Section 9
pp. 110–11619 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Section 9.
Sin may be considered as sin, or as a means of declaring God's justice in mens punishments. God 1doth not predestinate men to sin, as it is sin, but as a means of their punishment. He is not therefore, say they, the Author of sin. 1. A good end cannot moralize a bad action; it remaineth evil though the end be never so good Bonum oritur ex integris. •end, manner, yea matter too must be good, or else the action is naught. He that shall steal that he may give an alms; or commit adultery, that he may beget Children for the Church; Or oppress the poor to teach them patience, Or kill a wicked man that he may do no more hurt with his example; or do any forbidden thing, though his end be never so good, he sinneth notwithstanding. And the reason is because the evil of sin is greater then any good that can come by sin; forasmuch as it is laesio divinae majestatis, a wronging of God's majesty; and to Divino bono opposita, directly prejudicial to the good of Almighty God as much as any thing can be. This Saint Paul knew very well, and therefore he tells us plainly that we must not do evil that good may come thereof. Whosoever therefore willeth sin, though for never so good an end, he willeth that which is truly and formally a sin, and consequently God, though he will sin for never so good ends, yet willing it with such a powerful, and effectual will, as giveth a necessary being to it, he becometh Author of that which is formally sin. 2. The members of this distinction are not opposite, for sin as sin, and in no other consideration is means of punishment. If God therefore willeth it as a means of punishment, he willeth it as a sin; his decree it determinated at the the very formality of it. 3 This distinction fasteneth upon God a further aspersion, and loadeth him with three special indignities more. 1. Want of wisdom and providence. His counsels must needs be weak if he can find out no means to glorify justice, but by the bringing in of sin, which his soul hateth, into the world and appointing men to commit it, that so he may manifest justice in the punishment of it. 2. Want of sincerity and plain dealing with men.
Sinne may be considered as sinne, or as a meanes of declaring God's justice in mens punishments. God