Section 2
pp. 28–292 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sect. 2. E B. I hope you are not to learn that every untruth is a lye.
R. E. I suppose your citation of John 1. 62. 2. 21.1 is mis-printed for 1 John 1. 6. & 2 21. The first of which saith—If ⟨p. 29⟩we say that we have no fellowship with him, and walk in darkness, we lie and do not the truth. The other saith, that [No lie is of the truth.] But do either of these say, that every untruth is a lie. Is it not enough to hold 1. That every designed untruth which is positively voluntary is a lie: 2. And that every rash and carelessly uttered untruth, which is privatively voluntary (that is, where the will omitteth its Office) is a lie? Sure, brother, these many will be heavy enough upon you: you need not contend by false doctrine, for any more. And supposing that you are not to learn how singular you are in this assertion, is it any sign of your humility, to think that so few Divines before you (who so little avoid it) did know what a Lie is? If I had called you a wise, a calm, a sober and charitable man, when I had no evidence of the contrary, how can you prove that this had been a lie? You tell us anon that Prophets, Nathan, Samuel, and good men have been mistaken? And did those Prophets lie? You deny not that your Brother Powell was mistaken? And yet you would not have it said that he lied? Let this go therefore for your first false doctrine, when you say that every untruth is a lie.
R. E. I suppose your citation of John 1. 62. 2. 21.1 is mis-printed for 1 John 1. 6. & 2 21. The first of which saith—If ⟨p. 29⟩we say that we have no fellowship with him, and walk in darkness, we lie and do not the truth. The other saith, that [No lie is of the truth.] But do either of these say, that every untruth is a lie. Is it not enough to hold 1. That every designed untruth which is positively voluntary is a lie: 2. And that every rash and carelesly uttered untruth, which is privatively voluntary (that is, where the will omitteth its Office) is a lie? Sure, brother, these many will be heavy enough upon you: you need not contend by false doctrine, for any more. And supposing that you are not to learn how singular you are in this assertion, is it any sign of your humility, to think that so few Divines before you (who so little avoid it) did know what a Lie is? If I had called you a wise, a calm, a sober and charitable man, when I had no evidence of the contrary, how can you prove that this had been a lie? You tell us anon that Prophets, Nathan, Samuel, and good men have been mistaken? And did those Prophets lie? You deny not that your Brother Powel was mistaken? And yet you would not have it said that he lied? Let this go therefore for your first false doctrine, when you say that every untruth is a lie.