The Eleventh Days CONFERENCE. Of Christs Righteousness imputed: of Faith, Justification, and mans duty; their several parts, to a Christians Comfort. Speakers: Saul, Paul, a Libertine Teacher.The Eleventh Dayes CONFERENCE. Of Christs Righteousness imputed: of Faith, Justification, and mans duty; their several parts, to a Christians Comfort. Speakers: Saul, Paul, a Libertine Teacher.
pp. 219–262330 passagespart 4 of 9
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Lib. Seeing you like not my explications, tell me fully what you hold your selves, and then I shall better know whether we differ in sense or words only.
P. It's great pity for the Churches sake, but you would have understood that first, before you reviled us as Legal, and not have spoken evil of what you understand not. But it's better now, than not at all. Our judgement is as followeth:
I. That God hath three Essential Attributes, which he expresseth and glorifieth in his works; His Vital Power or Activity, his Wisdom, and his Will or Love: That all these are and operate conjunctly; but yet each appeareth in eminency in its special effects: That Gods Power eminently appeareth in the Being and Motion of things; and his Wisdom eminently in the ORDER of things; and his LOVE in the Goodness and Perfection of things: That accordingly he is, 1. The first Efficient, 2. The chief Dirigent, 3. The ultimate Final Cause of all.
II. That as to man, he is Related to us, 1. As our Creator, the Cause of our Being, Nature and natural Motion, as the Fountain of Nature: where Power is most Eminent. 2. As our Governor, and the God of ORDER, and the Dirigent Cause; where (all Attributes concur, but) Wisdom is most Eminent: 3. As our most Bounteous Benefactor, and most Amiable Good and End, where Goodness or Love is most eminent.
III. That accordingly God is the Author of Nature, Grace and Glory; and since the fall, of Natura, Medela, Sanitas, of our Nature, our ORDER and Gracious Government, and of our Holiness and Happiness; and so is our Creator, Redeemer and Sanctifier.
IV. That neither Man, Angel or any Creature can possibly have any good, but by Gods gift, any more than they can make themselves or a World: And this Gift must needs be free, seeing the Creature hath nothing that is good, but what it hath of God, and nothing to give him that can add to him, or but what is absolutely his own.
V. God is to us 1. Our OWNER, 2. Our RULER, 3. Our BENEFACTOR antecedently. And no man can Merit of God as he is an Owner or a mere Benefactor; for so he freely disposeth as he pleaseth of his own: But only of God as a Ruler, as is after opened.
VI. Therefore it is blasphemy to hold that man or Angel can Merit of God in point of proper Commutative Justice, which giveth in exchange one thing for another, to the benefit of the receiver: For as is said, God cannot Receive any addition to his perfection, nor have we any thing but his own to give him. Luke 17. 10. we are thus unprofitable servants as to a Proprietor in point of Commutation;
P. It's great pity for the Churches sake, but you would have understood that first, before you reviled us as Legal, and not have spoken evil of what you understand not. But it's better now, than not at all. Our judgement is as followeth:
I. That God hath three Essential Attributes, which he expresseth and glorifieth in his works; His Vital Power or Activity, his Wisdom, and his Will or Love: That all these are and operate conunctly; but yet each appeareth in eminency in its special effects: That Gods Power eminently appeareth in the Being and Motion of things; and his Wisdom eminently in the ORDER of things; and his LOVE in the Goodness and Perfection of things: That accordingly he is, 1. The first Efficient, 2. The chief Dirigent, 3. The ultimate Final Cause of all.
II. That as to man, he is Related to us, 1. As our Creator, the Cause of our Being, Nature and natural Motion, as the Fountain of Nature: where Power is most Eminent. 2. As our Governour, and the God of ORDER, and the Dirigent Cause; where (all Attributes concurr, but) Wisdom is most Eminent: 3. As our most Bounteous Benefactor, and most Amiable Good and End, where Goodness or Love is most eminent.
III. That accordingly God is the Author of Nature, Grace and Glory; and since the fall, of Natura, Medela, Sanitas, of our Nature, our ORDER and Gracious Government, and of our Holiness and Happiness; and so is our Creator, Redeemer and Sanctifier.
IV. That neither Man, Angel or any Creature can possibly have any good, but by Gods gift, any more than they can make themselves or a World: And this Gift must needs be free, seeing the Creature hath nothing that is good, but what it hath of God, and nothing to give him that can add to him, or but what is absolutely his own.
V. God is to us 1. Our OWNER, 2. Our RULER, 3. Our BENEFACTOR antecedently. And no man can Merit of God as he is an Owner or a meer Benefactor; for so he freely disposeth as he pleaseth of his own: But only of God as a Ruler, as is after opened.
VI. Therefore it is blasphemy to hold that man or Angel can Merit of God in point of proper Commutative Justice, which giveth in exchange one thing for another, to the benefit of the receiver: For as is said, God cannot Receive any addition to his perfection, nor have we any thing but his own to give him. Luke 17. 10. we are thus unprofitable servants as to a Proprietor in point of Commutation;
though the unprofitable servant be da••ned, Mat•h. 25. 30. in another sense; that is, who improveth not his Masters stock to the benefit of himself and others, and the pleasing of his Ruler.
VII. Mans Duty therefore meriteth only in point of Governing distributive Justice: And not every way neither in respect of that; For Governing Justice is distinguished according to the Law that governeth us: ⟨p. 231⟩which is either 1. The Law of Innocency, or 2. The Law of Grace: And no man since the fall can Merit of God according to the Justice of the Law of Innocency, which exacteth personal perfection.
