RICHARD BAXTERS second Account to Mr. John Cheney of his Judgment, accused by him of Atheism, subverting all Religion, Christianity, the Gospel, the Church, all Government, Introducing Popery, &c. Especially for asserting, 1. That Christ hath Instituted one Universal Church, of which he only is the Head; and particular Churches as parts of it, of which the Pastors are Subordinate Heads or Governors, and so formally differenced. 2. That neither of them is Constituted without some signification of consent: which he never before heard one Christian deny.RICHARD BAXTERS second Account to Mr. John Cheney of his Judgment, accused by him of Atheism, subverting all Religion, Christianity, the Gospel, the Church, all Government, Introducing Popery, &c. Especially for asserting, 1. That Christ hath Instituted one Universal Church, of which he onely is the Head; and particular Churches as parts of it, of which the Pastors are Subordinate Heads or Governours, and so formally differenced. 2. That neither of them is Constituted without some signification of consent: which he never before heard one Christian deny.
pp. 1–76169 passagespart 4 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mr. Chenies Accusations of me about Church-Covenants, and rigid Independency, and the odiousness hereof, considered.Mr. Chenies Accusations of me about Church-Covenants, and rigid Independencie, and the odiousness hereof, considered.
Qu. 7. Doth not the extreme bold confidence of the falsest of his own conceptions, show a very ⟨p. 45⟩unhumbled overvaluing of his own understanding? To be ignorant is common to Mankind; yea, and to be much ignorant of our ignorance, and to think that we know more than we do: But to have so little sense of this calamity, and so little suspicion of ones own understanding, as to be confident to such a height of accusation of the grossest falsehoods, where a lad of fourteen years old, that had read any thing of Logic and Politics, might have better taught him; (that I say not, the reason and use of Mankind) this seemeth somewhat beyond the common measure of self-conceitedness.
Qu. 7. Doth not the extreme bold confidence of the falsest of his own conceptions, shew a very ⟨p. 45⟩unhumbled overvaluing of his own understanding? To be ignorant is common to Mankind; yea, and to be much ignorant of our ignorance, and to think that we know more than we do: But to have so little sense of this calamity, and so little suspicion of ones own understanding, as to be confident to such a height of accusation of the grossest falshoods, where a lad of fourteen years old, that had read any thing of Logick and Politicks, might have better taught him; (that I say not, the reason and use of Mankind) this seemeth somewhat beyond the common measure of self-conceitedness.
§ 1. When he had said, that [it leads to two contrary Gods, which is to make no true God, p. 69.] He proceedeth [Mr. B. hath devised and framed two Covenants, the one to make a man a Member of the Church Universal, the other of the particular, p. 97. I will show, 1. That this is the same with the upstart way of the Independents: 2. The unsoundness of it, p. 101. Mr. B. and the Independents now, are contrary to their own principle ⟨p. 46⟩in baptizing the Infants of Non-Confederates, p. 129. [I do utterly withstand it as Wickedness and Abomination in Gods Church; I am to die and burn at a stake before I yield to any such thing: This is Mr. Baxters way: He offers it to Bishop Morley and Bishop Gunning, in his Preface to his last Book of Concord, that posterity may see what it is that he would have had, and laboured to set up in all the Churches: And accordingly, let both the present and future Ages see and know, p. 130. Your way is not so innocent as that of re-baptizing. For the very matter and terms of your Church-Covenant are unsafe, and plainly Schismatical! As if Constables and people of each Town must Confederate to be a Corporation, an Independent body having all jurisdiction within themselves, and such as will not enter into this Confederacy, must be counted none of the Kings Subjects.—To say there are no Churches in the world but a few Independent Churches,—were to go beyond Brownism: It were rather to teach Infidelity: such an opinion would be abhorred by all: Now Mr. Baxter and the Independents Doctrine saith it.—Their error, should they hold it habitually, predominantly, and practically, would be certainly their damnation.—p. 141, [I see not but Pagans, gross Heretics, Apostates, Thieves and Robbers might combine together and say, I take thee for my Pastor, and I take you for my people: Doth not your Doctrine infer it? p. 143. If I yield to their assertion, I must subvert the office of Christ and his Apostles, and all his faithful Ministers, and all the Churches to this day; which I will not do for fear of the censure of any man living, no nor of a whole Council of men, p. 57. The way that Mr. Baxter offers, ⟨p. 47⟩seems to be a worse way,—It is the way of rigid Independency.—Indeed Mr. B. in all his Writings seems to be against the Office of Lay-Elders:
§ 1. WHen he had said, that [it leads to two contrary Gods, which is to make no true God, p. 69.] He proceedeth [Mr. B. hath devised and framed two Covenants, the one to make a man a Member of the Church Universal, the other of the particular, p. 97. I will shew, 1. That this is the same with the upstart way of the Independents: 2. The unsoundness of it, p. 101. Mr. B. and the Independents now, are contrary to their own principle
But that he is not for them under another notion, as Heads and delegates of the people, mutually chosen by the Pastor and people, for assistance in Discipline, may be doubted. He seems to hint at it, &c.
§ 2. How little truth is in all this, and abundance such? 1. either it is truth that I am for rigid Independency, or not. If not,—if yea, I am glad that the Independent way is no worse. I am not much acquainted with them: But, if this man say true, 1. They are for no Covenanting, but consent to the relation signified. 2. They are not for binding any to continue in that relation. 3. They are not for binding any from a regular use of any other Minister, or Churches Communion. 4. In places where Parishes are divided by Law, and the ordinary attendance on the Pastors Ministration goeth for a sign of consent, they are true Churches and Members that thus signify it; and ad esse it is usually enough, though ad bene esse in doubtful cases the more express, as more intelligible caeteris paribus is best. 5. They are against an Office of Lay-Elders, distinct from Ministers of the Word and Sacraments, as of Gods institution for Church-government. 6. They are against Democracy, or the Church-governing power of the People. 7. They take reformed Parish-Churches for the best Order, not taking all for Members that are in the Parish, but all the capable. 8. They are against gathering Churches out of such Parish-Churches, without great necessity. 9. They are greatly against requiring ⟨p. 48⟩any qualification as necessary to Communion in point of holiness, but express consent to the Baptismal Covenant, or profession of Christianity, not disproved. 10. They make not the peoples Election of their Pastors necessary ad esse, but meer consent, though the Patron or others Elect them. 11. They suppose that the peoples Election or consent is not necessary to make a man a Minister in the Universal Church, but only to make him their Pastor. As to make a Physician, and to make him my Physician, differ. 12. They suppose that a true Minister officiateth as such, where ever he doth it. 13. They suppose that associations or correspondencies of Churches for concord and help, and Synods to that end, and dependency on such Synods, is usually a duty where it can well be had; and needless discord a fault. 14. They refuse not to submit in practice to the instructions or admonitions of any general Visitor or Overseer of many Churches, called by some Archbishops. 15. They refuse not the precedency of one Pastor in every particular Church over the rest of the Presbyters. 16.
§ 2. How little truth is in all this, and abundance such? 1. either it is truth that I am for rigid Independency, or not. If not,—if yea, I am glad that the Independent way is no worse. I am not much acquainted with them: But, if this man say true, 1. They are for no Covenanting, but consent to the relation signifyed. 2. They are not for binding any to continue in that relation. 3. They are not for binding any from a regular use of any other Minister, or Churches Communion. 4. In places where Parishes are divided by Law, and the ordinary attendance on the Pastors Ministration goeth for a sign of consent, they are true Churches and Members that thus signifie it; and ad esse it is usually enough, though ad bene esse in doubtful cases the more express, as more intelligible caeteris paribus is best. 5. They are against an Office of Lay-Elders, distinct from Ministers of the Word and Sacraments, as of Gods institution for Church-government. 6. They are against Democracie, or the Church-governing power of the People. 7. They take reformed Parish-Churches for the best Order, not taking all for Members that are in the Parish, but all the capable. 8. They are against gathering Churches out of such Parish-Churches, without great necessity. 9. They are greatly against requiring
They refuse him not the name of the Bishop, nor yet to submit to his negative voice as of the Quorum (or the Archbishops either) in Ordinations and all great public matters. 17. They are for separating from no Christians, further than they separate from Christ, or would force them to sin; but are for universal Love and Concord. 18. They are for obeying the Magistrate in all lawful things belonging to his function. 19. They take the most extensive Love, Peace, and Concord for the most desirable and best. 20. It is ⟨p. 49⟩next their obedience to Christ and his sufficient Laws; the great reason why they are against the terms imposed in most places of the Christian world, where things unnecessary and suspected are made necessary to Communion. Reader, Mr. Ch. is so honest a man, that it were unjust to take him for a deliberate studied Liar. Therefore seeing he saith that my way is rigid Independency, and oft maketh me a downright Independent, I that know my own Judgement, and knew not theirs so well as he seems to do, am glad to hear that they are no worse, and that they are wronged by such as accuse them of denying any of those Twenty points.
