Section 1
pp. 1–948 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 1–948 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. That I may show the due respect, which I bear your Worship, with my forwardness to answer your desires, as I can, with regard to Conscience.
1. That I may shew the due respect, which I beare your Worship, with my forwardnes to answer your desires, as I can, with regard to Conscience.
2. That you may see, I dissent not without cause, but have Reason on my side.
3. That if I can be convinced, that my Grounds are weak and insufficient, I may think better of my Opinion, which I have forsaken, then I can for the present.
3. That if I can be convinced, that my Grounds are weake and insufficient, I may think better of my Opinion, which I have forsaken, then I can for the present.
In the delivery of my Motives, I shall proceed in this Order,
1 I will state the Opinion which I dislike.
2 I will lay down my reasons against it.
Touching the first your Worship knows these two things very well;
Touching the first your Worship knowes these two things very well;
1 That the main [Greek or Hebrew], and Question in these Controversies, and that on which all the rest hang, is, What the decrees of God are, touching the everlasting condition of men, and how they are Ordered.
1 That the main 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and Question in these Controversies, and that on which all the rest hang, is, What the decrees of God are, touching the everlasting condition of men, and how they are Ordered.
2. That the Men which have disputed these things may be reduced to two sorts or sides.
The first side affirms, that there is such an absolute decree, proceeding from the good pleasure of God alone, without the consideration of mens final Unbelief and Impenitency, as, by which he casteth men off from Grace and Glory, and shuts up the far greater part of men (even of those that are called by the Preaching of the Gospel to Repentance and Salvation) under invincible and unavoidable sin and damnation.
The first side affirmes, that there is such an absolute decree, proceeding from the good pleasure of God alone, without the consideration of mens finall Unbeliefe and Impenitency, as, by which he casteth men off from Grace and Glory, and shuts up the farr greater part of men (even of those that are called by the Preaching of the Gospel to Repentance and Salvation) under invincible and unavoydable sin and damnation.
The other side, disavowing any such decree, say, that the Decree of God to cast off men for ever, is grounded upon the foresight of their continuance in sin and unbelief, both avoidable by Grace, and consequently inferring no mans damnation necessary.
The other side, disavowing any such decree, say, that the Decree of God to cast off men for ever, is grounded upon the foresight of their continuance in sin and unbeliefe, both avoydable by Grace, and consequently inferring no mans damnation necessary.
Worthy Sir, according to your desire to take into Consideration this writing directed unto you, at length I have gotten some leisure from other employments, to address my self to give you satisfaction in this particular.
WOrthy Sir, according to your desire to take into Consideration this writing directed unto you, at length I have gotten some leasure from other imployments, to addresse my selfe to give you satisfaction in this particular.
1 That I may show my self answerable to that respect which you have deserved at my hands; and not so only, but to my zeal of Gods truth, which hath deserved much more at the hands of us both.
1 That I may shew my selfe answerable to that respect which you have deserved at my hands; and not so only, but to my zeale of Gods truth, which hath deserved much more at the hands of us both.
2 That you may the better discern which of us two, whom you put to confer, doth maintain the cause of Gods truth, and hath the best reasons on his side.
2 That you may the better discern which of us two, whom you put to conferre, doth maintain the cause of Gods truth, and hath the best reasons on his side.
As for the change of Opinion here mentioned, such Professions are nothing strange. But whether such a Profession be in truth, or in pretence, and rather liberty taken to manifest that Opinion, which formerly hath been cherished: as also with what conscience void of all carnal respects, such a change or manifestation is made, it belongs not unto us to judge, but to leave that unto God, who trieth the hearts and reins. Sure we are, the heart of man is full of deceitfulness, both to deceive others, yea and to deceive our selves, the more need there is to be jealous over our selves, and to carry a watchful eye over our own souls, and whether we have changed a former way, or at the first chose one or other way, and continue to embrace that, whereof we have been at first informed; not to despise, but in the fear of God, to practice that 1holy counsel of the Apostle given to the Corinthians, a famous Church, and such as were destitute of no spiritual gift. Prove your selves, whether you are in the Faith, examine your selves: know ye not your own selves, that Jesus Christ is in you, except ye be Reprobates? as also to consider how indifferently we carry our selves, in using means to inform our selves in the way of truth, and whether they be not such as do discover our chief care hath been to bring our judgements about, to the embracing 2of that way (whether Truth or Error) which formerly we did effect. Certain it is, that Heresies must be, and that to this end, that they that are approved may be made manifest. And Illusions shall have their course, when the truth of God is not embraced with love, whatsoever be the pretence of our disaffecting it, whether harshness to affections, or discrepancy to carnal reason. And when such judgements have their course, Who are privileged from being seduced? Let our Saviour speak in this, 3So that if it were possible men should deceive the very elect. Upon what may we be assured to stand firm in time of such temptation? Let the Apostle answer us in this, 4when after the effectual working of Satan in them that perish, he comes near to them to whom he writes in the way of comfort thus, But we ought to give thanks alway to God, for you Brethren beloved of the Lord, because that God hath from the beginning chosen you unto salvation through sanctification of the spirit and faith of the truth.
As for the change of Opinion here mentioned, such Professions are nothing strange. But whether such a Profession be in truth, or in pretence, and rather liberty taken to manifest that Opinion, which formerly hath been cherished: as also with what conscience voyd of all carnall respects, such a change or manifestation is made, it belongs not unto us to judge, but to leave that unto God, who tryeth the hearts and reynes. Sure we are, the heart of man is full of deceitfulnesse, both to deceive others, yea and to deceive our selves, the more need there is to be jealous over our selves, and to carry a watchfull eye over our own soules, and whether we have chang'd a former way, or at the first chose one or other way, and continue to imbrace that, whereof we have been at first informed; not to despise, but in the feare of God, to practice that 1holy counsell of the Apostle given to the Corinthians, a famous Church, and such as were destitute of no spirituall gift. Prove your selves, whether you are in the Faith, examine your selves: know ye not your own selves, that Jesus Christ is in you, except ye be Reprobates? as also to consider how indifferently we carry our selves, in using means to inform our selves in the way of truth, and whether they be not such as doe discover our chiefe care hath been to bring our judgements about, to the imbracing 2of that way (whether Truth or Errour) which formerly we did effect. Certaine it is, that Heresies must be, and that to this end, that they that are approved may be made manifest. And Illusions shall have their course, when the truth of God is not imbraced with love, whatsoever be the pretence of our disaffecting it, whether harshnes to affections, or discrepancy to carnall reason. And when such judgements have their course, Who are priviledged from being seduced? Let our Saviour speake in this, 3So that if it were possible men should deceive the very elect. Upon what may we be assured to stand firme in time of such temptation? Let the Apostle answer us in this, 4when after the effectuall working of Satan in them that perish, he comes neere to them to whom he writes in the way of comfort thus, But we ought to give thankes alway to God, for you Brethren beloved of the Lord, because that God hath from the beginning chosen you unto salvation through sanctification of the spirit and faith of the truth.
