Now, whereas our adversaries, the Papists and others, deny that Christs words are sacramentally spoken, and say we are to keep the letter; we must here add something touching the controversy of the letter, and meaning of the letter. The Papists bear us in hand, that by the virtue and force of consecration there is made a transubstantiation, or changing of the bread into the body of Christ, the accidents only remaining. Others tell us of a consubstantiation, or co-existence of Christs body in, or with the bread. The Transubstantiaries,1 together with the Consubstantiaries, do boast and glory, that they understand the words of Christ simply and aright: But neither perform that which they brag and boast of; for that is the true simplicity and property of the word, whereunto, for the just understanding and interpretation thereof, nothing is to be added, neither ought to be taken from it, neither any thing altered. But as many as hold that the body of Christ is with, in, or under the bread, they add unto the words of Christ, and depart from true simplicity: For if that which Christ said is simply to be retained, and that not to be admitted which he said not; then may we not say, The bread is both bread and the body of Christ: but simply this only, The bread is the body of Christ. For he said not, My body is with, or in, or under the bread; or, The bread is both bread, and my body together: neither addeth he, as these add of their own, really, substantially, corporally; but he uttereth these bare words of the bread, This is my body. Neither have the Transubstantiaries their opinion drawn from the words of Christ simply understood, namely, that of the bread is made the body of Christ, or, the bread is changed into the body of Christ: for this is their own forgery and invention. For Christ said not, that the bread was now made, or was a making, or should be made; but simply said, The bread is my body, where no change could come between: so that the words of Christ be simply understood. Therefore falsely do they persuade the people that they simply rest on the propriety of Gods word, when as manifoldly and most far they swerve and depart from it.
NOw, whereas our adversaries, the Papists and others, deny that Christs words are sacramentally spoken, and say we are to keep the letter; wee must here adde something touching the controversie of the letter, and meaning of the letter. The Papists bear us in hand, that by the vertue and force of consecration there is made a transubstantiation, or changing of the bread into the body of Christ, the accidents only remaining. Others tell us of a consubstantiation, or co-existence of Christs body in, or with the bread. The Transubstantiaries,1 together with the Consubstantiaries, doe boast and glory, that they understand the words of Christ simply and aright: But neither perform that which they brag and boast of; for that is the true simplicity and property of the word, whereunto, for the just understanding and interpretation thereof, nothing is to be added, neither ought to be taken from it, neither any thing altered. But as many as hold that the body of Christ is with, in, or under the bread, they adde unto the words of Christ, and depart from true simplicity: For if that which Christ said is simply to be retained, and that not to be admitted which he said not; then may we not say, The bread is both bread and the body of Christ: but simply this only, The bread is the body of Christ. For he said not, My body is with, or in, or under the bread; or, The bread is both bread, and my body together: neither addeth he, as these adde of their own, really, substantially, corporally; but he uttereth these bare words of the bread, This is my body. Neither have the Transubstantiaries their opinion drawn from the words of Christ simply understood, namely, that of the bread is made the body of Christ, or, the bread is changed into the body of Christ: for this is their own forgery and invention. For Christ said not, that the bread was now made, or was a making, or should be made; but simply said, The bread is my body, where no change could come between: so that the words of Christ be simply understood. Therefore falsly do they perswade the people that they simply rest on the propriety of Gods word, when as manifoldly and most farre they swerve and depart from it.
- 1The Transubstantiaries and Consubstantiaries rely not on the simple meaning of Christs words.The Transubstantiaries and Consubstantiaries relie not on the simple meaning of Christs words.