Answered. 1. One unto the Major, or first Proposition (viz. That which every man is bound to believe, is true) a thing may be said to be true in a three-fold respect; Either quia promittitur, because it is promised; Or secondly, quia narratur, because it is related or declared; Or thirdly, quia praedicitur, because it is foretold; so that whatsoever a man is bound to believe, that same is true, either as promised, or as declared or done, or as foretold; Not always true in one and the same respect, or in every respect; but either as promised, or declared or reported, or as foretold. To apply this to the Argument in hand, that Christ died effectually for every man; If it be a truth, then it must be so, because God hath promised it, or declared it, or foretold it; if it be a truth, because promised, then it is with condition of faith; for though the very promise be true in it self, yet it is not performed unto us, without believing; the same promise still requiring faith for the performance of it, and then this will not prove that it is true that Christ died for all and every man absolutely, but only for Believers, or for all men only under the condition of faith: If it be a truth because only declared, or foretold, then whether a man believes, or believes not, this is true that Christ died for him; the reason is, all things which are true by way of Narration or Prediction, they are true upon their own account, they are true before we believe them (our faith makes them not to be so) and if we believe them not, yet are they true; our unbelief cannot make the truth of God a lye: But I suppose that no Arminian will say that Christ dyed effectually for every man, whether he doth believe, or doth not believe.
Answered. 1. One unto the Major, or first Proposition (viz. That which every man is bound to believe, is true) a thing may be said to be true in a three-fold respect; Either quia promittitur, because it is promised; Or secondly, quia narratur, because it is related or declared; Or thirdly, quia praedicitur, because it is foretold; so that whatsoever a man is bound to believe, that same is true, either as promised, or as declared or done, or as foretold; Not alwayes true in one and the same respect, or in every respect; but either as promised, or declared or reported, or as foretold. To apply this to the Argument in hand, that Christ died effectually for every man; If it be a truth, then it must be so, because God hath promised it, or declared it, or foretold it; if it be a truth, because promised, then it is with condition of faith; for though the very promise be true in it self, yet it is not performed unto us, without believing; the same promise still requiring faith for the performance of it, and then this will not prove that it is true that Christ died for all and every man absolutely, but only for Believers, or for all men only under the condition of faith: If it be a truth because only declared, or foretold, then whether a man believes, or believes not, this is true that Christ died for him; the reason is, all things which are true by way of Narration or Prediction, they are true upon their own account, they are true before we believe them (our faith makes them not to be so) and if we believe them not, yet are they true; our unbelief cannot make the truth of God a lye: But I suppose that no Arminian will say that Christ dyed effectually for every man, whether he doth believe, or doth not believe.