pp. 56–6224 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Object. 1. Paul and Barnabas, and the ⟨p. 57⟩other Brethren sent by the Church of Antioch, were sent unto the Elders and Apostles, vers. 2. but we do not read that the Churches were sent unto, which in ordinary Synods order calls for.
Object. 1. Paul and Barnabas, and the ⟨p. 57⟩other Brethren sent by the Church of Antioch, were sent unto the Elders and Apostles, vers. 2. but we doe not read that the Churches were sent unto, which in ordinary Synods order calls for.
Resp. 1. Though it be not in so many words expressed that the Churches were sent unto, yet it cannot be denied but they might be sent unto implicitly, though not explicitly.
Resp. 1. Though it be not in so many words expressed that the Churches were sent unto, yet it cannot be denyed but they might be sent unto implicitely, though not explicitely.
2 'Tis not to be doubted, but that the Church of Antioch, and the Church of Jerusalem, walked by the same rule: As therefore Paul and Barnabas went not to this Assembly without the cognizance of the Church of Antioch, so we may well think the Apostles and Elders at Jerusalem came not to this Assembly without the cognizance of the Church of Jerusalem.
3 Considering the extraordinary power of the Apostles: It is a sufficient acknowledgement of the liberty of Churches, that they had orderly and seasonable notice of the Assembly, were present at it, and were joined together with the Apostles in the conclusions of it; all which are manifest from the ⟨p. 58⟩Text, either in express words, or just Consequence from thence, vers. 4.22,23.
3 Considering the extraordinary power of the Apostles: It is a sufficient acknowledgment of the liberty of Churches, that they had orderly and seasonable notice of the Assembly, were present at it, and were joyned together with the Apostles in the conclusions of it; all which are manifest from the ⟨p. 58⟩Text, either in expresse words, or just Consequence from thence, vers. 4.22,23.
Object. 2. Our Synods consisting only of such Members as are Messengers of Churches, seem not to be exemplified by that, Acts 15. because that Assembly was constituted not of Messengers of the Church of Antioch, and the whole Fraternity of the Church of Jerusalem.
Object. 2. Our Synods consisting onely of such Members as are Messengers of Churches, seem not to be exemplified by that, Acts 15. because that Assembly was constituted not of Messengers of the Church of Antioch, and the whole Fraternity of the Church of Jerusalem.
Resp. 1. It's not to be doubted but the Apostles and Elders were present, according to the desire of the Church of Jerusalem, and so were as Messengers.
2 'Tis all one upon this point, whether a Church be present by the Fraternity it self, or by their Messengers: If conveniency of the place, and transaction of affairs will permit, 'tis at the choice of the Fraternity to be present immediately, or to send their Messengers.
2 'Tis all one upon this point, whether a Church be present by the Fraternity it selfe, or by their Messengers: If conveniency of the place, and transaction of affaires will permit, 'tis at the choyce of the Fraternity to be present immediately, or to send their Messengers.
3 What the Fraternity of Jerusalem did here, the like may the Fraternity of any Church in like cases do with us; as the Church of Cambridge (for instance) now if they please.
3 What the Fraternity of Jerusalem did here, the like may the Fraternity of any Church in like cases doe with us; as the Church of Cambridge (for instance) now if they please.
4 Where the Fraternity is present formally, there the Messengers are present virtually.
5 In such cases where the presence of the Fraternity immediately, or sending of Messengers are occasional circumstances (of which before) 'tis in the liberty of the Fraternity to do as they judge most for their Edification.
5 In such cases where the presence of the Fraternity immediately, or sending of Messengers are occasionall circumstances (of which before) 'tis in the liberty of the Fraternity to doe as they judge most for their Edification.
Object. 3. The judgement of the question in our Synods or Assemblies, ordinarily proceeds jointly from the Messengers of all Churches; at least the major part of them. But the judgement concerning matters agitated in that Synod, Acts 15. seems to proceed from one part thereof only, namely the Church of Jerusalem, as appears by the Letters sent from thence, not mentioning any part of that judgement, as proceeding from the Church Messengers of Antioch.
Object. 3. The judgement of the question in our Synods or Assemblies, ordinarily proceeds joyntly from the Messengers of all Churches; at least the major part of them. But the judgement concerning matters agitated in that Synod, Acts 15. seems to proceed from one part thereof onely, namely the Church of Jerusalem, as appears by the Letters sent from thence, not mentioning any part of that judgement, as proceeding from the Church Messengers of Antioch.