Like as before he did conclude unto himself their election, from observation of the work of their Faith, the labour of their Love, and the patience of their Hope. And the greater is the comfort which hereby is ministered unto us, the greater should be our care, to inform our selves aright, in the doctrine thereof, and especially to have an eye unto it, that we do not shape it in such a manner, that like as it is impossible we should have any assurance thereof, so it will prove equally impossible we should draw any comfort from thence.
Like as before he did conclude unto himselfe their election, from observation of the work of their Faith, the labour of their Love, and the patience of their Hope. And the greater is the comfort which hereby is ministred unto us, the greater should be our care, to informe our selves aright, in the doctrine thereof, and especially to have an eye unto it, that we doe not shape it in such a manner, that like as it is impossible we should have any assurance thereof, so it will prove equally impossible we should draw any comfort from thence.
1. But is it so, as here it is put upon you, that you knew very well indeed, that the main [Greek or Hebrew], and Question in these Controversies, and that on which all the rest hang, is, What the decrees of God are, touching the everlasting condition of men, and how they are ordered?
1. But is it so, as here it is put upon you, that you knew very well indeed, that the main 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and Question in these Controversies, and that on which all the rest hang, is, What the decrees of God are, touching the everlasting condition of men, and how they are ordered?
I assure you, if you knew this, you know more then I do. I had thought rather that the resolution of the Point concerning Predestination, had depended upon the resolution of the Point touching Grace efficacious, then the contrary. As namely, if Faith be confessed to be the gift of God, and that not with respect to any thing in man, it followeth herehence, that Predestination unto faith, and reprobation from ⟨p. 3⟩faith, must proceed merely upon the good pleasure of God, and not upon foresight of ought in man.
I assure you, if you knew this, you know more then I doe. I had thought rather that the resolution of the Point concerning Predestination, had depended upon the resolution of the Point touching Grace efficacious, then the contrary. As namely, if Faith be confessed to be the gift of God, and that not with respect to any thing in man, it followeth herehence, that Predestination unto faith, and reprobation from ⟨p. 3⟩faith, must proceed mecrely upon the good pleasure of God, and not upon foresight of ought in man.
There was a time when Austin thought, that God elected some to bestow the Holy Ghost upon 1them, that by working that which is good, they might obtain everlasting life: and who were those whom he thus elected? namely such as whom he foresaw would believe: and what was his reason for it? surely this; Quod ergo credimus nostrum est, quod autem bona operamur, Illius est, qui Credentibus dat Spiritum Sanctum; quod profeciò non dicerem, si jam scirem, etiam ipsam fidem inter dei munera reperiri quae dantur in eodem spiritu. Mark I pray the manner of his Retractation, I would not have said (so) if at that time I had known Faith to have been amongst the gifts of God, which are given in the same spirit. So then as soon as Austin came to acknowledge, that Faith it self was the gift of God, he therewithal came off from affirming, that Quem sibi crediturum esse praescivit, ipsum elegit, cui Spiritum Sanctum daret ut bona operando etiam vitam aeternam consequeretur. And like as before he maintained, that God elected some (to wit, Believers) to bestow the Holy spirit upon them, that by working good works, they might obtain also everlasting life; so now having found that Faith also, is the gift of God, he was accordingly to maintain, that God elected some to bestow the Holy spirit upon them, that both by believing, and working good works, they might obtain everlasting life: so that no longer was the foresight of Faith, to precede election in Austins opinion, to wit, after once he knew Faith to be the gift of God. And accordingly in his Book De Praedestin. Sanctorum, addressing himself to the rectifying of the Massilienses in the point of Predestination, wherein they did not as yet discern the truth of God: Adhuc in quaestione caligant de Praedestinatione sanctorum. Cap. 1. And againe, Si quid de Praedestinatione Sanctorum aliter sapiunt (Deus) illis hoc quoque revelabit. Ibid. Mark I pray you what course he takes to rectify them herein. cap. 2. Priùs itaque fidem quâ Christiani sumus donum dei esse debemus ostendere: and whereas he had performed this task very sufficiently before, manifesting by divers pregnant passages of holy Scripture, that Faith was the gift of God, and the Massilienses did elude them by such a distinction as this, Faith may be considered two ways, either as touching Initium, the first beginning of it;