VIII. The Law of Grace is in its first notion, a free gift of Christ, Pardon and Right to Life Eternal by Adoption, to all that will Accept it believingly as it is offered, that is, according to the nature of the Gift. And this Gift or Conditional promise and pardon no man can merit: For Christs perfect Righteousness and Sacrifice hath already merited it for us; and so hath left us no such work to do: Nor is there the least place for any humane Merit or Rewardableness from God, but on supposition of 1. Christs Merits and Meritorious Righteousness, 2. And of this free gift or Act of Oblivion and Life, already made to us without our desert.
IX. But yet this is not a mere Gift, but also a true Law: God is still our God and Governor, and Christ is Lord of all, Rom. 14. 9. He that is a King and Ruler hath his Laws and Judgement: That which is a Gift in the first respect, hath 1. Its condition, 2. Many commanded duties, and so is a Law of Grace in other respects. And it is only in respect to this Law of Grace that man is Rewardable, or can Merit.
X. The Gift is from God as Benefactor, considered as Good and in it self. But it is from God as Sapiential Rector quoad ordin•m conferendi, as to the Order and Reason why one man rather than another receiveth it. So that we Merit not of God as Benefactor nor as Rector by the Law of Innocency or Works; nor yet as to the Value or Goodness of the Benefit, which is a free Gift: But only of God as Rector by the Law of Grace, which regulateth the Reception of his free gifts, merited by the perfect Righteousness of Christ, and so only as to the Order and Reason why one more than another receiveth that free gift.
though the unprofitable servant be daned, Math. 25. 30. in another sense; that is, who improveth not his Masters stock to the benefit of himself and others, and the pleasing of his Ruler.
VII. Mans Duty therefore meriteth only in point of Governing distributive Justice: And not every way neither in respect of that; For Governing Justice is distinguished according to the Law that governeth us:
As if a Father hath many Sons, One living obediently, Others playing the prodigals, and upon his freely-offered pardon and grace one receiveth it thankfully, and the other refuseth it scornfully: Here both the obedient and the penitent son, have all upon free gift, as to Commutative Justice; but on various terms: And yet both merit in point of paternal Governing Justice; but very differently: One meriteth of strict Fatherly Justice; The other only of a forgiving Father, quite on other terms: And it is a Comparative Merit, by which he is fitter for pardon than the Sons that despise it, and spit in the Fathers face.
XI. God as a Benefactor and a Governor, giveth some benefits Antecedently to any duty of man: And these are never a Reward to us, (but of Christ perhaps, in some instances.) As Legislation, so the benefits of it, and that attend it, are before Reward and Judgement. But other benefits are given by God both as Benefactor and Legislator, upon condition of some duty of ours in the Antecedent gift, and so in the Judicial sentence and execution that duty is rendered as the reason of our actual Right to them: And these are a Reward.
XII. Our first Grace is no Reward, nor merited, because it antecedeth all conditional duty of ours.
XIII. Our first Reception of Right to Christ, Pardon and Life, being given on the condition of penitent Acceptance in faith, may be called a Reward, because they are consequent gifts on condition: But because the condition is so slender a thing as the thankful Acceptance of a free gift, Divines agree not of the fitness of the name [Reward and Merit] while they wholly agree about the thing. But our after-mercies and final Glory, being promised on the condition of such a faith as worketh by Love, obedience and improvement of Gods mercies in good works, and patience, ⟨p. 232⟩perseverance and conquest of the Flesh, the World and the Devil; therefore they have more unanimously agreed not only de re, but that the names of Reward and Rewardableness or Merit and Worthiness are here fit; but used only in the fore explained sense.
XIV. And though the Scripture oftest use the word [Greek or Hebrew] which most properly signifieth wages, which sounds as more than praemium a Reward, yet we wholly grant you that this is figuratively used, and that no man deserveth wages or any thing commutatively of God:
As if a Father hath many Sons, One living obediently, Others playing the prodigals, and upon his freely-offered pardon and grace one receiveth it thankfully, and the other refuseth it scornfully: Here both the obedient and the penitent son, have all upon free gift, as to Commutative Justice; but on various terms: And yet both merit in point of paternal Governing Justice; but very differently: One meriteth of strict Fatherly Justice; The other only of a forgiving Father, quite on other terms: And it is a Comparative Merit, by which he is fitter for pardon than the Sons that despise it, and spit in the Fathers face.
XI. God as a Benefactor and a Governour, giveth some benefits Antecedently to any duty of man: And these are never a Reward to us, (but of Christ perhaps, in some instances.) As Legislation, so the benefits of it, and that attend it, are before Reward and Judgement. But other benefits are given by God both as Benefactor and Legislator, upon condition of some duty of ours in the Antecedent gift, and so in the Judicial sentence and execution that duty is rendered as the reason of our actual Right to them: And these are a Reward.
XII. Our first Grace is no Reward, nor merited, because it antecedeth all conditional duty of ours.
XIII. Our first Reception of Right to Christ, Pardon and Life, being given on the condition of penitent Acceptance in faith, may be called a Reward, because they are consequent gifts on condition: But because the condition is so slender a thing as the thankful Acceptance of a free gift, Divines agree not of the fitness of the name [Reward and Merit] while they wholly agree about the thing. But our after-mercies and final Glory, being promised on the condition of such a faith as worketh by Love, obedience and improvement of Gods mercies in good works, and patience,
But every Scripture Metaphor hath its reason; And the reason of this is evident. Though God cannot be Profited, he can be Pleased. And his Will or Pleasure is the End of all his Government and Works: And he is Pleased most in that which doth the World, the Church and our selves the most good, for in that he is most glorified: Now he so maketh his Laws and Promises, as if our own and other mens good were his, and his Reward for our Pleasing by Order, Justice and Goodness, he calleth wages metaphorically, being instead of profiting him.
