The Explication.
pp. 193–20766 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 193–20766 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1THe doctrine which treateth of Gods providence is joyned with the place which treateth of the creation; because the providence, that is, the preservation and government of things created, doth not differ from the creation in the thing it self; (for that there is but one and the same will or power, or action of God whereby things both begin to be and continue;) but they differ in consideration only: For the omnipotent will of God is called creation, in respect of the beginning, when things, by the force and power of his will, took their being: it is called providence, as by the self-same power things are preserved: Wherefore, Providence is the continuance and accomplishment of creation, or, creation it selfe continuated and perpetuated. For we may not imagine that the creation of the world is like to the building of a ship, which the Ship-wright, as soon as hee hath finished it, committeth to the government of some Pilot: but wee must hold this as a grounded truth, that as nothing had ever been, except God had created them; so neither could they retaine and keep their being, neither their force of working, neither the very operation it selfe or motion, no, not the space of one moment or minute of time, if God did not preserve and move them effectually: And therefore the Scripture it selfe often joyneth the preservation and continuall administration of things with their creation; and from hence reasoneth for Gods providence. And God is called Jehovah, 2not only because hee once gave to every thing, both small and great, their being; but also because hee maintaineth it in all, and moveth them so, as that he not only seeth what is done in all things, but also causeth and inclineth them to do that which he from everlasting would every of them to doe. And by this his providence hee governeth, administreth, ruleth, and preserveth all things that they be not brought to confusion. Wee cannot therefore have a full and perfect knowledge of the creation, except we joyn with it the doctrine of providence. Touching providence these three things are principally questioned:
1. Whether there be any Providence. 2. What Providence is. 3. Why the knowledge thereof is necessary.
The two former of these are discussed here under this twenty seventh Question of the Catechism: the third is resolved in the twenty eighth Question immediately following.
THe two former of these are discussed here under this twenty seventh Question of the Catechism: the third is resolved in the twenty eighth Question immediatly following.
1Concerning this point of doctrine, three diverse erroneous opinions are found amongst Philosophers. §11. The Epicures will have either no providence at all, or only of those things which are, and are done in the lower parts of the world. §22. The Stoics have devised in stead of providence, an absolute necessity and order of all things being in the very nature of things, whereunto not only all other things, but God himself also is subject: which necessity they called destiny. §33. The Peripatetics did imagine, that God indeed doth behold and understand all things: but yet doth not order and rule all things, but moveth the celestial motions, and doth by them send down, by way of influence, some power and virtue unto the lower parts of nature; but the operations themselves or motions depend of the matter, and of the wills of men: that is, they will have the providence of God to be a prescience or fore-knowledge of God in all things, but not a will decreeing, causing, and ruling all things.
1COncerning this point of doctrine, three diverse erroneous opinions are found amongst Philosophers. §11. The Epicures will have either no providence at all, or onely of those things which are, and are done in the lower parts of the world. §22. The Stoicks have devised in stead of providence, an absolute necessity and order of all things being in the very nature of things, wherunto not only all other things, but God himself also is subject: which necessity they called destiny. §33. The Peripateticks did imagine, that God indeed doth behold and understand all things: but yet doth not order and rule all things, but moveth the celestiall motions, and doth by them send down, by way of influence, some power and vertue unto the lower parts of nature; but the operations themselves or motions depend of the matter, and of the wils of men: that is, they will have the providence of God to be a prescience or fore-knowledge of God in all things, but not a will decreeing, causing, and ruling all things.
1Contrarily, the Church teacheth out of the word of God, That nothing is extant and cometh to pass in the whole world, but by the certain and definite, though yet most free and most good, counsel and purpose of God. There are two sorts of arguments and proofs▪ whereby is confirmed,2 that there is a providence of God; Testimony of Scripture, and force of argument. §13Testimonies of Scripture are these: He giveth to all life, and breath▪ and all things.4 In him we live, and move, and have our being. Are not two sparrows sold for a farthing, 5and one of them shall not fall to the ground without your Father? Yea, 6and all the hairs of your head are numbered. God worketh all things after the counsel of his own will. Like to these are found infinite testimonies in the Scripture, by which both Gods universal and particular providence are established: for there is almost no point of heavenly doctrine which is more diligently inculcated and urged in the old Testament, then the doctrine of Gods providence. So in Jeremiah, God reasoneth from the general to the particular; that is, from the rule it self to the example: The general is,7 I have made the earth, the man, and the beast that are upon the ground, and have given it unto whom it pleased me. And presently he adjoineth the particular: Now have I given all these lands into the hands of Nebuchadnezzar the king of Babel, my servant.
1Contrarily, the Church teacheth out of the word of God, That nothing is extant and cometh to passe in the whole world, but by the certain and definite, though yet most free and most good, counsell and purpose of God. There are two sorts of arguments and proofs▪ whereby is confirmed,2 that there is a providence of God; Testimony of Scripure, and force of argument. §13Testimonies of Scripture are these: Hee giveth to all life, and breath▪ and all things.4 In him we live, and move, and have our being. Are not two sparrows sold for a farthing, 5and one of them shall not fall to the ground without your Father? Yea, 6and all the hairs of your head are numbred. God worketh all things after the counsell of his own will. Like to these are found infinite testimonies in the Scripture, by which both Gods universall and particular providence are established: for there is almost no point of heavenly doctrine which is more diligently inculcated and urged in the old Testament, then the doctrine of Gods providence. So in Jeremy, God reasoneth from the generall to the particular; that is, from the rule it self to the example: The generall is,7 I have made the earth, the man, and the beast that are upon the ground, and have given it unto whom it pleased mee. And presently hee adjoyneth the particular: Now have I given all these lands into the hands of Nebuchadnezzar the king of Babel, my servant.
1The arguments whereby the Providence is avouched are of two sorts; whereof one demonstrateth the thing that is in question, à posteriori, that is, from the works or effects of God: the other à priori, that is, from the attributes, or properties, or nature of God, whereon, as their proper cause, those effects depend: yet more known proofs, and more common and obvious are those which are drawn from the works or effects of God: For by these, as being more known unto us, we learn and know the cause it self, even the nature and properties of God: then, after we know the cause, we return back again from it to the effects, and demonstrate them by this, and have distinct and perfect knowledge thereof. And both these proofs and reasons are demonstrative, necessarily and irrefragably proving that which is in question, and common to Philosophy with Divinity. But the properties and works of God are better known of them which are in the Church, then of them which are without. And further, the providence of God is proved almost by the same arguments whereby it is showed that there is a God.
1The arguments whereby the Providence is avouched are of two sorts; whereof one demonstrateth the thing that is in question, à posteriori, that is, from the works or effects of God: the other à priori, that is, from the attributes, or properties, or nature of God, whereon, as their proper cause, those effects depend: yet more known proofs, and more common and obvious are those which are drawn from the works or effects of God: For by these, as being more known unto us, we learn and know the cause it selfe, even the nature and properties of God: then, after we know the cause, we return back again from it to the effects, and demonstrate them by this, and have distinct and perfect knowledge thereof. And both these proofes and reasons are demonstrative, necessarily and irrefragably proving that which is in question, and common to Philosophy with Divinity. But the properties and works of God are better known of them which are in the Church, then of them which are without. And further, the providence of God is proved almost by the same arguments whereby it is shewed that there is a God.