There was a time when Austin thought, that God elected some to bestow the Holy Ghost upon 1them, that by working that which is good, they might obtain everlasting life: and who were those whom he thus elected? namely such as whom he foresaw would believe: and what was his reason for it? surely this; Quod ergo credimus nostrum est, quod autem bona operamur, Illius est, qui Credentibus dat Spiritum Sanctum; quod profeciò non dicerem, si jam scirem, etiam ipsam fidem inter dei munera reperiri quae dantur in eodem spiritu. Marke I pray the manner of his Retractation, I would not have said (so) if at that time I had known Faith to have been amongst the gifts of God, which are given in the same spirit. So then as soon as Austin came to acknowledg, that Faith it selfe was the gift of God, he therewithall came off from affirming, that Quem sibi crediturum esse praescivit, ipsum elegit, cui Spiritum Sanctum daret ut bona operando etiam vitam aeternam consequeretur. And like as before he maintained, that God elected some (to wit, Believers) to bestow the Holy spirit upon them, that by working good workes, they might obtain also everlasting life; so now having found that Faith also, is the gift of God, he was accordingly to maintain, that God elected some to bestow the Holy spirit upon them, that both by believing, and working good workes, they might obtain everlasting life: so that no longer was the foresight of Faith, to precede election in Austins opinion, to wit, after once he knew Faith to be the gift of God. And accordingly in his Book De Praedestin. Sanctorum, addressing himselfe to the rectifying of the Massilienses in the poynt of Predestination, wherein they did not as yet discerne the truth of God: Adhuc in quaestione caligant de Praedestinatione sanctorum. Cap. 1. And againe, Si quid de Praedestinatione Sanctorum aliter sapiunt (Deus) illis hoc quoque revelabit. Ibid. Marke I pray you what course he takes to rectify them herein. cap. 2. Priùs itaque fidem quâ Christiani sumus donum dei esse debemus ostendere: and whereas he had performed this task very sufficiently before, manifesting by divers pregnant passages of holy Scripture, that Faith was the gift of God, and the Massilienses did elude them by such a distinction as this, Faith may be considered two waies, either as touching Initium, the first beginning of it;
or as touching Incrementum the augmentation thereof; and accommodating this distinction said, The passages of Scripture alleged by Austin proceeded as touching the Augmentation of it, which they willingly granted to be the work of God; but not as touching the initiation of it, which they still maintained to be the work of man. Therefore Austin addresseth himself in that discourse of his, to prove that the very Initiation of Faith, is the work of God, and not the Augmentation only. His words are these, Sed nunc iis respondendum esse video, qui divina testimonia, quae de hâc re adhibuïmus, ad hoc dicunt valere, ut noverimus ex nobis quidem nos habere ipsam fidem, sed incrementum ejus ex Deo: tanquam fides non ab ipso donetur nobis, sed ab ipso tantum augeatur in nobis ex merito quo coepit à nobis. And likewise in the 19. cap. of the same Book, having propounded the opinion of the Pelagians, namely that because God foresaw that we would be holy and unblameable before him in love, therefore he elected and predestinated us in Christ, before the foundation of the World; and showed how this opinion, contradicts that of the Apostle Ephes. 1. 4, 5. where it is said, that, God elected us in Christ, and predestinated us before the foundation of the World, that we should be holy and unblameable before him in love: and perceiving withal how the Massilians did avoid this as nothing contrary to their Tenet (though contrary to the Pelagian Tenet) forasmuch as they maintained not, that God foresaw any thing but our Faith, and therefore God elected us before the foundation of the World, that we should be holy and unblameable before him in love, (for these were their words) Nos autem dicimus nostram Deum non praescisse nisi fidem & ideo nos elegisse—ut etiam sancti & immaculati gratia atquè opere ejus essemus; what course doth Austin take to beat them off but this, namely to prove, that, Like as Holiness so Faith also, and that as touching the Initiation thereof, is the work of God. thus: Sed audiant ipsi in hoc testimonio, ubi dicit, sortem consecuti simus, praedestinati secundum propositum qui universa operatur. Ipse ergo ut credere incipiamus operatur qui universa operatur.
or as touching Incrementum the augmentation thereof; and accommodating this distinction said, The passages of Scripture alleadged by Austin proceeded as touching the Augmentation of it, which they willingly granted to be the work of God; but not as touching the initiation of it, which they still maintained to be the work of man. Therefore Austin addresseth himselfe in that discourse of his, to prove that the very Initiation of Faith, is the work of God, and not the Augmentation only. His words are these, Sed nunc iis respondendum esse video, qui divina testimonia, quae de hâc re adhibuïmus, ad hoc dicunt valere, ut noverimus ex nobis quidem nos habere ipsam fidem, sed incrementum ejus ex Deo: tanquam fides non ab ipso donetur nobis, sed ab ipso tantum augeatur in nobis ex merito quo coepit à nobis. And likewise in the 19. cap. of the same Book, having propounded the opinion of the Pelagians, namely that because God foresaw that we would be holy and unblameable before him in love, therefore he elected and predestinated us in Christ, before the foundation of the World; and shew'd how this opinion, contradicts that of the Apostle Ephes. 1. 4, 5. where it is said, that, God elected us in Christ, and predestinated us before the foundation of the World, that we should be holy and unblameable before him in love: and perceiving withall how the Massilians did avoid this as nothing contrary to their Tenent (though contrary to the Pelagian Tenent) forasmuch as they maintained not, that God foresaw any thing but our Faith, and therefore God elected us before the foundation of the World, that we should be holy and unblameable before him in love, (for these were their words) Nos autem dicimus nostram Deum non praescisse nisi fidem & ideo nos elegisse—ut etiam sancti & immaculati gratia atquè opere ejus essemus; what course doth Austin take to beat them off but this, namely to prove, that, Like as Holines so Faith also, and that as touching the Initiation thereof, is the work of God. thus: Sed audiant ipsi in hoc testimonio, ubi dicit, sortem consecuti simus, praedestinati secundum propositum qui universa operatur. Ipse ergo ut credere incipiamus operatur qui universa operatur.
