SECT. 1. and 2.
pp. 266–308142 passagespart 1 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 266–308142 passagespart 1 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. What if a member of your Church doe •how himselfe in private, to some brethren, to be a non-regenerated person, and so indeede not a member of the visible Church, by your doctrine, he should be excommunicated for non-regeneration, which is against Christs way, Matth. 18. who will have such sinnes as, if denyed, may be proved by two witnesses, onely to be censurable by the Church, else you shall retaine such an one, and admit him to prophane the Table of the Lord.
In this first and second Section I have nothing to examine but what hath been handled already, especially the Peoples power in Church-affairs hath been fully discussed; only the Author will have the preaching of the word, a worship not peculiar to the Church, but commune to those who are not in the Church-state at all, and that ordinarily in respect that Indians and Heathens may come and hear the Word, 1 Cor. 14. but this proveth not but that preaching of the word is proper and peculiar to the Church: but there is another mystery here, as from the first chapter, second Section, then preaching of the word is to be performed by gifted persons, yea ordinary preaching for the conversion of Souls, before there be any Pastors in the Church to Preach. Hence is that.
In this first and second Section I have nothing to examine but what hath beene handled already, especially the Peoples power in Church-affaires hath beene fully discussed; onely the Author will have the preaching of the word, a worship not pecu•iar to the Church, but commune to those who are not in the Church-state at all, and that ordinarily in respect that Indians and Heathens may come and heare the Word, 1 Cor. 14. but this proveth not but that preaching of the word is proper and peculiar to the Church: but there is another mystery here, as from the first chapter, second Section, then preaching of the word is to be performed by gifted persons, yea ordinary preaching for the conversion of Soules, before there be any Pastors in the Church to Preach. Hence is that.
Quest. I. Whether conversion of souls to Christ, be ordinarily the proper fruit & effect of the word preached by a sent Pastor; or if it be the […] and effect of the word preached by Pastors not as Pastors, but as […] to preach, and so of all persons not in office, yet gifted to preach?
Quest. I. Whether conversion of soules to Christ, be ordinarily the proper fruite & effect of the word preached by a sent Pastor; or if it be the 〈…〉 and effect of the word preached by Pastors not as Pastors, but as 〈…〉 to preach, and so of all persons not in office, yet gifted to preach?
The Churches of New-England in their Answers to the thirty two Questions, sent by the Ministers of Old-England, Answer 1by certain Theses, which I set down and examine.
The Churches of New-England in their Answers to the thirty two Questions, sent by the Ministers of Old-England, Answer 1by certaine Theses, which I set downe and examine.
1. The conversion of sinners followeth not always the preaching of every one that is in lawful office of the Ministry.
1. The conversion of sinners followeth not alwayes the preaching of every one that is in lawfull office of the Ministery.
2. When conversion doth follow, it doth not follow from the preaching of a Pastor, or by virtue of his office, but by the blessing of God.
2. When conversion doth follow, it doth not follow from the preaching of a Pastor, or by vertue of his office, but by the blessing of God.
Answ. 1. The former reason is most weak, conversion followeth not alway upon Christs preaching, and the Apostles their preaching did not always produce conversion: but I pray you because they were not efficacious means of conversion, doth it follow, Therefore they were not ordinary means? I think not.
Answ. 1. The former reason is most weake, conversion followeth not alway upon Christs preaching, and the Apostles their preaching did not alwayes produce conversion: but I pray you because they were not efficacious meanes of conversion, doth it follow, Therefore they were not ordinary meanes? I thinke not.
2. The second is as weak, Conversion followeth not upon the preaching of a Pastor by virtue of his office, but by the blessing of God. What? Ergo, Pastoral preaching is not an ordinary mean of conversion? neither doth conversion follow upon preaching, by virtue of the gift, no more then by virtue of the office, but by the blessing of God: Ergo, neither is preaching of a gifted man, the ordinary mean of conversion, as you teach, nor are the Sacraments by this reason, ordinary means to seal up our communion with Christ, and the graces of the Covenant, for Sacraments are efficacious means only by the blessing of God, and not by virtue of the office; We do not hold that the office hath influence, either in the word preached, or in the Souls of people, but it followeth not that the Pastoral preaching of these who are sent, Rom. 10. 14. Esa. 40. 9. and that with Pastoral authority, are not the means appointed of God for conversion, but here they confound means, actu primo, lawful and ordinary, with means efficacious, and, in actu secundo, blessed with success from the Lord.
2. The second is as weake, Conversion followeth not upon the preaching of a Pastor by vertue of his office, but by the blessing of God. What? Ergo, Pastorall preaching is not an ordinary meane of conversion? neither doth conversion follow upon preaching, by vertue of the gift, no more then by vertue of the office, but by the blessing of God: Ergo, neither is preaching of a gifted man, the ordinary mean of conversion, as you teach, nor are the Sacraments by this reason, ordinary meanes to seale up our communion with Christ, and the graces of the Covenant, for Sacraments are efficacious meanes onely by the blessing of God, and not by vertue of the office; We doe not hold that the office hath influence, either in the word preached, or in the Soules of people, but it followeth not that the Pastorall preaching of these who are sent, Rom. 10. 14. Esa. 40. 9. and that with Pastorall authority, are not the meanes appointed of God for conversion, but here they confound meanes, actu primo, lawfull and ordinary, with meanes efficacious, and, in actu secundo, blessed with successe from the Lord.
This we acknowledge (say they) that sound conversion of sinners, argueth that the instruments of such conversion were sent of God, Rom. 10. 14, 15. Jer. 23. 32. yet we dare not say that Gods word is not effectual to conversion, unless the man that speaketh it be a Minister, that is, a Church-officer, the contrary being evident, Joh. 4. ⟨p. 269⟩10. Act. 8. 4. Matth. 11. 19, 21. 1 Cor. 7. 16. and to say so, mere to limit the Spirit of God, where he hath not limited himself. 1 Cor. 12. 11. 1 Cor. 1. 27. 29.
