Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
They Object. I could not then ride ten miles to solace my self with1 my friends, except I had warrant from Scripture, and seeing the Scripture is as perfect in acts of the second Table, as in acts of the first; I must have a reason of all the business betwixt man and man, of all humane and municipal Laws, but it is certain (saith Sanderson) faith2⟨p. 107⟩as certain as Logic can make it, is not required in these, but only Ethical and Conjectural faith, whereby we know things to be Lawful Negatively: Its not required that we know them to be Positively conform to Gods Word.
They Object. I could not then ride ten miles to solace my self with1 my friends, except I had warrant from Scripture, and seeing the Scripture is as perfect in acts of the second Table, as in acts of the first; I must have a reason of all the businesse betwixt man and man, of all humane and municipall Laws, but it is certain (saith Sanderson) faith2⟨p. 107⟩as certain as Logick can make it, is not required in these, but onely Ethicall and Conjecturall faith, whereby we know things to be Lawfull Negatively: Its not required that we know them to be Positively conform to Gods Word.
1Jackson on the Creed, 1. Part.Iackson on the Creed, 1. Part.
with his word, who says (Redeem the time) you must give account for idle actions, if Christ say, you must give an account for idle Words. 2. Though there seem to be more Liberty in actions of the second Table, then of the first; because there be far moe Positive actions, not merely Moral, which concerneth the second Table, because of Economy, Policy, Municipal and Civill Laws, Arts, Sciences, Contracts amongst men, that are not in the first Table; yet the Morality of the second Table, is as expressly in Gods Word, as the Worship of the first Table. 1. Because what is justice and mercy, and love toward man in the second Table, doth no more depend upon mans sole will, but upon Gods Moral Law & the Law of nature, then it dependeth upon mans will or human wisdom, how God should be worshipped according to the first Table. For Gods will in his Word, is called by our Divines, a perfect Canon and rule of Faith, and also of Manners: And as the grace of God, Tit 2.
teacheth us what is Piety, so also what is Righteousness and Sobriety. 2. Because as Gods Word condemneth will-worship, which is come of no Nobler blood, then mans will, so condemneth it idle words, and idle actions, which are but will-works, and will-words, and deeds of will-justice, and will-mercy: and a will-conscience in the second Table, putteth no less a rub upon the wisdom of the Lord, the Law▪giver, then a will conscience in the first Table. But Formalists say, If mans will and authority cannot appoint Crossing, Holy humane-days, Surplice, and such, the decent expressions and incitements of Devotion, in the kind of Arbitrary, Mutable, and Ambulatory
Worship; but they must be therein guilty of adding to the Doctrine of Piety and Religion in the first Table: by that same reason they cannot make humane Civill and Positive Laws in War and Peace, to be means of conserving justice and mercy toward humane societies in the kind of duties of Righteousness and sobriety towards our selves and Neighbours; but they must be guilty of adding to the Doctrine of the second Table. I Answer: 1. The case is not alike, we cannot be Agents in the performing of any worship to God; nor can we use
⟨p. 114⟩
any Religious means for honouring God, which belong to the first
Ans. If you ride ten miles with your friend and do not advise1 with his word, who sayes (Redeem the time) you must give account for idle actions, if Christ say, you must give an account for idle Words. 2. Though there seem to be more Liberty in actions of the second Table, then of the first; because there be far moe Positive actions, not meerly Morall, which concerneth the second Table, because of Oeconomy, Policy, Municipall and Civill Laws, Arts, Sciences, Contracts amongst men, that are not in the first Table; yet the Morallity of the second Table, is as expresly in Gods Word, as the Worship of the first Table. 1. Because what is justice and mercy, and love toward man in the second Table, doth no more depend upon mans sole will, but upon Gods Morall Law & the Law of nature, then it dependeth upon mans will or human wisdom, how God should be worshipped according to the first Table. For Gods will in his Word, is called by our Divines, a perfect Canon and rule of Faith, and also of Manners: And as the grace of God, Tit 2.2 teacheth us what is Piety, so also what is Righteousnesse and Sobriety. 2. Because as Gods Word condemneth will-worship, which is come of no Nobler blood, then mans will, so condemneth it idle words, and idle actions, which are but will-works, and will-words, and deeds of will-justice, and will-mercy: and a will-conscience in the second Table, putteth no lesse a rub upon the wisdom of the Lord, the Law▪giver, then a will conscience in the first Table. But Formalists say, If mans will and authority cannot appoint Crossing, Holy humane-dayes, Surplice, and such, the decent expressions and incitements of Devotion, in the kinde of Arbitrary, Mutable, and Ambulatory 3Worship; but they must be therein guilty of adding to the Doctrine of Piety and Religion in the first Table: by that same reason they cannot make humane Civill and Positive Laws in War and Peace, to be means of conserving justice and mercy tovvard humane societies in the kinde of duties of Righteousnesse and sobriety tovvards our selves and Neighbours; but they must be guilty of adding to the Doctrine of the second Table. I Answer: 1. The case is not alike, we cannot be Agents in the performing of any worship to God; nor can we use ⟨p. 114⟩any Religious means for honouring God, which belong to the first4 Table:
1What certitude of Faith is required in all our actions of our daily conversation.
2Tit. 2. 11. 12. The Scripture a warrant for the morality of our acts of the second table, as for the acts of worship.
3Many actions of the 2. table are mixed, and not purely Moral, all the actions of the first table are purely moral.Many actions of the 2. table are mixt, and not purely Morall, all the actions of the first table are purely morall.
4The contr•ry is the clear judgement of Papists, as S••rc• teacheth us, tom. de virt. et statu Relig. l. 2. de superst. Cap. 1. Scriptura ipsa praecipit •bscr•are vot• que qua tamen voluntarie non ex precepto promittuntur, et ratio naturalis dictat, non solum esse facienda bona praecepta, sed etiam esse utile, plura bona et honesta facere, quam prec•pta sunt.—Und• etiam H•r•tici ipsi suos pe•uliares modos et ritus introducunt in modo colendi Deum, qui non sunt in Evangelio vel Divina lege praecepti, imo nec ipsi inter se in bujusmodi ritibus comveniunt, &c.
But in these we are Moral Agents, doing with special reference to conscience, and to true happiness and the glory of God, as the ends both of the work and workers: and therefore in these we are precisely ruled by the wisdom of God, who hath in his word set down what Worship, and what means of exciting Devotion, and decoring of his Worship pleaseth him, and hath not left men to Lord-will, or Lord-wit; but in many actions that belong to humane societies, we are not Moral Agents, but often Agents by Art, as in Military discipline, Trades useful for mans life, Economy and Policy in Kingdoms and Cities, in Sciences, as Logic, Physic, Mathematics, in these Finis operis, the end of the work is operation, according to the principles of Arts and Policy, and we are not in them Moral Agents, and so not to be regulated by Gods Word.
But in these we are Morall Agents, doing with speciall reference to conscience, and to true happinesse and the glory of God, as the ends both of the work and workers: and therefore in these we are precisely ruled by the wisdom of God, who hath in his word set down what Worship, and what means of exciting Devotion, and decoring of his Worship pleaseth him, and hath not left men to Lord-will, or Lord-wit; but in many actions that belong to humane societies, we are not Morall Agents, but often Agents by Art, as in Military discipline, Trades usefull for mans life, Oeconomy and Policy in Kingdoms and Cities, in Sciences, as Logick, Physick, Mathematicks, in these Finis operis, the end of the work is operation, according to the principles of Arts and Policy, and we are not in them Morall Agents, and so not to be regulated by Gods Word.
For the Scripture giveth not to us, precepts of Grammar, of War, of Trades, and Arts, teaching us to speak right Latin, to make accurate demonstrations: nor is the end of the work here a thing that pitcheth upon that tender and excellentest piece in us, our Conscience, and our Moral duties to God and men, but to make such humane Laws, just and suitable with sobriety and justice, is not left to Lord-will, but right reason, the principles of a natural Conscience (which are parts to us of Scripture) and the Word of God it self hath determined; whether, to carry Armour in the 1night, in such a case? Whether to eat flesh in such a season of the year▪ when the eating thereof hurteth the Common-Wealth, and the like belong to works of justice and mercy, or no? Now it is no marvel that in things belonging to our natural life, peace, societies, policy, where the end of the work is natural or civill, and belongeth not, as such, to the Conscience, and Salvation of the soul, that there men be Artificers or Agents according to Art, Economy, Policy, whereas the end of the work, Finis operis, in the Worship of God, is Moral, and a matter of an higher nature; and so the means and manner of Worship here, are determined by Gods Word. But when ⟨p. 119⟩actions of Arts, Sciences, Trades, Economy, Policy, and Laws positive, are elevated above themselves, Ad finem operantium, to the end that Agents are to look unto, as they be Moral Agents; Gods Word is as perfect a rule for acts of good manners in the second Table, as in the first: For example, that I speak good Latin, I am to see to Disputers Precepts; but that I lie not, and speak not Scandals or Blasphemies, while I speak Latin, there I am to look to Gods Law given by Moses. That a Tradesman make works according to Art, he is to advise with Art, but that he sell not his work at too dear a price, he is to advise with the eight Commandment; and when all these acts of Art are referred to Conscience▪ Salvation, and the glory of God, as they ought to be Respectus finis operantis▪ in respect of the Moral intention of the doer, all their Morality is squared by Gods-Word. Hence there be no actions of Worshipping God, but they be purely Morall, Et respectu finis operis, Et respectu finis operantiis;
For the Scripture giveth not to us, precepts of Grammar, of War, of Trades, and Arts, teaching us to speak right Latine, to make accurat demonstrations: nor is the end of the work here a thing that pitcheth upon that tender and excellentest peece in us, our Conscience, and our Morall duties to God and men, but to make such humane Laws, just and suitable with sobriety and justice, is not left to Lord-will, but right reason, the principles of a naturall Conscience (which are parts to us of Scripture) and the Word of God it self hath determined; whether, to carry Armour in the 1night, in such a case? Whether to eat flesh in such a season of the year▪ when the eating thereof hurteth the Common-Wealth, and the like belong to works of justice and mercy, or no? Now it is no marvel that in things belonging to our naturall life, peace, societies, policy, where the end of the work is naturall or civill, and belongeth not, as such, to the Conscience, and Salvation of the soul, that there men be Artificers or Agents according to Art, Oeconomy, Policy, whereas the end of the work, Finis operis, in the Worship of God, is Morall, and a matter of an higher nature; and so the means and manner of Worship here, are determined by Gods Word. But when ⟨p. 119⟩actions of Arts, Sciences, Trades, Oeconomy, Policy, and Laws positive, are elevated above themselves, Ad finem operantium, to the end that Agents are to look unto, as they be Morall Agents; Gods Word is as perfect a rule for acts of good manners in the second Table, as in the first: For example, that I speak good Latine, I am to see to Disputers Precepts; but that I lie not, and speak not Scandals or Blasphemies, while I speak Latine, there I am to look to Gods Law given by Moses. That a Tradesman make works according to Art, he is to advise with Art, but that he sell not his work at too dear a price, he is to advise with the eight Commandment; and when all these acts of Art are referred to Conscience▪ Salvation, and the glory of God, as they ought to be Respectus finis operantis▪ in respect of the Morall intention of the doer, all their Morallity is squared by Gods-Word. Hence there be no actions of Worshipping God, but they be purely Morall, Et respectu finis operis, Et respectu finis operantiis;
1The Jesuit speaketh of the Ceremonies of Lutherans▪ and the Prelatical faction in England.The Iesuit speaketh of the Ceremonies of Lutherans▪ and the Prelaticall faction in England.
but many actions belonging to the second Table, are either purely not Moral, as actions of mere Art, or they be mixed, and Respectu finis operis, in respect of the end of the work, they are not Moral, nor to be squared by the Word at all; and in respect of the Moral intention of the doer, they be Moral, and so mixed actions, and partly ruled by the Word, and partly ruled by Art or Policy, according to our seventh distinction.
but many actions belonging to the second Table, are either purely not Morall, as actions of meer Art, or they be mixed, and Respectu finis operis, in respect of the end of the work, they are not Morall, nor to be squared by the Word at all; and in respect of the Morall intention of the doer, they be Morall, and so mixed actions, and partly ruled by the Word, and partly ruled by Art or Policy, according to our seventh distinction.
II. Conclusion: In actions or Religious means of Worship, and actions Moral, whatever is beside the Word of God, is against the1 Word of God; I say in Religious means, for there be means of Worship, or Circumstances Physical, not Moral, not Religious, as whether the Pulpit be of stone or of timber, the Bell of this or this Metal, the house of Worship stand thus or thus in Situation.
II. Conclusion: In actions or Religious means of Worship, and actions Morall, whatever is beside the Word of God, is against the1 Word of God; I say in Religious means, for there be means of Worship, or Circumstances Physicall, not Morall, not Religious, as whether the Pulpit be of stone or of timber, the Bell of this or this Mettall, the house of Worship stand thus or thus in Situation.