So that it is clear in the opinion of Austin, that to take both himself and others off from premising the foresight of Faith unto Gods election, it is sufficient to prove that Faith is the gift of God, the work of God both touching the augmentation, and touching the first introduction thereof. And thus evincing the condition of Predestination, as excluding all foresight of Faith, from the condition of Predestination, as being throughout the work of God in man, rather then taking a contrary course, as if the main [Greek or Hebrew] were, ⟨p. 4⟩what is the condition of Gods decree of Predestination, as here it is pretended and supposed. And albeit it is commonly received of all sides (as if it were without question) that Faith is the gift of God: yet we find practises on foot, for the working of a manifest innovation herein. For not to speak of their interpretations of their own meanings, as, in what sense they say God works Faith in us; it is apparent the Remonstrants now a days, do as good as profess, that Faith is not bestowed upon us for Christs sake, in as much as they deny that Christ merited Faith for us. For when the Author of the Censure passed upon the Remonstrants Confession, disputeth thus, At si hoc tantum meritus est Christus tum Christus nobis non est meritus fidem nec regenerationem: the Remonstrants in the Answer hereunto, forthwith confess it in these 1words, Sanè ita est. Nihil ineptius, nihil vanius est quàm hoc Christi merito tribuere. Si enim Christus nobis meritus dicatur fidem & regenerationem, tum fides conditio esse non poterit, quam a peccatoribus Deus sub comminatione mortis aeternae exigeret. And by the way mark, I pray, that not any difference is put between Faith and Regeneration; manifestly signifying thereby, that as they grant it to be the work of man to believe, so we are commanded to make our selves a new heart.2
So that it is cleer in the opinion of Austin, that to take both himselfe and others off from premising the foresight of Faith unto Gods election, it is sufficient to prove that Faith is the gift of God, the work of God both touching the augmentation, and touching the first introduction thereof. And thus evincing the condition of Predestination, as excluding all foresight of Faith, from the condition of Predestination, as being throughout the work of God in man, rather then taking a contrary course, as if the main 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 were, ⟨p. 4⟩what is the condition of Gods decree of Predestination, as here it is pretended and supposed. And albeit it is commonly received of all sides (as if it were without question) that Faith is the gift of God: yet we find practises on foot, for the working of a manifest innovation herein. For not to speak of their interpretations of their own meanings, as, in what sence they say God workes Faith in us; it is apparent the Remonstrants now a daies, doe as good as professe, that Faith is not bestowed upon us for Christs sake, in as much as they deny that Christ merited Faith for us. For when the Author of the Censure passed upon the Remonstrants Confession, disputeth thus, At si hoc tantum meritus est Christus tum Christus nobis non est meritus fidem nec regenerationem: the Remonstrants in the Answer hereunto, forthwith confesse it in these 1words, Sanè ita est. Nihil ineptius, nihil vanius est quàm hoc Christi merito tribuere. Si enim Christus nobis meritus dicatur fidem & regenerationem, tum fides conditio esse non poterit, quam a peccatoribus Deus sub comminatione mortis aeternae exigeret. And by the way marke, I pray, that not any difference is put between Faith and Regeneration; manifestly signifying thereby, that as they grant it to be the work of man to believe, so we are commanded to make our selves a new heart.2
And as for ordering of the decrees, which here is added to complete the main [Greek or Hebrew], as here is pretended that in my opinion, is so far off from being the main [Greek or Hebrew], as that it is not to be accounted any [Greek or Hebrew] at all Theological, but merely Logical. Let the condition of the decrees be rightly explicated according to Divinity, and we shall have no need at all of Divinity for the right ordering of them. A mere Logical faculty by light of nature, will serve for this. For the decrees whereof we treat, are merely Intentions rerum gerendarum. Now for the ordering of these in what kind soever, we have received Rules of the Schools, never yet that I know contradicted by any; namely, that they are to be ordered according to the condition of the things intended, which are but two, to wit, the end and the means; and all do attribute priority to the intention of the end, and posteriority to the intention of the means. It is true, men may err, in designing the right end, as also, in designing the right means, and these errors are to be discovered, and the truth cleared by that science, whereunto the consideration of the end and means belong, and not by Logic. But agreement being made concerning the end and means, there is no doubt to be made, but that according to the most received Rules of Schools, the end must be acknowledged both first in intention, and last in execution, and contrarily the means last in intention and first in execution.
And as for ordering of the decrees, which here is added to compleat the main 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, as here is pretended that in my opinion, is so farr off from being the main 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, as that it is not to be accounted any 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 at all Theologicall, but meerly Logicall. Let the condition of the decrees be rightly explicated according to Divinity, and we shall have no need at all of Divinity for the right ordering of them. A meer Logicall faculty by light of nature, will serve for this. For the decrees whereof we treat, are meerely Intentiones rerum gerendarum. Now for the ordering of these in what kind soever, we have received Rules of the Schooles, never yet that I know contradicted by any; namely, that they are to be ordered according to the condition of the things intended, which are but two, to wit, the end and the means; and all doe attribute priority to the intention of the end, and posteriority to the intention of the means. It is true, men may erre, in designing the right end, as also, in designing the right means, and these errours are to be discovered, and the truth cleered by that science, whereunto the consideration of the end and means belong, and not by Logick. But agreement being made concerning the end and means, there is no doubt to be made, but that according to the most received Rules of Schooles, the end must be acknowledged both first in intention, and last in execution, and contrarily the means last in intention and first in execution.
2. But come we to the Decrees themselves, & the different opinions thereabouts, which follow in the next place. Now here I looked for different opinions about decrees, in the plural number, but I find the relation extends no farther then to one decree, and that of Reprobation. So at the first entrance reasons are promised, even in this writing, to be exhibited of change of opinion in certain controversies in the plural number, when in the issue, all comes but to one controversy, and that about Reprobation. Yet the Scripture speaketh fully of Election, sparingly of Reprobation in most places, leaving us to judge thereof, by consequence from the doctrine of Election Yet some passages we have (I confess) that give light and evidence to both alike. For like as it is said Acts 2. last. that God added daily to the Church such as should be saved. so 2 Cor. 4. 3. it is said, If our Gospel be hid, it is hid to them that are lost, and as it is signified Math. 24 24. that Tis impossible seducers should prevail over the elect. so 2 Thes. 2. both as much is signified ver. 13. and also expressed ver. 10. 11. that they shall prevail among them that perish: and the 1 Cor. 1. 18. we are given to understand jointly, that the preaching of the Cross is to them that perish foolishness: but unto us which are saved it is the power of God. and Rom. 9. 18. that as God hath mercy on whom he will, so also he hardeneth whom he will. And like as Acts 13. 48. we read that, as many believed as were ordained to eternal life; which phrase of ordaining to eternal life, I conceive (under correction) to be all one with the phrase of Writing our names in Heaven. Luke 10. 20. and writing us in heaven. Hebr. 12. 23. and this phrase I take to be all one with the writing of us in the Book of life. So on the other side we read, that Whose names were not written in the Book of Life from the foundation of the World should wonder when they beheld the Be•st, and not so only but 1worship him also. But give we every vessel leave to vent that liquor whereof it is full.