This we acknowledge (say they) that sound conversion of sinners, argueth that the instruments of such conversion were sent of God, Rom. 10. 14, 15. Jer. 23. 32. yet we dare not say that Gods word is not effectuall to conversion, unlesse the man that speaketh it be a Minister, that is, a Church-officer, the contrary being evident, Joh. 4. ⟨p. 269⟩10. Act. 8. 4. Matth. 11. 19, 21. 1 Cor. 7. 16. and to say so, mere to limit the Spirit of God, where he hath not limited himselfe. 1 Cor. 12. 11. 1 Cor. 1. 27. 29.
Answ. 1. Sending Rom. 10. 14. is an official and authoritative sending, not only a bare gifting and habilitating of the man sent, for it is such a sending, as the sending of Prophets, whose feet were pleasant upon the mountains, and the watchmen who lift up their voice, Esa. 52. 7, 8. Nah. 1. 15. and this is not a naked gifting, but besides they were commanded by God to speak, and so had authority: now though private Christians be instruments of conversion, yet it follows no ways, that they are preachers sent of God, in the sense that the Scripture speaketh, Rom. 10. 14. 15. and far less in the sense that is spoken, Jer. 23. 32. for it is said these who prophesy lies in Gods name, and were not sent, shall profit the people nothing; now the sending denied to be in these false teachers, is not only want of gifts, but want of an authoritative command of God to preach, as is clear, v. 21. I have not sent these Prophets, yet they ran; I have not spoken unto them, yet they prophesied. When it is said, The word of the Lord came to Jeremiah, to Ezekiel, &c. the meaning is not that Jeremiah was gifted only, but beside [Greek or Hebrew], an ability to prophecy, the Lord gave him [Greek or Hebrew], authority by a special Commandment, saying, Go speak, Lo I have sent thee, &c. Now this immediate Commandment from God himself speaking from heaven, or in a vi•on, is not in the Churches of the New Testament, yet God speaketh by the Elders and Presbytery to Pastors now, 1 Tim. 4. 14. 1 Tim. 5. 22. Tit. 1. 9. 10. except you I say with Arminians and Socinians, there is no need now of the Churches sending, all gifted may preach the Gospel, without any Church-call.
Answ. 1. Sending Rom. 10. 14. is an officiall and authoritative sending, not onely a bare gifting and habilitating of the man sent, for it is such a sending, as the sending of Prophets, whose feete were pleasant upon the mountaines, and the watchmen who lift up their voice, Esa. 52. 7, 8. Nah. 1. 15. and this is not a naked gifting, but besides they were commanded by God to speake, and so had authority: now though private Christians be instruments of conversion, yet it followes no wayes, that they are preachers sent of God, in the sense that the Scripture speaketh, Rom. 10. 14. 15. and farre lesse in the sense that is spoken, Jer. 23. 32. for it is said these who prophecie lyes in Gods name, and were not sent, shall profit the people nothing; now the sending denyed to be in these false teachers, is not onely want of gifts, but want of an authoritative command of God to preach, as is cleare, v. 21. I have not sent these Prophets, yet they ranne; I have not spoken unto them, yet they prophecyed. When it is said, The word of the Lord came to Jeremiah, to Ezekiel, &c. the meaning is not that Jeremiah was gifted onely, but beside 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, an hability to prophecy, the Lord gave him 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, authority by a speciall Commandement, saying, Go speake, Loe I have sent thee, &c. Now this immediate Commandement from God himselfe speaking from heaven, or in a vi•on, is not in the Churches of the New Testament, yet God speaketh by the Elders and Presbytery to Pastors now, 1 Tim. 4. 14. 1 Tim. 5. 22. Tit. 1. 9. 10. except you I say with Arminians and Socinians, there is no neede now of the Churches sending, all gifted may preach the Gospell, without any Church-call.
3. This consequence is loose, conversion of sinners argueth that the instruments were sent of God; Ergo, the Preaching of Pastors •• Pastors is not the ordinary mean of conversion.
3. This consequence is loose, conversion of sinners argueth that the instruments were sent of God; Ergo, the Preaching of Pastors •• Pastors is not the ordinary meane of conversion.
Lastly, We deny not but private Christians may be instruments of conversion, but the places which afterward shall be examined, prove not the point, that Pastoral preaching, in a constitute Church, is not the ordinary mean, but your Doctrine ⟨p. 270⟩is that Pastors as Pastors do only confirm those in the faith, who are already converted, but that they convert none at all, as Pastors, but that the only ordinary means of conversion, and of planting of men in formal state of Church-membership are men gifted to preach, and not Pastors by office; Sending (say they) sometimes importeth but an act of Gods providence, whereby men are gifted, and permitted to do such a thing, though they be not commanded of God, nor do in obedience to God, but for sinisterous ends, so God sent the King of Assyria, Isaiah 10. 6. 2 King. 24. 2. So they that preached of envy, Phil. 1. 15. are sent: So Balaam was sent. 2. Some are sent who beside gifts and permission, have also a sincere mind to employ their gifts, God by his Spirit stirring them up, 1 Joh. 7. 18. 3. Those are sent of God, who have both gifts, permission, and a sincere mind to employ their gifts, and withal a lawful calling to the office: if men want a lawful calling to that office of the ministry, and are not sent of God the third way, yet may they preach and convert souls, as sent of God, the first and second way.
