THE Ninth Days Conference Between A. and B. OF PERSEVERANCE.
pp. 198–20755 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
B. You come near to this truth; Indeed there are Principles better than either of your controverted Opinions, common to both sides, which may afford us great Consolation, and which sound Christians live upon. And I doubt your Disputes on both sides do more disturb than comfort most. But this must be granted, that Opinions are not true, because they are comfortable, nor all false that have any thing in them apt to trouble men, who have the sinful matter of trouble in ⟨p. 204⟩themselves: no more than Physic is naught that maketh men sick. We must take our Comforts on Gods terms. The truth is, your Doctrine seemeth more comfortable in the respects which you have named, as to the assurance of present Justification, and theirs more comfortable in another respect; viz. as to the continuance of it when they have it. But if this Doctrine were to be chosen by the comfortableness, yea and usefulness of it, there is a middle way (of some Schoolmen) which would be preferred before both. That is, that neither any of the Elect, nor any that have attained to confirmation •r a fixed degree of Grace, do ever fall away: But that there are some not-Elect, who are sincere and justified, but weak and mutable (as Adam in Innocency) and not confirmed, who fall away and perish: And this Vossius thinketh was Augustine's Opinion. And Grotius in his excellent Epistle against Molin: lately translated into English by Mr. Barksdale, affirmeth it to be the common judgment of the Fathers: which will be no small advantage to it with me. And 1. This avoideth the uncomfortable Doctrine which you charge on them; For this holdeth that a weak Christian may have the comfort of present Justification, that is not certain to persevere, nor that he is any better than some that fall away. 2. And it avoideth the uncomfortableness which they charge on you, viz. that no man can be assured of his Perseverance and Salvation: For these hold that all the consumed may be assured of it; And that all weak Christians may possibly attain to confirmation. 3. And it only leaveth weak unconfirmed Christian• uncertain of Salvation, which both sides are agreed in. For they confess that weak Christians are seldom if ever sure of their present sincerity and Justification: And you hold that they are uncertain to persevere: And so both of you hold them to be uncertain of Salvation. But proceed.
B. You come near to this truth; Indeed there are Principles better than either of your controverted Opinions, common to both sides, which may afford us great Consolation, and which sound Christians live upon. And I doubt your Disputes on both sides do more disturb than comfort most. But this must be granted, that Opinions are not true, because they are comfortable, nor all false that have any thing in them apt to trouble men, who have the sinful matter of trouble in