They refuse him not the name of the Bishop, nor yet to submit to his negative voice as of the Quorum (or the Archbishops either) in Ordinations and all great publick matters. 17. They are for separating from no Christians, further than they separate from Christ, or would force them to sin; but are for universal Love and Concord. 18. They are for obeying the Magistrate in all lawful things belonging to his function. 19. They take the most extensive Love, Peace, and Concord for the most desirable and best. 20. It is ⟨p. 49⟩next their obedience to Christ and his sufficient Laws; the great reason why they are against the terms imposed in most places of the Christian world, where things unnecessary and suspected are made necessary to Communion. Reader, Mr. Ch. is so honest a man, that it were unjust to take him for a deliberate studied Lyar. Therefore seeing he saith that my way is rigid Independency, and oft maketh me a downright Independent, I that know my own Judgement, and knew not theirs so well as he seems to do, am glad to hear that they are no worse, and that they are wronged by such as accuse them of denying any of those Twenty points.
And first, it savours of a spirit worse than his own, that when he had before used the word [Oath] as owned by me, and then said, he repented of it, that he still useth the word [Covenant] here as mine, instead of Consent, which is the word which I use, and over and over say, that I own no Covenant but any signification of Consent to the relation; only because I said, that not ad esse, but ad bene esse, plain or express Consent in doubtful cases is best. This smells of an ill intention; and now I will try his arguments against this Consent.
And first, it savours of a spirit worse than his own, that when he had before used the word [Oath] as owned by me, and then said, he repented of it, that he still useth the word [Covenant] here as mine, instead of Consent, which is the word which I use, and over and over say, that I own no Covenant but any signification of Consent to the relation; onely because I said, that not ad esse, but ad bene esse, plain or express Consent in doubtful cases is best. This smells of an ill intention; and now I will try his arguments against this Consent.
§ 4. P. 101. he saith Mr. B. acts contrary to his own Principles in baptizing the Children of No• confederates. The Universal and Particular Church make but one Church of God. He that refuseth ⟨p. 50⟩one Essential of Church-communion, is no Christian, and is to be debarred the Privileges of Christians. But according to you, Non-confederates refuse one essential of Church-communion—I may not baptize you, you are to me a Pagan.
§ 4. P. 101. he saith Mr. B. acts contrary to his own Principles in baptizing the Children of No• confederates. The Universal and Particular Church make but one Church of God. He that refuseth ⟨p. 50⟩one Essential of Church-communion, is no Christian, and is to be debarred the Priviledges of Christians. But according to you, Non-confederates refuse one essential of Church-communion—I may not baptize you, you are to me a Pagan.
Ans. Putares, sed calumniaris. Here is fallacia aequivocationis, and so quatuour termini. This Parish-Church and the Universal are not the same. The word Church in the Major, signifieth one thing, and in the Minor another. All is not essential to Communion in the Church Universal, which is essential to Communion with this or that, or any particular political Church. To the later, there must be, you say, Neighbourhood; and I say, proper Pastors and Flocks for personal Communion. But the Eunuch, Acts 8. was baptized into the Universal Church, and not into any Neighbourhood, Parish, Diocese, Assembly, or had any stated Pastor. He came into no Church meeting. Philip (the Deacon supposed) was snatched away from him in the open field, &c. Baptism as such, enters us into no particular Church. Your words [you are a Pagan to me] are too false for a Christian to have used. He that believeth with all his heart is no Pagan. I am a Minister of Christ to the world; but Infidels are not my Flock, or a Church. Catechizers should teach Children all this plain truth.
Ans. Putares, sed calumniaris. Here is fallacia aequivocationis, and so quatuour termini. This Parish-Church and the Universal are not the same. The word Church in the Major, signifieth one thing, and in the Minor another. All is not essential to Communion in the Church Universal, which is essential to Communion with this or that, or any particular political Church. To the later, there must be, you say, Neighbourhood; and I say, proper Pastors and Flocks for personal Communion. But the Eunuch, Acts 8. was baptized into the Universal Church, and not into any Neighbourhood, Parish, Diocess, Assembly, or had any stated Pastor. He came into no Churchmeeting. Philip (the Deacon supposed) was snatcht away from him in the open field, &c. Baptism as such, enters us into no particular Church. Your words [you are a Pagan to me] are too false for a Christian to have used. He that believeth with all his heart is no Pagan. I am a Minister of Christ to the world; but Infidels are not my Flock, or a Church. Catechizers should teach Children all this plain truth.
§ 5. II. P. 102. [Ask Mr. Baxter (saith he) Whom do you mean by the word Church, and at last he must come to one man the Pastor (as the Papist• the Pope.) He that covenanteth first, covenanteth with none but the Pastor. You change your terms. What Church must he covenant with that was first ⟨p. 51⟩baptized? Ans. Christ was baptized, and his first baptized Disciple and he were the Embryo of the Universal Church, if you can prove that one was baptized alone. And as to a particular Church, the Gatherer at first is only a Minister in the Church Universal, and authorized to that gathering which shall be the Foundation of his future relation: And the first person that consenteth, and he, are not a proper Church; for it is an Embryo, and in fieri, as a Troop when the Captain hath listed the first man. But usually many are made Christians first, and then they are materia disposita, and Consent maketh the Pastors and them to be particular Churches, Acts 14. 23. They ordained them Elders in every Church. Elders of their own, Acts 20. the Elders of the Church of Ephesus, and so of the rest of the Churches, are mentioned. And is the Captain a Troop, or the Pastor a Church, if he be the gatherer of it?
§ 5. II. P. 102. [Ask Mr. Baxter (saith he) Whom do you mean by the word Church, and at last he must come to one man the Pastor (as the Papist• the Pope.) He that covenanteth first, covenantet• with none but the Pastor. You change your terms. What Church must he covenant with that was first ⟨p. 51⟩baptized? Ans. Christ was baptized, and his first baptized Disciple and he were the Embryo of the Universal Church, if you can prove that one was baptized alone. And as to a particular Church, the Gatherer at first is onely a Minister in the Church Universal, and authorized to that gathering which shall be the Foundation of his future relation: And the first person that consenteth, and he, are not a proper Church; for it is an Embryo, and in fieri, as a Troop when the Captain hath listed the first man. But usually many are made Christians first, and then they are materia disposita, and Consent maketh the Pastors and them to be particular Churches,
§ 6. III. You name not Christ, (saith he) but the Pastor. Ans. When we say Captain A. B's Troop, we name not the General. When we say, the Bishop of London's Diocese, the King's Dominion, &c. we name not Christ, or God: For only the Genus proximum is to be in definitions. The Superior are supposed: they are Christians first.
§ 6. III. You name not Christ, (saith he) but the Pastor. Ans. When we say Captain A. B's Troop, we name not the General. When we say, the Bishop of London's Diocess, the King's Dominion, &c. we name not Christ, or God: For onely the Genus proximum is to be in definitions. The Superiour are supposed: they are Christians first.
§ 7. IV. You say (saith he) that before this Covenant men are but hewed stones, that is, all the faithful are Pagans. Ans. Putares. To be prepared for Baptism is somewhat more than to be Pagans: But till consent Christians are not Members of any particular Church. The Eunuch was but ⟨p. 52⟩a hewn stone, as you call it, as to a formed Congregation; but he was no Pagan, but a Member of the Body of Christ.
§ 8. V. This (saith he) makes the most excellent Ministers, Apostles, &c. mere Lay-men, such as go up and down preaching to Pagans where Christ is not known—plainly subverts the Gospel, &c. Ans. They are Christ's Ministers, and not Lay-men, while they convert Pagans, and yet Pagans are no Church: And till they are a Church, no Apostle is a Pastor of them as a Church. The Gospel standeth for all this.
§ 9. But (saith he) may not a man be a Shepherd by calling and occupation, unless he have a Flock, as well as a Physician? &c. Ans. Either you quarrel de re or de nomine. If de re, do you mean any more than that he is authorized to gather and rule a Flock? If more, what is it? If not, you calumniate if you pretend that I deny this; but if it be onely de nomine, whether the name of a Pastor may be given him that yet hath no Flock, or of a Captain to him that hath no Troop; I answer, 1. When you wrangle but about Names, try once more to stay that list of laying the overthrow of the Gospel on your Names. 2. Titles of Relation may be given aptitudinally ex intentione de futuro: But if one may be called a Pastor by relation to an intended Flock, much more to an actual Flock, and still it is a Relative to such a Flock intended. 3. Try in Scripture, and Councils, and all Church-writers, whether the title Pastor be not usually given only to those that have actual Flocks. But to avoid your quarrel, call you them by what name you list, if that will ease or please you.