1What is beside the Word of God in Morals, is contrary to the Word of God.
Our Formalists will have it in the power of rulers to Command in the matter of Worship, that which is beside the Word of God, and so is negatively Lawful, though it be not Positively conform to Gods Word, nor Commanded or warranted by practice; which I grant is a witty way of Romes devising, to make entry for Religious humane Ceremonies.
Our Formalists will have it in the power of rulers to Command in the matter of Worship, that which is beside the Word of God, and so is negatively Lawfull, though it be not Positively conform to Gods Word, nor Commanded or warranted by practice; which I grant is a witty way of Romes devising, to make entry for Religious humane Ceremonies.
But 1. Whatever is not of Faith, and a sure persuasion, that what I do pleaseth God, is sin, Rom. 14. 14. 23. And therefore neither can be Commanded by Rulers, nor practiced by inferiors: But things besides Scripture, and negatively Lawful, are things not ⟨p. 110⟩of Faith; Ergo, The Assumption I Prove: 1. I doubt if Lord-will, be the Lord-carver, of what pleaseth God. 2. If it may stand with the wisdom of Christ the Law-giver; for no Ceremonies maketh Christ a perfect Law-giver: 3. In things doubtsome, abstinence is the surest side; Ergo; Rulers ought not to command them: 4. Samuel, David, even wicked Saul abstained in things doubtsome, while the Oracle of God removed the doubts, and answered him. 5. Paul in eating or not eating, which are things most indifferent, requireth a certain persuasion of positive assurance, Rom. 14. 14. I know, and am persuaded by the Lord Jesus, that there is nothing unclean of it self, but to him that esteemeth any thing to be unclean, it is unclean.
But 1. Whatever is not of Faith, and a sure perswasion, that what I do pleaseth God, is sin, Rom. 14. 14. 23. And therefore neither can be Commanded by Rulers, nor practiced by inferiours: But things besides Scripture, and negatively Lawfull, are things not ⟨p. 110⟩of Faith; Ergo, The Assumption I Prove: 1. I doubt if Lord-will, be the Lord-carver, of what pleaseth God. 2. If it may stand with the wisdom of Christ the Law-giver; for no Ceremonies maketh Christ a perfect Law-giver: 3. In things doubtsome, abstinence is the surest side; Ergo; Rulers ought not to command them: 4. Samuel, David, even wicked Saul abstained in things doubtsome, while the Oracle of God removed the doubts, and answered him. 5. Paul in eating or not eating, which are things most indifferent, requireth a certain perswasion of positive assurance, Rom. 14. 14. I know, and am perswaded by the Lord Iesus, that there is nothing unclean of it self, but to him that esteemeth any thing to be unclean, it is unclean.
aMaster Sanderson saith, In things substantial of Gods Worship, and in things to be done upon necessity of salvation, what is not of Faith; certainly assuring us it is conform positively to Gods word, it is sin, so we abhor Popish Additions: But in the actions of our life, as the lifting of a straw, and in Ceremonial worship, or accidentals, it holdeth not (saith bMorton, and Doctor Burges) not in all particulars (saith cPaybodie) for there should be no end (saith dDoct. Jackson) of doubting, for Papists might doubt to assist our King against Roman Catholics.
aMaster Sanderson saith, In things substantiall of Gods Worship, and in things to be done upon necessity of salvation, what is not of Faith; certainly assuring us it is conforme positively to Gods word, it is sin, so we abhor Popish Additions: But in the actions of our life, as the lifting of a straw, and in Ceremoniall worship, or accidentals, it holdeth not (saith bMorton, and Doctor Burges) not in all particulars (saith cPaybodie) for there should be no end (saith dDoct. Iackson) of doubting, for Papists might doubt to assist our King against Roman Catholicks.
aSanderson Sermo.
bMorton Burges Supra.
cPaybod. par. 2. S. 14. p. 45.
dD. Jackson on the Creed, l. 3. c▪ 7. p. 275.D. Iackson on the Creed, l. 3. c▪ 7. p. 275.
Ans. 1. Let Formalists explain themselves; Doctrinals, Substantials, and essential worship, is such as God hath commanded in the Proposition, and in the Assumption, and particularly in Gods word; Accidentals are such, as he hath commanded in general, but left particulars to mens will, so they define, like M•sters of Arts.
Ans. 1. Let Formalists explain themselves; Doctrinals, Substantials, and essentiall worship, is such as God hath commanded in the Proposition, and in the Assumption, and particularly in Gods word; Accidentals are such, as he hath commanded in generall, but left particulars to mens will, so they define, like M•sters of Arts.
But this our Masters say, in all that Christ hath particularly Commanded, his Testament is perfect, and so I believe, what God hath set down, he hath set down, and so we have Scripture right down as perfect as the Fables of Aesop, & Nasoes Metamorphosis: what is in Aesop's and Nasoes books, is in their books, and what they command you,1 are with certainty of Faith to believe they command, and what the Prophets and Apostles writ, that they writ, and that is essential worship; what they writ not, they writ not. 2. Mr. Sandersons lifting up a straw, is a straw for an instance; actions of imagination are not Moral, we give him leave to rub his beard without Faith, as he weareth white sheets above his garments in Divine service against Faith. 3. To do in Faith, is to know, that, in that I serve Christ, and ⟨p. 111⟩am accepted of God, Rom. 14. 2. To do that which condemneth me not, and maketh me happy in the doing thereof, v. 21. 3. It is a Faith that I have before God in my conscience, v. 2•. 4. It is a persuasion by the Lord Jesus, that it is clean. 5. It is such, as I know is positively Lawful by Scriptures express warrant, 1▪ Cor. 10. 26. The earth is the Lords and the fullness thereof; Ergo, I have certainty of faith, that it is positively conform to Scripture what I do: but in things negatively Lawful, as lifting a straw, wearing a Surplice, I have no persuasion by the Lord Jesus, that I serve Christ, and am accepted of God in so doing, and know not from Psa. 24. 1. or from any other scripture, that it is lawful what I do. 3. A general warrant is either when the major Proposition only is sure by Scripture, but you must take the Assumption upon the Formalists Merchant-word, or where both Proposition and assumption can endure, [Greek or Hebrew] according as it is written; this latter we embrace with both our hands, but Formalists deny it to us: The first is their meaning. This, what is decent and not contrary to Gods Word, that the Rulers may command: But Surplice, Crossing, &c. are decent and not contrary to Gods Word; Ergo. So one Giles Widows esaith▪ Man and Wife are one flesh: Ergo, the Ring in Marriage is good. And, Fine linen is the Righteousness of the Saints, Rev. 19. Ergo, a Surplice is good. And, Matth. 16. Take up your cross: Ergo, the Crossing in Baptism is lawful.
But this our Masters say, in all that Christ hath particularly Commanded, his Testament is perfect, and so I believe, what God hath set down, he hath set down, and so we have Scripture right down as perfect as the Fables of Esop, & Nasoes Metamorphosis: what is in Esopes and Nasoes books, is in their books, and what they command you,1 are with certainty of Faith to believe they command, and what the Prophets and Apostles writ, that they writ, and that is essentiall worship; what they writ not, they writ not. 2. Mr. Sandersons lifting up a straw, is a straw for an instance; actions of imagination are not Morall, we give him leave to ruh his beard without Faith, as he weareth white sheets above his garments in Divine service against Faith. 3. To do in Faith, is to know, that, in that I serve Christ, and ⟨p. 111⟩am accepted of God, Rom. 14. 2. To do that which condemneth me not, and maketh me happy in the doing thereof, v. 21. 3. It is a Faith that I have before God in my conscience, v. 2•. 4. It is a perswasion by the Lord Iesus, that it is clean. 5. It is such, as I know is positively Lawfull by Scriptures expresse warrant, 1▪ Cor. 10. 26. The earth is the Lords and the fulnesse thereof; Ergo, I have certainty of faith, that it is positively conform to Scripture what I do: but in things negatively Lawfull, as lifting a straw, wearing a Surplice, I have no perswasion by the Lord Iesus, that I serve Christ, and am accepted of God in so doing, and know not from Psa. 24. 1. or from any other scripture, that it is lawfull what I do. 3. A generall warrant is either when the major Proposition only is sure by Scripture, but you must take the Assumption upon the Formalists Merchant-word, or where both Proposition and assumption can indure, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 according as it is written; this latter wee imbrace with both our hands, but Formalists deny it to us: The first is their meaning. This, what is decent and not contrary to Gods Word, that the Rulers may command: But Surplice, Crossing, &c. are decent and not contrary to Gods Word; Ergo. So one Giles Widdows esaith▪ Man and Wife are one flesh: Ergo, the Ring in Marriage is good. And, Fine linnen is the Righteousnesse of the Saints,
1The vanity of the perfection of Scripture in essentials, not in accidentals.
eGiles Widows, in his lawless kneels PuritanGiles Widows, in his lawlesse kneelles Puritan
Enough of this▪ But so the worship of the Devil is lawful▪ and, Aaron's golden Calf is lawful; for I can find a major Proposition for them in Scripture, of which you have a Faith both Negative and Positive; as this, Whatever God 1commandeth in his Word, that is lawful: But God commandeth the Indians Devil worship in his Word: Ergo, &c. I am not holden to give my Faith for the Assumption: Yet it is as good as our Masters reasoning. 4. Jackson is wide in his lawful Negatives, for to fight against Roman Catholics, at our Kings Command, upon good grounds, is not an indifferent thing, Except to kill men, and shed blood, be indifferent and lawful Negatively: I thought, to make War, had been amongst the Substantials, and Positively conform to Gods Word. 5. The Fathers, as Origen, Ambrose, Chrysostom, Theophylact, Oecumenius, Theodoret, Anselm and Jerome, upon the place Rom. 14. 23. as Vasquez saith ffrom this place, Rom: 14▪ 23. that What any doth, must be warranted by the light of the conscience as lawful. ⟨p. 121⟩If Formalist; stand to this, they must give us some things against conscience, and something beside conscience, that is morally lawful, and therefore if conscience see not such a thing against Scripture, though it have no warrant in Scripture, yet it is lawful, and done in a certain persuasion of a well informed conscience; but these who eat things thought to be unclean by Gods Law, to the scandal of others, who knew these meats were not against Piety and Gods Law, nor yet that the eating of them was against charity, while Paul delivered the Doctrine of Scandal, yet their eating was unlawful. 6. Formalists say nothing here, but what Papists said before them, they say, Men may go to War, doubting of the lawfulness thereof; and therefore hVasquez, iAngelus, kCorduba, and lNavarre. will us, While the doubt remaineth, to choose the surest side, as conscience ought to do: And mVasquez saith, Manente dubio, &c. To do so long as the doubt remaineth, is to do against the judgement of conscience: And nAdrianus saith, While they doubt, and yet go to War, they expose themselves to the danger of Man-slaughter, and by not going to War, they should only sin by not obeying. oSuarez saith, It is a speculative doubt, when Superiors commandeth it: And pSylvester saith, Such a doubt should be expelled at the commandment of Superiors.
Enough of this▪ But so the worship of the Devil is lawfull▪ and, Aarons golden Calf is lawfull; for I can finde a major Proposition for them in Scripture, of which you have a Faith both Negative and Positive; as this, Whatever God 1commandeth in his Word, that is lawfull: But God commandeth the Indians Devil vvorship in his Word: Ergo, &c. I am not holden to give my Faith for the Assumption: Yet it is as good as our Masters reasoning. 4. Jackson is wide in his lawfull Negatives, for to fight against Roman Catholicks, at our Kings Command, upon good grounds, is not an indifferent thing, Except to kill men, and shed blood, be indifferent and lawfull Negatively: I thought, to make War, had been amongst the Substantials, and Positively conform to Gods Word. 5. The Fathers, as Origen, Ambrose, Chrysostom, Theophylact, Oecumenius, Theodoret, Anselm and Ierome, upon the place Rom. 14. 23. as Vasquez saith ffrom this place, Rom: 14▪ 23. that What any doth, must be warranted by the light of the conscience as lawfull. ⟨p. 121⟩If Formalist; stand to this, they must give us some things against conscience, and something beside conscience, that is morally lawfull, and therefore if conscience see not such a thing against Scripture, though it have no warrant in Scripture, yet it is lawfull, and done in a certain perswasion of a well informed conscience; but these who eat things thought to be unclean by Gods Law, to the scandall of others, who knew these meats were not against Piety and Gods Lavv, nor yet that the eating of them was against charity, while Paul delivered the Doctrine of Scandall, yet their eating was unlawfull. 6. Formalists say nothing here, but what Papists said before them, they say, Men may go to War, doubting of the lawfulnesse thereof; and therefore hVasquez, iAngelus, kCorduba, and lNavarr. will us, While the doubt remaineth, to choose the surest side, as conscience ought to do: And
1(g) Bannes to. 3. 22. q. 1. art. 1. Omne quod non est ex fide, idest, quod fit contra propriam conscienti•• est peccatum.
fVasquez to. 1. 12. dis. 59. q. 19. Art 6. c. 2.
hVasquez to. 1. disp. 65. c. 1.
iAngelus verbo Dubium c. 1.
kCorduba l. 3. q. 4.
lNavir. in cap. de Penitentia dub. 7. n. 8.
mVasquez to. 1. disp. 66. cap. 9. Nec subditus dubius de justitia belli potest parere, quamdiu dubius manet.
nAdrianus in quod libet, punct. 2. ad art. 2. Milites dubii cligerent sic partem dubiam & expo•erent see periculo injuste occidendi et praedandi non eundo tantum pecearent non obediendo.Adrianus in quod libet, punct. 2. ad art. 2. Milites dubii cligerent sic partem dubiam & expo•erent se periculo injuste occidendi et praedandi non eundo tantum pecearent non obediendo.
