Chapter 2
pp. 223–237118 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 223–237118 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Lib. What the Papists or you mean, you best know your selves; but I know what you say: And you both talk like the ignorant enemies of Grace.
P. Do you include the Jansenists who say that all Christs Grace now is nothing but his irresistible efficient operation of Holy Love in the soul: and that God moveth us to it necessarily or insuperably? and that he now giveth no Grace merely sufficient, which is not effectual? or merely effectual to make us Able, but also to make us Act? and that now he leaveth nothing to our Free-will in Christs gracious operations, but giveth in act all the Will and all the merit that men have? and that Fear and obedience of a Law written, is our own Legal Righteousness, (though it respect the new Law;) but Christs Righteousness which he giveth us as distinct from our Legal Righteousness, is only his Spirit, or Love put into the heart?
P. Do you include the Jansenists who say that all Christs Grace now is nothing but his irrestible efficient operation of Holy Love in the soul: and that God moveth us to it necessarily or insuperably? and that he now giveth no Grace meerly sufficient, which is not effectual? or meerly effectual to make us Able, but also to make us Act? and that now he leaveth nothing to our Free-will in Christs gracious operations, but giveth in act all the Will and all the merit that men have? and that Fear and obedience of a Law written, is our own Legal Righteousness, (though it respect the new Law;) but Christs Righteousness which he giveth us as distinct from our Legal Righteousness, is only his Spirit, or Love put into the heart?
Lib. I do not believe that any Papist is so much for free grace.
P. But if you deny it, and the book be opened, and it found there written, is it nothing to you to be found in falsehood?
P. But if you deny it, and the book be opened, and it found there written, is it nothing to you to be found in falshood?
Lib. But I say not as Jansenius, that it is the Law written in us, but Christs Righteousness imputed to us, which is our Righteousness.
P. Did you not even now confess an Inherent Righteousness?
Lib. Yes; but not to our Justification.
P. Of that more anon: By Justification, they mean Making us holy.
Lib. But Jansenius is not a common Papist: why tell you me of him?
P. My business here is not to justify the Papists; but to understand your mind: I do not think you know what the Papists hold in it.
P. My business here is not to justifie the Papists; but to understand your mind: I do not think you know what the Papists hold in it.
Lib. I am not ashamed to be a stranger to their Books: But I will bring one when you will, that shall open the abomination of their doctrine of merit; Till then it's you to whom I speak.
P. Content: we will make another days work of that. Tell me then whether it be Names or Things that you make so much ado about?
P. Content: we will make another dayes work of that. Tell me then whether it be Names or Things that you make so much ado about?
Lib. Both: we like not ill names: and worse false doctrine.
P. What are the Names that displease you? Is Reward or Rewardableness one?
Lib. No: if you will understand them well: For they are Scripture words.
P. Is worthiness one of them?
Lib. Yes; if you will say that we are worthy of the Reward or of salvation.
P. Do you not know that the Scripture usually so speaketh? Rev. 3. 4. They shall walk with me in white; for they are worthy: 2 Thes. 1. 5, 11. Worthy of the Kingdom of God: 1 Thes. 2. 12. Walk worthy of God: ⟨p. 228⟩Luke 20. 35. That are accounted worthy to obtain that world—21. 36. That you may be counted worthy to scape all these things, and to stand, &c. Matth. 10. 11. Enquire who in it is worthy—13. If the house be worthy, let your peace remain. If it be not worthy, let your peace return—37. He that loveth Father or Mother more than me, is not worthy of me. Matth. 22. 8. They which were bidden were not worthy. Acts 13. 46. Ye judge your selves unworthy of everlasting life—Is not this Scripture?
Lib. By [Worthy] the Text meaneth not merit, but fitness to receive.
P. Our question is not now of the Meaning, but the Name you know.
Lib. I am not against the Scripture names, if well understood.
P. Merit is a name I perceive that you are against. And we make so small a matter of words, that you shall choose any other name of the same signification, and we will forbear this, rather than offend you: But yet tell me, Q. 1. What if the words [Greek or Hebrew] and [Greek or Hebrew] were translated Deserving and Merit, would it not be as true a translation as Worthy and Worthiness, when it is the very same thing that is meant? Nay, when Merit of Condignity is the highest kind, which the Papists themselves mention and are reproved for, do you not hereby imply that Condignity is a bigger word than bare Merit? Quest. 2. And I ask you, Whether all the ancient Teachers of the Churches since the Apostles, whose Writings are come down to us, do not familiarly apply these names [Greek or Hebrew] and Meritum to believers? And if you persuade men that all these Teachers and Churches were Papists, you will persuade most that believe you to be Papists too. But such is the success of over-doing! Quest. 3. And I would know, Whether in common speech, Reward and Merit or Desert be not Relatives, as Master and Servant, Husband and Wife are? Is there any Reward which is not Meriti Praemium, the Reward of Merit? What mean you your self else by the word Reward?