§ 9. But (saith he) may not a man be a Shepherd by calling and occupation, unless he have a Flock, as well as a Physician? &c. Ans. Either you quarrel de re or de nomine. If de re, do you mean any more than that he is authorized to gather and rule a Flock? If more, what is it? If not, you calumniate if you pretend that I deny this; but if it be onely de nomine, whether the name of a Pastor may be given him that yet hath no Flock, or of a Captain to him that hath no Troop; I answer, 1. When you wrangle but about Names, try once more to stay that list of laying the overthrow of the Gospel on your Names. 2. Titles of Relation may be given aptitudinally ex intentione de futuro: But if one may be called a Pastor by relation to an intended Flock, much more to an actual Flock, and still it is a Relative to such a Flock intended. 3. Try in Scripture, and Councils, and all Church-writers, whether the title Pastor be not usually given onely to those that have actual Flocks. But to avoid your quarrel, call you them by what name you list, if that will ease or please you.
§ 10. VI. According to this Doctrine, a Minister hath no Office or Authority but just to those of his own charge, he preacheth elsewhere but as a gifted man. Ans. Still false, as to me, of whom you speak! what a strange Chain of Calumnies can you make? A Minister is 1. Christ's Officer to the world to convert them. 2. To gather a Church in fieri. 3. To officiate pro tempore in any other Church, as a Licensed Physician to others (even to Physicians) doth his office.
§ 11. VII. It maketh void (saith he) Gods Ordinance of Ordination: for either they are Ministers by Ordination, or not: If yea, this Doctrine is erroneous. Ans. Unproved: Ordination, sine titulo, maketh a man a Minister to the World and to the Church indefinitely. Ordination with Institution doth that and more, viz. it tieth a Minister to a consenting people. Your Writings are all stigmatized with the shame of naked affirmations without proof, and then forgetfully you oft say [I have proved.] Why may not Consent, and Ordination, and Institution, and Induction too, be all needful? Is a man and woman's Consent needless, unless the Ministers marrying them be needless? May not a Town, Hospital, or Person, choose a Physician as theirs if he were licensed before? If a Captain have commission to raise a Troop, is consent of the Listed needless? So of a Major; a Pilot, or any relation which requires Consent.
§ 11. VII. It maketh void (saith he) Gods Ordinance of Ordination: for either they are Ministers by Ordination, or not: If yea, this Doctrine is erroneous. Ans. Unproved: Ordination, sine titulo, maketh a man a Minister to the World and to the Church indefinitely. Ordination with Institution doth that and more, viz. it tieth a Minister to a consenting people. Your Writings are all stigmatized with the shame of naked affirmations without proof, and then forgetfully you oft say [I have proved.] Why may not Consent, and Ordination, and Institution, and Induction too, be all needful? Is a man and womans Consent needless, unless the Ministers marrying them be needless? May not a Town, Hospital, or Person, chuse a Physician as theirs if he were licensed bebefore? If a Captain have commission to raise a Troop, is consent of the Listed needless? So of a Major; a Pilot, or any relation which requires Consent.
§ 12. VIII. It inferreth (saith he) that the Church is before the Officers, viz. Pagans a Church. Ans. All fictions as to me to whom he speaks: I said before, they are as the Heart to the Body; ⟨p. 54⟩the punctum saliens is the first organical part to make the rest; but not a part of the Body till the Body be made. They are Ministers to gather Churches, and then Pastors of Churches only by consent. And when Churches are gathered, and the Pastor dead, the people are Intentionally a Society, but actually but a Community, till a Pastor related to them make them a politic society: And then relata sunt simul—
§ 12. VIII. It inferreth (saith he) that the Church is before the Officers, viz. Pagans a Church. Ans. All fictions as to me to whom he speaks: I said before, they are as the Heart to the Body; ⟨p. 54⟩the punctum saliens is the first organical part to make the rest; but not a part of the Body till the Body be made. They are Ministers to gather Churches, and then Pastors of Churches onely by consent. And when Churches are gathered, and the Pastor dead, the people are Intentionally a Society, but actually but a Community, till a Pastor related to them make them a politick society: And then relata sunt simul—
§ 13. IX. This Doctrine puts a new clause into Baptism, which Christ never put in, and altereth Christianity (saith he.) Before I baptize you, I must have an antecedent Covenant or signified Consent from you to submit to me; and you must be baptized in the name of Paul, &c. No Church-covenant, no Church-member, no right to any Church-ordinance. Ans. Confundendo fortiter caluminaris. 1. The Eunuch consented to be a Christian of the Church Universal, but not to be of a particular Church; without that Consent he had not been baptized: but this was not needful to it. 2. The dispute whether Lay-mens baptism be valid, I leave to you. But if yea, it is not necessary that I judge the Baptizer a Minister. If not, then it is necessary, and my consent is necessary to make me a Christian, but not him a Minister: But mutual consent is necessary to his Pastoral relation to a particular Church. 3. An Ordinance common to the Church Universal, and proper to a particular Church, should not be confounded, nor so much as the modal ministration. Do I add to Baptism, if I say that by the Canons and Custom of all the Churches for one Thousand years, a man was not to be taken for the Bishop of any ⟨p. 55⟩Church without mutual consent? what's this to Baptism? And what temerity is it to feign men to wrong Christ by that which was his Institution, and so judged and used in all the Churches?
§ 13. IX. This Doctrine puts a new clause into Baptism, which Christ never put in, and altereth Christianity (saith he.) Before I baptize you, I must have an antecedent Covenant or signified Consent from you to submit to me; and you must be baptized in the name of Paul, &c. No Church-covenant, no Church-member, no right to any Church-ordinance. Ans. Confundendo fortiter caluminaris. 1. The Eunuch consented to be a Christian of the Church Universal, but not to be of a particular Church; without that Consent he had not been baptized: but this was not needful to it. 2. The dispute whether Lay-mens baptism be valid, I leave to you. But if yea, it is not necessary that I judge the Baptizer a Minister. If not, then it is necessary, and my consent is necessary to make me a Christian, but not him a Minister: But mutual consent is necessary to his Pastoral relation to a particular Church. 3. An Ordinance common to the Church Universal, and proper to a particular Church, should not be confounded, nor so much as the modal ministration. Do I adde to Baptism, if I say that by the Canons and Custom of all the Churches for one Thousand years, a man was not to be taken for the Bishop of any ⟨p. 55⟩
§ 14. X. [Saith he] It maketh the people Church-Rulers or Co-partners in office with the Pastors, so that without their Consent they can do nothing; not baptize. Ans. Of me the calumny hath no excuse, I have written so much to the contrary: Yea, the very Act calumniated essentially containeth the contrary in it. As he that consenteth to be a Servant, consenteth not to be Master, but to obey: So they that consent to be Lay-members of a Pastors Flock, consent that he, and not they, shall rule, and that they will be the obeying part. How could you wink so hard, as not to see that your false witness confuteth it self? And what if he cannot be their Governor without their consent, doth this give them any part in governing? Nay what if he cannot baptize a Non-consenter, or give him the Lords Supper, is the Refuser a Church-governor? The man had got a heap of Notions against the Independents in his mind, or his instigator that hath the same disease had thrust them in, and out they must come against he knew not whom or what, upon the word [Consent.] What work would he make in the Church, if he should deny the necessity of this Consent, and have the Church made a Prison where Infidels should be crammed and drenched with the Sacrament?
§ 14. X. [Saith he] It maketh the people Church-Rulers or Co-partners in office with the Pastors, so that without their Consent they can do nothing; not baptize. Ans. Of me the calumny hath no excuse, I have written so much to the contrary: Yea, the very Act calumniated essentially containeth the contrary in it. As he that consenteth to be a Servant, consenteth not to be Master, but to obey: So they that consent to be Lay-members of a Pastors Flock, consent that he, and not they, shall rule, and that they will be the obeying part. How could you wink so hard, as not to see that your false witness confuteth it self? And what if he cannot be their Governour without their consent, doth this give them any part in governing? Nay what if he cannot baptize a Non-consenter, or give him the Lords Supper, is the Refuser a Church-governour? The man had got a heap of Notions against the Independents in his mind, or his instigator that hath the same disease had thrust them in, and out they must come against he knew not whom or what, upon the word [Consent.] What work would he make in the Church, if he should deny the necessity of this Consent, and have the Church made a Prison where Infidels should be cram'd and drencht with the Sacrament?
