It cannot be denied, but they are liable to gross mistakes, about the object of their Worship here; and some of them acknowledge, that the people herein are deluded with great and detestable (h)impostures. What if the Tooth which they Worship for St. Christophers (as big as a mans (*)fist) should prove the Tooth of a Beast? or the Hair, which they Worship as part of St. Peter's Beard, should be the excrement of some Malefactor? or the shift which they Worship as the Virgin Mary's, should be the covering of some Harlot? or the dust, or the Vermin which they Worship, as the remains of some Saints, should have been in their original, no more holy than a Brute or a damned sinner? as great mistakes as these about their Relics, the World has discovered, and themselves have been convinced of. Valla, a person of great learning, and eminency amongst them, says plainly, (i)There are ten thousand such things (counterfeit Relics) in Rome it self. And if the seat of infallibility be so well stored with cheats, what shall we think of other places? They say indeed they have the attestation of Visions, Revelations, Miracles to insure them: but these they have, and produce as well for those that are confessed to be counterfeits, as for them which they take to be true. So that they are proved beyond all question, to be all alike: the true ones, as very ⟨p. 187⟩counterfeits as any; and the counterfeit, as true as the best. Now, may they with safety venture to Worship them for all this? Yes, their Devotion is maintained to be not only safe, but meritorious, however they be deluded about the object of it. They may worship at all adventure, what they take to be a Relic, though it be indeed no such thing: and yet be so far from Idolatry or any sin, that they deserve highly at Gods hand by so doing. If (k)any man think, says one, that to be a Relic of a Saint, which indeed is not so, he is not frustrate of the merit of his Devotion. Yea a man may merit by a mistaken belief, though he should worship the Devil, says another. (l)So that they have not only a fair excuse, but great encouragement to venture; though they may happen to Worship the Devil himself, and not only some limb of him, instead of Christ, or his Saints, or their remains. When the Lord declares Deut. 32. That his Wrath should burn to the bottom of Hell, for that the Israelites Worshipped Devils instead of God:
It cannot be denyed, but they are lyable to grosse mistakes, about the object of their Worship here; and some of them acknowledge, that the people herein are deluded with great and detestable (h)impostures. What if the Tooth which they Worship for St. Christophers (as bigg as a mans (*)fist) should prove the Tooth of a Beast? or the Hair, which they Worship as part of St. Petes Beard, should be the excrement of some Malefactor? or the shift which they Worship as the Virgin Maries, should be the covering of some Harlot? or the dust, or the Vermine which they Worship, as the remains of some Saints, should have been in their original, no more holy than a Bruit or a damned sinner? as great mistakes as these about their Reliques, the World has discovered, and themselves have been convinced of. Valla, a person of great learning, and eminency amongst them, sayes plainly, (i)There are ten thousand such things (counterfeit Reliques) in Rome it self. And if the seat of infallibility be so well stored with cheats, what shall we think of other places? They say indeed they have the attestation of Visions, Revelations, Miracles to insure them: but these they have, and produce as well for those that are confessed to be counterfeits, as for them which they take to be true. So that they are proved beyond all question, to be all alike: the true ones, as very ⟨p. 187⟩counterfeits as any; and the counterfeit, as true as the best. Now, may they with safety venture to Worship them for all this? Yes, their Devotion is maintained to be not only safe, but meritorious, however they be deluded about the object of it. They may worship at all adventure, what they take to be a Relique, though it be indeed no such thing: and yet be so far from Idolatry or any sin, that they deserve highly at Gods hand by so doing. If (k)any man think, sayes one, that to be a Relique of a Saint, which indeed is not so, he is not frustrate of the merit of his Devotion. Yea a man may merit by a mistaken belief, though he should worship the Devil, sayes another. (l)So that they have not only a fair excuse, but great incouragement to venture; though they may happen to Worship the Devil himself, and not only some limb of him, instead of Christ, or his Saints, or their remains. When the Lord declares
- (h)Ingentes & detestandae imposturae patefierent. Cassand. Consult. c. de reliquijs.
- (*)L. vives in August. de civit. Dei l. 15. c. 9. Dens molaris pugno Major.
- (i)Decem millia talium rerum Romae sunt. De Constant. donat.
- (k)Si quis putans aliquam esse particulam sancti, quae non est, merito suae devotionis non caret. Vasque ibid. cap. ult. n 114.
- (l)Holcot infra.