This Argument is disproved in the Schools of Logicians; for it is a Sophism (a non causa ut causa.) Therefore I answer to the Major: The Faith that is lively is not alone without Charity: That is true in working, but not in justifying. Therefore as touching the Cause and Office of Justifying, this is not the consequence thereof: Therefore in Justifying, Faith ⟨p. 505⟩is not alone without Charity. But as for the the Minor, though Faith that justifies is called lively in respect of good Works, yet it doth not justify in respect of those Works, but only upon the account of its Object, which, because Faith only without Charity embraces; therefore Faith only without Charity receives from thence the power of 1Justifying. If all things that any way are, or are done together, should be joined in one and the same Office, it would come to pass, that he that hath Feet, Eyes and Ears, because he hath not these Members alone, therefore he should be said to go not with his Feet only, but to walk with his Eyes, and see with his Ears, as hath been formerly demonstrated. Just so the case is in Faith, Charity, and other Virtues: Which tho' being infused by Grace, they inhere 2in the same subject, yet each one of them are distinguished by their peculiar Offices. Therefore if it be asked concerning the Office of Justification, What it is that reconciles us to God, and procures Eternal Life for us? I answer, it is Faith, and that only. If you ask; how? I answer, by Christ, the Mediator. Again, if you ask, what manner of Faith that is? I answer, It is not an idle or dead Faith, but lively and active. But if you would know by what marks you distinguish between a true Faith, and that which is counterfeit? St. Paul answers that question; The Faith, that is true, works by Love.
This Argument is disproved in the Schools of Logicians; for it is a Sophism (a non causa ut causa.) Therefore I answer to the Major: The Faith that is lively is not alone without Charity: That is true in working, but not in justifying. Therefore as touching the Cause and Office of Iustifying, this is not the consequence thereof: Therefore in Iustifying, Faith ⟨p. 505⟩is not alone without Charity. But as for the the Minor, though Faith that justifies is called lively in respect of good Works, yet it doth not justifie in respect of those Works, but only upon the account of its Object, which, because Faith only without Charity embraces; therefore Faith only without Charity receives from thence the power of 1Iustifying. If all things that any way are, or are done together, should be joyned in one and the same Office, it would come to pass, that he that hath Feet, Eyes and Ears, because he hath not these Members alone, therefore he should be said to go not withhis Feet only, but to walk with his Eyes, and see with his Ears, as hath been formerly demonstrated. Iust so the case is in Faith, Charity, and other Vertues: Which tho' being infused by Grace, they inhere 2in the same subject, yet each one of them are distinguished by their peculiar Offices. Therefore if it be asked concerning the Office of Iustification, What it is that reconciles us to God, and procures Eternal Life for us? I answer, it is Faith, and that only. If you ask; how? I answer, by Christ, the Mediatour. Again, if you ask, what manner of Faith that is? I answer, It is not an idle or dead Faith, but lively and active. But if you would know by what marks you distinguish between a true Faith, and that which is counterfeit? St. Paul answers that question; The Faith, that is true, works by Love.
- 1Why Faith is alone in Justifying.Why Faith is alone in Iustifying.
- 2How Faith, Charity, and other virtues are joined together.How Faith, Charity, and other vertues are joyned together.