XV. By all which it is most obvious that we are not at all the less, but the more beholden to God, for the Merit or Rewardableness of our actions: For as all the Benefit is free Gift, so it is of his Grace that we do any thing that is good, and that he accepteth it as Rewardable: And if it be any honour to a man to be good rather than bad, and the Righteous be more excellent than his neighbour, it is an addition of mercy, that God will honour those that honour him, and commandeth others so to do, Psal. 15. 4.
XVI. And now the case is very plain, both that Reward and Rewardableness (called Merit) there is, and why it is and must be so.
1. How can God be a Governor, and have a Law, and be a Judge, and Righteous in all this, if faith and godliness be not Rewardable? It is the second Article in our faith, and next believing that There is a God, that He is the Rewarder of them that diligently seek him, Heb. 11. 6. And when you would extirpate all faith and godliness on pretence of crying down Merit, you may see what over-doing tends to.
2. The very nature of all Gods Laws and Promises evidently infer a Reward: Without it there were no such thing as Faith, Hope, Desire, Joy, Content, forsaking all: Psal. 19. 11. In keeping them there is great reward. 58. 11. Verily there is a Reward for the righteous.—
3. There is notoriously a Reward even in this life, Matth. 19. 29. Who would change the profit and pleasure of a holy life here, for that of the unholy?
4. Reward and Rewardableness are found in the very Law of Nature it self: In that we are made for God as our end, and it is God himself who is our Reward: And holiness hath a natural tendency to happiness, yea, is the beginning of it it self:
But every Scripture Metaphor hath its reason; And the reason of this is evident. Though God cannot be Profited, he can be Pleased. And his Will or Pleasure is the End of all his Government and Works: And he is Pleased most in that which doth the World, the Church and our selves the most good, for in that he is most glorified: Now he so maketh his Laws and Promises, as if our own and other mens good were his, and his Reward for our Pleasing by Order, Justice and Goodness, he calleth wages metaphorically, being instead of profiting him.
XV. By all which it is most obvious that we are not at all the less, but the more beholden to God, for the Merit or Rewardableness of our actions: For as all the Benefit is free Gift, so it is of his Grace that we do any thing that is good, and that he accepteth it as Rewardable: And if it be any honour to a man to be good rather than bad, and the Righteous be more excellent than his neighbour, it is an addition of mercy, that God will honour those that honour him, and commandeth others so to do,
And as God is said in Nature to make sin punishable, in that he hath so formed Nature, that sin shall bring suffering in and with it (as poison brings pain and death); so in Nature he hath made our duty and holiness Rewardable, in forming man so, that health, peace and happiness shall be in and after it. Prov. 9. 12. If thou be wise, thou art wise for thy self.
5. The Light of Nature teacheth Parents, Masters, Princes and all Governors to take Goodness to be Rewardable, and Crimes to be punishable: And nothing is more universally approved by the common notices of humane nature than Justice, or abhorred than Injustice. Nature saith as 2 Sam. 23. 31. He that ruleth over men must be just: And as Isa. 10. 1. Woe to them that decree unrighteous decrees: And as Prov. 17. 13. Whoso ⟨p. 233⟩rewardeth evil for good, evil shall not depart from his house: Conscience will rebuke him that rewardeth evil to him that deserved it not, Psal. 7. 4. The better any man is, the more he is for Justice, and abhorreth the unjust, (and Alexander Severus, and Antonine, and such Just Princes and Judges, are honoured by all Subjects and Historians.) And as all Power is of God, and Rulers are but his Officers, (Rom. 13. 4, 5, 6.) so their Righteous Government is but the inferior part of Gods own Government, (as the King governeth by his Judges and Justices): And therefore it is God that Rewardeth and Punisheth by them. And indeed by the same reason that men deny a Reward to duty (the faultiness being pardoned through Christ) they would infer, that there is no Punishment for sin: But God saith, Isa. 3. 10, 11. Say to the Righteous It shall be well with him, and say to the wicked It shall be ill with him. He will plentifully reward the proud doers, Psal. 31. 23. Yea, they reward evil to themselves,
And man is naturally a Lover of himself, and God will make him know that he hath no need of him, but it is himself that shall be the gainer if he obey, and the loser if he sin: even to Cain after his first sin God saith, If thou do well, shalt thou not be accepted? but if thou do evil, sin lieth at the door. Man is an Intellectual and free agent: and therefore God will set before him life and death, good and evil, Deut. 30. 15. and whether they will hear or not hear, he will send his word, Ezek. 2. 5. and they shall be told of such Motives as should suffice to prevail with men of reason.
8. Man hath many and great Temptations to overcome; And as they work morally toward his deceit and ruin, so God will suitably give him such Moral motives as are fittest to move him to resist them: And therefore he will offer man so full and sure and glorious a Reward, as is fit to disgrace all the offers of the Devil, and will make men know that his Rewards are such, as no pleasure or profit of sin should stand in any competition with. Yea, he himself who is God Allsufficient will be our exceeding great Reward, Gen. 15. 1. No wonder if Moses (like other believers) despised the honours of Pharaoh's Court, and chose rather to suffer affliction with the people of God than to enjoy the pleasures of sin for a season, because he had respect to the recompense of reward, Heb. 11. 25, 26. And Paul went towards death rejoicing in these hopes, that having fought a good fight, and finished his course, henceforth a Crown of Righteousness was laid up for him by God the Righteous Judge, 2 Tim. 4. 8. who is not unrighteous to forget his servants work and labour of Love. And all believers are therefore steadfast and unmoveable, always abounding in the work of the Lord, as knowing that their labour is not in vain in the Lord, 1 Cor. 15. 58. And they work out their salvation with fear and trembling, laying up a treasure in Heaven, Matth. 6. 20. and laying up a good foundation for the time to come, and pressing forward for the prize,
P. If this be Gods Word, and Christs own Law and Doctrine, then you infer that Christ taketh down himself, and his own righteousness, and sets up man and humane merits. But give me leave to tell you, that if you deny [the Reward of Evangelical duty, and the Rewardableness or Worthiness (or Merit) of such duty, as it is but our Merit or Worthiness of the free Gift of Christ and Life, given by Paternal Love and Justice, to believing Penitent accepters, according to the tenor of the Covenant of Grace,] 1. You do contradict so much of the most express Texts of Scripture, as alloweth us to suspect that really you believe not the Scripture to be true, or that it is not it, but your own contradicting fancy, that is the measure of your belief; and you may on such terms hold the vilest absurdities, even what you list, as in despite of Scripture, while you pretend that it is for you.
