Answ. It is not lawful to communicate with the holiest Church on earth in an act of false worship we grant; but every false worship doth neither make a true Church, a false Church, or no Church; neither giveth it a ground and warrant of Separation; for there was much false worship in Corinth, where many were partakers of the Idols Table, 1 Cor. 8. 10. and many denied the Resurrection, and so Thyatira, Pergamus, Rev. 2. where were Balaam's doctrine, and Jezebel the false Prophetess, and yet none of these are to be separated from, as false Churches, and the Separatists would observe this, that when Churches in the New Testament are most sharply rebuked, if communion with these Churches going on in their sins be Idolatry and false worship, and offering of Devils Images to God, how is it, that the Lord and his Apostles rebuketh the faults, but never warneth the true and sound believers to separate and make a new Church, seeing this is ⟨p. 161⟩the only remedy to them, and there is not another way to escape the judgement of the whol• Church? 2. David would not take up the names of Idols in his lips, nor should any touch the garment spotted of the flesh, nor consent unto, or countenance Idols, but to communicate with a Church where there is a profane people and a false worship, in some points, is not to touch unclean garments, for the clean and the sound worship of God is clean, and as for the example of Achan, it is most impertinent, Israel knew not Achans sacrilege, till the Lord found out the man, and if this stand good, a lurking hypocrite, and an unseen Achan in a visible Congregation, bringeth a curse on the Congregation, and from such a Congregation we are to separate, What madness is this, we are to separate from a society, before we know any Achan to be amongst them. But Separatists say, God would not have punished Israel by making them •ly before the men of Ai, Josh. 7. If Israel did take no part with Achan, but because of Achans sacrilege they were punished, ver. 11. Israel hath sinned and transgressed my covenant, which I commanded them: for they have taken the accursed thing.
Answ. It is not lawfull to communicate with the holiest Church on earth in an act of false worship we grant; but every false worship doth neither make a true Church, a false Church, or no Church; neither giveth it a ground and warrant of Separation; for there was much false worship in Corinth, where many were partakers of the Idols Table, 1 Cor. 8. 10. and many denyed the Resurrection, and so Thyatira, Pergamus, Rev. 2. where were Balaams doctrine, and Jezabel the false Prophetesse, and yet none of these are to be separated from, as false Churches, and the Separatists would observe this, that when Churches in the New Testament are most sharply rebuked, if communion with these Churches going on in their sinnes be Idolatry and false worship, and offering of Devils Images to God, how is it, that the Lord and his Apostles rebuketh the faults, but never warneth the true and sound beleevers to separate and make a new Church, seeing this is ⟨p. 161⟩the only remedy to them, and there is not another way to escape the judgement of the whol• Church? 2. David would not take up the names of Idols in his lips, nor should any touch the garment spotted of the •lesh, nor consent unto, or countenance Idols, but to communicate with a Church where there is a prophane people and a false worship, in some points, is not to touch unclean garments, for the cleane and the sound worship of God is cleane, and as for the example of Achan, it is most impertinent, Israel knew not Achans sacriledge, till the Lord found out the man, and if this stand good, a lurking hypocrite, and an unseene Achan in a visible Congregation, bringeth a curse on the Congregation, and from such a Congregation we are to separate, What madnes is this, we are to separate from a society, before we know any Achan to be amongst them. But Separatists say, God would not have punished Israel by making them •ly before the men of Ai, Josh. 7. If Israel did take no part with Achan, but because of Achans sacriledge they were punished, ver. 11. Israel hath sinned and transgressed my covenant, which I commanded them: for they have taken the accursed thing.