pp. 2130–213115 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
IT is manifest to them that read histories, that not only Emperors, but also divers and sundry Councils in the East church have condemned and abolished images both by decrees and examples.
IT is manifest to them that read histories, that not onely Emperors, but also diuers and sundry Councels in the East church haue condemned and abolished images both by decrees and examples.
Petrus Crinitus de honesta disciplina, lib. 9. cap. 9. ex lib•is Augustatibus, haec verba transcripsit. Valens, & Theodosius Augusti Imperatores praefecto praetorio ad hunc modum scripserit. Quum sit nobis cura diligens in rebus omnibus superni numinis religionem tueri. Signum saluatoris Christi nemini quidem concedimus coloribus lapide aliáue materia finger, insculpere aut pingere, sed quocū que reperitur locotolli jubemus, gravissima poena eos mulctando qui contrarium decretis nostris, & imperio quicquam tentaverint. That is to say, Petrus Crinitus in his book of honest discipline, the 9. book, the 9. chapter, wrote out of the Emperors books, these words. Ualens and Theodosius the Emperors, wrote to the high Marshall or Lieutenant, in this sort. Where as we are very careful that the religion of almighty God should be ⟨p. 2131⟩in all things kept. We permit no man to cast, grave, or paint the Image of our Saviour Christ, either in colours, stone, or other matter: but wheresoever it be found, we command it to be taken away, punishing them most grievously that shall attempt any thing contrary to our decrees and Empire.
Petrus Crinitus de honesta disciplina, lib. 9. cap. 9. ex lib•is Augustatibus, haec verba transcripsit. Valens, & Theodosius Augusti Imperatores praefecto praetorio ad hunc modum scripserit. Quum sit nobis cura diligens in rebus omnibus superni numinis religionem tueri. Signum saluatoris Christi nemini quidem concedimus coloribus lapide aliáue materia fingere, insculpere aut pingere, sed quocū que reperitur locotolli iubemus, grauissima poena eos mulctando qui contrarium decretis nostris, & imperio quicquam tentauerint. That is to say, Petrus Crinitus in his booke of honest discipline, the 9. booke, the 9. chapiter, wrote out of the Emperours bookes, these wordes. Ualens and Theodosius the Emperours, wrote to the high Marshall or Lieuetenant, in this sort. Where as wee are very carefull that the religion of almighty God should be ⟨p. 2131⟩in all thinges kept. We permit no man to cast, graue, or paint the Image of our Sauiour Christ, either in colors, stone, or other matter: but wheresoeuer it be found, wee commaund it to be taken away, punishing them most greuously that shall attempt any thing contrary to our decrees and Empire.
Leo the 3. a man commended in histories for his excellent virtues and godliness, who (as is judged of some men) was the author of the book De re militari, that is, Of the feat of War, being translated out of Greek by sir John Cheek, and dedicated to king Henry the viij. your highness father, by public authority commanded, abolishing of Images, and in Constantinople caused all the images to be gathered together on a heap, & burned them unto ashes.
Leo the 3. a man commended in histories for his excellent vertues and godlinesse, who (as is iudged of some men) was the author of the booke De re militari, that is, Of the feate of Warre, beyng translated out of Greeke by sir Iohn Cheeke, and dedicated to king Henry the viij. your highnes father, by publike authoritie commaunded, abolishing of Images, and in Constantinople caused all the images to be gathered together on a heape, & burned them vnto ashes.
Constantine the first his son, assembled a Council of the bishops of the East church, in which Council it was decreed as followeth. It is not lawful for them that believe in God through Jesus Christ, to have any Images neither of the Creator, nor of any creatures set up in temples to be worshipped, but rather that all Images by the law of God, and for the avoiding of offence ought to be taken out of churches. Which decree was executed in all places where any Images were, either in Greece or in Asia. But in all these times, the bishops of Rome rather maintaining the authority of Gregory, weighing like christian bishops the peril of the Church, always in their assemblies allowed Images.
Constantine the first his sonne, assembled a Councel of the bishops of the East church, in which Councell it was decreed as followeth. It is not lawfull for them that beleeue in God through Iesus Christ, to haue any Images neither of the Creator, nor of any creatures set vp in temples to be worshipped, but rather that all Images by the law of God, and for the auoiding of offence ought to be taken out of churches. Which decree was executed in all places where any Images were, either in Greece or in Asia. But in all these tymes, the bishops of Rome rather mainteining the authoritie of Gregory, weighing like christian bishops the perill of the Church, alwayes in their assemblies allowed Images.
Not long after the Bishop of Rome practising with Tharasins Patriarch of Constantinople obtained of Irene the Empress, her son Constantine being then young, that a Council was called at Nice, in the which the Popes Legates were Presidents, which appeared well by their fruits: for in that Council it was decreed, that Images should not only be permitted in churches, but also worshipped, which council was confuted by a book written by Carolus Magnus the Emperor, calling it a foolish and an arrogant council.