Lastly, We deny not but private Christians may be instruments of conversion, but the places which afterward shall be examined, prove not the point, that Pastorall preaching, in a constitute Church, is not the ordinary meane, but your Doctrine ⟨p. 270⟩is that Pastors as Pastors doe onely confirme those in the faith, who are already converted, but that they convert none at all, as Pastors, but that the onely ordinary meanes of conversion, and of planting of men in formall state of Church-membership are men gifted to preach, and not Pastors by office; Sending (say they) sometimes importeth but an act of Gods providence, whereby men are gifted, and permitted to do such a thing, though they be not commanded of God, nor do in obedience to God, but for sinisterous ends, so God sent the King of Assyria, Esay 10. 6. 2 King. 24. 2. So they that preached of envy, Phil. 1. 15. are sent: So Balaam was sent. 2. Some are sent who beside gifts and permission, have also a sincere mind to imploy their gifts, God by his Spirit stirring them up, 1 Joh. 7. 18. 3. Those are sent of God, who have both gifts, permission, and a sincere mind to imploy their gifts, and withall a lawfull calling to the office: if men want a lawfull calling to that office of the ministery, and are not sent of God the third way, yet may they preach and convert soules, as sent of God, the first and second way.
Answ. 1. There should have been places of Scripture to prove that Balaam and the enviers of Paul, Phil. 1. 15. who preached Christ of envy, were sent the first way: for Balaam prophesied of the Star of Jacob, as one lawfully sent and a called Prophet, as all other Prophets, (though he was not a gracious man) for Numb. 24. 2. Balaam saw the visions of God, and the Spirit of God came upon him. 4. He saw the visions of the Almighty, and fell in a trance: and Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel had no other calling as Prophets, though in zeal and simplicity of prophesying, they differed from Balaam: and Paul would never have rejoiced that these teachers preached Christ, Phil. 1. 15. if they had without all calling of God preached Christ; doubtless they had a calling of the Church to preach, except you think that none have a calling, as called pastors, but those who are converted.
Answ. 1. There should have beene places of Scripture to prove that Balaam and the enviers of Paul, Phil. 1. 15. who preached Christ of envy, were sent the first way: for Balaam prophecied of the Starre of Iacob, as one lawfully sent and a called Prophet, as all other Prophets, (though hee was not a gracious man) for Numb. 24. 2. Balaam saw the visions of God, and the Spirit of God came upon him. 4. He saw the visions of the Almighty, and fell in a trance: and Isaiah, Ieremiah, Ezekiel had no other calling as Prophets, though in zeale and simplicitie of prophecying, they differed from Balaam: and Paul would never have rejoyced that these teachers preached Christ, Phil. 1. 15. if they had without all calling of God preached Christ; doubtlesse they had a calling of the Church to preach, except you thinke that none have a calling, as called pastors, but those who are converted.
3. By this distinction you hold that men may be ordinary Preachers gifted, and so sent of God to preach, and may and do convert souls, though they have no calling of the Church; which unsound doctrine the Arminians and Socinians hold this day: for they teach,
3. By this distinction you hold that men may be ordinary Preachers gifted, and so sent of God to preach, and may and doe convert soules, though they have no calling of the Church; which unsound doctrine the Arminians and Socinians hold this day: for they teach,
1. That all gifted persons may preach the Gospel, and convers souls.
1. That all gifted persons may preach the Gospel, and convers soules.
2. That all who are gifted to preach, are sent and lawfully called to preach, though the Church do not call them.
2. That all who are gifted to preach, are sent and lawfully called to preach, though the Church doe not call them.
3. That now since the Gospel is sufficiently revealed, and the Apostles are dead, there is required no calling of the Church, to make one a Lawful minister: And your Arguments they have, and you have their Arguments to evert all ministry and order of calling of pastors; so teach the Arminians, and so Episcopius; disp. 26. thes. 4. 5. Necessitatem missionis jam cessare dicendum est, ac 1p•inde fas licitumve esse homini Christian•, non tantum in magno necessitatis casu, aut in enormi ecclesiae defectione, sed quovis etiam tempore v•rbum divinum docere, si ad docendum sit idoneus, & qui doari v•lunt, id serio & obnixè postulant. So do the Socinians, A• lr. Roddeccius in not is in lib. Smiglecii pag. 3. Confitemur & olim ••l•sie ministros vocari potuisse, imo vocatos fuisse, & nunc etiam voc•ri posse; in vero id quod olim factum est, & hodie fieri potest, ad m•nus ministrorum requiratur, hoc vere & perpetuo quaeritur; Catch si• Raccoviensis, cap. 11. 305. 306. Cum per hujusmodi, ex praes•ripto Apostolicae doctrinae constituuntur, & in his duabus rebus praest •ut, vitae innocontiâ & ad docendum aptitudine, propter ejusmodi constitutionem apud omnes authoritatem suam merito in venire debent. Smaleius in refut. thes. D. Frantzii part 2. disp. 4. pag. 377. Hoc enim in questione est, an hujusmodi constitutio sit prorsus necessaria ad constituendum verbi dei ministrum: hoc autem nos negamus, nihil enim tale, (quod caput reiest) in descriptione eorum, quae ad episcopum constituendum requiritur, nec uspiam judicatum vel levissime videmus, cum qui talis sit, postea vocari, & mittiab aliquo debere, imo posse aliquem per se munus tale concupiscere vel aff•ctare manifeste scriptum legimus. Theoph. Nicolaid. in refut. tract. de miss. ministrorum cap. 10. pag. 80, 87. 88. Munus docendi non tam est honos, quam labor, laborem autem semper sumere li•et, h•ores non item: & pag. 91. Docet Paulus rect• id fieri posse, unumqu•mque munus docendi aggredi, m•do ad id aptus sit, quod aggredi cogitat, vel cupit.
