pp. 62–9364 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
7. The Jesuits, and Popish Doctors, as they are of a large1 conscience in many things: so in the doctrine of scandal, to2 extol obedience to men so high; as we may do things in themselves not necessary, yea that hath no necessity, but from the will of Commanders; And Formalists in this conspire▪ with them, even though from this do flow the ruin of many souls: and though the sinful scandalizing and ruin of these souls, flow from sinful corruption of either ignorance or frailty, or wilfulness or malice, yet the scandal ceaseth not to flow kindly▪ from the pretended obedience to an unlawful command, for the thing commanded having no Necessity▪ but the will of man is unlawful, and it is no good reason to say, Men are scandalized through their own ignorance and Malice. Ergo the scandal is taken, and not given, for these who were enemies ⟨p. 85⟩to the Truth, and were so scandalized at Davids murdering of Uriah, and Adultery, 2 Sam. 12. 14. as they were by him occasioned to blaspheme. Certain their actual scandal was from their own corruption. But what? Ergo, it was not also from Davids murder and adultery? and ergo it was a scandal3 only taken by the enemies, not given by David? Surely it followeth not. You may hence judge of the Rule of Lodo Caspensis, a Capucean. These (saith he) that do a work of it self indifferent, for a weighty cause, and use their own right, •tuta• tur suo jure, are excused from mortal sin, as these who let a house to Whores, and public Usurers, that are not strangers, though they may commodiously let it to others, they do not cooperate with sin, because the house it but a place, and extrinsical and remote to the sin. So Christians taken by Turks for danger of their life, (which is a weighty necessity) may furnish instruments necessary for war against Christians because they do a work indifferent of it self, for a just cause: so may a servant convey his Master to a Whore, yea and make the Bed for a Concubine▪ and open the door, and if his Master be to climb in at a window to a whore he may lift up his foot, or reach him a ladder. Why? the servant (saith he) useth his own right in doing a work of it self indifferent, U•itur suo jure faciens opus ex se indifferens, modo non placeat ei peccatum.
7. The Jesuits, and Popish Doctors, as they are of a large1 conscience in many things: so in the doctrine of scandall, to2 extoll obedience to men so high; as we may doe things in themselves not necessarie, yea that hath no necessitie, but from the will of Commanders; And Formalists in this conspire▪ with them, even though from this doe flow the ruine of many soules: and though the sinfull scandalizing and ruine of these soules, flow from sinfull corruption of either ignorance or frailtie, or wilfulnesse or malice, yet the scandall ceaseth not to flow kindly▪ from the pretended obedience to an unlawfull command, for the thing commanded having no Necessitie▪ but the will of man is unlawfull, and it is no good reason to say, Men are scandalized through their owne ignorance and Malice. Ergo the scandall is taken, and not given, for these who were enemies ⟨p. 85⟩to the Truth, and were so scandalized at Davids murthering of Uriah, and Adulterie, 2 Sam. 12. 14. as they were by him occasioned to blaspheme. Certaine their actuall scandall was from their owne corruption. But what? Ergo, it was not also from Davids murther and adulterie? and ergo it was a scandall3 only taken by the enemies, not given by David? Surely it solloweth not. You may hence judge of the Rule of Lodo Caspensis, a Capucean. These (saith he) that doe a worke of it selfe indifferent, for a weightie cause, and use their owne right, •tuta• tur suo jure, are excused from mortall sinne, as these who lett a house to Whores, and publick Usurers, that are not strangers, though they may commodiously lett it to others, they doe not cooperate with sinne, because the house it but a place, and extrinsecall and remote to the sinne. So Christians taken by Turkes for danger of their life, (which is a weighty necessitie) may furnish instruments necessarie for warre against Christians because they doe a worke indifferent of it selfe, for a just cause: so may a servant convey his Master to a Whore, yea and make the Bed for a Concubine▪ and open the doore, and if his Master be to climbe in at a window to a whore he may lift up his foot, or reach him a ladder. Why? the servant (saith he) useth his owne right in doing a worke of it selfe indifferent, Uitur suo jure faciens opus exse indifferens, modo non placeat ei peccatum.