1The order which is in the nature of things, that is, the most apt disposing of all the parts, and the succession of motions and actions continuing by certain and perpetual laws and courses, and serving for the preservation of the whole. and for those ends whereunto things were ordained: for where there is order, there is necessarily a cause ordaining and disposing the same.2 Now this order proceedeth not ⟨p. 195⟩from a mere sensible nature neither cometh it by chance or fortune: but contrarily he must needs be most wise who appointed and settled this order in the nature of things, and so he also who by his providence governeth and ruleth nature.
1THe order which is in the nature of things, that is, the most apt disposing of all the parts, and the succession of motions and actions continuing by certain and perpetuall lawes and courses, and serving for the preservation of the whole. and for those ends whereunto things were ordained: for where there is order, there is necessarily a cause ordaining and disposing the same.2 Now this order proceedeth not ⟨p. 195⟩from a meer sensible nature neither cometh it by chance or fortune: but contrarily he must needs be most wise who appointed and setled this order in the nature of things, and so he also who by his providence governeth and ruleth nature.
1The mind and understanding which is in Angles and men. Man, which as it were a little world, is ruled by a mind and understanding: much more then is the great world governed by divine providence; as in the administering whereof more wisdom is required. Whence it is said, He that planted the ear, shall he not hear? 2Or he that formed the eye; shall he not see?
1The minde and understanding which is in Angles and men. Man, which as it were a little world, is ruled by a mind and understanding: much more then is the great world governed by divine providence; as in the administring whereof more wisdome is required. Whence it is said, He that planted the ear, shall he not hear? 2Or hee that formed the eye; shall he not see?
1The natural notions or principles engrafted in our minds, or the law of nature, or the difference between things honest and dishonest. He that hath engraved in the minds of men the rule of directing their life, he will have men to live according to that rule, and thereafter respecteth and governeth their life, actions, and events. But God hath engraved in the minds of men such a rule, whereby to discern that which is honest from things dishonest: Therefore he is both the beholder and Judge of mans life: As many as have sinned without the law, shall perish also without the law: 2and as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law. (For the hearers of the law are not righteous before God, but the doers of the law shall be justified, &c.) 3And Plautus saith, There is verily a God who both heareth and seeth what we do. And Homer, God hath an upright eye.
1The naturall notions or principles ingraffed in our minds, or the law of nature, or the difference between things honest and dishonest. Hee that hath ingraved in the minds of men the rule of directing their life, he will have men to live according to that rule, and thereafter respecteth and governeth their life, actions, and events. But God hath ingraved in the minds of men such a rule, whereby to discern that which is honest from things dishonest: Therefore hee is both the beholder and Judge of mans life: As many as have sinned without the law, shall perish also without the law: 2and as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law. (For the hearers of the law are not righteous before God, but the doers of the law shall be justified, &c.) 3And Plautus saith, There is verily a God who both heareth and seeth what we doe. And Homer, God hath an upright eye.
1The terrors and torments of conscience in the wicked, which generally ensue upon sin committed by them. These fears cannot be stricken into any without some intelligent and understanding nature, which beholdeth and respecteth all humane affairs, especially seeing the wicked cannot escape: Therefore there is some revenger of sins and wickedness, who is God, and who inflicteth those horrors,2 and also who knoweth and regardeth all things, even the secrets of men: The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men. And Juvenal writing unto a friend of his, some way to comfort him for the loss which he had suffered by trusting too much a cozening and perjured Merchant: Why, saith he, dost thou think such fellows to have escaped, whose mind, being conscious and guilty of the deed, possesseth them with astonishment? &c.
1The terrours and torments of conscience in the wicked, which generally ensue upon sin committed by them. These feares cannot be stricken into any without some intelligent and understanding nature, which beholdeth and respecteth all humane affairs, especially seeing the wicked cannot escape: Therefore there is some revenger of sins and wickednesse, who is God, and who inflicteth those horrours,2 and also who knoweth and regardeth all things, even the secrets of men: The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodlinesse and unrighteousnesse of men. And Juvenal writing unto a friend of his, some way to comfort him for the losse which hee had suffered by trusting too much a cousening and perjured Merchant: Why, saith hee, dost thou think such fellowes to have escaped, whose mind, being conscious and guilty of the deed, possesseth them with astonishment? &c.
1Rewards and punishments. He that at all times and in all places adorneth virtue with rewards, and draweth the wicked to punishment, he must needs rule all mankind with his providence: But God yieldeth more pleasant successes and events to the good, which live with moderation and soberly, even to those that are without the Church, and punisheth heinous offences with grievous punishments in this life; yea, when men wink at them: Therefore God ruleth and governeth the whole world by his providence. The righteous shall rejoice when he seeth the vengeance: 2he shall wash his feet in the blood of the wicked. And men shall say, Verily there is fruit for the righteous; doubtless there is a God that judgeth in the earth. He that nurtureth the heathen, shall not he punish? Like unto this is the heathen Poets Axiom; Such things as a man doth, such an end and fruit thereof surpriseth him.
1Rewards and punishments. He that at all times and in all places adorneth vertue with rewards, and draweth the wicked to punishment, he must needs rule all mankind with his providence: But God yeeldeth more pleasant successes and events to the good, which live with moderation and soberly, even to those that are without the Church, and punisheth hainous offences with grievous punishments in this life; yea, when men wink at them: Therefore God ruleth and governeth the whole world by his providence. The righteous shall rejoyce when hee seeth the vengeance: 2hee shall wash his feet in the bloud of the wicked. And men shall say, Verily there is fruit for the righteous; doubtlesse there is a God that judgeth in the earth. He that nurtureth the heathen, shall not he punish? Like unto this is the heathen Poets Axiome; Such things as a man doth, such an end and fruit thereof surpriseth him.
1The order and preservation of Common-weals. He that ordereth and settleth the Empires and States of the whole world, preserveth and maintaineth them against the power, hatred, sleights, furies of devils, tyrants, and wicked men (which are far moe in number then the good, and wish rather the suppression, then the maintenance of laws,) and at his pleasure altereth and translateth them; it must needs be that he taketh care of, and guideth the affairs, counsels, and actions of men: But it is God, who alone is able to perform, and doth perform these things; for none, besides him, is mightier then the devil; and the order of Common-weals and Kingdoms doth always continue: Therefore God governeth all things by his providence. By me Kings reign, and Princes decree justice. 2That living men may know, that the most High hath power over the kingdom of men, and giveth it to whomsoever he will, and appointeth over it the most abject among men. And Tully saith in a certain Oration,3 Common-weals are governed far more by the aid and assistance of God, then by mans reason and counsel.
1The order and preservation of Common-weals. He that ordereth and setleth the Empires and States of the whole world, preserveth and maintaineth them against the power, hatred, sleights, furies of divels, tyrants, and wicked men (which are far moe in number then the good, and wish rather the suppression, then the maintenance of lawes,) and at his pleasure altereth and translateth them; it must needs be that he taketh care of, and guideth the affairs, counsels, and actions of men: But it is God, who alone is able to perform, and doth perform these things; for none, besides him, is mightier then the divell; and the order of Common-weales and Kingdoms doth alwaies continue: Therefore God governeth all things by his providence. By me Kings reign, and Princes decree justice. 2That living men may know, that the most High hath power over the kingdome of men, and giveth it to whomsoever hee will, and appointeth over it the most abject among men. And Tully saith in a certain Oration,3 Common-weals are governed far more by the aid and assistance of God, then by mans reason and counsell.
