DISCOURSE.
pp. 103–10622 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 103–10622 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. Pregnant Testimonies of Scripture directly opposite unto it. 2. Some principal attributes of God not compatible with it. 3. The end of the Word and Sacraments, with other excellent gifts of God to men, quite thwarted by it. 4. Holy and pious endeavours much hindered by it, if not wholly subversed. 5. The grounds of comfort, whereby distressed consciences are to be relieved, are all overthrown by it.
1. Pregnant Testimonies of Scripture directly opposite unto it. 2. Some principall attributes of God not compatible with it. 3. The end of the Word and Sacraments, with other excellent gifts of God to men, quite thwarted by it. 4. Holy and pious endeavours much hindered by it, if not wholly subversed. 5. The grounds of comfort, whereby distressed consciences are to be relieved, are all overthrown by it.
1. Ezech. 33. 11. As I live saith the Lord, I have no pleasure in the death of a sinner, but that the wicked turn from his ways and live. And least men should say 'tis true, God wills not the death of a repenting sinner, the Lord doth in another place of the same Prophet, extend the proposition to them also that perish, Ezech. 18. 32. I have no pleasure in the death of him that dieth. In this Scripture we may note three things.
1. Ezech. 33. 11. As I live saith the Lord, I have no pleasure in the death of a sinner, but that the wicked turne from his waies and live. And least men should say 'tis true, God wills not the death of a repenting sinner, the Lord doth in another place of the same Prophet, extend the proposition to them also that perish, Ezech. 18. 32. I have no pleasure in the death of him that dieth. In this Scripture we may note three things.
1. Gods affection to men set forth 1. Negatively, I have no pleasure in his death that dyeth. 2. Affirmatively, But that the wicked turn.
1. Gods affection to men set forth 1. Negatively, I have no pleasure in his death that dyeth. 2. Affirmatively, But that the wicked turne.
2. The persons in whose destruction he delighteth not, wicked men, such as for the rejecting of grace dye and are damned. If God have no pleasure in their death, much less in the death of men, either altogether innocent, or tainted only with original sin.
2. The persons in whose destruction he delighteth not, wicked men, such as for the rejecting of grace dye and are damned. If God have no pleasure in their death, much lesse in the death of men, either altogether innocent, or tainted only with originall sinne.
3. The truth of this affection, as I live; cupit sihi credi (saith Tertullian, Lib. de paenit. cap. 4.) God would fain have us to believe him, when he saith I will not the death of him that dyeth, and therefore he binds his speech with an oath: O beatos nos quorum causa Deus jurat, O miserrimos si nec juranti Domino credimus. Happy are we for whose sakes the Lord vouchsafeth to swear, but most unhappy if we believe him not when he swears. Now if God delight not in the destruction of wicked men, he did never out of his own pleasure take so many millions of men lying in the fall, and seal them up by an absolute decree under invincible damnation: for such a kind of decreeing men to everlasting death, is quite opposite to a delight in mens eternal life.
3. The truth of this affection, as I live; cupit sihi credi (saith Tertullian, Lib. de paenit. cap. 4.) God would faine have us to believe him, when he saith I will not the death of him that dyeth, and therefore he bindes his speech with an oath: O beatos nos quorum causa Deus jurat, O miserrimos si nec juranti Domino credimus. Happy are we for whose sakes the Lord vouchsafeth to sweare, but most unhappy if we believe him not when he swears. Now if God delight not in the destruction of wicked men, he did never out of his own pleasure take so many millions of men lying in the fall, and seale them up by an absolute decree under invincible damnation: for such a kind of decreeing men to everlasting death, is quite opposite to a delight in mens eternall life.
