Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The first five hundred years (saith aCalvin) images were not worshipped. Caj•s Caligula a proud Tyrant, commanded the Jews to set up his image in the Temple: the Jews answered they should rather die then pollute the Temple of God with images, as •aith bJosephus and cEusebius, and this fell out while the Apostles lived.
The first five hundred years (saith aCalvin) images were not worshipped. Caj•s Caligula a proud Tyrant, commanded the Iews to set up his image in the Temple: the Iews answered they should rather die then pollute the Temple of God with images, as •aith bIosephus and cEusebius, and this fell out while the Apostles lived.
Ann. 108. Plunius 2. writeth to Trajanus under the third Persecution, That Christians were men of good conversation, and detested vices, worshipped Christ, and would not worship Images
the Magdeburgenses testify; saith, Nos adoramus oculis ad caelum sublatis, non adimagines seu picturas, and, indignum ut imago Dei vivi imagini idoli, & mortu: fiat similis, (saith
he also) and not only thinketh it unlawful to represent God by an Image, but also saith, that Craftsmen, who profess themselves Christians, ought no• to make Images of God. An ancient Writer
Clemens Alexandrinus, Non est nobis imago sensibilis de materiâ sensibili, nisi quae precipitur intelligentiâ. Deus enim qui solus est verè Deas, intelligentiâ precipitur, non sensu: We have no sensible Image of sensible matter, because God is taken up by the understanding, not by the sense: and
of Polycarpus, an hearer of John the Apostle maketh it the Heresy of the Gnostics, that they held that Pilate made the Image of Jesus: Et quod imagines baberent Christi, Apostolorum atque Philosophorum▪ easque coronarent, ac colendas propo•erent.
Origen said, The Images of Christians are Christians indeed, with Gods Image: and, Nos veno ideo non honor amus simulachrá, quia quantū possumus, cavemnus, ne in•idamus in eam crudelitatem, ut et iis tribuamus divinitatis aliquid.
Grave Athanasius saith, [Greek or Hebrew] The invention of Images is from an evil fountain, and not from good, and whatsoever hath a bad beginning, cannot be deemed in any thing good, being altogether bad: The Papist Harding bringeth in a counterfeit Dialogue of Athanasius, betwixt Christ and his Church; and Christ comforting his Church, because she was persecuted for worshipping Christs Image;
Ann. 108. Plunius 2. writeth to Trajanus under the third Persecution, That Christians were men of good conversation, and detested vices, worshipped Christ, and would not worship Imagesd, as that Letter beareth: and eEusebius, reporteth Adrian had a purpose, (as saith fBucol.) to build a Church for the honour of Christ void of Images. See gSymson that ancient Writer: hJustine Martyr in this Age; Omnes imagines ad cultum proposit as simpliciter damnant Christiani. iTertullian, a most ancient writer, who lived under Severus in time of the fifth Persecution, as kthe Magdeburgenses testifie; saith, Nos adoramus oculis ad caelum sublatis, non adimagines seu picturas, and, indignum ut imago Dei vivi imagini idoli, & mortu: fiat similis, (saith lhe also) and not only thinketh it unlawfull to represent God by an Image, but also saith, that Craftsmen, who professe themselves Christians, ought no• to make Images of God. An ancient Writer mClemens Alexandrinus, Non est nobis imago sensibilis de materiâ sensibili, nisi quae precipitur intelligentiâ. Deus enim qui solus est verè Deas, intelligentiâ precipitur, non sensu: We have no sensible Image of sensible matter, because God is taken up by the understanding, not by the sense: and nNihil in rebus genitis potest referre Dei imaginem. This ancient Writer flourished, saith oCatolog. Testium veritat. Anno 150. or as pHospinian saith Ann, 200. and qIreneus, the disciple ⟨p. 182⟩of Polycarpus, an hearer of John the Apostle maketh it the Heresie of the Gnosticks, that they held that Pilate made the Image of Iesus: Et quod imagines baberent Christi, Apostolorum atque Philosophorum▪ easque coronarent, ac colendas propo•erent. aCyprian saith, Idols, or Images, be not only against the Law of God, but against the nature of man; bOrigen said, The Images of Christians are Christians indeed, with Gods Image: and, Nos veno ideo non honor amus simulachrá, quia quantū possumus, cavemnus, ne in•idamus in eam crudelitatem, ut et iis tribuamus divinitatis aliquid. cGrave Athanasius saith, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 The invention of Images is from an evil fountain, and not from good, and whatsoever hath a bad beginning, cannot be deemed in any thing good, being altogether bad: The Papist Harding bringeth in a counterfeit Dialogue of Athanasius, betwixt Christ and his Church; and Christ comforting his Church, because she was persecuted for worshipping Christs Image;
dEpist. Plinii. 2 ad Imporat Trajan.
eEuseb. Histor. lib. 3. cap. 33.
fBucol•. in Alexand. severo.
gSymson 1. Century cap. 1.
hJustin. Martyr. in Dialog. cum. Trypho. & apolog. 2.
but when and where this persecution was, none knoweth, for many times hath the Church been persecuted for not worshipping Images; but see the answer of the learned dJewell thereunto; eEpiphanius, who lived, Anno 370. proveth against the3 Collyridiams, That Mary nor no creature should be adored. Unde est simulachrificum hoc studium et diabolious conantus? praetext• enim 4justitiae sempersubiens hominum, mentem drabolus, mortalem naturam in hominum oculis deificans, Statuas humanas, imagines press ferentes per artum, veritatem expressit, et mortui quidem sunt qui adorantur: Item, Revera sanctum erat corpus Mariae, non tamen Deus, honorata, non in adorationem data. Mary was not God, and therefore is not to be adored: He professeth that he did rive a veil, that had painted in it the Image of Christ, or of some man▪ Cum ego videssem in Ecclesia Christi▪ contra authoritatem scripturarum, hominis pendere imaginem, scidi illud, &c.
but when and where this persecution was, none knoweth, for many times hath the Church been persecured for not worshipping Images; but see the answer of the learned dJewell thereunto; eEpiphanius, who lived, Anno 370. proveth against the3 Collyridiams, That Mary nor no creature should be adored. Ʋnde est simulachrificum hoc studium et diabolious conantus? praetext• enim 4justitiae sempersubiens hominum, mentem drabolus, mortalem naturam in hominum oculis deificans, Statuas humanas, imagines pre se ferentes per artum, veritatem expressit, et mortui quidem sunt qui adorantur: Item, Revera sanctum erat corpus Mariae, non tamen Deus, honorata, non in adorationem data. Mary was not God, and therefore is not to be adored: He professeth that he did rive a vail, that had painted in it the Image of Christ, or of some man▪ Cum ego videssem in Ecclesia Christi▪ contra authoritatem scripturarum, hominis pendere imaginem, scidi illud, &c.
dJewell against Harding 14. art. of adora•. pag. 506, 507.
eEpiphanius lib. 3. cont. Collyridianos.