2. You will deny the honour of Gods Image on man, and the work of the Holy Ghost, and the design of Christ, who came to destroy the works of the Devil, and save his people from their sins, and purify to himself a peculiar people zealous of good works.
3. You will disgrace the Church of God, which Christ washeth and sanctifieth, and render it too like to the unsanctified world.
4. You will leave man no ground for true assurance of Justification or Salvation, while the difference between the worthy and unworthy is taken away.
5. You will harden the wicked in their false presumptuous hopes, and teach them to say, We are but unworthy, and so are all.
6. You will destroy the comfort of well doing, by denying the reward, and making it seem to be in vain.
7. Hereby you will take down all holy diligence in our Christian race and warfare, while you deny the prize, and recompense of reward, Heb. 11. 26. We run for an incorruptible Crown, 1 Cor. 9. 25. Phil. 3. 14.
8. You will strengthen all Temptations, while you take down that which should be set against them. See Luke 12. 4. Heb. 4. 1. & 12. 28, 29. Matth. 6. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 19, 20, &c.
Yea, you deny all Religion, all the Kingdom of Christ, all Law, all Judgement, all Retribution, Heaven and Hell, all the true difference between Good and Evil, Holiness and Sin, all Praise and Dispraise, while you deny the Reward and Rewardableness of holy obedience by the Paternal Government of the Law of Grace: and that glory, honour and peace is to every one that doth good, both Jew and Gentile, Rom. 2. 7, 10.
Lib. You would persuade us that holiness is good for nothing, if it be not Rewardable; as if you knew of no other use of it; so ignorant are natural men of the things of God which are spiritually discerned: I will tell you that which your carnal mind cannot understand; 1. Holiness, Faith, Love, Obedience, &c. are Gods free Gifts, excellent in themselves without a Reward: 2. They are Fruits of the Spirit, and marks and signs of our future felicity, though they deserve it not. 3. I told you that they are Rewards to Christ, and Gifts to us.
Lib. You would perswade us that holiness is good for nothing, if it be not Rewardable; as if you knew of no other use of it; so ignorant are natural men of the things of God which are spiritually dis•erned: I will tell you that which your carnal mind cannot understand; 1. Holiness, Faith, Love, Obedience, &c. are Gods free Gifts, excellent in themselves without a Reward: 2. They are Fruits of the Spirit, and marks and signs of our future felicity, though they deserve it not. 3. I told you that they are Rewards to Christ, and Gifts to us.
P. And tell me if you can, 1. Why God cannot Reward those acts which are done by his own Grace? Cannot God make the Promise of a Reward to be a fit Moral Means for his Spirit to work by? Nay, doth not the scope of the Scripture tell you that he doth so?
2. Is there ever the less worthiness in it, because God causeth it? Tell me without shifting, Is an honest man no more worthy of a Princes favour than a Thief? If you are no more worthy of liberty, and protection, and life, than Atheists and Rebels, why do you call men Persecutors for using you as if you were such? Why call you men Malignants for hating, deriding and opposing godly men, if they deserve no better than the worst?
P. Do you deny Rulers to be Gods Officers, and that they are to make this difference by his appointment, and therefore it is done by God? 3. But without shifting tell me, Doth not every good action or inclination deserve praise from God and man? Doth it not deserve to be accounted and called just as it is?
P. 1. Come on then, let Conscience be a while unmuzzled: Why do you so much praise those of your own Church or Opinion? Why praise you so much the Ministers and people that are of your way? Why do you make a difference between them and such as are against you? 2. Why do you so aggravate the sin of those that vilify, deride and persecute you? Why call you the Saints, the precious ones on earth, Gods treasure and peculiar people? 3. Why were you lately so angry with the Ecclesiastical Politician, the Debate-maker, and other such Books, which vilify men whom you and I have better thoughts of, if they deserve no more praise than the vilest men? 4. Why were you so angry lately when you heard of one that reproached you? and so pleased with one that proclaimed your wisdom and goodness, and took your part? 5. And if good actions deserve not praise from God himself, why doth he praise them so greatly in his Word? Why will he say before all the world, Well done good and faithful servant? &c. 1. Dare you call God Ignorant Legalist? or charge him with mistakes? 2. Doth not every thing and person deserve to be thought and called just as it is? Else lying or silence must be the virtue, and Truth the Vice. 3. Is there no more good in a Saint than in a Devil? If there be, doth it not deserve to be called just as it is? 4. May not he who deserveth Hell by the Law of Works or Innocency, be yet Morally fit for, that is, Worthy of Heaven, according to the Law of Grace, which pardoneth his sins, and freely giveth him Christ and Life? 5. Doth not God praise his Servants more than the Devil or wicked men do? And will you not please the Devil and Malignants, to tell them the contrary? And is it not the mark of a just man, that a vile person is contemned in his eyes, but he honoureth them that fear the Lord, Psal. 15. 4. Doth not God himself praise Abel, Enoch, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Joshua, David, Job, &c. Wrangle not against the unresistible Light. Our light must so shine before men, that they may see our good works, and glorify our heavenly Father, Matth. 5. 16. Christ will come at last to be glorified in his Saints, and admired in all them that do believe, because the Gospel was believed by them, 2 Thess. 1. 10, 11. No man hath seen God at any time in his Essence; ⟨p. 234⟩[…] ⟨p. 235⟩
in which it is that his glory shineth: And to say that Gods Works and holy Image are not worthy (or Morally fit) to be praised, is to deny God his praise and glory on earth: He that despiseth you, despiseth me (saith Christ) and consequently him that sent me, Luke 10. 10.
