pp. 348–3526 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But this latter is as unpossible, as absurd; For how shall thirty or forty Congregations meet all, in one place, for all the several acts of Jurisdiction? Also you confess that many Congregations cannot meet in one place: that the proposition may be made good; We suppose these grounds of the Presbyterial frame of Churches: 1. That the presbyterial Church of Corinth, not the Congregation had the only power of excommunication. 2. That this man was to be excommunicated in presence, and so with the consent of the whole multitude, for so the Text saith, 1 Cor. 5. 4. [Greek or Hebrew]. When you are gathered together. 3. Excommunication is the highest act of Jurisdiction in the Church, being the binding of the sinner in Heaven and Earth, if therefore this highest act of Jurisdiction must be performed before all the Church congregated in one, then must all acts of Jurisdiction be performed also in presence of the congregated Church; for it concerneth their edification, and is a matter of conscience to then: all. 4. The reason why we think sit he should be excommunicated before, or in presence of that Congregation whereof he is a member, is because it concerneth them, and he is a member of this Congregation, But by your grounds, the whole Presbyterial or classical Church should be present, which were unpossible; for he is to you a Member of the whole Classical Church, and the power of excommunication is in the whole classical Church, and they ought to be present by the same ⟨p. 349⟩reason, that the Congregation, whereof he is a nearest member, is present.
But this latter is as unpossible, as absurd; For how shall thirty or forty Congregations meet all, in one place, for all the severall acts of Jurisdiction? Also you confesse that many Congregations cannot meete in one place: that the proposition may be made good; We suppose these grounds of the Presbyteriall frame of Churches: 1. That the presbyteriall Church of Corinth, not the Congregation had the onely power of excommunication. 2. That this man was to be excommunicated in presence, and so with the consent of the whole multitude, for so the Text sayth, 1 Cor. 5. 4. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. When you are gathered together. 3. Excommunication is the highest act of Iurisdiction in the Church, being the binding of the sinner in Heaven and Earth, if therefore this highest act of Iurisdiction must bee performed before all the Church congregated in one, then must all acts of Iurisdiction be performed also in presence of the congregated Church; for it concerneth their edification, and is a matter of conscience to then: all. 4. The reason why wee thinke sit hee should be excommunicated before, or in presence of that Congregation whereof hee is a member, is because it concerneth them, and hee is a member of this Congregation, But by your grounds, the whole Presbyteriall or classicall Church should be present, which were unpossible; for hee is to you a Member of the whole Classicall Church, and the power of excommunication is in the whole classicall Church, and they ought to bee present by the same ⟨p. 349⟩reason, that the Congregation, whereof hee is a neerest member, is present.
Answ. 1. There be many things in this argument to be corrected, as 1. That the Church of Corinth conve•ed in the whole multitude whom it concerned, for [Greek or Hebrew], doth not prove it; for the same Word is spoken of the meeting of the Apostles and Elders, who met in a Synod with authority, Acts 15. 6. the word [Greek or Hebrew] is attributed to the multitude, Acts 21. v. 22. and to the Church of Believers, 1 Cor. 11. 20. and 1 Cor. 14. 23. therefore the one word [Greek or Hebrew] seemeth to be no cogent Argument. 2. The word [Greek or Hebrew], which is not here in all this Chapter, or [Greek or Hebrew] is used in the New Testament, and by the seventy Interpreters, whose translation Christ and his Apostles do frequently follow in the New Testament, use the words for any meeting of good or ill, of civill or Ecclesiastical persons. As I might instance is a great many places of the Old and New Testament; then what is it, I pray you, which restricteth the signification of these words to signify a civill, rather then an Ecclesiastical meeting? certainly the actions which the company doth when they are met, and the end for which they meet. I give an instance in Acts 19. 