ARTICLE II. of Christs death and merit.
pp. 694–69863 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 694–69863 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Rom. 3.22. The righteousnesse of God by faith in Jesus Christ towards all, and on all that beleeve.
Acts 10.43. To him bare all the Prophets witness, that whosoever believeth on him, shall receive remission of sins through his Name.
Acts 10.43. To him bare all the Prophets witnesse, that whosoever beleeveth on him, shall receive remission of sins through his Name.
VII. When the Scripture then saith that Christ died (a) for all, that he gave himself a ransom (b) for all, that he died (c) for all, that he is a propitiation for the sins of the whole (d) world: this is necessarily understood, either of the greatness of the price, or of the sufficiency of his merit for all men, or of the effectual redemption of all Jews and Gentiles that embrace by faith the benefits of his death: For in these, saith Ambrose, a certain (e) kind of universality is conceived. And this is no more repugnant to the doctrine of the Gospel, then if some should say, that Christ by his death did indifferently redeem, and reconcile to God faithful Christians, and faithless Turks, Heathens, Epicures, Hypocrites, &c. although they receive not the merit of Christ by faith: which opinion is both impious, and repugnant to Gods word.
VII. When the Scripture then saith that Christ died (a) for all, that he gave himselfe a ransome (b) for all, that he died (c) for all, that he is a propitiation for the sins of the whole (d) world: this is necessarily understood, either of the greatnesse of the price, or of the sufficiency of his merit for all men, or of the effectual redemption of all Jews and Gentiles that embrace by faith the benefits of his death: For in these, saith Ambrose, a certaine (e) kinde of universality is conceived. And this is no more repugnant to the doctrine of the Gospell, then if some should say, that Christ by his death did indifferently redeeme, and reconcile to God faithfull Christians, and faithlesse Turks, Heathens, Epicures, Hypocrites, &c. although they receive not the merit of Christ by faith: which opinion is both impious, and repugnant to Gods word.
(a) 2 Cor. 5.15. Christ died for all, that they who live, may not hereafter live to themselves, but unto him who died, and was raised again for them.
(a) 2 Cor. 5.15. Christ died for all, that they who live, may not hereafter live to themselves, but unto him who died, and was raised againe for them.
(b) 1 Tim. 2.6. Christ gave himself as the price of redemption for all men.
(b) 1 Tim. 2.6. Christ gave himselfe as the price of redemption for all men.
(d) 1 John 2.2. He is the propitiation for our sins, and not for ours only, but for the sins of all the world.
(d) 1 John 2.2. He is the propitiation for our sins, and not for ours onely, but for the sins of all the world.
(e) Ambrose de vocatione Gentium l. 1. c. 3. Gods people have their own fullness: and, although a great part of men either reject, or resist the grace of their Saviour; yet, in those that are elected and fore-seen, and severed from the generality of all men, a certain kind of universality is conceived, that out of the whole world, the whole world may seem to be delivered, and out of all men, all men may seem to be assumed.
(e) Ambrose de vocatione Gentium l. 1. c. 3. Gods people have their owne fulnesse: and, although a great part of men either reject, or resist the grace of their Saviour; yet, in those that are elected and fore-seene, and severed from the generality of all men, a certaine kind of universality is conceived, that out of the whole world, the whole world may seeme to be deliyered, and out of all men, all men may seeme to be assumed.
VIII. Hence is that received and fit distinction, that Christ died for all men, in respect of the sufficiency of his merit, or the greatness of the price: but in respect of the efficacy and fruit of his death, he died for all, and only for the believers; seeing not all, but only the faithful receive him: but the rest reject him through infidelity.
VIII. Hence is that received and fit distinction, that Christ died for all men, in respect of the sufficiency of his merit, or the greatnesse of the price: but in respect of the efficacy and fruit of his death, he died for all, and onely for the beleevers; seeing not all, but only the faithfull receive him: but the rest reject him through infidelity.
Innocent. 3. l. 2. de myster. Missae. c. 4. An. Christi 1200. His bloud was poured out only for the predestinate, in respect of efficacy: but it was poured out for all men, in respect of sufficiency. For the effusion of the blood of that just One for the unjust, was so rich a price, that if the whole world would believe in the Redeemer, the chains of Satan should not be able to with-holy any; for, as the Apostle saith, Where sin hath abounded, grace hath much more abounded.