2. But come we to the Decrees themselves, & the different opinions thereabouts, which follow in the next place. Now here I looked for different opinions about decrees, in the plural number, but I find the relation extends no farther then to one decree, and that of Reprobation. So at the first entrance reasons are promised, even in this writing, to be exhibited of chang of opinion in certain controversies in the plurall number, when in the issue, all comes but to one controversy, and that about Reprobation. Yet the Scripture speaketh fully of Election, sparingly of Reprobation in most places, leaving us to judge thereof, by consequence from the doctrine of Election Yet some passages we have (I confesse) that give light and evidence to both alike. For like as it is said Acts 2. last. that God added daily to the Church such as should be saved. so 2 Cor. 4. 3. it is said, If our Gospell be hid, it is hid to them that are lost, and as it is signified Math. 24 24. that Tis impossible seducers should prevaile over the elect. so 2 Thes. 2. both as much is signified ver. 13. and also expressed ver. 10. 11. that they shall prevaile among them that perish: and the 1 Cor. 1. 18. we are given to understand joyntly, that the preaching of the Crosse is to them that perish foolishnesse: but unto us which are saved it is the power of God. and Rom. 9. 18. that as God hath mercy on whom he will, so also he hardneth whom he will. And like as Acts 13. 48. we read that, as many believed as were ordained to eternall life; which phrase of ordaining to eternall life, I conceive (under correction) to be all one with the phrase of Writing our names in Heaven. Luke 10. 20. and writing us in heaven. Hebr. 12. 23. and this phrase I take to be all one with the writing of us in the Book of life. So on the other side we read, that Whose names were not written in the Book of Life from the foundation of the World should wonder when they beheld the Be•st, and not so only but 1
I come to the consideration of the different opinions here proposed, concerning the decree of Reprobation; and herein, I will endeavour to open a clear way to the ⟨p. 5⟩right understanding of the truth, that your judgement may have the more free course in discerning it, and withal, to represent unto you, the unreasonable carriage of our Adversaries in the setting down of our Tenet, whereby you may guess, what you are to expect from them prosecuting against it. And herein I will insist upon these particulars. The first shall be the Things Decreed. The second the Cause of this decree. The third, the Persons on whom this Decree doth pass. The fourth shall be that claw of Unavoidable Sin, and Damnation.
I come to the consideration of the different opinions here proposed, concerning the decree of Reprobation; and herein, I will endeavour to open a clear way to the ⟨p. 5⟩right understanding of the truth, that your judgement may have the more free course in discerning it, and withall, to represent unto you, the unreasonable carriage of our Adversaries in the setting downe of our Tenent, whereby you may guesse, what you are to expect from them prosecuting against it. And herein I will insist upon these particulars. The first shall be the Things Decreed. The second the Cause of this decree. The third, the Persons on whom this Decree doth passe. The fourth shall be that claw of Unavoydable Sin, and Damnation.
1. The Things Decreed are here said to be, The casting off from grace and glory, and the shutting of men up under Damnation.
Now I pray observe here in the first place, that, by casting off from grace and glory, we mean no other thing, then the not giving of grace and glory; and by grace, we mean the grace of Faith and Repentance, the grace of Regeneration. For like as in Election God purposeth (we say) to give this grace unto some, which is the same with showing mercy on them. Rom. 9. 18. as we suppose; so on the other side, God purposeth to deny this grace unto others, which in Scripture phrase is to harden them, that being made opposite to Gods showing mercy. Rom. 9. 18. And for the farther clearing of the terms we say, that God by giving Faith and Repentance, doth cure that infidelity and impenitency, which is natural unto all, as being borne in sin: and by not giving this grace of Faith and Repentance unto others, God leaves their natural infidelity and impenitency uncured. And if this Author means ought else by shutting up under sin, then the not curing of their natural infidelity and impenitency, he doth us wrong, and what he means thereby I know not. As for shutting up under damnation, that is not our phrase, but we love to speak in plain terms, and say, that God doth purpose to inflict damnation on them whom he Reprobates.
Now I pray observe here in the first place, that, by casting off from grace and glory, we mean no other thing, then the not giving of grace and glory; and by grace, we mean the grace of Faith and Repentance, the grace of Regeneration. For like as in Election God purposeth (we say) to give this grace unto some, which is the same with shewing mercy on them. Rom. 9. 18. as we suppose; so on the other side, God purposeth to deny this grace unto others, which in Scripture phrase is to harden them, that being made opposite to Gods shewing mercy. Rom. 9. 18. And for the farther clearing of the termes we say, that God by giving Faith and Repentance, doth cure that infidelity and impenitency, which is naturall unto all, as being borne in sin: and by not giving this grace of Faith and Repentance unto others, God leaves their naturall infidelity and impenitency uncured. And if this Author means ought else by shutting up under sin, then the not curing of their naturall infidelity and impenitency, he doth us wrong, and what he means thereby I know not. As for shutting up under damnation, that is not our phrase, but we love to speak in plain tearmes, and say, that God doth purpose to inflict damnation on them whom he Reprobates.
Thus much for the clearing of the terms, as touching the things Decreed.
Thus much for the cleering of the tearmes, as touching the things Decreed.
Secondly, observe I pray, which is of principal consideration, that here we have no cause at all specified, why he refuseth to give them grace; cunningly leaving it to an improvident Reader to conceive, that the cause of the decree, which is here specified, to be the mere pleasure of Gods will, is indifferently appliable to the not giving of grace and glory, and to the shutting up under damnation as the cause thereof, which is a notorious imposture, yet I do not think this Author guilty of it, but others rather, who abuse their wits by cunning courses, to deceive the hearts of the simple. Amongst the Fallacies observed by Aristotle, there is one called Fallacia plurium interrogationum, as when many things are put together, and an answer is required to be made, either affirmatively or negatively to them all, as if they were but one; when indeed the answer cannot be made aright, without distinction of the things demanded, the one whereof perhaps requires an answer affirmative, the other negative. As for example, to instance as touching one of the Controversies here declined: We are often demanded, whether every one that heareth the Gospel, be not bound to believe that Christ died for him? Now I say this phrase Christ died for me includes many things, as the benefits which arise unto me by the death of Christ, may be conceived to be many. But let these benefits be distinguished, and we shall readily answer to the question made, and that perhaps differently, as namely, affirmatively to some, negatively to others; as thus. Do you speak of Christs dying for me, that is, for the pardon of my sins, and for the salvation of my soul: I answer affirmatively and say, I am bound to believe that Christ died for the procuring of these benefits unto me in such manner, as God hath ordained, to wit, not absolutely but conditionally, to wit, in case I do believe and repent. For God hath not otherwise ordained, that I should reap the benefit of pardon and salvation, by virtue of Christs Death and Passion, unless I believe in him and repent. But if question be made, whether I am bound to believe that Christ died for me, to procure faith and repentance unto me; I do not say, that I am bound, or that every one who hears the Gospel, is bound to believe this.
