pp. 1852–185334 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
That which was lacking in talk (through my default) at your being here, I have supplied by writing in your absence now at the length getting some opportunity and leisure.1 The 17. day of November, being brought hither by two of the clock at after noon, I was presented before my Lord of London and other two bishops, Master Dean, M. Roper, M. Welsh, Doct. Harpsfield Archdeacon of London, and other two or three, all sitting at one table. There were also present Doct. Dale. Master George Mordant, M. Dee. Then, after the bishop of London had read unto himself the letter that came from the Council, he spake with moe words, but (as I remember) to this effect: that the cause of their assembly was,2 to hear mine examination, whereunto he had authority by the Council, and had provided Master Welsh and an other, whose name I know not (but well I remember, though he obtained it not, yet desired he my Lord, that I might hear the Councels letters) to be there if any matters of the common law should arise, to discuss them, he entreated my Lord to determine all controversies of Scriptures: and as for the Civill law, he and Doctor Dale should take it on them.
THat whiche was lacking in talke (through my defaulte) at your being here, I haue supplyed by writing in your absence now at the length getting some opportunitie and leysure.1 The 17. day of Nouember, beyng brought hither by two of the clocke at after noone, I was presented before my Lord of London and other two byshops, Mayster Deane, M. Roper, M. Welche, Doct. Harpsfield Archdeacon of London, and other two or three, all sitting at one table. There were also present Doct. Dale. Maister George Mordant, M. Dee. Then, after the byshop of London had read vnto himselfe the letter that came from the Counsell, hee spake with mo wordes, but (as I remember) to this effect: that the cause of theyr assembly was,2 to heare mine examination, wherevnto hee had authoritie by the Counsell, and had prouided Mayster Welch and an other, whose name I knowe not (but wel I remember, though he obtayned it not, yet desired hee my Lorde, that I might heare the Councels letters) to be there if anye matters of the common lawe shoulde arise, to discusse them, he intreated my Lorde to determine all controuersies of Scriptures: and as for the Ciuill law, he and Doctor Dale should take it on them.
Wherefore he demanded of me the cause of mine imprisonment I said that the occasion of mine apprehension was a letter which I wrote to one Christopher Goodman, wherein (certifying him of such news as happened here) among the rest,1 I wrote that there were certain printed papers of questions scattered abroad. Whereupon, being suspected to be privy unto the devising or publishing of the same, I was committed to the Fleet: but sithens heard I nothing thereof, after the Commissioners had received my submission. The sum whereof was: that as I was sure there neither could be true witnesses, nor probable conjecture against me in that behalf: so refused I no punishment, if they of their consciences would judge me privy to the devising, printing, or publishing of those questions. But my Lord affirming that there was an other cause of mine imprisonment sithens, demanded if I had not after, sith I was committed unto the Fleet spoken or written somewhat against the natural presence of Christ in the sacrament of the altar.
Wherfore he demaunded of me the cause of mine imprisonment I sayd that the occasion of myne apprehension was a letter which I wrote to one Christofer Gooodman, wherein (certifiyng hym of such newes as happened here) amonge the reste,1 I wrote that there were certayne printed papers of questions scattered abroad. Whereupon, beyng suspected to be priuye vnto the deuising or publishing of the same, I was committed to the Fleete: but sithens heard I nothing therof, after the Commissioners had receaued my submission. The summe wherof was: that as I was sure there neyther coulde be true witnesses, nor probable coniecture agaynst me in that behalfe: so refused I no punishment, if they of theyr consciences would iudge me priuy to the deuising, printing, or publishing of those questions. But my Lord affirming that there was an other cause of mine imprisonment sithens, demaunded if I had not after, sith I was committed vnto the Fleete spoken or written somewhat agaynst the naturall presence of Christ in the sacrament of the aultar.
Then desired I his Lordship to be good unto me, trusting that he would put me to answer to no new matters, except I were first discharged of the old. And when I stood long in that, M. Welsh answered that it was procured that I should so do, right well. For albeit I were imprisoned for treason, if during the time of endurance, I had maintained heresy, that were no sufficient allegation against the Ordinary: neither, whether I were before him acquitted or condemned, should it take away the former fault. Then my Lord affirming that I was not brought before him but for heresy, and the other Gentleman saying that doubtless I was discharged of my former matter, my desire was, that I might be charged according to the order of the law, to hear my accusers.
