Who then marching toward Rome, was there resisted by the Romans from entering. But in the siege (sayeth the author) the Romans within so plaid the Lyons, that a poor Hare (or such a like thing) coming toward the City: the host of Arnulphus followed after with such a main cry, that the valiant Romans upon the walls for very fear, (where there was no hurt) cast themselves desperately over the walls: so that Arnulphus with little labour scaled the walls, and gate the City. Thus Arnulphus obtaining the City of Rome, rescueth Pope Formosus, and beheadeth his adversaries, whom the Pope, to gratify with like recompense again, blesseth and crowneth him for Emperor. Thus Formosus sitting fast about the space of 4. or 5. years followed his predecessors: after whose time (as I said) within the space of ix. years were ix. Bishops as followeth. But in the mean time concerning the story of this Formosus declared by Sigebert, and many other Chroniclers: this thing would I gladly ask, and more gladly learn of some indifferent good Catholic person, which not of obstinacy, but of simple error being a papist would answer his conscience. Whether doth he think the holy order of Priesthood, which he taketh for one of the seven Sacraments, to be Character indelebilis or not? If it be not indelebilis, 1that is, if it be such a thing, as may be put of: why then doeth the Popes doctrine so call and so hold the contrary, pretending it to be indelebile, unremovable? If it be in deed, so as they teach and affirm, indelebilis character, why then did Pope John, or could Pope John, annihilate & cuacuate one of his vij. Popeholy Sacraments: making of a Priest a non Priest, or a layman: uncharactering his own order, which is (as he sayeth) a Character, which in no wise may be blotted out, or removed? Again, ⟨p. 146⟩how soever Pope John is to be judged in this matter, to do either well or not well,2 this would I know, if he did well in so dispriesting and discharactering Formosus, for such private offences? If yea, how then standeth his doing with his own doctrine, which teacheth the contrary? If he did not well, how then standeth his doctrine with his doings to be true, which teacheth that the Pope with his Synod of Cardinals can not err? Moreover if this Pope John did not err in his disordering Formosus:
Who then marching toward Rome, was there resisted by the Romaines from entring. But in the siege (sayeth the author) the Romaines within so playd the Lyons, that a poore Hare (or such a like thing) comming towarde the Citie: the hoste of Arnulphus followed after with such a maine crie, that the valiaunt Romaines vpon the walles for very feare, (where there was no hurt) cast themselues desperately ouer the walles: so that Arnulphus with little laboure scaled the walles, and gate the Citie. Thus Arnulphus obtaining the Citie of Rome, rescueth Pope Formosus, and beheadeth hys aduersaries, whome the Pope, to gratifie wyth like recompence againe, blesseth and crowneth him for Emperoure. Thus Formosus sitting fast about ye space of 4. or 5. yeres followed his predecessours: after whose time (as I sayde) within the space of ix. yeares were ix. Bishops as followeth. But in the meane time concerning the storie of thys Formosus declared by Sigebert, and many other Chroniclers: this thing woulde I gladly aske, and more gladly learne of some indifferent good Catholike person, whyche not of obstinacie, but of simple errour being a papist wold aunswere his conscience. Whether doth he thinke the holy order of Priesthoode, which hee taketh for one of the seuen Sacramentes, to be Character indelebilis or not? If it be not indelebilis, 1that is, if it be such a thing, as may be put of: why then doeth the Popes doctrine so call and so hold the contrary, pretending it to be indelebile, vnremoueable? If it be in deede, so as they teach and affirme, indelebilis character, why then did Pope Iohn, or could Pope Iohn, adnichilate & cuacuate one of his vij. Popeholy Sacraments: making of a Priest a non Priest, or a layman: vncharactering hys owne order, which is (as he sayeth) a Character, which in no wise may be blotted out, or remoued? Againe, ⟨p. 146⟩how soeuer Pope Iohn is to be iudged in this matter, to do either wel or not wel,2 this wold I know, if he did well in so dispriesting and discharactering Formosus, for suche priuate offences? If yea, how then stādeth his doing wyth his owne doctrine, which teacheth the contrary? If he did not well, how then standeth his doctrine with his doings to be true, which teacheth that the Pope with his Synode of Cardinals can not erre? Moreouer if this Pope Iohn did not erre in his disordering Formosus:
- 1Character ind• lebilis.
- 2Whether the pope with his Cardinals may err.Whether the pope with hys Cardinals may erre.