And no marvel the command of Superiors to Papists is an Oracle, and blind obedience is good meriting; therefore qGratian and the Jesuit rSanches saith, Inferiors are not holden to examine the commandments of Superiors.
And no marvell the command of Superiors to Papists is an Oracle, and blinde obedience is good meriting; therefore qGratian and the Iesuit rSanches saith, Inferiors are not holden to examine the commandments of Superiors.
5. Jackson saith, This (Whatsoever is not of Faith is Sin) holdeth in omission of good, as in commission of evil: Ergo, Your not practising 1indifferent Ceremonies, is not of Faith, and so Sin. Ans. He that obeyeth doubtingly, is condemned, and he that obeyeth not doubtingly, is condemned; But, Master Doctor, your enumeration is not sufficient, and may strike against doubting to worship a Romish Idol, at the command of Superiors; for I show you a third, and ⟨p. 113⟩its Pauls way, Eat not, obey not, and abstain with persuasion of Faith, that what you do is agreeable Positively to Gods Word.
5. Iackson saith, This (Whatsoever is not of Faith is Sin) holdeth in omission of good, as in commission of evil: Ergo, Your not practising 1indifferent Ceremonies, is not of Faith, and so Sin. Ans. He that obeyeth doubtingly, is condemned, and he that obeyeth not doubtingly, is condemned; But, Master Doctor, your enumeration is not sufficient, and may strike against doubting to worship a Romish Idol, at the command of Superiors; for I shew you a third, and ⟨p. 113⟩its Pauls way, Eat not, obey not, and abstain with perswasion of Faith, that what you do is agreeable Positively to Gods Word.
Jackson saith, They sin, not by doubting, if the fear of evil after mature deliberation, be not extraordinary, and such as cannot be recompensed by the goodness which appeareth in the act of Obedience. Doubting is no internal part or essential cause of sin, we sin not because we doubt, but because while we doubt, we prefer an evil, or a less good, before a good, or a greater good. So their sin was not doubting, but they preferred not eating, which was a bodily loss only, to the evil feared, which was to be partakers of the Table of Devils, and being Apostates from the Israel of God. Ans. Paul expressly saith, doubting is sin, and condemneth it ver. 23. and requireth, ver. 5. Let every man be persuaded in his conscience, v. 21. Happy is he that condemneth not himself in that which he alloweth, v. 23. Whatsoever (more or less in Moral actions) is not of Faith, is sin: 2. Internal persuasion, Rom. 14. 14. Is an internal cause of obedience, as v. 21. And therefore doubting being a sin that condemneth, Rom. 14. 23. must be such a sinful ingredient, as maketh the action sinful. 3. We both sin, because we doubt, and also because we prefer a less1 good, or an evil to a greater good. 4. No feared evil, though never so evil, whether of sin or punishment if it follow not kindly, but only by accident, and through the corruption of our nature, should or can make us do any thing doubtingly or sinfully, for then we might do evil, that good might come of it: No good of obedience can warrant me to sin, and disobey God, nor should that be called obedience, nor is it obedience to men, which is disobedience to God. 5. It is an untruth that non-eating was only a bodily loss, for non-eating Physical, is a bodily loss, but Paul urgeth non-eating moral, to eschew the fall of one for whom Christ died. 6. The Doctor saith Ibidem. No power under the Heaven could make a Law over the Romans, enjoining such meats, because Gods law (as they conceive) condemned them. Now how pleasant are right words? I assume, we conceive God hath denounced all the plagues written in his Book, upon practisers of humane Ceremonies, as upon adders to the word of God, Rev. 22. 19. Yea Heresies, to with, that Christ is not the consubstantial Son of God, may seem probable to us; shall the good of obedience in believing my Pastor, whom God hath set over me, hinder me to obey? 7.
Jackson saith, They sin, not by doubting, if the fear of evil after mature deliberation, be not extraordinary, and such as cannot be recompenced by the goodnes which appeareth in the act of Obedience. Doubting is no internall part or essentiall cause of sin, vve sin not because vve doubt, but because vvhile vve doubt, vve prefer an evil, or a lesse good, before a good, or a greater good. So their sin vvas not doubting, but they preferred not eating, vvhich vvas a bodily losse onely, to the evil feared, vvhich vvas to be partakers of the Table of Devils, and being Apostates from the Israel of God. Ans. Paul expresly saith, doubting is sin, and condemneth it ver. 23. and requireth, ver. 5. Let every man be perswaded in his conscience, v. 21. Happy is he that condemneth not himself in that which he alloweth, v. 23. Whatsoever (more or lesse in Morall actions) is not of Faith, is sin: 2. Internall perswasion, Rom. 14. 14. Is an internall cause of obedience, as v. 21. And therefore doubting being a sin that condemneth, Rom. 14. 23. must be such a sinfull ingredient, as maketh the action sinfull. 3. We both sin, because we doubt, and also because we prefer a lesse1 good, or an evil to a greater good. 4. No feared evil, though never so evil, whether of sin or punishment if it follow not kindly, but only by accident, and through the corruption of our nature, should or can make us do any thing doubtingly or sinfully, for then we might do evil, that good might come of it: No good of obedience can warrant me to sin, and disobey God, nor should that be called obedience, nor is it obedience to men, which is disobedience to God. 5. It is an untruth that non-eating was only a bodily losse, for non-eating Physicall, is a bodily losse, but Paul urgeth non-eating morall, to eschew the fall of one for whom Christ died. 6. The Doctor saith Ibidem. No power under the Heaven could make a Law over the Romans, injoyning such meats, because Gods law (as they conceive) condemned them. Now how pleasant are right words? I assume, we conceive God hath denounced all the plagues written in his Book, upon practisers of humane Ceremonies, as upon adders to the word of God, Rev. 22. 19. Yea Heresies, to with, that Christ is not the consubstantiall Son of God, may seem probable to us; shall the good of obedience in believing my Pastor, whom God hath set over me, hinder me to obey? 7.
Papists say also, that Scripture is ⟨p. 114⟩perfect in general, allowing that Ceremonies should be, when1 Paul saith, Let all things be done in order and decency, 1 Cor. 14. But the Scripture giveth no particular warrant for these, but only the Churches determination. So wScotus, xSuarez, yBellarmine zVasquez aBannes, band Duvallius. The Scripture implicitly, and generally containeth all the substantials necessary for salvation, but not traditions in particular, that is the Churches part, just as Formalists say, order and decency is commanded in the word, but Crossing, Surplice, Humane days and such are left to the Prelates Calendar, to fill up what his Lordship thinketh good. So Hooker (c) Speech is necessary, but it is not necessary that all speak one kind of Language, Government is necessary, but the particulars, Surplice, Crossing, &c. Are left to the Church.
Papists say also, that Scripture is ⟨p. 114⟩perfect in generall, allowing that Ceremonies should be, when1 Paul saith, Let all things be done in order and decency, 1 Cor. 14. But the Scripture giveth no particular warrant for these, but onely the Churches determination. So wScotus, xSuarez, yBellarmine zVasquez aBannes, band Duvallius. The Scripture implicitely, and generally containeth all the substantials necessary for salvation, but not traditions in particular, that is the Churches part, just as Formalists say, order and decency is commanded in the word, but Crossing, Surplice, Humane dayes and such are left to the Prelates Kalender, to fill up what his Lordship thinketh good. So Hooker (c) Speech is necessary, but it is not necessary that all speak one kinde of Language, Government is necessary, but the particulars, Surplice, Crossing, &c. Are left to the Church.
1Papists say the Srcipture in general is perfect, but not in particulars of worship, and so say Formalists.Papists say the Srcipture in generall is perfect, but not in particulars of worship, and so say Formalists.
wScotus, Prologue. in senten. q. 3. ad art. 3. Terminus praefixus [Theologiae] quantum ad revelationem▪ Divinam est •orum qu••u•• in•sadra Scriptura, sicut habetur ult. Apocalyps. Si quis •pposucrit ad ista, apponet ei Deus plagas quae contine••ur in Scriptura, & que possunt clici de ipsisScotus, Prolog. in senten. q. 3. ad art. 3. Terminus praefixus [Theologiae] quantum ad revelationem▪ Divinam est •orum qu••u•• in•sadra Scriptura, sicut habetur ult. Apocalyps. Si quis •pposucrit ad ista, apponet ei Deus plagas quae contine••ur in Scriptura, & que possunt clici de ipsis
xSuarez de tripl. virt. Theolog. Tract. 1. disp. 5. Sect. 4. Ad perfectionem non est, quod omnia credenda contineat explicite, satis est enim quod contineat mysteria nostrae redemptionis, & substantialia fundamenta Ecclesiae, cum mediis necessarijs ad salutem.
yBellar. de Effec. Sacrament. cap▪ 32. respons. ad Arg. 2. Christus ad plenum nos instruxit (in Scriptura) de ucro Dei cultu. Bellar. Respondet, id verum est de instructione generali, non autem de particulari.Bellar. de Effec. Sacrament. cap▪ 32. respons. ad Arg. 2. Christus ad plenum nos instruxit (in Scriptura) de vcro Dei cultu. Bellar. Respondet, id verum est de instructione generali, non autem de particulari.
2. What is negatively Lawful here, cannot be admitted; If1 Rulers may Command one thing that is negatively Lawful, they may Command all things; because what they Command under this formal reason, as not against Scripture, they should not add nor devise new worship, though they Command all of that kind: But the latter is absurd, for so they might Command in Gods worship. 1. The actions of sole imagination, the lifting of a straw, and all idle actions that cannot edify. 2. They might Command a new Ark to represent Christ incarnate, as the Jews Ark did represent him to be incarnate, a new Passover, to represent the Lamb already slain, and all the materials of the Ceremonial Law ⟨p. 115⟩with reference to Christ already incarnate, dead, and risen again: For all these are by Formalists Learning negatively Lawful; Show us a Scripture where they are forbidden, more then Surplice, Crossing, except because they be not Commanded. If it be said, They do not Command things negatively Lawful, as such, but as they edify and teach: Well then, 1. As they edify and teach, they are positively good, and apt to edify, and so must be proved by the Word as Commanded, and so not negatively Lawful, and not as beside, but as Commanded in the Word. 2. Yet it will follow, that all these may be used in Faith, that is, out of a sure persuasion that they are not contrary to Gods Word, and so Lawful. I might dance in a new linen Ephod, before a new Jewish Ark, representing Christ already incarnate, and that in the negative Faith of Mr. Sanderson, Hooker, and Jackson, for this Ark is not against Scripture, yet this Ark is not Commanded, and so not forbidden. 3. Idle actions that have no use or end, might be Lawfully Commanded by this, because they are not forbidden, yet are such unlawful, Quia carent justâ necessitate et utilitate, as Gregorius saith: I prove the connection, because an action Moral, such as (to Sign with the Cross) performed by a Subject of Christs visible Kingdom, for Gods glory and edification of the Church, which yet is neither Commanded nor forbidden by God, nor Commanded by natures light (for none but those that are beside reason will say this) nor light of Gods word, or the habit of Religion, hath no more reason, then the making or forming a Syllogism in Barbara, which of it self cometh only from Art;
2. What is negatively Lawfull here, cannot be admitted; If1 Rulers may Command one thing that is negatively Lawfull, they may Command all things; because what they Command under this formall reason, as not against Scripture, they should not adde nor devise new worship, though they Command all of that kinde: But the latter is absurd, for so they might Command in Gods worship. 1. The actions of sole imagination, the lifting of a straw, and all idle actions that cannot edifie. 2. They might Command a new Ark to represent Christ incarnat, as the Jews Ark did represent him to be incarnat, a new Passeover, to represent the Lambe already slain, and all the materials of the Ceremoniall Law ⟨p. 115⟩with reference to Christ already incarnat, dead, and risen again: For all these are by Formalists Learning negatively Lawfull; Shew us a Scripture where they are forbidden, more then Surplice, Crossing, except because they be not Commanded. If it be said, They do not Command things negatively Lawfull, as such, but as they edifie and teach: Well then, 1. As they edifie and teach, they are positively good, and apt to edifie, and so must be proved by the Word as Commanded, and so not negatively Lawfull, and not as beside, but as Commanded in the Word. 2. Yet it will follow, that all these may be used in Faith, that is, out of a sure perswasion that they are not contrary to Gods Word, and so Lawfull. I might dance in a new linnen Ephod, before a new Iewish Ark, representing Christ already incarnat, and that in the negative Faith of Mr. Sanderson, Hooker, and Jackson, for this Ark is not against Scripture, yet this Ark is not Commanded, and so not forbidden. 3. Idle actions that have no use or end, might be Lawfully Commanded by this, because they are not forbidden, yet are such unlawfull, Quia carent justâ necessitate et utilitate, as Gregorius saith: I prove the connexion, because an action Morall, such as (to Sign with the Crosse) performed by a Subject of Christs visible Kingdom, for Gods glory and edification of the Church, which yet is neither Commanded nor forbidden by God, nor Commanded by natures light (for none but those that are beside reason will say this) nor light of Gods word, or the habit of Religion, hath no more reason, then the making or forming a Syllogisme in Barbara, which of it self cometh only from Art;
1What is only negative in Gods worship, cannot be commanded.