Then desired I his Lordship to bee good vnto me, trusting that he would put me to aunswere to no new matters, excepte I were first discharged of the old. And when I stoode long in that, M. Welch aunswered that it was procured that I shoulde so doe, right well. For albeit I were imprisoned for treason, if during the tyme of enduraunce, I had mayntayned heresie, that were no sufficient allegation agaynst the Ordinarye: neyther, whether I were before him acquitted or condemned, shoulde it take awaye the former fault. Then my Lord affirming that I was not brought before him but for heresie, and the other Gentleman saying that doubtles I was discharged of my former matter, my desire was, that I might bee charged according to the order of the lawe, to heare my accusers.
Then Doctor Chadsey was sent for, who reported that in the presence of Master Mosley & the Lieutenant of the Tower,1 I spake against the real presence and the sacrifice of the Mass, and that I affirmed that their Church was the Church of Antichrist.
Then Doctour Chadsey was sent for, who reported that in the presence of Mayster Mosley & the Lieuetenant of the Tower,1 I spake agaynst the reall presence and the sacrifice of the Masse, and that I affirmed that theyr Church was the Churche of Antichrist.
Is not this true, quoth my Lord▪ I said yea. Will you continue therein, quoth he? Yea said I. Wilt thou then maintain it by learning, said he? Therein quoth I, I should show my self to have little wit, knowing mine own youth and ignorance,1 if I would take on me to maintain any controversy against so many grave and learned men. But my conscience was satisfied in the truth which was sufficient to my salvation.
Is not this true, quoth my Lord▪ I sayde yea. Will you continue therein, quoth he? Yea sayde I. Wilt thou then mayntayne it by learning, sayd he? Therein quoth I, I should shewe my selfe to haue little witte, knowing myne owne youth and ignoraunce,1 if I would take on me to mayntayne any controuersie agaynste so many graue and learned men. But my conscience was satisfied in the truth which was sufficient to my saluation.
Roper. Conscience? (quoth M. Roper) so shall every Jew and Turk be saved. We had hereafter much talk to no purpose, and especially on my part, who felt in my self, through cold and open air much dullness of wit and memory. At the length I was asked what conscience was: and I said, the certifying of the trueth.
Roper. Conscience? (quoth M. Roper) so shall euerye Iewe and Turke be saued. We had hereafter much talke to no purpose, and especiallye on my part, who felt in my selfe, through colde and open ayre muche dullnesse of witte and memorye. At the length I was asked what conscience was: and I sayde, the certifying of the trueth.
M. Welsh. With that M Welsh rose up, desiring leave to talk with me alone. So he taking me aside into an other chamber,1 said that he was sorry for my trouble, and would gladly see me at liberty, he marvelled, that I being a young man, would stand against all the learned men of the realm, yea, and contrary to the whole determination of the Catholic Church from Christs time, in a matter wherein I could have no great learning▪ I ought not to think mine own wit better then all mens, but should believe them that were learned. I promise you (quoth he) I have read all Peter Martyrs book, and Cranmers, and all the rest of them, and have conferred them with the contrary, as Roffensis, and the Bishop of Winchester. &c. and could not perceive but that there was one continual truth, which from the beginning had been maintained: and those that at any time severed from this unity, were answered and answered again. This was the sum of his tale, which lacked neither wit nor eloquence.
M. Welch. With that M Welch rose vp, desiring leaue to talke with me alone. So he taking me aside into an other chamber,1 said that he was sory for my trouble, and woulde gladly see me at libertie, he maruayled, that I being a young man, would stande agaynst all the learned men of the realme, yea, and contrary to the whole determination of the Catholicke Churche from Chrystes time, in a matter wherin I could haue no great learning▪ I ought not to thinke mine owne wit better then all mennes, but shoulde beleue them that were learned. I promise you (quoth hee) I haue read all Peter Martyrs booke, and Cranmers, and all the rest of them, and haue conferred them with the contrary, as Roffensis, and the Byshop of Winchester. &c. and could not perceiue but that there was one continuall truth, whiche from the begynning had bene mayntayned: and those that at anye time seuered from this vnitie, were aunswered and aunswered agayn. This was the summe of hys tale, whiche lacked neyther witte nor eloquence.