3[f] Idem ibid.
4(g) Lactantius, institut. l. 2. cap. 2. Etenim hominis imago necessaria tum videtur, cum procul abest, supervacua futura cum presto est, dei autem cujus spiritus ac numen ubique diffusum, abesse nunquam potest, semper utique imago supervacua est. The Arguments of the ancients against Images.
Lactantius Formianus, Images are to represent these who are absent. God is every where present, it is vanity therefore to form an image of God. Also hThere is no Religion, where there is an image: Also ⟨p. 183⟩iyour gods be either in Heaven, or not; if they be not in Heaven, why do ye worship them? If they be in Heaven, why do ye not lift your eyes to Heaven while you adore them? Why do you convert your eyes toward walls, stocks and stones, rather then toward that place where you imagine your gods to be?
Lactantius Formianus, Images are to represent these who are absent. God is every where present, it is vanity therefore to forme an image of God. Also hThere is no Religion, where there is an image: Also ⟨p. 183⟩iyour gods be either in Heaven, or not; if they be not in Heaven, why do ye worship them? If they be in Heaven, why do ye not lift your eyes to Heaven while you adore them? Why do you convert your eyes toward walls, stocks and stones, rather then toward that place where you imagine your gods to be?
hLactantius lib. 2. cap. 19.
iIb. Cur ad parietes & signa, & lapides potissimum quam illo spectatis, ubi cos esse credatis. ib. instit. div. l. 2. c. 1.
kHis Arguments against Images be these: l1. They forget reason, when they fear the work of their own hands: 2. mGod is not absent, but present every where: 3. nThe image is a dead thing void of sense, God is the eternal and everliving God: 4. oNothing mortal should be worshipped. 5. pWhat vanity to hope for protection from these things, which cannot defend themselves • 6. qThe image is less and viler then the worshipper: 7. rMan according to Gods image, is the image of God. 8. (s) God needeth nothing, neither torches because he made the light, nor images. This man lived, Anno 300. Before which time the Church of Christ being persecuted, they had no Churches, nor Images to be ornaments in their Churches, as saith (t) Ambrosius, and also uChrysostom, who was displeased with the fooleries in Temples in his time, and saith, They were not like the Temples of the Apostolic Churches: and xTertullian, and yEusebius saith, They had then, Simplices domos, Simple houses, void of paintries and pictures: And the want of Temples was objected against Christian Religion, as zOrigen cleareth in the time of Constantine, the son of Chlorus, as saith, aSozomen, and bEusebius, Temples were builded, but as cJoan. Quintinus expoundeth Tertullian, without the ornaments of images, and dTertullian himself maketh building of Altars, and portraits, Idol•tricos cultus, Idolatrous worship. In the forty years space, betwixt the reign of Valerian, and the 19. year of Diocletian, there were Oratories and Temples builded, but neither painted Pictures, nor Images in them, as saith [e] Eusebius: Yea, of thirty Bishops of Rome, even from Peter and Paul to Sylvester, and Constantine the Emperor; to wit, three hundred years, there were none, who were not persecuted to blood, or to death, or some other way. It is a vain thing to say, they had breathing time to build17⟨p. 184⟩Temples, and erect Altars, and golden Images of Christ, and the Virgin Mary, and the Saints. It is true, in the two hundred year after Christ, under Alexander Severus, Gordianus, Philippus, Gallienus; Churches were builded, as fNicephorus saith, but again under Diocletian they were demolished to the ground, but observe well there were no Images of Christ broken, which that Tyrant in despite of Christ, would not have omitted; see gEusebius, they were builded again under great Constantine, so hSozomen, iOtho Phrisingensis kand Nicephorus.
kHis Arguments against Images be these: l1. They forget reason, when they fear the work of their own hands: 2. mGod is not absent, but present every where: 3. nThe image is a dead thing void of sense, God is the eternall and everliving God: 4. oNothing mortall should be worshipped. 5. pWhat vanity to hope for protection from these things, which cannot defend themselves • 6. qThe image is lesse and viler then the worshipper: 7. rMan according to Gods image, is the image of God. 8. (s) God needeth nothing, neither torches because he made the light, nor images. This man lived, Anno 300. Before which time the Church of Christ being persecuted, they had no Churches, nor Images to be ornaments in their Churches, as saith (t) Ambrosius, and also uChrysostom, who was displeased with the fooleries in Temples in his time, and saith, They were not like the Templ•s of the Apostolick Churches: and xTertullian, and yEusebius saith, They had then, Simplices domos, Simple houses, void of paintries and pictures: And the want of Temples was objected against Christian Religion, as zOrigen cleareth in the time of Constantine, the son of Chlorus, as saith, aSozomen, and bEusebius, Temples were builded, but as
kinstit. l. 2. c. 2.
lIbid.
mInstit. l 2. c. 3.
nInstit. l. 2. c. 4.
oInstit. l. 2. c. 18.
pIbid.
qInstit. l. 6. c. 11.
rAmbros. officior l. 2. cap. 21.
uChrys. l. 2. epist. 246.
xTertullian apol et c•nt. valent.
yEusebius hist. ec. l. 9. c 10.
zOrigen cont. cles. l. 9. c. 4.
aSozomen l. 1. c. 8.
bEuseb. in vita constan. l. •.
cJoan Armitants in explan••io can 5. concilii gangren
dTertull. lib. de Idol. Plutarch in vitae Numae non dum ingenia Grecorum atque Tuscorum fingendis simulachris urbem inundaverunt, ita Tertullian, Apol. c. 25.