§ 15. XI. [It sets up (saith he) Rebaptization by a Law—For it requireth of godly baptized ⟨p. 56⟩ones an antecedent Covenant to be Members of the particular Church: As if a man should covenant to be a godly Citizen of London—to be a Member of Gods Church at K. and hold communion therewith: the people are called on to be new Christians, as if they had been no Christians before] Ans. It is a sin to read such words without grief and indignation. What! is every renewal of the Covenant of Godliness or Christianity a Rebaptizing, or supposeth us Pagans? Is this made by a Minister a heinous sin? Are we not to do it in every partaking of the Lords Supper? Yea, explicitly or implicitly in every prayer. Is Mr. Allen's Book for Covenanting, and Mr. Rawlet's of Sacramental Covenanting, such unchristening Heresies? Is it damnable or sinful to covenant to be a godly Servant, or a godly Husband or Wife, or a godly Minister or Magistrate? Doth this suppose them ungodly before? with wat weapons are we assaulted?
§ 15. XI. [It sets up (saith he) Rebaptization by a Law—For it requireth of godly baptized ⟨p. 56⟩ones an antecedent Covenant to be Members of the particular Church: As if a man should covenant to be a godly Citizen of London—to be a Member of Gods Church at K. and hold communion therewith: the people are called on to be new Christians, as if they had been no Christians before] Ans. It is a sin to read such words without grief and indignation. What! is every renewal of the Covenant of Godliness or Christianity a Rebaptizing, or supposeth us Pagans? Is this made by a Minister a heinous sin? Are we not to do it in every partaking of the Lords Supper? Yea, explicitely or implicitely in every prayer. Is Mr. Allen's Book for Covenanting, and Mr. Rawlet's of Sacramental Covenanting, such unchristening Heresies? Is it damnable or sinful to covenant to be a godly Servant, or a godly Husband or Wife, or a godly Minister or Magistrate? Doth this suppose them ungodly before? with wat weapons are we assaulted?
§ 16. XII. He adds [It bindeth people to be dwellers within the precincts of that one Church, to hear no other Minister, to join with no other Congregation. Ans. Concatenated Calumnies, as to me: They only consent to the Relation of Lay-members till they remove their dwelling or relation. They consent to take that Church but as a part of the Universal, and therefore to hold just Communion with all others, and receive what benefit they can from any other Ministers. I abhor a Covenant that renounceth Communion with the Universal Church, or any part of it, without necessary cause. Putide haec putares.
§ 16. XII. He addes [It bindeth people to be dwellers within the precincts of that one Church, to hear no other Minister, to joyn with no other Congregation. Ans. Concatenated Calumnies, as to me: They onely consent to the Relation of Lay-members till they remove their dwelling or relation. They consent to take that Church but as a part of the Universal, and therefore to hold just Communion with all others, and receive what benefit they can from any other Ministers. I abhor a Covenant that renounceth Communion with the Universal Church, or any part of it, without necessary cause. Putide haec putares.
§ 17. XIII. He adds, [What shall godly ⟨p. 57⟩Strangers, Travellers, &c. do? your Doctrine maketh them invaders.] Ans. 1. If I have no notice of their consent to communicate with us pro tempore, they expect it not: And de ignotis non judicat Ecclesia; and non apparere is equal to non esse. If I have notice of their Consent, it supposeth some notice that they are baptized, or Christians, and have more right than Heathens to Communion: And if so, 1. They consent to be Members of the Universal Church, and as such I shall give them the Sacrament and Communion, though I were no Pastor of any particular stated Church. 2. They consent to a Transient Temporary Communion with me as a Minister in the Catholic Church. And 3. They consent to transient temporary Communion with that particular Church, and transient temporary Communion I will give them; yea, and may call them transient Members of that Church; but no further any of these than they consent. A Christian giving evidence of his Christianity, hath right to transient Communion in all Churches in the world where he cometh: yea, all are not bound to live in stated Churches; some are Travellers, some unsettled Ambassadors, some Factors amongst Heathens, some of no Habitation, Beggars, Pedlars, Tinkers, and such wandering Trades; some live where is no Church with whom they may hold lawful Communion, &c. Now we have a new Divine risen up in the end of the world, that seems to make all the settled Churches of Christ in the world for many hundred years, to be all Traitors to Christ, because these wanderers must not consent to their special relations, ⟨p. 58⟩nor enjoy their proper Privileges; and because they consent themselves to a more settled relation and Communion than these wanderers or refusers are capable of. What would all the old Church, that made so many Canons about their proper Communion, have thought of this mans Doctrine, if he had come among them at their Elections, Discipline, Distributions to the Widows and Poor, and said, Hold Sirs! You are all destroying Baptism and Christianity, by consenting to more towards one another than you owe to every unknown wanderer, or refuser of a settled Churchstate? As if with our new Politician all Cities and Corporations are Traitors, or deny or wrong the King, because all Subjects are not Citizens, some being Vagrants, some in Villages, some Soldiers, some in odd Houses, &c.
and because Cities consent to a special sort of Government which the rest have not. Between the Anathematizers and these over-wise Censurers, there are few Christians in the world that are not condemned as no Christians for being sound Christians.
§ 18. XIV. He was aware that we say that every one that may come into the Temple is not a part of my special Charge as a Pastor, which I cannot do for all: And he saith, [It's all one to your Doctrine if he refuse your Church-covenant—The Minister all this while is no Minister; the People all this while are no Christians.—They are no more lawful Pastor and People, than Whoremonger and Whore going together, and committing acts of filthiness, and living in Fornication all their days—Ans. Continued Calumny as to me. Is no modesty or tender fear of sinning against the Ninth ⟨p. 59⟩Commandment left? 1. He that refuseth Consent to be a stated Member, is none such: But is he therefore no Christian? Awake, Conscience! Do any Independents say that none are Christians but their special charge; yea, or stated Members of particular Churches? If there be any such, what's that to me? 2. Such persons may be Members of the Universal Church, and I am a Pastor in the Universal Church; and as such may communicate with them. 3. If he desire temporary Communion, he consents to as much as he desireth, and that he may have: If he desire more, he shall have more. § 19. But (saith the Accuser) what speak you of Literae Communicatoriae, These are nothing to your case; (he saith it, ergo, he proveth it.) It shuts him out of all particular Churches and Congregations under Heaven, except, &c.] Ans. Putares! of me it's thus true or false. 1. He that consents not to be a stated Member of any Church, none, because he would be none: and it's blind self-contradiction, to say that I shut him out, because he will not come in. 2. He that consenteth to be a Member of the Universal Church shall not be shut out. 3. He that by literas Communicatorias, or any good testimony, showeth himself a Christian, and desireth only one days temporary Communion with a stated particular Church, shall not be denied that which he desireth, nor will we urge him to more.
§ 18. XIV. He was aware that we say that every one that may come into the Temple is not a part of my special Charge as a Pastor, which I cannot do for all: And he saith, [It's all one to your Doctrine if he refuse your Church-covenant—The Minister all this while is no Minister; the People all this while are no Christians.—They are no more lawful Pastor and People, than Whoremonger and Whore going together, and committing acts of filthiness, and living in Fornication all their days—Ans. Continued Calumny as to me. Is no modesty or tender fear of sinning against the Ninth ⟨p. 59⟩
§ 19. XV. He adds [It layeth waste Parish bounds, leaving people to go to what Church they will—Intimating, that being a godly man and a Parishioner, doth not make him a Member of the Parish-Church—Teaching people to be disorderly.] ⟨p. 60⟩Ans. 1. A quatenus ad omne valet consequentia. I said enough before to prove the falsehood of your Church-estate. 1. Then there were no Church till there were Parish-bounds 2. Then if Papists, Anabaptists, &c. be godly, and dwell in the Parish, they are Members against their wills. 3. And they are Members of two particular Churches; one in despite of them, and of the other as Consenters. 4. There are some Houses that are in no Parish (that I have known.) Alas, these must be of no Church. 5. Some parts of one Parish are in the middle of another. The truth is, Parish-bounds are ordinarily of good use for Order, and Order is for Edification, and to promote the thing ordered: and he layeth it not waste, 1. That giveth it no more than its due, as a humane mutable circumstance, and not as essential. 2. Nor he that refuseth it when it is turned against the end and the res ordinanda.