Lib. Faith, Love, Holiness, Obedience, Patience are worthy that God should be praised for them, but not Man: for they are worthy as Gods works, but not as ours.
P. 1. They are none of our works as the chief agents, but only second causes under God: And are not second causes to be praised in their places and degree? Will you not praise Sun and Moon and Stars, and all Gods works, that he may be praised for them? Do you not praise a good Servant, a good Horse or Dog, a good House or Land? yea, and your Friend or Teacher? Do you not praise your own party, when you say that they are wiser and better than others?
2. Believe and regard the Word of God. Do none of these Texts following speak of Praise as due to men, in subordination to God? Deut. 26. 18, 19. The Lord hath avouched thee this day to be his peculiar people, and to make thee high above all Nations, in Praise, and in Name, and in Honour, and that thou mayest be an holy people to the Lord thy God. Prov. 27. 21. As is the fining pot for Silver, and the furnace for Gold, so is a man to his praise. Isa. 62. 7. Give him no rest till he make Jerusalem a praise in the earth. Zeph. 3. 19, 20. I will get them praise in every land, &c. I will make you a name and a praise among all people of the earth. Rom. 2. 29. Whose praise is not of men, but of God. John▪ 12. 43. They loved the praise of men more than the praise of God. 1 Cor. 4. 5. Then shall every man have praise of God. 2 Cor. 8. 18. The brother whose praise is in the Gospel, &c. Phil. 4. 8. If there be any praise, think of these things. 1 Pet. 2. 14. Governors are sent by him for the praise of them that do well. See Prov. 27. 2. & 28. 4
P. 1. Have I told you that he himself calleth his servants worthy? and will you contradict Gods Word? 2. Dare you yet deny any thing to be worthy to be called what it indeed is? Is not a Christian worthy to be called a Christian? and a sober man to be called a sober man, and an honest man to be called an honest man? Must humility make us liars? Tell me, Are you worthy your self to be accounted and called an Infidel, a Heathen, an Apostate, a Heretic, a wicked ungodly man, that never repented, nor did good?
P. 1. Have I told you that he himself calleth his servants worthy? and will you contradict Gods Word? 2. Dare you yet deny any thing to be worthy to be called what it indeed is? Is not a Christian worthy to be called a Christian? and a sober man to be called a sober man, and an honest man to be called an honest man? Must humility make us lyars? Tell me, Are you worthy your self to be accounted and called an Infidel, a Heathen, an Apostate, a Heretick, a wicked ungodly man, that never repented, nor did good?
P. Must God and man account you such as you are not fit or worthy to be accounted? And will you go on to accuse and contradict Gods Word? Your fancy hath got some harsh conceit of the sense of the word [Worthy] and that cometh still into your mind, as if it meant a worthiness which supposed not that all that we have is of mercy and grace: when the Scripture meaneth no such worthiness, but such as is that of a loving, dutiful, thankful Child, of the inheritance; A moral fitness.
Lib. Well, suppose that our actions and we are worthy of Praise, that is, to be called as they are; yet they are worthy also of dispraise, that is, to be accounted as menstruous rags, defiled with sin, and deserving Hell; and is not this a pitiful praise?
Lib. Well, suppose that our actions and we are worthy of Praise, that is, to be called as they are; yet they are worthy also of dispraise, that is, to be accounted as menstruous rags, defiled with sin, and deserving Hell; and is not this a pittiful praise?
P. Did you ever hear us deny any of this? Why talk you of that which we are all agreed in? But 1. It is not holiness, but the faulty imperfections of it, and the sin that is contrary to it, which deserveth Hell. 2. And the faults of sincere believers deserve not Hell according to the Law of Grace, by which we are to be judged, so as to be liable to it, but only so as to be accounted condemnable, had we not been pardoned.
P. Did you ever hear us deny any of this? Why talk you of that which we are all agreed in? But 1. It is not holiness, but the faulty imperfections of it, and the sin that is contrary to it, which deserveth Hell. 2. And the faults of sincere believers deserve not Hell according to the Law of Grace, by which we are to be judged, so as to be lyable to it, but only so as to be accounted condemnable, had we not been pardoned.
P. All these words your obstinacy hath put me to use, to convince you that Faith and Holiness is worthy of any thing at all, and that the word [Worthy] which God himself useth of them, is not abused by God, nor false. But what it is that God will account the righteous worthy of, the Scripture must determine; where I have showed you before that the words are plain. They are counted worthy of God, 1 Thess. 2. 12. and of his Kingdom, 2 Thess. 1. 5. Worthy to obtain that world, and the resurrection, Luke 20. 35. They shall walk with Christ in white, for they are worthy.
P. All these words your obstinacy hath put me to use, to convince you that Faith and Holiness is worthy of any thing at all, and that the word [Worthy] which God himself useth of them, is not abused by God, nor false. But what it is that God will account the righteous worthy of, the Scripture must determine; where I have shewed you before that the words are plain. They are counted worthy of God, 1 Thess. 2. 12. and of his Kingdom, 2 Thess. 1. 5. Worthy to obtain that world, and the resurrection, Luke 20. 35. They shall walk with Christ in white, for they are worthy.