A. But sure, all out jus and right that men have over their1 houses, and that Captives and servants have to their Masters and Lords, is jus limitatum, a right ruled, limited▪ bounded by the word of God, nor is the work they perform morally indifferent, (physically it is) and Captive Christians, if for danger of their life, they may prepare necessary instruments of war against Christians, they may kill Christians also: for what power the conquering Lords have over Captives to command them to prepare fire and sword, against the innocent witnesses of Jesus Christ, because they are such, the same jus right have they to command to kill the innocent. But for no cause the most weighty, can we choose either to shed innocent blood, or to co-operate with the shedding of it, nor to co-operate with the works of darkness, for it is shameful that a servant may lawfully co-operate with, and thrust his master in at a window, to go▪ ⟨p. 86⟩to a whore, the jus or dominion of Masters to command, and the right of servants to obey is only in the Lord. Yea to kill a man is Physically indifferent, for that is physically, yea morally without relation to any law indifferent, which is capable of lawfulness, or unlawfulness, according as it shall be commanded of, or forbidden by God. But for a man to kill his son, is of it self such, certain, if God command a Judge to kill his son, it is lawful for the father to kill his son, if the Lord forbid Abraham to kill his son, it is unlawful for Abraham to kill his son. And therefore Caspensis hath no more reason to use the Instance of captives preparing war against innocent Christians and of a servant thrusting his Master in at door or window to a whore, then of captives killing the innocent, or of servants breaking a house, and taking away the goods of a man in the night▪ or of servants committing whoredom at the command of their Conquerors or Lords, the one kind of action in it self is as indifferent and susceptible of moral lawfulness, and unlawfulness, as the other.
A. But sure, all out jus and right that men have over their1 houses, and that Captives and servants have to their Masters and Lords, is jus limitatum, a right ruled, limited bounded by the word of God, nor is the worke they performe morally indifferent, (physically it is) and Captive Christians, if for danger of their life, they may prepare necessary instruments of warre against Christians, they may kill Christians also: for what power the conquering Lords have over Captives to command them to prepare fire and sword, against the innocent witnesses of Jesus Christ, because they are such, the same jus right have they to command to kill the innocent. But for no cause the most weighty, can we choose either to shed innocent blood, or to co-operate with the shedding of it, nor to co-operate with the works of darknes, for it is shamefull that a servant may lawfully co-operate with, and thrust his master in at a window, to goe
And if the Master do co-operate to commit harlotry in climbing in at a window to a whore, and to robbing, in digging through an innocent mans house in the night, to kill the Master of the house, and to steal his goods, then the servant that co-operateth in these same physical actions, and also diggeth through the innocent mans house and kills himself, is the harlot, and the robber, by cooperation and participation, no less then the Master. The naked1 relation of a captive, and of a servant, cannot make the captive and servant innocent and guiltless co-operators, for then to sin at the command of any Conqueror and Master, because I am in the condition of a captive and servant, were lawful, though God forbid and inhibit me to do, what I do, by the command of my Master and Conqueror, for in so doing, Utor meo jure, I use my right as a servant. For God forbiddeth me in what relation I be in, servant, or Captive, to sin, at the command of any, or for declining any ill of punishment▪ Though as weighty as the torment of hell separated from sinful despairing and blaspheming of God. Now to co-operate with that which I know to be a sin, is to partake in other mens sins, which is forbidden, as a sin, 1 Tim. 5. 22. Eph. 5. 11. But to ⟨p. 87⟩run with the thief, and to help an Arch-robber, Prov. 1. 13. 14. is a consenting to his robbery and bloodshed. And to help any to dig through a house, or to climb in at a window to Incest, Sodomy, Buggery, to fetch a beast to the Master who rageth in the sin of Bestiality, or to fetch a young man to the Master or Conqueror to the sin of abominable Sodomy, knowing the Master and conquerors mind is to co-operate to Bestiality and Sodomy, is as high a measure of sinful cooperating in these abominations, as for the servant to help up, or life up his Master, to go in, at a window to an harlot, for this is a consent to these sins, and a consent in the highest degree; so to give a knife to a Master, who seeketh it from his servant, to kill his Father, Mother, Prince, Pastor, is to consent formally to such horrible parricides, and therefore Caspensis should have brought instances in Buggery, Sodomy, Parricide, when as he used softer Names of fornication and harlotry.