§ 19. XV. He adds [It layeth waste Parishbounds, leaving people to go to what Church they will—Intimating, that being a godly man and a Parishioner, doth not make him a Member of the Parish-Church—Teaching people to be disorderly.] ⟨p. 60⟩Ans. 1. A quatenus ad omne valet consequentia. I said enough before to prove the falsehood of your Church-estate. 1. Then there were no Church till there were Parish-bounds 2. Then if Papists, Anabaptists, &c. be godly, and dwell in the Parish, they are Members against their wills. 3. And they are Members of two particular Churches; one in despight of them, and of the other as Consenters. 4. There are some Houses that are in no Parish (that I have known.) Alas, these must be of no Church. 5. Some parts of one Parish are in the middle of another. The truth is, Parish-bounds are ordinarily of good use for Order, and Order is for Edification, and to promote the thing ordered: and he layeth it not waste, 1. That giveth it no more than its due, as a humane mutable circumstance, and not as essential. 2. Nor he that refuseth it when it is turned against the end and the res ordinanda.
§ 20. XVI. He adds, [Then if the Pastor set over them be a son of Belial—and sinfully tolerated by the Magistrate; the people of the Parish who can neither remove him, nor sit under a more edifying Minister, must covenant to him, &c. Ans. Strange! who would have thought but this was nearer your opinion than theirs? Briefly, if the man be tolerable, they must rather accept of him than have none. If he be intolerable in the Ministry, they may use such common gifts as he hath, (as we read even a Cicero) but they must be of no particular Church, till they can be so on lawful terms. Even a Council of the Popes decreed, that till men can have lawful Pastors, they must forbear that Communion that supposeth such: And who can doubt of it?
§ 20. XVI. He addes, [Then if the Pastor set over them be a son of Belial—and sinfully tolerated by the Magistrate; the people of the Parish who can neither remove him, nor sit under a more edifying Minister, must covenant to him, &c. Ans. Strange! who would have thought but this was neerer your opinion than theirs? Briefly, if the man be tolerable, they must rather accept of him than have none. If he be intolerable in the Ministry, they may use such common gifts as he hath, (as we read even a Cicero) but they must be of no particular Church, till they can be so on lawful terms. Even a Council of the Popes decreed, that till men can have lawful Pastors, they must forbear that Communion that supposeth such: And who can doubt of it?
§ 21. XVII. Next, he quibbles only with a Question [How long shall it last?] Answ. How long will you be of the Parish-Priests or the Diocesans Flock, or of a Physicians Hospital? We cannot secure men from providential changes a day, and therefore would not have them to bind themselves but on such suppositions—He that means to go to morrow to another Country, should consent but to this days Communion. He that intendeth here to dwell, must consent to the relation of a stated Member of that Flock till he remove, or till God show him just cause to change that relation: till then, he should know his proper Pastors.
§ 21. XVII. Next, he quibbles onely with a Question [How long shall it last?] Answ. How long will you be of the Parish-Priests or the Diocesans Flock, or of a Physicians Hospital? We cannot secure men from providential changes a day, and therefore would not have them to binde themselves but on such suppositions—He that means to go to morrow to another Countrey, should consent but to this days Communion. He that intendeth here to dwell, must consent to the relation of a stated Member of that Flock till he remove, or till God shew him just cause to change that relation: till then, he should know his proper Pastors.
§ 22. XVIII. Next, he questioneth, [Who shall degrade them that prove Heretical or Scandalous? &c.] Ans. The Ordainers made him a Minister by Investiture, &c. and yet without our consent he was not related to us as our Pastor, or we to him as part of that Church. And so we may withdraw our consent, and become none of his special Church-flock, and leave it to the Ordainers to degrade him if he must be degraded, as to the world and Church Universal. One would think this Answer should be undeniable. But he goeth on with his dismal accusations, p. 116. [The particular Church-covenant is a thing of mans invention, no where required of God; it is destructive to the Church and Souls, should it be practised.] Ans. Seeing Covenanting and known Consenting are all one with him, what a dreadful damning sin doth the man make it for to consent to be under our Pastors Office? Then he that would escape damnation must not consent to the office ⟨p. 62⟩of the Parish-priest, much less of the Bishop: much less swear obedience to the Bishop: And least of all, say or swear never to endeavour any alteration. We have need to bless us from Conformity, if Consenting be so damnable. But what meant he to say [should it be practised?] Doth he not know that it is practised by them all? and so that this Judge doth damn them all.
§ 23. XIX. He next answereth two of our pretences. 1. From the Election of Ministers by the people: And saith, Election is quite another thing; till they are ordained, they are no men in office—but persons designed—Ans. Alas, that the man that hath all this while been damning others, should not see that he hath so damned himself; yea, and quite exceeded my damning error. This it is to print with the zeal described Jam. 3. before men know what it is that they talk of. Note, that he is not against the peoples election (if he be intelligible) and yet elsewhere [They are Rebels and no Christians] that stand not to the King and Parliaments election. 2. Note, that he talks of one election, (to the Office of the Ministry as such) and I talk of another election, even to be our particular Pastor: For this Physician to be my Physician. 3. Note, that the mans bare word must, against all common use and reason, persuade us that Consent which I require is more than Election, which is much less. The Elector nominateth and first determineth of the person. Consent may come after, even in obedience to the Elector. The King electeth the Bishop, and the Patron the incumbent Parson. Doth every one that after consenteth do more? or must we lay by our senses ⟨p. 63⟩in believing such Writers against damning error? 4. Note, that he quite overgoeth the truth on the popular extreme, which he accuseth others of: As if the people must elect a man to the indefinite Office of a Minister as such, which is false. Christ sent out his Apostles, and the Apostles sent abroad a converting Church-gathering Ministry without any popular election. The Ordainers must choose who shall be a Minister (by his consent.) The Christian people should choose [and must consent at least] who shall be the special Guide of their own Souls; or their Pastor in particular. And the Magistrate must choose, 1. Whom he will maintain and encourage. 2. Whom he will tolerate. How came he to think that Election is nothing to the case, as if Consent were something more? yet is he at it again, P. 119. [They make it another Baptism.]
§ 23. XIX. He next answereth two of our pretences. 1. From the Election of Ministers by the people: And saith, Election is quite another thing; till they are ordained, they are no men in office—but persons designed—Ans. Alas, that the man that hath all this while been damning others, should not see that he hath so damned himself; yea, and quite exceeded my damning errour. This it is to print with the zeal described
§ 24. XX. Next, he answereth our saying that [No man can be a Pastor to a people against their wills.] And doth he say Yea, or Nay? Neither plainly, but talks of somewhat else, and saith, [He is a Pastor by Office and Calling whether the people will or not, and so Pastor and people are not simul naturâ.] As if the equivocating with the word [Pastor] warranted him to damn his Brethren, and confound Church-order: As [a Pastor] signifieth but a Minister commissioned to become the actual undertaking Guide of a particular Church-flock when he is called to it; so this man may be called a Pastor aptitudinal, as a man is a Captain that hath Commission to raise a Troop: But as the word [Pastor] signifieth one that is actually the Overseer of a particular Church-flock, ⟨p. 64⟩he is none till he have a Flock; and in both senses Pastor and Flocks are relate and correlate, & simul naturâ: that is, in the first, simul in esse cognito & intentionali: In the later, in esse existente. But, saith he, [God is God whether the people will or no; and Christ is Christ, Apostles are Apostles—and so faithful ordained Ministers are Pastors.] Ans. This is but the fallacy of the foresaid equivocation of the word [Pastor.] 1. God is not made God, nor Christ made Christ, nor Apostles or indefinite Ministers such by contract or humane consent: But he that said, Come out from amongst them, &c. I will be your God, and you shall be my people, and maketh some a holy Nation and peculiar people, &c. is so related to none but Consenters. Christ is an offered Saviour to refusers; but he is not the Saviour and Head of any as Christians, or a Church actually, but Consenters: without consent we are not materia disposita receptive of the peculiar relation. A man may be authorized to be a Tutor, Schoolmaster, Physician, Captain, Master, &c. without my consent: but he is not my Tutor, Master, &c. till I consent, save aptitudinally, not actually. 2. And these relations are more dependent on humane Contract or Consent, than Gods being God, &c. But, saith he, [If all be Pagans, the Minister lawfully ordained and appointed to convert and baptize and be a Pastor to them, is a true, full, and complete Pastor before he have christened one soul of them. Ans. True or false as the equivocation is taken:
§ 24. XX. Next, he answereth our saying that [No man can be a Pastor to a people against their wills.] And doth he say Yea, or Nay? Neither plainly, but talks of somewhat else, and saith, [He is a Pastor by Office and Calling whether the people will or not, and so Pastor and people are not simul naturâ.] As if the equivocating with the word [Pastor] warranted him to damn his Brethren, and confound Church-order: As [a Pastor] signifieth but a Minister commissioned to become the actual undertaking Guide of a particular Church-flock when he is called to it; so this man may be called a Pastor aptitudinal, as a man is a Captain that hath Commission to raise a Troop: But as the word [Pastor] signifieth one that is actually the Overseer of a particular Church-flock,
As one decreed to be a Husband to a Wife that is yet unborn, may by the deceiving improper language of an equivocator be said to be the true, ⟨p. 65⟩full and complete Husband of her yet unborn or unmarried; that is, one designed to be a Husband hereafter in a proper sense; so here. But Pastor est ovium seu gregis Pastor: Analogum per se positum stat pro significato famosiore. Heathens are no Church; Ergo, no man is a Pastor of them as a Church. Is he a complete Pastor of a Flock that hath none?
