But let us see what S. Bernard 1saith, of this text. What shall we say? is this alonely all the merit of freewill, that he doth alonely consent? yea doubtless. Not that, the same consent, in the which is all his merit, is not of God, when that we can neither think (the which is less, then to consent) any thing of our selves, as though we were sufficient of our selves. These words be not mine, but the Apostles, the which giveth unto God, and not to his freewill, all manner of things, that can be good, that is to say, to think, to will or to perform. &c. Here you not, that all things, that can be good S. Bernard giveth to God? Now, what strength hath freewill, he can neither think good, nor well, nor yet perform it? what remaineth? I know nothing, but either it is included in thinking, in willing, or in performing, and all these be given to God. Also our master Christ saith, 2Shall men gather grapes of thorns, ⟨p. 268⟩or figs of bramble bushes? An evil tree, can bring forth no good fruit. What meaneth our master, when he saith, that grapes be not gathered of thorns? nothing else, but that the fruit must be like the manner of the tree. And therefore saith he, an evil tree, can not bring forth good fruit. Now, can you not deny, but that freewill without grace, is an evil tree, Ergo, his fruit must needs be evil, he may well bring forth fruit, but it shall not be good. Is not all freewill's power declared in these words, he can not? I pray you, what meaneth our master Christ in these words, he can not? Christ said, he can not, and will you say, he can? Also our master saith. You adders birds, how can you 3speak good things, seeing that you be evil. Had not these men freewill? and yet saith our master, they could 4not speak good things. You reckon it but a small power, to speak good, and yet as small as it is, freewill can not do it, he may well speak, but it shall not be good. For how should he speak good, that is evil of him self? how should he do good, that knoweth no good? but is the very enemy of goodness, yea and as much as •yeth in him, he would there were no goodness.
But let vs sée what S. Barnarde 1sayth, of this text. What shall we say? is this alonely all the merite of fréewill, that hée doth alonely consent? yea doubtles. Not that, the same consent, in the whiche is all his merite, is not of God, when that we can neither thinke (the whiche is lesse, then to consent) any thyng of our selues, as though we were sufficient of our selues. These wordes bée not myne, but the Apostles, the whiche geueth vnto God, and not to his fréewil, all maner of thinges, that can bée good, that is to say, to thinke, to will or to performe. &c. Here you not, that all thyngs, that can bée good S. Barnarde geueth to God? Now, what strength hath fréewill, hee can neither thinke good, nor wel, nor yet performe it? what remaineth? I know nothyng, but either it is included in thinking, in willyng, or in performyng, and all these bée geuē to God. Also our maister Christ saith, 2Shal men gather grapes of thornes, ⟨p. 268⟩or figges of bromble bushes? An euill trée, can bryng foorth no good frute. What meaneth our maister, whē hée sayth, that grapes bée not gathered of thornes? nothyng els, but that ye frute must bée lyke the manner of the trée. And therefore sayth hée, an euill trée, can not bryng forth good frute. Now, can you not denye, but that fréewill without grace, is an euill trée, Ergo, his frute must needes bée euil, hée may well bryng forth frute, but it shall not bée good. Is not all fréewils power declared in these wordes, hée can not? I pray you, what meaneth our maister Christ in these woordes, hee can not? Christ sayd, hée can not, and will you say, hée can? Also our maister sayth. You adders byrdes, howe can you 3speake good thynges, séeyng that you bée euill. Had not these men fréewill? and yet sayth our maister, they could 4not speake good thynges. You recken it but a small power, to speake good, and yet as small as it is, fréewill can not doe it, hée may well speake, but it shall not bée good. For how should hée speake good, that is euill of him selfe? how should hée doe good, that knoweth no good? but is the very enemy of goodnes, yea and asmuch as •yeth in him, hée wold there were no goodnes.
- 1Barnarde lib. arbit.
- 2Math. 7.
- 3Math 12.
- 4Mans freewill without Gods grace can do nothing that is good.Mans freewill without Gods grace can doe nothing that is good.