41. the word [Greek or Hebrew] (the like I say of [Greek or Hebrew]) signifieth not the Church of Christ, and why? it is a reason that cannot be controlled. They were assembled for to raise a tumult against Paul which was no Church-action, and so no Church end is here. So v. 39. But if you enquire any thing in other matters, it shall be determined [Greek or Hebrew] in a lawful assembly; surely the end of such an assembly in Ephesus, where this man was Town-Clark in the meeting, could be. no Church-business, Hence we are led to know what [Greek or Hebrew], an Assembly or Church signifieth here not the Church of Christ, so Psal. 22. 16. the Assembly of the wicked hath enclosed me [Greek or Hebrew] Merighem the seventy Interpreters turn it [Greek or Hebrew], and Tertullian followeth them, the persons congregated, the actions and end for which they convene lead us to this, that the Word signifieth not a Church of Christ. So we may see,
The place must signify the Church of Believers, because the end of their meeting was the Supper of the Lord, or their communion, v. 20. as the Text cleareth, and 1 Cor. 14. 23. when the whole Church cometh together, that was for prophesying and hearing of the Word, as the Text is evident, v. 16, 17, 18, 23, 24, 25 26, 27. and therefore here the word [Greek or Hebrew] must signify the Church of Pastors preaching, and people hearing the Word, praying and praising God. So in the third place when [Greek or Hebrew], the Church is convened to bind and loose, and to excommunicate, as Mat. 18. 17. 18. 19. there is no necessity that the Word Church, should include those who have no power of the keys, and cannot by power of the Keys bind and loose. And therefore from the naked and mere Grammar of the word [Greek or Hebrew], no argument can be drawn to prove that [Greek or Hebrew] Matth. 18. 17. must signify that same which it doth signify, 1 Corin. 1. 1. 1 Corin. 11. 18. 1 Corin. 14. 23. for the word actu primo, and originally, signifieth any meeting, but the persons who are Congregated and the end for which they meet leadeth us to the meaning and Grammatical sense of the word, in that place. Now Matth. 18. the Ecclesia, a Church Congregated there is such as bindeth and looseth in Heaven and Earth, and congregated for that use: therefore I see not how the circumstances of the place helping us to the Grammatical sense of the word here, as in all other places, doth not enforce us to say in this place Mat. 18. the word Ecclesia, Church, must signify only those who have power to bind and loose, that is, only the Elders, and not the people. So to come to the place, 1 Cor. 5.
The place must signifie the Church of Believers, because the end of their meeting was the Supper of the Lord, or their communion, v. 20. as the Text cleareth, and
Those who come under the name of [Greek or Hebrew], congregated together, must be expounded by the persons Office, and the end of their meeting, now the persons Office is Ministerial, he will have them congregated by Pauls Ministerial spirit, and in the name and with the power of the Lord Jesus, this is the power of the Keys, which he who hath ⟨p. 351⟩Davids Keys Isaiah. 22. 22. on his Shoulders, Revel. 3. 7. giveth to his own Officers, Matth. 16. 19. and these persons cannot be all that he writeth unto v. 1. all that were puffed up, and mourned not at the offence given by the incestuous […], to Jesus Christs holy Nam• and Church, all who are to forbear eating and drinking with excommunicated persons, vers. 11. all who were in danger to be leavened, vers 6. all who were to keep the Feast in sincerity, not with the old Leaven of wickedness and malice: for these directly were the whole multitude of Believers, Men, Women, and Children, who (I am sure) were not capable of the Keys and the Ministerial power of Paul. 2. The end wherefore these [Greek or Hebrew] who were convened, did meet and convene, was, vers. 5. [Greek or Hebrew]. to deliver the man to Satan, they were not convened to celebrate the Lords Supper, as the Church is convened, 1 Cor. 11. 18. nor for hearing the Word of Prophecy, or Preaching, as 1 Cor. 14. 