As one decreed to be a Husband to a Wife that is yet unborn, may by the deceiving improper language of an equivocator be said to be the true, ⟨p. 65⟩full and compleat Husband of her yet unborn or unmarried; that is, one designed to be a Husband hereafter in a proper sense; so here. But Pastor est ovium seu gregis Pastor: Analogum per se positum stat pro significato famosiore. Heathens are no Church; Ergo, no man is a Pastor of them as a Church. Is he a compleat Pastor of a Flock that hath none?
§ 25. XXI. But saith he, [Mark the matter, you are baptized a godly man; I have nothing against you, only this, I cannot take you for one of my Flock, unless by a voluntary consent, &c. I must shut you out as an Apostate, or a Pagan.] Ans. Calumny and Deceit conjunct. 1. It's immodest calumny to say, [as an Apostate or a Pagan] I take him for a Christian, and on due testimony shall admit him to such Communion (lawful) as he himself desireth. 1. Whether as a Member of the Universal Church. 2. Or also as a fixed Member of another Church desiring temporary transient Communion here. 2. It is gross Deceit to say [I put him out] that refuseth to come in. If I give him no more than he is willing of, what do I put him out from? If I take him not for a Member of my proper stated Charge, it is because he desireth it not. I thank God I never was a proper Pastor to any People against their wills, nor ever will be, were I capable of more service.
§ 25. XXI. But saith he, [Mark the matter, you are baptized a godly man; I have nothing against you, onely this, I cannot take you for one of my Flock, unless by a voluntary consent, &c. I must shut you out as an Apostate, or a Pagan.] Ans. Calumny and Deceit conjunct. 1. It's immodest calumny to say, [as an Apostate or a Pagan] I take him for a Christian, and on due testimony shall admit him to such Communion (lawful) as he himself desireth. 1. Whether as a Member of the Universal Church. 2. Or also as a fixed Member of another Church desiring temporary transient Communion here. 2. It is gross Deceit to say [I put him out] that refuseth to come in. If I give him no more than he is willing of, what do I put him out from? If I take him not for a Member of my proper stated Charge, it is because he desireth it not. I thank God I never was a proper Pastor to any People against their wills, nor ever will be, were I capable of more service.
§ 26. But, saith he, [This makes against you—Can any man forbid these people from being Members of the Particular Church that are of the Universal?] Ans. Self-contradiction! Do we forbid them that are not willing, or do they forbid ⟨p. 66⟩themselves? Doth the Physician forbid them to be his Patients that consent not? Do we shut them out that will not come in? Yet he feigneth us to do no less than cast them out of the Church Universal, as casting them out of all Particulars under Heaven. Ans. Calumny hath got such a channel, that his Writing runneth commonly that way. 1. I cast them out of no Church under Heaven, who will not consent to come in. 2. Were they of no particular Church, they may be in the Universal, as I before proved, of many sorts.
§ 27. He next noteth, that it is but signified Consent that I require: But he saith, neither Christ nor his Apostles mention it, and all the Church are without it. Ans. Let us try here whether this be true or false, and all his damning and unchristening censures fall not on the Holy Ghost and all the Churches. I. It is certain, that besides Ministers unfixed and of general indefinite work, there were by the Holy Ghost in the Apostles time fixed Churches of Neighbour-Christians settled. II. It is certain that these had fixed Pastors of their own, that were related to them specially as their special Charge, so as they were not related to all or any other Churches. III. It is certain that these Pastors had not equal authority to go into all other mens Dioceses or Parishes, and say, You are as much my Charge as any others, and play the Bishops in other mens Dioceses; though when they had a Call, they might be Ministerial Temporary Helpers. IV. It is certain that these Pastors were specially obliged to many Offices for those peculiar Flocks, which ⟨p. 67⟩to other Churches they were not so obliged to (but only to occasional help.) Dr. Hammond nameth many of them, and so do the Scripture and Canons. 1. A constant public Teaching them, which they owe not to all others or any. 2. Constant Government by the Keys. 3. Constant Administration of the Lords Supper. 4. Constant leading them in public Worship, Prayer, Praise, &c. 5. A special care of the Poor. 6. Ordinary Visitation of the Sick. 7. Comforting the Afflicted, admonishing Offenders, watching over all. The Canons will tell you much, which every man oweth more to his own Charge than to others. V. It is certain that this Flock oweth a more special attendance, and account, and obedience to these Pastors, than to Strangers or others of other Churches. 1. To hear them. 2. To receive the Communion ordinarily of them. 3. To maintain them; and so in the rest. V. I. It is certain that none of this was done or can be done without mutual Consent. VII. It is certain that this Churchstate, Office, and Duty was settled by Christ's Apostles, and continued by the common consent of the Churches on Earth from age to age.
§ 27. He next noteth, that it is but signified Consent that I require: But he saith, neither Christ nor his Apostles mention it, and all the Church are without it. Ans. Let us trie here whether this be true or false, and all his damning and unchristning censures fall not on the Holy Ghost and all the Churches. I. It is certain, that besides Ministers unfixed and of general indefinite work, there were by the Holy Ghost in the Apostles time fixed Churches of Neighbour-Christians setled. II. It is certain that these had fixed Pastors of their own, that were related to them specially as their special Charge, so as they were not related to all or any other Churches. III. It is certain that these Pastors had not equal authority to go into all other mens Diocesses or Parishes, and say, You are as much my Charge as any others, and play the Bishops in other mens Diocesses; though when they had a Call, they might be Ministerial Temporary Helpers. IV. It is certain that these Pastors were specially obliged to many Offices for those peculiar Flocks, which
§ 28. That it was an Apostolical Establishment is plain in Acts 14. 23. They ordained them Elders in every Church. To omit the sense of [Greek or Hebrew], which in the most usual sense includeth Suffrages, it is evident that [Greek or Hebrew] implieth the fixing of the several Elders to their several Churches, so as to make them the stated Elders of those Churches as their Flock in peculiar. ⟨p. 68⟩Acts 20. 17. Are they called the Elders of that Church over which, as their Flock, the Holy Ghost had made them Overseers to feed the Church of God, to imitate Paul that taught them publicly and from house to house; and was this no peculiar pastoral relation? or were any but Consenters Members of that Church? Tit. 1. 5. when Titus was to ordain Elders in every City, it is equal to every Church. And it stated them as their peculiar Pastors, even Bishops, as Gods Stewards over them in particular, v. 7. more than others. Jam. 5. 14. the sick that must call for the Elders of the Church, were their proper Flock, as is supposed. The Angels of the seven Churches Rev. 2 and 3. were not equally the Angels of other Churches. Phil. 1. 1. the Bishops and Deacons of the Church at Philippi had a fixed peculiar relation to them as theirs: Archippus had a proper Ministry at Coloss, Col. 4. 17. And Laodicea had a peculiar Church, v. 16. 1 Thess. 5. 12, 13. showeth the common state of the Christian Churches: Know them which labour among you, and are over you in the Lord, and admonish you; and to esteem them very highly in love for their works sake. And be at peace among your selves. Here Pastors to labour, and admonish, and be over them, are to be known, owned, esteemed, beloved persons, dwelling among them, and knowing their own Flock, and the peoples duty to them and one another laid down. And shall a Christian Minister say, [O but do not promise, no nor signify any consent to do it, for that is to be rebaptized, and is damning to the practisers.] The Bishops and Elders that Timothy is instructed about, were such as had
the Elders that Peter writeth to were to feed the Flock of God which was among them, taking the oversight of them (more than of all the world) not by constrain, but willingly, (and may they not signify willingness?) not as Lords, but Examples to their Flocks, and Shepherds under the chief Shepherd. Heb. 13. 7, 17, 24. fully expresseth it, Obey them that have the rule over you; they watch for your Souls as those that must give account, not of all the world, but of that Flock that they oversee. The same Church had Bishops that had Deacons, and some Deaconesses, Widows, &c. but it was never known that Deacons were to be indefinite Overseers of the poor of all Churches, but they had ever relation to particular Churches. This is the ordering of the Churches appointed by the Holy Ghost, Tit. 1. 5. And yet this man maketh it an abuse or injury against Christ, and overthrow of the Gospel.