and as such hath no Moral use, and by as good reason may the Church Command dancing before a new devised Ark; yea, such an action involveth a contradiction, and is Moral, and not Moral: for of its own nature it tendeth to no edification, for then it might be proved by good reason to be edificative, and an action cannot be edificative from the will of men, for Gods will, not mens will▪ giveth being to things.
and as such hath no Morall use, and by as good reason may the Church Command dancing before a new devised Ark; yea, such an action involveth a contradiction, and is Morall, and not Morall: for of its own nature it tendeth to no edification, for then it might be proved by good reason to be edificative, and an action cannot be edificative from the will of men, for Gods will, not mens will▪ giveth being to things.
4. What is beside Scripture, as a thing not repugnant thereunto, wanteth that by which every thing is essentially Lawful: Ergo, It is not Lawful. The Consequence is sure, I prove the Antecedent: Gods Commanding will, doth essentially constitute a thing Lawful, Gods Commanding will only maketh eating and drinking bread and wine in the Lords Supper Lawful, and the Lords forbidding ⟨p. 116⟩will should make it unlawful; and Gods forbidding to eat of the Fruit of the Tree of knowledge of good and evil, maketh the non-eating obedience, and the eating disobedience. As the killing of Isaac by Abraham, is Lawful, and that because God Commandeth it; and the not killing of him, again is Lawful, when God forbiddeth it. But things negatively Lawful and beside the word of God, wanteth Gods Commanding will; for God Commandeth not the materials of Jewish Ceremonies to represent Christ already come, and such like: for if he should Command them, they should be according to the word of God, and not beside the word of God: If it be said they have Gods Commanding will, in so far that he doth not forbid any thing not contrary to his own word; but hath given the Church Authority to add to his worship, things not contrary to his word, as they shall see they do promove godliness, or may edify the Church: But then if the Church must see by the light of reason, and natural judgement, aptitude in these to promove godliness, they are Commanded by God, who hath even stamped in them that aptitude to edify, and so are not beside Gods word. 4. Our Divines condemn all the Traditions of the Church of Rome; as Purgatory, Prayer for the dead, Imagery, Adoring of Relics, all the Crossing, Holy water, Chrism, Oil, Babies, Bells, Beads, &c. Because God hath no where Commanded them, and sins venial and beside the Law, and sins mortal and contrary to the Law, we condemn; because, as what is capable of seeing, and life,1 and hearing, and yet doth not see, live, nor hear, that in good reason we call blind, dead, and deaf; all beside the word are capable of Moral goodness, and yet not Morally good, because not warranted by Gods word, therefore they must be Morally evil.
4. What is beside Scripture, as a thing not repugnant thereunto, wanteth that by which every thing is essentially Lawfull: Ergo, It is not Lawfull. The Consequence is sure, I prove the Antecedent: Gods Commanding will, doth essentially constitute a thing Lawfull, Gods Commanding will only maketh eating and drinking bread and wine in the Lords Supper Lawfull, and the Lords forbidding ⟨p. 116⟩will should make it unlawfull; and Gods forbidding to eat of the Fruit of the Tree of knowledge of good and evil, maketh the non-eating obedience, and the eating disobedience. As the killing of Isaac by Abraham, is Lawfull, and that because God Commandeth it; and the not killing of him, again is Lawfull, when God forbiddeth it. But things negatively Lawfull and beside the word of God, wanteth Gods Commanding will; for God Commandeth not the materials of Jewish Ceremonies to represent Christ already come, and such like: for if he should Command them, they should be according to the word of God, and not beside the word of God: If it be said they have Gods Commanding will, in so far that he doth not forbid any thing not contrary to his own word; but hath given the Church Authority to adde to his worship, things not contrary to his word, as they shall see they do promove godlinesse, or may edifie the Church: But then if the Church must see by the light of reason, and naturall judgement, aptitude in these to promove godlinesse, they are Commanded by God, who hath even stamped in them that aptitude to edifie, and so are not beside Gods word. 4. Our Divines condemne all the Traditions of the Church of Rome; as Purgatory, Prayer for the dead, Imagery, Adoring of Reliques, all the Crossing, Holy water, Chrisme, Oyl, Babies, Bells, Beads, &c. Because God hath no where Commanded them, and sins veniall and beside the Law, and sins mortall and contrary to the Law, we condemne; because, as what is capable of seeing, and life,1 and hearing, and yet doth not see, live, nor hear, that in good reason we call blinde, dead, and deaf; all beside the word are capable of Morall goodnesse, and yet not Morally good, because not warranted by Gods word, therefore they must be Morally evil.
1Opinion of sanctity & Divine necessity, not essential to false worship.Opinion of sanctity & Divine necessity, not essentiall to false worship.
III. Conclus. Opinion of Sanctity, holiness and Divine necessity, is not essential to false worship. Formalists will have their Ceremonies innocent and Lawful, so they be not contrary to the word of God. 2. So they be not instamped with an opinion that they bind the Conscience, and are of Divine necessity, holiness and efficacy; So aMorton their Prelate, for opinion of justice, necessity, efficacy and merit, (saith he) make them Doctrinals and so unlawful: But this is but that which Papists say: So Suarez bsaith, That their ⟨p. 117⟩unwritten Traditions are not added to the word of God, as parts of the word of God; but as things to be believed and observed by the Churches Commandment; and these who did swear by Jehovah and Malcom, Zeph. 1. esteemed Malcom, and an oath by Malcom, not so Religiously and so holy, as an oath by Jehovah and Malcom; and yet no doubt, they ascribed some necessity to oaths by Malcom and Jehoram saying, (Am I Jehovah to kill and make alive) who yet worshipped Jeroboam's Calves, esteemed the worshipping of these Calves less necessary, and less holy and meritorious, then the worshipping of the true Jehovah; yet the Calves called their gods, which brought them out of the Land of Egypt, had some necessity and opinion of holiness.
III. Conclus. Opinion of Sanctity, holinesse and Divine necessity, is not essentiall to false worship. Formalists will have their Ceremonies innocent and Lawfull, so they be not contrary to the word of God. 2. So they be not instamped with an opinion that they binde the Conscience, and are of Divine necessity, holinesse and efficacy; So aMorton their Prelat, for opinion of justice, necessity, efficacy and merit, (saith he) make them Doctrinals and so unlawfull: But this is but that which Papists say: So Suarez bsaith, That their ⟨p. 117⟩unwritten Traditions are not added to the word of God, as parts of the word of God; but as things to be believed and observed by the Churches Commandment; and these who did swear by Jehovah and Malcom, Zeph. 1. esteemed Malcom, and an oath by Malcom, not so Religiously and so holy, as an oath by Jehovah and Malcom; and yet no doubt, they ascribed some necessity to oaths by Malcom and Jehoram saying, (Am I Jehovah to kill and make alive) who yet worshipped Ieroboams Calves, esteemed the worshipping of these Calves lesse necessary, and lesse holy and meritorious, then the worshipping of the true Yehovah; yet the Calves called their gods, which brought them out of the Land of Aegypt, had some necessity and opinion of holinesse.
aMorton, Innocency of ceremonies general defence c. 1. S. 15.Morton, Innocency of ceremonies generall defense c. 1. S. 15.
bSuarcz, to. de trip. vi•t. theol. tract. 1. dis. 5. S. 4. Haec vero & similia (traditionalia non scripta) non adduntur scripturis ut fiant qua•i partes •jus (quod potest etiam censeri prohibitum) sed adduntur ut cr•denda & servanda.
For 1. Aaron in making a Calf, and Proclaiming a Feast to the Calf, committed false worship; but Aaron placed not holiness, justice, or merit in that worship: Because, Exod. 32. 22. for fear of the people who in a tumult gathered themselves together against him, he committed that Idolatry; Ergo, necessity of Sanctity, Merit, and Divine obligation, is not essential to false worship: Jeroboam Committed Idolatry in saying, These are thy Gods O Israel; but he placed no efficacy or merit therein, because, 1 King. 12. 27. He did it, least the people going to Jerusalem, should return to Rehoboam, and kill him; And the Philistines dis-worship in handling the Ark unreverently, had no such opinion, they doubting whither God or Fortune ruled the Ark, 1 Sam. 6. 9. It were strange if these who say in their heart, There is no God, Ezech. 9. 9. Psal. 94. 6. And so fail against inward worship due to God, should think that the denying of God were service and meritorious service to God; and that Peter denying Christ, and Judaizing, Gal. 2. 12. for fear, thought and believed he did meritorious service to Christ therein: Pilate in condemning Christ; Judas in selling him; the Soldiers in scourging him, did dis-worship to their Creator, the Lord of glory: Shall we think that Pilate, who for fear of the people did this▪ believed he was performing necessary, Divine and Meritorious worship to God? 2. If opinion of necessity Divine, of Merit and sanctity, as touching the conscience, were essential to false worship; it were impossible for gain and glory, to Commit Idolatry, to preach lies in the Name of the Lord for a handful of barley, as Ezek. 13. 19. Mic. 3. 5. 1 Kin. 22. 6. 1 Tim. 4▪1, 2. Tit. 1. 11. For its a contradiction to ⟨p. 118⟩Preach Arianism, Turkism, Popery, against the light of the mind only for gain; and yet to think that in so doing, they be performing meritorious service to God: Yea, they who devise will-worship, know their own will to be the Lord-carver of that worship, at least they may know it; yet shall we think they hold themselves necessitated, by a Religious obligation so to do? Else it were impossible, that men could believe the burning their Children were will-worship, indifferent and Arbitrary to the worshippers, which is open war against reason: Now a worship cannot be false, wanting that which is essential to false worship. 3.
For 1. Aaron in making a Calf, and Proclaiming a Feast to the Calf, committed false worship; but Aaron placed not holinesse, justice, or merit in that worship: Because, Exod. 32. 22. for fear of the people who in a tumult gathered themselves together against him, he committed that Idolatry; Ergo, necessity of Sanctity, Merit, and Divine obligation, is not essentiall to false worship: Ieroboam Committed Idolatry in saying, These are thy Gods O Israel; but he placed no efficacy or merit therein, because, 1 King. 12. 27. He did it, least the people going to Ierusalem, should return to Rehoboam, and kill him; And the Philistims dis-worship in handling the Ark unreverently, had no such opinion, they doubting whither God or Fortune ruled the Ark, 1 Sam. 6. 9. It were strange if these who say in their heart, There is no God, Ezech. 9. 9. Psal. 94. 6. And so fail against inward worship due to God, should think that the denying of God were service and meritorious service to God; and that Peter denying Christ, and Iudaizing, Gal. 2. 12. for fear, thought and believed he did meritorious service to Christ therein: Pilate in condemning Christ; Iudas in selling him; the Souldiers in scourging him, did dis-worship to their Creator, the Lord of glory: Shall we think that Pilate, who for fear of the people did this▪ believed he was performing necessary, Divine and Meritorious worship to God? 2. If opinion of necessity Divine, of Merit and sanctity, as touching the conscience, were essentiall to false worship; it were impossible for gain and glory, to Commit Idolatry, to preach lies in the Name of the Lord for a handfull of barley, as Ezek. 13. 19. Mic. 3. 5. 1 Kin. 22. 6. 1 Tim. 4▪1, 2. Tit. 1. 11. For its a contradiction to ⟨p. 118⟩
False worship is false worship by order of nature, before we have any opinion, either that there is Religious necessity in it, or mere indifferency: Ergo, Such an opinion is not of the essence of false worship. 4. By that same reason, opinion of unjustice, or opinion of doing justice, should be of the essence of unjustice; Cains killing of his Brother, should not be Man-slaughter, except Cain placed some divine Sanctity in that wicked fact, which is against all reason; and the reason is alike in both Gods Commanding will and his forbidding will. They Answer, Gods will constituteth Lawfulness in essential worship, and mans will in things arbitrary; but this is to beg the question, for when we ask what is essential worship, they say, it is that which God commandeth, and what is accidental or arbitrary, it is that which human authority commandeth, & this is just, Gods will is the essential cause of that worship whereof it is the essential cause, & mans will is the essential cause of that, whereof it is the essential cause. 5. All the materials of Jewish and Turkish worship, might be appointed for right worship, so we held them to be Arbitrary. 6. God cannot forbid false worship, but in that tenure, that he commandeth true worship; but whether we esteem it true, or not, holy, or not; he commandeth true worship, Erg. &c.