Secondly, observe I pray, which is of principall consideration, that here we have no cause at all specified, why he refuseth to give them grace; cunningly leaving it to an improvident Reader to conceive, that the cause of the decree, which is here specified, to be the meer pleasure of Gods will, is indifferently applyable to the not giving of grace and glory, and to the shutting up under damnation as the cause thereof, which is a notorious imposture, yet I doe not think this Author guilty of it, but others rather, who abuse their witts by cunning courses, to deceive the hearts of the simple. Amongst the Fallacies observed by Aristotle, there is one called Fallacia plurium interrogationum, as when many things are put together, and an answer is required to be made, either affirmatively or negatively to them all, as if they were but one; when indeed the answer cannot be made aright, without distinction of the things demanded, the one whereof perhaps requires an answer affirmative, the other negative. As for example, to instance as touching one of the Controversies here declined: We are often demanded, whether every one that heareth the Gospell, be not bound to believe that Christ died for him? Now I say this phrase Christ died for me includes many things, as the benefits which arise unto me by the death of Christ, may be conceived to be many. But let these benefits be distinguished, and we shall readily answer to the question made, and that perhaps differently, as namely, affirmatively to some, negatively to others; as thus. Doe you speak of Christs dying for me, that is, for the pardon of my sins, and for the salvation of my soule: I answer affirmatively and say, I am bound to believe that Christ died for the procuring of these benefits unto me in such manner, as God hath ordained, to wit, not absolutely but conditionally, to wit, in case I doe believe and repent. For God hath not otherwise ordained, that I should reap the benefit of pardon and salvation, by vertue of Christs Death and Passion, unlesse I believe in him and repent. But if question be made, whether I am bound to believe that Christ died for me, to procure faith and repentance unto me; I doe not say, that I am bound, or that every one who hears the Gospel, is bound to believe this.
Nay the Remonstrants now a days, deny in express terms, that Christ merited 1this for any at all. I am not of their opinion in this; but I see clearly a reason manifesting, that Christ merited not this for all, no not for all and every one, that hears the Gospel. For if he had, then either he hath merited it for them absolutely or conditionally. Not absolutely, for then all and every one of them should believe de facto, which is untrue; for the Apostle saith, Fides non est Omnium: Nor conditionally, for 2what condition I pray can be devised, upon the performance whereof, God for Christs sake should give us faith, and repentance? In like sort, if I am demanded ⟨p. 6⟩whether God did decree, of the mere pleasure of his will, to refuse to give grace and glory unto some, and to inflict upon them damnation. To this I cannot answer at once, there being a Fallacy in the demand. But distinguish them, I answer and say, that, as touching the point of denying grace, God doth that of his mere pleasure; but as touching the denial of glory, and the inflicting of damnation, he doth not decree to do these of mere pleasure, but rather merely for sin, to wit, for their infidelity and impenitency, and all the bitter fruits that shall proceed from them. So that Reprobation according to our Tenet rightly stated, is the decree of God partly to deny unto some, and that of his mere pleasure, the grace of Faith and Repentance, for the curing of that infidelity and hardness of heart, which is natural unto all, and partly to deprive them of glory, and to inflict damnation upon them, not of his mere pleasure, but merely for their final continuance in sin, to wit, in infidelity and impenitency, and all the fruits that proceed therehence.
Nay the Remonstrants now a daies, deny in expresse tearmes, that Christ merited 1this for any at all. I am not of their opinion in this; but I see clearly a reason manifesting, that Christ merited not this for all, no not for all and every one, that hears the Gospel. For if he had, then either he hath merited it for them absolutely or conditionally. Not absolutely, for then all and every one of them should believe de facto, which is untrue; for the Apostle saith, Fides non est Omnium: Nor conditionally, for 2what condition I pray can be devised, upon the performance whereof, God for Christs sake should give us faith, and repentance? In like sort, if I am demanded ⟨p. 6⟩whether God did decree, of the meer pleasure of his will, to refuse to give grace and glory unto some, and to inflict upon them damnation. To this I cannot answer at once, there being a Fallacy in the demand. But distinguish them, I answer and say, that, as touching the poynt of denying grace, God doth that of his meer pleasure; but as touching the denyall of glory, and the inflicting of damnation, he doth not decree to doe these of meer pleasure, but rather meerly for sin, to wit, for their infidelity and impenitency, and all the bitter fruits that shall proceed from them. So that Reprobation according to our Tenent rightly stated, is the decree of God partly to deny unto some, and that of his meer pleasure, the grace of Faith and Repentance, for the curing of that infidelity and hardnes of heart, which is naturall unto all, and partly to deprive them of glory, and to inflict damnation upon them, not of his meer pleasure, but meerly for their finall continuance in sin, to wit, in infidelity and impenitency, and all the fruits that proceed therehence.
2. Now as for the cause of this decree, as likewise of all the decrees of God, when any of our Divines say, that it is the mere pleasure of God, as in some places it is expressed of some decrees, let them be understood aright; not as if they distinguished between the decree of God, and the good pleasure of his will; for we know full well, that the decree of God is the good pleasure of his Will, what decree soever it be: but hereby we only exclude, all causes from without, moving God to make any such decree; like as when it is said, Deuteron. 7. 7. The Lord did not set his love upon you, nor choose you, because ye were more in number then any people, but because the Lord loved you, as much as to say, The Lord loved you, because he loved you. Where we cannot soberly devise any distinction between love and love, as between the cause and the effect; only hereby is excluded all cause from without. Now we are ready with open face to profess, that of the Will and decree of God, there neither is, nor can be any cause from without: all things from without being temporal, and the Will of God being eternal, and the Will of God quoad actum Volentis, being the very Essence of God; For God is a pure Act and that indivisibly One, whereby he is said to Be whatsoever he is, as we do conceive variety of perfections in God, yet all these are but one indivisible Act in God; and by this one indivisible Act, he both knows all that he knows, and willeth and decreeth all that he willeth and decreeth. Man when he willeth any thing, as likewise an Angel when he willeth ought, they produce an act of willing passing upon this or that object: but it is not so with God, in whom there is no accident. And therefore Aquinas was bold to profess, that never any man was so mad, as to 1profess that merits were the cause of Predestination, as touching the act of God predestinating: and why so? why surely upon this ground, because predestination is the will of God: and like as nothing can be the cause of the will of God, as touching the act of willing, so nothing can be the cause of divine predestination, as touching the act of God predestinating. His words are these in the same place; Sic inquirenda est ratio praedestinationis, sicut inquiritur ratio divinae voluntatis. dictum est autem suprà, quod non est assignare causam divinae voluntatis ex parte actus volendi.