3. That now since the Gospell is sufficiently revealed, and the Apostles are dead, there is required no calling of the Church, to make one a Lawfull minis•er: And your Arguments they have, and you have their Arguments to evert all ministerie and order of calling of pastors; so teach the Arminians, and so Episcopius; disp. 26. thes. 4. 5. Necessitatem missionis jam cessare dicendum est, ac 1p•inde fas licitumve esse homini Christian•, non tantum in magno necessitatis casu, aut in enormi ecclesiae defectione, sed quovis etiam tempore v•rbum divinum docere, si ad docendum sit idoneus, & qui doari v•lunt, id serio & obnixè postulant. So doe the Socinians, A• lr. Roddeccius in not is in lib. Smiglecii pag. 3. Confitemur & olim ••l•sie ministros vocari potuisse, imo vocatos fuisse, & nunc etiam voc•ri posse; in vero id quod olim factum est, & hodie fieri potest, ad m•nus ministrorum requiratur, hoc vere & perpetuo quaeritur; Cat•ch si• Raccoviensis, cap. 11. 305. 306. Cum per hujusmodi, ex praes•ripto Apostolicae doctrinae constituuntur, & in his duabus rebus praest •ut, vitae innocontiâ & ad docendum aptitudine, propter ejusmodi constitutionem apud omnes authoritatem suam merito in venire debent. Smaleius in refut. thes. D. Frantzii parte 2. disp. 4. pag. 377. Hoc enim in questione est, an hujusmodi constitutio sit prorsus necessaria ad constituendum verbi dei ministrum: hoc autem nos negamus, nihil enim tale, (quod caput reiest) in descriptione eorum, quae ad episcopum constituendum requiritur, nec uspiam judicatum vel levissime videmus, cum qui talis sit, postea vocari, & mittiab aliquo debere, imo posse aliquem per se munus tale concupiscere vel aff•ctare manifeste scriptum legimus. Theoph. Nicolaid. in refut. tract. de miss. ministrorum cap. 10. pag. 80, 87. 88. Munus docendi non tam est honos, quam labor, laborem autem semper sumere li•et, h•ores non item: & pag. 91. Docet Paulus rect id fieri posse, unumqumque munus docendi aggredi, mdo ad id aptus sit, quod aggredi cogitat, vel cupit.
Quest. II. Whether or not all gifted persons may preach the Word of God publicly, and ordinarily, for the gathering in of souls to Christ, though they be destitute of all official authority, or Church calling to that ministry?
Quest. II. Whether or not all gifted persons may preach the Word of God publikely, and ordinarily, for the gathering in of soules to Christ, though they be destitute of all officiall authoritie, or Church calling to that ministery?
Our brethren hold all gifted persons not in office may ordinarily ⟨p. 272⟩preach publicly; So teach Mr. Robinson in a Treatise entitled The peoples ple t for prophesying, the Arguments of which book I shall shortly discuss. Hence these considerations.
Our brethren hold all gifted persons not in office may ordinarily ⟨p. 272⟩preach publikely; So teach Mr. Robinson in a Treatise intituled The peoples ple t for prophecying, the Arguments of which booke I shall shortly discusse. Hence these considerations.
1. Distinct. There is one power of public preaching in a Church not constitute, and another in a Church constitute; gifted persons in extraordinary cases, where a Church is not planted, may publicly preach, but the case is otherwise in a Church constituted.
1. Distinct. There is one power of publike preaching in a Church not constitute, and another in a Church constitute; gifted persons in extraordinary cases, where a Church is not planted, may publikely preach, but the case is otherwise in a Church constituted.
2. Distinct. Pastors not only as gifted men, but as Pastors are •illed of God, for the conversion of souls, and the visible Church is Christs visible kingdom, and visible society, to make persons members of the invisible Church of the first borne.
2. Distinct. Pastors not onely as gifted men, but as Pastors are •illed of God, for the conversion of soules, and the visible Church is Christs visible kingdome, and visible society, to make persons members of the invisible Church of the first borne.
3. Dist. Public preaching, as it is the ordinary mean of saving such as believe, is proper and peculiar to the Church, both subjectively, as being only in the Church, and objectively as being only exercised on the Church members, pierce, but upon Pagans by accident.
3. Dist. Publike preaching, as it is the ordinary meane of saving such as beleeve, is proper and peculiar to the Church, both subjectively, as being onely in the Church, and objectively as being onely exercised on the Church members, perse, but upon P•gans by accident.
4. Dist. There is a call to an habitual and ordinary prophesying, here is required not only a calling by gifts, but also a collation of authority to the office, either immediately by God, or mediately by the Church, and there is a call to some particular or occasional acts of exhorting, as the Martyrs and Stephen are called to give confession of their faith, and a King in battle, to exhort his army, or a Prince his Subjects to piety, and to this latter there is no other call required, but the place and profession of the exhorter, though he be not by office a Pastor.
4. Dist. There is a call to an habituall and ordinary prophe•ying, here is required not onely a calling by gifts, but also a collation of authoritie to the office, either immediately by God, or mediately by the Church, and there is a call to some particular or occasionall acts of exhorting, as the Martyrs and Stephen are called to give consession of their faith, and a King in battell, to exhort his army, or a Prince his Subjects to piety, and to this latter there is no other call required, but the place and profession of the exhorter, though hee bee not by office a Pastor.
5. Dist. There is a formal calling of the Church, as the laying on of the hands of the Elders, and a virtual and interpretative calling or tacit approbation of the Church, when learned men of eminent gifts, not in office, do write Commentaries, Sermons on Canonic Scriptures, and tractates refuting heresies; to this the tacit approbation of the Church is required, but these have not ordinary pastoral care, nor are they the ordinary converters of souls to Christ, as the pretended Prophets of Separatists are.
5. Dist. There is a formall calling of the Church, as the laying on of the hands of the Elders, and a virtuall and interpretative calling or tacite approbation of the Church, when learned men of eminent gifts, not in office, do write Commentaries, Sermons on Canonick Scriptures, and tractates resuting heresies; to this the tacite approbation of the Church is required, but these have not ordinary pastorall care, nor are they the ordinary converters of soules to Christ, as the pretended Prophets of Separatists are.
6. Dist. Gifted Christians may occasionally admonish, warn, rebuke and exhort one another; 1. privately; 2. without any Pastoral care of souls as they are a Church, but only as they occasionally converse with them; 3. Excommuni officio charitatis, by the Law of nature, charity tying one member to help another; 4. Not authoritatively by special office; but all authority here is from the word occasionally ⟨p. 273⟩spoken. The Pastor is to preach, 1. Publicly; 2. To the Church as the Church. 3. With a pastoral obligation to all alike, whether he converse daily with them or not. 4. Not only by the tie of common Charity, but by a virtue of a special office. 5. With authority both objective from the word, and official from his charge. 6. And is obliged to separate himself for this charge allanerly, as a watchman who must give an account in a special manner to Jesus Christ.