23, 24. And whether you construe the Words [Greek or Hebrew] with the Power of the Lord Jesus, with the Verb [Greek or Hebrew], to deliver to Satan, or with the Participle [Greek or Hebrew] congregated in the Name and Power of CHRIST, all is one; the multitude of common Believers, of Men, Women, and Children, are neither capable of the power, nor of the exercise of that power to deliver to Satan. And therefore this meeting together, by no Grammar doth lead us to say that the sentence was to be pronounced in face and presence of the multitude convened, vers. 21. Giving, but not granting that the Church of Corinth, in all its members, must be convened. Though I hold it not necessary by this place, yet it followeth not that all other acts of Jurisdiction must be exercised in face of the whole Congregation: for there is a special reason of the pronouncing of the sentence, which is not in other acts:
the pronouncing of the sentence, concerneth more the nearest Congregation of which the Delinquent is a member, in relation of nearest and daily Communion, it concerneth also other Congregations of the Classical Church, of which also the Delinquent ⟨p. 352⟩is a member, but not so immediately and nearly, because (as I said before) the more universal the Church visible is, the external visible Communion is l•sse; even as when the number of a Family is cut off, by the Sword of the Magistrate, the matter first and more intimately and more nearly concerneth the Family whereof he is a Member, yet it doth also concern the Common-Wealth, of which also he is a Member. A Finger of the right Hand is infected with a contagious Gangrene, it is to be cut off; yet the cutting-off concerneth more nearly the right Hand, then it doth the left Hand, and the whole Body. For the contagion should first over-spread the right Hand and Arm, and Shoulder, before it infect the left Hand, and the whole Body; though it do not a little concern the whole Body also. So though actual Excommunication concern all the Churches of the Presbytery: yet it doth more nearly concern the Congregation whereof he is a Member. 2. The pronouncing of the sentence being edificative, it is a fit mean to work upon others, but calling and trying of witnesses, and Juridical discerning of a Man to be Excommunicated, requiring secrecies, yea and some scandals, and circumstances of Adultery, Incest, Pestiality, requiring a modest covering of them, from Virgins, young Men, Children and the multitude, we have no warrant of GOD, that they should be tried before the whole multitude, nor are acts of Jurisdiction for their excellency, to be brought forth before the people but for their nearness of concernment, and use of edification.
the pronouncing of the sentence, concerneth more the neerest Congregation of which the Delinquent is a member, in relation of nearest and dayly Communion, it concerneth also other Congregations of the Classicall Church, of which also the Delinquent ⟨p. 352⟩is a member, but not so immediately and neerely, because (as I sayd before) the more universall the Church visible is, the externall visible Communion is l•sse; even as when the number of a Family is cut off, by the Sword of the Magistrate, the matter first and more intimately and more neerely concerneth the Family whereof hee is a Member, yet it doth also concerne the Common-Wealth, of which also hee is a Member. A Finger of the right Hand is infected with a contagious Gangren, it is to bee cut off; yet the cutting-off concerneth more neerely the right Hand, then it doth the left Hand, and the whole Body. For the contagion should first over-spread the right Hand and Arme, and Shoulder, before it infect the left Hand, and the whole Body; though it doe not a little concerne the whole Body also. So though actuall Excommunication concerne all the Churches of the Presbyterie: yet it doth more neerely concerne the Congregation whereof hee is a Member. 2. The pronouncing of the sentence being edificative, it is a fit meane to worke upon others, but calling and trying of witnesses, and Juridicall decerning of a Man to bee Excommunicated, requiring secrecies, yea and some scandals, and circumstances of Adultery, Incest, Pestiality, requiring a modest covering of them, from Virgins, young Men, Children and the multitude, wee have no warrant of GOD, that they should bee tryed before the whole multitude, nor are acts of Jurisdiction for their excellency, to bee brought forth before the people but for their neerenesse of concernment, and use of edification.