TO say that this or that opinion is untrue, because it doth in terminis contradict places of Scripture, is a very superficiary consideration: yet it is not the first time that I have found it to drop from an Arminians pen: But that it is a very superficiary consideration, I prove thus; For to deny God the Son to be equal to the Father, is in terminis to contradict a pregnant place of Scripture, Phil. 2. Where it is expressly said of God the Son, that he thought it no robbery to be equal to the Father: yet notwithstanding it is agreeable to that of our Saviour, where he saith, the Father is greater then I; and so vice versâ. In like manner to say that God cannot repent, is in terminis to contradict pregnant places of Scripture: again to say that God can repent, is in terminis to contradict other as pregnant places of Scripture; yet neither of these is unsound; because each phrase is agreeable to Scripture in some place or other. And the reason hereof is, because in terminis only to contradict the Scripture, is not to contradict the Scripture; But when we contradict the meaning of Scripture, then and not till then, are we justly said to contradict the Scripture; And the reason hereof is, because the word of God consists not in the outward bark or bone of the letter, but in the inward pith and marrow of the meaning. And as for contradiction unto Scripture in terminis, it may easily be proved, that to deny Gods delight in the destruction of obstinate sinners, is to contradict a very 1pregnant place of Holy Scripture, as namely Prov. 1. 24, 25, 26. Because I have called and ye refused, I have stretched out my hand and no man regarded; but ye have set at naught all my counsel, and would none of my reproof: I will also laugh at your calamity, I will mock when your fear cometh; when your fear cometh as desolation, and your destruction as a Whirlwind. And yet never a whit the more, is any contradiction found in Scripture for this: because though they contradict each the other in terminis, yet there is no contradiction if we consider the true meaning: As for example, it is both true that the Father is greater then the Son, as touching the Sons Manhood; And the Son equal to the Father as touching his Godhead. So of repentance, it cannot be attributed to God as it signifies change of mind or counsel;
TO say that this or that opinion is untrue, because it doth in terminis contradict places of Scripture, is a very superficiary consideration: yet it is not the first time that I have found it to drop from an Arminians penne: But that it is a very superficiary consideration, I prove thus; For to deny God the Sonne to be equall to the Father, is in terminis to contradict a pregnant place of Scripture, Phil. 2. Where it is expressely said of God the Sonne, that he thought it no robbery to be equall to the Father: yet notwithstanding it is agreeable to that of our Saviour, where he saith, the Father is greater then I; and so vice versâ. In like manner to say that God cannot repent, is in terminis to contradict pregnant places of Scripture: again to say that God can repent, is in terminis to contradict other as pregnant places of Scripture; yet neither of these is unsound; because each phrase is agreeable to Scripture in some place or other. And the reason hereof is, because in terminis only to contradict the Scripture, is not to contradict the Scripture; But when we contradict the meaning of Scripture, then and not till then, are we justly said to contradict the Scripture; And the reason hereof is, because the word of God consists not in the outward barke or bone of the letter, but in the inward pith and marrow of the meaning. And as for contradiction unto Scripture in terminis, it may easily be proved, that to deny Gods delight in the destruction of obstinate sinners, is to contradict a very 1pregnant place of Holy Scripture, as namely Prov. 1. 24, 25, 26. Because I have called and ye refused, I have stretched out my hand and no man regarded; but ye have set at naught all my counsell, and would none of my reproofe: I will also laugh at your calamity, I will mock when your feare cometh; when your feare cometh as desolation, and your destruction as a Whirlewind. And yet never a whit the more, is any contradiction found in Scripture for this: because though they contradict each the other in terminis, yet there is no contradiction if we consider the true meaning: As for example, it is both true that the Father is greater then the Sonne, as touching the Sonnes Manhood; And the Sonne equall to the Father as touching his Godhead. So of repentance, it cannot be attributed to God as it signifies change of mind or counsell;
but it may be attributed unto God, as it signifies change of sentence; according to that of Gregory, Deus mutat sententiam, consilium nunquam. So as touching Gods pleasure or delight in the death of a sinner, as it is the destruction of the creature he delighteth not in it; but as it is a just punishment of the impenitent creature, he delights therein: Thus Piscator reconciles it, on Ezech. 18. v. 23, & 32. Surely God delights in the execution of justice, as well as in the execution of mercy, as Jer. 9. 24. I am the Lord which exerciseth loving kindness, judgement, and righteousness in the earth, for in these things I delight saith the Lord.
but it may be attributed unto God, as it signifies change of sentence; according to that of Gregory, Deus mutat sententiam, consilium nunquam. So as touching Gods pleasure or delight in the death of a sinner, as it is the destruction of the creature he delighteth not in it; but as it is a just punishment of the impenitent creature, he delights therein: Thus Piscator reconciles it, on Ezech. 18. v. 23, & 32. Surely God delights in the execution of justice, as well as in the execution of mercy, as Jer. 9. 24. I am the Lord which exerciseth loving kindnesse, judgement, and righteousnesse in the earth, for in these things I delight saith the Lord.