The dream of Platina, for the building of a Church, by the donation of Constantine, with twelve portions of earth, equal to the number of the twelve Apostles, and of another Church, with the title of the holy Cross at Jerusalem, which Helena found in that place, and Constantine placed in this Church at Rome, is refuted by lHospinian: yet is there no word of any Images in these Churches.
The dream of Platina, for the building of a Church, by the donation of Constantine, with twelve portions of earth, equall to the number of the twelve Apostles, and of another Church, with the title of the holy Crosse at Ierusalem, which Helena found in that place, and Constantine placed in this Church at Rome, is refuted by lHospinian: yet is there no word of any Images in these Churches.
mArnobius An. 330. maintaineth against the heathen, that the Christians ought to have no Images: 1. Because the device of images is a novelty, and was not before two thousand years, but God and Religion are no new things. 2. nBecause either the Gods dwelleth in their images, against their will, or of their own accord; if the former be said, they are compelled, which is absurd. If the latter, then they do either bide always in their images, and so are miserable, or they go out of the images when they please, and then the images are empty things.
mArnobius An. 330. maintaineth against the heathen, that the Christians ought to have no Images: 1. Because the device of images is a novelty, and was not before two thousand years, but God and Religion are no new things. 2. nBecause either the Gods dwelleth in their images, against their will, or of their own accord; if the former be said, they are compelled, which is absurd. If the latter, then they do either bide alwayes in their images, and so are miserable, or they go out of the images when they please, and then the images are empty things.
That could not be: 1. Because his manhood was joined with his Godhead, and could not be separated therefrom. 2. Because his Godhead cannot be represented, Mortuis, & inanimatis coloribus, with dead and lifeless colours. bHieronimus, who lived, An. 331. under Constantine, denieth that any Creature, Angel, or Virgin Mary should be worshipped. cRuffinus faith, Helena the mother of Constantine adored crucified Christ, but antiquity saith not, that she adored the nails that fixed him to the Cross, because they were but creatures.
That could not be: 1. Because his manhood was joyned with his Godhead, and could not be separated therefrom. 2. Because his Godhead cannot be represented, Mortuis, & inanimatis coloribus, with dead and livelesse colours. bHieronimus, who lived, An. 331. under Constantine, denyeth that any Creature, Angel, or Virgin Mary should be worshipped. cRuffinus faith, Helena the mother of Constantine adored crucified Christ, but antiquity saith not, that she adored the nails that fixed him to the Crosse, because they were but creatures.
dAmbrosius, who lived, Anno 370. condemneth Images. 1. Because they change the images of the dead, in the glory of God, who worshippeth images: 2. The living serve the dead. 3. They take from ⟨p. 185⟩stocks and stones what they are, and give to them, what they are not. 4. eIdols are unclean. 5. It is undecentf, to worship what men maketh with their hands. 6. Because gimages are but shadows.
hAugustine condemneth Images. 1. Because they infect the weak minds of rude people, to worship them. 2. They have eyes and see not. 3. The creatures are images of God, not stocks. 4. Idols iare husks and empty. 5. These kwho brought in Images, took away the fear of God, and increased error. 6. Martyrs lare not gods. 7. Confounded mbe they who worship stones, our living stone Christ is in heaven.
hAugustine condemneth Images. 1. Because they infect the vveak mindes of rude people, to worship them. 2. They have eyes and see not. 3. The creatures are images of God, not stocks. 4. Idols iare huskes and empty. 5. These kwho brought in Images, tooke away the feare of God, and increased error. 6. Martyrs lare not gods. 7. Confounded mbe they who worship stones, our living stone Christ is in heaven.
8. aThough worshippers of Images say, they worship God in Images, yet they worship devils; for good men, as Paul and Barnabas, Angels, and Cornelius forbade men to worship them. 9. It is a shame to adore a beast endowed with sense and life, far more to adore a dumb and lifeless creature, August, ps. 113. bChrysostom is against Images. 1. Because the Law of God forbiddeth them. 2. cGod must be honoured, as he willeth himself. 3. It is da depressing of souls to worship Images. eIt cometh from Satan to take Gods glory from him, fit is mockery that man should be the creator of God, the Creator of all things.
8. aThough worshippers of Images say, they worship God in Images, yet they worship devills; for good men, as Paul and Barnabas, Angels, and Cornelius forbade men to worship them. 9. It is a shame to adore a beast endowed with sense and life, farre more to adore a dumbe and livelesse creature, August, ps. 113. bChrysostome is against Images. 1. Because the Law of God forbiddeth them. 2. cGod must be honoured, as he willeth himselfe. 3. It is da depressing of soules to worship Images. eIt commeth from Satan to take Gods glory from him, fit is mockerie that man should be the creator of God, the Creator of all things.
hDamascene a superstitious man much for Images acknowledgeth two things. 1. That Images are but [Greek or Hebrew] unwritten traditions. 2. He acknowledgeth that the brazen Serpent, the Cherubims were made for signification, not for imitation or adoration.
hDamascen a superstitious man much for Images acknowledgeth two things. 1. That Images are but 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 unwritten traditions. 2. He ackowledgeth that the brazen Serpent, the Cherubims were made for signification, not for imitation or adoration.
hGregor. lin. 9. ep. 9. Perlatum est ad nos, quod inconsider• to zelo succensus sanctorum magines sub bac, quasi excusatione, ne adorari debuissent, confregeris, & quidem, quia cas adorari, vet•isses omnino laudamus, fregisse vero reprehendimus.