8. The non-necessaries, or such things as need not be in the1 worship of God, which do bring scandal, Must 1. be such as are neither necessary in speciè, nor in individuo, in kind, or in species or nature, or in their individuals and particulars, as the whole Category of Mens devises, as
8. The non-necessaries, or such things as need not be in the1 worship of God, which do bring scandall, Must 1. be such as are neither necessarie in speciè, nor in individuo, in kind, or in spece or nature, or in their individuals and particulars, as the whole Categorie of Mens devises, as
1. Unwritten traditions—not necessary, not written. 2. Humane mystical, symbolical signs and Ceremonies—not necessary, not written. 3. Humane holy days, crossing, kneeling to Elements, Altars, Crossing, Surplice, Rochets, &c,—not necessary, not written. 4. This and this humane holy day, this crossing—not necessary, not written.1
1. Unwritten traditions—not necessary, not written. 2. Humane mysticall, symbolical signes and Ceremonies—not necessarie, not written. 3. Humane holy dayes, crossing, kneeling to Elements, Altars, Crossing, Surplice, Rochets, &c,—not necessary, not written. 4. This and this humane holy day, this crossing—not necessarie, not written.1
2. These things are judged not necessary, that are not necessary by way of dis-junction, as Surplice is not necessary by way of dis-junction, for neither is Surplice necessary, nor any other white or red habit, that hath some mystical religious signification, like unto Surplice; So kneeling to the Elements is neither Necessary, nor any the like religious honouring of them, by prostration before them, o• kissing them.
2. These things are judged not necessarie, that are not necessarie by way of dis-junction, as Surplice is not necessarie by way of dis-junction, for neither is Surplice necessarie, nor any other white or red habit, that hath some mysticall religious signification, like unto Surplice; So kneeling to the Elements is neither Necessarie, nor any the like religious honouring of them, by prostration before them, o• kissing them.
But, the things of the Directory for the public worship, as many of them are necessary, and have express warrant in the Word, as Praying, Preaching, Sacraments, Praising, &c. So 2. some things that are non-necessaries in the individual or particular words, or things, yet are they not to be removed in their alternative necessity, either this or the like though some be thereby scandalized. Because though they be not necessary simply, yet are they necessary by way of dis-junction, as that the Minister say, either these, or the like words, for words to that sense are necessary. So the order that the Directory prescribes in citing such and such acts of Divine worship is necessary either this way, or a way as convenient not different from this, for some order of necessity there must be. So the Liturgy or Service Book, what ever Jos. Hall say on the contrary (as it is little that he doth, or can say) though it should contain many things necessary in speciè, in the kind, sit for the external public worshipping of God, yet because these words in Individuo, in their particulars are not necessary, is to be removed, because though all the matter were good (as much of it is Popish) yet that book in its structure, frame, style, Grammar, method, and form is popish, and framed after the model of the Roman Missal, especially performed with the cursed Authority of the Council of Trent, under Pius the fifth, in all the Masses, Rubrics, Epistles, Gospels, &c. is scandalous, and a Directory in Scripture words is better, and is therefore justly laid aside by the Reverend Assembly, and honourable Court of parliament, because there is scandal in words, in style and language, in divine worship. And these who will abstain from practising of some things in the Directory, for fear of scandalizing others, must give reasons from the Word that these things they forbear, are neither necessary simply, nor by way of dis-junction. Because as I conceive, Things neither necessary in the same individuals, nor by way of dis-junction, are such Non-necessaries as are to be removed out of the worship of God, for fear of scandal. And that any such non-necessaries can be found in the Directory, I do not see as yet.