2. Here first, the Author declines from the former phrase, of having no pleasure in the death of a sinner, to not willing the death of a sinner; which phrases have no small difference, as Piscator observes upon that in Ezech. 33. 11. for saith he, potest homo velle id quo non delectatur, ut aegrotus potest velle potum amarum, quo non delectatur, potest enim eum velle non perse, sed propter aliud, nempe ad recuper andam valetudinem. And to deny that God willeth the death of as many as dye, is in terminis to contradict a pregnant place of Scripture, as where it is said, that God worketh all things according to the counsel of his will, Ephes. 1. 11. And therefore seeing the inflicting of death is Gods work he must will it: But this Author is more happy for invention then his fellows: For whereas others of his opinion, work upon the place as it is rendered in the vulgar Latin, Nolo mortem peccatoris: this Author hath found out an argument from the very phrase of our last English translation, to advantage his cause, as when from Gods having no pleasure in the death of a sinner, he quaintly infers, therefore God doth not of mere pleasure, will or decree their death; But how superficiary this is also, and how foully it falls in the issue, upon the Author himself (as usually it falleth out with men, that affect new and quaint inventions) I hope to discover in due place.
2. Here first, the Author declines from the former phrase, of having no pleasure in the death of a sinner, to not willing the death of a sinner; which phrases have no small difference, as Piscator observes upon that in Ezech. 33. 11. for saith he, potest homo velle id quo non delectatur, ut aegrotus potest velle potum amarum, quo non delectatur, potest enim eum velle non perse, sed propter aliud, nempe ad recuper andam valetudinem. And to deny that God willeth the death of as many as dye, is in terminis to contradict a pregnant place of Scripture, as where it is said, that God worketh all things according to the counsell of his will, Ephes. 1. 11. And therefore seeing the inflicting of death is Gods work he must will it: But this Author is more happy for invention then his fellowes: For whereas others of his opinion, work upon the place as it is rendred in the vulgar Latine, Nolo mortem peccatoris: this Author hath found out an argument from the very phrase of our last English translation, to advantage his cause, as when from Gods having no pleasure in the death of a sinner, he quaintly inferres, therefore God doth not of meer pleasure, will or decree their death; But how superficiary this is also, and how fouly it falls in the issue, upon the Author himselfe (as usually it falleth out with men, that affect new and quaint inventions) I hope to discover in due place.
Farther observe; that place, Ezech. 33. 11. I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, according to our last English translation, and that, Ezech. 18. 23. Have I any pleasure at all that the wicked should dye, do differently render one and the same phrase in the Hebrew, in the death of the wicked, Ezech. 33. 11. which is word for word according to the Hebrew; that the wicked should dye Ezech. 18. 23. which being not according to the precise terms of the original, it followeth that hereby, our Translators did expound the sense of the Hebrew, which is word for word, in the death of the wicked, and so accordingly, that phrase, Ezek. 18. 32. in the death of him that dieth, importeth as much as this, that he who dyeth should dye.
Farther observe; that place, Ezech. 33. 11. I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, according to our last English translation, and that, Ezech. 18. 23. Have I any pleasure at all that the wicked should dye, doe differently render one and the same phrase in the Hebrew, in the death of the wicked, Ezech. 33. 11. which is word for word according to the Hebrew; that the wicked should dye Ezech. 18. 23. which being not according to the precise termes of the originall, it followeth that hereby, our Translators did expound the sense of the Hebrew, which is word for word, in the death of the wicked, and so accordingly, that phrase, Ezek. 18. 32. in the death of him that dieth, importeth as much as this, that he who dyeth should dye.
And as for Tertullian, that which he allegeth out of him, neither makes for him nor against us: we all believe what the Prophet delivereth; but we enquire about the sense of it; But in the same place Tertullian interprets the place not absolutely but comparatively, thus, Vivo inquit Dominus, & paenitentiam malo quam mortem, and indeed thus it is accommodated more then once in the Book of Common prayer, as first in the general absolution; then, in one of the Collects upon Good-Friday: There is a double pleasure, that God may be said to take in the one, but a single pleasure only in the other. For in the death of an impenitent sinner, God delights only in the execution of justice: but in the conversion of such a one that he may live, God delights both in the execution of mercy, which is equivalent to his delight taken in the execution of judgement, and over and above he delights in their repentance; For like as of such as fall from God, it is said, His soul hath no pleasure in them: so of such as turn unto him, it is as true, that his soul hath pleasure in them.