(i)Gregorius Magnus, though he be alleged by Papists for adoration of Images. Yet in his Epistle to Serenus Bishop of Massilia, An. 600. he forbiddeth the adoration of Images, and alloweth only the Historical use of them, as is observed by kFran. White, lby Hospinian and mCatol. testum veritatis, and nthis man being the first who brought Images into the Church hath this Caveat, atque indica (saith he to Sirenus) quod non tibi, ipsa visio historiae quae, pictura teste, pandebatur, displicueri•: sed illa adoratio quae picturis ⟨p. 186⟩fuerit in competenter exhibita, & si quis imagines facere voluerit, minimè prohibe, adorare vero imagines omnibus modis divita, sed hoc solicitè admoneas, ut ex visione rei gestae, ardorem conjunctionis percipiant, & in adoration solius Trinitatis prosternantur. It is clear that this man teacheth an adoration of Images, though he make them only books to the rude. This same oGregorius will have the sign of the cross adored, because when the Devil came to a Jew sleeping in the night in the Temple of an Idol, the Jew being afraid, signed himself with the Cross, and the Devil fled; but when doth Jews come in any Christian Churches, or Idol-Temples, who abhor the name of Christ, and so hate both the Cross and Christ, and what can be proved from a fact of Satan?
(i)Gregorius Magnus, though he be alledged by Papists for adoration of Images. Yet in his Epistle to Serenus Bishop of Massilia, An. 600. he forbiddeth the adoration of Images, and alloweth onely the Historicall use of them, as is observed by kFran. White, lby Hospinian and mCatol. testum veritatis, and nthis man being the first who brought Images into the Church hath this Caveat, atque indica (saith he to Sirenus) quod non tibi, ipsa visio historiae quae, pictura teste, pandebatur, displicueri•: sed illa adoratio quae picturis ⟨p. 186⟩fuerit in competenter exhibita, & si quis imagines facere voluerit, minimè prohibe, adorare vero imagines omnibus modis divita, sed hoc solicitè admoneas, ut ex visione rei gestae, ardorem conjunctionis percipiant, & in adoratione solius Trinitatis prosternantur. It is cleare that this man teacheth an adoration of Images, though he make them onely bookes to the rude. This same oGregorius will have the signe of the crosse adored, because when the Devill came to a Iew sleeping in the night in the Temple of an Idoll, the Iew being afraid, signed himselfe with the Crosse, and the Divell fled; but when doth Iewes come in any Christian Churches, or Idoll-Temples, who abhorre the name of Christ, and so hate both the Crosse and Christ, and what can be proved from a fact of Sathan?
kFran. Whites way to the Church, ch. 9, sect. 2. p. 114.
In the eighth age, pBede Imaginum cultus & adoratio, the worshipping and adoring of Images is unlawful. 1. Because they have no office in the doctrine of the Gospel. 2. qWe are forbidden to adore, salute, or worship them. 3. The (d) rChurch is not taught to seek the Lord by Images, but by faith and good works. 4. The sApostolic Church did not worship God in Images. 5. Images twant, documento antiquitatis, antiquity, example, and the Scripture. 6. We wfrustrate God of worship due to him. 7. Peter uPaul, Angels forbade to worship them, but God only.
In the eighth age, pBeda Imaginum cultus & adoratio, the worshipping and adoring of Images is unlawfull. 1. Because they have no office in the doctrine of the Gospell. 2. qWe are forbidden to adore, salute, or worship them. 3. The (d) rChurch is not taught to seeke the Lord by Images, but by faith and good workes. 4. The sApostolique Church did not worship God in Images. 5. Images twant, documento antiquitatis, antiquity, example, and the Scripture. 6. We wfrustrate God of worship due to him. 7. Peter uPaul, Angels forbad to worship them, but God only.
pBede l. 2. c. 21. ad peragenda nostrae salutis mysteria nullum penitus officium habere n•scuntur.Beda l. 2. c. 21. ad peragenda nostrae salutis mysteria nullum penitus officium habere n•scuntur.
qBede l. 1. c. 9. adorare, salutare, collar, inhibemur pene in cunctis scripturae locis.Beda l. 1. c. 9. adorare, salutare, colare, inhibemur pene in cunctis scripturae locis.
rIdem. l. 1. c. 21.
sIdem l. 1. c. 24. Idem l. 6. c. 21.
tIbid.
wCod. l. 8. tit. 12. leg. 20. Theodos. Valentinian
We forbid the Church (saith the civill Law) to be obscured with Images. Have the Image of God, (saith xEphrem) in thy heart, non colorum varietate in ligno, not in Images and colours. Who can make (saith yDamascene) a representation of the invisible God. zGretserus saith, the Jews would not admit of Ensigns and Trophies of the Romans for fear Images should be hidden under them. So said Josephus abefore him. Their own men say with us, bHulcot who lived an. 1346. saith Latreia, divine worship belongeth to God only, the Image is not God, neither the Cross; (saith Joan. Pic. Mirandula, Concl. 3.) nor the Image of Christ is to be adored (adoration Latreia eo modo quo ponit Thomas) with divine worship, the guise of Thomas Aquinas cPeresius Ajala a Popish Bishop, for adoration of Images, saith he, there is neither Scripture, nor Church tradition, nor consent of Fathers, nor good reason to make it good. For saith dGabriel ⟨p. 187⟩Biel, The image either considered in it self as it is metal or stone, or as it is a holy sign, is a sensible Creature, to which Latreia, Divine honour should not be given: and the Romish cDecrees saith, We commend you that you forbid images of Saints to be Worshipped: The dDouai Doctors say, Idols have eyes and cannot see, &c. Now if they have Images of God and Christ which can see, and hear, and speak, we exceedingly desire to know: eAlexander Allensis, fDurandus say, That images in themselves, and properly, are not to be Worshipped.