P. To end this tedious talk with one that seemeth loth to understand, say Yea or Nay to these two questions. 1. Do you allow of the use of the word [Worthy]?
P. 2. Do you deny it to be true in the sense I have opened, that is, that we have that worthiness which is nothing but a Moral aptitude for that promised Reward, which as to the worth of it is but Gods free gift, merited for us by Christ, and is only a Fathers Reward as to the ordering of it as our Governor, even a Reward of grateful Children.
P. 2. Do you deny it to be true in the sense I have opened, that is, that we have that worthiness which is nothing but a Moral aptitude for that promised Reward, which as to the worth of it is but Gods free gift, merited for us by Christ, and is only a Fathers Reward as to the ordering of it as our Governour, even a Reward of grateful Children.
P. Then you grant both Name and Thing: And are not you ashamed then to have so long traduced and reviled such as hold and say but that which you are forced to justify? and to make poor souls believe that works are cried up, and Christ is injured, and mens salvation hazarded by it, when yet you confess that all is true, in word and sense.
P. Then you grant both Name and Thing: And are not you ashamed then to have so long traduced and reviled such as hold and say but that which you are forced to justifie? and to make poor souls believe that works are cryed up, and Christ is injured, and mens salvation hazarded by it, when yet you confess that all is true, in word and sense.
P. 1. But is that a good reason for you to revile those that use them in the Scripture sense? 2. And if you will forsake Scripture words as oft as men misuse them, it will be in the power of any Heretics to drive you from all Scripture phrase, by abusing all. 3. And how can you more effectually promote Popery, than by forsaking Scripture language, and leaving it to their possession and use? Will not men think then, that the Scripture sense is liker to be with them, than with you? Were it not better for you to hold to the Word of God, and only detect and disclaim mens ill expositions of it?
P. 1. But is that a good reason for you to revile those that use them in the Scripture sense? 2. And if you will forsake Scripture words as oft as men misuse them, it will be in the power of any Hereticks to drive you from all Scripture phrase, by abusing all. 3. And how can you more effectually promote Popery, than by forsaking Scripture language, and leaving it to their possession and use? Will not men think then, that the Scripture sense is liker to be with them, than with you? Were it not better for you to hold to the Word of God, and only detect and disclaim mens ill expositions of it?
CHAP. III. Whether our own Righteousness be any way necessary and conducible to our Justification before God? Or Whether we are any way justified by it? and how far?
••
•
⟨p. 231⟩
which is either 1. The Law of Innocency, or 2. The Law of Grace: And no man since the fall can Merit of God according to the Justice of the Law of Innocency, which exacteth personal perfection.
VIII. The Law of Grace is in its first notion, a free gift of Christ, Pardon and Right to Life Eternal by Adoption, to all that will Accept it believingly as it is offered, that is, according to the nature of the Gift. And this Gift or Conditional promise and pardon no man can merit: For Christs perfect Righteousness and Sacrifice hath already merited it for us; and so hath left us no such work to do: Nor is there the least place for any humane Merit or Rewardableness from God, but on supposition of 1. Christs Merits and Meritorious Righteousness, 2. And of this free gift or Act of Oblivion and Life, already made to us without our desert.
IX. But yet this is not a meer Gift, but also a true Law: God is still our God and Governour, and Christ is Lord of all, Rom. 14. 9. He that is a King and Ruler hath his Laws and Judgement: That which is a Gift in the first respect, hath 1. Its condition, 2. Many commanded duties, and so is a Law of Grace in other respects. And it is only in respect to this Law of Grace that man is Rewardable, or can Merit.
X. The Gift is from God as Benefactor, considered as Good and in it self. But it is from God as Sapiential Rector quoad ordin•m conferendi, as to the Order and Reason why one man rather than another receiveth it. So that we Merit not of God as Benefactor nor as Rector by the Law of Innocency or Works; nor yet as to the Value or Goodness of the Benefit, which is a free Gift: But only of God as Rector by the Law of Grace, which regulateth the Reception of his free gifts, merited by the perfect Righteousness of Christ, and so only as to the Order and Reason why one more than another receiveth that free gift.
⟨p. 232⟩
perseverance and conquest of the Flesh, the World and the Devil; therefore they have more unanimously agreed not only de re, but that the names of Reward and Rewardableness or Merit and Worthiness are here fit; but used only in the fore explained sense.
XIV. And though the Scripture oftest use the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 which most properly signifieth wages, which sounds as more than praemium a Reward, yet we wholly grant you that this is figuratively used, and that no man deserveth wages or any thing commutatively of God:
.
XVI. And now the case is very plain, both that Reward and Rewardableness (called Merit) there is, and why it is and must be so.
1. How can God be a Governour, and have a Law, and be a Judge, and Righteous in all this, if faith and godliness be not Rewardable? It is the second Article in our faith, and next believing that There is a God, that He is the Rewarder of them that diligently seek him,
. And when you would extirpate all faith and godliness on pretence of crying down Merit, you may see what over-doing tends to.
2. The very nature of all Gods Laws and Promises evidently inferr a Reward: Without it there were no such thing as Faith, Hope, Desire, Joy, Content, forsaking all:
. Who would change the profit and pleasure of a holy life here, for that of the unholy?
4. Reward and Rewardableness are found in the very Law of Nature it self: In that we are made for God as our end, and it is God himself who is our Reward: And holiness hath a natural tendency to happiness, yea, is the beginning of it it self:
Isa. 3. 9
.
