pp. 404–4063 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. This is no more a good argument to prove that the obtruders of circumcision did teach false doctrine, and were not condemned by the Apostles and Elders Synodically, then if one should say, this is not a Synodical decree of the Church, because it is proven and made good by the Word of God, for ⟨p. 405⟩Synodical decrees exclude not Gods word, though they be not formally Scripture; for in some part of the Epistle the Apostles may well speak of themselves as distinguished from Elders and as Apostles, and yet the assembly is an ordinary Synod and not an Apostolic meeting, for if we should argue thus, the whole Church, men and women, v. 22. sent messengers to Antioch, as the Church, and not as Apostles, our brethren would think it a weak consequence to infer, Ergo, this was nothing but a Congregational, not an Apostolical meeting. Yet our brethren contend that the whole Church and single Congregation of Jerusalem did concur in this meeting as consenters, and having power also, though not of jurisdiction; but I wonder why our brethren should so contend that there was no power of censuring put forth in this Assembly, seeing one of their special answers, whereby they would prove that this it not a pattern of an ordinary Synod, and such a Synod as we contend for, having power of jurisdiction is, that this was an ordinary meeting of the Elders and Church of Jerusalem, giving counsel and advise with the Apostles to the Church of Antioch, but I am sure the business of not scandalizing did as much concern the Church of Jerusalem, and therefore in the Synod they ought to put forth power of jurisdiction, if any of their members, hearing that the Apostles contended that the ceremonial Law did not lay a tie on the conscience of either Jew or Gentile, in foro dei, before Gods court, as the places cited by James prove, v. 15, 16, 17. (& Peter saith expressly that God now putteth no difference betwixt Jews and Gentiles, v. 9. but […] are saved through the grace of our Lord Jesus, v. 11.) should ab •aine from blood, to the offence of the weaker, should not this Congregation all Church condemn such, in ordine ad censuram, in order to excommunication?
Answ. This is no more a good argument to prove that the obtruders of circumcision did teach false doctrine, and were not condemned by the Apostles and Elders Synodically, then if one should say, this is not a Synodicall decree of the Church, because it is proven and made good by the Word of God, for ⟨p. 405⟩Synodicall decrees exclude not Gods word, though they bee not formally Scripture; for in some part of the Epistle the Apostles may well speak of themselves as distinguished from Elders and as Apostles, and yet the assembly is an ordinary Synod and not an Apostolick meeting, for if wee should argue thus, the whole Church, men and women, v. 22. sent messengers to Antioch, as the Church, and not as Apostles, our brethren would thinke it a weake consequence to inferre, Ergo, this was nothing but a Congregational, not an Apostolical meeting. Yet our brethren contend that the whole Church and single Congregation of Ierusalem did concurre in this meeting as consenters, and having power also, though not of jurisdiction; but I wonder why our brethren should so contend that there was no power of censuring put forth in this Assembly, seeing one of their speciall answers, whereby they would prove that this it not a patterne of an ordinary Synod, and such a Synod as wee contend for, having power of jurisdiction is, that this was an ordinary meeting of the Elders and Church of Ierusalem, giving counsell and advise with the Apostles to the Church of Antioch, but I am sure the businesse of not scandalizing did as much concerne the Church of Ierusalem, and therefore in the Synod they ought to put forth power of jurisdiction, if any of their members, hearing that the Apostles contended that the ceremoniall Law did not lay a tie on the conscience of either Jew or Gentile, in foro dei, before Gods court, as the places cited by Iames prove, v. 15, 16, 17. (& Peter saith expresly that God now putteth no difference betwixt Iewes and Gentiles, v. 9. but 〈…〉 are saved through the grace of our Lord Iesus, v. 11.) should ab •aine from blood, to the offence of the weaker, should not this Congregation all Church condemne such, in ordine ad censuram, in order to excommunication?
yea the Eldership and Congregation of Jerusalem here convened as our brethren say, should have failed in this first Synod, and also the Apostles with them, if they neglected to exercise juridical power over their own Congregation in the case of scandal, and a scandal as possible to them to fall in as the Gentiles, and therefore either this assembly consisting of Apostles and of the particular Church of Jerusalem erred, which we cannot say, or then they did exercise power in order to excommunication towards ⟨p. 406⟩their own Church, and so there is some juridical power put forth in this meeting.
yea the Eldership and Congregation of Jerusalem here convened as our brethren say, should have failed in this first Synod, and also the Apostles with them, if they neglected to exercise juridicall power over their owne Congregation in the case of scandall, and a scandall as possible to them to fall in as the Gentiles, and therefore either this assembly consisting of Apostles and of the particular Church of Ierusalem erred, which wee cannot say, or then they did exercise power in order to excommunication towards ⟨p. 406⟩their owne Church, and so there is some juridicall power put forth in this meeting.