False worship is false worship by order of nature, before we have any opinion, either that there is Religious necessity in it, or meer indifferency: Ergo, Such an opinion is not of the essence of false worship. 4. By that same reason, opinion of unjustice, or opinion of doing justice, should be of the essence of unjustice; Cains killing of his Brother, should not be Man-slaughter, except Cain placed some divine Sanctity in that wicked fact, which is against all reason; and the reason is alike in both Gods Commanding will and his forbidding will. They Answer, Gods will constituteth Lawfulnesse in essentiall worship, and mans will in things arbitrary; but this is to beg the question, for when we ask what is essentiall worship, they say, it is that which God commandeth, and what is accidental or arbitrary, it is that which human authority commandeth, & this is just, Gods wil is the essentiall cause of that worship whereof it is the essentiall cause, & mans will is the essentiall cause of that, whereof it is the essentiall cause. 5. All the materials of Jewish and Turkish worship, might be appointed for right worship, so we held them to be Arbitrary. 6. God cannot forbid false worship, but in that tenure, that he commandeth true worship; but whether we esteem it true, or not, holy, or not; he cōmandeth true worship, Erg. &c.
IV. Conclusion, It is a vain and unwarrantable distinction to divide 1worship in essential, which hath Gods; 1. Particular approving will to be the Warrant thereof, and worship accidental or Arbitrary, which hath only Gods general and permissive will, and hath mans will for its father; so Ceremonies (say they) In these, hath Gods general will, according to their specification, whether a Surplice be decent, or not, is from mans will, therefore they are called worship reductively, because in their particulars, they have no Divine institution, and they tend to the honouring of God, not as worship, but as ⟨p. 119⟩adjuncts of worship; so aMorton; so bBurges.
IV. Conclusion, It is a vain and unwarrantable distinction to divide 1worship in essentiall, which hath Gods; 1. Particular approving will to be the Warrant thereof, and worship accidentall or Arbitrary, which hath only Gods generall and permissive will, and hath mans will for its father; so Ceremonies (say they) In these, hath Gods generall will, according to their specification, whether a Surplice be decent, or not, is from mans will, therefore they are called worship reductively, because in their particulars, they have no Divine institution, and they tend to the honouring of God, not as worship, but as ⟨p. 119⟩adjuncts of worship; so aMorton; so bBurges.
1The distinction of worship essential and accidental of Gods general and particular will is to be rejected.The distinction of worship essentiall and accidentall of Gods generall and particular will is to be rejected.
Ans. As Sacramental worship is lawful essential worship, so that this element, bread and wine, and this water is not Arbitrary; Ergo, If decency be of divine institution, and Gods approving will, then that Surplice or Crossing, or not Surplice and Crossing be decent, is not Arbitrary, and only from Gods permitting will: If the general must be warranted by the word, so also specials under the general, else mens will may make a horned Bullock a decent Sacrifice to represent Christ already come in the f••sh; for if the written word warrant not the specials of Religious observances, a door is open for all humane inventions: The uniting of these two (The Crossing of the finger in the Air above a child's face) and (the dedication of the child to Christs service) are every way like to the uniting, Of Bread and Wine eaten and drunken, and the souls nourishing by Christ crucified and apprehended by Faith: If there be odds, it is in the Authority of the institutors: Our Formalists say, the one is essential, because ordained by Christ, and so bindeth the conscience, and the other Arbitrary, accidental and of less authority: We owe them thanks indeed, the sin is the greater that the Authority is the less, but the external worship is alike. There be odds betwixt the kissing of a wife by a stranger, and the kissing by her own husband, and odds betwixt an act of Royal Majesty performed by the King, and that same Act performed by a Traitor feigning the same Act, as there be odds betwixt money stricken by a Tinker, and by the Kings master of Coin; will this distinction serve the whorish woman, the kisses of a strange man be Arbitrary, indifferent and accidental: but the kisses of my own husband be essential and kindly. And the Tinker might save his head for his false coin, the Kings money is essentially Legal and currant, but money stricken by me, is Arbitrary and of less Authority, then the Kings Lawful Coin. 2. If it be necessary and good to honour God by decency and order, the particular goodness and holiness of Surplice and Crossing is also good and holy. But God hath particularly, Micah 6. 8. Showed thee what is good O man; Ergo, he hath also showed what is particularly holy. But God hath not showed us in his Word any goodness in Crossing, Surplice, because they are of mans devising:
Ans. As Sacramentall worship is lawfull essentiall worship, so that this element, bread and wine, and this water is not Arbitrary; Ergo, If decency be of divine institution, and Gods approving will, then that Surplice or Crossing, or not Surplice and Crossing be decent, is not Arbitrary, and only from Gods permitting will: If the generall must be warranted by the word, so also specials under the generall, else mens will may make a horned Bullock a decent Sacrifice to represent Christ already come in the f••sh; for if the written word warrant not the specials of Religious observances, a door is open for all humane inventions: The uniting of these two (The Crossing of the finger in the Air above a childes face) and (the dedication of the childe to Christs service) are every way like to the uniting, Of Bread and Wine eaten and drunken, and the souls nourishing by Christ crucified and apprehended by Faith: If there be oddes, it is in the Authority of the institutors: Our Formalists say, the one is essentiall, because ordained by Christ, and so bindeth the conscience, and the other Arbitrary, accidentall and of lesse authority: We owe them thanks indeed, the sin is the greater that the Authority is the lesse, but the externall worship is alike. There be oddes betwixt the kissing of a wife by a stranger, and the kissing by her own husband, and oddes betwixt an act of Royall Majesty performed by the King, and that same Act performed by a Traitor faining the same Act, as there be oddes betwixt money stroken by a Tinker, and by the Kings master of Coyne; will this distinction serve the whorish woman, the kisses of a strange man be Arbitrary, indifferent and accidentall: but the kisses of my own husband be essentiall and kindely. And the Tinker might save his head for his false coyne, the Kings money is essentially Legall and currant, but money stroken by me, is Arbitrary and of lesse Authority, then the Kings Lawfull Coyn. 2. If it be necessary and good to honour God by decency and order, the particular goodnesse and holynesse of Surplice and Crossing is also good and holy. But God hath particularly, Micah 6. 8. Shewed thee what is good O man; Ergo, he hath also shewed what is particularly holy. But God hath not shewed us in his Word any goodnesse in Crossing, Surplice, because they are of mans devising:
If it be said, the particular goodness of Surplice and Crossing is good and showed to us in the general. I Answer, ⟨p. 120⟩goodness of indifferent Rites, is, Repugnantia in adjecto, and a flat contradiction, as who would say, cold fire, indifferent is neither good nor evil, neither Lawful, nor unlawful: 2. Then God hath not showed us all Moral goodness in his word, because he hath not showed to us the goodness of Ceremonies. 3. Lawfulness is an essential property of Divine worship resulting from Gods particular approving will in his word, as is clear, Hosea 8. 5. 1 Chro. 15. 13. Lev. 10. 1. 2 Sam. 7. 7. Jer. 7. 30. Act. 15. 24. Ergo, Arbitrary worship must have Gods approving will, commanding it, else it is not Lawful: I prove the Antecedent from the causes of worship: 1. The end of worship, which is the honouring of God maketh not worship Lawful; Idolaters may intend to honour God in their Idolatry, as well as true worshippers. 2. The matter of worship is not essential to Lawful worship, for Lawful and unlawful worship may have the same common matter, as Solomons Calves in the Temple were lawful, because ordained of God, and Samaria's Calves were unlawful, because they were from men, the matter of both might be one and the same metal, Hosea 8. 3. The Form of worship in general, is not the essential and specifice Form of Lawful worship, as the specifice Form of a living creature is not the specifice form of a man, the specifice form of a man is not the specifice form of a just man, as just. Also I may conceive Sacramental eating in general, and not conceive whether it be Lawful or unlawful: For if Lawfulness were the specifice form of worship, I could not conceive worship, but I behooved to conceive Lawfulness in it. Now then Gods commanding will, being wanting to Arbitrary worship, it cannot be Lawful; Ergo, unlawful. If it be answered, Ceremonies are negatively lawful, not positively lawful, and the Argument proceedeth of Lawfulness positive, which is commanded in the word. But this is, 1. a begging of the question. 2. Negative Lawfulness, is from mans will, which should not be a Creatrix of the goodness of things or of Lawfulness, nor can it Create goodness, except you make man to be God: 4.
If it be said, the particular goodnesse of Surplice and Crossing is good and shewed to us in the generall. I Answer, ⟨p. 120⟩goodnesse of indifferent Rites, is, Repugnantia in adjecto, and a flat contradiction, as who would say, cold fire, indifferent is neither good nor evil, neither Lawfull, nor unlawfull: 2. Then God hath not shewed us all Morall goodnesse in his word, because he hath not shewed to us the goodnesse of Ceremonies. 3. Lawfulnesse is an essentiall property of Divine worship resulting from Gods particular approving will in his word, as is clear, Hosea 8. 5. 1 Chro. 15. 13. Lev. 10. 1. 2 Sam. 7. 7. Ier. 7. 30. Act. 15. 24. Ergo, Arbitrary worship must have Gods approving will, commanding it, else it is not Lawfull: I prove the Antecedent from the causes of worship: 1. The end of worship, which is the honouring of God maketh not worship Lawfull; Idolaters may intend to honour God in their Idolatry, as well as true worshippers. 2. The matter of worship is not essentiall to Lawfull worship, for Lawfull and unlawfull worship may have the same common matter, as Solomons Calves in the Temple were lawfull, because ordained of God, and Samaria's Calves were unlawfull, because they were from men, the matter of both might be one and the same mettall, Hosea 8. 3. The Form of worship in generall, is not the essentiall and specifice Form of Lawfull worship, as the specifice Form of a living creature is not the specifice form of a man, the specifice form of a man is not the specifice form of a just man, as just. Also I may conceive Sacramentall eating in generall, and not conceive whether it be Lawfull or unlawfull: For if Lawfulnesse were the specifice form of worship, I could not conceive worship, but I behooved to conceive Lawfulnesse in it. Now then Gods commanding will, being wanting to Arbitrary worship, it cannot be Lawfull; Ergo, unlawfull. If it be answered, Ceremonies are negatively lawfull, not positively lawfull, and the Argument proceedeth of Lawfulnesse positive, which is commanded in the word. But this is, 1. a begging of the question. 2. Negative Lawfulnesse, is from mans will, which should not be a Creatrix of the goodnesse of things or of Lawfulnesse, nor can it Create goodnesse, except you make man to be God: 4.