And as for Tertullian, that which he alleadgeth out of him, neither makes for him nor against us: we all believe what the Prophet delivereth; but we enquire about the sense of it; But in the same place Tertullian interprets the place not absolutely but comparatively, thus, Vivo inquit Dominus, & paenitentiam malo quam mortem, and indeed thus it is accommodated more then once in the Book of Common prayer, as first in the generall absolution; then, in one of the Collects upon Good-Friday: There is a double pleasure, that God may be said to take in the one, but a single pleasure only in the other. For in the death of an impenitent sinner, God delights only in the execution of justice: but in the conversion of such a one that he may live, God delights both in the execution of mercy, which is equivalent to his delight taken in the execution of judgement, and over and above he delights in their repentance; For like as of such as fall from God, it is said, His soule hath no pleasure in them: so of such as turne unto him, it is as true, that his soule hath pleasure in them.
3. But give we him leave to enjoy the interpretation he affecteth, yet consider I pray, whether he doth not enjoy it tanquam Diis iratis, and to his bane: for mark I pray his argument, and consider whether I do not from the same argument, most strongly conclude against him.
3. But give we him leave to enjoy the interpretation he affecteth, yet consider I pray, whether he doth not enjoy it tanquam Diis iratis, and to his bane: for marke I pray his argument, and consider whether I doe not from the same argument, most strongly conclude against him.
1. His argument runs thus, If God delighteth not in the destruction of wicked men, he did never out of his own pleasure, take so many millions of men lying in the fall, and seal them up by an absolute decree under invincible damnation. Now from the rule of contraries, I herehence dispute thus; If this be a good consequence which he makes, then on the contrary it follows, that seeing God doth take pleasure and delight in mans eternal life (as this Author expressly acknowledgeth) therefore he did out of his own pleasure, take so many million of men lying in the fall, and seal them up by an absolute decree under invincible salvation. Now this conclusion is as directly opposite unto him in the point of election, as his conclusion is opposite to ours in the point of reprobation. And my argument must be of the same force and validity with his; because Contrariorum contraria est ratio. Yet I will not content my self with this answer.
1. His argument runnes thus, If God delighteth not in the destruction of wicked men, he did never out of his own pleasure, take so many millions of men lying in the fall, and seale them up by an absolute decree under invincible damnation. Now from the rule of contraries, I herehence dispute thus; If this be a good consequence which he makes, then on the contrary it followes, that seeing God doth take pleasure and delight in mans eternall life (as this Author expressely acknowledgeth) therefore he did out of his own pleasure, take so many million of men lying in the fall, and seale them up by an absolute decree under invincible salvation. Now this conclusion is as directly opposite unto him in the poynt of election, as his conclusion is opposire to ours in the poynt of reprobation. And my argument must be of the same force and validity with his; because Contrariorum contraria est ratio. Yet I will not content my selfe with this answere.
2. Therefore consider I pray in the next place, the true meaning of this phrase I have no pleasure: in these places of the Prophet, the Author himself though he doth not plainly profess what is the meaning of it, as it became him to do, and not to depend upon colour of words suitable; yet by his drift he manifests the meaning of it to be this, that God doth not bring death upon a sinner, of mere pleasure, but being provoked thereunto, (and that according to the purport of the first place Ezech. 18.) by the sinner himself; and also, (according to the purport of the second place) only in case of impenitency. And I concur with him in this: And so I conceive it to be delivered in the same sense with that Lament. 3. 32, 33. For though he cause grief (to wit by reason of mens sins v. 39.) yet will he have compassion according to the multitude of his mercies, (to wit, in case he repents Jer. 18. 7. Judg. 10. 16.) For he doth not afflict willingly, nor grieve the children of men. Mark I pray, not willingly; to wit, in as much as he is provoked thereunto by sin, and by refusal to repent. And this is in the former Scripture phrases, not to take pleasure in the afflicting and grieving of men. For if any work be such, as wherein pleasure is taken; we need not enquire after a cause why it is done, but though no pleasure be taken in it, yet for some benefit redounding thereby, a man may do it, yea though it be grievous and bitter unto him: As a sick man is willing to take a bitter potion for the recovery of his health. Now come we to the argument: God takes no pleasure in the death of any; therefore he doth not of pleasure inflict death. We willingly grant it, in as much as he never inflicts eternal death on any, that doth not dye in sin unrepented of: And as he doth not inflict death on any of mere pleasure, that is, without just cause on the part of him that dyeth, deserving it: So we ⟨p. 106⟩willingly confess, that God did never decree to inflict death on any without just cause on the Malefactors part deserving death. And this is the uttermost whereunto this Authors argument can be extended. And all our Divines unanimously confess, that God neither decreed to damn any man of his mere pleasure, but for his sin wherein he died without repentance.