Innocent. 3. l. 2. de myster. Missae. c. 4. An. Christi 1200. His bloud was poured out only for the predestinate, in respect of efficacy: but it was poured out for all men, in respect of sufficiency. For the effusion of the bloud of that just One for the unjust, was so rich a price, that if the whole world would beleeve in the Redeemer, the chaines of Satan should not be able to with-holy any; for, as the Apostle saith, Where sin hath abounded, grace hath much more abounded.
Thom. Aquinas de veritate mat. Art. 26. q. 7. An. Christi 1270. The sufficiency of Christs merit is equally extended to all, but not the efficacy thereof: which comes to pass, partly by free-will, partly by Divine election, by which the effect of Christs merits is conferred in mercy on some, and in Gods just judgement it is with-drawn from some.
Thom. Aquinas de veritate mat. Art. 26. q. 7. An. Christi 1270. The sufficiency of Christs merit is equally extended to all, but not the efficacy thereof: which comes to passe, partly by free-will, partly by Divine election, by which the effect of Christs merits is conferred in mercy on some, and in Gods just judgement it is with-drawn from some.
Idem. in cap. 5. Apocal. We may speak two ways of that Redemption which was performed by the suffering of God: Either according to sufficiency, and so his suffering redeemed all, because he delivered all, so far as concerned him; for he is sufficient to save and redeem all, although there were infinite worlds, as Anselm saith, lib. 2. Cur Deus homo, &c. c. 14. or according to efficacy; and so he redeemed not all by his suffering, because all do not adhere to the Redeemer, and therefore, all have not the efficacy of redemption.
Idem. in cap. 5. Apocal. We may speake two wayes of that Redemption which was performed by the suffering of God: Either according to sufficiency, and so his suffering redeemed all, because he delivered all, so far as concerned him; for he is sufficient to save and redeeme all, although there were infinite worlds, as Anselme saith, lib. 2. Cur Deus homo, &c. c. 14. or according to efficacy; and so he redeemed not all by his suffering, because all do not adhere to the Redeemer, and therefore, all have not the efficacy of redemption.
Peter Lombard l. 3. dist. 22. Christ offered himself for all to God the Trinity, in respect of the sufficiency of the price: but only for the Elect, in respect of efficacy; because he effected salvation only for the predestinated.
Peter Lombard l. 3. dist. 22. Christ offered himselfe for all to God the Trinity, in respect of the sufficency of the price: but only for the Elect, in respect of efficacy; because he effected salvation only for the predestinated.
Peter Galatinus de arcanis Cathol. veritatis l. 8. c. 14. on that place of Isaiah cap. 53. My just Servant shall justify many. Though the suffering of Christ is sufficient to blot away the sins of all men, yet it was not to blot them all away: but of those only who were to believe in him, and were to repent: for that cause he saith, And he took away, or •are the sins of many.
Peter Galatinus de arcanis Cathol. veritatis l. 8. c. 14. on that place of Esay cap. 53. My just Servant shall justifie many. Though the suffering of Christ is sufficient to blot away the sins of all men, yet it was not to blot them all away: but of those only who were to beleeve in him, and were to repent: for that cause he saith, And he tooke away, or •are the sins of many.
IX. Thus, besides the School-men, the Orthodox Fathers also teach: So Prosper Aquitanicus, in the year of Christ 460. Resp. ad object. Vincent. object. 1. Whereas it is rightly said, that our Saviour was crucified for the redemption of all the world, for undertaking the affairs of humane nature, and for the common loss in Adam: yet, it may be said, that he died only for these, to whom his death was profitable. And Cyril on John l. 11. c. 19. saith, That Christ is an Advocate for the sins of all the ⟨p. 697⟩world: that is, not only for the Jews, but also for other Nations; or, for all who, being called by faith, attain to righteousness and sanctification; so that the benefit of a Mediator, not without cause, belongs only to them, whose Mediator and High-Priest he is.
IX. Thus, besides the Schoole-men, the Orthodox Fathers also teach: So Prosper Aquitanicus, in the yeare of Christ 460. Resp. ad object. Vincent. object. 1. Whereas it is rightly said, that our Saviour was crucified for the redemption of all the world, for undertaking the affaires of humane nature, and for the common losse in Adam: yet, it may be said, that he died only for these, to whom his death was profitable. And Cyril on John l. 11. c. 19. saith, That Christ is an Advocate for the sins of all the ⟨p. 697⟩world: that is, not only for the Jews, but also for other Nations; or, for all who, being called by faith, attaine to righteousnesse and sanctification; so that the benefit of a Mediatour, not without cause, belongs only to them, whose Mediatour and High-Priest he is.