P. Merit is a name I perceive that you are against. And we make so small a matter of words, that you shall choose any other name of the same signification, and we will forbear this, rather than offend you: But yet tell me, Q. 1. What if the words 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 were translated Deserving and Merit, would it not be as true a translation as Worthy and Worthiness, when it is the very same thing that is meant? Nay, when Merit of Condignity is the highest kind, which the Papists themselves mention and are reproved for, do you not hereby imply that Condignity is a bigger word than bare Merit? Quest. 2. And I ask you, Whether all the antient Teachers of the Churches since the Apostles, whose Writings are come down to us, do not familiarly apply these names 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and Meritum to believers? And if you perswade men that all these Teachers and Churches were Papists, you will perswade most that believe you to be Papists too. But such is the success of over-doing! Quest. 3. And I would know, Whether in common speech, Reward and Merit or Desert be not Relatives, as Master and Servant, Husband and Wife are? Is there any Reward which is not Meriti Praemium, the Reward of Merit? What mean you your self else by the word Reward?
Lib. I mean Gods free Gift without respect to merit or desert.
P. Doth not the usage of the World distinguish between a mere Gift and a Reward? What if you give money to the next man you meet without respect to any thing in him, will you call it a Reward? Review all the Scripture Texts that speak of a Reward, and see whether they have no relation to any foregoing act in man. God gave Christ himself to the lapsed world: Was this Gift of Christ a Reward? God gave some Prophets, some Apostles, &c. and giveth the Gospel to Infidel Nations: Is this Gift a Reward? or ever so called? Your humane nature is Gods Gift: but is it a Reward? Nay, will you say, that the first Grace is a Reward; which is said to be Pelagianism?
P. Doth not the usage of the World distinguish between a meer Gift and a Reward? What if you give money to the next man you meet without respect to any thing in him, will you call it a Reward? Review all the Scripture Texts that speak of a Reward, and see whether they have no relation to any foregoing act in man. God gave Christ himself to the lapsed world: Was this Gift of Christ a Reward? God gave some Prophets, some Apostles, &c. and giveth the Gospel to Infidel Nations: Is this Gift a Reward? or ever so called? Your humane nature is Gods Gift: but is it a Reward? Nay, will you say, that the first Grace is a Reward; which is said to be Pelagianism?
Lib. Well: but Rewards are Gods second Gifts as they follow the former, without respect to Worthiness or Merit.
P. That cannot be neither: If God first Give the world a Saviour, and then give them the Covenant of Grace and Pardon through him, is this a Reward? If Christ first heal the sick man, and then cause him to walk, or if Peter and John first heal the lame man, and then cause him joyfully to leap, &c. is the second a Reward? If an Infidels Life be first preserved, and then the Gospel given him, is this a Reward?
Lib. No: but a Reward supposeth only our Fitness to receive a free gift, which is called our worthiness, and not our Merit.
P. Do you mean our Natural fitness or our Moral? A man is Naturally fit for his food, when he is hungry: Will you say therefore that his food is his Reward for being hungry?
Lib. Well; Let it be then his Moral, or rather his Spiritual fitness.
P. Your explications are but darkening: Spiritual is either Natural or Moral as well as corporal. The soul as a Spirit is in its nature fit to understand common things here in the body; Is this understanding its Reward for being a Spirit? But Heaven is a Reward.
P. Your explications are but darkning: Spiritual is either Natural or Moral as well as corporal. The soul as a Spirit is in its nature fit to understand common things here in the body; Is this understanding its Reward for being a Spirit? But Heaven is a Reward.
Lib. Well: Call it a Moral fitness if you will: but what is that to Merit?
P. It is so much to it, as to tell the world that such as you, do revile others for holding the same which you are forced to profess your self, and wrangle about mere words, and know it not. For by [Merit] is meant nothing else but [A moral aptitude for Reward] or that Rewardableness which consisteth in Moral Good or Evil, as freely done and had, and so acceptable to God as our Governor. But tell me next what word will you choose to serve instead of Merit, that we may agree in it?
P. It is so much to it, as to tell the world that such as you, do revile others for holding the same which you are forced to profess your self, and wrangle about meer words, and know it not. For by [Merit] is meant nothing else but [A moral aptitude for Reward] or that Rewardableness which consisteth in Moral Good or Evil, as freely done and had, and so acceptable to God as our Governour. But tell me next what word will you choose to serve instead of Merit, that we may agree in it?
