The fourth Argument.
pp. 235–25150 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Secondly, Observe also how uncertain they were, when all was done; what they speak rightly concerning God, or the life to come in one breath, they are ready to unsay it again in another, as if their speeches had fallen from them against their wills, or as Caiaphas his confession of Christ. They raise their Conclusions from such uncertain Premises, that the Conclusions also must needs be uncertain.
Secondly, Observe also how uncertain they were, when all was done; what they speak rightly concerning God, or the life to come in one breath, they are ready to unsay it again in another, as if their speeches had faln from them against their wils, or as Caiphas his confession of Christ. They raise their Conclusions from such uncertain Premises, that the Conclusions also must needs be uncertain.
Thirdly, Observe also how rare that Knowledge was among them. It may be in all the world there may be a few hundreds of learned Philosophers, and among those there is one part Epicures, another Peripatetics, &c. that acknowledge not a future Happiness or Misery: And of those few that do acknowledge it, none knows it truly, nor the way that leads to it. How few of them could tell what was mans chief good? And those few, how imperfectly? with what mixtures of falsehood? we have no certainty of any of them that did know so much, as that there was but one God. For though Socrates dyed for deriding the multitude of gods, yet there is no certain Record of his right belief of the Unity of the Godhead. Besides, what Plato and aPlotinus did write of this, that was found, there is far greater probability that they had it from Scripture, then merely from Nature and Creatures. For bthat Plato had read the Writings of Moses, is proved already by divers Authors. The like may be said of cSeneca, and many others. So that if this means had contained any sufficiency in it for salvation, yet it would have extended but to some few of all the learned Philosophers: And what is this to an universal sufficiency to all mankind? Nay, there is not one of all their exactest Moralists, that have not mistaken Vice for Virtue; yea, most of them give the names of Virtue to the foulest Villainies, such as Self-murder in several cases, Revenge, a proud and vainglorious affectation of Honour and Applause, with other the like; so far have these few learned Philosophers been from the true Knowledge of things