Answ. Surely the aforesaid reverend Brethren of New England have these words, cBut it seemeth to us that the power (of a Synod) is not properly a power and exercise of government and jurisdiction, but a power of doctrine, and so a Synod is rather a •aching then a governing Church; from which I infer; 1. That out Brethren cannot deny a power of governing to a Synod, but it is not so proper governing, as excommunication and ordination performed in their Congregations, but (say I) it is more properly governing, as to make Laws and rules of governing, is a more noble, eminent and higher act of governing (as is evident in the King and his Parliament) then the execution of these Laws and rules. 2. Our brethren incline to make a Synod a teaching Church; but I infer that Synodical teaching by giving out decrees tying many Churches, as our Brethren of dNew England, and the forenamed eauthors teach, is an ordinance of Christ that can be performed in no single Congregation on earth, for a doctrinal Canon of one Congregation can lay no ecclesiastical tie upon many Churches. Ergo, by this reason our Congregations shall be dependent, as were the Jewish Synagogues. 3. With favour of these learned men it is a begging of the question to make Jerusalem the supreme Church, and the Synagogues dependent Churches, because it was lawful only at Jerusalem to sacrifice, for I hold that Jerusalem was a dependent Church no less then the smallest Synagogue in all the tribes, for in a Catholic meeting of all Judah for renewing a Covenant with God, Jerusalem was but a sister Church, with all of Judah, Benjamin, Ephraim, Manasseh, who 2 Chron. 15. 9. 10. 11, 12. made up one great Church which did swear that Covenant. Ordinances ⟨p. 415⟩do not formally make Churches visible, nor divers ordinances divers Churches; profession of the truth formally constituteth a visible Church, and Church union in ordinances and government, and this was alike in the Synagogues and in Jerusalem. It was a thing merely typical that at Jerusalem only, and in the Temple only should there be offerings and sacrifices, because in Christ God-man, all our worship and service and prayers are accepted of the Father, but (I pray you) did this instampe Jerusalem with any note of Church-supremacy above the meanest Synagogue in all Israel and Judah?
Answ. Surely the aforesaid reverend Brethren of New England have these words, cBut it seemeth to us that the power (of a Synod) is not proporly a power and exercise of government and jurisdiction, but a power of doctrine, and so a Synod is rather a •aching then a governing Church; from which I inferre; 1. That out Brethren cannot deny a power of governing to a Synod, but it is not so proper governing, as excommunication and ordination performed in their Congregations, but (say I) it is more properly governing, as to make Lawes and rules of governing, is a more noble, eminent and higher act of governing (as is evident in the King and his Parliament) then the execution of these Lawes and rules. 2. Our brethren incline to make a Synod a teaching Church; but I inferre that Synodicall teaching by giving out decrees tying many Churches, as our Brethren of dNew England, and the forenamed eauthors teach, is an ordinance of Christ that can bee performed in no single Congregation on earth, for a doctrinall Canon of one Congregation can lay no ecclesiasticall tie upon many Churches. Ergo, by this reason our Congregations shall bee dependent, as were the Jewish Synagogues. 3. With favour of these learned men it is a begging of the question to make Jerusalem the supreme Church, and the Synagogues dependent Churches, because it was lawfull onely at Jerusalem to sacrifice, for I hold that Jerusalem was a dependent Church no lesse then the smallest Synagogue in all the tribes, for in a Catholick meeting of all Judah for renewing a Covenant with God, Ierusalem was but a sister Church, with all of Iudah, Benjamin, Ephraim, Manasseh, who 2 Chron. 15. 9. 10. 11, 12. made up one great Church which did sweare that Covenant. Ordinances ⟨p. 415⟩doe not formally make Churches visible, nor divers ordinances divers Churches; profession of the truth formally constituteth a visible Church, and Church union in ordinances and government, and this was alike in the Synagogues and in Ierusalem. It was a thing meerely typicall that at Ierusalem onely, and in the Temple onely should there bee offerings and sacrifices, because in Christ God-man, all our worship and service and prayers are accepted of the Father, but (I pray you) did this instampe Ierusalem with any note of Church-supremacy above the meanest Synagogue in all Israel and Iudah?
- cIb. c. 1. pag. 8.
- dChurch-government of New-England, Answer to q. 14. pag. 43, 44.
- eMr Mather & Mr. Thomson Answer to Mr. Herle, c. 4 pag. 40, 41, sig.