Section 19
pp. 291–2932 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sect. 19. Envy is another capital crime, and in general they inveigh against it, as (l)a Devilish wickedness; yet when they come to give particular rules for Conscience and practice, they leave room enough for the entertainment of it in the hearts and lives of their Catholics: the general notion of it, is an excessive grief at the good of others, but all are acquitted from mortal quiet, who grieve at others good, because it may be prejudicial to themselves, or because they want it. So ⟨p. 292⟩far a man may envy all in the world, who have more worth, honour, or power, or prosperity than himself. (m)This may be good or evil, but evil in no other degree, than the desire of temporals, which when it is excessive, is of it self, by their doctrine, but Venial. Or they may grieve at others good, (n)because they think those who have it, unworthy of it. Grief or Indignation at the outward happiness of others, upon this account solely, is of it self a Venial fault with Aquinas and Cajetan. But why evil at all? the reason is because, since that which is grieved at, is neither an evil of sin or punishment, it seems in a manner to reprove God, and to grieve, as though there were injustice in the Dispenser of these things. All the envy in the world may find shelter and security in these decisions as a harmless Venial. If this last mentioned be not Envy, what is? why a grief at the good of others, as it lessens and obscures our proper worth or excellency. But he that thinks others more unworthy, and himself far better, will think it a lessening and obscuring his own worth, to have it so over-looked; and that which they distinguish and mince in speculation, will go down together in practice. However, two limitations they add, which will commonly excuse Envy: it must be betwixt equals(o), and so Grief at the prosperity of Inferiors, or Superiors at least, will be acquitted. Also, if it be for little things, (p)it is Venial. Now all Temporals are little things to him who has the Eternal in his prospect; so way is made to acquit all envy for outward prosperity, which yet they make the only