1The virtues and singular gifts, or heroical instincts, and the excellency of Artificers, ⟨p. 196⟩which God bestoweth for the universal good and preservation of mans society. And these things are far greater, then that they can proceed from a thing merely sensible, without understanding; and more excellent, then that they should be given of nothing, or gotten by men: nay rather, when God will do things for the preserving of mans society, he giveth us men endued with heroical and noble virtues, inventers of arts and sciences, Princes valiant, good, and wise, and other the like fit and able instruments: and contrary, when he will punish us for our deserts, he taketh away again such profitable and preserving instruments from us: Therefore there is some disposer of these good things, and so the governor of humane affairs: The Lord stirred up the spirit of Cyrus. 2The Lord taketh away the strong man, and the man of war, the judge, and the prophets. He giveth wisdom to the wise, and understanding to those that understand.
1The vertues and singular gifts, or heroicall instincts, and the excellency of Artificers, ⟨p. 196⟩which God bestoweth for the universall good and preservation of mans society. And these things are far greater, then that they can proceed from a thing meerly sensible, without understanding; and more excellent, then that they should be given of nothing, or gotten by men: nay rather, when God will do things for the preserving of mans society, hee giveth us men indued with heroicall and noble vertues, inventers of arts and sciences, Princes valiant, good, and wise, and other the like fit and able instruments: and contrary, when he will punish us for our deserts, he taketh away again such profitable and preserving instruments from us: Therefore there is some disposer of these good things, and so the governour of humane affairs: The Lord stirred up the spirit of Cyrus. 2The Lord taketh away the strong man, and the man of war, the judge, and the prophets. He giveth wisdome to the wise, and understanding to those that understand.
1The prediction and signification of events, or of things to come, and the execution or accomplishment thereof. He that of himself doth fore-show certainly unto men things to come, doth not only fore-see those things, but also causeth them, and hath the whole nature of things so in his power, that nothing can be done without his will and pleasure: But God alone doth of himself certainly fore-show things to come: Therefore he doth not only fore-see them, but also causeth them, either by his own proper effecting them or permitting them to be effected by others; and therefore governeth humane affairs:2 Hath he said, and shall he not do it? And Tully saith, Are there gods, and do they not signify or fore-tell things?
1The prediction and signification of events, or of things to come, and the excecution or accomplishment thereof. He that of himself doth fore-shew certainly unto men things to come, doth not only fore-see those things, but also causeth them, and hath the whole nature of things so in his power, that nothing can be done without his will and pleasure: But God alone doth of himself certainly fore-shew things to come: Therefore he doth not only fore-see them, but also causeth them, either by his own proper effecting them or permitting them to be effected by others; and therefore governeth humane affairs:2 Hath he said, and shall he not do it? And Tully saith, Are there gods, and do they not signifie or fore-tell things?
1All things in the whole world, both great and small, are not only ordained, but are also done, and tend to their certain and appointed ends: Therefore it is God, who by his wisdom and power, as he destineth all things to their ends, so also doth bring them thereunto:2 Man liveth not by bread only, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God.
1All things in the whole world, both great and small, are not onely ordained, but are also done, and tend to their certain and appointed ends: Therefore it is God, who by his wisdome and power, as hee destineth all things to their ends, so also doth bring them thereunto:2 Man liveth not by bread onely, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God.
1There is a God: Therefore there is providence. For, that God should not rule and govern the world created by him, hath flat repugnancy with the nature of God, (for the world can no more consist without God, then be created without him) and they who deny providence, deny God to be God, and take away all religion.§2 2He is omnipotent, who hath all things so in his own power, that with every thing he may do what he will, and without his will nothing can be done: But God is omnipotent: Therefore he hath the whole nature of things in his power, and effectually moveth and governeth all things at his own pleasure.§3 3It is the property of a wise governor to let nothing of that which he hath in his power to be done without his will and counsel: God is most wise, and hath all things in his power, and is present with them: Nothing therefore is done in the world without Gods providence.§4 4God is most just, and Judge of the world: Therefore he, in ruling the world, giveth rewards unto the good, and inflicteth punishments upon the wicked.§5 5God is most good: But that which is most good is most communicable: Therefore as God of his infinite goodness created the world, to the end he might communicate himself unto it; so by the same his goodness doth he preserve, administer, and rule the world created.§6 6Every positive thing, and all good is from God, as the first cause and chief good; and not only substances, but all their motions and actions are a certain positive thing, and good: Therefore all motions also have God their first cause, and are done by his will. §77He that willeth the end or consequent of any event, willeth also the mean or event which goeth before: But God willeth the ends of all things which are done: Therefore he willeth also all precedent events, either simply and absolutely, or in some sort and respect.§8 8God is the first cause of all things: Therefore all things depend on him.§9 9An unchangeable prescience or fore-knowledge dependeth of an unchangeable cause: God fore-knoweth all things unchangeably from everlasting: Therefore this his fore-knowledge must depend of an unchangeable cause. But there is no unchangeable cause beside the will of God: Therefore all things ⟨p. 197⟩depend and are governed of the will of God. The sum of all is this: God is almighty, most wise, most just, and most good:
1THere is a God: Therefore there is providence. For, that God should not rule and govern the world created by him, hath flat repugnancy with the nature of God, (for the world can no more consist without God, then be created without him) and they who deny providence, deny God to be God, and take away all religion.§2 2He is omnipotent, who hath all things so in his own power, that with every thing he may do what he will, and without his wil nothing can be done: But God is omnipotent: Therefore he hath the whole nature of things in his power, and effectually moveth and governeth all things at his own pleasure.§3 3It is the property of a wise governour to let nothing of that which hee hath in his power to be done without his will and counsell: God is most wise, and hath all things in his power, and is present with them: Nothing therefore is done in the world without Gods providence.§4 4God is most just, and Judge of the world: Therefore hee, in ruling the world, giveth rewards unto the good, and inflicteth punishments upon the wicked.§5 5God is most good: But that which is most good is most communicable: Therefore as God of his infinite goodnesse created the world, to the end he might communicate himselfe unto it; so by the same his goodnesse doth hee preserve, administer, and rule the world created.§6 6Every positive thing, and all good is from God, as the first cause and chief good; and not only substances, but all their motions and actions are a certain positive thing, and good: Therefore all motions also have God their first cause, and are done by his will. §77He that willeth the end or consequent of any event, willeth also the mean or event which goeth before: But God willeth the ends of all things which are done: Therefore he willeth also all precedent events, either simply and absolutely, or in some sort and respect.§8 8God is the first cause of all things: Therefore all things depend on him.§9 9An unchangeable prescience or fore-knowledge dependeth of an unchangeable cause: God fore-knoweth all things unchangeably from everlasting: Therefore this his fore-knowledge must depend of an unchangeable cause. But there is no unchangeable cause beside the will of God: Therefore all things ⟨p. 197⟩depend and are governed of the will of God. The summe of all is this: God is almighty, most wise, most just, and most good:
Therefore he ordained and created nothing without some especial end and purpose, neither ceaseth he to guide and direct his works unto those ends for which he hath appointed them, neither suffereth he those things to be wrought by chance, which he hath made and ordained to the manifestation of his glory: These things hast thou done, and I held my tongue; 1and thou thoughtest wickedly, that I am even such a one as thy self, &c. Hath God forgotten to be gracious? My counsel shall stand, and I will do whatsoever I will.2
Therefore he ordained and created nothing without some especiall end and purpose, neither ceaseth he to guide and direct his works unto those ends for which he hath appointed them, neither suffereth he those things to be wrought by chance, which he hath made and ordained to the manifestation of his glory: These things hast thou done, and I held my tongue; 1and thou thoughtest wickedly, that I am even such a one as thy selfe, &c. Hath God forgotten to be gracious? My counsell shall stand, and I will doe whatsoever I will.2
Prescience or fore-knowledge, and providence and predestination differ each from other; Prescience is the knowledge of God whereby he fore-saw from all eternity, not only what himself would do, but also what other his creatures by his permission would also do: as namely, that they would sin. Providence and predestination, although they both concern the things which God himself would work and accomplish, yet herein they vary, in that providence extendeth it self unto all the works and creatures of God; but predestination properly respecteth reasonable creatures: For,1 Predestination is the most wise, eternal, and unchangeable decree of God, whereby he deputed and destined every man, before he was created, to his certain use and end; as hereafter in its due place shall be more copiously declared. But providence is the eternal, most free, unchangeable, 2most just, wise, and good counsel of God whereby he worketh all good things whatsoever are found in all creatures, and permitteth also evil things to be done, and directeth all things both evil and good, to his glory, and the safety of his chosen.