the Elders that Peter writeth to were to feed the Flock of God which was among them, taking the oversight of them (more than of all the world) not by constrain, but willingly, (and may they not signifie willingness?) not as Lords, but Examples to their Flocks, and Shepherds under the chief Shepherd. Heb. 13. 7, 17, 24. fully expresseth it, Obey them that have the rule over you; they watch for your Souls as those that must give account, not of all the world, but of that Flock that they oversee. The same Church had Bishops that had Deacons, and some Deaconesses, Widows, &c. but it was never known that Deacons were to be indefinite Overseers of the poor of all Churches, but they had ever relation to particular Churches. This is the ordering of the Churches appointed by the Holy Ghost, Tit. 1. 5. And yet this man maketh it an abuse or injury against Christ, and overthrow of the Gospel.
§ 29. II. As for the constant judgement and practice of all Churches, I am ashamed that such usage should put me to such a work, as to prove that they ever held and practised that which this man condemneth in me. He knoweth nothing of the Churches state, and History, and Canons, that knoweth not, 1. That all Churches were Societies of Christians united under their proper known Bishops or Pastors, fixed to those Flocks ⟨p. 70⟩by proper relation, though also related to the World and the Church Universal. 2. That the people did not only Consent, but Choose their Pastors, and he was to be no Bishop that had not their consent. 3. That the Laity of other Churches promiscuously had no power to choose them, but only those whom they were set over. 4. That the Bishops, as Ignatius speaks, were to know the particular Members of their Churches, and see that they came constantly to the Assemblies, even to enquire after Maids and Servants, saith he, by name. 5. That they made multitudes of Canons for exercising particular Discipline on each person that needed it, by long suspending some from Communion, restoring others, taking care of the poor and of all. 6. That they took not the Catechumens for the Church, but Candidates, and prepared and tried them before admittance. 7. That it was not mere baptizing that made them of that Flock; for they preached and baptized in other places. 8. That it was not mere neighbourhood of Christians; for there were sometime divers Churches in one City, as in Meletius case at Alexandria; and Dr. Hammond thinks the Jewish and Gentile Christians at first had several Bishops and Churches in the same Cities ordinarily. And the Audians, Luciferians, Donatists, and others that were of the same Religion, had divers Churches, besides such as the Novatians, that had some little Doctrinal differences: and none till now ever thought that these were all the same Pastors special Flocks, and the same particular Churches. Yea, I have elsewhere cited that Council ⟨p. 71⟩that decreed that if any Bishop neglected to convert the Heretics, &c. he that converted them should have them (as his Flock or Church.) In a word, all Church-history and Canons describing their particular Churches, and their Elections, Orders, Offices, Privileges, Discipline, &c.
§ 29. II. As for the constant judgement and practice of all Churches, I am ashamed that such usage should put me to such a work, as to prove that they ever held and practised that which this man condemneth in me. He knoweth nothing of the Churches state, and History, and Canons, that knoeth not, 1. That all Churches were Societies of Christians united under their proper known Bishops or Pastors, fixed to those Flocks
⟨p. 46⟩
in baptizing the Infants of Non-Confederates, p. 129. [I do utterly withstand it as Wickedness and Abomination in Gods Church; I am to die and burn at a stake before I yield to any such thing: This is Mr. Baxters way: He offers it to Bishop Morley and Bishop Gunning, in his Preface to his last Book of Concord, that posterity may see what it is that he would have had, and laboured to set up in all the Churches: And accordingly, let both the present and future Ages see and know, p. 130. Your way is not so innocent as that of re-baptizing. For the very matter and terms of your Church-Covenant are unsafe, and plainly Schismatical! As if Constables and people of each Town must Confederate to be a Corporation, an Independent body having all jurisdiction within themselves, and such as will not enter into this Confederacy, must be counted none of the Kings Subjects.—To say there are no Churches in the world but a few Independent Churches,—were to go beyond Brownism: It were rather to teach Infidelity: such an opinion would be abhorred by all: Now Mr. Baxter and the Independents Doctrine saith it.—Their errour, should they hold it habitually, predominantly, and practically, would be certainly their damnation.—p. 141, [I see not but Pagans, gross Hereticks, Apostates, Thieves and Robbers might combine together and say, I take thee for my Pastor, and I take you for my people: Doth not your Doctrine infer it? p. 143. If I yield to their assertion, I must subvert the office of Christ and his Apostles, and all his faithful Ministers, and all the Churches to this day; which I will not do for fear of the censure of any man living, no nor of a whole Council of men, p. 57. The way that Mr. Baxter offers,
⟨p. 47⟩
seems to be a worse way,—It is the way of rigid Independencie.—Indeed Mr. B. in all his Writings seems to be against the Office of Lay-Elders:
⟨p. 48⟩
any qualification as necessary to Communion in point of holiness, but express consent to the Baptismal Covenant, or profession of Christianity, not disproved. 10. They make not the peoples Election of their Pastors necessary ad esse, but meer consent, though the Patron or others Elect them. 11. They suppose that the peoples Election or consent is not necessary to make a man a Minister in the Universal Church, but only to make him their Pastor. As to make a Physician, and to make him my Physician, differ. 12. They suppose that a true Minister officiateth as such, where ever he doth it. 13. They suppose that associations or correspondencies of Churches for concord and help, and Synods to that end, and dependencie on such Synods, is usually a duty where it can well be had; and needless discord a fault. 14. They refuse not to submit in practice to the instructions or admonitions of any general Visiter or Overseer of many Churches, called by some Archbishops. 15. They refuse not the precedency of one Pastor in every particular Church over the rest of the Presbyters. 16.
. the Elders of the Church of Ephesus, and so of the rest of the Churches, are mentioned. And is the Captain a Troop, or the Pastor a Church, if he be the gatherer of it?
Church without mutual consent? what's this to Baptism? And what temerity is it to feign men to wrong Christ by that which was his Institution, and so judged and used in all the Churches?
Strangers, Travellers, &c. do? your Doctrine maketh them invaders.] Ans. 1. If I have no notice of their consent to communicate with us pro tempore, they expect it not: And de ignotis non judicat Ecclesia; and non apparere is equal to non esse. If I have notice of their Consent, it supposeth some notice that they are baptized, or Christians, and have more right than Heathens to Communion: And if so, 1. They consent to be Members of the Universal Church, and as such I shall give them the Sacrament and Communion, though I were no Pastor of any particular stated Church. 2. They consent to a Transient Temporary Communion with me as a Minister in the Catholick Church. And 3. They consent to transient temporary Communion with that particular Church, and transient temporary Communion I will give them; yea, and may call them transient Members of that Church; but no further any of these than they consent. A Christian giving evidence of his Christianity, hath right to transient Communion in all Churches in the world where he cometh: yea, all are not bound to live in stated Churches; some are Travellers, some unsetled Embassadors, some Factors amongst Heathens, some of no Habitation, Beggars, Pedlars, Tinkers, and such wandring Trades; some live where is no Church with whom they may hold lawful Communion, &c. Now we have a new Divine risen up in the end of the world, that seems to make all the setled Churches of Christ in the world for many hundred years, to be all Traitors to Christ, because these wanderers must not consent to their special relations,
⟨p. 58⟩
nor enjoy their proper Priviledges; and because they consent themselves to a more setled relation and Communion than these wanderers or refusers are capable of. What would all the old Church, that made so many Canons about their proper Communion, have thought of this mans Doctrine, if he had come among them at their Elections, Discipline, Distributions to the Widows and Poor, and said, Hold Sirs! You are all destroying Baptism and Christianity, by consenting to more towards one another than you owe to every unknown wanderer, or refuser of a setled Churchstate? As if with our new Politician all Cities and Corporations are Traytors, or deny or wrong the King, because all Subjects are not Citizens, some being Vagrants, some in Villages, some Souldiers, some in odde Houses, &c.