M. Greene. Then spake I. Forasmuch as it pleaseth your Mastership to use me so familiarly (for he so behaved himself towards me,1 as though I had been his equal) I shall open my mind freely unto you desiring you for to take it in good worth. I consider my youth, lack of wit and learning, which would god it were but a little under the opinion that some men have of me.2 But God is not bound to time, wit, or knowledge, but rather chooseth infirma mundi. ut confunderet fortia. Neither can men appoint bonds to Gods mercy: For, I will have compassion (saith he) on whom I will show mercy. There is no respect of persons with God, whether it be old or young, rich, or poor, wise, or foolish, Fisher, or Basket maker. God giveth knowledge of his truth, through his free grace, to whom he list. James. i. Neither do I think my self only to have the trueth,3 but steadfastly believe that Christ hath his spouse the Catholic and universal Church, dispersed in many realms where it pleaseth him spiritus ubi vult spirat: no more is he addicted to any one place then to the person and quality of one man. Of this Church I nothing doubt my self to be a member, trusting to be saved by the faith that is taught in the same.4 But how this Church is known is in a manner the end of all controversy. And the true marks of Christs Church is the true preaching of his word and ministering of his sacraments. These marks were sealed by the Apostles, and confirmed by the ancient fathers, till at the length they were through the wickedness of men and the devil,5 sore worn, and almost utterly taken away. But God be praised that he hath renewed the print, that his truth may be known in many places. For my self, I call God to witness, I have no hope in mine own wit and learning, which is very small: but I was persuaded thereto by him, as by an *instrument, that is excellent in all good learning and living. And God is my record, that chiefly I sought it of him, by continual prayer with tears. Furthermore, what I have done herein, it is not needful for me to speak: but one thing (I say) I wish of God with all my hart that all men which are of contrary judgement,
For God knoweth that my whole study is to please him: Besides that, care I not for mans pleasure, or displeasure.
For God knoweth that my whole study is to please hym: Besides that, care I not for mannes pleasure, or displeasure.
M. Welsh. No M. Greene (quoth he) think not so uncharitably of any man, but judge rather that men labour for your souls health, as for their own. And alas,1 how will you condemn all our forefathers? Or how can you think your self to be of the catholic Church, without any continuance, and contrary to the judgement of all learned men?
M. Welch. No M. Greene (quoth he) thinke not so vncharitably of any man, but iudge rather that men labour for your soules health, as for theyr owne. And alas,1 how will you condemne all our forefathers? Or how can you thinke your selfe to bee of the catholicke Church, without anye continuaunce, and contrary to the iudgement of all learned men?
Greene. Then said I, Sir, I have no authority to judge any man: nevertheless, I doubt not but that I am of the true catholic Church, how soever our learned men here judge of me.
Greene. Then sayde I, Syr, I haue no authoritie to iudge anye manne: neuerthelesse, I doubte not but that I am of the true catholicke Church, howe soeuer our learned men here iudge of me.
Welsh▪ Why, then (said he) do you suppose your own wit and learning, better then all theirs? if you do not give credit only to them, other learned men shall resort unto you, that shall persuade you by the Scriptures and Doctors.
Welche▪ Why, then (sayd he) do you suppose your own wyt and learning, better then all theirs? if you doe not geue credite onely to them, other learned men shall resort vnto you, that shal perswade you by the Scriptures and Doctours.
Greene. Sir (ꝙ I) God knoweth that I refuse not to learn of any child, but I would embrace the trueth from the mouth of a natural fool, in any thing wherein I am ignorant, and that in all things, saving my faith: But concerning the truth, wherein I ⟨p. 1853⟩am throughly persuaded, I cannot submit my self to learn, unless it be, as your mastership said, that I perused the books on both sides: For so might I make my self an indifferent judge: otherwise I may be seduced. And here we fell out again in a long talk of the Church, wherein his learning and wit, was much above mine: but in the end I told him I was persuaded, and that he did but lose his labour.
Greene. Sir (ꝙ I) God knoweth that I refuse not to learn of any childe, but I would embrace the trueth from the mouth of a naturall foole, in any thing wherein I am ignoraūt, and that in all thinges, sauing my faith: But concerning the truth, wherein I ⟨p. 1853⟩am throughly perswaded, I cannot submit my selfe to learne, vnlesse it be, as youre maistership sayd, that I perused the bookes on both sides: For so might I make my selfe an indifferent iudge: otherwise I may be seduced. And here we fell out agayne in a long talke of the Churche, wherein his learning and wit, was much aboue myne: but in the ende I told hym I was perswaded, and that hee did but lose his labour.
Welsh. Why then (ꝙ he) what shall I report to my Lord?
Welch. Why then (ꝙ he) what shall I report to my Lord?
Greene. Even as pleaseth you (ꝙ I) or else you may say that I would be glad to learn, if I had books on both sides. So he going in, the Bishops (even then risen, and ready to depart) asked how he liked me? He answered: in faith my Lord, he will be glad to learn, which words when they were taken least they should mistake his meaning and mine, I said yea my Lord, so that I may have books on both sides, as Calvin, and my Lord of Canterburies books, and such other. Well (ꝙ my lord I will satisfy thy mind therein also: and they all were in great hope, that shortly I should become a good Catholic as they call it.
