Contradiction 18
pp. 72–733 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The 18th Contradiction is thus stated.
18. The form of the visible Church is the Covenant, either explicit, or implicit: and the latter is sometimes fully sufficient Mr. H. Surv. part. 1. pag. 47. 48 and others. | 18. You say an implicit uniting, viz. A walking and communicating with you is a sufficient evidencing of the Form: we say, Their solemn confession of their faith & express open covenanting with the Lord to wake with such a body of Saints, in all the ways of Christ to be the manifest Form. D. Holmes ibid. | 18. It is not general Profession will serve the turn, but there must be a peculiar engagement and appropriation to this or that particular body, Mr. H. Surv. pag 63. Yet he said An Implicit Covenant was sufficient.
18. The forme of the visible Church is the Covenant, either explicite, or implicite: and the latter is sometimes fully sufficient Mr. H. Surv. part. 1. pag. 47. 48 and others. | 18. You say an implicit uniting, viz. A walking and communicating with you is a sufficient evidencing of the Forme: we say, Their folemne confession of their faith & expresse open covenanting with the Lord to wake with such a body of Saints, in all the wayes of Christ to be the manifest Forme. D. Holmes ibid. | 18. It is not generall Profession will serve the turne, but there must be a peculiar engagement and appropriation to this or that particular body, Mr. H. Surv. pag 63. Yet he said An Implicite Covenant was sufficient.
Ans. The expressions of Mr H. quoted in Column 1: and Column 3: will not amount to an opposition of himself, much less to a Contradiction. For though he make an Implicit Covenant sufficient, yet a general Profession will not serve the turn; to make an Implicit Covenant. For an Implicit Covenant must be with Reference to this or that particular Body: or else it is neither Covenant at all, nor Implicit. A General ⟨p. 73⟩Profession entereth not any man into any Relation with any Church, unless he offer himself to Join with them as Mr Hooker in that Place more largely, & truly openeth himself. Neither doth Dr Holmes his expression contradict him. For he that maketh the explicit Covenant the manifest form of the Church, He doth not gainsay the implicit covenant to be a real Form of the Church, though not so manifest but more obscure.