Commandment left? 1. He that refuseth Consent to be a stated Member, is none such: But is he therefore no Christian? Awake, Conscience! Do any Independents say that none are Christians but their special charge; yea, or stated Members of particular Churches? If there be any such, what's that to me? 2. Such persons may be Members of the Universal Church, and I am a Pastor in the Universal Church; and as such may communicate with them. 3. If he desire temporary Communion, he consents to as much as he desireth, and that he may have: If he desire more, he shall have more. § 19. But (saith the Accuser) what speak you of Literae Communicatoriae, These are nothing to yourcase; (he saith it, ergo, he proveth it.) It shuts him out of all particular Churches and Congregations under Heaven, except, &c.] Ans. Putares! of me it's thus true or false. 1. He that consents not to be a stated Member of any Church, none, because he would be none: and it's blind self-contradiction, to say that I shut him out, because he will not come in. 2. He that consenteth to be a Member of the Universal Church shall not be shut out. 3. He that by literas Communicatorias, or any good testimony, sheweth himself a Christian, and desireth onely one days temporary Communion with a stated particular Church, shall not be denied that which he desireth, nor will we urge him to more.
. before men know what it is that they talk of. Note, that he is not against the peoples election (if he be intelligible) and yet elsewhere [They are Rebels and no Christians] that stand not to the King and Parliaments election. 2. Note, that he talks of one election, (to the Office of the Ministry as such) and I talk of another election, even to be our particular Pastor: For this Physician to be my Physician. 3. Note, that the mans bare word must, against all common use and reason, perswade us that Consent which I require is more than Election, which is much less. The Elector nominateth and first determineth of the person. Consent may come after, even in obedience to the Elector. The King electeth the Bishop, and the Patron the incumbent Parson. Doth every one that after consenteth do more? or must we lay by our senses
⟨p. 63⟩
in believing such Writers against damning errour? 4. Note, that he quite overgoeth the truth on the popular extream, which he accuseth others of: As if the people must elect a man to the indefinite Office of a Minister as such, which is false. Christ sent out his Apostles, and the Apostles sent abroad a converting Church-gathering Ministry without any popular election. The Ordainers must chuse who shall be a Minister (by his consent.) The Christian people should chuse [and must consent at least] who shall be the special Guide of their own Souls; or their Pastor in particular. And the Magistrate must chuse, 1. Whom he will maintain and encourage. 2. Whom he will tolerate. How came he to think that Election is nothing to the case, as if Consent were something more? yet is he at it again, P. 119. [They make it another Baptism.]
⟨p. 64⟩
he is none till he have a Flock; and in both senses Pastor and Flocks are relate and correlate, & simul naturâ: that is, in the first, simul in esse cognito & intentionali: In the later, in esse existente. But, saith he, [God is God whether the people will or no; and Christ is Christ, Apostles are Apostles—and so faithful ordained Ministers are Pastors.] Ans. This is but the fallacy of the foresaid equivocation of the word [Pastor.] 1. God is not made God, nor Christ made Christ, nor Apostles or indefinite Ministers such by contract or humane consent: But he that said, Come out from amongst them, &c. I will be your God, and you shall be my people, and maketh some a holy Nation and peculiar people, &c. is so related to none but Consenters. Christ is an offered Saviour to refusers; but he is not the Saviour and Head of any as Christians, or a Church actually, but Consenters: without consent we are not materia disposita receptive of the peculiar relation. A man may be authorized to be a Tutor, Schoolmaster, Physician, Captain, Master, &c. without my consent: but he is not my Tutor, Master, &c. till I consent, save aptitudinally, not actually. 2. And these relations are more dependent on humane Contract or Consent, than Gods being God, &c. But, saith he, [If all be Pagans, the Minister lawfully ordained and appointed to convert and baptize and be a Pastor to them, is a true, full, and compleat Pastor before he have christened one soul of them. Ans. True or false as the equivocation is taken:
⟨p. 67⟩
to other Churches they were not so obliged to (but onely to occasional help.) Dr. Hammond nameth many of them, and so do the Scripture and Canons. 1. A constant publick Teaching them, which they owe not to all others or any. 2. Constant Government by the Keys. 3. Constant Administration of the Lords Supper. 4. Constant leading them in publick Worship, Prayer, Praise, &c. 5. A special care of the Poor. 6. Ordinary Visitation of the Sick. 7. Comforting the Afflicted, admonishing Offenders, watching over all. The Canons will tell you much, which every man oweth more to his own Charge than to others. V. It is certain that this Flock oweth a more special attendance, and account, and obedience to these Pastors, than to Strangers or others of other Churches. 1. To hear them. 2. To receive the Communion ordinarily of them. 3. To maintain them; and so in the rest. V. I. It is certain that none of this was done or can be done without mutual Consent. VII. It is certain that this Churchstate, Office, and Duty was setled by Christ's Apostles, and continued by the common consent of the Churches on Earth from age to age.
⟨p. 69⟩
their proper Flocks, and took care of them as the Church of God, that were to rule them well, and labour in the Word and Doctrine; to preach the word in season and out of season, reprove, rebuke, exhort, with all long-suffering and Doctrine, &c. 1 Pet. 5. 1, 2, 3.
§ 28. That it was an Apostolical Establishment is plain in Acts 14. 23. They ordained them Elders in every Church. To omit the sence of 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which in the most usual sence includeth Suffrages, it is evident that 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 implieth the fixing of the several Elders to their several Churches, so as to make them the stated Elders of those Churches as their Flock in pepeculiar. ⟨p. 68⟩Acts 20. 17. Are they called the Elders of that Church over which, as their Flock, the Holy Ghost had made them Overseers to feed the Church of God, to imitate Paul that taught them publickly and from house to house; and was this no peculiar pastoral relation? or were any but Consenters Members of that Church? Tit. 1. 5. when Titus was to ordain Elders in every City, it is equal to every Church. And it stated them as their peculiar Pastors, even Bishops, as Gods Stewards over them in particular, v. 7. more than others. Jam. 5. 14. the sick that must call for the Elders of the Church, were their proper Flock, as is supposed. The Angels of the seven Churches Rev. 2 and 3. were not equally the Angels of other Churches. Phil. 1. 1. the Bishops and Deacons of the Church at Philippi had a fixed peculiar relation to them as theirs: Archippus had a proper Ministry at Colosse, Col. 4. 17. And Laodicea had a peculiar Church, v. 16. 1 Thess. 5. 12, 13. sheweth the common state of the Christian Churches: Know them which labour among you, and are over you in the Lord, and admonish you; and to esteem them very highly in love for their works sake. And be at peace among your selves. Here Pastors to labour, and admonish, and be over them, are to be known, owned, esteemed, beloved persons, dwelling among them, and knowing their own Flock, and the peoples duty to them and one another laid down. And shall a Christian Minister say, [O but do not promise, no nor signifie any consent to do it, for that is to be rebaptized, and is damning to the practisers.] The Bishops and Elders that Timothy is instructed about, were such as had ⟨p. 69⟩their proper Flocks, and took care of them as the Church of God, that were to rule them well, and labour in the Word and Doctrine; to preach the word in season and out of season, reprove, rebuke, exhort, with all long-suffering and Doctrine, &c. 1 Pet. 5. 1, 2, 3.
⟨p. 70⟩
by proper relation, though also related to the World and the Church Universal. 2. That the people did not onely Consent, but Chuse their Pastors, and he was to be no Bishop that had not their consent. 3. That the Laity of other Churches promiscuously had no power to chuse them, but onely those whom they were set over. 4. That the Bishops, as Ignatius speaks, were to know the particular Members of their Churches, and see that they came constantly to the Assemblies, even to enquire after Maids and Servants, saith he, by name. 5. That they made multitudes of Canons for exercising particular Discipline on each person that needed it, by long suspending some from Communion, restoring others, taking care of the poor and of all. 6. That they took not the Catechumens for the Church, but Candidates, and prepared and tried them before admittance. 7. That it was not mere baptizing that made them of that Flock; for they preached and baptized in other places. 8. That it was not mere neighbourhood of Christians; for there were sometime divers Churches in one City, as in Meletius case at Alexandria; and Dr. Hammond thinks the Jewish and Gentile Christians at first had several Bishops and Churches in the same Cities ordinarily. And the Audians, Luciferians, Donatists, and others that were of the same Religion, had divers Churches, besides such as the Novatians, that had some little Doctrinal differences: and none till now ever thought that these were all the same Pastors special Flocks, and the same particular Churches. Yea, I have elsewhere cited that Council
⟨p. 71⟩
that decreed that if any Bishop neglected to convert the Hereticks, &c. he that converted them should have them (as his Flock or Church.) In a word, all Church-history and Canons describing their particular Churches, and their Elections, Orders, Offices, Priviledges, Discipline, &c.