of it from you; But includeth that such power you have: much less his Decree to do more for others. 5. All the World acknowledgeth, that a Benefactor as such is free to give his own benefits as he pleases, unequally. And giving more to one taketh nothing from another. Suppose that God had for 4000 years, till Christ's Incarnation, but willed and given his mercy equally to all the World, even so much as might leave the matter merely to their wills; and after that had given greater mercy to the Christian Churches, taking nothing from the rest: Had this been any injury or diminution to the rest? Suppose now God should fetch half the damned out of Hell, is this any more hurt or wrong to the rest than if he had delivered none. But all these things are here anticipated, and cannot be fully answered till we come to the Article of Grace; where we must show how God doth differ his Operations on mens Souls: For none can deny, but as he differenceth them, so he decreed to difference them, and no otherwise.
He that God fore-knoweth shall sin and perish, it necessarily followeth Necessitate consequentiae; and it is impossible but it should follow, that he will sin and perish, but not by Gods fore-knowledge. Causal necessitating either taketh away the true power of escaping, or depriveth of such power by prevention: But so doth not the Election or Decree of God. 2. Though we hold such absolute Election as hath been opened to you, and that God decreeth to cause men to believe, before he fore-seeth that they will believe, (in order of Nature, according to humane Conception;) yet we hold as you do, that Reprobation doth not so proceed, but that God decreeth men to Hell only on fore-sight of final wickedness, which he never caused or willed. And if in this we agree with you, you must accuse your selves as much as us. 3. God doth both Decree to give, and actually give men power to do more than they do; And his decreeing that another man shall well use that power which he hath, doth sure take away no power from you. 4. Yea, Gods not decreeing to cause you to use your own power well, doth take none of it from you; But includeth that such power you have: much less his Decree to do more for others. 5. All the World acknowledgeth, that a Benefactor as such is free to give his own benefits as he pleases, unequally. And giving more to one taketh nothing from another. Suppose that God had for 4000 years, till Christ's Incarnation, but willed and given his mercy equally to all the World, even so much as might leave the matter meerly to their wills; and after that had given greater mercy to the Christian Churches, taking nothing from the rest: Had this been any injury or diminution to the rest? Suppose now God should fetch half the damned out of Hell, is this any more hurt or wrong to the rest than if he had delivered none. But all these things are here anticipated, and cannot be fully answered till we come to the Article of Grace; where we must shew how God doth differ his Operations on mens Souls: For none can deny, but as he differenceth them, so he decreed to difference them, and no otherwise.