2. Therefore consider I pray in the next place, the true meaning of this phrase I have no pleasure: in these places of the Prophet, the Author himselfe though he doth not plainly professe what is the meaning of it, as it became him to doe, and not to depend upon colour of words suitable; yet by his drift he manifests the meaning of it to be this, that God doth not bring death upon a sinner, of meere pleasure, but being provoked thereunto, (and that according to the purport of the first place Ezech. 18.) by the sinner himselfe; and also, (according to the purport of the second place) only in case of impenitency. And I concurre with him in this: And so I conceive it to be delivered in the same sense with that Lament. 3. 32, 33. For though he cause griefe (to wit by reason of mens sinnes v. 39.) yet will he have compassion according to the multitude of his mercies, (to wit, in case he repents Ier. 18. 7. Iudg. 10. 16.) For he doth not afflict willingly, nor grieve the children of men. Mark I pray, not willingly; to wit, in as much as he is provoked thereunto by sinne, and by refusall to repent. And this is in the former Scripture phrases, not to take pleasure in the afflicting and grieving of men. For if any work be such, as wherein pleasure is taken; we need not enquire after a cause why it is done, but though no pleasure be taken in it, yet for some benefit redounding thereby, a man may doe it, yea though it be grievous and bitter unto him: As a sick man is willing to take a bitter potion for the recovery of his health. Now come we to the argument: God takes no pleasure in the death of any; therefore he doth not of pleasure inflict death. We willingly grant it, in as much as he never inflicts eternall death on any, that doth not dye in sinne unrepented of: And as he doth not inflict death on any of meere pleasure, that is, without just cause on the part of him that dyeth, deserving it: So we ⟨p. 106⟩willingly confesse, that God did never decree to inflict death on any without just cause on the Malefactors part deserving death. And this is the uttermost whereunto this Authors argument can be extended. And all our Divines unanimously confesse, that God neither decreed to damne any man of his meer pleasure, but for his sinne wherein he died without repentance.
3. Observe the cunning of this Disputer, to deceive himself first, and then to abuse his readers: For whereas he should have proceeded in his argument by degrees, thus; God hath no pleasure in the death of a sinner, therefore he doth not of his own pleasure inflict death; and thence proceed (if he had thought good) to conclude the like of Gods decree, thus; if God doth not of his own pleasure inflict, then neither doth he of his own pleasure decree to inflict death and damnation: This author leaping over the inflicting of death, as a block in his way (for the last consequence would have betrayed its own nakedness) flieth at first to the application of it, to Gods decree: Now I willingly grant, that Gods having no pleasure in the death of a sinner, doth signify, that God inflicts death on no man without a cause, for that were of mere pleasure to inflict: But dares he herehence infer, therefore God doth not of mere pleasure decree to inflict death and damnation on man for sin, for to this alone comes all the force of this argument. Now to show the vanity of this consequence, consider I pray.
3. Observe the cunning of this Disputer, to deceive himselfe first, and then to abuse his readers: For whereas he should have proceeded in his argument by degrees, thus; God hath no pleasure in the death of a sinner, therefore he doth not of his own pleasure inflict death; and thence proceed (if he had thought good) to conclude the like of Gods decree, thus; if God doth not of his ownpleasure inflict, then neither doth he of his own pleasure decree to inflict death and damnation: This author leaping over the inflicting of death, as a block in his way (for the last consequence would have betrayed its own nakednesse) flyeth at first to the application of it, to Gods decree: Now I willingly grant, that Gods having no pleasure in the death of a sinner, doth signify, that God inflicts death on no man without a cause, for that were of meer pleasure to inflict: But dares he herehence inferre, therefore God doth not of meer pleasure decree to inflict death and damnation on man for sinne, for to this alone comes all the force of this argument. Now to shew the vanity of this consequence, consider I pray.
