The sixth Doubt, A man may be easily deceived in these ways of Signs, for this 1Knowledge consisteth of a practical Syllogism thus, Every one that loveth the brethren is translated from death to life, But I love the brethren, Therefore I am translated from death to life. Therefore a late Author (Cornwall in his Treatise of Justification, ⟨p. 54⟩pag. 17.) denieth, The faith wrought in such a practical Syllogism, to be by the power of the Lord Almighty, but only in the strength of humane reason, and therefore is only an humane faith. But this is a very dangerous Assertion, and like that which the Jesuits would impose upon the Protestants concerning a doctrinal Faith thus, There is Veroniana Methodus, by which the Jesuits would conclude the Protestants have no faith, because (say they) the object of faith must be according to the Protestants, Purum putum verbum Dei, the meer word of God, but now there is nothing, which the Protestants believe, but they conclude it by way of a Syllogism, and in this Syllogism, the Assumption or the mere inference is not in Scripture, or they may err in making the inference, and so they have no conclusion de fide. But all this is sophistry, for a proxim and immediate conclusion is in the principle, and so believed with the same faith that the principle is, and when a man by reason makes a conclusion, his reason is only the Instrument, not the Argument of his faith, his reason is not the ground of his faith, nor doth it suggest the matter to be believed, but is the instrument to discover it. As he that diggeth in a mine of gold, his instruments he useth in removing the earth that covered it, do not make the gold, but discover it. And as for this practical Syllogism, it is not made by mere humane reason, for when the soul makes the assumption, it doth it, being sanctified and enlightened by the Spirit of God, and so is an instrument in his hand, for there is the same proportion between the Spirit of God in spiritual things, and reason in philosophical things; so that as in Philosophy, reason makes the major and minor in any Syllogism; so in spiritual things, the Spirit of God enableth a man to make a whole Syllogism for a believers comfort and establishment.
The sixth Doubt, A man may be easily deceived in these wayes of Signs, for this 1Knowledge consisteth of a practical Syllogism thus, Every one that loveth the brethren is translated from death to life, But I love the brethren, Therefore I am translated from death to life. Therefore a late Authour (Cornwell in his Treatise of Justification, ⟨p. 54⟩pag. 17.) denieth, The faith wrought in such a practical Syllogism, to be by the power of the Lord Almighty, but only in the strength of humane reason, and therefore is only an humane faith. But this is a very dangerous Assertion, and like that which the Jesuites would impose upon the Protestants concerning a doctrinal Faith thus, There is Veroniana Methodus, by which the Jesuites would conclude the Protestants have no faith, because (say they) the object of faith must be according to the Protestants, Purum putum verbum Dei, the meer word of God, but now there is nothing, which the Protestants believe, but they conclude it by way of a Syllogism, and in this Syllogism, the Assumption or the meer inference is not in Scripture, or they may erre in making the inference, and so they have no conclusion de fide. But all this is sophistry, for a proxim and immediate conclusion is in the principle, and so believed with the same faith that the principle is, and when a man by reason makes a conclusion, his reason is only the Instrument, not the Argument of his faith, his reason is not the ground of his faith, nor doth it suggest the matter to be believed, but is the instrument to discover it. As he that diggeth in a mine of gold, his instruments he useth in removing the earth that covered it, do not make the gold, but discover it. And as for this practical Syllogism, it is not made by meer humane reason, for when the soul makes the assumption, it doth it, being sanctified and enlightned by the Spirit of God, and so is an instrument in his hand, for there is the same proportion between the Spirit of God in spiritual things, and reason in philosophical things; so that as in Philosophy, reason makes the major and minor in any Syllogism; so in spiritual things, the Spirit of God enableth a man to make a whole Syllogism for a believers comfort and establishment.
- 1Doubt 6.