OF TOLERATION:
pp. 39–95189 passagespart 3 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The Position is laid down in General on both sides, that Erring persons are so, and so, to be dealt withal. That such is the power and duty of the Magistrate in such cases. The definition of Heresy is agreed on for the main; only the Papists place the Churches determination, where others thrust in the Heretics conviction (a thing much more obscure to bystanders and Judges also.) The appellations wherewith truth persecuted, and error pursued, are clothed, still the same. The consequents urged on all sides, of dishonour to God, trouble to the State, and the like not at all discrepant. The arguments for the one, and other, for the most part the same. Look what Reasons one Sect gives for the punishing of another, ⟨p. 64⟩the names being changed are retorted. He blasphemeth to the Heretic, who chargeth blasphemy upon him. We use no other Arguments, cite no other Texts, press no other consequencies for the punishing of other Heretics, then the Papists the wisest Heretics breathing, do for the punishment of us.
The Position is laid downe in Generall on both sides, that Erring persons are so, and so, to be dealt withall. That such is the power and duty of the Magistrate in such cases. The definition of Heresie is agreed on for the maine; onely the Papists place the Churches determination, where others thrust in the Hereticks conviction (a thing much more obscure to bystanders and Judges also.) The appellations wherewith truth persecuted, and error pursued, are cloathed, still the same. The consequents urged on all sides, of dishonour to God, trouble to the State, and the like not at all discrepant. The arguments for the one, and other, for the most part the same. Looke what Reasons one Sect gives for the punishing of another, ⟨p. 64⟩the names being changed are retorted. He blasphemeth to the Hereticke, who chargeth blasphemy upon him. Wee use no other Arguments, cite no other Texts, presse no other consequencies for the punishing of other Hereticks, then the Papists the wisest Hereticks breathing, doe for the punishment of us.
No colour, no pretence, but hath been equally used in all hands: None can say, this is mine. To Luther's objection, that the Church of Christ never burned an Heretic, for Huss, and Hierome were none; Bellarmine answers, they were Heretics to them Catholics, which did suffice: de Laic. cap. 21. And indeed this Vicissitude of things is very pernicious. All Christians almost are Heretics to some enjoying Authority: (as Salvian said the case was, between the Homoousians and Arians in his time) and most of those enjoying authority, are persuaded it is their duty, to suppress them whom they account Heretics; and answerably have more or less acted, according to this persuasion, until by blood, Wars, and horrid devastations of Nations, some of them have been wearied: From the first Ceraysado against the Albigenses, through the War of the Hussites under Zifea and the Procopij, those dreadful Massacres, before recounted, what a stage of blood, hath Europe been made upon this account? I desire that to this point the Declaration of the Netherlands, at the beginning of their Troubles (whom Bellarmine affirms to have Petitioned for Liberty of Conscience, as he was writing de Haereticidio, the thing being long before granted at Spira, at the Convention of the States of the Empire, in the year 1526.) may be seriously considered.