6. Dist. Gifted Christians may occasionally admonish, warne, rebuke and exhort one another; 1. privately; 2. without any Pastorall care of soules as they are a Church, but onely as they occasionally converse with them; 3. Excommuni officio charitatis, by the Law of nature, charitie tying one member to helpe another; 4. Not authoritatively by speciall office; but all authoritie here is from the word occasionally ⟨p. 273⟩spoken. The Pastor is to preach, 1. Publikely; 2. To the Church as the Church. 3. With a pastorall obligation to all alike, whether he converse daily with them or not. 4. Not onely by the tie of common Charitie, but by a vertue of a speciall office. 5. With authority both objective from the word, and officiall from his charge. 6. And is obli•ged to separate himselfe for this charge allanerly, as a watchman who must give an account in a speciall manner to Jesus Christ.
Our brethren hold that the ordinary and established way in the Church of Christ to the end of the world, is that all that are converted are made fit materials for the visible Church by private Christians, as gifted of God to preach publicly, and to gather a true Church to Christ. 2. That none unconverted, as they are such, are under any pastoral care of Christs officers. 3. That Pastors as Pastors, do convert none, but only confirm those who are already converted; and that if Pastors shall convert any to Christ, it is by accident, as we say, with Aristotle, Musicus curat aegrotum, a Musician cureth a sick man, which he doth no ways as a musician: for Pastors do convert as gifted persons, and not as Pastors, and conversion of souls is no proper Church-work, but accidental to Pastors.
Our brethren hold that the ordinary and established way in the Church of Christ to the end of the world, is that all that are converted are made fit materialls for the visible Church by private Christians, as gifted of God to preach publikely, and to gather a true Church to Christ. 2. That none unconverted, as they are such, are under any pastorall care of Christs officers. 3. That Pastors as Pastors, doe convert none, but onely confirme those who are already converted; and that if Pastors shall convert any to Christ, it is by accident, as we say, with Aristotle, Musicus curat aegrotum, a Musician cureth a sick man, which he doth no wayes as a musician: for Pastors doe convert as gifted persons, and not as Pastors, and conversion of soules is no proper Church-worke, but accidentall to Pastors.
But that none can take on him lawfully to preach the Word publicly, in the established and ordinarily approved way of Christ for the conversion of souls, but he who is not only gifted, but also called thereunto by God and his Church, I prove.
But that none can take on him lawfully to preach the Word publikely, in the established and ordinarily approved way of Christ for the conversion of soules, but he who is not only gifted, but also called thereunto by God and his Church, I prove.
1. Argum. If faith come ordinarily by hearing a Pastor sent of God, and such Pastors as are called messengers with good news, and watchmen not only gifted, but also instructed with authority of office, then are not gifted persons, because gifted, called of God to be ordinary converters of souls. But the former is true, Rom. 10. 14. for they are [Greek or Hebrew], and of these the Prophet saith, Isa. 52. 8. Thy watchmen shall lift up the voice. And it is thus confirmed, That Gospel which is the power of 1God and the wisdom of God to those who are saved, is the Gospel preached by such as are sent both to preach and baptise: but 2the Gospel preached by gifted men, only out of office, is not the Gospel preached by those who are sent both to preach and to baptise: Ergo, the Gospel preached by only gifted persons void of all office, is not the power and wisdom of God to those who are saved. The assumption is granted, for gifted men out ⟨p. 274⟩of office may not lawfully baptise. I prove the proposition, 1 Cor. 1. 23. but we preach Christ, &c. That this [we] is to be understood of those who are sent both to preach and baptise, is clear, vers. 17. But Christ sent me not to baptise, but to preach, that is, he sent me not to baptise principally, Ergo, in one and the same Patent from heaven, Paul was warranted to preach, and to baptise, as one commission is given, Matth. 28. 19. to teach all Nations, and to baptise, yea it is [Greek or Hebrew] then it is such a preaching as must be backed with the sealing by baptism; also if he had meant that preaching was not peculiar to Apostles and other successors, he should have said. But yet preach Christ crucified, &c. for Separatists do teach, with Socinians, that there was a multitude of unofficed Prophets at Corinth.
1. Argum. If faith come ordinarily by hearing a Pastor sent of God, and such Pastors as are called messengers with good newes, and watchmen not onely gifted, but also instructed with authority of office, then are not gifted persons, because gifted, called of God to be ordinary converters of soules. But the former is true, Rom. 10. 14. for they are 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and of these the Prophet saith, Isa. 52. 8. Thy watchmen shall lift up the voyce. And it is thus confirmed, That Gospel which is the power of 1God and the wisedome of God to those who are saved, is the Gospel preached by such as are sent both to preach and baptise: but 2the Gospel preached by gifted men, only out of office, is not the Gospel preached by those who are sent both to preach and to baptise: Ergo, the Gospel preached by onely gifted persons voyd of all office, is not the power and wisdom of God to those who are saved. The assumption is granted, for gifted men out ⟨p. 274⟩of office may not lawfully baptise. I prove the proposition, 1 Cor. 1. 23. but wee preach Christ, &c. That this [wee] is to bee understood of those who are sent both to preach and baptise, is cleare, vers. 17. But Christ sent mee not to baptise, but to preach, that is, he sent mee not to baptise principally, Ergo, in one and the same Patent from heaven, Paul was warranted to preach, and to baptise, as one commission is given, Matth. 28. 19. to teach all Nations, and to baptise, yea it is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 then it is such a preaching as must bee backed with the sealing by baptisme; also if he had meant that preaching was not peculiar to Apostles and other successors, hee should have said. But yet preach Christ crucified, &c. for Separatists do teach, with Socinians, that there was a multitude of unofficed Prophets at Corinth.