6. Holiness is Gods Image, and the product of the Holy Ghost; and the Devil and Malignants labour to dishonour it: And contrarily God honoureth it, and by his Rewards will honour it openly before the world,
.
7. God will Govern man according to mans nature and capacity; else what need of Scripture, Ministry, &c.
And as God is said in Nature to make sin punishable, in that he hath so formed Nature, that sin shall bring suffering in and with it (as poyson brings pain and death); so in Nature he hath made our duty and holiness Rewardable, in forming man so, that health, peace and happiness shall be in and after it. Prov. 9. 12. If thou be wise, thou art wise for thy self.
5. The Light of Nature teacheth Parents, Masters, Princes and all Governours to take Goodness to be Rewardable, and Crimes to be punishable: And nothing is more universally approved by the common notices of humane nature than Justice, or abhorred than Injustice. Nature saith as 2 Sam. 23. 31. He that ruleth over men must be just: And as Isa. 10. 1. Wo to them that decree unrighteous decrees: And as Prov. 17. 13. Whoso ⟨p. 233⟩rewardeth evil for good, evil shall not depart from his house: Conscience will rebuke him that rewardeth evil to him that deserved it not, Psal. 7. 4. The better any man is, the more he is for Justice, and abhorreth the unjust, (and Alexander Severus, and Antonine, and such Just Princes and Judges, are honoured by all Subjects and Historians.) And as all Power is of God, and Rulers are but his Officers, (Rom. 13. 4, 5, 6.) so their Righteous Government is but the inferiour part of Gods own Government, (as the King governeth by his Judges and Justices): And therefore it is God that Rewardeth and Punisheth by them. And indeed by the same reason that men deny a Reward to duty (the faultiness being pardoned through Christ) they would inferr, that there is no Punishment for sin: But God saith, Isa. 3. 10, 11. Say to the Righteous It shall be well with him, and say to the wicked It shall be ill with him. He will plentifully reward the proud doers, Psal. 31. 23. Yea, they reward evil to themselves, Isa. 3. 9.
6. Holiness is Gods Image, and the product of the Holy Ghost; and the Devil and Malignants labour to dishonour it: And contrarily God honoureth it, and by his Rewards will honour it openly before the world, Matth. 6. 4, 6. And Christ will come in glory to be glorified in his Saints, and admired in all them that believe, even because they have believed, 2 Thess. 1. 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11.
7. God will Govern man according to mans nature and capacity; else what need of Scripture, Ministry, &c.
And man is naturally a Lover of himself, and God will make him know that he hath no need of him, but it is himself that shall be the gainer if he obey, and the loser if he sin: even to Cain after his first sin God saith, If thou do well, shalt thou not be accepted? but if thou do evil, sin lyeth at the door. Man is an Intellectual and free agent: and therefore God will set before him life and death, good and evil, Deut. 30. 15. and whether they will hear or not hear, he will send his word, Ezek. 2. 5. and they shall be told of such Motives as should suffice to prevail with men of reason.
8. Man hath many and great Temptations to overcome; And as they work morally toward his deceit and ruine, so God will suitably give him such Moral motives as are fittest to move him to resist them: And therefore he will offer man so full and sure and glorious a Reward, as is fit to disgrace all the offers of the Devil, and will make men know that his Rewards are such, as no pleasure or profit of sin should stand in any competition with. Yea, he himself who is God Allsufficient will be our exceeding great Reward, Gen. 15. 1. No wonder if Moses (like other believers) despised the honours of Pharaoh's Court, and chose rather to suffer affliction with the people of God than to enjoy the pleasures of sin for a season, because he had respect to the recompence of reward, Heb. 11. 25, 26. And Paul went towards death rejoycing in these hopes, that having fought a good fight, and finished his course, henceforth a Crown of Righteousness was laid up for him by God the Righteous Judge, 2 Tim. 4. 8. who is not unrighteous to forget his servants work and labour of Love. And all believers are therefore stedfast and unmoveable, alwayes abounding in the work of the Lord, as knowing that their labour is not in vain in the Lord, 1 Cor. 15. 58. And they work out their salvation with fear and trembling, laying up a treasure in Heaven, Matth. 6. 20. and laying up a good foundation for the time to come, and pressing forward for the prize, Phil. 3. 8, 9. and laying hold upon eternal life.
.
9. You will disgrace the Word and Ministry and all Means, if after all we are never the more accepted.
10. In a word, you deny Gods Government, in denying his Governing Justice and Judgements, and that is to deny God to be our God:
P. If this be Gods Word, and Christs own Law and Doctrine, then you inferr that Christ taketh down himself, and his own righteousness, and sets up man and humane merits. But give me leave to tell you, that if you deny [the Reward of Evangelical duty, and the Rewardableness or Worthiness (or Merit) of such duty, as it is but our Merit or Worthiness of the free Gift of Christ and Life, given by Paternal Love and Justice, to believing Penitent accepters, according to the tenour of the Covenant of Grace,] 1. You do contradict so much of the most express Texts of Scripture, as alloweth us to suspect that really you believe not the Scripture to be true, or that it is not it, but your own contradicting fancy, that is the measure of your belief; and you may on such terms hold the vilest absurdities, even what you list, as in despight of Scripture, while you pretend that it is for you.
2. You will deny the honour of Gods Image on man, and the work of the Holy Ghost, and the design of Christ, who came to destroy the works of the Devil, and save his people from their sins, and purifie to himself a peculiar people zealous of good works.
3. You will disgrace the Church of God, which Christ washeth and sanctifieth, and render it too like to the unsanctified world.
4. You will leave man no ground for true assurance of Justification or Salvation, while the difference between the worthy and unworthy is taken away.
