Part 2
pp. 135582 passagespart 10 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. Here being nothing said but what was often said and answered before, I shall spare reciting again the same things. You should not only have said, but have proved that we are made righteous by Atonement: you should have proved according to your speech, that a sinners righteousness or justification lieth in Atonement, and that according to the sense of the Dialogue, namely, such a pardon of sin as neither is the effect of, nor doth acknowledge, nay, doth deny the very being of the satisfactory meritorious Legal Obedience of Christ. And that this your doctrine of a sinners righteousness hath ever been well known and witnessed amongst the godly in all ages from the beginning of the world, that it hath been witnessed by the practice of all sacrifices before the Law, and under the Law, by the doctrine of the Prophets, and by the doctrine of the New Testament, for the making good of which false testimony of yours concerning the witness of the forementioned, you produce no not so much as one reason, but after so slanderous and blasphemous an assertion (pardon my true testimony of your false testimony) you abuse the ignorant, and weary the intelligent Reader with a continual missing or begging the question.
Answ. Here being nothing said but what was often said and answered before, I shall spare reciting again the same things. You should not only have said, but have proved that we are made righteous by Atonement: you should have proved according to your speech, that a sinners righteousnesse or justification lieth in Atonement, and that according to the sense of the Dialogue, namely, such a pardon of sin as neither is the effect of, nor doth acknowledge, nay, doth deny the very being of the satisfactory meritorious Legall Obedience of Christ. And that this your doctrine of a sinners righteousnesse hath ever been well known and witnessed amongst the godly in all ages from the beginning of the world, that it hath been witnessed by the practice of all sacrifices before the Law, and under the Law, by the doctrine of the Prophets, and by the doctrine of the New Testament, for the making good of which false testimony of yours concerning the witnesse of the forementioned, you produce no not so much as one reason, but after so slanderous and blasphemous an assertion (pardon my true testimony of your false testimony) you abuse the ignorant, and weary the intelligent Reader with a continual missing or begging the question.