2. Now as for the cause of this decree, as likewise of all the decrees of God, when any of our Divines say, that it is the meer pleasure of God, as in some places it is expressed of some decrees, let them be understood aright; not as if they distinguished between the decree of God, and the good pleasure of his will; for we know full well, that the decree of God is the good pleasure of his Will, what decree soever it be: but hereby we only exclude, all causes from without, moving God to make any such decree; like as when it is said, Deuteron. 7. 7. The Lord did not set his love upon you, nor chuse you, because ye were more in number then any people, but because the Lord loved you, as much as to say, The Lord loved you, because he loved you. Where we cannot soberly devise any distinction between love and love, as between the cause and the effect; only hereby is excluded all cause from without. Now we are ready with open face to professe, that of the Will and decree of God, there neither is, nor can be any cause from without: all things from without being temporall, and the Will of God being eternall, and the Will of God quoad actum Volentis, being the very Essence of God; For God is a pure Act and that indivisibly One, whereby he is said to Bee whatsoever he is, as wee doe conceive variety of perfections in God, yet all these are but one indivisible Act in God; and by this one indivisible Act, he both knowes all that he knowes, and willeth and decreeth all that he willeth and decreeth. Man when he willeth any thing, as likewise an Angel when he willeth ought, they produce an act of willing passing upon this or that object: but it is not so with God, in whom there is no accident. And therefore Aquinas was bold to professe, that never any man was so mad, as to 1professe that merits were the cause of Predestination, as touching the act of God predestinating: and why so? why surely upon this ground, because predestination is the will of God: and like as nothing can be the cause of the will of God, as touching the act of willing, so nothing can be the cause of divine predestination, as touching the act of God predestinating. His words are these in the same place; Sic inquirenda est ratio praedestinationis, sicut inquiritur ratio divinae voluntatis. dictum est autem suprà, quod non est assignare causam divinae voluntatis ex parte actus volendi.
But because like as the love of God is sometime taken for the good thing which God bestows, like as Jansenius interprets that place John. 14. 21. He that loveth me shall be beloved of my Father, to wit, of the effect of the Fathers love; and we commonly say, that Passions are attributed unto God not quoad Affectum, but quoad Effectum: in like sort the Will of God is taken for the thing willed, as 1 Thes. 4. 3. This is the will of God, even your sanctification, that is, this is willed by him. Therefore Aquinas distinguisheth a double consideration in the will of God, one quoad actum volentis, and so it hath no cause from without; another quoad res volitas, and so it may have a cause. So likewise in predestination as considering it either quoad actum Praedestinantis, and so it hath no cause, or quoad effectum Praedestinationis, and so it may have a cause, as there he professeth, both touching the will of God in general, and touching Predestination in special. Of the will of God in generall, thus; Non est assignare causam voluntatis divinae ex parte actus volendi, sed potest assignari ratio ex parte volitorum, in quantum scilicet Deus vult esse aliquid propter aliud. And of predestination in speciall, thus; Sed hoc sub quaestione vertitur, utrum ex parte effectus praedestinatio habeat aliquam causam; & hoc est quaerere utrum Deus praeordinaverit se daturum effectum praedestinationis alicui propter aliqua merita. Now thus we acknowledge of predestination, both in the way of a meritorious cause on Christs part, and in the way of a disposing cause on our part. For God we say, hath predestinated to bestow upon us, both grace and glory for Christs sake; where Christ is made a meritorious cause of grace and glory, ⟨p. 7⟩but not of the act of predestination. And farther we say, that God hath predestinated to bestow glory upon us, as a reward of grace, as a reward of faith, repentance, and good works: and to this purpose it is said that God by his grace, doth make us meet partakers of the inheritance of the Saints in light, Coloss. 1. 12. But as for the bestowing of grace on any, we say there is no cause thereof on mans part, For he hath mercy on whom he will. Rom. 9. 18. and he hath called us with an holy calling not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace. 2 Timoth. 1. 9.
But because like as the love of God is sometime taken for the good thing which God bestowes, like as Jansenius interprets that place Iohn. 14. 21. He that loveth me shall be beloved of my Father, to wit, of the effect of the Fathers love; and we commonly say, that Passions are attributed unto God not quoad Affectum, but quoad Effectum: in like sort the Will of God is taken for the thing willed, as 1 Thes. 4. 3. This is the will of God, even your sanctification, that is, this is willed by him. Therefore Aquinas distinguisheth a double consideration in the will of God, one quoad actum volentis, and so it hath no cause from without; another quoad res volitas, and so it may have a cause. So likewise in predestination as considering it either quoad actum Praedestinantis, and so it hath no cause, or quoad effectum Praedestinationis, and so it may have a cause, as there he professeth, both touching the will of God in generall, and touching Predestination in speciall. Of the will of God in generall, thus; Non est assignare causam voluntatis divinae ex parte actus volendi, sed potest assignari ratio ex parte volitorum, in quantum scilicet Deus vult esse aliquid propter aliud. And of predestination in speciall, thus; Sed hoc sub quaestione vertitur, utrum ex parte effectus praedestinatio habeat aliquam causam; & hoc est quaerere utrum Deus praeordinaverit se daturum effectum praedestinationis alicui propter aliqua merita. Now thus we acknowledge of predestination, both in the way of a meritorious cause on Christs part, and in the way of a disposing cause on our part. For God we say, hath predestinated to bestow upon us, both grace and glory for Christs sake; where Christ is made a meritorious cause of grace and glory, ⟨p. 7⟩but not of the act of predestination. And farther we say, that God hath predestinated to bestow glory upon us, as a reward of grace, as a reward of faith, repentance, and good workes: and to this purpose it is said that God by his grace, doth make us meet partakers of the inheritance of the Saints in light, Coloss. 1. 12. But as for the bestowing of grace on any, we say there is no cause thereof on mans part, For he hath mercy on whom he will. Rom. 9. 18. and he hath called us with an holy calling not according to our workes, but according to his own purpose and grace. 2 Timoth. 1. 9.