Lib. I know not what words to use that please you, when we are not agreed about the thing signified: I hold not any Reward in proper sense, but only free gift, and therefore how can I tell you what word to use instead of merit? I think the word Reward is used but figuratively.
P. Christ saith, [Matth. 6. 4, 6. Your Father which seeth in secret shall Reward you openly: Col. 3. 24. Ye shall receive the reward of the inheritance: Heb. 10. 35. Cast not away your confidence which hath great recompense of reward: Heb. 11. 26. He had respect to the recompense of reward: v. 6. He that cometh to God must believe that God is, and that he is the rewarder of them that diligently seek him: Mat. 16. 27. He shall reward every man according to his works.] I ask you again, What is meant here by Rewarding?
P. Christ saith, [Matth. 6. 4, 6. Your Father which seeth in secret shall Reward you openly: Col. 3. 24. Ye shall receive the reward of the inheritance: Heb. 10. 35. Cast not away your confidence which hath great recompence of reward: Heb. 11. 26. He had respect to the recompence of reward: v. 6. He that cometh to God must believe that God is, and that he is the rewarder of them that diligently seek him: Mat. 16. 27. He shall reward every man according to his works.] I ask you again, What is meant here by Rewarding?
Lib. I tell you again, the meaning is, that as men show their liking of a thing that pleaseth them, by a proper Reward, so God showeth his liking of our duty by a free gift of some greater good, which therefore after the manner of men he calleth a Reward.
Lib. I tell you again, the meaning is, that as men shew their liking of a thing that pleaseth them, by a proper Reward, so God sheweth his liking of our duty by a free gift of some greater good, which therefore after the manner of men he calleth a Reward.
P. If it be a Metaphor, I ask you but the Meaning and Reason of the name. If it be because it followeth our duty, then every gift that followeth our duty, is a reward, without any further respect to that duty, but the order of time: but that you denied before; Else Christs Incarnation, and the Apostles, and the Gospel, and all that ever followeth our duty, should be a Reward. But if you mean, that it is called a Reward, as it is a sign of Gods approbation of our duty only, then if God should tell men that he Approveth of their duty, it would be a reward, though he immediately annihilate them, or should never do them any good: which I think you will not say. If you say, that all three must concur, viz. that it be 1. A Benefit or Gift, 2. Following duty, 3. Signifying an Approbation of it, you come almost up to all that is asserted by them that you quarrel with: If God should by some benefit to one man signify that he approved the duty of another, or of a thousand more, and should annihilate them all; this were no reward to them. Therefore when you have talked all that you can devise to say, you must say, that there is some Fitness in the duty for that approbation and benefit, and that the Relation of the Gift to that Fitness, is it that denominateth it a Reward: And that though there be no Cause in man of any Acts of God ex parte agentis, yet are there Causes in man of our Reception and of the effects, ex ⟨p. 230⟩parte recipientis; And so that mans Rewardable duties are his Moral aptitude, cause or condition, why he rather than one that doth otherwise receiveth that Gift, which is called the Reward. But we are gone from our question de nomine, and have already dispatched also that de re: Have you any more to say of any Matter besides words (in which you confess we speak as the Scripture doth) in which we differ?
P. If it be a Metaphor, I ask you but the Meaning and Reason of the name. If it be because it followeth our duty, then every gift that followeth our duty, is a reward, without any further respect to that duty, but the order of time: but that you denyed before; Else Christs Incarnation, and the Apostles, and the Gospel, and all that ever followeth our duty, should be a Reward. But if you mean, that it is called a Reward, as it is a sign of Gods approbation of our duty only, then if God should tell men that he Approveth of their duty, it would be a reward, though he immediately annihilate them, or should never do them any good: which I think you will not say. If you say, that all three must concurr, viz. that it be 1. A Benefit or Gift, 2. Following duty, 3. Signifying an Approbation of it, you come almost up to all that is asserted by them that you quarrell with: If God should by some benefit to one man signifie that he approved the duty of another, or of a thousand more, and should annihilate them all; this were no reward to them. Therefore when you have talkt all that you can devise to say, you must say, that there is some Fitness in the duty for that approbation and benefit, and that the Relation of the Gift to that Fitness, is it that denominateth it a Reward: And that though there be no Cause in man of any Acts of God ex parte agentis, yet are there Causes in man of our Reception and of the effects, ex ⟨p. 230⟩parte recipientis; And so that mans Rewardable duties are his Moral aptitude, cause or condition, why he rather than one that doth otherwise receiveth that Gift, which is called the Reward. But we are gone from our question de nomine, and have already dispatched also that de re: Have you any more to say of any Matter besides words (in which you confess we speak as the Scripture doth) in which we differ?
Lib. Seeing you like not my explications, tell me fully what you hold your selves, and then I shall better know whether we differ in sense or words only.