Resp. 1. We may distinguish between the Synods passing for acts of judgement upon the Question discussed, and the sending of that judgement passed by the Synod. That the Messengers of the Church of Antioch did judge jointly with the Church of Jerusalem, concerning ⟨p. 60⟩the matters agitated in that Synod, appears thus: In every regular discharge of the duty of the Church-messengers in a Synod where there is a concurrence of ability, right, and duty, to pass an actual judgement, as declarative to the truth, there was an actual judgement.
Resp. 1. We may distinguish between the Synods passing for acts of judgement upon the Question discussed, and the sending of that judgement passed by the Synod. That the Messengers of the Church of Antioch did judge joyntly with the Church of Jerusalem, concerning ⟨p. 60⟩the matters agitated in that Synod, appears thus: In every regular discharge of the duty of the Church-messengers in a Synod where there is a concurrence of ability, right, and duty, to passe an actuall judgement, as declarative to the truth, there was an actuall judgement.
But such was the case in this Synod, ergo.
The Reason why the judgement of the Church of Jerusalem, and not of the Messengers of the Church of Antioch, is only made mention of in the letter, might be, because the judgement of the Church-Messengers of Antioch was already known to the Church; nor had they any doubt of their Messengers concurrence with the Church of Jerusalem in the present Conclusions; if there were any doubt in that respect, they were personally present to satisfy it.
The Reason why the judgement of the Church of Jerusalem, and not of the Messengers of the Church of Antioch, is onely made mention of in the letter, might be, because the judgement of the Church-Messengers of Antioch was already known to the Church; nor had they any doubt of their Messengers concurrence with the Church of Jerusalem in the present Conclusions; if there were any doubt in that respect, they were personally present to satisfie it.
2 Because the contrary minded had already signified their non acquiescence or not resting, either in the judgement of the Church of Antioch, or their Messengers, in the delivery of the Decrees of the Synod unto Churches, there appears ⟨p. 61⟩not any cause out of the Text, to doubt the delivery of the same, as the joint judgement of them all, but the contrary.
2 Because the contrary minded had already signified their non acquiescence or not resting, either in the judgement of the Church of Antioch, or their Messengers, in the delivery of the Decrees of the Synod unto Churches, there appears ⟨p. 61⟩not any cause out of the Text, to doubt the delivery of the same, as the joynt judgement of them all, but the contrary.
Resp. 1. Paul and Barnabas here are not properly parties, in that they act not their own case, but the case of the truth, & that as sent from the Church.
Resp. 1. Paul and Barnabas here are not properly parties, in that they act not their owne case, but the case of the truth, & that as sent from the Church.
2 Though they be supposed to be parties, yet it's not universally true, that a party may not be a Judge.
As 1 In case the party offended be a society: or some public person equivalent.
As 1 In case the party offended be a society: or some publick person equivalent.
2 In case the party in such acts of judgement, be freed from error; which was the present condition of the Apostles, guided in their administrations by an infallible spirit.
Object. 5. This Synod, Acts 15. 1so speaketh, as having power to lay the truth of God (cleared and declared by it) as a burden upon the Churches, v. 28. which our ordinary Synods seem not to have power to do.
Object. 5. This Synod, Acts 15. 1so speaketh, as having power to lay the truth of God (cleared and declared by it) as a burthen upon the Churches, v. 28. which our ordinary Synods seem not to have power to doe.
Resp. The notion or term [burden] ⟨p. 62⟩may be taken politically (i. e.) for a truth imposed by virtue of Church power and Authority: this though the Apostles as Apostles might do, yet if they did so in this place (which we rather conceive not) it was extraordinary, and Consequently not Exemplary.
Resp. The notion or tearm [burthen] ⟨p. 62⟩may be taken politically (i. e.) for a truth imposed by virtue of Church power and Authority: this though the Apostles as Apostles might doe, yet if they did so in this place (which we rather conceive not) it was extraordinary, and Consequently not Exemplary.
Or the word Burden, may be taken for the charging of the Church to receive and yield Obedience in the Lord unto the truth, discussed, cleared, and orderly commanded to them: In which sense if we take it here according as it's taken in divers places elsewhere, Pro. 30.1. & 21.1. Rev. 2.24. then the stile or manner of speaking is exemplary.
Or the word Burthen, may be taken for the charging of the Church to receive and yield Obedience in the Lord unto the truth, discussed, cleared, and orderly commanded to them: In which sense if we take it here according as it's taken in divers places elswhere, Pro. 30.1. & 21.1. Rev. 2.24. then the stile or manner of speaking is exemplary.