PRescience or fore-knowledge, and providence and predestination differ each from other; Prescience is the knowledge of God whereby he fore-saw from all eternity, not only what himselfe would doe, but also what other his creatures by his permission would also do: as namely, that they would sin. Providence and predestination, although they both concern the things which God himselfe would work and accomplish, yet herein they vary, in that providence extendeth it self unto all the works and creatures of God; but predestination properly respecteth reasonable creatures: For,1 Predestination is the most wise, eternall, and unchangeable decree of God, whereby he deputed and destined every man, before he was created, to his certain use and end; as hereafter in its due place shall be more copiously declared. But providence is the eternall, most free, unchangeable, 2most just, wise, and good counsell of God whereby he worketh all good things whatsoever are found in all creatures, and permitteth also evill things to be done, and directeth all things both evill and good, to his glory, and the safety of his chosen.
1The explication and confirmation of each part of this definition severally. Counsel.) The providence of God is called in Scripture the counsel of God: The counsel of the Lord shall endure for ever. My counsel shall stand. God willing to show the stableness of his counsel. Out of these testimonies it is clear and apparent, that we are to understand by the name of providence not only the bare science or knowledge of things present and to come, but also the decree and effectual will of God: for the name of counsel comprehendeth both; to wit, An understanding, or prescience and fore knowledge of things to come, or to be done, and of the causes for which they are,2 or are not to be done. Likewise, A will effecting or working a thing for certain causes, and that in due time and order. Providence therefore is not the bare fore-seeing or fore knowledge, but the fore-knowledge together with the will of God: even as [Greek or Hebrew], which we translate providence, signifieth with the Greeks both a knowledge and a care of things.
1The explication and confirmation of each part of this definition severally. Counsell.) The providence of God is called in Scripture the counsell of God: The counsell of the Lord shall endure for ever. My counsell shall stand. God willing to shew the stablenesse of his counsell. Out of these testimonies it is cleer and apparant, that we are to understand by the name of providence not only the bare science or knowledge of things present and to come, but also the decree and effectuall will of God: for the name of counsell comprehendeth both; to wit, An understanding, or prescience and fore knowledge of things to come, or to be done, and of the causes for which they are,2 or are not to be done. Likewise, A will effecting or working a thing for certain causes, and that in due time and order. Providence therefore is not the bare fore-seeing or fore knowledge, but the fore-knowledge together with the will of God: even as 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which wee translate providence, signifieth with the Greeks both a knowledge and a care of things.
1Eternal.) Because seeing neither the ignorance of any thing, nor increase of knowledge, or change of wil• falleth into God, it is certain that he knew and decreed all things from everlasting: The Lord hath possessed me in the beginning of his way. 2Which declare the last things from the beginning, and from old the things that were not done. He hath chosen us in Christ before the foundation of the world. We speak the wisdom of God which he had determined before the world.
1Eternall.) Because seeing neither the ignorance of any thing, nor increase of knowledge, or change of wil• falleth into God, it is certain that hee knew and decreed all things from everlasting: The Lord hath possessed me in the beginning of his way. 2Which declare the last things from the beginning, and from old the things that were not done. Hee hath chosen us in Christ before the foundation of the world. Wee speak the wisdome of God which he had determined before the world.
1Most free.) That is, a decree which was made from everlasting, of all things and events, as it pleased him of his great wisdom and goodness, when he had perfect power otherwise to have directed his counsel, or else to have omitted it, or to have things otherwise then he decreed to do them by his counsel:2 He doth whatsoever he will. As the clay is in the potters hand, so are you in mine hand.
1Most free.) That is, a decree which was made from everlasting, of all things and events, as it pleased him of his great wisdome and goodnesse, when he had perfect power otherwise to have directed his counsell, or else to have omitted it, or to have things otherwise then he decreed to do them by his counsell:2 He doth whatsoever he will. As the clay is in the potters hand, so are you in mine hand.
1Unchangeable.) Because neither error of counsel, nor any change or mutation falleth into God; but what he hath once decreed from everlasting, that, as being most good and right, doth he will everlastingly, and at length bring to pass. The Strength of Israel will not lie nor repent. I am the Lord, I change not. So Numb. 33.10. Job 23.13. Psal. 33.13. Prov. 19.21. Isa. 14.24, 25, 26, 27. & 46.10. Ezek. 12.28. James 1.17. Rom. 11.29. Heb. 6.17.
1Unchangeable.) Because neither errour of counsell, nor any change or mutation falleth into God; but what he hath once decreed from everlasting, that, as being most good and right, doth he will everlastingly, and at length bring to passe. The Strength of Israel will not lie nor repent. I am the Lord, I change not. So Numb. 33.10. Job 23.13. Psal. 33.13. Prov. 19.21. Isa. 14.24, 25, 26, 27. & 46.10. Ezek. 12.28. James 1.17. Rom. 11.29. Heb. 6.17.
1Most wise.) This is showed both by the wonderful course of things and even•s in the world, and by the Scripture it self: With him is wisdom and strength, he ⟨p. 198⟩hath counsel and understanding. 2O the depth of the wisdom and knowledge of God! So 1 Sam. 16.7. 1 King. 8.39. 1 Chro. 28.9. Psal. 33.11. Job 36.23. Psal. 33.15. & 139.1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. & 147.5. Prov. 8.30.
1Most wise.) This is shewed both by the wonderfull course of things and even•s in the world, and by the Scripture it self: With him is wisdome and strength, hee ⟨p. 198⟩hath counsell and understanding. 2O the depth of the wisdome and knowledge of God! So 1 Sam. 16.7. 1 King. 8.39. 1 Chro. 28.9. Psal. 33.11. Job 36.23. Psal. 33.15. & 139.1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. & 147.5. Prov. 8.30.