Not long after the Bishop of Rome practising wyth Tharasins Patriarch of Constantinople obteyned of Irene the Empresse, her sonne Constantine being thē yong, that a Councell was called at Nice, in the which ye Popes Legates were Presidents, which appeared well by their fruits: for in that Councell it was decreed, that Images should not onely be permitted in churches, but also worshipped, which councell was confuted by a booke written by Carolus Magnus the Emperour, callyng it a foolish and an arrogant councell.
Soon after this Council, arose a sharp contention between Irene the Empress, and her son Constantine the 6. the Emperor, who destroyed Images. And in the end as she had before wickedly burned the bones of her father in law Constantine the v. so afterward unnaturally she put out the eyes of her own son Constantine the sixth.
Soone after this Councell, arose a sharpe contention betwene Irene the Empresse, and her sonne Constantine the 6. the Emperour, who destroyed Images. And in the end as she had before wickedly burned the bones of her father in lawe Constantine the v. so afterward vnnaturally she put out the eyes of her owne sonne Constantine the sixt.
About which time as Eutropius writeth, the Sun was darkened most terribly for the space of 17. days, God showing by that dreadful sign, how much he misliked those kinds of proceedings.
About which tyme as Eutropius writeth, the Sunne was darkened most terribly for the space of 17. days, God shewyng by that dreadfull signe, how much hee misliked those kynds of proceedyngs.
To be short, there was never thing that made more division, or brought more mischief into the church, then the controversy of Images: by reason whereof, not only the East church was divided from the West, and never since perfectly reconciled, but also the Emperor was cut asunder and divided, and the gate opened to the Saracens and Turks to enter and overcome a great piece of Christendom. The fault whereof most justly is to be ascribed to the patrons of Images, who could not be contented with the ensample of the Primitive Church being most simple and sincere, and most agreeable to the Scripture. For as Tertullian sayth: Quod primum verum, quod posterius adulterinū. That is to say, What as is first, that is true, & that that is latter is counterfeit. But with all extremity, maintained the use of images in churches, whereof no profit nor commodity did ever grow to the church of God. For it is evident, that infinite millions of souls have been cast into eternal damnation by the occasion of Images used in place of religion, and no history can record that ever any one soul was won unto Christ by having of Images. But least it might appear that the West church had always generally retained and commended Images. It is to be noted that in a Council holden in Spain called Concilium Eliberinum, the use of Images in churches was clearly prohibited in these form of words. Placuit in ecclesijs picturas esse non debere, ne quod colitur aut adoratur in parietibus depingatur. That is to say, We decree that pictures ought not to be in churches, least that be painted upon the walls which is worshipped or adored.
To bee short, there was neuer thing that made more diuision, or brought more mischiefe into the church, then the controuersie of Images: by reason whereof, not onely the East church was deuided from the West, and neuer since perfectly reconciled, but also the Emperour was cut asunder and deuided, and the gate opened to the Saracens and Turkes to enter and ouercome a great piece of Christendome. The fault whereof most iustly is to bee ascribed to the patrons of Images, who could not be contented wt the ensample of the Primitiue Church beyng most simple and sincere, and most agreeable to the Scripture. For as Tertullian sayth: Quod primum verum, quod posterius adulterinū. That is to say, What as is first, that is true, & that that is latter is counterfeit. But wt all extremitie, mainteined the vse of images in churches, whereof no profite nor commoditie did euer grow to the church of God. For it is euident, that infinite millions of soules haue bene cast into eternall damnation by the occasion of Images vsed in place of religion, and no history can recorde that euer any one soule was wonne vnto Christ by hauing of Images. But least it might appeare that the West church had alwayes generally retained and commended Images. It is to be noted that in a Councell holden in Spaine called Concilium Eliberinum, the vse of Images in churches was clerely prohibited in these forme of wordes. Placuit in ecclesijs picturas esse non debere, ne quod colitur aut adoratur in parietibus depingatur. That is to say, Wee decree that pictures ought not to be in churches, least that be painted vpon the walles which is worshipped or adored.
But this notwithstanding experience hath declared, that neither assembling in Councils, neither writings, preachings, decrees, making of laws, prescribing of punishments, hath holpen against Images, to the which Idolatry hath been committed, nor against Idolatry whilst Images stood. For these blind books and dumb schoolmasters (which they call lay mens books) have more prevailed by their carved and painted preaching of Idolatry, then all other written books and preachings in teaching the truth, and that horror of that vice.
But this notwithstandyng experience hath declared, that neither assembling in Councels, neither writinges, preachings, decrees, makyng of lawes, prescribing of punishments, hath holpen against Images, to the which Idolatry hath bene committed, nor against Idolatry whilest Images stoode. For these blynde bookes and dumme schoolemaisters (which they call lay mens bookes) haue more preuailed by their carued and painted preachyng of Idolatry, then all other written bookes and preachynges in teaching the truth, and that horror of that vice.
Having thus declared unto your highness a few causes of many which do move our consciences in this matter, we beseech your highness most humbly not to strain us any further, but to consider that Gods word doth threaten a terrible judgement unto us, if we being pastors and ministers in his Church, should assent unto the thing which in our learning and conscience we are persuaded doth tend to the confirmation of error, superstition and Idolatry, and finally, to the ruin of the souls committed to our charge, for the which we must give an account to the prince of pastors at the last day, Heb. 13. 1. Pet. 5. We pray your majesty also not to be offended with this our plainness and liberty, which all good and christian princes have ever taken in good part at the hands of godly Bishops.
Hauing thus declared vnto your highnes a few causes of many which do mooue our consciences in this matter, we beseech your highnes most humbly not to strayne vs any further, but to consider that Gods worde doth threaten a terrible iudgement vnto vs, if we being pastors and ministers in his Church, should assent vnto the thing which in our learnyng and conscience wee are perswaded doth tend to the confirmation of errour, superstition and Idolatry, and finally, to the ruine of the soules committed to our charge, for the which we must geue an account to the prince of pastors at the last day, Heb. 13. 1. Pet. 5. Wee pray your maiestie also not to bee offended with this our plainnesse and libertie, which all good and christian princes haue euer taken in good parte at the handes of godly Bishops.
S. Ambrose writing to Theodosius the Emperor useth these words: Sed neque imperiale est libertatem dicendi negare, neque sacerdotale quod sentiat non dicere. Item in causa verò Dei quem audies, si sacerdotem non audies cuius major peccatur periculo, quis tibi verum audebit dicere, si sacerdos non audeat? Epist. lib. 5. Epist. 29. That is to say, But neither is it the part of an Emperor to deny free liberty of speaking, nor yet the duty of a priest not to speak what he thinketh. And again, In gods cause whom wilt thou hear, if thou wilt not hear the priest to whose great peril the fault should be committed? Who dare say the truth unto thee, if the priest dare not? These and such like speeches of S. Ambrose, Theodosius and Ualentinianus the Emperors did always take in good part, and we doubt not but your grace will do the like, of whose not only clemē city but also beneficence, we have largely tasted.
S. Ambrose writing to Theodosius the Emperour vseth these wordes: Sed neque imperiale est libertatem dicendi negare, neque sacerdotale quod sentiat non dicere. Item in causa verò Dei quem audies, si sacerdotem non audies cuius maiore peccatur periculo, quis tibi verum audebit dicere, si sacerdos non audeat? Epist. lib. 5. Epist. 29. That is to say, But neither is it the part of an Emperour to deny free libertie of speaking, nor yet the duety of a priest not to speake what hee thinketh. And agayne, In gods cause whome wilte thou heare, if thou wilt not heare the priest to whose great peril the fault should be committed? Who dare say the truth vnto thee, if the priest dare not? These and such like speaches of S. Ambrose, Theodosius and Ualentinianus the Emperours did alwayes take in good part, and we doubt not but your grace will do the lyke, of whose not onely clemē cie but also beneficense, we haue largely tasted.
We beseech your Majesty also, in these and such like controversies of religion, to refer the discussement and deciding of them to a Synod of your bishops and other godly learned men, according to the example of Constantinus Maximus, and other christian Emperors, that the reasons of both parts being examined by them, the judgement may be given uprightly in all doubtful matters.
We beseech your Maiestie also, in these and such lyke controuersies of religion, to referre the discussement and deciding of them to a Synode of your bishops and other godly learned men, accordyng to the example of Constantinus Maximus, and other christian Emperours, that the reasons of both parts beyng examined by them, the iudgement may be geuen vprightly in all doubtfull matters.
And to return to this present matter, we most humbly beseech your majesty to consider, that besides weighty causes in policy which we leave to the wisdom of your honourable counsellors the stablishment of Images by your authority, shall not only utterly discredit our ministers as builders up of the things which we have destroyed, but also blemish the fame of your most godly father, and such notable fathers as have given their life for the testimony of Gods truth, who by public law removed all Images.
And to returne to this present matter, we most humbly beseech your maiestie to consider, that besides waightie causes in pollicie which wee leaue to the wisedome of your honourable counsailors the stablishment of Images by your authoritie, shall not onely vtterly disceredite our ministers as builders vp of the thinges which wee haue destroyed, but also blemishe the fame of your most godly father, and such notable fathers as haue geuen their lyfe for the testimony of Gods truth, who by publike lawe remooued all Images.
The almighty and everliving God plentifully endue your majesty with his spirit and heavenly wisdom, and long preserve your most gracious reign and prosperous government over us to the advancement of his glory, to the overthrow of superstition, and to the benefit & comfort all your highness loving subjects.
The almighty and euerliuyng God plentifully endue your maiestie with his spirite and heauenly wisedom, and long preserue your most gracious raigne and prosperous gouernment ouer vs to the aduauncement of his glory, to the ouerthrow of superstition, and to the benefit & comfort all your highnes louyng subiects.