But, the things of the Directorie for the publick worship, as many of them are necessarie, and have expresse warrant in the Word, as Praying, Preaching, Sacraments, Praising, &c. So 2. some things that are non-necessaries in the individual or particular words, or things, yet are they not to be removed in their alternative necessitie, either this or the like though some be therby scandalized. Because though they be not necessarie simply, yet are they necessarie by way of dis-junction, as that the Minister say, either these, or the like words, for words to that sense are necessarie. So the order that the Directorie prescribes in citing such and such acts of Divine worship is necessarie either this way, or a way as convenient not different from this, for some order of necessity there must be. So the Liturgie or Service Booke, what ever Jos. Hall say on the contrary (as it is little that he doth, or can say) though it should containe many things necessarie in speciè, in the kind, sit for the externall publick worshipping of God, yet because these words in Individuo, in their particulars are not necessarie, is to be reoved, because though all the matter were good (as much of it is Popish) yet that booke in its structure, frame, style, Grammer, methode, and forme is popish, and framed after the model of the Roman Missale, especially performed with the cursed Authoritie of the Councell of Trent, under Pius the fift, in all the Masses, Rubricks, Epistles, Gospels, &c. is scandalous, and a Directorie in Scripture words is better, and is therefore justly layd aside by the Revevent Assemblie, and honourable Court of parliament, because there is scandall in words, in style and language, in divine worship. And these who will abstaine from practising of some things in the Directorie, for feare of scandalizing others, must give reasons from the Word that these things they forbeare, are neither necessarie simply, nor by way of dis-junction. Because as I conceive, Things neither necessarie in the same individuals, nor by way of dis-junction, are such Non-necessaries as are to be removed out of the worship of God, for feare of scandall. And that any such non-necessaries can be found in the Directorie, I doe not see as yet.
Ob. The people had the more opinion of Deity in the thing they adored the baser it was. None hath any such opinion of the cross. ⟨p. 89⟩Ergo, it is no scandalous object. Ans. All our Divines hold, that Heathens of old, and Papists of late, worship Images, as religious memorative signs of God, Hooker with one dash of his Pen, against the Prophets and Scriptures, acquiteth them of Idolatry, therefore the Cross may be adored, without any opinion of Deity in it.
Ob. The people had the more opinion of Dietie in the thing they adored the baser it was. None hath any such opinion of the crosse. ⟨p. 89⟩Ergo, it is no scandalous object. Ans. All our Divines hold, that Heathens of old, and Papists of late, worship Images, as religious memorative signes of God, Hooker with one dash of his Pen, against the Prophets and Scriptures, acquiteth them of Idolatrie, therefore the Crosse may be adored, without any opinion of Dietie in it.
Obj. Be it true, that crosses were purposely appointed to ••• adored, yet not so now. The Jews would not admit of the Image of Caesar in the Church, yet they abolished it not, but admitted it in their coin. The adored cross differeth as far from this, as the Brazen Serpent that Solomon made to bear up the Cistern of the Temple, and that which Israel adored in the wilderness, And the Altars that Josiah destroyed, as being mere Instruments1 of Idolatry, and that which the Tribe of Reuben erected beyond Jordan. Solomon destroyed not the Temple and Idols framed only of purpose for the worship of foreign Gods, because2 they stood now as forlorn, and did no harm. Josiah afterward razed them for some inconvenients, yet God saith both these Kings, in religion walked straightly.
Obj. Be it true, that crosses were purposely appointed to ••• adored, yet not so now. The Jewes would not admit of the Image of Caesar in the Church, yet they abolished it not, but admitted it in their coyne. The adored cross differeth as farre from this, as the Brazen Serpent that Salomon made to beare up the Cisterne of the Temple, and that which Israel adored in the wilderness, And the Altars that Josiah destroyid, as being meere Instruments1 of Idolatrie, and that which the Tribe of Reuben •rected beyond Jordan. Salomon distroyed not the Temple and Idols framed only of purpose for the worship of forrains Gods, because2 they stood now as forlorne, and did no harme. Josiah afterward razed them for some inconvenients, yet God saith both these Kings, in religion walked straightly.
Ans. 1. Though the Cross were first framed for no adoration; yet we plead against the Images and Crosses of Lutherans as not necessary, in divine worship, and therefore to be removed, though never adored.
Ans. 1. Though the Cross were first framed for no adoration; yet we plead against the Images and Crosses of Lutherans as not necessarie, in divine worship, and therefore to be removed, though never adored.
2. The people think Baptism incomplete without the Cross, Ergo, to them it has the like necessity, as water.
2. The people thinke Baptisme incompleat without the Crosse, Ergo, to them it has the like necessitie, as water.
3. How will Hooker prove never any burnt Incense to the Brazen Serpent, but believed it really to be God? that is his dream, beside the Text.
3. How will Hooker prove never any burnt Incense to the Brazen Serpent, but beleeved it really to be God? that is his dreame, beside the Text.
4. By this Luther ••• have their desire; for actual intention that Images be lawful remembrancers of Christ, without intention of adoration, shall make Images as lawful teaching Ceremonies, as Hooker will have the sign of the Cross.
4. By this Luther ••• have their desire; for actuall intention that Images be lawfull remembrancers of Christ, without intention of adoration, shall make Images as lawfull teaching Ceremonies, as Hooker will have the sigue of the Crosse.
5. We remove not crosses from coin, no more then the Jews did the image of C•s•r. But we agree with them. Hooker being judge, in Banishing them from the worship.
5. We remove not crosses from coyne, no more then the Jewes did the image of C•s•r. But wee agree with them. Hooker being judge, in Banishing them from the worship.
6. Hezekiah then might have broken the old, and made a new Brazen Serpent, for a memorial of the miraculous cure, so ⟨p. 90⟩they had not burnt Incense to it; The remembrance of the old mercy should have been as good in the new, as in the old. But1 certainly the Brazen Serpent was not destroyed as Brass, but in all its religious use. It was not purged, but abolished.
6. Ezechiah then might have broken the old, and made a new Brazen Serpent, for a memoriall of the miraculous cure, so ⟨p. 90⟩they had not burnt Incen•e to it; The remembrance of the old mercie should have been as good in the new, as in the old. But1 certainly the Brazen Serpent was not destroyed as Brasse, but in all its religious use. It was not purged, but abolished.
7. If we may make Images and Orasses alike in shape, but dislike in use, in Gods worship, we may bring in Golden Calves to the Temples, and the Image of Dagon, and the Sidonian Gods, and Altars such as Josiah destroyed, so at their first moulding we imprint on them, chaste and innocent religious intentions and signification, and make them alike in shape, but dislike in use to heathen worship. But sure the Calf of Egypt, and the Calf that Aaron made, though like in shape, yet were dislike in use.
7. If we may make Images and Orasses alike in shape, but dislike in use, in Gods worship, we may bring in Golden Calves to the Temples, and the Image of Dagon, and the Sidonian Gods, and Altars such as Josiah destroyed, so at their first moulding we imprint on them, chaste and innocent religious intencions and signification, and make them alike in shape, but dislike in use to heathen worship. But sure the Calfe of Egypt, and the Calfe that Aaron made, though like in shape, yet were dislike in use.
8. We read of no new Inconvenients that the Images and Temples that Solomon erected to strange Gods, did in Josiahs time, which they did not in •••ekiahs time, but that they were Monuments of Idolatry in both; It seems that Nooker would commend Hezekiah, for not demolishing the Images of Solomons outlandish Gods; But then it was Josiahs zeal without knowledge, that he demolished them. 2. We then might well suffer the Images of Jupiter, Dagon, Ashtaroth to stand before the people publicly, so they do no harm•: and Papists and Lutherans say the Images of Christ and the Saints do• no harm, when the Pastors carefully teach the people, that there is no Dietie• nor God-h•ad dwelling in them. 3. We say the sign of the Cross is a mere instrument of Idolatry and Superstition, and what ever good intention, or pious signification was stamped on it, at the first, by mens carnal wisdom and will zeal, it no more made it good, then if upon the Image of Dagon, you would found the like good intention and pious signification.
8. We read of no new Inconvenients that the Images and Temples that Salomon erected to strange Gods, did in Josiahs time, which they did not in •••ekiahs time, but that they were Monuments of Idolatrie in both; It seemes that Nooker would commend Ezechiah, for not demolishing the Images of Salomons outlandish Gods; But then it was Josiahs zeale without knowledge, that he demolished them. 2. We then might well suffer the Images of Jupiter, Dagon, Ashtarosh to stand before the people publickly, so they doe no harm•: and Papists and Lutherans say the Images of Christ and the Saints do• no harme, when the Pastors carefully teach the people, that there is no Dietie• nor God-h•ad dwelling in them. 3. Wee say the signe of the Crosse is a meere instrument of Idolatrie and Superstition, and what ever good intention, or pious signification was stamped on it, at the first, by mens carnall wisdome and will zeale, it no more made it good, then if upon the Image of Dagon, you would found the like good intention and pious signification.
9. Though Hezekiah was commended by God, it no more followeth his omission in not demolishing Solomons outlandish Idols must be lawful, and a part of his upright walking in •• matters of religion, then because David is commended, as walking uprightly in all things, save in the matter of Uriah, that his numbering of the people, his revengeful attempt to destroy Nabal and all his, must also be a part of Davids walking uprightly before God.
9. Though Ezechiah was commended by God, it no more followeth his omission in not demolishing Salomons outlandish Idols must belawfull, and a part of his upright walking in •• matters of religion, then because David is commended, as walking uprightly in all things, save in the matter of Uriah, that his numbering of the people, his revengefull attempt to destroy Nabal and all his, must also be a part of Davids walking uprightly before God.
10. Solomon had a warrant for the Brazen Image in the Temple, not to abolish it. But Hezekiah had no warrant not to Abolish the Brazen Serpent, after the people burnt Incense to it, even suppose the People should, upon the exhortation of the Priests, have desisted from burning Incense to it. I see not, if Images may be lawful Remembrancers to us, so we adore them not; But the Golden Calves, the Images that Solomon made to outlandish Gods, the Image of Diana, and all the heathen Images that the Word speaketh against should be brought into the Christian Churches, to teach us to flee, and eschew the adoring of these abominations, for we have as great need of Ceremonial and Historical remembrancers to teach us to eschew evil, as to admonish us to follow good. But the truth is, except we will be wiser then God, we need neither.
10. Salomon had a warrant for the Brazen Image in the Temple, not to abolish it. But Ezechiah had no warrant not to Abolish the Brazen Serpent, after the people burnt Incense to it, even suppose the People should, upon the exhortation of the Priests, have desisted from burning Incense to it. I see not, if Images may be lawfull Remembrancers to us, so we adore them not; But the Golden Calves, the Images that Salomon made to outlandish Gods, the Image of Diana, and all the heathen Images that the Word speaketh against should be brought into the Christian Churches, to teach us to flee, and eschew the adoring of these abominations, for we have as great need of Ceremoniall and Historicall remembrancers to teach us to eschew evill, as to admonish us to follow good. But the truth is, except we will be wiser then God, we need neither.
Obj. Some things are of their own nature scandalous, and1 cannot choose but breed offence as those sinks of execrable filth which Josiah did turn out: Some things though not by nature generally, and of themselves, are generally turned to evil through a corrupt habit grown, and uncurably settled in the minds of men, without the removal of the thing, as was the worshipping of the Brazen Serpent. But some, as the Cross though subject either almost, or altogether to as much corruption, are yet curable with more facility and ease.
Obj. Some things are of their owne nature scandalous, and1 cannot choose but breed offence as those sinkes of execrable filth which Josiah did turne out: Some things though not by nature generally, and of themselves, are generally turned to evill through a corrupt habit growne, and uncurably settled in the mindes of men, without the removall of the thing, as was the worshipping of the Brazen Serpent. But some, as the Crosse though subject either almost, or altogether to as much corruption, are yet curable with more facilitie and ease.
Ans. Objects sinful and so intrinsically scandalous are to be removed, as the Image of Jupiter, Molech, both because sins, and and so not necessary. 2. Because scandalous, for the truth is, even sins (if we speak accurately) are not scandalous actum secundo, in regard of our corruption, our sins may sad the Angels, but they are not properly scandalous to Angels, and therefore every thing actively scandalous, as scandalous is to be removed. 2. How doth Hooker prove that the Vessels made for Baal, are in their own nature more incurable then the sign of the Cross? You may remove the superstitious intention and Idolatrous use of any vessel, and turn it to a good use; Yet Josiah burnt them to ashes. The like may be said of the Groves which he stamped to powder, and cast in the brook Kidron, And of the Chariots five of the Sun, which he burnt with fire, and of the ⟨p. 92⟩bones of dead men, not any of these, being of their own nature more indifferent, and innocent creatures of God, were of their own nature more scandalous, and more uncurable then the sign of the Cross. The like may be said of Altars, and I pray are reasonable men, the Priests of the high places of their own nature uncurable? are they not capable of repentance, and curable by doctrine? yet 2 King. 23. 20. Josiah slew all the Priests of the high places. 3. Teaching may remove evil customs, otherwise how should the Gospel convert sinners, that are accustomed from the womb to do evil? Jer. 13. 23. Jer. 22. 21. Ephes. 2. 1. 2. 3. 4. Tit. 3. 3. 4 5. therefore scandalous objects of the second kind, are no more to be removed, then the Sign of the Cross. 4. It is false, that scandalous objects of the third sort are more easily cured, except they be removed, for no humane prudence, when the sign of the Cross, and the Brazen serpent, are sure, not necessary in Gods worship. And when men have, and so still may abuse them to Superstition and Idolatry, can make these being now actively scandalous, to be not actively scandalous, as no ar• can make a pit to be no pit. Indeed Gods ordinances, because necessary, may be cured, from scandal by teaching.
But it is Gods only prerogative, by his commanding will to make a thing, not necessary in his worship, to be necessary, and to alter the nature of things, so as his command could have made the Brazen Serpent, to remain a lawful teaching Sign, and no scandalous object, and only he might have forbidden the burning of Incense to it. The Ancient Ignatius, or any had no warrant to make confession of Christ before enemies and mockers, by gestures or crossing, Paul did it not, Peter commandeth confession to be verbal, 1 Pet. 3. 14. 15,
But it is Gods only prerogative, by his commanding will to make a thing, not necessarie in his worship, to be necessarie, and to alter the nature of things, so as his command could have made the Brazen Serpent, to remaine a lawfull teaching Signe, and no scandalous object, and only he might have forbidden the burning of Incense to it. The Ancient Ignatius, or any had no warrant to make confession of Christ before enemies and mockers, by gestures or crossing, Paul did it not, Peter commandeth confession to be verball, 1 Pet. 3. 14. 15,
There be many ancient laws, yea Divine and Apostolic constitutions1 acknowledged to be good, that the Church hath laid aside. Some things cannot be removed without danger of greater evils to succeed in their place. Wisdom must give place to necessity. Seneca, Necessitas, quicquid coegit, defendit.
There be many ancient lawes, yea Divine and Apostolike constitutions1 acknowledged to be good, that the Church hath layd aside. Some things cannot be removed without danger of greater evils to succeed in their place. Wisedome must give place to necessitie. Seneca, Necessitas, quicquid coegit, defendit.
Ans. 2. We know no necessity to have, nor any danger to want such wares, as Surplice, Crossing, bowing to Altars, to elements, which sure the Apostolic Church wanted, both in ⟨p. 93⟩speciè, and in individuo. The like Papists say for adoring of Images, that Hooker here saith, for Surplice, and the like Scandals. So doth the Jesuit Tannerus say, in. 22. to. 3, dis. 5. de religione. q. •. dub. 3. Quando dicitur Adorationem imaginum non esse licitam, qui non est scripta. Respo. (inquit) apostol• familiari Spiritus instinctu quadam Ecclesiis tradider•nt Servanda que non reliquerunt in scriptis—inter hujusmodi Traditiones est Imaginum Christi adoratio.
Ans. 2. We know no necessitie to have, nor any danger to want such wares, as Surplice, Crossing, bowing to Altars, to elements, which sure the Apostolike Church wanted, both in ⟨p. 93⟩speciè, and in individuo. The like Papists say for adoring of Images, that Hooker here saith, for Surplice, and the like Scandals. So doth the Jesuit Tannerus say, in. 22. to. 3, dis. 5. de religione. q. •. dub. 3. Quando dicitur Adorationem imaginum non esse licitam, qui non est scripta. Respo. (inquit) apostol• familiari Spiritus instinctu quadam Ecclesiis tradider•nt Servanda que non reliquerunt in scriptis—inter hujusmodi Traditiones est Imaginum Christi adoratio.