Arbitrary goodness and Lawfulness hath either a particular warrant and cause of its goodness, and Lawfulness from Gods express Commandment, or 2. From the light of nature, or 3. From the sole will of men, or 4. partly from natures light, partly from mans will, but any of these ways it cannot ⟨p. 121⟩be Lawful, I prove the Antecedent: for it cannot have its warrant from Gods general will whereby the Proposition of a Syllogism is warranted, but not the Assumption▪ for thu• the golden Calf of Jeroboam; the worshipping of Satan should be lawful: for I can form a Syllogism to it from Scripture (all worship commanded in the Word is Lawful▪ but Jeroboam's golden Calf is Commanded in the Word; Ergo, It is Lawful. And if both Major▪ Proposition and Assumption be warranted by the Word, then are Ceremonies essential and not Arbitrary worship. If Ceremonies be warranted by the light of nature, this is a part of Gods Word, and Rom. 1. 19, 20. God hath showed it to us, as, Rom. 2. 14, 15. We would see natures light to prove that whiteness of linen signifieth Pastoral holiness, rather then whiteness in the wall, and that the cross signifieth dedication of a child to Christs service, rather then lifting up of the child toward Heaven signifieth the same; and yet Ceremonies must be by this reason essential worship; yea, to Sacrifice a sheep to represent Christ already Crucified▪ is as Lawful this way as all our Ceremonies. If the third be said, that Ceremonies have their goodness and Lawfulness from the sole will of men; then Ceremonies are Will-worship: for worship instituted by the sole will of men, without light of Scripture, or nature, is Will-worship. 2. The devisers of them are either Brutish, or void of reason, and the practicers are servants of men, because they serve will, or rather lust of men, without any reason Commanding. 3. If Ceremonies come partly from mens will, partly from the light of reason▪ then do they conclude the Lawfulness of Ceremonies either fallibly or necessarily: If the former be said, we have little warrant of conscience to practice them;
Arbitrary goodnesse and Lawfulnesse hath either a particular warrant and cause of its goodnesse, and Lawfulnesse from Gods expresse Commandment, or 2. From the light of nature, or 3. From the sole will of men, or 4. partly from natures light, partly from mans will, but any of these wayes it cannot ⟨p. 121⟩be Lawfull, I prove the Antecedent: for it cannot have its warrant from Gods generall will whereby the Proposition of a Syllogisme is warranted, but not the Assumption▪ for thu• the golden Calse of Ieroboam; the worshipping of Satan should be lawfull: for I can forme a Syllogisme to it from Scripture (all worship commanded in the Word is Lawfull▪ but Ieroboams golden Calf is Commanded in the Word; Ergo, It is Lawfull. And if both Major▪ Proposition and Assumption be warranted by the Word, then are Ceremonies essentiall and not Arbitrary worship. If Ceremonies be warranted by the light of nature, this is a part of Gods Word, and Rom. 1. 19, 20. God hath shewed it to us, as, Rom. 2. 14, 15. We would see natures light to prove that whitenesse of linnen signifieth Pastorall holinesse, rather then whitenesse in the wall, and that the crosse signifieth dedication of a childe to Christs service, rather then lifting up of the childe toward Heaven signifieth the same; and yet Ceremonie• must be by this reason essentiall worship; yea, to Sacrifice a sheep to represent Christ already Crucified▪ is as Lawfull this way as all our Ceremonies. If the third be said, that Ceremonies have their goodnesse and Lawfulnesse from the sole will of men; then Ceremonies are Will-worship: for worship instituted by the sole will of men, without light of Scripture, or nature, is Will-worship. 2. The devisers of them are either Brutish, or void of reason, and the practicers are servants of men, because they serve will, or rather lust of men, without any reason Commanding. 3. If Ceremonies come partly from mens will, partly from the light of reason▪ then do they conclude the Lawfulnesse of Ceremonies either •allibly or necessarily: If the former be said, we have little warrant of conscience to practice them;
nor can God be honoured, nor these things Lawful, good, and edificative, more then unlawful, evil and unapt to edify, seeing there be no light of Scripture, or nature to make them good to us▪ and because a fallible and unnecessary consequence, is over fallible and unnecessary, and standeth (as Aristotle faith well) in an indivisible point. It is a non-consequence, and so mens will is the best house that Ceremonies are descended of. If they can be proved by a necessary and infallible consequence, we desire to hear it, for it must be thus or the like: Things not contrary to the Word, and commanded as apt to edify, may be Lawful Arbitrary Worship: But ⟨p. 122⟩Ceremonies are such; Ergo, the Proposition is not true▪ because Rulers judge either such things apt to edify, because they see them to be so in themselves, or because they judge them to be so in themselves, therefore they are so in themselves: the former cannot be said, because this light whereby Rulers see Ceremonies to be apt to edify, is either light of Scripture, or nature, or both: If this be said, they can make others see this light. Also, if there be goodness and aptitude to edify souls in Ceremonies by natures light, sound reason, or the Word of God, they cannot be Arbitrary or indifferent worship: but must be essential worship, having warrant and Commandment from God▪ for what natures light, or Scripture Commandeth, that God himself Commandeth, and what God Commandeth is essential, not Arbitrary worship. 2. And secondly, they are not Arbitrary things, but necessary and Lawful by natures light, by Scripture, or both, which they deny; if the latter be true, then is the will of Rulers, that which maketh Ceremonies good and Lawful▪ a••in and blasphemous assertion, for Pope or Prince, or mens pleasure find pre-existent goodness and Lawfulness in things, and they do not make them good: It is proper to God alone, who calleth things that are not, to create both beings and goodness of beings. 5. If Arbitrary goodness and Lawfulness of Ceremonies be thus warrantable, because nor contrary to the word, and esteemed Arbitrary; I might fail against the first four Commandments, by superstition and idolatry: so I esteem these, to wit, Idolatry and superstition Arbitrary, and not of Divine necessity, and yet in so doing, I should neither sin, nor commit acts of false worship;
nor can God be honoured, nor these things Lawfull, good, and edificative, more then unlawfull, evil and unapt to edifie, seeing there be no light of Scripture, or nature to make them good to us▪ and because a fallible and unnecessary consequence, is over fallible and unnecessary, and standeth (as Aristotle faith well) in an indivisible point. It is a non-consequence, and so mens will is the best house that Ceremonies are descended of. If they can be proved by a necessary and infallible consequence, we desire to hear it, for it must be thus or the like: Things not contrary to the Word, and commanded as apt to edifie, may be Lawfull Arbitrary Worship: But ⟨p. 122⟩Ceremonies are such; Ergo, the Proposition is not true▪ because Rulers judge either such things apt to edifie, because they see them to be so in themselves, or because they judge them to be so in themselves, therefore they are so in themselves: the former cannot be said, because this light whereby Rulers see Ceremonies to be apt to edifie, is either light of Scripture, or nature, or both: If this be said, they can make others see this light. Also, if there be goodnesse and aptitude to edifie souls in Ceremonies by natures light, sound reason, or the Word of God, they cannot be Arbitrary or indifferent worship: but must be essentiall worship, having warrant and Commandment from God▪ for what natures light, or Scripture Commandeth, that God himself Commandeth, and what God Commandeth is essentiall, not Arbitrary worship. 2. And secondly, they are not Arbitrary things, but necessary and Lawfull by natures light, by Scripture, or both, which they deny; if the latter be true, then is the will of Rulers, that which maketh Ceremonies good and Lawfull▪ a••in and blasphemous assertion, for Pope or Prince, or mens pleasure finde pre-existent goodnesse and Lawfulnesse in things, and they do not make them good: It is proper to God alone, who calleth things that are not, to create both beings and goodnesse of beings. 5. If Arbitrary goodnesse and Lawfulnesse of Ceremonies be thus warrantable, because nor contrary to the word, and esteemed Arbitrary; I might fail against the first four Commandments, by superstition and idolary: so I esteem these, to wit, Idolatry and superstition Arbitrary, and not of Divine necessity, and yet in so doing, I should neither sin, nor commit acts of false worship;
because superstition and Idolatry are indeed forbidden, but superstition and Idolatry, with the opinion, that they have neither holiness, merit, nor Divine necessity, but are merely Arbitrary, are no where forbidden in the word. Let Formalists by their grounds, show us a Scripture for it; for they cannot by their Doctrine be forbidden as false worship, seeing they want that which essentially constituteth false worship (as they teach) for they (as the Argument supposeth) want opinion of necessity, Divine merit and holiness. 6. If the Churches will, commanding Crossing, and Surplice, make them Lawful; then their forbidding them shall make them unlawful, and mans will shall be a Pope and God. 7. If Rulers conclude them Lawful, then either upon National ⟨p. 123⟩reasons concerning Britain rather then other Nations, or upon reasons immutable & eternal▪ if the latter be said, they be essential worship, not Arbitrary▪ if the former be said, they be more apt to stir up the dull senses of British men, then others, which is a dream. Dull senses are alike every where, sin original alike in all places, and God in his perfect word hath provided alike remedies against natural dullness to all mankind, else we in Britain do supererogate, and the word▪ must be perfect to some Nations, in that which is common to all, and not to others. 8. By as good reason, Arbitrary mercy, and Arbitrary justice is holden as Arbitrary worship; for the Lords word is as perfect in works of charity for the second Table, as in works of Religion for the first, and if so be, then it were in mens will to do things conducing for the murdering, or not murdering of our brethren, of their own wit and will, without the word of God, and there should be some lawful acts of will-love, or will-murder. 9. Laws oblige (as Papists grant) as aDriedo, and bVasquez say, after Gerson, Occam, Almain, and other Papists, from the goodness of the matter commanded in the Law, not from the will of the Law-giver: If then the general will and command of God constitute Arbitrary worship, this worship from Gods will layeth a band on the conscience, no less then essential worship: For Hezekiah is no less obliged in conscience to apply Figs to his boil, and Moses to make every little ring in the Tabernacle: when God commandeth these, then the Prophets are to write Canonic Scripture:
because superstition and Idolatry are indeed forbidden, but superstition and Idolatry, with the opinion, that they have neither holinesse, merit, nor Divine necessity, but are meerly Arbitrary, are no where forbidden in the word. Let Formalists by their grounds, shew us a Scripture for it; for they cannot by their Doctrine be forbidden as false worship, seeing they want that which essentially constituteth false worship (as they teach) for they (as the Argument supposeth) want opinion of necessity, Divine merit and holinesse. 6. If the Churches will, commanding Crossing, and Surplice, make them Lawfull; then their forbidding them shall make them unlawfull, and mans will shall be a Pope and God. 7. If Rulers conclude them Lawfull, then either upon Nationall ⟨p. 123⟩reasons concerning Britain rather then other Nations, or upon reasons immutable & eternal▪ if the latter be said, they be essential worship, not Arbitrary▪ if the former be said, they be more apt to stir up the dull senses of Brittish men, then othe•s, which is a dream. Dull senses are alike every where, sin originall alike in all places, and God in his perfect word hath provided alike remedies against naturall dulnesse to all mankinde, else we in Britaine do supererogate, and the word▪ must be perfect to some Nations, in that which is common to all, and not to others. 8. By as good reason, Arbitrary mercy, and Arbittary justice is holden as Arbitrary worship; for the Lords word is as perfect in works of charity for the second Table, as in works of Religion for the first, and if so be, then it were in mens will to do things conducing for the murthering, or not murthering of our brethren, of their own wit and will, without the word of God, and there should be some lawfull acts of will-love, or will-murther. 9. Laws oblige (as Papists grant) as aDriedo, and bVasquez say, after Gerson, Occam, Almain, and other Papists, from the goodnesse of the matter commanded in the Law, not from the will of the Law-giver: If then the generall will and command of God constitute Arbitrary worship, this worship from Gods will layeth a band on the conscience, no lesse then essentiall worship: For Hezechiah is no lesse obliged in conscience to apply Figs to his boyle, and Moses to make every little ring in the Tabernacle: when God commandeth these, then the Prophets are to write Canonick Scripture:
aDriedo de Libert Christ. l. 3. c. 3. ad arg. 3. Non est in potestate legislatoris prout voluerit obligare ad mortale & veniale sed hoe provient ex materiaegravitate.
bVasquez Tom. 2. in 12. disput. 154. c. 3. Neque enim in voluntate legislator is est obligare vel non obligare.