Now let us apply this to reprobation, which is the will of God, as well as predestination, and if there can be no cause of predestination quoad actum Praedestinantis, because there can be no cause of the will of God quoad actum volentis; Who seeth not, that by the same reason, there can be no cause of reprobation quoad actum reprobantis? And if it be a mad thing to maintain that merits are the cause of predestination quoad actum praedestinantis; it must be as mad a thing to maintain, that any merits of the creature, can be the cause of reprobation quoad actum reprobantis. And this doctrine Aquinas applies expressly to Reprobation it self, upon the 9. Rom. Lect. 2da, at the end of these words Praescientia peccatorum potest esse aliqua ratio reprobationis: but how? ex parte actus reprobantis? nothing less, but rather ex parte effectus; and what effect? not the denying of grace, but only as touching the inflicting of punishment: thus, Praescientia peccatorum potest esse aliqua ratio reprobationis, ex parte paenae quae praeparatur reprobatis, in quantum scilicet Deus proponit se puniturum malos propter peccata quae à seipsis habent non à Deo.
Now let us apply this to reprobation, which is the will of God, as well as predestination, and if there can be no cause of predestination quoad actum Praedestinantis, because there can be no cause of the will of God quoad actum volentis; Who seeth not, that by the same reason, there can be no cause of reprobation quoad actum reprobantis? And if it be a mad thing to maintain that merits are the cause of predestination quoad actum praedestinantis; it must be as mad a thing to maintain, that any merits of the creature, can be the cause of reprobation quoad actum reprobantis. And this doctrine Aquinas applies expresly to Reprobation it selfe, upon the 9. Rom. Lect. 2da, at the end of these words Praescientia peccatorum potest esse aliqua ratio reprobationis: but how? ex parte actus reprobantis? nothing lesse, but rather ex parte effectus; and what effect? not the denying of grace, but only as touching the inflicting of punishment: thus, Praescientia peccatorum potest esse aliqua ratio reprobationis, ex parte paenae quae praeparatur reprobatis, in quantum scilicet Deus proponit se puniturum malos propter peccata quae à seipsis habent non à Deo.
And farther we prove this, both by clear evidence of Scripture, and clear evidence of reason, and thirdly by as clear a representation of their infatuation that oppose this doctrine, and particularly of the Author of this discourse.
And farther we prove this, both by cleare evidence of Scripture, and cleare evidence of reason, and thirdly by as cleare a representation of their infatuation that oppose this doctrine, and particularly of the Author of this discourse.
First by clear evidence of Scripture. Rom. 9. 11. Where the Apostle proves, that Election stands not of good works, by an argument drawn from the circumstance of the time, when that Oracle, The elder shall serve the younger, was delivered; together with the present condition of Jacob and Esau, answerable to that time; thus, Before the children were borne, or had done good or evil, it was said to Rebecca, The Elder shall serve the Younger, Therefore the purpose of God according to Election stands not of good works. Now look by what strength of reason the Apostle concludes this of Election, by the same strength of argumentation may I conclude of reprobation, in proportion, thus, Before the Children were borne, or had done Good or Evil, it was said to Rebecca The Elder shall serve the Younger; therefore the purpose of God according to reprobation, stands not of evil works: that is, like as good works are not the cause of Election, so evil works are not the cause of Reprobation, to wit, quoad actum reprobantis, as touching the very act and eternal decree of God it self.
First by cleare evidence of Scripture. Rom. 9. 11. Where the Apostle proves, that Election stands not of good works, by an argument drawn from the circumstance of the time, when that Oracle, The elder shall serve the younger, was delivered; together with the present condition of Jacob and Esau, answerable to that time; thus, Before the children were borne, or had done good or evill, it was said to Rebecca, The Elder shall serve the Younger, Therefore the purpose of God according to Election stands not of good workes. Now look by what strength of reason the Apostle concludes this of Election, by the same strength of argumentation may I conclude of reprobation, in proportion, thus, Before the Children were borne, or had done Good or Evill, it was said to Rebecca The Elder shall serve the Younger; therefore the purpose of God according to reprobation, stands not of evill workes: that is, like as good workes are not the cause of Election, so evill workes are not the cause of Reprobation, to wit, quoad actum reprobantis, as touching the very act and eternall decree of God it selfe.
Secondly, observe, I pray, whether my reason be not as clear; If God upon the foresight of sin, doth ordain a man unto damnation; (thus I am content to propose it in the most rigorous manner) then this is done either by necessity of nature, or by the constitution of God: Not by necessity of nature, as it is confessed; and the cause is evident, for undoubtedly he could annihilate them, and so he can the holiest creature that lives, as all sides confess. Therefore it must be by the constitution of God: but neither can this hold. For if so, then God did constitute, that is ordain, that upon the foresight of sin, he would ordain men unto damnation. Where observe that the act of divine ordination, is made the object of divine ordination: as much as to say, he did ordain to ordain, or he did decree to decree: Whereas the objects of Gods decrees are always things temporal; as for example, We say well, God did decree to create the world, to make man out of the earth, to send Christ into the World, to preserve us, to redeem us, sanctify us, save us. But Gods ordination or decree is an act eternal, and cannot be the object of his decree or ordination. I challenge all the Powers of darkness to answer this, and to vindicate the Tenet, which I impugn, from that absurdity, which I charge upon it, if they can.
Secondly, observe, I pray, whether my reason be not as cleare; If God upon the foresight of sin, doth ordain a man unto damnation; (thus I am content to propose it in the most rigorous manner) then this is done either by necessity of nature, or by the constitution of God: Not by necessity of nature, as it is confessed; and the cause is evident, for undoubtedly he could annihilate them, and so he can the holiest creature that lives, as all sides confesse. Therefore it must be by the constitution of God: but neither can this hold. For if so, then God did constitute, that is ordaine, that upon the foresight of sin, he would ordaine men unto damnation. Where observe that the act of divine ordination, is made the object of divine ordination: as much as to say, he did ordaine to ordaine, or he did decree to decree: Whereas the objects of Gods decrees are alwaies things temporall; as for example, We say well, God did decree to create the world, to make man out of the earth, to send Christ into the World, to preserve us, to redeeme us, sanctify us, save us. But Gods ordination or decree is an act eternall, and cannot be the object of his decree or ordination. I challenge all the Powers of darknes to answer this, and to vindicate the Tenent, which I impugne, from that absurdity, which I charge upon it, if they can.
O but some will say, it's very harsh to say, that God of his mere pleasure doth ordain men unto damnation.
O but some will say, it's very harsh to say, that God of his meer pleasure doth ordain men unto damnation.