Answ. 1. There be many things in this argument to be corrected, as 1. That the Church of Corinth conve•ed in the whole multitude whom it concerned, for 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, doth not prove it; for the same Word is spoken of the meeting of the Apostles and Elders, who met in a Synod with authority, Acts 15. 6. the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 is attributed to the multitude, Acts 21. v. 22. and to the Church of Believers, 1 Cor. 11. 20. and 1 Cor. 14. 23. therefore the one word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 seemeth to bee no cogent Argument. 2. The word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which is not here in all this Chapter, or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 is used in the New Testament, and by the seventy Interpreters, whose translation Christ and his Apostles doe frequently follow in the New Testament, use the words for any meeting of good or ill, of civill or Ecclesiasticall persons. As I might instance is a great many places of the Old and New Testament; then what is it, I pray you, which restricteth the signification of these words to signifie a civill, rather then an Ecclesiasticall meeting? certainly the actions which the company doth when they are met, and the end for which they meete. I give an instance in Acts 19. 41. the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 (the like I say of 〈non-Latin alphabet〉) signifieth not the Church of Christ, and why? it is a reason that cannot bee controlled. They were assembled for to raise a tumult against Paul which was no Church-action, and so no Church end is here. So v. 39. But if you enquire any thing in other matters, it shall be determined 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in a lawfull assembly; surely the end of such an assembly in Ephesus, where this man was Town-Clark in the meeting, could be. no Church-businesse, Hence wee are led to know what 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, an Assembly or Church signifieth here not the Church of Christ, so Psal. 22. 16. the Assembly of the wicked hath inclosed mee 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Merighem the seventy Interpreters turne it 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and T•rtullian followeth them, the persons congregated, the actions and end for which they convenc lead us to this, that the Word signifieth not a Church of Christ. So wee may see, Psal. 26. 5. ⟨p. 350⟩the Congregation of Elders cannot bee a true Church, 2. 1 Cor. 11. 18. for first when you come together to the Church, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, I heare there are divisions amongst you.
Those who come under the name of 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, congregated together, must bee expounded by the persons Office, and the end of their meeting, now the persons Office is Ministeriall, hee will have them congregated by Pauls Ministeriall spirit, and in the name and with the power of the Lord Jesus, this is the power of the Keyes, which hee who hath ⟨p. 351⟩Davids Keyes Esai. 22. 22. on his Shoulders, Revel. 3. 7. giveth to his owne Officers, Matth. 16. 19. and these persons cannot be all that hee writeth unto v. 1. all that were p•ffed up, and mourned not at the offence given by the incestuous 〈…〉, to Iesus Christs holy Nam• and Church, all who are to forbeare eating and drinking with excommunicated persons, vers. 11. all who were in danger to be leavened, vers 6. all who were to keepe the Feast in sincerity, not with the old Leaven of wickednesse and malice: for these directly were the whole multitude of Believers, Men, Women, and Children, who (I am sure) were not capable of the Keyes and the Ministeriall power of Paul. 2. The end wherefore these 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 who were convened, did meete and convene, was, vers. 5. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. to deliver the man to Satan, they were not convened to celebrate the Lords Supper, as the Church is convened, 1 Cor. 11. 18. nor for hearing the Word of Prophecy, or Preaching, as 1 Cor. 14. 23, 24. And whether you construe the Words 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 with the Power of the Lord Iesus, with the Verbe 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, to deliver to Satan, or with the Participle 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 congregated in the Name and Power of CHRIST, all is one; the multitude of common Believers, of Men, Women, and Children, are neither capable of the power, nor of the exercise of that power to deliver to Satan. And therefore this meeting together, by no Grammar doth leade us to say that the sentence was to be pronounced in face and presence of the multitude convened, vers. 21. Giving, but not granting that the Church of Corinth, in all its members, must bee convened. Though I hold it not necessary by this place, yet it followeth not that all other acts of Jurisdiction must bee exercised in face of the whole Congregation: for there is a speciall reason of the pronouncing of the sentence, which is not in other acts: