But perhaps too much hath been said of those things, which, being clear enough of themselves, would not at this time need any Explication, unless I were forced thereunto by the Calumnies of Hosius, Osorius, and such Others, whose Opinion seems to me, to be faulty upon a Twofold account. 1First, in that they think this Doctrine of Christian Assurance, which we Establish in Christ, should by no means be endured in the Church, and which they call Confidence and Presumption, than which they affirm, that nothing is more hurtful and pernicious to the Salvation of the Godly. Hosius adds his own Judgment; that to him no Abomination (as he expresses himself) seems greater in the sight of God, than this so great presumption of the Heretics: Neither wants he here his Authorities 2wrested from the Scriptures: What, saith he, doth not the command of the Gospel teach us, to confess our selves to be unprofitable Servants in all respects, yea, when we have performed all that God commanded us: From whence Hosius presently gathers, that he who assures himself that he is in a State of Grace, he doth as much as if contrary to the command of the Lord, he called himself a profitable Servant. O Wise Headpiece! As if this Assurance and full Persuasion, which we maintain, did rely on any Dignity of ours, and did not wholly depend upon the certainty of the promise of ⟨p. 305⟩God. I come to their other Calumny, no less absurd, whereby they most unjustly slander us, as if we referred the whole cause of our Justification to nothing else but only an opinionative assurance; so that to obtain the Remission of sins, we taught that no other thing is necessary, but that every Man should, by a special faith, be persuaded in his own mind, that his sins are forgiven him, which is most false, as there is almost nothing true in the Books of Hosius. For though we confess this to be most sure, that nothing is more sure than our Justification by Christ; yet if the cause be enquired for, which properly justifies us from our sins, we answer, It is faith, not whereby we believe that we are Justified, (as Hosius chatters) but whereby we believe in Christ the Son of God, who only is a propitiation for our sin.
But perhaps too much hath been said of those things, which, being clear enough of themselves, would not at this time need any Explication, unless I were forced thereunto by the Calumnies of Hosius, Osorius, and such Others, whose Opinion seems to me, to be faulty upon a Twofold account. 1First, in that they think this Doctrine of Christian Assurance, which we Establish in Christ, should by no means be endured in the Church, and which they call Confidence and Presumption, than which they affirm, that nothing is more hurtful and pernicious to the Salvation of the Godly. Hosius adds his own Iudgment; that to him no Abomination (as he expresses himself) seems greater in the sight of God, than this so great presumption of the Hereticks: Neither wants he here his Authorities 2wrested from the Scriptures: What, saith he, doth not the command of the Gospel teach us, to confess our selves to be unprofitable Servants in all respects, yea, when we have performed all that God commanded us: From whence Hosius presently gathers, that he who assures himself that he is in a State of Grace, he doth as much as if contrary to the command of the Lord, he called himself a profitable Servant. O Wise Headpiece! As if this Assurance and full Perswasion, which we maintain, did rely on any Dignity of ours, and did not wholly depend upon the certainty of the promise of ⟨p. 305⟩God. I come to their other Calumny, no less absurd, whereby they most unjustly slander us, as if we referred the whole cause of our Iustification to nothing else but only an opinionative assurance; so that to obtain the Remission of sins, we taught that no other thing is necessary, but that every Man should, by a special faith, be perswaded in his own mind, that his sins are forgiven him, which is most false, as there is almost nothing true in the Books of Hosius. For though we confess this to be most sure, that nothing is more sure than our Iustification by Christ; yet if the cause be enquired for, which properly justifies us from our sins, we answer, It is faith, not whereby we believe that we are Iustified, (as Hosius chatters) but whereby we believe in Christ the Son of God, who only is a propitiation for our sin.
- 1A twofold Calumny of the Papists.
- 2Hosius in confut. lib. 1. pag. 14.