1Most just.) Because the will of God is the only fountain and the chief rule of justice, and is manifested and declared in the law. Whatsoever therefore God will, or hath decreed, or doth work, it is simply and in it self just, whether we know, or not know the manner,2 how it is just: There is no iniquity with the Lord our God, neither respect of persons. So Nehem. 9.33. Job 9.2. Psalm. 36.7. & 119.137. Daniel 9.7, 14.
1Most just.) Because the will of God is the only fountain and the chiefe rule of justice, and is manifested and declared in the law. Whatsoever therefore God will, or hath decreed, or doth work, it is simply and in it self just, whether wee know, or not know the manner,2 how it is just: There is no iniquity with the Lord our God, neither respect of persons. So Nehem. 9.33. Job 9.2. Psalm. 36.7. & 119.137. Daniel 9.7, 14.
1Whereby God worketh.) This is added, that we may know the counsel of God not to be idle, but effectual and forcible in working: For God not only once created things, and bestowed on them a virtue and force whereby to work, but also doth preserve and move, by his presence and continual working, all things at his pleasure,2 according as Christ speaketh, My Father worketh hitherto, and I work. No creature, whether great or small, can either be, or move, or do, or suffer any thing,3 except God effectually preserve, move, and govern it. In him we live, and move, and have our being. And God worketh all things by his sole and eternal will, without any labour or motion: for to will in him, is both to be able, and to do: and contrarily, his power and action is his very eternal and unchangeable will: For in God the will is not dis-joined from his efficacy and working, as it cometh to pass in creatures. The working or operation of God is two-fold; general, 4whereby he sustaineth and governeth all things, especially mankind. Special, whereby he beginneth the salvation of his chosen in this life, and perfecteth it in the life to come:5 God is the Saviour of all men, especially of those that believe. As many as are led by the Spirit of God, they are the sons of God. The eyes of the Lord are over the righteous. Another division there is of Gods working, whereby it is divided into immediate and mediate working. Immediate working is, When beside, or contrary to the means and order settled by him in nature, he worketh what he will; as in all miracles, which are described and declared to this end, that we might learn, that God doth work most freely, either by means, or without them: For that all those miracles are not wrought without divine power, both experience teacheth us (inasmuch as they cannot be wrought by the power of any creature;) and the Scripture witnesseth:6 as, Which only doth great wonders. This is the finger of God. Mediate working is, When God by creatures or second causes produceth those effects, to which those creatures or causes are by the accustomed and common order of nature fit, and so made of God: as when he sustaineth us by nourishments▪ and driveth away diseases by medicines. Take a lump of dry figs, and lay it upon the bile, and he shall recover.
1Whereby God worketh.) This is added, that wee may know the counsell of God not to be idle, but effectuall and forcible in working: For God not only once created things, and bestowed on them a vertue and force whereby to work, but also doth preserve and move, by his presence and continuall working, all things at his pleasure,2 according as Christ speaketh, My Father worketh hitherto, and I worke. No creature, whether great or small, can either be, or move, or doe, or suffer any thing,3 except God effectually preserve, move, and govern it. In him wee live, and move, and have our being. And God worketh all things by his sole and eternall will, without any labour or motion: for to will in him, is both to be able, and to doe: and contrarily, his power and action is his very eternall and unchangeable will: For in God the will is not dis-joyned from his efficacy and working, as it cometh to passe in creatures. The working or operation of God is two-fold; generall, 4whereby he sustaineth and governeth all things, especially mankind. Speciall, whereby he beginneth the salvation of his chosen in this life, and perfecteth it in the life to come:5 God is the Saviour of all men, especially of those that beleeve. As many as are led by the Spirit of God, they are the sons of God. The eyes of the Lord are over the righteous. Another division there is of Gods working, whereby it is divided into immediate and mediate working. Immediate working is, When beside, or contrary to the meanes and order setled by him in nature, hee worketh what hee will; as in all miracles, which are described and declared to this end, that wee might learn, that God doth work most freely, either by means, or without them: For that all those miracles are not wrought without divine power, both experience teacheth us (inasmuch as they cannot bee wrought by the power of any creature;) and the Scripture witnesseth:6 as, Which only doth great wonders. This is the finger of God. Mediate working is, When God by creatures or second causes produceth those effects, to which those creatures or causes are by the accustomed and common order of nature fit, and so made of God: as when hee sustaineth us by nourishments▪ and driveth away diseases by medicines. Take a lump of dry figs, and lay it upon the byle, and hee shall recover.
So likewise God by his word written, read, heard▪ showeth unto us both his will and himself:1 They have Moses and the Prophets, let them hear them. Moreover, The mediate working or action of God is done sometimes by good, 2sometimes by vicious and sinful instruments, as well natural as voluntary: Yet so, that the work of God in them, and by them, is always most good, most just, and most holy: For the goodness of Gods works depends not upon the goodness, wisdom, and rightness of the instrument, but of God. As touching good instruments, that by them God worketh very well, there is no controversy among the godly: but of evil instruments, all think not the same. Nevertheless yet, except we will deny, 1. The trials and chastisements of the godly, or, 2. The punishments of the wicked, which are done by the wicked, both to be just, and to proceed from the will, power, and efficacy of God; as also, 3. The virtues, and such actions and deeds of the wicked as have been for the safety of mankind, to be the gifts and blessings of God; that is, except we will deny that God is a just Judge of the world, and powerful in operation, and the efficient of all good things; we must needs doubtless confess, that God doth also execute and accomplish his just and holy works and judgments by evil and sinful instruments:3 So God sendeth Joseph into Egypt by his wicked brethren, and the Midianites: blesseth Israel by Balaam: tempteth the people by false prophets: vexeth Saul by Satan: punisheth David by Absalom, and by the curses of Shimei: Solomon by rebellious ⟨p. 199⟩Jeroboam: Rehoboam, by the traitorous people of Israel: trieth Job by Satan, and the Chaldees:4 carrieth away into captivity Judah and Jerusalem by the hand of Nebuchadnezzar.
So likewise God by his word written, read, heard▪ sheweth unto us both his will and himselfe:1 They have Moses and the Prophets, let them hear them. Moreover, The mediate working or action of God is done sometimes by good, 2sometimes by vicious and sinfull instruments, as well naturall as voluntary: Yet so, that the work of God in them, and by them, is alwayes most good, most just, and most holy: For the goodnesse of Gods works depends not upon the goodnesse, wisedome, and rightnesse of the instrument, but of God. As touching good instruments, that by them God worketh very well, there is no controversie among the godly: but of evill instruments, all think not the same. Neverthelesse yet, except wee will deny, 1. The trials and chastisements of the godly, or, 2. The punishments of the wicked, which are done by the wicked, both to be just, and to proceed from the will, power, and efficacy of God; as also, 3. The vertues, and such actions and deeds of the wicked as have been for the safety of mankinde, to be the gifts and blessings of God; that is, except wee will deny that God is a just Judge of the world, and powerfull in operation, and the efficient of all good things; we must needs doubtlesse confesse, that God doth also execute and accomplish his just and holy works and judgments by evill and sinfull instruments:3 So God sendeth Joseph into Egypt by his wicked brethren, and the Midianites: blesseth Israel by Balaam: tempteth the people by false prophets: vexeth Saul by Sathan: punisheth David by Absalom, and by the curses of Shemei: Salomon by rebellious ⟨p. 199⟩Jeroboam: Roboam, by the traiterous people of Israel: trieth Job by Sathan, and the Chaldees:4 carrieth away into captivity Judah and Jerusalem by the hand of Nebuchadnezzar.
