But to excommunicate one and account him for a brother, are contraries: Therefore if he be to be accounted for a brother, he is not to be excommunicated. That these are contraries is also thus proved: To excommunicate is, Not to account one for a brother: But, Not to account one for a brother, and, To account one for a brother, are contraries: Therefore also to excommunicate one, and account him for a brother, are contraries, and so cannot stand together; except, Not to account, and, To account for a brother should be all one. Ans. There is an ambiguity and diverse understanding of these words, To account for a brother: seeing there are degrees of brother-hood. Wherefore the contrariety is not here of force; for all men are brethren, both Christians and Turks: But Christians nevertheless, though they account Turks for their brethren and neighbours, and desire their salvation, yet do they not account them for Christian brethren. If then they are to account Turks for their brethren, then much more must they account them, and seek their salvation, who were before-time brethren, that is, Christians. 2. It is a fallacy of taking that simply and wholly to be true, which is true but in part: Account him for a brother; that is, in love, desire, and hope of saving him, but not in reckoning him amongst the sons of God, and members of the Church, until he repent. 3. He saith not,* Account him for a brother; but,* Admonish him as a brother: that is, as him who sometimes was a brother; and who, if he repent, must again be reputed a brother. For they are not altogether deprived of all hope of salvation, who are excommunicated, but that they may return again by repentance, and be included under the same hope. Now Paul useth this phrase, because he would that love and hope of amendment should be the rule of reproof. For a brother admonisheth a brother friendly, and to a good end.
Object. 10. What Paul did, that are not we to follow: 3Paul did excommunicate Hymenaeus and Alexander without the Churches consent: Therefore we must excommunicate no man. Ans. The Major proposition is false, if it be generally understood. Repl. The Major is thus proved: What Paul did by his Apostolic authority, that are not we to follow: But he did this by his Apostolic authority. Now the Minor is proved by Pauls words: I have delivered, saith he, Hymenaeus and Alexander unto Satan:
But to excommunicate one and account him for a brother, are contraries: Therefore if he be to be accounted for a brother, he is not to be excommunicated. That these are contraries is also thus proved: To excommunicate is, Not to account one for a brother: But, Not to account one for a brother, and, To account one for a brother, are contraries: Therefore also to excommunicate one, and account him for a brother, are contraries, and so cannot stand together; except, Not to account, and, To account for a brother should be all one. Ans. There is an ambiguity and diverse understanding of these words, To account for a brother: seeing there are degrees of brother-hood. Wherefore the contrariety is not here of force; for all men are brethren, both Christians and Turks: But Christians neverthelesse, though they account Turks for their brethren and neighbours, and desire their salvation, yet do they not account them for Christian brethren. If then they are to account Turks for their brethren, then much more must they account them, and seek their salvation, who were before-time brethren, that is, Christians. 2. It is a fallacy of taking that simply and wholly to be true, which is true but in part: Account him for a brother; that is, in love, desire, and hope of saving him, but not in reckoning him amongst the sons of God, and members of the Church, until he repent. 3. He saith not,* Account him for a brother; but,* Admonish him as a brother: that is, as him who sometimes was a brother; and who, if he repent, must again be reputed a brother. For they are not altogether deprived of all hope of salvation, who are excommunicated, but that they may return again by repentance, and be included under the same hope. Now Paul useth this phrase, because he would that love and hope of amendment should be the rule of reproofe. For a brother admonisheth a brother friendly, and to a good end.
Object. 10. What Paul did, that are not we to follow: 3Paul did excommunicate Hymenaeus and Alexander without the Churches consent: Therefore wee must excommunicate no man. Ans. The Major proposition is false, if it be generally understood. Repl. The Major is thus proved: What Paul did by his Apostolick authority, that are not we to follow: But he did this by his Apostolick authority. Now the Minor is proved by Pauls words: I have delivered, saith he, Hymenaeus and Alexander unto Sathan:
- *Habete.
- *Monet.Monete.
- 31 Tim. 1.20.