X. But, of all men, Austin speaks most clearly; whose opinion (because it is altogether ours) I thought to set in opposition to some Sycophants. Thus he speaks: If we consider* the greatness and power of the price, and that it belongs to the only cause of mankind, the blood of Christ is the redemption of the whole world; but they that pass out of this life without faith and the Sacrament of regeneration, they are not partakers of redemption. Whereas then by reason of that one nature of all, and the one cause of all, undertaken by our Lord truly, all are said to be redeemed, and yet not all are delivered from captivity; doubtless the property of redemption is in them, out of whom the Prince of this world is ejected: and now they are no more the vessels of Satan, but the members of Christ. Whose death is not so spent upon mankind, that they also who are not regenerated, should appertain to his redemption; but so, that what by one example is done for all, by a particular Sacrament should be celebrated in each one: for that cup of immortality, which was composed of our infirmity, and of our verity, and of divine verity; it hath in it self that, which may benefit all; but if it be not drunk, it doth not cure.
X. But, of all men, Austin speakes most clearely; whose opinion (because it is altogether ours) I thought to set in opposition to some Sycophants. Thus he speaks: If we consider* the greatnesse and power of the price, and that it belongs to the only cause of mankinde, the bloud of Christ is the redemption of the whole world; but they that passe out of this life without faith and the Sacrament of regeneration, they are not partakers of redemption. Whereas then by reason of that one nature of all, and the one cause of all, undertaken by our Lord truly, all are said to be redeemed, and yet not all are delivered from captivity; doubtlesse the propertie of redemption is in them, out of whom the Prince of this world is ejected: and now they are no more the vessels of Satan, but the members of Christ. Whose death is not so spent upon mankinde, that they also who are not regenerated, should appertaine to his redemption; but so, that what by one example is done for all, by a particular Sacrament should be celebrated in each one: for that cup of immortality, which was composed of our infirmity, and of our verity, and of divine verity; it hath in it selfe that, which may benefit all; but if it be not drunke, it doth not cure.
This doctrine, of the efficacy of Christs death, D. Parry handled more at large in the first part of the golden Ladder of salvation, where he wrote a particular Exercise of it: As also in the Epitome of Arminianism, or The examination of the five Articles of the Remonstrants in the Netherlands: As also in the Body of Christian doctrine to the 40. Question, Edit. posthumae: Also Collegio 18. disp. 23. of Christs death for all: And, lastly, in that peculiar Speech, which we placed among the Orations declaimed in the University, Tom. 2. oper. Theol. D. Parry. In which Writings, he defends and retains that distinction of the School-men and Ancient Fathers, of sufficiency and efficacy, with other Orthodox Divines: But the good old man, a little before his death, when he understood, that in the Provincial Synod of Dort, this was called into question unwisely by some brethren, under Parries name and authority, he began to think more seriously of it, supposing that it was not altogether so necessary; whereas without it, these [Greek or Hebrew], or seeming contradictions of Scripture, may seem to be fitly reconciled.
THis doctrine, of the efficacy of Christs death, D. Parry handled more at large in the first part of the golden Ladder of salvation, where he wrote a particular Exercise of it: As also in the Epitome of Arminianisme, or The examination of the five Articles of the Remonstrants in the Netherlands: As also in the Body of Christian doctrine to the 40. Question, Edit. posthumae: Also Collegio 18. disp. 23. of Christs death for all: And, lastly, in that peculiar Speech, which we placed among the Orations declaimed in the University, Tom. 2. oper. Theol. D. Parry. In which Writings, he defends and retaines that distinction of the Schoole-men and Ancient Fathers, of sufficiency and efficacy, with other Orthodox Divines: But the good old man, a little before his death, when he understood, that in the Provinciall Synod of Dort, this was called into question unwisely by some brethren, under Parries name and authority, he began to think more seriously of it, supposing that it was not altogether so necessary; whereas without it, these 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or seeming contradictions of Scripture, may seeme to be fitly reconciled.