1He worketh all good things.) Even in all creatures, both great and small, he worketh good things. So that not only he doth engender and preserve in them a general power and force of working, but doth also effectually move them, so that without his will being effectual and working, that power and force never in any thing showeth forth it self, or is brought into act; that is, not only all force of working, but also the act and operation it self is in all creatures from God, as the efficient thereof, and directer: For, by the name of good are understood,2 1. The substances and natures of things. 2. Their quantities and qualities, forces or powers, or inclinations. 3. Habits and faculties of the mind conformed to the will of God. 4. Motions, actions, and events, as they are motions, and agree with the law of God. 5. Punishments, as they are the execution of Gods justice, are inflicted by God the most just and righteous Judge of the world. All these, sith they are either things created of God, or something ordained by him, and agreeing with his divine law and justice, they must needs partake both of the nature of good, and proceed from their efficient, and by his providence continue and be directed.
1He worketh all good things.) Even in all creatures, both great and small, he worketh good things. So that not only he doth ingender and preserve in them a generall power and force of working, but doth also effectually move them, so that without his will being effectuall and working, that power and force never in any thing sheweth forth it self, or is brought into act; that is, not only all force of working, but also the act and operation it self is in all creatures from God, as the efficient thereof, and directer: For, by the name of good are understood,2 1. The substances and natures of things. 2. Their quantities and qualities, forces or powers, or inclinations. 3. Habits and faculties of the mind conformed to the will of God. 4. Motions, actions, and events, as they are motions, and agree with the law of God. 5. Punishments, as they are the execution of Gods justice, are inflicted by God the most just and righteous Judge of the world. All these, sith they are either things created of God, or something ordained by him, and agreeing with his divine law and justice, they must needs partake both of the nature of good, and proceed from their efficient, and by his providence continue and be directed.
19. He permitteth also evil things to be done.) Evil is twofold: the one of crime or offence, which is sin; the other of pain or punishment, which is every destruction or affliction, or forsaking of the reasonable creature, inflicted by God for sin. Example of each signification and meaning is, If this nation, 2against whom I have pronounced, turn from their wickedness, I will repent of the plague that I thought to bring upon them. But now, because the evil of pain or punishment, 3being the execution of the law, and declaration of Gods justice, is indeed naturally evil, as it is a destruction of the creature; but is, in a consideration a moral good, as it is agreeing with the order of Gods justice: this sort of evils also, not only as it is an action or motion, but also as it is a destruction or affliction of sinners, is to be ascribed to God, as author and efficient thereof: §11. Because he is the first cause and efficient of all good things. Now all evil of punishment or pain, as it is a punishment, doth partake of the nature of moral good, because the law and order of Gods justice requireth the punishment of sin, and they are the execution or declaration of Gods justice: Therefore God is the author of punishments. §22. Because it is the part of a Judge to punish sin: and because God is Judge of the world, and will be acknowledged the maintainer of his justice and glory:4 Ye execute not the judgments of man, but of the Lord. §33. Because the whole Scripture with great consent referreth both the punishments of the wicked, and the chastisements, and exercises, and martyrdoms of the godly, as also the passion and death of the Son of God himself, which is a sacrifice for the sins of men, to the effectual and forcible working of the will of God. As, There is no evil (to wit,5 of punishment) in the city which the Lord hath not done. I the Lord make peace, and create evil. 6Wherefore we account in the number of good things the punishments of the wicked, and Gods judgments: which God not only by his unchangeable decree will have done, but also doth them by his effectual power and will.
19. He permitteth also evill things to be done.) Evill is twofold: the one of crime or offence, which is sin; the other of pain or punishment, which is every destruction or affliction, or forsaking of the reasonable creature, inflicted by God for sin. Example of each signification and meaning is, If this nation, 2against whom I have pronounced, turn from their wickednesse, I will repent of the plague that I thought to bring upon them. But now, because the evill of pain or punishment, 3being the execution of the law, and declaration of Gods justice, is indeed naturally evill, as it is a destruction of the creature; but is, in a consideration a morall good, as it is agreeing with the order of Gods justice: this sort of evils also, not onely as it is an action or motion, but also as it is a destruction or affliction of sinners, is to be ascribed to God, as authour and efficient thereof: §11. Because hee is the first cause and efficient of all good things. Now all evill of punishment or pain, as it is a punishment, doth partake of the nature of morall good, because the law and order of Gods justice requireth the punishment of sin, and they are the execution or declaration of Gods justice: Therefore God is the authour of punishments. §22. Because it is the part of a Judge to punish sin: and because God is Judge of the world, and will be acknowledged the maintainer of his justice and glory:4 Yee execute not the judgments of man, but of the Lord. §33. Because the whole Scripture with great consent referreth both the punishments of the wicked, and the chastisements, and exercises, and martyrdomes of the godly, as also the passion and death of the Son of God himselfe, which is a sacrifice for the sinnes of men, to the effectuall and forcible working of the will of God. As, There is no evill (to wit,5 of punishment) in the city which the Lord hath not done. I the Lord make peace, and create evill. 6Wherefore wee account in the number of good things the punishments of the wicked, and Gods judgments: which God not onely by his unchangeable decree will have done, but also doth them by his effectuall power and will.
For although the destruction be evil in respect of the creature who suffereth it, yet it is good in respect of the law and order of divine justice exacting it, and in respect of God most justly inflicting it, and executing as it were the proper and peculiar work of the Judge of the world. Object. 1. God made not death. Answ. True, not before sin,1 when he created all things. Object. 2. Thy destruction is of thy self, Israel. Ans. True,2 as concerning the desert; but as concerning the effecting or inflicting of their punishments, it is from God. Object. 3. He will not death. Ans. 3He will not death with a desire of destroying, or that he delighteth in the destruction, vexation, or perdition of his creature; neither would he it, or would effect or cause it, if it were nothing else but a destruction and perdition. But he willeth it, and worketh it, and delighteth in it, as it is the punishment of sin, and the execution of his justice,4 or the delivery of his Church, or a chastisement, or trial, or martyrdom, or ransom. Obj. 4. He will ⟨p. 200⟩that all men shall be saved. 1 Tim. 2.2, 4. 2 Pet. 3.9. Ans. All men, that is, all sorts of men: For out of all sorts of men he chooseth his chosen.
For although the destruction be evill in respect of the creature who suffereth it, yet it is good in respect of the law and order of divine justice exacting it, and in respect of God most justly inflicting it, and executing as it were the proper and peculiar work of the Judge of the world. Object. 1. God made not death. Answ. True, not before sin,1 when he created all things. Object. 2. Thy destruction is of thy selfe, Israel. Ans. True,2 as concerning the desert; but as concerning the effecting or inflicting of their punishments, it is from God. Object. 3. He will not death. Ans. 3He will not death with a desire of destroying, or that hee delighteth in the destruction, vexation, or perdition of his creature; neither would hee it, or would effect or cause it, if it were nothing else but a destruction and perdition. But he willeth it, and worketh it, and delighteth in it, as it is the punishment of sin, and the execution of his justice,4 or the delivery of his Church, or a chastisement, or tryall, or martyrdome, or ransome. Obj. 4. He will ⟨p. 200⟩that all men shall be saved. 1 Tim. 2.2, 4. 2 Pet. 3.9. Ans. All men, that is, all sorts of men: For out of all sorts of men he chuseth his chosen.