1. It is as if he should argue thus in plain terms; sin is always the meritorious cause of damnation; therefore sin is the meritorious cause of Gods eternal decree of damnation: Now this Enthymeme hath no force any farther, then it may be reduced into a Categorical Syllogism; and this Enthymeme is reducible into no other Syllogism then this; Damnation is the decree of Damnation, sin is the cause of Damnation, therefore sin is the cause of the decree of damnation. But in this Syllogism the proposition contains a notorious untruth: Or thus, Sin is the cause of damnation; therefore the foresight of sin is the cause of the decree of damnation: But this Enthymeme is not reducible unto any categorical Syllogism at all, for as much as it consists of four terms; all which must be clapped into the Syllogism whereunto it is reduced, and consequently make that Syllogism consist of four terms, which utterly overthrows the illative form thereof.
1. It is as if he should argue thus in plain termes; sinne is alwaies the meritorious cause of damnation; therefore sinne is the meritorious cause of Gods eternall decree of damnation: Now this Enthymeme hath no force any farther, then it may be reduced into a Categoricall Syllogisme; and this Enthymeme is reducible into no other Syllogisme then this; Damnation is the decree of Damnation, sinne is the cause of Damnation, therefore sinne is the cause of the decree of damnation. But in this Syllogisme the proposition containes a notorious untruth: Or thus, Sinne is the cause of damnation; therefore the foresight of sinne is the cause of the decree of damnation: But this Enthymeme is not reducible unto any categoricall Syllogisme at all, for as much as it consists of foure termes; all which must be clapt into the Syllogisme whereunto it is reduced, and consequently make that Syllogisme consist of foure termes, which utterly overthrowes the illative forme thereof.
2. We may as well dispute thus; Good works as well as faith and repentance are the disposing cause unto salvation, therefore good works as well as faith and repentance (or the foresight of them) are the disposing cause to Gods election, or to the decree of salvation.
But shall I tell you, the chief flourish whereupon this Author (and usually the Arminians) doth insist in this his loose argumentation, I conceive it to be this; they hope their credulous readers, unexpert in distinguishing between Gods eternal decree, and the temporal execution thereof, will be apt hereupon to conceit, that we maintain, that God doth not only of mere pleasure decree whatsoever he decreeth, but also that he doth decree of mere pleasure to damn men: which yet is utterly contrary (if I be not deceived) to the tenet of all our Divines: all concurring in this, that God in the execution of the decree of damnation, proceeds according to a Law, and not in the execution of reprobation only, but also in the execution of election. And the law is this, Whosoever believes shall be saved, whosoever believes not shall be damned, And like as he inflicteth not damnation, but by way of punishment, so he confers not salvation but by way of reward. But in the execution of his decrees of election unto grace, and reprobation from grace; we willingly profess that God proceeds according to no law given unto men, to prepare themselves hereunto, but merely according to his good pleasure, having mercy on whom he will, and hardening whom he will: And this indeed is the critical point of this controversy: But neither this Author nor his complices (some of them of my knowledge) have any heart to deal on this. I come to his Second pregnant place as he calleth it.
But shall I tell you, the chiefe flourish whereupon this Author (and usually the Arminians) doth insist in this his loose argumentation, I conceive it to be this; they hope their credulous readers, unexpert in distinguishing between Gods eternall decree, and the temporall execution thereof, will be apt hereupon to conceit, that we maintain, that God doth not only of meer pleasure decree whatsoever he decreeth, but also that he doth decree of meer pleasure to damne men: which yet is utterly contrary (if I be not deceived) to the tenet of all our Divines: all concurring in this, that God in the execution of the decree of damnation, proceeds according to a Law, and not in the execution of reprobation only, but also in the execution of election. And the law is this, Whosoever believes shall be saved, whosoever believes not shall be damned, And like as he inflicteth not damnation, but by way of punishment, so he conferres not salvation but by way of reward. But in the execution of his decrees of election unto grace, and reprobation from grace; we willingly professe that God proceeds according to no law given unto men, to prepare themselves hereunto, but meerly according to his good pleasure, having mercy on whom he will, and hardning whom he will: And this indeed is the criticall poynt of this controversy: But neither this Author nor his complices (some of them of my knowledge) have any heart to deale on this. I come to his Second pregnant place as he calleth it.