We forbid the Church (saith the civill Law) to be obscured with Images. Have the Image of God, (saith xEphrem) in thy heart, non colorum varietate in ligno, not in Images and colours. Who can make (saith yDamascen) a representation of the invisible God. zGretserus saith, the Iewes would not admit of Ensignes and Trophies of the Romans for fear Images should be hidden under them. So said Josephus abefore him. Their own men say with us, bHulcot who lived an. 1346. saith Latreia, divine worship belongeth to God onely, the Image is not God, neither the Crosse; (saith Ioan. Pic. Mirandula, Concl. 3.) nor the Image of Christ is to be adored (adoratione Latreia eo modo quo ponit Thomas) with divine worship, the guise of Thomas Aquinas cPeresius Ajala a Popish Bishop, for adoration of Images, saith he, there is neither Scripture, nor Church tradition, nor consent of Fathers, nor good reason to make it good. For saith dGabriel ⟨p. 187⟩Biel, The image either considered in it self as it is mettall or stone, or as it is a holy signe, is a sensible Creature, to which Latreia, Divine honour should not be given: and the Romish cDecrees saith, We commend you that you forbid images of Saints to be Worshipped: The dDoway Doctors say, Idols have eyes and cannot see, &c. Now if they have Images of God and Christ which can see, and hear, and speak, we exceedingly desire to know: eAlexander Allensis, fDurandus say, That images in themselves, and properly, are not to be Worshipped.
cPeresius Ajala de trad. pag. 3. De Imagineque scripturam neque traditionem, neque communem sensum sanctorum, neque concilium generalis determinationem, neque etiam rationem adducunt.
dGabriel Biel in Can. lec. 49.
cD•cret. 3. dist. 3. c. 27. Grego.
dDouai men, Annot. 2 Sam. 5. 8. The blind and the lame shall not enter in the Temple.Doway men, Annot. 2 Sam. 5. 8. The blinde and the lame shall not enter in the Temple.
gGeo: Cassander wisheth, That they had continued (in majorum suorum sententia) in the mind of their forefathers, and that the Superstition of people in, Worshipping images had been suppressed. The Council convened by hConstantius Capronimus condemneth Worshipping of Images, or placing them in Churches. 1. Because it is forbidden in the second Commandment. 2. The Picturing of Christ is a dividing of the two Natures. 3. It is against the Ancients, Epiphanius, Nazianzen, Chrysostom, Athanasius, Amphylocius, Theodorus, Eusebius Pamphili. The Council of Nice is builded upon lies. Adrian Bishop of Rome, writeth to the Council of Nice, That the Emperor Constantine being a Leper, and labouring to cure his Leprosy by shedding of innocent Babes blood; Peter and Paul appeared to him by night, in a Vision, and bade him go to be Baptized by Sylvester, and that he, to be cured by Sylvesters Baptizing, builded a Temple with the Images of Peter and Paul. This is as true as the Image of Christ spake to Tho: Aquinas at Naples, Bene Scripsistti de me, Thoma, Why is not all Evangel that Aquinas hath written then? For their own Platina asaith, The story of Constantine's Leprosy is a fable; and Socrates saith, That Constantine was sick when he was 65. years, and he maketh no mention of his leprosy; so bHospinianus saith, and our own cSimson saith, That Sylvester and Marcus his successor were both dead before Constantine was Baptized: dGenebradus a Papist saith, ⟨p. 188⟩down right, that the Council of Frankford condemned the second Nicene Council; But eBellarmine, fSuarez, gSanderus' hAlanus, deny that the Doctrine of the second Nicene Council for Adoring images, is Condemned by the Council of Frankford; they say it is only expounded, and that the right way of Adoring images is made manifest: Yea, saith iNauclerus, kSabellicus, and lBlandus: The Council of Frankford reserveth due honour to images, and saith nothing against the Council of Nice. But this is to deny daylight at Noon-day: For mAnnonius is most clear in it, and nAbbot Uspergens. othe Book of Charles the Great saith the same. The Synod of Frankford was convened An. 794. of purpose to condemn the second Synod of Nice, called the seventh pretended and false Synod: pAventinus saith expressly, Scita Grecorum (in Synodo Nicena decreta) de imaginibus adorandis in concili• francofurtensi rescissa & abolita sunt:
gGeo: Cassander wisheth, That they had continued (in majorum suorum sententia) in the minde of their forefathers, and that the Superstition of people in, Worshipping images had been suppressed. The Councell convened by hConstantius Capronimus condemneth Worshipping of Images, or placing them in Churches. 1. Because it is forbidden in the second Commandment. 2. The Picturing of Christ is a dividing of the two Natures. 3. It is against the Ancients, Epiphanius, Nazianzen, Chrysostome, Athanasius, Amphylocius, Theodorus, Eusebius Pamphili. The Councell of Nice is builded upon lies. Adrian Bishiop of Rome, writeth to the Councell of Nice, That the Emperour Constantine being a Leaper, and labouring to cure his Leprosie by shedding of innocent Babes blood; Peter and Paul appeared to him by night, in a Vision, and bade him go to be Baptized by Sylvester, and that he, to be cured by Sylvesters Baptizing, builded a Temple with the Images of Peter and Paul. This is as true as the Image of Christ spake to Tho: Aquinas at Naples, Bene Scripsistti de me, Thoma, Why is not all Evangell that Aquinas hath written then? For their own Platina asaith, The story of Constantines Leprosie is a fable; and Socrates saith, That Constantine was sick when he was 65. years, and he maketh no mention of his leprosie; so bHospinianus saith, and our own cSimson saith, That Sylvester and Marcus his successor were both dead before Constantine was Baptized: dGenebradus a Papist saith, ⟨p. 188⟩down right, that the Councell of Frankford condemned the second Nicene Councell; But eBellarmine, fSuarez, gSanderus' hAlanus, deny that the Doctrine of the second Nicene Councell for Adoring images, is Condemned by the Councell of Frankford; they say it is onely expounded, and that the right way of Adoring images is made manifest: Yea, saith
gCassand. In Consultatione ad ferdinandum & maximilianum art. An. 1170.
hConcil. Constantine polit. An. 755. of 338. Bishops. Yea, this same second councel of Nice, and the seventh Epistle to the Synod, condemneth Nestorius of Idolatry, and condemneth the Arians as Idolaters, who Worshipped Christ whom they believed to be a man only: And Athanasius, contr. Arian. Orati. 1. And Nyssenus in Laud. Bas. And Nazianzen, Orati. 40. say. To Adore a Creature, though in the Name of Christ or God, is Idolatry.Concil. Constantin• polit. An. 755. of 338. Bishops. Yea, this same second councel of Nice, and the seventh Epistle to the Synod, condemneth Nestorius of Idolatry, and condemneth the Arians as Idolaters, who Worshipped Christ whom they believed to be a man onely: And Athanasius, contr. Arian. Orati. 1. And Nyssenus in Laud. Bas. And Nazianzen, Orati. 40. say. To Adore a Creature, though in the Name of Christ or God, is Idolatry.