Robinson, as if he had learned in Socinus his school, saith to 1this, But for the word sending which he so much urgeth, it must be known, that all who teach lawfully are sent by Christ, in respect of their personal gifts and graces, so ordinary officers are not sent by those who appoint them to minister, as was the extraordinary Apostles sent by Christ who appointed them. Sending importeth a passeth of the sent from the sender to another, and so the Apostles were sent by Christ to preach the Gospel to the Jews and Gentiles, and so are not Pastors sent by the Church (which calleth them) unto others, but to minister unto her self, after the exercise of public ministry is ended, the Church do publicly exhort and require, as the Rulers do Paul and Barnabas, Act 13. 14. that if they have any word of exhortation, they would say on.
Robinson, as if he had learned in Socinus his schoole, saith to 1this, But for the word sending which he so much urgeth, it must bee knowne, that all who teach lawfully are sent by Christ, in respect of their personall gifts and graces, so ordinary officers are not sent by those who appoint them to minister, as was the extraordinary Apostles sent by Christ who appointed them. Sending importeth a passeth of the sent from the sender to another, and so the Apostles were sent by Christ to preach the Gospel to the Jewes and Gentiles, and so are not Pastors sent by the Church (which calleth them) unto others, but to minister unto her selfe, after the exercise of publike ministery is ended, the Church doe publikely exhort and require, as the Rulers doe Paul and Barnabas, Act 13. 14. that if they have any word of exhortation, they would say on.
Answ. Surely Mr. Yates, and we both have much for us to urge the necessity of sending, except men would run unsent, and so be guilty of intrusion, for so doth the Scripture, Exod. 28. 1. Take to thee Aaron thy brother, &c. Numb. 1. 49. Thou shalt appoint the Levites over the Tabernacle of the Testimony, and over all the vessels, and all that belongeth thereunto: so saith Hezekiah to the Levites, The Lord hath chosen you to stand before him, and to minister unto him: Isaiah 6. 8. And I heard the voice of the Lord saying, Whom shall I send, and who shall go for me? 9. and he said, go and say to this people, Jerem. 1. 4. And the Word of the Lord came unto me, saying, v. 5. Hos. 1. 1. and the Word of the Lord came to me, Heb. 1. 1. Joh. 1. 6. There was a man sent of God, Luk. 3. 2. Matth. 10. 5. Those ⟨p. 275⟩twelve Jesus sent forth, Isa. 48. 16. Isa. 61. 1. Heb. 5. 4. Joh. 20. 21. Matth. 28. 19. Mark 16. 15. Rom. 11. 1. Rom. 1. 1. Gal. 1. 1. Act. 14. 13. Paul and Barnabas ordained Elders in every Church, 1 Tim. 4. 14. 1 Tim. 5. 22. 2 •im. 2. 2, 3. Tit. 1. 9, 10. If you urge not sending, you go from the Scriptures.
Answ. Surely Mr. Yates, and wee both have much for us to urge the necessitie of sending, except men would runne unsent, and so be guilty of intrusion, for so doth the Scripture, Exod. 28. 1. Take to thee Aaron thy brother, &c. Numb. 1. 49. Thou shalt appoint the Levits over the Tabernacle of the Testimony, and over all the vessels, and all that belongeth thereunto: so saith Hezekiah to the Levites, The Lord hath chosen you to stand before him, and to minister unto him: Esay 6. 8. And I heard the voyce of the Lord saying, Whom shall I send, and who shall goe for me? 9. and hee said, goe and say to this people, Jerem. 1. 4. And the Word of the Lord came unto me, saying, v. 5. Hos. 1. 1. and the Word of the Lord came to me, Heb. 1. 1. Joh. 1. 6. There was a man sent of God, Luk. 3. 2. Matth. 10. 5. Those ⟨p. 275⟩twelve Jesus sent forth, Isa. 48. 16. Isa. 61. 1. Heb. 5. 4. Joh. 20. 21. Matth. 28. 19. Mark 16. 15. Rom. 11. 1. Rom. 1. 1. Gal. 1. 1. Act. 14. 13. Paul and Barnabas ordained Elders in every Church,
2. He saith all who lawfully teach are sent of God in respect of personal gifts. But 1. where doth the holy Ghost speak so in the Scripture? All then who have gifts to be Kings and Magistrates are sent of God to the throne and bench? what bloody confusions would hence fellow? Yea if they have gifts to be Kings and do not all fly to the throne, they resist the calling of God, and sin in so doing, as Jonah did, and hide their Lords Talent. 2. Women in whose lips is the Law of grace, Prov. 31. 26. and who are to teach the younger women, Tit. 2. 3. 4. are so sent of God to preach; O but (say they) they are forbidden to preach. I answer, true, then (to be gifted to preach:) is not all one with this (to be sent to preach) for to be sent to preach of God, is to be commanded to preach. If then women be sent in respect of gifts, they are commanded to preach, and that by God, and yet Gods Word forbiddeth them to preach; Ergo, that same will of God revealed doth command and forbid one and the same thing, which is absurd. Ergo, to be gifted is not to be sent to preach. 3. You here clearly side with Arminians and So•inians, for Episcopius arequireth no more to preaching, but that the man be idoneous and apt to teach. And bTheoph Nocolaides, that there be in him an holy life and aptitudo ad docendum alios, aptitude to teach others. 4. Arminians and Socinians teach that the sending, Rom. 10. 14. and other places are meant of extraordinary sending which is now ceased, since the Apostles are dead. So (c) Episcopius dand Arminians in their confession. eSocinus fOstorodius expound the place, Rom. 10. 14. Paulum de suo duntaxat tempore loqui, and so there is no need of sending now: and Robinson sympathizing with them, saith, Ordinary officers are not sent now by the Church, as the Apostles were then sent of Christ; but the professors of Leiden grefuting the Arminians, say there is a necessity of sending now as there was then, and hCalvin, iBeza, kParaeus accord to this, ⟨p. 276⟩that Paul speaketh of ordinary calling. 4. The Word of God differenceth the giving of gifts to the ministry, and the giving of authority, and sending authoritative by a lawful calling, the one being collatio [Greek or Hebrew], the other […], as Matth. 10. 1. Then he called the twelve, and gave them power, and v. 5. their sending and gifting by authority is clear, these twelve he sent out: So Jer. 1.
2. He saith all who lawfully teach are sent of God in respect of personall gifts. But 1. where doth the holy Ghost speake so in the Scripture? All then who have gifts to be Kings and Magistrates are sent of God to the throne and bench? what bloody confusions would hence fellow? Yea if they have gifts to bee Kings and do not all flie to the throne, they resist the calling of God, and sinne in so doing, as Jonah did, and hide their Lords Talent. 2. Women in whose lipps is the Law of grace, Prov. 31. 26. and who are to teach the younger women, Tit. 2. 3. 4. are so sent of God to preach; O but (say they) they are forbidden to preach. I answer, true, then (to be gifted to preach:) is not all one with this (to bee sent to preach) for to bee sent to preach of God, is to be commanded to preach. If then women bee sent in respect of gifts, they are commanded to preach, and that by God, and yet Gods Word forbiddeth them to preach; Ergo, that same will of God revealed doth command and forbid one and the same thing, which is absurd. Ergo, to be gifted is not to be sent to preach. 3. You here clearely side with Arminians and So•inians, for Episcopius arequireth no more to preaching, but that the man bee idoneous and apt to teach. And bTheoph Nocolaides, that there be in him an holy life and aptitudo ad docendum alios, aptitude to teach others. 4. Arminians and Socinians teach that the sending, Rom. 10. 14. and other places are meant of extraordinary sending which is now ceased, since the Apostles are dead. So (c) Episcopius dand Arminians in their confession. eSocinus fOstorodius expound the place, Rom. 10. 14. Paulum de suo duntaxat tempore loqui, and so there is no need of sending now: and Robinson sympathizing with them, saith, Ordinary officers are not sent now by the Church, as the Apostles were then sent of Christ; but the professors of Leyden g
5. I have separated thee, &c. this is calling and sending, & v. 9. Then the Lord put forth his hand and touched my mouth, this is a giving of gifts, and Isa. 1. 1. Isaiah is gifted when he saw the visions of God, but Chap. 6. 7. he is sent and receiveth authority to go, beside that v. 8, 9. and Job. 20. when Christ breathed upon the Disciples, he giveth them the gifts of the holy Spirit, but when he saith, Go and teach, and as my father sent me, so send I you, he giveth them authority and sendeth them: yea though Prophets did prophesy true things that should come to pass, yet were they false Prophets, De•t. 13. 1, 2. because the Lord sent them not. And for the place, Rom. 10, 14. cited from Isa. 52. though Prophets hearing Isaiah and Jeremiah prophesy of the peoples return from Babylon, should prophecy the same that Isaiah and Jeremiah had prophesied, yet not being sent of God, they should have been false Prophets: and after the Spirit is entered unto Ezekiel, ch. 2. 2. and so he is gifted, yet is there another sending, v. 3. then said the Lord unto me, &c. And might (I pray you) Baruch have preached all his Master Jeremiahs Prophecies? But I think that should not have made him a Prophet: yea and Christ in whom was all fullness of gifts and grace, Job. 1. 16. Col. 2. 9. yet took not on him to be a Priest of the New Testament till he was called of God, as Aaron, Heb. 5. 4, 5. Job. 1. 18. and Calvin, Musculus, Gualter, expone the Prophets and Pastors, prophesying peace, Isa. 52. to be the Prophets, who not only were gifted to preach, but sent with special authority, to prophesy the peoples deliverance out of Babylon. And lastly, by this also have the gifted Prophets a calling of God, to administrate the Sacraments, because, if to be gifted, be to be sent of God, certainly they are gifted to administrate the Sacraments no less then to preach, and so lsaith the Arminians, with ⟨p. 277⟩their Socinians, as mSocinus and nSmalcius, If they say, Christ requireth a particular Minister to the Sacraments, but not so to the word: I answer, to pastoral preaching he requireth also a peculiar minister, as our brethren teach, from Act. 20. 28. 1 Pet. 5 4. 5. but to teaching by virtue of a gift any gifted man is sufficient:
5. I have separated thee, &c. this is calling and sending, & v. 9. Then the Lord put forth his hand and touched my mouth, this is a giving of gifts, and Isa. 1. 1. Isaiah is gifted when he saw the visions of God, but Chap. 6. 7. he is sent and receiveth authority to goe, beside that v. 8, 9. and Job. 20. when Christ breathed upon the Disciples, hee giveth them the gifts of the holy Spirit, but when he saith, Go and teach, and as my father sent me, so send I you, he giveth them authoritie and sendeth them: yea though Prophets did prophecie true things that should come to passe, yet were they false Prophets, De•t. 13. 1, 2. because the Lord sent them not. And for the place, Rom. 10, 14. cited from Isa. 52. though Prophets hearing Isaiah and Jeremiah prophecie of the peoples returne from Babylon, should prophecy the same that Isaiah and Jeremiah had prophecied, yet not being sent of God, they should have beene false Prophets: and after the Spirit is entered unto Ezecbiel, ch. 2. 2. and so he is gifted, yet is there another sending, v. 3. then said the Lord unto me, &c. And might (I pray you) Baruch have preached all his Master Jeremiahs Prophecies? But I thinke that should not have made him a Prophet: yea and Christ in whom was all fulnesse of gifts and grace, Job. 1. 16. Col. 2. 9. yet tooke not on him to be a Priest of the New Testament till he was called of God, as Aaron, Heb. 5. 4, 5. Job. 1. 18. and Calvin, Musculus, Gualter, expone the Prophets and Pastors, prophecying peace, Isa. 52. to be the Prophets, who not onely were gifted to preach, but sent with speciall authority, to prophecie the peoples deliverance out of Babylon. And lastly, by this also have the gifted Prophets a calling of God, to administrate the Sacraments, because, if to be gifted, be to be sent of God, certainly they are gifted to administrate the Sacraments no lesse then to preach, and so lsaith the Arminians, with ⟨p. 277⟩
the same distinction may as well hold that there is a pastoral administration of the Sacraments and a common administration of them by virtue of a gift, yea and oGerardus observeth well, that to the calling of the ministry belongeth the administration of the Sacraments, as a special part thereof, 1 Cor. 12. 29. Ephes. 4. 11. Jam. 3. 1. 7. yea and if ministers be stewards, 1 Cor. 4. 12. are they not dispensators of the Sacraments, by their office, as of the Word?
the same distinction may as well hold that there is a pastorall administration of the Sacraments and a common administration of them by vertue of a gift, yea and oGerardus observeth well, that to the calling of the ministery belongeth the administration of the Sacraments, as a speciall part thereof, 1 Cor. 12. 29. Ephes. 4. 11. Jam. 3. 1. 7. yea and if ministers bee stewards, 1 Cor. 4. 12. are they not dispensators of the Sacraments, by their office, as of the Word?
5. Robinson giveth for shame a sort of calling to the unofficed Prophets, to wit, that the Church requireth them, if they have a word of exhortation, to speak on, as Act. 13. But 1. not his Church, but the rulers required Paul and Barnabas to speak. 2. The Rulers knew them to be Apostles and Pastors by office, for there were Prophets there, Chap. 14. 1. but the Apostles would have none to preach, as Pastors by office, but such as are proved, and authorized by the Elders, 1 Tim. 3. 10. ch. 4. 14. 1 Tim. 5. 22. 2 Tim. 2. 2, 3. 3. This calling of the Church is only for orders cause in the constitute Church, but a thing not necessary by divine institution, and so the Socinians. So Smalcius pteach us that the Churches sending and calling in the Apostolic Church was a custom, […] decorum arbitramur (saith Smalcius) u• id observaretur; and and so saith qAndr. Raddecius, and the rArminians have also the same distinction: But this place approveth not that every by person (so to speak) might preach in the Jews Synagogues.
5. Robinson giveth for shame a sort of calling to the unofficed Prophets, to wit, that the Church requireth them, if they have a word of exhortation, to speake on, as Act. 13. But 1. not his Church, but the rulers required Paul and Barnabas to speake. 2. The Rulers knew them to be Apostles and Pastors by office, for there were Prophets there, Chap. 14. 1. but the Apostles would have none to preach, as Pastors by office, but such as are proved, and authorized by the Elders, 1 Tim. 3. 10. ch. 4. 14. 1 Tim. 5. 22. 2 Tim. 2. 2, 3. 3. This calling of the Church is onely for orders cause in the constitute Church, but a thing not necessary by divine institution, and so the Socinians. So Smalcius pteach us that the Churches sending and calling in the Apostolick Church was a custome, 〈…〉 decorum arbitramur (saith Smalcius) u• id observaretur; and and so saith qAndr. Raddecius, and the rArminians have also the same distinction: But this place approveth not that every by person (so to speake) might preach in the Jewes Synagogues.
2. Argum. If Christ ascending on high led captivity captive, and gave gifts unto men, some to be Apostles and some Pastors and Doctors, and that for the gathering of Christs body, and ⟨p. 278⟩if some, not all are Prophets, 1 Cor. 12. 29. then hath God appointed Pastors in office to be the ordinary gatherers of souls in to Jesus Christ, and if this be not said, when he ascended on high, he made all private Christians de jure, preachers to edify publicly the whole Church, and if any be not gifted, it is their own fault, for they are obliged to be such.
2. Argum. If Christ ascending on high led captivitie captive, and gave gifts unto men, some to be Apostles and some Pastors and Doctors, and that for the gathering of Christs body, and ⟨p. 278⟩if some, not all are Prophets, 1 Cor. 12. 29. then hath God appointed Pastors in office to bee the ordinary gatherers of soules in to Jesus Christ, and if this bee not said, when hee ascended on high, hee made all private Christians de jure, preachers to edifie publikely the whole Church, and if any bee not gifted, it is their owne fault, for they are obliged to bee such.
3. Argum. He who Matth. 10. 42. contradistinguisheth the prophet and the righteous man, as different persons, and having different rewards, he doth not acknowledge a righteous man to be a Prophet, hoc ipso, because he is a righteous man. But Christ doth contradistinguish them, v. 41. He that receiveth a Prophet in the name of a Prophet, shall receive a Prophets reward, and he that receiveth a righteous man, in the name of a righteous man, shall receive a righteous mans reward; Ergo, Christ acknowledgeth them to differ. Now if a righteous man, hoc ipso, because he is a righteous man, and a member of the Church, should exercise these same specifice acts with a Prophet, that is, if he should publicly preach to convert souls, he should by this place be a Prophet, and the reward of a Prophet should be given to the receiver of the righteous man, yea and more then the reward of a Prophet, in respect he is both a righteous man, and a Prophet.
3. Argum. He who Matth. 10. 42. contradistinguisheth the prophet and the righteous man, as different persons, and having different rewards, he doth not acknowledge a righteous man to be a Prophet, hoc ipso, because he is a righteous man. But Christ doth contradistinguish them, v. 41. He that receiveth a Prophet in the name of a Prophet, shall receive a Prophets reward, and he that receiveth a righteous man, in the name of a righteous man, shall receive a righteous mans reward; Ergo, Christ acknowledgeth them to differ. Now if a righteous man, hoc ipso, because hee is a righteous man, and a member of the Church, should exercise these same specifice acts with a Prophet, that is, if hee should publikely preach to convert soules, he should by this place bee a Prophet, and the reward of a Prophet should be given to the receiver of the righteous man, yea and more then the reward of a Prophet, in respect he is both a righteous man, and a Prophet.