Greene. Euen as pleaseth you (ꝙ I) or els you may say that I would be glad to learne, if I had bookes on both sides. So he going in, the Bishoppes (euen then risen, and ready to depart) asked how he liked me? He aunswered: in fayth my Lord, he will be glad to learne, whiche wordes when they were taken least they should mistake his meaning and mine, I sayde yea my Lorde, so that I maye haue bookes on both sides, as Caluin, and my Lord of Caunterburies bookes, and such other. Well (ꝙ my lordt I will satisfie thy minde therein also: and they all were in grea hope, that shortly I shoulde become a good Catholicke as they call it.
Then was I brought into my Lords inner chamber (* where you were) and there was put in a chamber with master Dee, who entreated me very friendly. That night I supped at my Lords table, and lay with master Dee in the chamber you did see On the morrow I was served at dinner from my Lords table, and at night did eat in the hall with his gentlemen: where I have been placed ever sithence, and fared wonderful well. Yea, to say the truth,2 for my liberty within the bonds of his Lordships house: for my lodging and fare, scarce have I been at any time abroad, in better case so long together, and have found so much gentleness of my Lord, and his Chaplains, and other servants that I should easily have forgotten that I was in prison, were it not that this great cheer was often powdered with unsavoury sauses of examinations, exhortations, posings, and disputations.3
Then was I brought into my Lordes inner chamber (* where you were) and there was put in a chamber with mayster Dee, who entreated me very frendly. That night I supped at my Lords table, and lay with mayster Dee in the chamber you did see On the morrow I was serued at dinner from my Lordes table, and at night did eate in the hall with his gentlemē: where I haue bene placed euer sithence, and fared wonderfull well. Yea, to say the truth,2 for my liberty within the bondes of his Lordships house: for my lodging and fare, scarce haue I bene at any time abroade, in better case so long together, and haue found so much gentlenesse of my Lorde, and his Chaplaynes, and other seruauntes that I should easily haue forgotten that I was in prison, were it not that this great cheare was often pouthered with vnsauery sauses of examinations, exhortations, posinges, and disputations.3
For shortly after supper the first monday at night, I was had into my Lords bed chamber, and there he would know of me how I came first into these heresies I said I was persuaded thereto by the scriptures, and authorities of the Doctors, alleged by Peter Martyr in his Lectures upon the xi. Chapter of the first Epistle to the Corinthians, whiles he entreated there on that place De coena domini, by the space of a month together.1 But then my Lord enforced the plainness of Christs words, and his almighty power demanding of me, what reason should move me from the literal sense of the words: but I having no lust to those matters, would have alleged that there were books sufficient of that matter, as Peter Martyr, Cranmer, and Oecolampadius: nevertheless when this shift would not serve,2 but I was constrained to say somewhat, I said I was moved from the literal sense, by the manner of speaking by the circumstance, and by conference of other places of the scriptures. It is evident that Christ took bread, and that he showed them (they seeing it) bread, which he affirmed to be his body.
For shortly after supper the first monday at night, I was hadde into my Lordes bedde chamber, and there he woulde know of me howe I came first into these heresies I sayde I was perswaded thereto by the scriptures, and authorities of the Doctours, alledged by Peter Martyr in hys Lectures vppon the xi. Chapiter of the first Epistle to the Corinthians, whiles hee intreated there on that place De coena domini, by the space of a moneth together.1 But then my Lord enforced the playnnesse of Chrystes woordes, and his almightye power demaundinge of mee, what reason shuld moue me from the litterall sense of the words: but I hauing no lust to those matters, woulde haue alledged that there were bookes sufficient of that matter, as Peter Martyr, Cranmer, and Oecolampadius: neuerthelesse when this shifte would not serue,2 but I was constrayned to say somewhat, I sayd I was moued from the litterall sense, by the manner of speakyng by the circumstaunce, and by conference of other places of the scriptures. It is euident that Christ tooke breade, and that hee shewed them (they seeing it) bread, whiche hee affirmed to be his body.
1Christ affirmed that bread was his body.
But that affirmation taken literally, can by no means be true.
But that affirmation taken literally, can by no meanes be true.
For this predication, Panis est corpus Christi, or corpus Christi est panis, is neither identica nor accidentalis, nor aessentialis praedicatio, Wherefore of necessity, I must say it was spoken in the like sense, as Christ was a door, a vine, and a way. Neither can it serve to say: that it was not of bread that he affirmed to be his body,1 and that for two causes.