Now,1 Of evil of crime or offence, there is another consideration: For, These, as they are sins, or evils of crime, are not considered as good. And Saint James saith of them, Let no man, when he is tempted (that is, when he is solicited to evil) say, that he is tempted of God: Therefore God neither intendeth them in his counsel and purpose, neither alloweth, nor worketh, nor furthereth, but only suffereth or permitteth them to be done of devils and men; that is, doth not hinder them from being done, when yet he could hinder them: partly to show in punishing them his justice, and partly to show in pardoning them his mercy:2 The Scripture hath concluded all under sin, &c. For the same purpose have I stirred thee up, &c. But in the mean season the forsaking of his creature, or depriving him of divine light and rightness, and the action it self, which devils and men sinning do against the law and will of God, he notwithstanding by his general providence and efficacy willeth and moveth; but to such an end as doth best agree with his nature, law, justice and goodness, whether it be known or unknown to us: Therefore sins are truly said to be done, not by the will or working, but by the permission of God. The word permission in this place is to be retained, because both it and others of the same force are sometimes found in the Scripture;3 as, Therefore suffered I thee not to touch her. God suffered him not to hurt me. He suffered no man to do them wrong. These now are the nations which the Lord left, that he might prove Israel by them. Who in times past suffered all the Gentiles to walk in their own ways. But yet we must expound it aright out of the Scriptures, lest we detract from God a great part of the government of the world, and humane affairs: For God neither willeth, nor willeth not sins simply; but in some respect he willeth, and in some respect he willeth not, but only permitteth them. Which, that it may the better be understood,4 we must know, that in every sin or evil of crime are two things; namely, The material, or subject, and the formal; that is, the corruption it self, or defect of rightness, sticking and inherent in the subject. The subject is a thing positive, or a thing in nature, as an inclination, action; and therefore doth it partake of the nature of good, and is wrought and moved by God:
Now,1 Of evill of crime or offence, there is another consideration: For, These, as they are sins, or evils of crime, are not considered as good. And Saint James saith of them, Let no man, when hee is tempted (that is, when hee is solicited to evill) say, that hee is tempted of God: Therefore God neither intendeth them in his counsell and purpose, neither alloweth, nor worketh, nor furthereth, but only suffereth or permitteth them to be done of divels and men; that is, doth not hinder them from being done, when yet he could hinder them: partly to shew in punishing them his justice, and partly to shew in pardoning them his mercy:2 The Scripture hath concluded all under sin, &c. For the same purpose have I stirred thee up, &c. But in the mean season the forsaking of his creature, or depriving him of divine light and rightnesse, and the action it selfe, which divels and men sinning doe against the law and will of God, hee notwithstanding by his generall providence and efficacy willeth and moveth; but to such an end as doth best agree with his nature, law, justice and goodnesse, whether it be known or unknown to us: Therefore sins are truly said to be done, not by the will or working, but by the permission of God. The word permission in this place is to be retained, because both it and others of the same force are sometimes found in the Scripture;3 as, Therefore suffered I thee not to touch her. God suffered him not to hurt mee. He suffered no man to do them wrong. These now are the nations which the Lord left, that hee might prove Israel by them. Who in times past suffered all the Gentiles to walk in their own wayes. But yet wee must expound it aright out of the Scriptures, lest wee detract from God a great part of the government of the world, and humance affairs: For God neither willeth, nor willeth not sins simply; but in some respect hee willeth, and in some respect he willeth not, but only permitteth them. Which, that it may the better be understood,4 we must know, that in every sin or evill of crime are two things; namely, The materiall, or subject, and the formall; that is, the corruption it selfe, or defect of rightnesse, sticking and inherent in the subject. The subject is a thing positive, or a thing in nature, as an inclination, action; and therefore doth it partake of the nature of good, and is wrought and moved by God:
But corruption is not wrought by God, but came unto the subject by the will of devils and men forsaking God: Wherefore no sin can be, or be imagined, which is not in some good thing, and had adjoined unto it some consideration and respect of good. Otherwise, God for his infinite goodness would not suffer it to be done, neither should it be desired of any, neither should at all be: so that it is truly said, That there cannot be put any thing which is the chief and extreme evil, that is, such as doth take away good wholly: for it should not be desired but under some show and apparency that it had of good; neither should it have a subject wherein to be, and so should destroy it self. But albeit evil is always joined with good,1 and doth concur with it in the same actions or inclinations; yet these two things are diligently to be severed and discerned, neither is the work of the Creator to be confounded with the work of the creature sinning: lest either God thereby be made the cause of sin, or the greatest part of the government of the world and humane affairs be taken from him.
But corruption is not wrought by God, but came unto the subject by the will of divels and men forsaking God: Wherefore no sin can be, or be imagined, which is not in some good thing, and had adjoyned unto it some consideration and respect of good. Otherwise, God for his infinite goodnesse would not suffer it to be done, neither should it be desired of any, neither should at all be: so that it is truly said, That there cannot be put any thing which is the chief and extreme evill, that is, such as doth take away good wholly: for it should not be desired but under some shew and apparency that it had of good; neither should it have a subject wherein to be, and so should destroy it self. But albeit evill is alwayes joyned with good,1 and doth concurre with it in the same actions or inclinations; yet these two things are diligently to be severed and discerned, neither is the work of the Creatour to be confounded with the work of the creature sinning: lest either God thereby be made the cause of sin, or the greatest part of the government of the world and humane affairs be taken from him.
1Hereby may we understand, How far forth God willeth sin, and how he willeth not, but permitteth it. §12He willeth therefore sins, As concerning their matter, that is, the actions themselves of men sinning, motions and inclinations to objects; as they are only such, God willeth, worketh, and directeth them: for both they partake of the nature of good; and if God simply would them not, they should not at all be done. §23As concerning the ends whereunto God destineth those actions which are sins; that is, he willeth the actions of sinners, as they are the punishments of the wicked, or chastisements, or trials, or martyrdoms of the godly, or the sacrifice of the Son of God for the sins of men: But these ends are most good, and most agreeing with the nature, justice, and goodness of God: Therefore God (the first cause of all good) willeth, intendeth, and worketh these in the sins or actions of the wicked; and by a consequent, also the actions themselves which the wicked do in sinning; and by which, as means, God attaineth to those ends. §34As concerning the withdrawing of his grace, ⟨p. 201⟩that is, his divine light and rightness: This withdrawing is an action proper to God, namely, his eternal and forcible working will, destining whom it will to be forsaken. It is also just and holy, because God is bound to none: and because it is either the exploration & trial of the creature, or the punishment of sin. And this withdrawing once being put, the inclinations, motions, and actions of the creature cannot but err and swerve from the law of God, and be sins. Now as the inclinations, 5motions, and actions of sinners are sins, that is, are repugnant to order and nature, and swerve from the law of God, because they are done without the knowledge of Gods will, & purpose of obeying him: so God neither willeth, nor ordaineth, nor alloweth, nor commandeth nor worketh, nor furthereth them: but forbiddeth, condemneth, punisheth, and suffereth them to be committed of his creatures, and to concur with his most just decrees, judgments, and works: thereby to show, how necessary and needful for the creature is the grace of the holy Ghost to fly sin, and to manifest his justice and power in punishing sin.
1Hereby may we understand, How far forth God willeth sin, and how hee willeth not, but permitteth it. §12He willeth therefore sins, As concerning their matter, that is, the actions themselves of men sinning, motions and inclinations to objects; as they are only such, God willeth, worketh, and directeth them: for both they partake of the nature of good; and if God simply would them not, they should not at all be done. §23As concerning the ends whereunto God destineth those actions which are sins; that is, he willeth the actions of sinners, as they are the punishments of the wicked, or chastisements, or tryals, or martyrdomes of the godly, or the sacrifice of the Son of God for the sins of men: But these ends are most good, and most agreeing with the nature, justice, and goodnesse of God: Therefore God (the first cause of all good) willeth, intendeth, and worketh these in the sins or actions of the wicked; and by a consequent, also the actions themselves which the wicked doe in sinning; and by which, as means, God attaineth to those ends. §34As concerning the withdrawing of his grace, ⟨p. 201⟩that is, his divine light and rightnesse: This withdrawing is an action proper to God, namely, his eternall and forcible working will, destining whom it will to be forsaken. It is also just and holy, because God is bound to none: and because it is either the exploration & tryall of the creature, or the punishment of sinne. And this withdrawing once being put, the inclinations, motions, and actions of the creature cannot but erre and swerve from the law of God, and be sins. Now as the inclinations, 5motions, and actions of sinners are sins, that is, are repugnant to order and nature, and swerve from the law of God, because they are done without the knowledge of Gods will, & purpose of obeying him: so God neither willeth, nor ordaineth, nor alloweth, nor commandeth nor worketh, nor furthereth them: but forbiddeth, condemneth, punisheth, and suffereth them to be committed of his creatures, and to concurre with his most just decrees, judgments, and works: thereby to shew, how necessary and needfull for the creature is the grace of the holy Ghost to flye sin, and to manifest his justice and power in punishing sin.
Wherefore the permission of sin is no idle permission, or a cessation & ceasing of Gods providence and working in the actions of the wicked, as if they did depend only upon the will of the creature: but this permission is of efficacy, and worketh. It is permission, as concerning the formal cause of sin, that is, corruption it self, which the creature hath of it self, not by any affection or working of God: but it is of efficacy, and working, as concerning the motion and actions of the creature sinning, which God effectually willeth, and moveth as also concerning the withdrawing of his grace, and the ends whereunto he destineth, directeth, and bringeth the actions of them that sin.1 God then is said to permit sin, §11. Because his will, whereby he will have some one work done by a reasonable creature, he doth not make known unto him. §22. Because he doth not correct and incline the will of the creature to obey in that work his divine will, that is, to do it to that end which God will, by either general or special commandment. These two are signified, when God is said to withdraw from his creature his grace, or special working; to forsake him: to deprive him of light or rightness, or of conformity with the law: to leave him in natural blindness and corruption: to will and permit, that, together with the action (which God worketh by his creature, and in respect of God most just) the sin of the creature may concur, by the coming whereof, that action in respect of the creature, is made evil, and highly displeasing God. §33. Because notwithstanding, God so moveth, inclineth, and ruleth by his secret and general providence the will and all the actions of the creature so forsaken, as that by the creature sinning, himself doth execute the most just decree of his own will. For such is the liberty, wisdom, goodness, and power of God, that no less by vicious, than by good instruments, he mo•t well, justly, and holily worketh what he will. Neither is Gods work, by reason of either the goodness, or badness of the instrument, more or less good: as neither the work of the wicked men is made good, for that God doth well use it. For God doing in all things what he will, willeth always, & doth that which is right.2
Wherefore the permission of sin is no idle permission, or a cessation & ceasing of Gods providence and working in the actions of the wicked, as if they did depend only upon the will of the creature: but this permission is of efficacy, and worketh. It is permission, as concerning the formall cause of sin, that is, corruption it selfe, which the creature hath of it selfe, not by any affection or working of God: but it is of efficacy, and working, as concerning the motion and actions of the creature sinning, which God effectually willeth, and moveth as also concerning the withdrawing of his grace, and the ends whereunto he destineth, directeth, and bringeth the actions of them that sin.1 God then is said to permit sin, §11. Because his will, whereby he will have some one worke done by a reasonable creature, hee doth not make knowne unto him. §22. Because he doth not correct and incline the will of the creature to obey in that worke his divine will, that is, to doe it to that end which God will, by either generall or speciall commandement. These two are signified, when God is said to withdraw from his creature his grace, or speciall working; to forsake him: to deprive him of light or rightnesse, or of conformity with the law: to leave him in naturall blindnesse and corruption: to will and permit, that, together with the action (which God worketh by his creature, and in respect of God most just) the sin of the creature may concurre, by the comming whereof, that action in respect of the creature, is made evill, and highly displeasing God. §33. Because notwithstanding, God so moveth, inclineth, and ruleth by his secret and generall providence the will and all the actions of the creature so forsaken, as that by the creature sinning, himselfe doth execute the most just decree of his owne will. For such is the liberty, wisedome, goodnesse, and power of God, that no lesse by vicious, than by good instruments, he mo•t well, justly, and holily worketh what he will. Neither is Gods worke, by reason of either the goodnesse, or badnesse of the instrument, more or lesse good: as neither the worke of the wicked men is made good, for that God doth well use it. For God doing in all things what he will, willeth alwayes, & doth that which is right.2
Now that together with him working well the creature may also work well, it is necessary that the special working of God therein concur with his general working, that is, that he correct the creature by his spirit. When as therefore God doth move the creature only by a general working, and not by a special, the creature doth necessarily, though yet freely, swerve and defect from rightness, God himself notwithstanding working holily, and accomplishing by his creature the just & good work of his will and providence.
Now that together with him working well the creature may also worke well, it is necessary that the speciall working of God therin concurre with his generall working, that is, that he correct the creature by his spirit. When as therefore God doth move the creature only by a generall working, and not by a speciall, the creature doth necessarily, though yet freely, swerve and defect from rightnesse, God himselfe notwithstanding working holily, and accomplishing by his creature the just & good worke of his will and providence.
1If any man demand, why then God doth not correct vicious instruments, that God using them well, themselves also may work well? God himself answereth him, I will have merry on whom I will have mercy: O man, 2who art thou that pleadest against God? Hath not the Potter power of the clay? who hath given unto him first, and it shall be recompensed? God performeth nothing of duty, but all of mercy unto his creatures. It is free therefore to him, to do what, and in what sort, & how far forth, and to whom he will, according as it is said. Is it not lawful for me to do as I will with mine own?3
1If any man demand, why then God doth not correct vicious instruments, that God using them well, themselves also may worke well? God himselfe answereth him, I will have merry on whom I will have mercy: O man, 2who art thou that pleadest against God? Hath not the Potter power of the clay? who hath given unto him first, and it shall be recompenced? God performeth nothing of duty, but all of mercy unto his creatures. It is free therfore to him, to do what, and in what sort, & how far forth, and to whom he will, according as it is said. Is it not lawfull for me to doe as I will with mine owne?3