5. You will harden the wicked in their false presumptuous hopes, and teach them to say, We are but unworthy, and so are all.
6. You will destroy the comfort of well doing, by denying the reward, and making it seem to be in vain.
7. Hereby you will take down all holy diligence in our Christian race and warfare, while you deny the prize, and recompence of reward, Heb. 11. 26. We run for an incorruptible Crown, 1 Cor. 9. 25. Phil. 3. 14.
8. You will strengthen all Temptations, while you take down that which should be set against them. See Luke 12. 4. Heb. 4. 1. & 12. 28, 29. Matth. 6. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 19, 20, &c. Matth. 5. 10, 11, 12.
9. You will disgrace the Word and Ministry and all Means, if after all we are never the more accepted.
10. In a word, you deny Gods Government, in denying his Governing Justice and Judgements, and that is to deny God to be our God:
[…]
⟨p. 236⟩
but we see him here in a glass; and that is, in his Works and Image;
P. 1. Come on then, let Conscience be a while unmuzzled: Why do you so much praise those of your own Church or Opinion? Why praise you so much the Ministers and people that are of your way? Why do you make a difference between them and such as are against you? 2. Why do you so aggravate the sin of those that vilifie, deride and persecute you? Why call you the Saints, the precious ones on earth, Gods treasure and peculiar people? 3. Why were you lately so angry with the Ecclesiastical Politician, the Debate-maker, and other such Books, which vilifie men whom you and I have better thoughts of, if they deserve no more praise than the vilest men? 4. Why were you so angry lately when you heard of one that reproached you? and so pleased with one that proclaimed your wisdom and goodness, and took your part? 5. And if good actions deserve not praise from God himself, why doth he praise them so greatly in his Word? Why will he say before all the world, Well done good and faithful servant? &c. 1. Dare you call God Ignorant Legalist? or charge him with mistakes? 2. Doth not every thing and person deserve to be thought and called just as it is? Else lying or silence must be the virtue, and Truth the Vice. 3. Is there no more good in a Saint than in a Devil? If there be, doth it not deserve to be called just as it is? 4. May not he who deserveth Hell by the Law of Works or Innocency, be yet Morally fit for, that is, Worthy of Heaven, according to the Law of Grace, which pardoneth his sins, and freely giveth him Christ and Life? 5. Doth not God praise his Servants more than the Devil or wicked men do? And will you not please the Devil and Malignants, to tell them the contrary? And is it not the mark of a just man, that a vile person is contemned in his eyes, but he honoureth them that fear the Lord, Psal. 15. 4. Doth not God himself praise Abel, Enoch, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Joshua, David, Job, &c. Wrangle not against the unresistible Light. Our light must so shine before men, that they may see our good works, and glorifie our heavenly Father, Matth. 5. 16. Christ will come at last to be glorified in his Saints, and admired in all them that do believe, because the Gospel was believed by them, 2 Thess. 1. 10, 11. No man hath seen God at any time in his Essence; ⟨p. 234⟩〈…〉⟨p. 235⟩〈…〉⟨p. 236⟩but we see him here in a glass; and that is, in his Works and Image;
. They that by well doing, seek for glory, and honour, and immortality, eternal life: Glory, honour and peace to every man that worketh good. & 9. 21. & 12. 10. & 13. 7.
. Do you believe and regard no one of all these words of God?
P. 1. They are none of our works as the chief agents, but only second causes under God: And are not second causes to be praised in their places and degree? Will you not praise Sun and Moon and Stars, and all Gods works, that he may be praised for them? Do you not praise a good Servant, a good Horse or Dog, a good House or Land? yea, and your Friend or Teacher? Do you not praise your own party, when you say that they are wiser and better than others?
2. Believe and regard the Word of God. Do none of these Texts following speak of Praise as due to men, in subordination to God? Deut. 26. 18, 19. The Lord hath avouched thee this day to be his peculiar people, and to make thee high above all Nations, in Praise, and in Name, and in Honour, and that thou maist be an holy people to the Lord thy God. Prov. 27. 21. As is the fining pot for Silver, and the furnace for Gold, so is a man to his praise. Isa. 62. 7. Give him no rest till he make Jerusalem a praise in the earth. Zeph. 3. 19, 20. I will get them praise in every land, &c. I will make you a name and a praise among all people of the earth. Rom. 2. 29. Whose praise is not of men, but of God. John▪ 12. 43. They loved the praise of men more than the praise of God. 1 Cor. 4. 5. Then shall every man have praise of God. 2 Cor. 8. 18. The brother whose praise is in the Gospel, &c. Phil. 4. 8. If there be any praise, think of these things. 1 Pet. 2. 14. Governours are sent by him for the praise of them that do well. See Prov. 27. 2. & 28. 4. & 31. 30, 31. 1 Cor. 11. 2. Prov. 29. 23. Honour shall uphold the humble in spirit. & 21. 21. He findeth life, righteousness and honour. Psal. 149. 4. This honour have all his Saints. Prov. 3. 16. & 4. 8. & 8. 18. & 15. 33. & 20. 3. & 22. 4. Eccles. 10. 1. John 5. 44. Rom. 2. 7, 10. They that by well doing, seek for glory, and honour, and immortality, eternal life: Glory, honour and peace to every man that worketh good. & 9. 21. & 12. 10. & 13. 7. 1 Tim. 5. 17. The Elders that rule well are accounted worthy of double honour. & 1 Tim. 6. 1. 1 Sam. 2. 30. Them that honour me, I will honour. Psal. 91. 15. John 12. 26. If any man serve me, him will my Father honour. 1 Pet. 2. 17. Prov. 13. 18. Do you believe and regard no one of all these words of God?