for Gods Authority in Commanding, is equal in all, though in respect of the matter, there be great things, and less things of the Law: therefore Gods general permissive-will, doth no less oblige the conscience, then his approving will. 10. To this Arbitrary worship agreeth all the properties of will-worship; as 1 Colos. 2. 18. It beguileth us of our reward; for no promise of God is made of a Bishopric for conformity▪ 2. It is will-humility, to be devouter then God willeth us. 3. It intrudeth in things not known in the word. 4. It holdeth not the head Christ, for it maketh him not a perfect Law-giver, if Prelates under him give Laws added to his word, and that after the Traditions of men. 5. It enthralleth men dead with Christ, to a yoke. They object, But not to yoke upon the conscience. Answer; yea, but we are in Christ freed also from the external yoke, as from shedding of blood in Circumcision, ⟨p. 124⟩removal out of the Camp seven days, many Ceremonial Sabbaths, presenting of the male-children, and going up to sacrifice at Jerusalem; yea, expensive offerings, all called burdens, Act. 15. 10. Col. 2. 20. Gal▪ 4. 3, 4, 5. Col. 2. 14. 15. And multiplied holy days, Surplice, Crossing, keeping us in that same bondage; though less (they may say) Magis, & minus non variant speciem. 6. This worship perisheth with the use: 7. Subjecteth us to the Ordinances of men. 8. Hath a show of wisdom, Mr. Burges asaith, Some will-worship i• not unlawful, a• three Sermons in one day. The free-vvill offerings and vows were in some sort vvill-Worship. The Church at her godly discretion, and will, may appoint some Formalities to attend the Worship. Answer, Gregor▪ de valent saith, That some Idolatry is Lawful, some unlawful: This man saith, some will-worship is lawful, some unlawful, that is, some sin is Lawful, some unlawful: 2. Three preachings come from zeal, not from will, and is no new worship different from preaching, and there may be reason therefore, where all cannot be present in one day at all the three, there is reason for three preachings, none for Crossing: 3. Will as will, is carver of will-worship: Will createth not the worship, but determineth the circumstances according to the light of reason, in Lawful worship. But where will, as will, void of reason hath influence in the worship, it is wills brood:
for Gods Authority in Commanding, is equall in all, though in respect of the matter, there be great things, and lesse things of the Law: therefore Gods generall permissive-will, doth no lesse oblige the conscience, then his approving will. 10. To this Arbitrary worship agreeth all the properties of will-worship; as 1 Colos. 2. 18. It beguileth us of our reward; for no promise of God is made of a Bishoprick for conformity▪ 2. It is will-humility, to be devouter then God willeth us. 3. It intrudeth in things not known in the word. 4. It holdeth not the head Christ, for it maketh him not a perfect Law-giver, if Prelares under him give Laws added to his word, and that after the Traditions of men. 5. It inthralleth men dead with Christ, to a yoak. They object, But not to yoak upon the conscience. Answer; yea, but we are in Christ freed also from the externall yoak, as from shedding of blood in Circumcision, ⟨p. 124⟩removall out of the Campe seven dayes, many Ceremoniall Sabbaths, presenting of the male-children, and going up to sacrifica at Jerusalem; yea, expensive offerings, all called burdens, Act. 15. 10. Col. 2. 20. Gal▪ 4. 3, 4, 5. Col. 2. 14. 15. And multiplied holy dayes, Surplice, Crossing, keeping us in that same bondage; though lesse (they may say) Magis, & minus non variant speciem. 6. This worship perisheth vvith the use: 7. Subjecteth us to the Ordinances of men. 8. Hath a shew of wisdom, Mr. Burges asaith, Some will-worship i• not unlavvfull, a• three Sermons in one day. The free-vvill offerings and vows vvere in some sort vvill-Worship. The Church at her godly discretion, and will, may appoint some Formalities to attend the Worship. Answer, Gregor▪ de valent saith, That some Idolatry is Lawfull, some unlawfull: This man saith, some will-worship is lawfull, some unlawfull, that is, some sin is Lawfull, some unlawfull: 2. Three preachings come from zeal, not from will, and is no new worship different from preaching, and there may be reason therefore, where all cannot be present in one day at all the three, there is reason for three preachings, none for Crossing: 3. Will as will, is carver of will-worship: Will createth not the worship, but determineth the circumstances according to the light of reason, in Lawfull worship. But where will, as will, void of reason hath influence in the worship, it is wills brood:
4▪ The Freewill offerings were determined by God, the poor should offer a pair of Doves, in the Free-will offering: But the rich a Lamb, and it was sin for the rich to offer a pair of doves, and therefore will was not determinatrix in this. 5. The man jumbleth together godly discretion and will: they be much different; but for godliness in short sleeves, and Crossing a finger in the Air, I understand it not, nor can reason dream of any warrant for it, but will, as will, that is, mans lust made it.
4▪ The Freewill offerings were determined by God, the poor should offer a pair of Doves, in the Free-will offering: But the rich a Lamb, and it was sin for the rich to offer a pair of doves, and therefore will was not determinatrix in this. 5. The man jumbleth together godly discretion and will: they be much different; but for godlinesse in short sleeves, and Crossing a finger in the Aire, I understand it not, nor can reason dream of any warrant for it, but will, as will, that is, mans lust made it.
Neither do Formalists go from aSuarez, and bBellarmine, who call that will-worship, which is devised only by a man• wit, and is not conform to the principles of Faith, and wanteth all reason, and the received use of the Church.
Neither do Formalists go from aSuarez, and bBellarmine, who call that will-worship, which is devised only by a man• wit, and is not conforme to the principles of Faith, and wanteth all reason, and the received use of the Church.
aSuarez de relig. to. 2. de hovest v•ti lib. 1. c. 1. n. 8. 9.Suarez de relig. to. 2. de houest v•ti lib. 1. c. 1. n. 8. 9.
But we are disputing here against the Churches use, as if it were not yet a received use. But upon these grounds I go: 1. Reason not binding and strongly concluding, is no reason, but mere will. So Ceremonies have no reason: If the reason bind, they are essential worship: 2. Authority is only ministerial in ordering Gods worship, ⟨p. 125⟩and hath no place to invent new worship. 3. Authority as Authority especially humane, giveth no light, nor no warrant of conscience to obey, and therefore authority naked and void of scriptures-light is here bastard authority. 11. In all this Formalists but give the Papists distinction of Divine and Apostolic Traditions: for power of inventing Ceremonies to them is Apostolic, but not infallible and Divine: cSuarez giveth the difference: God saith he, Is the Immediate Author of Divine Traditions, and the Apostles only publishers: But the Apostles are immediate Authors of Apostolic Traditions, God in special manner guiding their will. So dCajetan eSotus fBellar. So our Formalists gDuname hHooker iSutluvius; But I like better what kCyprian saith, That no Tradition, but what is in the word of God, is to be received: But this distinction is blasphemous, and contrary to Scripture, 1 Cor▪ 14▪ 57. The things▪ that I write unto you: (even of decency and order, as v. 29. 40.) Are the Commandment of the Lord, 2. Pet. 3. 2. Peter willeth them to be mindful of the words which were spoken before, by the holy Prophets, and of the Commandments of us the Apostles of the Lord and S•vio••: Then the Apostles Commandments are equal with the Commandments of the Prophets. But in the Old Testament, there were not some Traditions Divine, and some not every way Divine, but Prophetical, for the Prophets were the mouth of God, as is clear, 2 Pet. •. 19, 20, 21. Luk. 1. 70. Rom. 1. 2. So 1 Tim. 6. 13. I give thee charge in the sight of God—14. That thou keep this Commandment without spot, unrebukable, until the appearing of the Lord Jesus. Now the Commandment (as Beza lnoteth) Are all that he writ of discipline, which Formalists say, are for the most Apostolic, but not Divine Traditions. 2. If Ceremonies seem good to the holy Ghost▪ as they say they do from Act. 15. then they must seem good to the Father and the Son, as the Canon is Act. 15. But that Canon was proved from express Scripture; as Peter proveth, v. 7, 8, 9. and James v. 13, 14, 15, 16.
But we are disputing here against the Churches use, as if it were not yet a received use. But upon these grounds I go: 1. Reason not binding and strongly concluding, is no reason, but meer will. So Ceremonies have no reason: If the reason binde, they are essentiall worship: 2. Authority is only ministeriall in ordering Gods worship, ⟨p. 125⟩and hath no place to invent new worship. 3. Authority as Authority especially humane, giveth no light, nor no warrant of conscience to obey, and therefore authority naked and void of scriptures-light is here bastard authority. 11. In all this Formalists but give the Papists distinction of Divine and Apostolick Traditions: for power of inventing Ceremonies to them is Apostolick, but not infallible and Divine: cSuarez giveth the difference: God saith he, Is the Immediate Author of Divine Traditions, and the Apostles only publishers: But the Apostles are immediate Authors of Apostolick Traditions, God in speciall manner guiding their will. So dCajetan eSotus fBellar. So our Formalists gDuname hHooker iSutluvius; But I like better what kCyprian saith, That no Tradition, but what is in the word of God, is to be received: But this distinction is blasphemous, and contrary to Scripture, 1 Cor▪ 14▪ 57. The things▪ that I write unto you: (even of decency and order, as v. 29. 40.) Are the Commandment of the Lord, 2. Pet. 3. 2. Peter willeth them to be mindefull of the vvords which were spoken before, by the holy Prophets, and of the Commandments of us the Apostles of the Lord and S•vio••: Then the Apostles Commandments are equall with the Commandments of the Prophets. But in the Old Testament, there were not some Traditions Divine, and some not every way Divine, but Propheticall, for the Prophets were the mouth of God, as is clear, 2 Pet. . 19, 20, 21.
cSuarez de tripl. virtut. tract. 1. dis. 5. Sect. 4.
dCajetan opusc. to. 1. tract. 27.
eSotus de justific. l. 7 c. 6. ar. 1
fBellar. de verbo non Scripto.
gDouna. l. 3. c. 36.
h3 Book p. 153.
iSutluvius, de Presbyt. c. 11. p. 67.
kCyprian epist. 74. Unde ista traditio? &c. si in Evangelio praecipitur, aut in Apostolorum Epistolis, aut actibus continetur, & observetur Divina et sanctahaes traditio. The distinction of divine and of Apostolic Traditions rejected.Cyprian epist. 74. Vnde ista traditio? &c. si in Evangelio praecipitur, aut in Apostolorum Epistolis, aut actibus continetur, & observetur Divina et sanctahaes traditio. The distinction of divine and of Apostolick Traditions rejected.
If they come from the Spirit, inspiring the Apostles, they cannot err in such Traditions; If from the spirit guided by the holy Ghost, they come from Scripture. 3. If these traditions come from no spirit led by light of Scripture, we shall not know, whether they be Lawful, or not, for the Scripture is a Canonic rule of lawful and unlawful. 4. If any Apostolic spirit be given to Authors of Ceremonies, why not also ⟨p. 126⟩in preaching and praying? How then do many of them turn Arminians, Papists, Socinians? 5. The Apostolic spirit leading institutors of Ceremonies, doth either infuse light natural, supernatural, or Scriptural in devising Ceremonies, and so Eatenus, in so far they were essential worship▪ or the Apostolic spirit doth lead them, with no light at all, which is brutish Enthusiasm: or 3. Gods Apostolic spirit infuseth the general equity, and negative Lawfulness of these truths (Surplice is an Apostolical sign of Pastoral holiness) and (Crossing a sign of Dedication of a child to Christs service) Now light, for this we would exceedingly have. If this light be immediately infused, then Surplice, Crossing are as Divine, as if God spake them; for truths immediately inspired lost no divinity, because they come through sinful men; for Balaam his Prophecy of the star of Jacob, was as Divine, in regard of Authority, as if God had spoken it, but if these trash come from an inferior spirit, we desire to know what spirit speaketh without the word. But some may object; The preaching of the word is somewhat humane, because its not from the infallible spirit that dited the word; Ergo, Ceremonies may come from the holy Spirit, though they be not as lawful as Scripture. Ans. Let them be proved to be from the warrant, that the word is preached, and we yield to all▪ 5. Apostolic Ceremonies, but not Divine have Gods general allowing will for the accepting of them. Now Samsons mother, Judg. 13. 23. proveth well, The Lord hath accepted our offering; Ergo, it is Lawful, and he will not kill us. So God accepted Abel, and Noah their Sacrifices; Ergo, they were Lawful, and Divine worship. So Hosea 8. 8. They sacrifice flesh for the sacrifices of my offerings, and they eat it, but the Lord accepteth them not. Ergo, offerings of flesh without offering of themselves as living sacrifices to God are now unlawful:
If they come from the Spirit, inspiring the Apostles, they cannot erre in such Traditions; If from the spirit guided by the holy Ghost, they come from Scripture. 3. If these traditions come from no spirit led by light of Scripture, we shall not know, whether they be Lawfull, or not, for the Scripture is a Canonick rule of lawfull and unlawfull. 4. If any Apostolick spirit be given to Authors of Ceremonies, why not also ⟨p. 126⟩in preaching and praying? How then do many of them turn Arminians, Papists, Socinians? 5. The Apostolick spirit leading institutors of Ceremonies, doth either infuse light naturall, supernaturall, or Scripturall in devising Ceremonies, and so Eatenus, in so far they were essential worship▪ or the Apostolick spirit doth lead them, with no light at all, which is brutish Enthusiasme: or 3. Gods Apostolick spirit infuseth the generall equity, and negative Lawfulnesse of these truths (Surplice is an Apostolicall signe of Pastorall holinesse) and (Crossing a signe of Dedication of a childe to Christs service) Now light, for this we would exceedingly have. If this light be immediatly infused, then Surplice, Crossing are as Divine, as if God spake them; for truths immediatly inspired lost no divinity, because they come through sinfull men; for Balaam his Prophesie of the star of Jacob, was as Divine, in regard of Authority, as if God had spoken it, but if these trash come from an inferiour spirit, we desire to know what spirit speaketh without the word. But some may object; The preaching of the word is somewhat humane, because its not from the infallible spirit that dited the word; Ergo, Ceremonies may come from the holy Spirit, though they be not as lawfull as Scripture. Ans. Let them be proved to be from the warrant, that the word is preached, and we yeeld to all▪ 5. Apostolick Ceremonies, but not Divine have Gods generall allowing will for the accepting of them. Now Sampsons mother, Judg. 13. 23. proveth well, The Lord hath accepted our offering; Ergo, it is Lawfull, and he will not kill us. So God atcepted Abel, and Noah their Sacrifices; Ergo, they were Lawfull, and Divine worship. So Hosea 8. 8. They sacrifice flesh for the sacrifices of my offerings, and they eat it, but the Lord accepteth them not. Ergo, offerings of flesh without offering of themselves as living sacrifices to God are now unlawfull:
If God accept of Ceremonies, they must be Divine service, if he accept them not, they must be unlawful. They Answer, He accepteth them as Arbitrary worship, not as essential: I Answer, God might have accepted so Samsons sacrifice, and Noah's, as arbitrary worship, and yet not be gracious to them, nor reward their sacrificing, as good service, contrary to the Texts alleged; but I doubt much, if the Lord be gracious to men, and accept in Christ corner Caps, Surplice, Crossing, humane holy days.