and aUspergensis saith, in this Synod it was decreed, Ut septima & universalis Synodus, nec septima nec aliquid diceretur, quasi supervacua ab omnibus abdica tu est; and the same saith bEginradus, cGeo• Cassander: But the very Arguments in the Nicene Council are set down, and dissolved in the Frankford Council, as our own Master dSimson observeth: As the Nicene Council reasoneth from the Cherubims, and the brazen Serpent. Frankford Answereth, These were made at Gods Commandment, images not so. 2. Yea, say they, and with them eLorinus, The Cherubims and brazen Serpent were not made to be Worshipped; see these and many other Arguments, set down and Answered by the Council of Frankford: As also saith fthe Learned Author of Catol. Test. Verit. The Arguments used by this Council, proveth that no Adoration is due to Images, as may be hence collected: As also out of the book of gCharles against the dreams of Tarasius, whose entry to the Priesthood was unlawful, and was a gross Idolater, and against the Idolater Pope Adrian; Because 1. There is no holiness in images, either as they are figures or colours, or as they are Consecrated. ⟨p. 189⟩2. Because to Adore is to glorify, hbut only God is to be glorified. 3. God Commanded us not to love images, but men, and sent his son in the flesh for men, and not for images; and if ithey be not to be believed on, neither are they to be Adored. 4. It cannot be proved that the honour of the image, is the honour of the Sampler: Christ said not, What ye do to images, ye do to me, nor he that receiveth images, receiveth me. This Argument proveth, that Veneration is not due to the Images, as to books of the Trinity; because that the Veneration of the Image, is an honouring of God, there must be an union betwixt the Images and God or Christ, betwixt the Tree and Christ. 1. There is no union lawful, that can be a Warrant of honouring any thing; but an union Warranted of God, betwixt Crossing in the Air, and Dedication to Christs Service, betwixt Surplice and Pastoral Sanctity; There is no union, nor is there a personal union betwixt Christ and the Image: Nor 2. an union of parts, as betwixt the shoulders and the head. Nor 3. is there a Divine relative union, as betwixt the mean or the end, the Servant or the Lord: for as aJohn White saith well;
and aVspergensis saith, in this Synod it was decreed, Ʋt septima & universalis Synodus, nec septima nec aliquid diceretur, quasi supervacua ab omnibus abdica tu est; and the same saith bEginradus, cGeo• Cassander: But the very Arguments in the Nicene Councell are set down, and dissolved in the Frankford Councell, as our own Master dSimson observeth: As the Nicene Councell reasoneth from the Cherubims, and the brazen Serpent. Frankfoord Answereth, These were made at Gods Commandment, images not so. 2. Yea, say they, and with them eLorinus, The Cherubims and brazen Serpent were not made to be Worshipped; see these and many other Arguments, set down and Answered by the Councell of Frankfoord: As also saith fthe Learned Author of Catol. Test. Verit. The Arguments used by this Councell, proveth that no Adoration is due to Images, as may be hence collected: As also out of the book of gCharles against the dreames of Tarasius, whose entry to the Priesthood was unlawfull, and was a grosse Idolater, and against the Idolater Pope Adrian; Because 1. There is no holinesse in images, either as they are figures or colours, or as they are Consecrated. ⟨p. 189⟩2. Because to Adore is to glorifie, hbut only God is to be glorified. 3. God Commandedus not to love images, but men, and sent his son in the flesh for men, and not for images; and if ithey be not to be believed on, neither are they to be Adored. 4. It cannot be proved that the honour of the image, is the honour of the Samplar: Christ said not, What ye do to images, ye do to me, nor he that receiveth images, receiveth me. This Argument proveth, that Veneration is not due to the Images, as to books of the Trinity; because that the Veneration of the Image, is an honouring of God, there must be an union betwixt the Images and God or Christ, betwixt the Tree and Christ. 1. There is no union lawfull, that can be a Warrant of honouring any thing; but an union Warranted of God, betwixt Crossing in the Air, and Dedication to Christs Service, betwixt Surplice and Pastorall Sanctity; There is no union, nor is there a personall union betwixt Christ and the Image: Nor 2. an union of parts, as betwixt the shoulders and the head. Nor 3. is there a Divine relative union, as betwixt the mean or the end, the Servant or the Lord: for as
aUspergens. in Chron. Anno 793.Vspergens. in Chron. Anno 793.
bEginradus in vita Caroli Magni.
cCassander in Consul. ad ferdinand. & Maxmilian imp.
dSimson, Treatise of Images, pag. 48.
eLorinus in Art. 17. ver. 25. Serpentem. Conflari•jusfit non quod adorari vellet, nam postea confregit.
and bthe Scripture proveth, all union betwixt God and the means of Worship, which are to be reverenced as means of Worship in relation to God, is by divine institution; now certainly if by divine ordination there had been an union betwixt the Image and God, then had it been lawful to lay the Image in the heart, to say: How love I thy Image? (the painted pictures and wooden portraits of Christ, the wood of the Cross are my delight) (I hope in the wood) (I have taken images for my heritage, they are sweeter to me, nor the honey or the honey comb) (how pleasant are the wooden feet of these dead and senseless Ambassadors of Christ, who bring to my soul news of God, or of my Redeemer Jesus.)
and bthe Scripture proveth, all union betwixt God and the meanes of Worship, which are to be reverenced as meanes of Worship in relation to God, is by divine institution; now certainly if by divine ordination there had been an union betwixt the Image and God, then had it been lawfull to lay the Image in the heart, to say: How love I thy Image? (the painted pictures and wooden portracts of Christ, the wood of the Crosse are my delight) (I hope in the wood) (I have taken images for my heritage, they are sweeter to me, nor the honey or the honey combe) (hovv pleasant are the wooden feet of these dead and senslesse Ambassadors of Christ, who bring to my soul news of God, or of my Redeemer Iesus.)
