AN APPENDIX: Containing a Full and Modest Reply to Mr. Philip Cary's Rejoinder to my Vindiciae Legis & Foederis.
pp. 167–305235 passagespart 2 of 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
First, How far did the Covenant of Grace prevail against the Covenant of Works? Was it so far prevalent and victorious as utterly to vanquish and disannul ⟨p. 188⟩it, as a Covenant of Works to them? or was it not? Was the Victory you speak of, a complete, or a partial one? If you say it was incomplete and partial, then you leave them (as I told you before you must) partly under the Promise, and partly under the Curse; justified in part, and condemned in part. But if you say, it was a complete and perfect Victory, then it utterly dissolved its obligation as a Covenant of Works; then they did not remain under two opposite Covenants, as you affirmed they did; but on their believing, changed their state with their Covenant, as we affirm they did.
First, How far did the Covenant of Grace prevail against the Covenant of Works? Was it so far prevalent and victorious as utterly to vanquish and disannul ⟨p. 188⟩it, as a Covenant of Works to them? or was it not? Was the Victory you speak of, a compleat, or a partial one? If you say it was incompleat and partial, then you leave them (as I told you before you must) partly under the Promise, and partly under the Curse; justified in part, and condemned in part. But if you say, it was a compleat and perfect Victory, then it utterly dissolved its obligation as a Covenant of Works; then they did not remain under two opposite Covenants, as you affirmed they did; but on their believing, changed their state with their Covenant, as we affirm they did.
Secondly, If you say, it did not totally free them from the Curse of the Covenant of Works, but however prevailed so far that they were not actually damned by virtue of the Curse; then be pleased to answer me one Question more, How it was possible for them to be absolutely under the Curse of the Law (as you affirmed they were) and yet that Curse to be so superseded by the Covenant of Grace, as here you speak?
Secondly, If you say, it did not totally free them from the Curse of the Covenant of Works, but however prevailed so far that they were not actually damned by vertue of the Curse; then be pleased to answer me one Question more, How it was possile for them to be absolutely under the Curse of the Law (as you affirmed they were) and yet that Curse to be so superseded by the Covenant of Grace, as here you speak?