If God accept of Ceremonies, they must be Divine service, if he accept them not, they must be unlawfull. They Answer, He accepteth them as Arbitrary worship, not as essentiall: I Answer, God might have accepted so Sampsons sacrifice, and Noahs, as arbitrary worship, and yet not be gracious to them, nor reward their sacrificing, as good service, contrary to the Texts alledged; but I doubt much, if the Lord be gracious to men, and accept in Christ corner Caps, Surplice, Crossing, humane holy dayes.
They object, Our Circumstances of time, place, persons, &c. are ⟨p. 127⟩no more warranted by the Scripture, then Ceremonies are. And God might in his wisdom (•aith aBurges) have calculated the order of times and places, such climates and seasons; but he hath left these, as he hath left our Ceremonies to the Churches liberty.
They object, Our Circumstances of time, place, persons, &c. are ⟨p. 127⟩no more warranted by the Scripture, then Ceremonies are. And God might in his wisdom (•aith aBurges) have calculated the order of times and places, such climats and seasons; but he hath left these, as he hath left our Ceremonies to the Churches liberty.
aBurges rejoinder, cap. 1. Sect. 16. p. 90. Circumstances not positive religious observances as Ceremonies are.Burges rejoynder, cap. 1. Sect. 16. p. 90. Circumstances not positive religious observances as Ceremonies are.
Ans. Time and place (as I observed already) being circumstances Physical, not Moral, nor having any Religious influence to make the worship new and different in nature, from that which is commanded in the Law, though they be not expressly in the Word, do not hinder, but you may say, Such an act of worship is according as it is written: for as Praying, Preaching, hearing, is according as it is written: so is Praying and Preaching in this convenient place, proved by that same Scripture (As it is written) but one and the same Scripture doth not warrant Order and Surplice. 2. The question is not, what Gods wisdom can do, for he could set down all the names of Preaching Pastors, Doctors, Deacons, Elders in the Word; but his wisdom thus should have made ten Bibles more then there be: But all our Ceremonies might have been Comprehended in one Chapter of the Revelation, if God had thought good to Honour them with inserting them in the Canon. 3. He hath determined these by natures light, and prudence, which dwelleth with that light, revealed in the Word; That a Bishop be thus qualified, as 1 Tim. 3. is Moral and determined; but that they call him John, Thomas, and be of such Parents, Country, stature of body, is Physical and in Christs wisdom, is not determined, nor could it be conveniently. Lastly, that general permissive will of God, is good, for all the Ceremonies of Rome, taught by Papists; As for ours, as Suarez de Trip lic. virt. tract. 1. disp. 2. Sect. 6. n. 3. Dicendum fidem quoad substantiam credibilium semper fuisse eandem a principio generis humani. And so faith Alensis, 3. p. q. 69. Lombard. 3. dist. 25. and Durandus, 3. dist. 25. Bonaventura, 16. Art. 2. q. 1. Hugo de sancto victore de sacram, •. 1. part. 10. cap. 4. This they have from the Fathers, Vincentius Lyrinensis, co•t▪ prop. voc. nov. cap. 37. Jreneus, contr. hereticos, lib. 3. cap. 2. Jerome in Psal. 86. Aug. de civitate, Dei lib. 11. cap. 3. lib. 14. cap. 7. Chrysost. de Lazero homil. 4. Cyprianus sermone de Baptismo. Optatus Milevitanus, contr. parmeni. de caelo, l. 5. And I might cite many others, who all affirm, All truth Divine is in Scripture, all not in Scripture is to be rejected: So Suarez, de leg. tom. 4. cap. 1. ⟨p. 128⟩Haec enim praecepta Ecclesiastica pro universally.
Ans. Time and place (as I observed already) being circumstances Physicall, not Morall, nor having any Religious influence to make the worship new and different in nature, from that which is commanded in the Law, though they be not expresly in the Word, do not hinder, but you may say, Such an act of worship is according as it is written: for as Praying, Preaching, hearing, is according as it is written: so is Praying and Preaching in this convenient place, proved by that same Scripture (As it is written) but one and the same Scripture doth not warrant Order and Surplice. 2. The question is not, what Gods wisdom can do, for he could setdown all the names of Preaching Pastors, Doctors, Deacons, Elders in the Word; but his wisdom thus should have made ten Bibles more then there be: But all our Ceremonies might have been Comprehended in one Chapter of the Revelation, if God had thought good to Honour them with inserting them in the Canon. 3. He hath determined these by natures light, and prudence, which dwelleth with that light, revealed in the Word; That a Bishop be thus qualified, as 1 Tim. 3. is Morall and determined; but that they call him John, Thomas, and be of such Parents, Country, stature of body, is Physicall and in Christs wisdom, is not determined, nor could it be conveninetly. Lastly, that generall permissive will of God, is good, for all the Ceremonies of Rome, taught by Papists; As for ours, as Suarez de Trip lic. virt. tract. 1. disp. 2. Sect. 6. n. 3. Dicendum fidem quoad substantiam credibilium semper fuisse eandem a principio generis humani. And so faith Alensis, 3. p. q. 69. Lombard. 3. dist. 25. and Durandus, 3. dist. 25. Bonaventura, 16. Art. 2. q. 1. Hugo de sancto victore de sacram, •. 1. part. 10. cap. 4. This they have from the Fathers, Vincentius Lyrinensis, co•t▪ prop. voc. nov. cap. 37. Jreneus, contr. hereticos, lib. 3. cap. 2. Hyerom in Psal. 86. Aug. de civitate, Dei lib. 11. cap. 3. lib. 14. cap. 7. Chrysost. de Lazero homil. 4. Cyprianus sermone de Baptismo. Optatus Milevitanus, contr. parmeni. de caelo, l. 5. And I might cite many others, who all affirm, All truth Divine is in Scripture, all not in Scripture is to be rejected: So Suarez, de leg. tom. 4. cap. 1. ⟨p. 128⟩Haec enim praecepta Ecclesiastica pro universali.
Ecclesia tantum sunt quatuor, qut quinque, quae solum sunt determinationes quaedam juris Divini moraliter necessaria homini.—Reliqua omnia vel pertinent ad particulares status qui voluntarie suscipiuntur, vel ad ordinem judicial•m. Et id•m contra seotae Anglica. Erro. lib. 2. cap. 16. Dicimus authoritatem Dei (in benedictione Campanarum) non de esse, saltem in radice & origine, quia ipse dedit authoritatem Pastoribus Ecclesiae ad regendam Ecclesiam, & disponenda, eaequae ad accidentarios ritus Ecclesiae pertinent. Bannes, tom. 3. in 22. q. 10. dub. 2. Notandum quod neque Pontifex, neque tota Ecclesia possunt novum articulum, novum dogma quoad substantiam, aut novum Sacramentum instituere. Andr. Duvallius, in 2. de legib. q. 4. Art. 2. Ceremoniae & judicialia in vetere lege erant juris Divini, in Nova lege sunt juris tantum Ecclesiastici: And Valdensis de Doctrina fidei, l. 2. cap. 22. Ecclesia non potest Novum articulum proponere: So Alphas. a Castro in summa, lib. 1. cap. 8. And Canus, loc. lib. 2. cap. 7. Cameracensis, 2. sentent. q. 1. Art. 1. Principia Theologia sunt ipsae s• cry Canonis veritates, quoniam adipsa fit ultima resoluti• Theologici discursus, & ex iis primo singulae propositions Theologiae deducuntur.
Ecclesia tantum sunt quatuor, qut quinque, quae solum sunt determinationes quaedam juris Divini moraliter necessaria homini.—Reliqua omnia vel pertinent ad particulares status qui voluntarie suscipiuntur, vel ad ordinem judicial•m. Et id•m contra seotae Anglica. Erro. lib. 2. cap. 16. Dicimus authoritatem Dei (in benedictione Campanarum) non de esse, saltem in radice & origine, quia ipse dedit authoritatem Pastoribus Ecclesiae ad regendam Ecclesiam, & disponenda, eaequae ad accidentarios ritus Ecclesiae pertinent. Bannes, tom. 3. in 22. q. 10. dub. 2. Notandum quod neque Pontifex, neque tota Ecclesia possunt novum articulum, novum dogma quoad substantiam, aut novum Sacramentum instituere. Andr. Duvallius, in 2. de legib. q. 4. Art. 2. Ceremoniae & judicialia in vetere lege erant juris Divini, in Nova lege sunt juris tantum Ecclesiastici: And Valdensis de Doctrina fidei, l. 2. cap. 22. Ecclesia non potest Novum articulum proponere: So Alphas. a Castro in summa, lib. 1. cap. 8. And Canus, loc. lib. 2. cap. 7. Cameracensis, 2. sentent. q. 1. Art. 1. Principia Theologia sunt ipsae s• cri Canonis veritates, quoniam adipsa fit ultima resoluti• Theologici discursus, & ex iis primo singulae propositiones Theologiae deducuntur.
V. Conclus. Matters of fact are not, and need not be proved by Scripture: 1. Because sense maketh them known to us. 2. Their Morality is sufficiently known from Gods Word. 3. In matters of fact there may be invincible ignorance: Christs Resurrection is not a matter of fact, as aHugo Grotius saith, but also a matter of Law, as all the miracles and Histories in the Word, and to be believed, because God hath so spoken in the Word.
V. Conclus. Matters of fact are not, and need not be proved by Scripture: 1. Because sense maketh them known to us. 2. Their Morality is sufficiently known from Gods Word. 3. In matters offact there may be invincible ignorance: Christs Resurrection is not a matter of fact, as aHugo Grotius saith, but also a matter of Law, as all the miracles and Histories in the Word, and to be believed, because God hath so spoken in the Word.
Adrianus saith, While they doubt, and yet go to War, they expose themselves to the danger of Man-slaughter, and by not going to War, they should onely sin by not obeying.
Sylvester saith, Such a doubt should be expelled at the commandment of Superiors.
zVasquez Tom. 2. in 1▪ 2. disp. 151. cap. 3. Nihil novi (propositi) Statuere possunt, quod non pertineat ad pristi•um statum cujusque conservandum—pro libito far legem certe non licet.Vasquez Tom. 2. in 1▪ 2. disp. 151. cap. 3. Nihil novi (propositi) Statuere possunt, quod non pertineat ad pristi•um statum cujusque conservandum—pro libito ferre legem certe non licet.
aBannes To. 3. in 22. q. 1. Art. 10. ad. arg. 3. Scriptura indicat nobis Divini •uminis sensum, non tamen in individuo, & in specie sed in communi & generali quadam ratione.
bAnd Duvallius in 2. Thomae. tract. de legib. q. 5. Art. 1. ad Arg. 2. Scriptura est sufficiens, quia ipsa omnia, tam ered••da quam agenda impli•ite contineat, & propterea expresse ad Ecclesiam tanquam ad Columnam veritatis, tam in fide, quam in preceptis been vivendi nos remittit.And Duvallius in 2. Thomae. tract. de legib. q. 5. Art. 1. ad Arg. 2. Scriptura est sufficiens, quia ipsa omnia, tam ered••da quam agenda impli•ite contineat, & propterea expresse ad Ecclesiam tanquam ad Columnam veritatis, tam in fide, quam in preceptis bene vivendi nos remittit.
Preach Arrianisme, Turcisme, Popery, against the light of the minde only for gain; and yet to think that in so doing, they be performing meritorious service to God: Yea, they who devise will-worship, know their own will to be the Lord-carver of that worship, at least they may know it; yet shall we think they hold themselves necessitated, by a Religious obligation so to do? Else it were impossible, that men could believe the burning their Children were will-worship, indifferent and Arbitrary to the worshippers, which is open war against reason: Now a worship cannot be false, wanting that which is essentaill to false worship. 3.
. I give thee charge in the sight of God—14. That thou keep this Commandment without spot, unrebukable, untill the appearing of the Lord Iesus. Now the Commandment (as Beza
noteth) Are all that he writ of discipline, which Formalists say, are for the most Apostolicke, but not Divine Traditions. 2. If Ceremonies seem good to the holy Ghost▪ as they say they do from Act. 15. then they must seeme good to the Father and the Son, as the Canon is Act. 15. But that Canon was proved from expresse Scripture; as Peter proveth, v. 7, 8, 9. and James v. 13, 14, 15, 16.