Ans. This is but the old argument of Erastus, repeated almost a hundred times to please the people. We never taught that either Presbytery or Minister can give, or take away inward Communion with God. But hence it will not follow, that Excommunication is an empty thing, for all we do is but, a Ministry, Christ doth make the whole Gospel, promises, threatening, Sacraments, effectual, else, What is Paul? What is Apollo? but the Ministers by whom ye believe? And what is the planting of Paul, or the watering of Apollo, except God give the increase? If this annul Excommunication, because Excommunicators are not properly judges, but only Servants and Heralds to declare what Christ doth in Heaven, then may Erastus prove that the Word, Promises, threatenings of the Gospel; The Apostles, Evangelists, Pastors, Teachers are nothing, for all of themselves are mere declarations of Gods will. 2. Those who Excommunicate because they judge not,1 but declare the will of Christ, they are not for that void of all authority, for their declaration is authoritative. What did Jeremiah but declare Gods will, yet it is such a prophetical and authoritative declaration, as I conceive Baruch or any other not sent as a Prophet of God, could not bear that which God putteth on Jeremiah, c. 1. 10. See, I have this day set thee over the Nations, and over the Kingdoms to root out, and to pull down, to destroy, and to pull down, to build and to plant: Hath Jeremiah no Prophetical authority over the Nations and Kingdoms to whom he prophesieth in the Name of the Lord, to build and destroy, to root out, and to plant, because he declareth and prophesieth, that such Nations shall be destroyed and rooted out for their wickedness, and such shall be builded and planted? Then mere declaration saith nothing against Excommunication; Paul, saith he, and the rest of the Apostles were nothing but Ministers, 1 Cor. 3. 5. and yet authority they had, else he could not say, 2 Cor. •0. 6. We have in readiness vengeance against all disobedience, Verse 8. For though ⟨p. 267⟩I should boast somewhat more of our Authority, &c. I should not be ashamed, and 2 Cor. 5. 20. Now then we are Ambassadors for Christ, but I pray you 1 Cor. 12. 29. Are all Apostles? Are all Prophets? Are all Teachers?
Ans. This is but the old argument of Erastus, repeated almost a hundred times to please the people. We never taught that either Presbytery or Minister can give, or take away inward Communion with God. But hence it will not follow, that Excommunication is an empty thing, for all we doe is but, a Ministery, Christ doth make the whole Gospel, promises, threatning, Sacraments, effectuall, else, What is Paul? What is Apollo? but the Ministers by whom ye beleeve? And what is the planting of Paul, or the watering of Apollo, except God give the increase? If this anull Excommunication, because Excommunicators are not properly judges, but onely Servants and Heralds to declare what Christ doth in Heaven, then may Erastus prove that the Word, Promises, threatnings of the Gospel; The Apostles, Evangelists, Pastors, Teachers are nothing, for all of themselves are meere declarations of Gods will. 2. Those who Excommunicate because they judge not,1 but declare the will of Christ, they are not for that void of all authority, for their declaration is authoritative. What did Ieremiah but declare Gods will, yet it is such a propheticall and authoritative declaration, as I conceive Baruch or any other not sent as a Prophet of God, could not beare that which God putteth on Ieremiah, c. 1. 10. See, I have this day set thee over the Nations, and over the Kingdomes to root out, and to pull downe, to destroy, and to pull downe, to build and to plant: Hath Ieremiah no Propheticall authority over the Nations and Kingdomes to whom he prophesieth in the Name of the Lord, to build and destroy, to root out, and to plant, because he declareth and prophesieth, that such Nations shall be destroyed and rooted out for their wickednes, and such shall be builded and planted? Then meer declaration saith nothing against Excommunication; Paul, saith he, and the rest of the Apostles were nothing but Ministers, 1 Cor. 3. 5. and yet authoritie they had, else he could not say, 2 Cor. •0. 6. We have in readinesse vengeance against all disobedience, Verse 8. For though ⟨p. 267⟩I should boast somewhat more of our Authority, &c. I should not be ashamed, and 2 Cor. 5. 20. Now then we are Ambassadors for Christ, but I pray you 1 Cor. 12. 29. Are all Apostles? Are all Prophets? Are all Teachers?
- 1Though Excommunication be only declarative, yet it is not empty.Though Excommunication be onely declarative, yet it is not empty.