For this predication, Panis est corpus Christi, or corpus Christi est panis, is neither identica nor accidentalis, nor aessentialis praedicatio, Wherfore of necessitie, I must say it was spoken in the like sense, as Christ was a dore, a vyne, and a waye. Neyther can it serue to say: that it was not of bread that he affirmed to bee his body,1 and that for two causes.
For what soever he showed, that was bread: for nought else was seen.
For what soeuer he shewed, that was bread: for nought els was seene.
But that which he showed, he affirmed to be his body:
But that which he shewed, he affirmed to be hys body:
Ergo he affirmed of bread, that it was his body.
The second reason is: for that it was not changed before, seeing benedixit, is gratias egit, or ells Christ affirmed no true proposition, and you are without authority.
The second reason is: for that it was not chaunged before, seeyng benedixit, is gratias egit, or ells Christe affirmed no true proposition, and you are without authoritie.
In the end of this letter, there were noted these sentences following, collected for confirmation of his former assertions, videlicet.
Eadem locutio poculi. i. The same phrase is used and spoken upon the cup.
Eadem locutio poculi. i. The same phrase is vsed and spoken vpon the cup.
Dicitur postea panis. It is called bread in the same place afterward.
Eadem ratione reiecero corpus, qua tu panem. i. By the reason,1 as it may be denied to be bread, it may be denied to be the body.
Eadem ratione reiecero corpus, qua tu panem. i. By the reason,1 as it may be denyed to be bread, it may be denyed to be the body.
Ascendit in coelum. i. His body ascended into heaven.
Ascendit in coelum. i. His body ascended into heauen.
Corpore nobis factus est similis in omnibus post nativitatem. At nostrum corpus non potest esse in duobus locis: Ergo &c.
Corpore nobis factus est similis in omnibus post natiuitatem. At nostrum corpus non potest esse in duobus locis: Ergo &c.
In body he was like to us in all things after his nativity (sin excepted.) Seeing then our body cannot be in two places at once: Ergo, neither his.
In body hee was lyke to vs in all thinges after his natiuitie (sinne excepted.) Seeyng then our body cannot be in two places at once: Ergo, neyther his.
Discipuli non stupebant. &c. His Disciples took it as no miracle nor wonder.
Discipuli non stupebant. &c. His Disciples tooke it as no miracle nor wonder.
M. Greene. Then spake I. For asmuche as it pleaseth youre Maystership to vse me so familiarly (for hee so behaued hymselfe towardes me,1 as though I had bene hys equall) I shall open my mind freely vnto you desiring you for to take it in good worth. I consider my youth, lack of wit and learning, which would god it were but a little vnder the opinion that some men haue of me.2 But God is not bounde to time, witte, or knowledge, but rather choseth infirma mundi. vt confunderet fortia. Neyther can men appoynt bondes to Gods mercy: For, I will haue compassion (sayth he) on whome I will shew mercy. There is no respecte of persons with God, whether it be olde or young, riche, or poore, wise, or foolish, Fisher, or Basket maker. God geueth knowledge of hys truth, through hys free grace, to whome he liste. Iames. i. Neither doe I thinke my selfe onely to haue the trueth,3 but steadfastly beleue that Christ hath hys spouse the Catholicke and vniuersall Church, dispersed in many realmes where it pleaseth him spiritus vbi vult spirat: no more is hee addicted to any one place then to the person and qualitie of one man. Of this Church I nothing doubt my selfe to be a member, trusting to be saued by the fayth that is taught in the same.4 But how this Church is knowne is in a maner the end of all controuersie. And the true markes of Christes Church is the true preaching of his worde and ministering of his sacramentes. These markes were sealed by the Apostles, and confirmed by the auncient fathers, till at the length they were through the wickednes of men and the deuill,5 sore worne, and almost vtterly taken away. But God bee praysed that he hath renewed the print, that hys truth may be knowne in many places. For my selfe, I call God to witnesse, I haue no hope in mine owne wit and learning, whiche is very small: but I was perswaded thereto by hym, as by an *instrument, that is excellent in al good learning and liuing. And God is my record, that chiefly I sought it of hym, by continuall prayer with teares. Furthermore, what I haue done herein, it is not needefull for me to speake: but one thing (I say) I wish of God with all my hart that all men which are of contrary iudgement,7 woulde seeke the truth in like maner. Now I am •rought hether before a great many of Byshops, and learned men, to be made a foole and laughing stocke: but I waygh it not a rushe: