But though there be not any good disposition in the soul towards Christ, in partaking of his Supper, yet is it not necessary that vile and wicked dispositions should be excluded? No, there is no more need of this than the other. The mind and the heart may actually entertain such as are sinful; without any more danger than it rejects those that are good. It is but a slight fault (r)to communicate out of ostentation and vain glory; and so to nourish pride while he should be feeding upon Christ; and to design his own honour without any act of reverence for Christ: he may let his thoughts run out upon vanity, or entertain his soul with vain delights, without the least motion of love, or delight, or desire for Christ, without the least act of Faith in him: and may be pleasing himself with sin, in stead of grieving for it; when he hath the greatest advantage to look upon him whom he hath pierced. And all this he may do without any guilt, that need be repented of, or regarded. This is all the worship and honour that it is needful their souls should give to Christ, even in the Sacrament of his body ⟨p. 51⟩and blood; who will have others cursed to hell, and burnt beforehand, for not giving divine worship to a Wafer. But this is not all, their Church will be satisfied with greater indignity offered to Christ than this: for they teach, that those who communicate unworthily, to such a degree as they count sacrilege, (and that so heinous, as they question whether it be not as tolerable, to cast that which they count their God, to be devoured by dogs; or throw it into the dirt to be trampled on; and (t)many of them are positive, that it is greater wickedness than murder or adultery, or that uncleanness against nature, which is most abominable) (u)do fully satisfy the precept of the Church for this Communion. Thus Soto, Corduba, Covarruvius, and others alleged by them. And this is all derived from their St. Thomas, that Maxim of his so generally received. (x)The Law commanding an act, enjoins the substance of it, but not the manner. By which we must understand, that the Church would have the thing done, but regards not how they do it, whether as Christians or as Atheists.
But though there be not any good disposition in the soul towards Christ, in partaking of his Supper, yet is it not necessary that vile and wicked dispositions should be excluded? No, there is no more need of this than the other. The mind and the heart may actually entertain such as are sinful; without any more danger than it rejects those that are good. It is but a slight fault (r)to communicate out of ostentation and vain glory; and so to nourish pride while he should be feeding upon Christ; and to design his own honour without any act of reverence for Christ: he may let his thoughts run out upon vanity, or entertain his soul with vain delights, without the least motion of love, or delight, or desire for Christ, without the least act of Faith in him: and may be pleasing himself with sin, in stead of grieving for it; when he hath the greatest advantage to look upon him whom he hath pierced. And all this he may do without any guilt, that need be repented of, or regarded. This is all the worship and honour that it is needful their souls should give to Christ, even in the Sacrament of his body ⟨p. 51⟩and blood; who will have others cursed to hell, and burnt beforehand, for not giving divine worship to a Wafer. But this is not all, their Church will be satisfied with greater indignity offered to Christ than this: for they teach, that those who communicate unworthily, to such a degree as they count sacriledge, (and that so hainous, as they question whether it be not as tolerable, to cast that which they count their God, to be devoured by dogs; or throw it into the dirt to be trampled on; and (t)many of them are positive, that it is greater wickedness than murther or adultery, or that uncleanness against nature, which is most abominable) (u)do fully satisfy the precept of the Church for this Communion. Thus Soto, Corduba, Covarruvius, and others alledged by them. And this is all derived from their St. Thomas, that Maxim of his so generally received. (x)The Law commanding an act, injoyns the substance of it, but not the manner. By which we must understand, that the Church would have the thing done, but regards not how they do it, whether as Christians or as Atheists.
- (r)Dicendum videtur, si peccatum venial sit aliquando circumstantia ipsius actus communicandi, peccatum esse veniale sic communicare v. g. si quis communicat propter ostentationem seu vanam gloriam; vel certe si actu sit in ipso peccato veniali, ut in vana aliqua cogitation aut delectatione, & ea ratione accedat distractus, & sine debita attention & devotion, ibid. disp. 66. Sect. 1. Ostentation and vain-glory are here counted venial faults, because they are directly opposite to the act of communicating: and so is outward irreverence, vain prating, and gestures, inconsistent with modesty, while they are at the Sacrament, for the same reason. But other sins, not so opposite to the act, as studying a lye, or revenge, or detraction, (or uncleanness, or any the like in venial degrees) while they are communicating (though the distraction there be voluntary, and all holy fervour be thereby hindered,) are no faults at all in reference to the Sacrament. Jo. Sanc. disp. 23. alleging for it Scotus, Richardus de St. Vict. Major, Adrian, Margarita Casuum, Soto, Marcella, Ledesma, Vivaldus, Coriolanus, and divers others, n. 20. 21.Dicendum videtur, si peccatum veniale sit aliquando circumstantia ipsius actus communicandi, peccatum esse veniale sic communicare v. g. si quis communicat propter ostentationem seu vanam gloriam; vel certe si actu sit in ipso peccato veniali, ut in vana aliqua cogitatione aut delectatione, & ea ratione accedat distractus, & sine debita attentione & devotione, ibid. disp. 66. Sect. 1. Ostentation and vain-glory are here counted venial faults, because they are directly opposite to the act of communicating: and so is outward irreverence, vain prating, and gestures, inconsistent with modesty, while they are at the Sacrament, for the same reason. But other sins, not so opposite to the act, as studying a lye, or revenge, or detraction, (or uncleanness, or any the like in venial degrees) while they are communicating (though the distraction there be voluntary, and all holy fervour be thereby hindred,) are no faults at all in reference to the Sacrament. Jo. Sanc. disp. 23. alledging for it Scotus, Richardus de St. Vict. Maior, Adrian, Margarita Casuum, Soto, Marcella, Ledesma, Vivaldus, Coriolanus, and divers others, n. 20. 21.
- (t)An hoc peccatum sit gravius homicidio—aut adulterio, vel omnibus peccatis contra naturam: quidam enim Theologi ita existimant, ut Gabriel. Petr. Soto, Ledesma, Dominic. Soto, Suar. ibid. Sect. 2.
- (u)Dicendum est cum qui voluntarie suscipit sacramentum Eucharistiae, etiamsi indigne sumat, implere praeceptum communicandi; etiamsi alias peccet mortaliter per sacrilegium indignae sumptionis. Ita tenet in specie Corduba in genere Soto, Covarruvius, qui alios referunt, ibid. disp. 70. Sect. 3.