cAmbrose, dGregorius, eAugustine fChrysostom saith, The honour of the servant redoundeth to the Master, when he is a servant by appointment of the Master, and he that heareth faithful Pastors, heareth Christ who sent them: And aAthanasius, and bBasil, to prove the honouring and adoring of Christ, the substantial Image of God, to be the honouring of God the Father, say; The hearing of the Image, or of the servant of the King, is the hearing of the King. But the Image is formally made an Image of God, and the saints by mens imagination▪ not by Gods word or his ⟨p. 190⟩ordination: Their own cPeresius saith, If the imagination were carried upon the image or sampler with one motion, yet it cannot be concluded, that the same is to be done in Adoration: And dwe are not to worship God by our fantasies, saith Augustine, nor by our ecarnal thoughts. Suarez, Bellarmine, Vasquez, Gretserus, buildeth all their Adoration of images, upon the saying of Aristotle; De memor & remiscen, cap. 2.
cAmbrose, dGregorius, eAugustine fChrysostom saith, The honour of the servant redoundeth to the Master, when he is a servant by appointment of the Master, and he that heareth faithfull Pastors, heareth Christ who sent them: And aAthanasius, and bBasill, to prove the honouring and adoring of Christ, the substantiall Image of God, to be the honouring of God the Father, say; The hearing of the Image, or of the servant of the King, is the hearing of the King. But the Image is formally made an Image of God, and the saints by mens imagination▪ not by Gods word or his ⟨p. 190⟩ordination: Their own cPeresius saith, If the imagination were carried upon the image or samplar with one motion, yet it cannot be concluded, that the same is to be done in Adoration: And dwe are not to worship God by our fantasies, saith Augustine, nor by our ecarnall thoughts. Suarez, Bellarmine, Vasquez, Gretserus, buildeth all their Adoration of images, upon the saying of Aristotle; De memor & remiscen, cap. 2.
cAmbros. epist. 26.
dGregor. in reg. l. 5. cap. 1.
eAugustine on these words, he that receiveth you receiveth me.
Hence the fFathers of Trent, gdreaming Damascene, hdoting Nicephorus; if we believe iSuarez, make this a principle of their Bible of Idol worship; That God and the Image are one, but we see not how they be one, nor can we say that God is present in the Image as in a place: for if he be present in the Image, In loco ut sic, as in such a place, then he is there as in a consecrated place, and by promise, and so they must give us the word of God, for Gods presence in Images; but if God be present in Images, as In loco simpliciter, non ut in loco ut sic: As he is in all places, then is he not present in images, as in images, but as in all creatures, and then let us say Amen, to kVasquez, who saith, all things which have a being, A Mouse and Frog are to be adored, as having resemblance with God the first being: And he saith, this is the opinion of aCajetanus, and citeth bLeontius the dreamer, who was at the Council of Nice the seventh false Synod; who saith, all Creatures visible and invisible are to be adored. And the Popes Professor cJoannes de Lugo proveth by four great reasons, that all creatures should be adored.
Hence the fFathers of Trent, gdreaming Damascene, hdoting Nicephorus; if we believe iSuarez, make this a principle of their Bible of Idoll worship; That God and the Image are one, but we see not how they be one, nor can we say that God is present in the Image as in a place: for if he be present in the Image, In loco ut sic, as in such a place, then he is there as in a consecrated place, and by promise, and so they must give us the word of God, for Gods presence in Images; but if God be present in Images, as In loco simpliciter, non ut in loco ut sic: As he is in all places, then is he not present in images, as in images, but as in all creatures, and then let us say Amen, to kVasquez, who saith, all things which have a being, A Mouse and Frog are to be adored, as having resemblance with God the first being: And he saith, this is the opinion of aCajetanus, and citeth bLeontius the dreamer, who was at the Councell of Nice the seventh false Synod; who saith, all Creatures visible and invisible are to be adored. And the Popes Professor cJoannes de Lugo proveth by four great reasons, that all creatures should be adored.
fConc. Trident. Sess. 25.
gDamasceu. l. 4. c. 12.
hNicephor. in dial. constant. de imaginibus
iSuarez in 3. part Thom. to. 1. q. 25. art. 3. disp. 54. Sect. 3.
kVasquez in 3. part •om. 1. disp. •10. cap. 2. God not in the Image as in a place. Vasquez will have all things to be adored. Joan. de Lugo proveth the same by four reasons.
aCajetan. 22. q. •03. art. 3. ad. 4.
bLeontius in Dialog. 5. cont. Judaeos. Ut r•fertur in 7. Synod. falsa act. 4.Leontius in Dialog. 5. cont. Judaeos. Vt r•fertur in 7. Synod. falsa act. 4.
cJoan. de Lugo de myster. incarnat. disp. 37. Sect. 1. n. 1. 2, 3.
2. Because we use to kiss and adore material places, and the stone, or field where an Angel, or Saint hath been, for the touching and propinquity of the place and that holy thing, but Gods omnipresence sanctifieth all creatures. Be doing then, Masters, kiss, and adore the sanctified Devil and Hell fire, but take heed you scald not your lips.
2. Because we use to kisse and adore materiall places, and the stone, or field where an Angel, or Saint hath been, for the touching and propinquity of the place and that holy thing, but Gods omnipresence sanctifieth all creatures. Be doing then, Masters, kisse, and adore the sanctified Devil and Hell fire, but take heed you scald not your lips.
4. Man in a special manner is the living image of God. But true it ⟨p. 191⟩is, God is to be praised for all his creatures; but external Adoration before them, and laying a part of Gods glory upon them, for that is forbidden by your own, for dLeo the first saith the contrary, and eSalmeron saith; The body of fMoses was hidden of old for fear of Idolatry, and the use of Images and pictures were by God forbidden to the Jews in the second command, saith [f] Alexander Alens. gAlbertus, hBonaventura, iMartinus de Ajala, kAbulensis, who I am sure have with them in this, Albertus and Bonaventura, that the Images of God, because (say they) he is an invisible Spirit, are forbidden by the Law of nature.
