Objection 1
pp. 298–2992 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ob. 1. The power of the Keys cannot be given to the catholic representative Church, or catholic Presbytery, as to the first ⟨p. 299⟩subject to be an ordinary and constant mean of edification; The exercise whereof, in an ordinary and constant way, is unpossible; But the exercise of this Ministerial power given to the catholic visible Presbytery, as to the first subject, in an ordinary and constant way, is unpossible; Ergo, such a power is not given to the Catholic representative Church, as to the first subject, to be an ordinary and constant mean of edification. The proposition is clear, it is uncongruous to the Wisdom of Jesus Christ that he should give that to be a mean, which possibly cannot attain the end. The Assumption is as evident; for the Catholic visible Presbytery cannot meet in an ordinary and constant way.
Ob. 1. The power of the Keys cannot be given to the catholick representative Church, or catholick Presbytery, as to the first ⟨p. 299⟩subject to be an ordinary and constant meane of edification; The exercise whereof, in an ordinary and constant way, is unpossible; But the exercise of this Ministeriall power given to the catholick visible Presbytery, as to the first subject, in an ordinary and constant way, is unpossible; Ergo, such a power is not given to the Catholick representative Church, as to the first subject, to be an ordinary and constant meane of edification. The proposition is cleare, it is uncongruous to the Wisdome of Jesus Christ that hee should give that to bee a meane, which possibly cannot attaine the end. The Assumption is as evident; for the Catholick visible Presbytery cannot meete in an ordinary and constant way.
Answ. 1. By distinguishing the Major proposition; That power of the Keys remote cannot be given to the catholic presbytery as to the first subject, the exercise whereof in an ordinary and constant way is impossible physically and ex natura rei. True, but now the Assumption is false; That nearer power cannot be given as a mean of edification, the exercise whereof is morally and through the corruption of mens nature physically impossible. That is false, and denied, and in either sense the conclusion cannot be true. 2. I grant the whole, and yet nothing is concluded against us. For the power of the Keys is not given to the catholic Presbytery as to the first subject, to be a mean of edification in an ordinary and constant way; but only in an extraordinary and occasional way, in those things which concern the power of jurisdiction belonging to the whole Catholic Church. By (extraordinary) here I mean not that which is against a particular Law of God, and cannot be done without a Divine dispensation of providence, but by (extraordinary) I mean that which is rarò contingens, and doth not oft fall out; as almost it never falleth out that the universal Church hath need to excommunicate a national Church, for all and every one of a national Church do never fall away from the Faith. Yet a remote power for Excommunication, is in the Catholic visible Church.