Yong. Worshipful master Doctor, although you have learnedly, and Clerkly defended these your conclusions this day: yet seeing that I am now placed to impugn them in place of a better: I do begin thus with you. It hath pleased Christ to make us partakers of his holy spirit, and that in very deed, by receiving of the Christen faith, hope, and charity, ergo much more of his own blessed body, and blood spiritually and in very deed in the Lords supper. Item the Angels food was altogether holy from above, and heavenly called Manna, ergo also this celestial, and heavenly food can be justly esteemed to be of no less excellency then that,1 but without comparison better: and so no very wheat, after due consecration of it. Item the words of holy scripture are evermore effectual, and working, ergo they must perform the thing indeed that they do promise. For he that might create, might also change at his pleasure, the natures, and substances of creatures, as appeareth that Christ did by changing water into wine at a Marriage in Galilee. But Christ in the Scripture did promise John. 6. that the bread that he would give, is his flesh in deed, which promise was never fulfilled till in his last supper, when he took bread, gave thanks, blessed it, and gave it to his disciples saying, take, eat, this is my body. Which bread then was his flesh in deed, as doth well appear in the said place, and next promise depending upon the same, thus, which flesh I will give for the life of the world. This last promise was fulfilled by him upon the Cross, ergo the first was likewise at his last Supper. So that it was but one, and the same flesh, first and last promised and performed.
Yong. WOrshipful mayster Doctor, although you haue learnedly, and Clarkely defended these your conclusiōs this day: yet seeing that I am now placed to impugne thē in place of a better: I do begin thus wt you. It hath pleased Christ to make vs partakers of his holy spirite, and that in very deede, by receiuing of the Christen fayth, hope, and charitye, ergo muche more of his owne blessed bodye, and bloud spiritually and in very deede in the Lordes supper. Item the Aungels foode was altogether holy from aboue, and heauenly called Manna, ergo also this celestial, and heauenly foode can be iustly estemed to be of no lesse excellency then that,1 but without comparison better: and so no very wheate, after due consecration of it. Item the wordes of holy scripture are euermore effectuall, and working, ergo they must performe the thing indeede that they doe promise. For he that might create, might also chaunge at hys pleasure, the natures, and substaunces of creatures, as appeareth that Christ did by chaunging water into wyne at a Mariage in Galile. But Christ in the Scripture dyd promise Iohn. 6. that the bread that he would geue, is hys flesh in deede, whiche promise was neuer ful•illed till in his last supper, when he tooke bread, gaue thankes, blessed it, and gaue it to his disciples saying, take, eate, this is my body. Which bread then was his flesh in deede, as doth well appeare in the sayd place, and next promise depending vpon the same, thus, which flesh I will geue for the life of the world. This last promise was fulfilled by him vpon the Crosse, ergo the first was likewise at his last Supper. So that it was but one, and the same flesh, first and last promised and performed.
- 1The words of Scripture ever effectual.The wordes of Scripture euer effectuall.