Object. 6. God is eternal. 1Heaven is the palace and seat of God: Therefore heaven is eternal. Ans. It doth not follow: for first, there are four terms in this Syllogism. For God is one thing, 2and the palace and seat of God another thing, which is not God. In like manner the body is the seat of the soul: but it followeth not hereof, that the body is a spiritual, intelligent, immortal essence, because the soul is. Secondly, Heaven is the seat of God, not properly nor necessarily; because God, as being an infinite essence, is in all things, and without all things. And Aristotle himself witnesseth, that he is without heaven: therefore he can be, though heaven be not; neither needeth he this tabernacle: But he is said to dwell in heaven, though he fill all things with his essence and power: 1. Because he is above all things, and the Lord and ruler of all. 2. Because he exhibiteth there his glory, majesty, and grace more clearly and fully to be beheld and enjoyed of the blessed Angels and men, then here on earth. Against the first answer, Ubiquitaries reply in Aristotle's behalf, on this manner; The blessedness of God is not without God, but is God himself. Heaven is the blessedness of God, not any place: 3Therefore heaven is God himself. Ans. 1. Not only Aristotle, but the sacred Scripture also doth every where distinguish heaven from God, as the thing made, from the maker thereof: and also opposeth heaven to earth, so that it affirmeth earth to be below, and heaven above us, where God communicateth himself and his blessedness unto the elect more clearly and fully then on earth. Heaven, saith God himself, is my seat, 4and earth my foot-stool. Wherefore, although heaven were somewhere taken for heavenly blessedness, yet might it not be hereof inferred, that heaven properly is not a place wherein the elect enjoy, and shall for ever enjoy that blessedness: for also hell sometimes signifieth hellish pains: yet so, that it excludeth not the place where the wicked, being truly severed from the godly, shall suffer those pains and torments. 2. The Minor is false, if heaven be taken for that blessedness which is God himself, being sufficient unto himself in all things: for heaven is a thing created and finite; that blessedness is uncreate and immense.
Object. 6. God is eternall. 1Heaven is the palace and seat of God: Therefore heaven is eternall. Ans. It doth not follow: for first, there are four terms in this Syllogisme. For God is one thing, 2and the palace and seat of God another thing, which is not God. In like manner the body is the seat of the soule: but it followeth not hereof, that the body is a spirituall, intelligent, immortall essence, because the soul is. Secondly, Heaven is the seat of God, not properly nor necessarily; because God, as being an infinite essence, is in all things, and without all things. And Aristotle himselfe witnesseth, that he is without heaven: therefore he can be, though heaven be not; neither needeth he this tabernacle: But he is said to dwell in heaven, though he fill all things with his essence and power: 1. Because he is above all things, and the Lord and ruler of all. 2. Because he exhibiteth there his glory, majesty, and grace more cleerly and fully to be beheld and injoyed of the blessed Angels and men, then here on earth. Against the first answer, Ubiquitaries reply in Aristotles behalfe, on this manner; The blessednesse of God is not without God, but is God himselfe. Heaven is the blessednesse of God, not any place: 3Therefore heaven is God himself. Ans. 1. Not onely Aristotle, but the sacred Scripture also doth every where distinguish heaven from God, as the thing made, from the maker thereof: and also opposeth heaven to earth, so that it affirmeth earth to be below, and heaven above us, where God communicateth himselfe and his blessednesse unto the elect more cleerly and fully then on earth. Heaven, saith God himselfe, is my seat, 4and earth my foot-stoole. Wherefore, although heaven were somewhere taken for heavenly blessednesse, yet might it not be hereof inferred, that heaven properly is not a place wherein the elect enjoy, and shall for ever enjoy that blessednesse: for also hell sometimes signifieth hellish pains: yet so, that it excludeth not the place where the wicked, being truly severed from the godly, shall suffer those pains and torments. 2. The Minor is false, if heaven be taken for that blessednesse which is God himselfe, being sufficient unto himselfe in all things: for heaven is a thing created and finite; that blessednesse is uncreate and immense.
- 1Lib. 1. de Coelo cap. 9.
- 2Two causes why God is chiefly said to be in heaven.
- 3Heaven is the place of the blessedness of the elect: but not God himself, or blessedness.Heaven is the place of the blessednesse of the elect: but not God himself, or blessednesse.
- 4Isa. 66.1.