XI. We therefore, with all our heart, reject the Epicurean blasphemies of the late Pelagians; namely, Huberus, Puccius, and such like: by which the foundation of Christian faith is utterly overthrown: as, 1. That Christ so died for all men, that, by his death, truly and undoubtedly all men are freed from all sin and condemnation, whether they believe or not. 2. That by Christs death God was reconciled to all mankind: and that he hath truly received into his favour the whole race of mankind, whether they be Turks, Jews, or Epicures. 3. And that he hath also received them to mercy, who before his death were in hell: For Huberus in his 66. These, saith, That Christ died effectually for them. 4. That remission of sins ⟨p. 698⟩is given equally to all.1 5. That the pardon of sin is general. 6. That the Reprobates were as well saved by Christ, as others. 7. That all, and every one by the bounty and universal grace of God the Father in Christ, are saved. 8. That as Christ was the Creator, so he is the Redeemer of all and every one.
XI. We therefore, with all our heart, reject the Epicurean blasphemies of the late Pelagians; namely, Huberus, Puccius, and such like: by which the foundation of Christian faith is utterly overthrowne: as, 1. That Christ so died for all men, that, by his death, truly and undoubtedly all men are freed from all sin and condemnation, whether they beleeve or not. 2. That by Christs death God was reconciled to all mankind: and that he hath truly received into his favour the whole race of mankinde, whether they be Turks, Jews, or Epicures. 3. And that he hath also received them to mercy, who before his death were in hell: For Huberus in his 66. These, saith, That Christ died effectually for them. 4. That remission of sins ⟨p. 698⟩is given equally to all.1 5. That the pardon of sin is generall. 6. That the Reprobates were as well saved by Christ, as others. 7. That all, and every one by the bounty and universall grace of God the Father in Christ, are saved. 8. That as Christ was the Creator, so he is the Redeemer of all and every one.
One Egg is not liker to another, then Huberus is to Puccius: they both build upon one foundation, to wit, upon the general redemption, pardon, and salvation by Christs death, without any particular faith; from which notwithstanding Infidels fall away: here is only the difference, that what is covertly and sophistically spoken by Huberus, is roundly professed by Puccius; to wit, Pelagianism, necessarily resulting thence, (as is showed in Margarita Aurea) that there is no original sin, seeing that by the power of Christs death all men, and every one are borne, as they are men, according to Huberus; as they are redeemed men, according to Puccius: in the state of grace and salvation, saith he; in the bosom and grace of God, saith this, and therefore in the state of blessedness, so they procure not their own destruction by infidelity. Let the Church, yea, let God judge between these two, and between Osiander, with what conscience he can deny, that there is any controversy about this; to wit, Whether God hath bestowed his Son upon all the world, that is▪ on all and every man, to be a Saviour, even to the ends of the earth, of all them that embrace him by faith: whereas we do both know, and •each the same thing from the mouth of Christ: But Puccius and Huberus, on the contrary, cry out, That Christ is given as a Saviour to all men absolutely, and hath saved all men effectually, whether they believe or not. It is well then, that Osiander fights for us, and refutes his own brethren himself.
One Egge is not liker to another, then Huberus is to Puccius: they both build upon one foundation, to wit, upon the generall redemption, pardon, and salvation by Christs death, without any particular faith; from which notwithstanding Infidels fall away: here is only the difference, that what is covertly and sophistically spoken by Huberus, is roundly professed by Puccius; to wit, Pelagianisme, necessarily resulting thence, (as is shewed in Margarita Aurea) that there is no originall sin, seeing that by the power of Christs death all men, and every one are borne, as they are men, according to Huberus; as they are redeemed men, according to Puccius: in the state of grace and salvation, saith he; in the bosome and grace of God, saith this, and therefore in the state of blessednesse, so they procure not their owne destruction by infidelity. Let the Church, yea, let God judge betweene these two, and betweene Osiander, with what conscience he can deny, that there is any controversie about this; to wit, Whether God hath bestowed his Son upon all the world, that is▪ on all and every man, to be a Saviour, even to the ends of the earth, of all them that embrace him by faith: whereas we do both know, and •each the same thing from the mouth of Christ: But Puccius and Huberus, on the contrary, cry out, That Christ is given as a Saviour to all men absolutely, and hath saved all men effectually, whether they beleeve or not. It is well then, that Osiander fights for us, and refutes his owne brethren himselfe.