4. Man in a speciall manner is the living image of God. But true it ⟨p. 191⟩is, God is to be praised for all his creatures; but externall Adoration before them, and laying a part of Gods glory upon them, for that is forbidden by your own, for dLeo the first saith the contrary, and eSalmeron saith; The body of fMoses was hidden of old for fear of Idolatry, and the use of Images and pictures were by God forbidden to the Iews in the second command, saith [f] Alexander Alens. gAlbertus, hBonaventura, iMartinus de Ajala, kAbulensis, who I am sure have with them in this, Albertus and Bonaventura, that the Images of God, because (say they) he is an invisible Spirit, are forbidden by the Law of nature.
dLeo. 1. Serm. 7. De nativita abstinendum ab ipsa specic offi•ij.
But I return to the Synod of Frankfurt: 5. lBecause images are void of senses and reason. 6. It cannot be proved by the example of the Apostles, mErgo, (say I) Images are neither to be teaching books, nor adored creatures: 7. The ancient Fathers nwere ignorant of this worship. 8▪ Only the rich awho are able to sustain Images, should be saved, and not the poor. 9. There bis no profit, but great vanity in adoring Images.
But I return to the Synod of Franckeford: 5. lBecause images are void of senses and reason. 6. It cannot be proved by the example of the Apostles, mErgo, (say I) Images are neither to be teaching books, nor adored creatures: 7. The ancient Fathers nwere ignorant of this worship. 8▪ Only the rich awho are able to sustain Images, should be saved, and not the poor. 9. There bis no profit, but great vanity in adoring Images.
To the Arguments from miracles it is answered, cthat these miracles are lying signs: for, Ea miracula, nulla Evangelii lectio tradit. 2. They deny that all things are to be adored, in the which, or by the which dGod wrought miracles. Gregorius Nyssenus bowed his knee to the Image of Abraham: What then? the Council saith, these books of Nyssenus are perished.
To the Arguments from miracles it is answered, cthat these miracles are lying signes: for, Ea miracula, nulla Evangelii lectio tradit. 2. They deny that all things are to be adored, in the which, or by the which dGod wrought miracles. Gregorius Nyssenus bowed his knee to the Image of Abraham: What then? the Councell saith, these books of Nyssenus are perished.
The fable of Agbarus, to whom the Image of Christs face painted in a cloth was sent, was not in the world till the year of God, 700. It is a counterfeit work ascribed to Athanasius, in stile and phrase of writing not like to him, where it is said, that it was the image of Christ crucified by the Jews in Berythus a Town in Syria, out of whose side flowed blood and water, which being mixed with water, could cure all diseases; eso Symson.
The fable of Agbarus, to whom the Image of Christs face painted in a cloath was sent, was not in the world till the year of God, 700. It is a counterfeit work ascribed to Athanasius, in stile and phrase of writing not like to him, where it is said, that it was the image of Christ crucified by the Iews in Berythus a Town in Syria, out of whose side flowed blood and water, which being mixed with water, could cure all diseases; eso Symson.
eSymson treats of the worshipping of Images, pag. 50, 51.
The Testimony fof the Council of Eliberia is clear, that images should not be in Churches gCanus, hSurjus and your own men say, this Council condemneth images. For 370. years ⟨p. 192⟩there were no Images in Churches; in this age Martyrs were admired, and the Grecians first, especially Gregorius Nyssenus the brother of Basilus had Images in Churches; iSozomen saith, Christians took into Churches pieces of Christs image, broken by Julian the Apostate, in the first age, when Religion was born down and holy Pastors killed.
The Testimony fof the Councell of Eliberia is clear, that images should not be in Churches gCanus, hSurjus and your own men say, this Councell condemneth images. For 370. years ⟨p. 192⟩there were no Images in Churches; in this age Martyrs were admired, and the Grecians first, especially Gregorius Nyssenus the brother of Basilus had Images in Churches; iSozomen saith, Christians took into Churches pieces of Christs image, broken by Iulian the Apostat, in the first age, when Religion was born down and holy Pastors killed.
fConcilium Eleherio, cap. 36. Placuit in Ecclesiis picturas, non esse debere, ne quod colitur, aut adoratur, in parictibus pingatur.
gCa•us line 5. cap. 4.
hSurjus 1 Tom. of concell. an in can. 36. cont. Eliber.
Gregorius Magnus first defended that images should be in Churches. Its like the Apostate Julian would hate any thing, bearing the name of Christ most falsely, yea, and Antiquity beareth contradictions most apparent touching images.
Gregorius Magnus first defended that images should be in Churches. Its like the Apostate Iulian would hate any thing, bearing the name of Christ most falsly, yea, and Antiquity beareth contradictions most aparent touching images.
But bNicephorus saith, the creatures of God are the Lawful Images of God. But it is more then evident, by what I have said, that ancient Papists and Synods used images to be memorials of God, and not to be adored.
But bNicephorus saith, the creatures of God are the Lawfull Images of God. But it is more then evident, by what I have said, that ancient Papists and Synods used images to be memorials of God, and not to be adored.
Tertullian himself maketh building of Altars, and portracts, Idol•tricos cultus, Idolatrous worship. In the fourty years space, betwixt the reign of Valerian, and the 19. year of Dicclesian, there were Oratories and Temples builded, but neither painted Pictures, nor Images in them, as saith [e] Eusebius: Yea, of thirty Bishops of Rome, even from Peter and Paul to Sylvester, and Constantine the Emperour; to wit, three hundred years, there were none, who were not persecuted to blood, or to death, or some other way. It is a vain thing to say, they had breathing time to build
Temples, and erect Altars, and golden Images of Christ, and the Virgin Mary, and the Saints. It is true, in the two hundreth year after Christ, under Alexander Severus, Gordianus, Philippus, Gallienus; Churches were builded, as
Nicephorus saith, but again under Dioclesian they were demolished to the ground, but observe well there were no Images of Christ broken, which that Tyrant in despite of Christ, would not have omitted; see
Blandus: The Councell of Frankford reserveth due honour to images, and saith nothing against the Councell of Nice. But this is to deny daylight at Noon-day: For
the Book of Charles the Great saith the same. The Synod of Frankford was convened An. 794. of purpose to condemne the second Synod of Nice, called the seventh pretended and false Synod: