1Assert. 3. By the place 1 Pet. 2. The servant unjustly buffeted is not to buffet his master again, but to bear patiently as Christ did, who when he was reviled, did not revile again. Not because the place condemneth resistance for self-defence, but because buffeting again is formally re-offending, not defending; defending is properly a warding of a blow or stroke: if my neighbour come to kill me, and I can by no means save my life by flight, I may defend my self, and all Divines say, I may rather kill, ere I be killed, because I am nearer by the law of nature, and dearer to my self, and my own life then to my brother: but if I kill him out of malice, or hatred, the act of defending, by the unlawful manner of doing, becometh an act of offending, and murder, whence the mind of the blood-shedder will ⟨p. 321⟩vary the nature of the action, from whence this corollary doth naturally issue, that the physical action of taking away the life maketh not murder, nor homicide,2 and so the physical action of offending my neighbour is not murder: Abraham may kill his son, he for whom the cities of refuge were ordained, and did kill his brother, yet not hating him, he was not, by Gods law, judged a murderer. And 2. It necessarily hence followeth, that an act which is physically an act of offending my brother, yea even to the taking away of his life is often morally and legally an act of lawful self-defence: an offending of another necessitated from the sole invention of self-defence is no more but an act of innocent self defence: if David with his men had killed any of Sauls men, in a set battle, David and his men only intending self defence, the war •n Davids part was mere defensive, for physical actions of killing, indifferent of themselves, yet imp•rated by a principle of natural self-defence, and clothed with this formal end of self-defence, or according to the substance of the action, the act is of self-defence. If therefore one shall wound me deadly, and I know it is my death, after that, to kill the killer of my self, I being only a private man, must be no act of self-defence, but of homicide, because it cannot be imperated by a sinless dictate of a natural conscience, for this end of self-defence, after I know I am killed.
1Assert. 3. By the place 1 Pet. 2. The servant unjustly buffeted is not to buffet his master again, but to bear patiently as Christ did, who when he was reviled, did not revile again. Not because the place condemneth resistance for self-defence, but because buffeting again is formally re-offending, not defending; defending is properly a warding of a blow or stroak: if my neighbour come to kill me, and I can by no means save my life by flight, I may defend my self, and all Divines say, I may rather kill, ere I be killed, because I am nearer by the law of natur•, and dearer to my self, and my own life then to my brother: but if I kill him out of malice, or hatred, the act of defending, by the unlawfull manner of doing, becometh an act of offending, and murther, whence the mind of the blood-shedder will ⟨p. 321⟩vary the nature of the action, from whence this corolarie doth naturally issue, that the physicall action of taking away the life maketh not murther, nor homicide,2 and so the physical action of offending my neighbour is not murther: Abraham may kill his son, he for whom the cities of refuge were ordained, and did kill his brother, yet not hating him, he was not, by Gods law, judged a murtherer. And 2. It necessarily hence followeth, that an act which is physically an act of offending my brother, yea even to the taking away of his life is often morally and legally an act of lawfull self-defence: an offending of another necessitated from the sole invention of self-defence is no more but an act of innocent self defence: if David with his men had killed any of Sauls men, in a set battel, David and his men onely intending self defence, the war •n Davids part was meere defensive, for physicall actions of killing, indifferent of themselves, yet imp•rated by a principle of naturall self-defence, and clothed with this formall end of self-defence, or according to the substance of the action, the act is of self-defence. If therefore one shall wound me deadly, and I know it is my death, after that, to kill the killer of my selfe, I being onely a private man, must be no act of self-defence, but of homicide, because it cannot be imperated by a sinlesse dictate of a naturall conscience, for this end of self-defence, after I know I am killed.
- 1Re-offending in ended is contrary to patient •ubj•ct•on.
- 2The physical act of taking away of the life maketh not homicide.The physicall act of taking away of the life maketh not homicide.