And if the Master doe co-operate to commit harlotrie in climbing in at a window to a whore, and to robbing, in digging thorow an innocent mans house in the night, to kill the Master of the house, and to steale his goods, then the servant that co-operateth in these same physicall actions, and also diggeth thorow the innocent mans house and kills himselfe, is the harlot, and the robber, by cooperation and participation, no lesse then the Master. The naked1 relation of a captive, and of a servant, cannot make the captive and servant innocent and guiltlesse co-operators, for then to sinne at the command of any Conqueror and Master, because I am in the condition of a captive and servant, were lawfull, though God forbid and inhibite me to doe, what I doe, by the command of my Master and Conqueror, for in so doing, Utor meo jure, I use my right as a servant. For God forbiddeth me in what relation I be in, servant, or Captive, to sinne, at the command of any, or for declining any ill of punishment▪ Though as weightie as the torment of hell separated from sinfull dispairing and blaspheming of God. Now to co-operate with that which I know to be a sinne, is to partake in other mens sinnes, which is forbidden, as a sinne, 1 Tim. 5. 22. Eph. 5. 11. But to ⟨p. 87⟩runne with the theefe, and to helpe an Arch-robber, Prov. 1. 13. 14. is a consenting to his robberie and bloodshed. And to help any to digge thorow a house, or to climbe in at a window to Incest, Sodomie, Buggerie, to fetch a beast to the Master who rageth in the sinne of Beastialitie, or to setch a young man to the Master or Conqueror to the sinne of abominable Sodomie, knowing the Master and conquerors minde is to co-operate to Beastialitie and Sodomie, is as high a measure of sinfull cooperating in these abominations, as for the servant to helpe up, or life up his Master, to goe in, at a window to an harlot, for this is a consent to these sinnes, and a consent in the highest degree; so to give a knife to a Master, who seeketh it from his servant, to kill his Father, Mother, Prince, Pastor, is to consent formally to such horrible paricides, and therefore Caspensis should have brought instances in Bugrie, Sodomie, Parricide, when as he used softer Names of fornication and harlotrie.
Ans. Objects sinfull and so intrinsecally scandalous are to be removed, as the Image of Jupiter, Molech, both because sins, and and so not necessarie. 2. Because scandalous, for the truth is, even sins (if we speake accurately) are not scandalous actum secundo, in regard of our corruption, our sinnes may sad the Angels, but they are not properly scandalous to Angels, and therefore every thing actively scandalous, as scandalous is to be removed. 2. How doth Hooker prove that the Vessels made for Baal, are in their own nature more incurable then the signe of the Crosse? You may remove the superstitious intention and Idolatrous use of any vessell, and turne it to a good use; Yet Josiah burnt them to ashes. The like may be said of the Groves which he stamped to powder, and cast in the brook Kidron, And of the Chariots five of the Sunne, which he burnt with fire, and of the ⟨p. 92⟩bones of dead men, not any of these, being of their owne nature more indifferent, and innocent creatures of God, were of their owne nature more scandalous, and more uncurable then the signe of the Crosse. The like may be said of Altars, and I pray are reasonable men, the Priests of the high places of their own nature uncurable? are they not capable of repentance, and curable by doctrine? yet 2 King. 23. 20. Josiah slew all the Priests of the high places. 3. Teaching may remove evil customes, otherwise how should the Gospell convert sinners, that are accustomed from the wombe to doe evill? Jer. 13. 23. Jer. 22. 21. Ephes. 2. 1. 2. 3. 4. Tit. 3. 3. 4 5. therefore scandalous objects of the second kinde, are no more to be removed, then the Signe of the Crosse. 4. It is false, that scandalous objects of the third sort are more easily cured, except they be removed, for no humane prudence, when the signe of the Crosse, and the Brasen serpent, are sure, not necessarie in Gods worship. And when men have, and so still may abuse them to Superstition and Idolatrie, can make these being now actively scandalous, to be not actively scandalous, as no ar• can make a pite to be no pite. Indeed Gods ordinances, because necessarie, may bee cured, from scandall by teaching.